Refuge – 2014-06-04 – KR

32 min · 4,303 words · 4 June 2014

Refuge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Refuge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Refuge - 2014-06-04 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Before a group takes refuge, the teacher explains what refuge means as a protector against cyclic existence, and that the Buddhist refuge can be examined by reason. He covers the objects of refuge (Dharma, Buddha and Sangha), the specific and common refuge precepts, and cautions against hasty conversion. Questions about karma and refuge are answered briefly at the end.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 33 min

UUID: 371a189b-eba2-4d23-9a05-d3b22e2ac12a

Date: 2014-06-04

Words: 4,299

Then I’m delighted that we all gathered tonight and if I understand correctly, most of you are planning on taking refuge with Geshela and I was asked by Tenzin to give a brief introduction on refuge precepts. Then we have half an hour, so what I thought to do was to cover refuge itself during fifteen minutes. Geshe will cover it in much greater detail, and then the refuge precepts, which are a natural outflow of refuge during the remaining fifteen minutes. And then you will have an elaborate teaching on refuge from Geshela, and I would encourage you to think very carefully about it. So, what do we mean by refuge?

Every one of us has already many refuges within our mind stream. For instance, I would assume in Australia, most of you take refuge in the welfare state. In other words, you assume that if something goes wrong, the state will be there to take care of you. That’s a very powerful refuge. In other parts of the world, people take refuge in their family.

Some people take refuge in relationships, perhaps the most unstable refuge there is. And certainly in The United States, people take refuge in money. Well, refuge is in other words, you turn to when everything else goes bad. It is what will protect you. Now there are two types of refuges, material and non material refuges.

I think in the West at present, most of us only have material refuges, and most of you are here because your material refuges have failed you. Probably you would not be here otherwise. The non material refuges can either be refuges which are accessible to thought, which are logical, or refuges which are not accessible to thought. Most of the great world religions offer a refuge god who is not accessible to thought. In other words, god is not the subject of logical investigations, you just must accept on faith.

Buddhism is unique in the great world religions, and it’s a debate whether it’s a religion or philosophy, in that the Buddhist refuge, which is actually the teachings, is accessible to thought, to logic. So this is quite alien, if you have come from any other religious tradition. You are not only encouraged to think it is indispensable. And in this context, whether your background is thank you, my dear. Whether your background is originally Christian or just secular, I think we have to talk about the issue of conversion.

Then in this matter, His Holiness for the last twenty years has been remarkably constant. His Holiness discourages the conversion of Westerners. It’s quite explicit. And His Holiness’s stance on the conversion of Westerners has basically changed since I became a Buddhist, largely because of the extreme instability of most Westerners conversion. Now conversion generally is a source of instability, generally it is.

You are going from your own culture, your own language, your own framework of reference and frankly your own karmic imprint to something which is completely different. Now it will stay for a long time up here, it has to sink down here, and in most cases it does not. The statistics are quite clear, the cases have been studied in France, I don’t know of similar studies in Australia, but Lenoir, a French sociologist, gathered data from both Zen and Tibetan centers, including the one center which had been keeping records for thirty years, and what they found, and it was constant throughout all the Buddhist traditions, was that of let us say 100 people who came during a teaching on year zero, after five years 10 were still coming, and after ten years three were still coming. So this is an attrition rate of 97% over ten years. I my impression in Australia, and I have been here since 2008, is the situation is much worse here.

The French Buddhists I know are much more stable than the Australian Buddhists I know. This is a reason for which His Holiness has said, and this was applied to the French, but could apply as well to us, I believe that the French who are Christian by culture and ancestry should remain Christian. It is better to stick to your own traditional values, it is only if after mature reflection, you believe that Buddhism could offer you more than Christianity, that you should become a Buddhist. And his wife has repeated exactly the same thing in a recent book beyond religion. It is certainly not my intention in presenting this book to make more Buddhists.

