1 h 42 min · 4,052 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 102-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche opens by cultivating compassion for infinite sentient beings, then offers a radical analysis of suffering’s true root. He contrasts visible suffering—disease, aging, death—that modern medicine addresses, with invisible suffering from future rebirths, which only Dharma can remedy. Ignorance, not disease itself, causes all suffering, and understanding dependent origination is the antidote. Through three levels of interdependence—causality, parts, and conceptual imputation—Rinpoche uses examples of a table, cup, and hand to show how persons exist only as nominal imputations on the five aggregates: unfindable under ultimate analysis, yet functionally real. The teaching culminates in the Prāsaṇgika view that unfindability does not entail nonexistence. Suited to practitioners with prior Buddhist study.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0138.mp3
UUID: a85f464d-293e-4dce-8dea-14fab026fd89
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Rinpoche's Story
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,046
So to listen and to explain teachings, it is capital that a motivation to benefit others be generated. And this motivation should be one which arises reflecting on the fact that others are infinite in numbers, and we ourselves are only one. Therefore, the benefit which can arise wishing to have an infinite numbers of beings itself can only be infinite. So we will meditate for one or two minutes on generating the motivation which reflects, I will listen to the Three Principles of the Path, the very essence of the teachings of the Buddha, and specifically, the explanation of the view, which is the core of the Buddha’s teaching with the motivation of giving rise to the three, great compassion, love, and the great motivation aspiring towards Buddha bodhicitta for the benefit of all mother sentient beings as vast as space. Page one one b.
Page five. So as the great bodhisattva Śāntideva said, the means to eliminate the suffering with which we live is the teachings. And the meaning of this quote is that for at present, we are mired in both bodily and mental sufferings, which are sufferings we do not desire. There is one and one only medicine to eliminate this, and these are the teachings. In other words, the Dharma.
So there are, broadly speaking, two categories of, suffering. The sufferings which we can see and the sufferings which are invisible. The sufferings which we can see, we in the West have become very knowledgeable with. And from morning to evening, we use countless means to overcome them. These are the sufferings of birth, disease, aging, and death, the sufferings associated with epidemics, bush bushfires, earthquakes, and whatnot.
And although we put countless effort in overcoming these sufferings and have become very proficient at it, at best, this can only remain contingent and temporary. There is, however, another category of sufferings, the sufferings which are invisible. These are the sufferings which happen after this life. The great minds of Tibet and India dedicated considerable effort to reflecting on what happened after this life. And they concluded that the sufferings after this life were far greater than anything this life could ever pretend to inflict
Us. For this reason, they put tremendous effort in finding the means to overcome these invisible sufferings of after this life, and the means to overcome them are the development of wisdom. Now all among us most probably do not believe in the existence of any future life and therefore cannot be bothered to put any effort in eliminating these invisible sufferings. A minority may believe in the existence of future lives, and an even smaller number may understand the sufferings associated with them, and then it becomes meaningful to try to eliminate these invisible future sufferings. So there are moreover two categories of suffering, physical and nonphysical sufferings.
Physical sufferings are sufferings such as disease. Now when we are sick, we go to the doctor for treatment, and his treatment, if successful, will eradicate the disease temporarily. It, however, can never eradicate the disease or tear the disease out from the root. The reason no medical treatment can ever tear disease out from the root is because the root cause of disease is never bodily. The root cause of disease is always mental.
Physical treatment medicine can never treat the mind. And although science has been extraordinarily successful in understanding the matter, scientists are unable to understand the mind because it does not lend itself to investigation by the means at their disposal. The mental states such as desire, anger, or love, which they acknowledge are considered to be epiphenomena manifestations of the functioning of the brain, of the nervous system, and of the nervous influx, all of which can be examined using microscopes or telescopes for objects which are further away. But the mind itself, because it is nonmaterial, can never appear in a microscope. Microscope.
