Public Talks – 2010-10-03 – KR

1 h 1 min · 6,822 words · 3 October 2010

Public Talks (Khensur Rinpoche)
Public Talks (Khensur Rinpoche)
Public Talks - 2010-10-03 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A speaker at a symposium on integrating Buddhism into daily life argues that modern physics and Buddhist thought meet on key points. He describes atoms as mostly empty space, wave-particle duality, and Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle as parallels to emptiness and impermanence. He also links karma to cause and effect and to the mind, and compares scientific discovery to meditation. The talk ends with a question and answer session on karma and quantum-style change of mind.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 1m

UUID: 5e757aa4-226f-412c-b84c-83572c2c2afc

Date: 2010-10-03

Words: 6,818

Congratulations everybody for taking note of daylight saving. No doubt there will be a few people. So this symposium has been advertised as the opportunity at the suggestion of Khensur Rinpoche for his older students to meet, to discuss with the community and friends integrating Buddhism into their daily lives. Malvin is one of Rinpoche’s newest students, enthusiastic, dedicated, and exemplary in his service of doing a lot behind the scenes for TBI. Obviously in terms of past lives there’s a connection there.

Malvin works in the engineering trades as a technician, received an undergraduate degree in physics in The US, hence the accent. His primary focus over the past twenty five years in his free time has been on the sciences as they express the hidden aspects of nature and with bridging work between the two. His special interests are the human subtle energy system, physics and technology, astronomy and all aspects of oriental esoteric thought. He is the author of Bodies of Fire and Exploration of the Lesser Chakra System. He has authored numerous articles and has lectured on various aspects of esoteric studies with several non profit organizations dedicated to the teaching of the same.

So it’s my pleasure to hand over to Melvin. Thank you. Thanks Chris. As Chris has mentioned, I’m probably pretty new to Khensur Rinpoche. I’ve only been involved with the center here since 2007.

But my involvement with Buddhism has pretty much been lifelong in one aspect or another. I came from a background in the Bible Belt in the middle of The US, grew up in North Carolina, and hence was steeped in all the conservative Christian ethic, which might lead one to wonder why I would end up in Buddhism. But the the fact is that my family upbringing has essentially given me a very open mind about things and encouraged me to investigate every aspect of of life. So my my father and my mother both were educators. My father was a musician, started us all on violin with there were four siblings when we were three years old.

So I had exposure to music and university level education pretty much all my life. And when I went into uni, I had a double major to begin with in music and physics. But my father made it pretty clear to me that I didn’t really have the, the discipline for the practice of the the violin to be any kind of a success in music. I took his advice and stayed in physics, which I’ve not really regretted actually. In a recent teaching, Khensur Rinpoche in in his course, the Bodhichittavivarana, made the following statement.

He said, nowadays, the scientific approach to reality and scientists in general are characterized by great intellectual integrity and honesty. And this means that the dialogue of Buddhism with science is extraordinarily fruitful. Rinpoche would like us to do everything in our power to foster this. We ourselves as Buddhists should study the scientific worldview, and the scientists from their side are very interested in the traditional perspectives of Buddhist philosophy. Far from discounting them, they actually ask very clear and well thought out questions about the understandings Buddhists have on these matters.

So Rinpoche thinks it would be very beneficial for a mutually helpful approach to a rise where Buddhists try to understand the scientific worldview and scientists from their own side try to understand the Buddhist worldview and this will lead to improvement for all. As most of us probably know, His Holiness is spearheading efforts along those lines as well. Now when I was in my late teens and decided to go into physics, I didn’t really have any huge interest in Buddhism at the time. In fact, I’d just come through a period where I’ve been through my born again phase. As, you know, it’s kind of a rite of passage in the Bible Belt, you know, you you examine one one examines their religious beliefs and whether or not it fits with the worldview and all.

And for most of my teenage years, I was pretty devout, which indicates somewhat the karma I’ve had around religion. But when I was 17, I had a crisis of conscience, and it resolved around revolved around the whole idea of hell, basically. I couldn’t understand how loving God could condemn his creations to hell for simple lapses in reason or wrong views. And that lead led me to disconnect myself with the church and with Christianity itself there for a couple of years. But it also led me in my agnostic path to research all the other aspects of religious thought and scientific thought at the same time.