In fact, when I’m asked to give Buddhist teachings in the West, I share my personal view that it is not by and large a good idea for people to adopt religious practices which are not well grounded in their own culture and educational background. To do so can be difficult and lead to unnecessary confusion. When you take refuge, you are undergoing the Buddhist equivalent of baptism, you are becoming Buddhist. If you have any doubts, it is better to wait, much better, for your own sake and for the sake of the spread of the teachings in the West. Then before taking refuge, it is indispensable to study carefully the teachings, nothing is gained by rushing into taking refuge to then realize one, two or three years down the line, that one is simply unable to accept core Buddhist teachings.

Specifically, for refuge to occur, there must be a complete mental assent to refuge, otherwise a refuge will not have occurred. And specifically, when you go to refuge, for refuge, you are going for refuge against what we know as cyclic existence, which means the beginningless reincarnations every single one of us has experienced. If you find it difficult to believe in reincarnation or if even though believing in reincarnation, you find it difficult to believe in karma, then it does not seem possible to take refuge at all. If you don’t believe in reincarnation, there is nothing to take refuge against or from. And if you don’t believe in karma and causality, there is no means the Buddhist teachings can protect you.

The Buddhist teachings are first and foremost an explanation of the functioning of karma and causality, and then an explanation of the means to transcend this. So for your own sake, the first step is to fully understand what the Buddhists mean by psychic existence, and ask yourself, does my own cyclic existence exist or not? If it doesn’t, then refuge becomes purely a sociological ceremony, and we have too many of those. So with this prelude, what precisely are the objects of refuge? The foremost object of refuge is a teachings, the dharma.

The other objects of refuge are in a sense derivative. The dharma or the Buddhist teachings are an object of refuge because they protect the person from suffering in future lives. As Geshe-la has made very clear here, whether there is protection from suffering in this life or not is open to question. This is not the goal of the teachings, this is not the reason Buddha Shakyamuni set out on his search and taught his dharma. Therefore, the first object of refuge is the dharma, and this dharma must not just be paid lip service, it must be understood.

It can be presented in two ways, either through the four noble truths, which is the way the Buddha taught dharma in the context of what is known as the first turning of the wheel of the law, or in terms of the Four Seals. Both have been presented at TBI. I would greatly encourage you to study the Four Noble Truths, study the Four Seals, and ask yourself a very simple question, is this true or not? You if you’re thinking of refuge, you are no longer in the situation of suspension of disbelief, where you attend teachings and see basically what is being said. You are thinking of a commitment which extends not only through this life, but in future lives.

So you have to ask the question of truth, and you should take as much time as is necessary to be able to say, yes, I am convinced that let’s say the four seals are true. In the case of the four seals, certainly three of the four seals are broadly speaking verified scientifically. In the case of the Four Noble Truths, it’s a much more difficult topic. It’s always very awkward when one has people who have already taken refuge, and one realizes that there is profound doubt regarding the basics of the teachings. That at this point, it is open to question whether refuge is actually present in their mind stream or not.

So I encourage you, we have a very good Geshe here, we have a good library, do not rush, study carefully, think, take your time, and once you are really convinced that not the details such as Mount Meru, the core elements of the Buddhist teachings are true, then you can take refuge with sincerity and honesty, and then it is a very transformative experience. So as we said, one takes refuge in the Buddha’s dharma, his teachings, and then obviously as a result of this one takes refuge in the teacher of those teachings, Buddha himself. The great Buddhist philosopher, Dignaga, paid homage to the Buddha precisely because the Buddha had taught his teachings. He said this qualified the Buddha as what’s known as a being who is a valid cognizer. And then one also takes refuge in those who follow these teachings, which is known as a Sangha.

Now these are the objects of refuge, and if we analyze them in a bit more detail, you’ll see that they are quite profound. The dharma can be presented in terms either of ultimate or conventional dharma. Ultimate dharma are the last two of the four noble truths, the noble truth of cessation, in other words, the end of the afflictions in your mind stream, and the noble truth of the path. This is the actual refuge. The actual refuge is the third and the fourth Noble Truth, specifically the third Noble Truth, it’s the ultimate refuge.

