1 h 51 min · 3,986 words · 5 October 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher explains emptiness and dependent arising: under ultimate analysis the person cannot be found as truly established, yet it exists as a mere name or dependent arising, which avoids the extreme of nihilism. He contrasts the Svatantrika and Prasangika views and the two truths, then has students reflect on and answer questions about the mode of existence of the person.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 52m
UUID: f810a23a-d0ee-4399-b06f-c8777efe715e
Date: 2014-10-05
Words: 3,982
I said today is probably 26 or seven degrees. That’s correct? Yes. Really? I’ve tried now.
29. Really? Really? Really? As you said in the Udanavarga, even one on the third ground does not forsake the intention of engaging in hearing.
The meaning of this quote is that even a third ground bodhisattva, in other words, a very advanced bodhisattva, does not forsake study. If even a third ground bodhisattva does not forsake study, all the more so, ourselves who are beginners should engage in study. And study is the preliminary to practice. So generally speaking, study and hearing are synonymous. Hearing, in other words study, is for the sake of understanding.
Therefore, we should engage in study in conjunction with practice. The purpose of study is, at its very best, to enable them to attain high grounds and paths. If this is difficult or unrealistic, at the very least we should try to perfect our mind and to improve it. Then mere faith is just that, mere faith. It is the way people of dharma faculties practice.
So the way you have been attending these teachings for the last two days, focusing on the teachings and on the benefit for others, this is precisely dharma, nothing else than dharma. Srirajan. Nirajan. This is really dharma. That’s great.
Now, there is if instead of this when no one surrounded at home, goes on walks, engages in meaningless talk, blah blah, with one’s relatives, then one will have truly wasted one’s life. So even if for one hour one does something meaningful like this, this is important. Then the the motivation is indeed the foundation of one’s practice, and this motivation will arise independently on whatever faith we have created. However, it is very difficult for motivation to arise suddenly and swiftly. It can only arise in a solid fashion if one reflects on things in a leisurely way.
And, therefore, through repeated study, Jetsongkapa eventually reached the point where he gained the realizations, which enabled him to praise Buddha Shakyamuni for teaching dependent origination. In this praise, the central stanza, which explicates refuge, states that it Buddha Shakyamuni is praised for having taught dependent origination after generating certainty and a valid cognizer realizing dependent origination. This is the uncommon praise of Buddha Shakyamuni and the uncommon refuge. And, therefore, it is critically important for us to generate a valid cognizer realizing subtle dependent arising or, if this is not possible, at the very least, a conviction which understands subtle dependent arising. Therefore, we must strive to understand that a person which is permanent, one, and independent does not exist.
Should such a person exist, this would be irrational at odds with reason. So when one reflects on the persons being empty of being permanent one and independent, one should not reflect on other people as being empty, of being permanent, one, and independent. It is one’s own self, which is empty of being permanent, one, and independent. And this application to oneself should be self evident. It is obvious that we are not permanent.
We eat, and after eating, our stomach is full, then it becomes empty. We sleep, then we wake, then we go back to sleep. We are in a constant state of flux. And the foundation of the understanding of subtle dependent arising is therefore an understanding of initially coarse impermanence. That coarse impermanence, in other words, the certainty of our own death, is something which is self evident.
Therefore, the persons being permanent, one, and independent is the object of negation. This is what you should understand. After this on this basis, it is excellent to ask questions. It is not the case that the person is unrelated to the aggregates. The person is related to the aggregates.
Therefore, the person should be an object of investigation and of analysis, and we should invent endeavor to find whether the person is present within us at some point of our bodies from the top of our heads to the soles of our feet. Now generally speaking, we are constituted of body and mind. It is fairly obvious the person is not present within the body. Should a present person be present within the mind, it would probably have to be mind. If it were mind, since the person itself has physical constituents, the mind in question would also have to have physical constituents, which is self contradictory.