Now when I was in uni, it was a it was a liberal arts college, which meant that you had a I had exposure to all the different disciplines. So I had to take PE classes and religious classes because it was a church funded school. And I’d have to say that it was probably the best sort of education I could have had because of that exposure, I didn’t have a closed mind about anything. And in the comparative religious studies, we studied Buddhism along with all the other religions. It was it was quite quite a good exposure.

But when I got into physics, my main interests were in particle physics, astronomy, and sound. And in fact, I had to do a modern physics experiment toward the end of the tenure there in which did a study on Fourier analysis, which is basically the analysis of of sound waves and reproducing sound waves from the various harmonics and that sort of thing. But the thing that really clinched it for me in terms of Buddhism was the study of the atom itself. And I’ll just read a little passage from it’s in the bibliography bibliography too about the book His Holiness, the first one. And he says, nowadays, physicists explain that phenomena do not exist merely objectively in and of themselves, but exist in terms of, in the context of involvement with a perceiver or observer.

I feel the topic of the relation between matter and consciousness is a place where Eastern philosophy and particularly Buddhist philosophy and science could meet. I think this would be a happy marriage with no divorce. If we work along the lines of joint effort with Buddhist scholars, not merely scholars, but those who also have some practice in meditation and pure unbiased physicists, if such a thing exists, to investigate, study, and engage in deeper research in the field of the relation between matter and consciousness, we may find beautiful things that may be helpful. This does not have to be considered the the practice of religion but can be done simply for the extension of human knowledge. That’s quite a statement.

He goes on to say, Buddhism belongs to neither religion nor pure science, but this situation presents us with an opportunity to make a link or a bridge between faith and science. This is why I believe that in the future, we will have to work at bringing these two forces more closely together than they are they are at the present. We’re gonna examine a bit of this this morning. And hopefully see that science has at its very foundation a confirmation of Buddhist practice. Now as as was stated in the introduction, I work as a technician.

And one might ask why if I have a degree in physics, didn’t continue on with it. Well, when I was 21 years old, I kinda lost my heart for school, really. There’s an American musician named Frank Zappa who made a statement once that if you want to if you want to party, go to college. If you wanna learn something, to the library. So I went to college for four years.

And then later on, I went to the library. And in fact, I spent a good many years in libraries, you know, trolling around for information on on matters, human subtle energy, and Chinese medicine, and all sorts of things. That’s been a journey in and of itself, but what we want to look at today is the relation between or what I wanna examine today is the relation between pure science and and Buddhist, fundamental Buddhist thought. Now one of the other reasons I didn’t continue on with school is because of basically had to get a job. I had the money.

And working in a physics laboratory with an undergraduate degree didn’t afford many opportunities. And I could see myself living in a little shack somewhere without much in the way of resources. So I went into industry basically and wound up first in metal fabrication shops and that led me into machinery and eventually brought me to Australia where I’ve continued the work on machine tools all along. What it’s done is it’s put me in a unique position because most machine tool technicians or most people who work on machinery at all don’t have any real idea of physics. But having the understanding of all the the basic laws of physics, I can look at things differently with a machine and nut out things that other people can’t.

So I’m the person that people call when no one else can fix it, basically. It’s led to some very interesting situations in terms of service, in terms of skillful means, in terms of putting one’s faith in theory and practice. In all, I would have to say I’ve I’ve been able to apply a lot of the the Buddhist ethic to my work all along. K. Now the thing about science is it’s science is kind of well, it’s it’s not really been around for more than about two hundred and fifty years if you really get down to brass tacks about it.

On the back of the bibliography, is there an extra one floating around there? Okay. We see certain timelines in terms of the the basic fundamentals of physics. And we start with Pythagoras who sought a mathematical understanding of the universe and he was involved with irrational numbers. What’s an irrational number?

Well, if you remember your mathematics, it’s a it’s a number where the decimal places never end. So if I if I put pi number of oranges up here, you couldn’t do it. Okay? Because the only way you can really represent such a number is through geometry. Now in a recent lecture by my able colleague here on sacred geometry and geometry sacred architecture and geometry, it was pointed out that the basis of all physical manifestation is numbers.

And when you get into particle physics, that’s very true. But the thing we also noticed about the the dates for Pythagoras is that he lived at the time of Shakyamuni Buddha. So there there was an impulse into the world at that point, if you wanna call it that. I don’t believe that things happen in isolation. The seeds were sown for pure science back in that time.