Conventionally, dharma are all Buddhist texts and teachings because they teach the means to actually realize the Noble Truth of cessation, which is our goal. Then Buddha himself has two aspects, ultimate and conventional. The ultimate aspect is the two aspects of Buddha’s omniscience, his all knowingness, the dharmakaya and the emptiness of the dharmakaya. The conventional aspect are the two bodies Buddha manifests, the body of manifestation, the body of emanation. In the case of the Sangha, which we call casually the monastic community, the ultimate Sangha are beings, monastics, who have realized emptiness, in other words, who are on the path of seeing, and the conventional Sangha is at least four fully ordained member, members of the Buddhist monastic community.

These are your objects of refuge. The dharma, because it transforms your own mind, The Buddha, because he taught it. The Sangha, because they practice it. This dharma will only impact your mind if your assessment of your predicament is the same as that of the Buddha’s. So if for instance, you are interested in Buddhism for health reasons or because of psychological issues, and you view the Buddhist teachings as helping you in this in this way, then it is impossible for you to take refuge.

There’s no foundation. You’re taking refuge for the problems of this life. Teachings may or may not help you. So I really encourage you to study in detail the works of authors such as Stevenson, have done a very very careful study of the existence of past and future lives, there’s a lot of very strong data about the existence of past and future lives, and to try to generate powerful certainty within yourself, then taking refuge will be profoundly meaningful, and having taken refuge, there are certain precepts associated with refuge, but these are a fairly natural outflow outcome of refuge once you fully understand refuge. So we have precepts which are specific to each of the three objects of refuge, the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, and we have general precepts.

Then I start with the precepts which are specific, and these precepts which are specific are subdivided into two groups, what one should avoid and what one should practice, these are called proscriptive and prescriptive precepts. So having taken refuge regarding the Buddha, what you should avoid is to pay any type of homage to worldly deities, then in the West it’s not an issue. People don’t believe in anything, so why would they believe in worldly deities? I would say that most Asian countries are at present only sociologically Buddhist, the true refuge is refuge in spirits. But for yourselves, you know, it might happen that you become profoundly convinced of the power of spirits, you know, people in the New Age groups tend to be more oriented towards that, having taken refuge you cannot rely on them.

Then the second prescriptive, well, I get confused with them as well, so the second thing to be avoided regarding the Dharma is all forms of violence, having taken refuge in the Dharma, the core of Buddhist teachings is non violence, and here non violence is not purely physical non violence as we understand it in the West, it’s a rejection of anger in all its forms, so verbal non violence is rejected, and it really entails an active stance against anger. Then the third thing to be avoided regarding the Sangha is having taken refuge in the Sangha to avoid any association with non Buddhist practitioners. Now this seems quite stark, but at the beginning, if one has taken refuge, one is quite fragile in one’s refuge. One can easily be destabilized, and therefore, one should try to befriend and be acquainted with people on the same path as oneself. If one has long-standing non-Buddhist friends, one takes a certain amount of distance without making it too obvious.

Now, what are the prescriptive injunctions? What should one, in other words, practice? Regarding the Buddha, if the Buddha is indeed the teacher of something this profound, then we should show respect to all representations of the Buddha. You see, in worldly matters in America, the picture of the president is always put on high in the room of any official, and disrespect to the picture of the president or the flag in some states is a punishable offense. Now here we’re talking of something much more profound.

If the dharma is true, then the Buddha taught something unique, and therefore his statues should be saluted wherever one sees them, you see this in Asia. Representations of the Buddha should never be bought nor sold. So this has become endemic, it is a breach of the refuge precepts. You can make an offering, but it is very sad to see this constant sale of Buddhist statues and Buddhist objects, these are not objects which are part of commerce. Commerce stops at the door of the temple, or at least it should.

Then the second prescriptive injunction is to respect every text, but more fundamentally, and it is said in the Kadam tradition, to respect every letter as the Dharma, in other words, to respect language as the purveyor of the teachings, and you will see that the Geshes, for instance, are very uncomfortable having letters on their shoes. For this reason, language is respected, But more fundamentally, texts. You should not put texts in low areas. Definitely, you should not walk over them. If you are carrying Buddhist texts or putting Buddhist texts on a shelf, the Buddhist texts must come on top.