So in this investigation of the relationship between the person and the aggregate aggregates, even though the final view which we are studying is the Prasangika view, we must understand the view of the lower schools from Vaibhashika up to Svatantrika, for which the person is established from its own side since this view is the foundation leading up to the Prasangika view. The topic which is presented yesterday of the relationship between dependent arising and emptiness is a difficult topic. Therefore, we must put great effort into trying to understand it. It is not something we will understand easily, but through regular effort and study, eventually, one day, we will get an inkling of what is being said. Then progressively over time, this will turn into a conviction.
To generate some type of a valid cognizer of this topic is extremely difficult. It is extremely important that you make a clear unmistaken distinction between the status of the person when unexamined and the status of the person when examined. When unexamined, the status of the person can be presented either as arising from one’s mother or if one wishes to bring in the existence of past lives as the product of previous existences. However, when one examines the status of the person, at this point, one is using ultimate analytical reasonings. And this is not easy.
These ultimate analytical reasonings are not easy. So the Svatantrika Madhyamaka view is a more intuitively accessible view, where even though one does indeed refute the existence of a permanent one and independent person, nonetheless, a person is seen as existing within one’s mind. Specifically, we are composed of body and mind, and the person is seen by the as none other than the mental continuum. This is not the case for the Prasangika view. The Prasangikas counter the person’s being the mental continuum.
The mode of analysis of the person is as follows. When powerful emotions, powerful sensations arise at this point, one should investigate where this person experiencing these emotions is. Alternatively, if powerful faith in the spiritual teacher, in the dharma, or the Sangha arise in one’s mind, at this point, one should investigate who is the Experiencer of this faith and where this Experiencer is. Therefore, we should investigate where we are, who we are ourselves. And through repeat repeated analysis and investigation, we will not find ourselves.
This unfindability of the self is an unfindability within both the body and the mind. So initially, we investigate one’s body, one’s form, to see whether the I exists in the head, in the feet, in the hands, and so forth. And upon finding that this is not the case, we investigate our minds to see whether the mind the I is either in the sense consciousnesses or the mental consciousness. Upon finding that this is not the case, ultimately, we realize such an I does not exist. Upon turning our minds inwards and investigating the person, the I or the self, we will not find it.
This unfindability of the self, the fact that it does not exist when its existence is investigated, is not a discovery or a findability of its nonexistence. As is said in the essence of Nectar, upon investigating with a reasoning of ultimate investigation, I find the lack of true existence of the self. I do not, however, find the utter nonexistence of the self. No. Therefore, what what is found is that the self is not truly established or established from its own side, but not that it is utterly nonexistent.
Mhmm. So it’s not sound. Right? However, when it is not investigated or analyzed, it does seem to exist from its own side. When under ultimate investigation, ultimate analysis, the person is not found.
What is not found is a person existing from its own side, existing truly or existing inherently. This does not entail the utter nonexistence of the person. However, those of dull faculties, of dull acumen, upon investigating the presence or the absence of the person within the basis of imputation of the aggregates, upon not finding the person within this basis of imputation, can conclude that the person does not exist at all. When they conclude this, they have succumbed or fallen into the extreme of nihilism. So those of Dull acumen, upon investigating forcefully, conclude wrongly that the person does not exist at all and deduce that karma and causality do not exist either, succumbing thereby to the extreme of nihilism.
Do you understand? Alit. Oh. It’s excellent if you really understand this. Excellent.
Yeah. Very important. Very important. So upon investigation, upon analysis, this usual I whom we see as existent disappears. It ceases to appear to the mind.
This is what occurs under ultimate analysis. So it is critical, therefore, to avoid succumbing to the extreme of nihilism and to see that world, the person, cannot be found under ultimate investigation. Nonetheless, it does exist. Under ultimate investigation, the person is not found within its basis of imputation. It is not found within the body.
It is not found within the mind. It is not found within the conglomerate of the aggregates, nor is it found within the aggregates individually. Yet it exists. The question which arises is what is its mode of existence? This is the question I have for you.