So there was a lot of thought with Pythagoras and his followers about number and about manifestation in general. Whereas with Shakyamuni, you had the the science of mind being born. We go forward with Democritus, who gave the first theory of atoms and said that space is largely empty, which is quite a statement in itself. Aristotle formalized the gathering of scientific knowledge and logical reasoning. And after that, you don’t really see much until we get to Galileo.

That’s a long period intervening. Geshe-la was called the father of physics, and he said that the laws of nature are mathematical, which is the basic premise of of physics. K. Physics, of course, we we physicists have great pride in this, but, physics is basically the the king of physical sciences because it underlies all the physical sciences. Everything is described by some mathematical formula or can be described that way.

With Newton, we got the laws of motion, both the birth of classical physics and anyone who takes a course in physics studies Newtonian mechanics. Force, mass acceleration, attraction to gravity, and that sort of thing. And then there was an intervening period in between. So it seems to kinda go in fits and starts, and it seems to pick up speed as well in terms of development of science. With Stoney in 1874, we had the theory of the electron and its estimated mass, and this is the first exposition of a subatomic particle.

The thing is when you major in physics, you have to do all the experiments that prove these things too. So I had to to do the experiments that prove the the mass of electrons, the the radius of a hydrogen atom, for instance, all these things. And you can read down the list. All the great names in physical science or or physics were there, Röntgen, Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Rutherford, De Broglie, Schrodinger, Heisenberg, Gell-Mann and Zweig, all up to string theory that we have today. The the turning point for me in terms of physics came down to the very structure of the atom itself.

When we, when we’re in school, we’re we’re taught that we have an atom. Your basic hydrogen atom has this kind of structure. You have a proton. You do it? Yeah.

You have a proton, an electron, which orbits this proton as the planetary model of the atom. And it was it’s also known known as the Bohr Rutherford model of the atom. Now if you if you know the mass of this, the proton, you know the mass of the electron, and you can calculate the the the radii of each one, you get some rather interesting things. So if we take our little orange orange proton here and do a comparative study of this, a comparative size analysis, shall we say, our electron would not even be visible. An electron is said to be a point mass point charge, which means that it’s only one dimensional.

You can’t really quantify it further than that. So if we come out from the center of this proton with our electron, how how far do you think we’d have to go? Keep going. Oh, no. Really?

Yeah. Somewhere in between. If our if our proton here was point one meter, You’d have to go 7.5 kilometers out to get to the first electron. Basically, the distance or or the ratio between the size of proton and the first electron shell is is 75,000. Now when we think of atoms, we think of them being solid.

We think of them as having substance. They can be weighed. They can be measured in some way. But the fact of the matter is there is one defining characteristic of this, which is? It’s empty.

It’s space. It’s a simple spatial relationship. I remember the first time I I looked at this and I did the calculations, and I sat there and looked at what I had before me and realized the tremendous spaces in between these things. I remember sitting there with my mouth open going, son of a biscuit eater. I didn’t quite use those terms.

Most people, when they look at these things, don’t think about the sorts of things I was thinking about though because what I realized was that the entirety of the physical universe had no real foundation, no foundation in fact. Now what’s what’s the primary goal of Buddhism? To realize emptiness. Well, welcome to scientific Dharma. Because Dharma, as Anthony rightly pointed out yesterday with the quote of Geshe Potowa, true Dharma dispels illusions or delusions.

That’s quite a dispelling argument. As it turns out, you can break down this proton into further subatomic particles, which they now term quarks. And as it turns out, the distance between those quarks is much the same. So the more you break this down, the more you realize that you’re not actually looking at at, hard physical substance. You’re looking more in terms of the, the concept of something rather than the actual thing itself.

Okay? But wait, there’s more. It gets better. Oops. Okay.

So in the science labs in the uni, you know, we had to calculate the mass of the electron, mass of protons, all the distances between the two, and then you get to what’s famously known as the slit experiment. Okay. So if you have a plate that has slits in it okay. This is the solid bit here. And you can take an electron gun, shall we say, and emit a beam of electrons and aim it through the top slit.

Okay? If you look at this on its side and you have a phosphor screen on the other side, okay, if you shoot a beam of electrons through the slit, it’s gonna cause this phosphor thing to glow. And what you would expect to see, there’s just one slit, one slit, It’s just one little spot. Right? Well, that’s not what you get.