You should never put anything above them, simply out of respect for the teachings. And the third prescriptive injunction regarding the Sangha this time is to respect the colors of the Sangha, which are symbols of renunciation. In other words, to respect mainly the colors yellow and red, and in some Chinese Buddhist nations, gray blue. It’s mainly yellow and red. So these are the three specific injunctions.

The common injunctions, are shared by all three objects of refuge, Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. First, if you have taken refuge, to take refuge over and again. It seems trite, but this deepens the sensation of refuge, of going for protection. The second one is at every meal, and it is an excellent opportunity to gain merit, to offer one’s food. We have prayers, I think, the prayer book.

You should pray, you should utter these prayers whenever you eat and whenever you drink. Then the act of eating and drink drinking is sanctified. It’s no longer something merely mundane. And you offer the first part of the food to the Buddha, who has obviously no usage for it whatsoever, it’s for your own sake you do this, and then you consume it. Then the third injunction is one which must be qualified somewhat.

It is to lead others to refuge. What is meant here is that if others express their with a wish to take refuge, to become Buddhist in other words, you should do everything you can to help them. Buddhism does not proselytize, since proselytism is something which demeans the teachings, it cheapens the teachings, and therefore it is only those who from their side express interest to whom the teaching should then be explained. Then having taken refuge, and this develops the first injunction, you should take refuge three times by day and three times by night, ideally in the morning and at night before going to sleep. Then the notion of refuge will be present in your mindstream.

The fifth common injunction is that once you have taken refuge, and this is a natural result of taking refuge, whatever project you are involved in, you should entrust yourself to the Triple Gem. Now when this is powerful, it can be extraordinarily powerful. I know of one Tibetan Geshe, Lobsang Yatso, he was the head of the school of dialectics in Dharamsala, who was surrounded by a bushfire in Tibet. They had them in the summer, you know. It just happened quickly when he was in the hills.

And by the time he looked around him, he was surrounded by flames and facing death. And he took refuge, very powerfully, under the circumstances you can imagine. And after taking refuge, he found an opening. Then whether finding this opening is a result of refuge or not, that depends on one’s own faith. He believed it.

If your refuge is powerful, it becomes something which is dominant in your life. If refuge is wobbly, everything else is wobbly in terms of practice. Once your refuge is destroyed, all your vows collapse instantaneously. Finally, the sixth injunction is not to abandon the Triple Gem even at the cost of your own life, which is easily said, but you must train yourself mentally. If you are to stay on a plane and the plane is hijacked by extremists, and you are told to give up your refuge or you will be shot, Then being shot is after all the end of this life, which is going to come of anyway.

Keeping pure refuge guarantees having refuge in a future life. Then if you weigh the two, it’s not difficult to choose. Especially being shot is not painful. If you’re shot in the head, you don’t feel anything. You know?

It’s over before you know it happened. Right? Then you should think about it in these terms. Train your mind so that your own refuge becomes more and more powerful. Then I have covered what I wanted to, mention.

Do you have any questions? We have five minutes. Intoxicants. Intoxicants. That is something else.

Are lay vows. Refuge is the act of becoming Buddhist, like baptism is the act of becoming a Christian. Then if you want, many Buddhists don’t have lay vows, but if you want to protect your ethics and accumulate more merit, you can take five, four, three, two or even one lay vow. You don’t have to. It is independent from refuge.

These are vows in the same category as monastic vows and known as vows of individual liberation. And then having taken refuge, since you were a Buddhist, you can also take bodhisattva vows, which are above this. You can even take tantric vows, but they all rest on refuge. In other words, if your refuge collapses, every single vow you have taken collapses at the same time. If from the depth of your heart, for instance, you cease to view the teachings as an object of refuge, you view them as force, for instance, there’s quite a few so called Western Buddhists who are in that category, like Stephen Batchelor who says, the Buddha never taught reincarnation, you know.