So when we investigate and find that under ultimate analysis, the person is unfindable, it is critical to avoid succumbing to the extreme of nihilism, which asserts that the person is utterly nonexistent. At this point, the question which arises is what exactly is the mode of existence of the person, and this leads directly to the analysis of emptinesses being a dependent arising. So here, the relationship between emptiness and dependent arising occurs. So yesterday, when I asked you to reflect about this in a leisurely fashion and analyze, this is what I meant. This is what is meant by meditation.
Really, for us, there is little hope to gain experiences such as calm abiding. Therefore, one must investigate carefully. And upon not finding the person under investigation, one should then inquire what is the mode of existence of the person. So the person under this type of investigation is something which is quite odd. It turns into something which is ephemeral and unstable.
And this is why it is said in in the great stages of the path of Je Tsongkhapa that the person is akin to a mirror to an illusion. It is unstable, ephemeral, and fragile. And therefore, under ultimate analysis, the person is unfindable. What is unfindable is the truly established person, the person, which is established from its own side. If this is the case, the question which arises is what is the mode of existence of the person, and can it be found within body and mind?
So this is what I ask you to reflect over yesterday, and even if you were unable to do it, I’d ask you to think over it today. We shall therefore take a couple of minutes and meditate upon this. Mhmm. And then there will be questions and answers. Mhmm.
Remember? A lot of numbers. Yes. We will do the recitations. So under ultimate analysis, we find that our mode, apparent mode of abiding does not exist.
This, however, in no way intimates that we are utterly nonexistent, which would amount to succumbing to the extreme of nihilism. Yet we do exist. So what is our mode of existence? This is a question I would like to ask you, and I would like you to ask ask you to speak sincerely in accordance with your innermost feeling on the topic. How do you feel?
No need to talk to think a lot anymore. That’s a profound one. We should go into it. I’m not quite sure what you were reading and I’m not quite sure if you understood. Well, it’s a meditation on emptiness.
And it goes through four steps: identification, what is to do with individual and capable. It’s Jeffrey Hopkins’ meditation emptiness. But I really like your own opinion. Yeah. Yeah.
Well, I was thinking about it. And when Geshela said, when you look for it, it’s not there. When you don’t look for it, it’s there. Then from that I thought well then it must be a form of mind or consciousness. What must be?
The I. The mind consciousness of a person if you look for it and it’s not there and we don’t look for it and it appears then to me, then that implies that it’s a it’s a consciousness and that it’s an imputation of an of an I. That is my Yeah. And Anna also. Yeah.
Mine was what I’ve just adjusted. I’ve just put the person is dependent arising, dependent on the basis, and a consciousness which imputes the I on that basis. Pamela has been listening a And? Long time. And when you say grasping, you just the middle of body is a person.
And so that seems to be the cause of of the normality, of the need for an idea of a person comes from somewhere else. It’s caused by something else. I will finish it. Are you saying that the mode of existence of the person when it is not being examined is its true existence? I keep collapsing onto the object of negation.
In other words, like analogy for me is like a reflection in the mirror that even though I know that it’s a reflection, but I I still see myself as existing from the same side. So I can’t when I look for that, I can’t find it. So I can only conclude that the mode of existence is just habituation, a strong habituation of my thinking. To moment. They are dependent on causes and conditions which are continually changing.
And they have a summary of the past. Recognizing that I can’t see the self that is being imputed to the basis of imputation can be solid and any more than ephemeral and unstable and any more than a label which has been attached to the basis of imputation which is so ephemeral and unstable. And another question also. I think Then I’m very happy with your answers. I was hoping for something more in accordance with the teachings of Jetsongkapa and Aryadeva and Nagarjuna, but I had asked you to express your own opinion, and I am very happy you did so from the depths of your hearts.
And among the various answers, there were two answers which were dead on. Whoever said that it merely exists as a name gave the precise answer. And, therefore, when one investigates using ultimate analytical reasonings, the person or the eye, one does not find anything. What one does not find is an inherently existent personal eye or a personal eye existent from its own side. Yet, when one does not engage in ultimate analytical investigation, this person or this eye appears.