If you, aim a beam of light through here, what you get are interference rings. K? And light as we know is is a wave phenomenon. It has frequency. It can be measured in terms of frequency.

Well, as it turns out, if you shoot a beam of electrons to the top slit, you still get interference rings. So you’re not you’re not looking at particles. You’re looking at waves. So as it turns out, every particle can be seen as a wave and vice versa. And this is another of the fundamentals of physics.

Okay? Which is summarized for us in the famous equation, which is the equation of special relativity from Einstein. This is the equation that equates matter and energy. So if we’re if in our solar system model of the atom, if we’re not looking at substance, we’re not looking at even particles, What are we actually seeing? We’re seeing energetic constructs of some some description.

Can I ask you a question about that? Yeah. What is the reason you couldn’t say it’s a wave of particles? You can. You can.

Yes. So it’s a wave of particles. Essentially what you can do and what a lot of physics does is say that instead of being one long continuous wave, you say it’s a wave packet that has a certain dimension. And that’s what it, you know, that’s the quantum model basically. So it’s a short burst of energy, short bursts of certain frequency.

So it is a wave particle as you say and it can be expressed in either way. You can either do the Newtonian side of it and calculate its mass or its apparent mass or you can measure it as a frequency. And in fact, as it turns out, every atom, every molecule can be expressed in terms of some frequency function. So when I did my Fourier analysis, I was also looking at the the basic wave structure of of matter itself. Okay.

So this these wave structures can be expressed in complex mathematical formulas. Does that answer that? Yeah. Okay. So we’re we’re we’re not looking at solid substance.

We’re looking at energy. We’re we’re looking at perception. And when we go back to his holiness’s statement, we begin to see how science and Buddhism can come together in in pure sort of fashion. And if we can leave our our cultural and group prejudices aside, we can come at some kind of an understanding about the the very very basis of our our existence, our physical existence at least, and try to find meaning in that somehow. And that’s that’s been my focus ever since ever since uni.

Because when I had those realizations, it began to dawn on me very quickly that if I went on and got a graduate degree, it wouldn’t really serve me in terms of my understanding of of life and of matter. Whatever. Yes. I could I could make some sort of contribution to science, but it would be empty or or hollow for me somehow. So I went into industry.

I worked for a while. I got some money behind me. Then I went back to libraries, as I said, I I started pouring through all this material. And I came up with a lot of information, which is which you can find in in the books and the bibliography. But one thing I will say is that if one had direct yogic cognition and could focus the consciousness down to the the size of an atom and could see this atom in its actual state, then what you would end up with is is very much a wave type model.

And in fact, this has been done. There’s a a book called Occult Chemistry, which is written by two trained clairvoyants and it’s since been verified physicist, Steven Phillips, who I actually had a conversation with some years ago. And basically, the the clairvoyant investigations confirm the entire quark and string theory. So we’re onto something with all this. Things are not as they seem.

If we can read between the lines, in a matter of speaking, then we begin to get the truth of, well, basically the physical world. And by inference, we can begin to move from that, which is what the science of psychology in its embryo state as it is now is beginning to do. Okay? So what’s been the result of all this science? Well, true scientific investigation starting with Galileo and Newton led to eventually to the Industrial Revolution in the late seventeen hundreds.

And I’ll just read you a little excerpt about about that. The Industrial Revolution was a period from the eighteenth and nineteenth century where major changes in agricultural manufacturing, mining, transport, and technology had a profound effect on the socioeconomic and cultural conditions starting in The United Kingdom, then subsequently spreading throughout Europe, North America, and eventually the world. The Industrial Revolution marks a major turning point in human history. Almost every aspect of daily life was eventually influenced in some way. Most notably, average income and population began to exhibit unprecedented sustained growth.

In the two centuries following 1800, the world’s average income increased over tenfold, while the world’s population increased over sixfold. In the words of the Nobel Prize winning Robert e Lucas junior, for the first time in history, the living standards of the masses of ordinary people have begun to undergo sustained growth. Nothing remotely like this economic behavior has happened before. Now prior to that, the world subsisted largely on a draft animal economy. You know, we we rode horses everywhere.