It is beyond the pole of their investigation. So it is remarkable how proficient modern scientists have become, specifically in medical science, in diagnosis And for instance, in identifying which organ is deficient and sometimes actually performing organ transplants or implanting for that matter artificial organs or identifying for instance the area of the body which is diseased and treating that area directly or for that matter, cutting nerves which themselves transmit the sensation of pain from an area which cannot be healed. All of this is generally very beneficial. Everybody thinks it is quite extraordinary that in some cases, he has heard of poor people have been in situation where they have basically have no face left and had a mere orifice for a mouth and a face transplant was performed. And then through this, they had actually the requisite apertures for the senses and were able to function as human beings.
So what it is remarkable what science has been able to do for the benefit of human beings at the material level precisely because the mind does not appear in the mirror of their microscopes, then there is no understanding of mental phenomena. So the doctor of the mental condition is the Buddha. That is his prerogative. We leave the body to the physicians. And the diseases of the mind are diseases of the main minds and of the mental factors.
Anger, for instance, is a mental disease. It is a disease of the mind, and such a disease of the mind can only be counteracted by a mental remedy. The remedy to the mental disease of anger is the remedy of love and compassion. This is what acts as an antidote to anger. Likewise, desire is a mental disease.
The antidote to desire is generally speaking meditation on ugliness, the specific meditations on the skeletons, the skeletal nature phenomena, and more generally meditation on renunciation. Meditation on renunciation is the most powerful of all because that mind which generates renunciation functions and as an antidote to all forms of desire, not just desire for other persons or other phenomena, but all sources of enjoyment are counteracted by the mind of renunciation. And generally speaking, sentient beings are said to have 81,000 different types of delusions. And to counteract these 81,000 different types of of delusions, the Buddha taught 81,000 different bunches of teachings. So since there are 81,000 different delusions, we would need 81,000 antidotes, one for each one.
There is obviously no possibility to meditate on 81,000 antidotes because, for instance, the antidote to anger would not function as an antidote to desire. The antidote for desire itself will not function as an antidote for anger. They are specific. So the key is therefore to find the very root of these 81,000 delusions. And if we examine carefully, we will find that the very root of the 81,000 delusions is actually ignorance.
And if we eliminate the root in the same way as if we cut the root of a tree, all of the branches which are which spring out from the trunk of the tree will eventually wither and die. Likewise, if we cut the root of these 81,000 delusions, all 81,000 delusions will disappear. As Āryadeva, the great Madhya Mika scholar said so beautifully, in the same way as the bodily organ has control over the senses. Likewise, Rinpoche says the first part of this verse refers to the fact that even though we have many different, sense organs, the eye sense organ, the ear sense organ, nose, tongue, bodily, the other sense organs are actually subsidiary to the bodily sense organ which controls them all and which underlies them. Their field of activity is smaller.
Want to look at today’s. Likewise, in the second verse, Āryadeva says, to overcome all the afflictions, overcome ignorance. For indeed, Rinpoche says, ignorance underlies all afflictions. It is actually the cause of coarse afflictions which are born from it, but even the subtle afflictions, well, they’re not necessarily born from it are mixed with it. And therefore, to eliminate both the coarse and the subtle afflictions, one must eliminate ignorance which is at their root.
And once ignorance is eliminated, the afflictions will will disappear in and of themselves. And what is the means to put an end to ignorance? Both Sūtra and Tantra together teach jointly that the means is a realization of interdependence. As Āryadeva said, he who realizes interdependence puts an end to ignorance. Therefore, it is capital to meditate on interdependence.
And as Je Tsongkhapa said, since through mere renunciation and bodhicitta for enlightenment is not possible, enter the path of interdependence which leads to the city of liberation. Likewise, Buddha himself said, he who sees interdependence sees phenomena. He who sees phenomena sees buddhahood. The meaning of this quote is that seeing buddhahood is actually akin to attaining full enlightenment. Therefore, meditation on interdependence is fundamental.
And therefore, to eliminate a fever, it will never be sufficient just to drink something cold or take medicine against the fever since this can only act at a bodily level. And as Rinpoche has explained, the from among the true sufferings, bodily and mental sufferings, mental sufferings is the are the ultimate cause. They are the underlying cause. It is therefore the afflictions, the negative mental states, which are the cause of bodily suffering. And in turn, is ignorance, which is the cause of the negative mental states of afflictions.