At that point, your refuge collapses, whatever other vows you might have have also collapsed, So the result of this viewpoint is that you have broken all the vows you ever took. For this reason, refuge is like the foundation of a house. When you want to build a house, I think even in Australia, you don’t have foundations. It says a lot about the psychology of the country to me, but even in Australia, you check the ground, don’t you? Right?

You don’t build on just anything, because you may spend as much as you want on the house. If your ground is wobbly, your walls are going to crack within a couple of years and everything else goes to pieces. Refuge is your foundation, you examine the land, you check and you build carefully. Do you have other questions? Please.

Do your past deeds affect the taking of refuge? Can I? Well, certainly we’re in a city of what? 1 and a half million in Adelaide. Right?

And there’s what? Two, four, six, eight, nine people in this room. Nine out of one and a half million wish to take refuge. So that means you have a karmic connection. From a Buddhist standpoint, it wouldn’t happen otherwise.

Whether that karmic connection is strong enough, that we don’t know. And probably you don’t know either. But that connection is why you ended up here. Then that connection made the link, you have to build on it. And for Westerners, generally speaking, it is taught in the teachings that there are two ways to practice, the one based on faith and the one based on reason.

I think honestly for Westerners, there’s only one way to practice, and it’s a way based on reason. We don’t have faith because we were not raised as children, as Buddhists. It’s very difficult to ask a Westerner to have faith. Why should he or she? So we must rely on reason in study.

And therefore, I really encourage you to study carefully the Buddhist teachings at the center, and then to go home and to do your own research. I have tried to bridge things in my conference conferences, but there’s only so much which can be done. You have to do the work yourself. Read the work of scientists who have studied the evidence for past and future lives, study simplified versions of the works of physicists who say that basically there’s an intimate relation between mind and matter, and the mind cannot be material, and on this basis, over the years, you will build a very solid practice. Otherwise, the risk, you see, which I’ve seen many many times in the last thirty and some years, is to fall a bit in love with the teachings.

Right? That’s the result of a karmic imprint. Right? To take on board more than you are actually comfortable with. And then the mind is like a rat, you know, when you push the mind in a corner for a very long time, it rebels and you have problems on your head.

Then everything snaps and the person leaves. Then they come back. But there has been damage. Karmically, there has been damage. And that damage must be corrected.

So for yourselves, instead of going too quickly at the beginning and then having problems later, go slowly. You can attend teachings at this center, the lam-rim teachings, all your life without ever becoming Buddhist. So attend the teachings, think on the meaning, ask yourself, is this true or not? You need to be 80 per that you need 80% of the teachings to be true, then maybe Mount Meru isn’t where they said it was, but that as His Holiness the Dalai Lama said, Buddha did not come to teach geography. Right?

So the basics must just be clear to you, and then if you have no discomfort in your mind and you wish to take refuge, then as his holiness said here, out of millions of Westerners, statistically, are a couple who have a karmic connection with Buddhism. Then he will be one of the couple, and it will be of great benefit. Then, I’m afraid we have to stop here for now. I’d be glad to talk to you privately after the teachings, you know, and I encourage all of you to think carefully. His Holiness has been so clear on this topic, if you have any doubt, check his recent publications.

Every teaching he has given in the West, he has encouraged Westerners to be cautious. We have thirty, forty years of experience now of rapid conversion and rapid deconversion, you know. So for yourself, this is something you don’t want to happen. Right? Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
four seals
The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
individual liberation
The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
Kadam
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Atisha, Dromtönpa and their followers, the "Kadampa geshes"; the forerunner of the Gelug School. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Do your past deeds affect whether you take refuge, and how should a Westerner approach it?

Wishing to take refuge shows a karmic connection, since from a Buddhist standpoint it would not happen otherwise. Whether the connection is strong enough is not known, so it has to be built on. For Westerners, who were not raised as Buddhists, practice must rest on reason rather than faith. This means studying the teachings carefully, doing one's own research, and going slowly. Taking on more than one is comfortable with can make the mind rebel, and the resulting damage must later be corrected. One can attend lam-rim teachings for life without becoming Buddhist. Take refuge only when the basics seem true and there is no discomfort in the mind.

Scroll to Top