We we plowed the fields with horses. We relied on animals and, you know, our own backbreaking labor to get anywhere and did so for a pittance, you know, subsistence living, basically. Starting in the later later part of the eighteenth century, there began a transition in parts of Great Britain’s previously manual labor and draft animal based economy towards machine based manufacturing. It started with the mechanization of the textile industries, development of iron making techniques, and the increased use of refined coal. Trade expansion was enabled by the introduction of canals, improved roads and railways, the introduction of steam power fueled primarily by coal, water utilization of water wheels, and power machinery mainly in textile manufacturing underpin the dramatic increases in production capacity, so on and so forth.

So what does this actually mean? Well, what it’s done is given the average person in the world two things. It’s given them an education because you have to teach people how to use these machines And it’s given people income, which is freedom. So in a lot of ways, at least in the West, the industrial revolution has given us the capacity, the the freedom to explore dharma. Whereas in past times, we didn’t really have that unless you went into a monastery.

Otherwise, you had to work. There was no opportunity. Okay? So we’re we’re getting to a point here where we can begin to tie some things together. There has been a lot talk and I listened with great interest yesterday the comments that were made about science and Buddhism and there there tends to be when when you put the two together, there tend to be a camp there tends to be a camp on either side.

You know, you’re either pro Buddhist or pro science. And really the the truth lies in between because pure physics, pure science is in itself metaphysical And a lot of the discoveries have been made through impulses that came through metaphysical means, dreams, visions, that sort of thing. If you walk out the door, go out to the main street and look overhead, you’ll see power cables. Right? Well, a hundred and fifty years ago, you wouldn’t have seen anything like that.

And those power cables were there due to the visions of one man, that was Nikola Tesla. Nikola Tesla was quite an interesting figure in and of himself. He was celibate all his life. A lot of people considered him to be a mad scientist. He was also synesthete, which means basically that he saw letters and numbers in terms of color.

He also would sit down and mentally go through any invention, any creation in his mind until he had it right in his mind and then he would build it and it always worked without fail. Which brings us to the one statement about science that really puts it in tune with Buddhism and that is meditation because what he was doing was a meditative practice until he got the that’s that’s how we do it. And if if the method is true, then you arrive at a true outcome. Now if you put a thousand, a 100,000, a million people together all meditating on the same thing, not necessarily in the same space, but all thinking about the same thing, attributing all their results into a central bank, if you will, what do you end up with? Well, you end up with electricity, electronics.

You end up with all the modern technological marvels that we see around us today. I mean, computer science is a case in point. Literally, billions of people use that technology now, and it would have been unheard of even fifty years ago. Okay? But the fact is that you have millions of people sitting down programming, you know, making the chips, everything associated with it and it is a meditative effort because they go into work eight hours a day, sometimes longer than that, day after day, week after week.

You know Pamela mentioned the ten thousand hour thing for mastery and my father basically told me the same thing. He says, Look son, if you’re going learn to play the violin, you’ve to put in the hours because it takes about ten thousand hours to learn how to play this thing correctly, which is what he did. I said, right dad, you know, can really see myself doing that. At that point in my life. The point is if you put in concentrated mental effort over a long period of time, you get results if you do it properly.

And science is one of the areas in Western life where that occurs on an everyday basis because the one thing that drives the pure scientist is the joy of discovery. Now science advances through several means. Does anyone have an idea of where most of our current technology came from? What period in human history? The period between, say, the years 1917 and 1945.

Yeah. Our modern technology evolved largely through that time, and it hasn’t changed a lot since, actually. The transistor was invented in 1945, I think, or 1949. I can’t remember exactly. But out of that period, we we had the the the big advances in flight.

You know, the Iron Bird flying in the West. A lot in terms of transport, electronics, radar, all these systems, they evolved through the war. The atom bomb, atomic energy, all these modern things. Television. Television.

Yep. Major advances in radio. Microwaves, you know, evolved through radar. The microwave oven was discovered by guys working on radar installations standing in front of the radar warming themselves up in the microwaves. We don’t know how many of those died of cancer later but no, that’s how they discovered it.

So science and technology in one respect advanced through crisis. Necessity is a mother of invention. Advances through meditation. So repeated focus on it until till you get the eureka moment. It advances through cooperation.

A lot of minds focused on the same thing. It advances through visionary people like Tesla, like Einstein. Einstein got a lot of his information through dream like states. It advances through building on what is known and working on the faith that, yes, we’ve proven this so this should work and that very often happens. We can see this in Buddhist practice as well.