So it is through eliminating ignorance at the root that all the other forms of suffering can be eliminated. And when we speak of eliminating ignorance, we refer naturally to the realization of interdependence. As Rinpoche explained several courses ago, there are three broad types of interdependence. The coarsest is the interdependence of causes and conditions. Then a more subtle level of interdependence is interdependence on parts.
And the most subtle level of interdependence of all is interdependence on conceptual imputation. Now while the latter is quite difficult to understand. The first interdependence on causes and conditions is quite accessible to us. It’s accessible to experience. We know, for instance, that a flower is dependent on its causes and conditions.
The cause of a flower is the seed of the flower. The conditions are, for instance, water, manure, fertilizer, and sunlight. If either the cause or the conditions are absent, a flower will not arise. So a flower cannot be said to be an independent existent, which exists independently of its causes and conditions. Likewise, for the second category of interdependence, interdependence on parts.
If Rinpoche takes the example of the table in front of him, the table in front of him depends on its various parts and directions, the top, the bottom, the sides, the outside, the inside, the actually 14 different sectors of the table, all of which go towards constituting the table. There is no such thing as a table which does not depend on its parts. And finally, the most subtle form of interdependence is that which Rinpoche explained previously, which is the interdependence in terms of conceptual imputation. For instance, a person being dependent on the conceptual imputation of the name person on a basis of designation, which are the five aggregates. And when we talk of interdependence, what is meant precisely by this?
What is meant by the term interdependence is actually arising from another. The Tibetan term tendrel has two syllables. Ten is the base and relwa is related. So it’s related to a base, related to an other. Now how can phenomena arise from others or originate from others?
There are actually two ways for them to do this. They can actually either arise from another or be generated from another, which are two very different terms. For instance, the I is said to arise from the aggregates because the I is in the continuum of the aggregates. The eye on the other hand is not said to be generated from the aggregates. A human being is said to be generated from his parents in the same way as a sprout is be said is said to be generated from a seed.
So for instance, when we speak of the interdependence of a person from within the two categories of interdependence, a person is interdependent because it arises from the aggregates.
So it is therefore important to again and again meditate on interdependence And through repeated analysis, and only in this way would eventually the meaning of emptiness dawn to the mind. Otherwise, the meaning of emptiness will not dawn to the mind. Now fundamentally, Rinpoche has explained over the last couple of sessions the relationship between the basis of imputation and the imputed phenomenon. In the specific case of the person, the basis of imputation of the five aggregates and the imputed phenomenon is the person. There is no such thing as a basis of imputation without an imputed phenomenon.
Likewise, there can be no such thing as an imputed phenomenon without a basis of imputation. The two basis of imputation and imputed phenomenon are mutually dependent. And a person can therefore be said to be not only an interdependent phenomenon, but also a dependent origination. It is an interdependent phenomenon because it is not a phenomenon which arises or because it is a phenomenon which arises in dependence on others, because it’s a not a phenomenon which does not arise independently of others. The meaning of this is that the very interdependence of phenomena and the very interdependence of persons actually prevents persons from being inherently existent.
Anything which is interdependently existing cannot be inherently existing. Anything which is inherently existing cannot be interdependently existing. So in the case of the person through establishing that it exists in dependence on others, that it is a dependent arising, we have automatically established that it cannot be inherently existing. If we were to analyze using other lines of reasoning, anything which is inherently existing is inherently existing as one or inherently existing as different. If the person were inherently existing, it would be inherently existing either as one or as different.
Inherently existing either as one or as different with the aggregates. If the person were inherently one with the aggregates, then it will actually have to be one with the aggregates in the strictest sense of the term, which means that whenever you said person, you would be saying aggregates. And whenever you said aggregates, you would be saying person. And you would technically have to have the very same name for these two categories of phenomena, the imputed phenomenon, the basis of imputation. This is obviously not the case.
Likewise, if the person and the aggregates were inherently different, then they would be absolutely unrelated. There would be no connection in the slightest between them. This is obviously not the case. They would be as unrelated as a horse and a sheep, say. So through reasoning in these terms, we can establish that a person is not inherently existing and is a dependent arising.