I remember my first exposure to Orthodox Buddhism was in Melbourne 2007, was it? Yeah. And we we got the Vajradhara Lama Chöpa empowerment at the end of it. I’d never done any, tantric practice before that. I remember after a few weeks of doing it, I noticed how my mind had changed, how it was much clearer, how I was getting insights into things that wasn’t happening before that.

And it gave me faith because I could see that it worked. In fact, there was a statement made by one of the Abbots of Pungtsok Ling Monastery in that he said that the meditations of the Tibetan Plateau are the ones for the West and they are brain exercises. And it involves all the visualization which westerners are quite good at. You know, we visualize maps every day. We we we we’re told told taught to visualize things in school.

Okay. Science advances through thorough testing, you know. Test my words as if they were gold. Well, science is not gonna put anything forward until it’s actually been tested and proven. Of course, there are the heretics in the world that throw the fly in the ointment and help things along sometimes.

But on the whole, unless it’s verifiable, science isn’t gonna use it. Any technician will tell you, you don’t use what doesn’t work. And finally, advances through prestige. There is a French scientist named Gustave Le Bon who lived back in Einstein’s time. He was largely known for his theories on crowd psychology, social psychology, But he said that he was also very interested in physical sciences.

And he said that, yes, science advances through prestige. If you don’t have a lot of letters after your name, if you’re not involved in certain groups, if you don’t know certain people, you don’t get a word in. It doesn’t matter if you’re right or not. So, yeah, I don’t have a lot of letters after my name, and I’m not world not known worldwide. But like all of you here, we have our statements to make, our realizations on things.

If we keep going with this line of thinking, science, if we look at our models of the atom and matter and that sort of thing, is an a religious recognition of Buddhist principles. Now when science is geared toward corporate ends, it becomes very materialistic. But there’s another side of that thing too. Thomas Edison, the the great American inventor, said that the measure of success for him was if one of his inventions was commercially viable. They didn’t mean that in a materialist sense.

His thinking was that if you made something useful and it helped people, they would buy it. So his thinking was that, okay, if people buy this thing, then there must be a use for it. So I’ve done something of purpose. And this is another way that science has advanced in terms of materialism. So you get one invention which leads to something else, you know, someone gets an idea for it and it just keeps going like that.

So advances of science and technology have been logarithmic. It hasn’t just been a steady state thing. Okay. Still got fifteen minutes. Materialistic science sows the seed of its own doom.

If you see science as if you see matter as material, then if you look back at everything that we looked at examined before, you realize that material side of things has no meaning. There’s one more fly in the ointment that I wanna add, and that’s the Heisenberg uncertainty principle in terms of particle physics. And it says basically that if you that you cannot simultaneously examine the position of a particle and its momentum. Okay? So if you try to to measure the momentum of a moving particle, you can’t know exactly where its distance is and vice versa.

Okay? So there’s no certainty, at least at a subatomic level, in terms of position and movement. So if you’re examining wave packets or wave particles, the whole thing becomes very vague and confused in some ways. You don’t really know what you’re looking at. This is a great place for the mind to be actually because you have to abandon certain conceptions that one has about the very state of matter itself.

A couple other points I’ll add before I finish up here. When you go into universities, especially in the scientific field, you get students to study the tenets of science, shall we say, all the scientific laws, mathematical laws. And you have to know these things and be able to reproduce them without error. Okay? And it’s very much like the Buddhist idea of debate where you have to be very clear about what your thought processes are.

There can’t be any muddling. And when you’re on the edge of something new, there are great debates that rage in these universities. And in fact, you can almost see that the university model in the West, at least in terms of science, is kind of an embryonic notion of an eastern monastery, what little I know about monasteries. But you can see, hopefully, from everything that’s been said, there are some parallels between Western science and Buddhism, Buddhist thought. And that hopefully, as time goes on, the two will come together and produce some really good results for the rest of us.

So I think I’ll leave it there and open the floor to questions. Is what materializes for us through our actions. Would that be a connection? One way of putting it, if that makes sense. Because energy equals matter.

Mean matter could be a result. If something you receive, if something happened to you, it sort of materialising to a certain degree. Yeah. Well, what you’re describing are the questions that I wrestled with for a period of time in my early twenties. One of the basic fundamentals of Buddhism is cause and effect, and it’s a basic scientific law as well.

So if you exert a force against an object, it’s gonna produce a resulting force. It’s And gonna have an equal and opposite effect on the person emanating or the object emanating the force. So if you smack two balls together, it’s not just gonna be the one ball that gets hit, it’s the other one as well. They’re both gonna experience an impact. Now that’s not answering your question, but we’re getting to it.

So essentially in in Buddhism, know that if you if you exert an action towards someone, you’re gonna get something back at the same time. Depending on what you give out, you’re gonna give back something corresponding. If you react towards someone angrily, you’re liable to get the same thing back unless the other person has a higher ethic. In terms of the net result, you can see it in terms of one’s psyche. Let’s say for instance someone comes up to you and hits you in the shoulder or something.

Yes, there is a physical effect from that, but it also has a psychic energy to it as well which goes more toward the energetic side of the equation. In fact, you can use energetic formulas like homeopathics to heal the physical wound. But it also has an effect on the mental side of things as well. To say that E equals MC squared applies to karma. Well, karma is largely what the esotericists would call a causal mental phenomena.

It’s a mind emotional connection largely, and that’s that’s what determines our actions. Karma is basically the result of choice. Now science hasn’t actually gotten to the place where you can say that in terms of the realm of thought, e equals m c squared. But if you look at it in terms of concepts about matter, you can see how it plays out. It’s not an easy question to answer.

No? Yeah. What you said about when you observe something you affect what you see. Could have an implication with karma because karma is causing an effect in the mind. Therefore, the way you change your mind is affecting what actually might be physically, apparently presenting to you.

True, very true. Yeah, equal and opposite reaction, yes. Yes? Consciousness is operating in a Newtonian mechanical kind of a way. And my the understanding of the physicists who That’s right.

One of the fundamental things about quantum mechanics is that it says that energy levels don’t change in a linear or gradual fashion. They change by leaps. And if anyone has had realizations about things, you realize that it’s not a gradual process. You go through a period of meditation and it’s often when you stop thinking about it that the idea comes in. Then when it does come in, you realize that a whole new field has been opened and it’s not like you gradually saw all this stuff.

It’s like, oh, well, there’s all this new stuff there. So in that respect, I can see where the mind moves in a quantum fashion. Now, the big pot of gold for physics at the moment is what they call the theory of everything. Wouldn’t it be great to have a mathematical model where you can confirm every single experimental basis, you know? And this this goes there there are some people some physicists who are trying to say that superstring theory is the basic theory of everything.

Now string theory, with string theory you start getting into multidimensionality, like 11 dimensions instead of just the three or four that we know. It is very, very abstract. And it does kind of sound like metaphysics in a way. It is, in a sense, beyond physics. But to be able to define these dimensions just sticks in the craw of a lot of people because the thinking is too Newtonian.

It’s too mechanical. It’s it’s too bound by this notion that that’s a hard table. My my proton is a solid thing. Whereas if you peel that orange, you realize something different. So no, I don’t think the mind moves in a linear fashion.

I think it does move in quanta. I don’t know if I have answered the first part of what you were saying, but does that go? Yes. It is still a causal process, isn’t Even if it is going in, you still have to do the meditation before that quantum leap can happen. So there’s still a causal process.

It’s just happening in a different way than a limited linear fashion. If you don’t exert any force, nothing happens. Yeah. Mean, still the Newtonian models hold. They just have to be altered at a subatomic level, yes.

The one thing I’ll say in regard to this is that when you get to the sort of level of thinking, begin to realize that instead of looking at actual physical models, you’re looking at total abstractions. And the science itself has its own totally abstract notions of things but it’s also it’s grossly physical side of things. And it’s when when people can’t bridge the the two that problems ensue and that you have the misunderstandings about, for instance, what Buddhism is, what science actually is and where it’s all going. So with that, I think it’s time to finish it off. Thank you so much, Melvin.

I think all our electrons are buzzing and maybe some of us have got more space between our ears and we can look forward to exploring the space inside the orange if you’d like to have some morning tea. So, you so much.

Key terms in this teaching

Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Why can't matter be described as a wave of particles, or can it?

It can be described that way. Instead of one long continuous wave, physics often treats matter as a wave packet of a certain size, which is basically the quantum model: a short burst of energy at a certain frequency. So it is a wave-particle and can be expressed either way. One approach is the Newtonian side, calculating its mass or apparent mass. The other is to measure it as a frequency. Every atom and every molecule can be expressed in terms of some frequency function. Studying the basic wave structure of matter through Fourier analysis showed that these wave structures can be expressed in complex mathematical formulas.

Scroll to Top