In the same same way as, for instance, a flower can be said to be not inherently existing, but a dependent arising because it arises in dependence on many causes and conditions, its seed and so forth. So these are the lines of reasoning which we have to adopt. As Nāgārjuna said in the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, anything which is a dependent arising necessarily does not exist inherently. Finger. So to take the example of his hand, if we analyze Rinpoche’s hand, then he has fingers, and he has a palm, and skin on the back of the hand, and flesh and bones in between.
And in dependence on all of these, we can say that the hand is imputed. But if we were to try to find the hand using ultimate reasoning among its basis of imputation, the hand is unfindable. We cannot say the hand is the finger, the hand is the palm, the hand is the flesh or the skin at the back. Yet, Rinpoche’s hand exists because it can perform a function. He can hold things with his hand.
If you take, for instance, himself as an example. So Khensur Rinpoche has his aggregates, his body, and so forth. And Khensur Rinpoche is imputed. The name Khensur Rinpoche is imputed on these aggregates. So, therefore, you would think Khensur Rinpoche exists.
Then when you examine, you say, where is Khensur Rinpoche? Well, it’s not his knees. It’s not his hands. It’s not his shoulders. And you might come to the conclusion Khensur Rinpoche does not exist.
So he would like to reassure you he really does exist. He is teaching. And as Āryadeva said, the body is composed of earth, water, fire, air, space, and various other constituents. And Rinpoche himself is composed of these constituents. He’s composed of the solid, liquid, fire, air, space, consciousness, and so forth.
And Khensur Rinpoche himself can be said to be a mere nominal imputation on these constituents. So this mere nominal imputation is the only mode of existence of Rinpoche because under ultimate analysis, Rinpoche is unfindable in the same way as all phenomena for that matter are totally unfindable under ultimate analysis. Yet they exist. They exist as mere nominal conceptual imputations. And his holiness of Dalai Lama has said that this is one of the main contributions which Buddhism can make to modern scientific research.
Because modern scientific research leads scientists to a profound understanding of all the constituents of body and matter. But there is a very big risk that through analyzing systematically the body and never finding the person, they may conclude that, while the parts exist, the person itself does not exist and fall into a nihilist view. And to such a viewpoint, has suggested that one respond, while indeed the person is unfindable under ultimate analysis, yet nonetheless, it does exist as a mere nominal conceptual imputation. His Holiness believes indeed too that this will provoke smiles of bewilderment from the scientists.
All of the Buddhist schools from the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards, which means the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka, the Cittamātra, the Sautrāntika, and the Vaibhāṣika, all believe indeed that. That if there is a phenomenon, that phenomenon is necessarily findable. And therefore, since a person exists, a person is necessarily findable under ultimate analysis. And they then try to identify the locus of the person in the aggregates. So some assert that the person is the body, the form aggregates.
Some assert that it’s a continuum of the aggregates. Some assert that it is the mind basis of all, the ālaya vijnana. Some assert that it is the mental consciousness, such as certain Chittamatras. But all assert that since a person exists, it must be findable. It is only the Prāsaṇgika school which asserts that although the person is unfindable, unfindability under ultimate analysis is not a criterion for nonexistence, and this is the uncommon position of the Prāsaṇgika school.
So the lowest schools are unable to formulate a difference between existence and true existence on the one side and nonexistence and true nonexistence on the other side. They consider therefore that every existent is necessarily truly existent. Every nonexistent is also truly nonexistent. Likewise, consider that everything which is truly existent exists, and everything which is truly nonexistent does not exist. The Prasangikas, in the light of their scholarship and understanding of phenomena, postulate a difference between existence and true existence on the one side and between nonexistence and true nonexistence on the other side.
And they assert that while the table in front of Rinpoche, for instance, can be said to be an existent. It is not a true existent because true existence does not exist. In so doing, they give major headaches to the lower schools. Yeah. So the question is, can Rinpoche explain why when we meditate on the emptiness of the self of persons, we develop an understanding of dependent arising through analyzing a cup or some other such phenomenon?
So Rinpoche said he took the example of his cup to explain the process of meditating on interdependence and the unfindability of phenomena. In the same way as when we analyze Rinpoche’s cup, we find that it does not exist independently of its parts and its sections, top, bottom, outside, inside and so forth. And that the cup, Rinpoche’s cup, is only designated in dependence on, or is named in dependence on these parts. In the same way, a person is named in dependence on the parts of that person, which are the five aggregates. So the cup and the person are similar in that they are both imputations on the basis of basis of imputation.
This is a case for all phenomena. Likewise, for Rinpoche’s table for a book and so forth. So what is this? And therefore, it is the procedure of analysis, which is the same for all of the examples he gave, whether it be a cup, an object of any type, his book, or whatever. And it is very important having understood it on one basis to extend it to other basis.
This is what is meant when we speak of analysis through valid cognition. So if we only have a very small and narrow mind and we do it, this analysis on one object only and are afraid to extend it to others, He says that’s rather a sign of stupidity. So this procedure is characteristic of Madhyamaka and Pramāna Vartika studies in which typology can be extended to all the phenomena with great flexibility. This is not the case when one studies Vinaya or Abhidharma, which have their uncommon mode of presentation. So Rinpoche suggested instead of keeping your eyes closed fearfully like this, you look around what’s happening in the room.
Okay. Thank you. Okay. Page nine. Okay.
Take care. Thank you very much. Announcement for, tenets. You may have noticed that you have not received a doubt sheet this week, and just as a reference, you will not get a doubt sheet this week. The reason for this is that I have heard rumors that some people are not reviewing tenets before coming to the discussion group.
And the goal of the discussion group is for your own doubts to be present in your minds. So this week, before coming to the discussion group, please cover the material we covered last week and come up with your own questions. And if you don’t have any whatsoever, then I’ll try to provide. Hello. I have a few announcements.
This Saturday, there will be a teaching on, self on self, no self, and freedom. Okay? It’s by, Ilya. Please welcome everybody and by it’s a donation. And next tomorrow, there will be a teaching.
Geshe-la is going to give his teachings on
Essence of nectar and, be enjoyable. And, please, maybe, welcome everybody. And, this, Sunday is going to be a sojong day. There will be a, where was it? Precept in the morning.
And, after that, maybe the refuge ceremony. If you haven’t taken the refuge, then maybe register. And, so and, just that and the October retreat is, you know, that is around the place, flies. Another very auspicious thing, you know, is happening now. You know, we, before Saka Dawa, are going to receive a thousand Arms.
And, so, hopefully, maybe tomorrow night, we will update, but we’ll see. And, yeah. If you haven’t taken refuge, if you’re thinking and being in, teachings for a long time and, haven’t taken refuge, I think it’s time for you to take, really. There’s no harm for you, really. And, there will be good time, and it’s very auspicious, you know, day on this Sunday so that I strongly recommend, you know, to to to if those who coming for center and receiving teaching a long time and not sure about, but I would recommend, you know, should take there’ll be, much more, accumulating merits, you know, if you have a refuge.
And, you’re making, committing oneself very strongly towards the Triple Gem. So that’s my recommendation. Okay? And, that’s it. Thank you very much.
There’s a child there. Like, our program is somewhere around here. Okay? I won’t go through all those again.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Saka Dawa
- One of four great holy days of the Tibetan calendar, falling on the fifteenth of the fourth Tibetan month, Saka Dawa commemorates the Buddha’s birth, enlightenment and parinirvana. LYWA
- Sojong possadha (Skt)
- The bi-monthly practice by ordained Sangha of purifying broken vows by confession in front of other Sangha members. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Why do we analyze a cup or other object when meditating on the emptiness of the self of persons?
A cup is used as an example for meditating on interdependence and the unfindability of phenomena. Analysis shows the cup does not exist independently of its parts, such as top, bottom, outside and inside, and is only designated in dependence on them. In the same way, a person is named in dependence on the five aggregates. So both are imputations on a basis of imputation. The procedure is the same for any object, such as a table or a book, and it is important to extend what is understood on one basis to others. Doing the analysis on one object only, afraid to extend it, is a sign of a narrow mind.