Many scholars assert that, this appearance, is the actual mode of existence of the person. This is not the case. It is its mode of existence is its object of negation. Therefore, under ultimate analytical investigation, the person or the I is not found. And this, therefore, regards with the notion of emptiness being a dependent arising.
When we assert that phenomena are mere names, we are saying that they arise independence on mere nominal imputation. And, therefore, when we engage in ultimate analytical investigation of the person, all that is left which we can find is the mere name. Let us take Chris’s case. Chris at present is a father, but Chris became a father only at the point where his wife bore a child in her womb. Before that point, the name father was not applied to Chris.
At the very instant at which his wife bore a child in her womb, the name father was applied to Chris. Therefore, father, the name father, arises in dependence on the presence of the cause, the child in Chris’s wife’s womb. Then mere name is therefore a very difficult concept to understand. When it reflects profoundly on mere nominality, mere name, all phenomena become illusion like, ephemeral, and unstable. It is independence on this that an understanding of emptiness is possible.
Otherwise, to speak of emptiness is basically meaningless. And therefore, this is what one must do to give reflection on emptiness its potency. If we reflect, for instance, or meditate on forbearance, love, or compassion just for a couple seconds, there is immediate benefit. This is not the case if we reflect on emptiness. We must understand the actual meaning of any emptiness, and only at this point will there be some benefit.
Which is why under ultimate reasoning of ultimate analytical investigation, phenomena become like an illusion. Because just as an illusion appears as long as it is unexamined, in the moment it is examined, it dissipates. Likewise, phenomena disappear under ultimate analytical investigation. And therefore, when under ultimate analytical investigation, the person is not found, what is not found is a truly established person or a person established from its own side. It is not the case that at this point, nothing whatsoever is found.
It is therefore critically important to establish a link between emptiness and dependent arising since once one understands that when under ultimate analytical investigation, a mere name remains, one will not have succumbed to the extreme of nihilism. Otherwise, one will have succumbed to the extreme of nihilism. Therefore, mere nominality or dependent arising are what prevents one from falling into the extreme of nihilism. As we said in Jetsongkapa’s three principles of the path, for so long as one is unable to conciliate, the incontrovertible dependent arising of appearances and the lack of assertion of emptiness for so long one will not have engaged in the path taught by the conqueror. Therefore, if one is unable to understand that the person’s not being established from its own side in no way prevents the person from being both the accumulator of karma and the experiencer of the fruition of karma, then one will not have understood the import of emptiness.
Likewise, if one believes that it is necessary for the person to be established from its own side to be the experiencer of karma, of the fruition of karma and the accumulator of karma, then one will not have understood the import of emptiness. Who asserts this? So why is this the case? Because is Svatantrikas consider that the person is established from his or her own side and that the person is findable within the aggregates. Otherwise, they assert that the person could not be both an accumulator of karma and an experiencer of the fruition of karma.
Therefore, the the Sotantrika Madhyamikas do not understand in the slightest the subtle selflessness of persons. Then, Svatantrika Madhyamikas consider that if when under ultimate analytical investigation, the person is not found and all that subsists is the name, one will have succumbed to the extreme of nihilism since it will be impossible on this basis to posit a person who is an accumulator of karma and an experiencer of the consequences or the fruition of karma. Then for those of you who attend the tenets class, it is in this context that in commentary on Prasannapada of Chandrakirti, the doubt arises, is, in this case, emptiness, a an implicative negation? Therefore, for so long, as as was stated in the stanza of these three principles of the path, the realization of emptiness and the realization of dependent arising are not related and are incompatible for so long, one will not have encountered the thought of the conqueror. However, it is in this context that the doubt expressed by Jetsongkapa in the Legs Shad Nying Po, the commentary on the root verses on Prasannapada arises.
Because if it is the case that upon realizing the sound uttering ’emptiness’, the concept of mere nominality arises in the mind. Emptiness, instead of being a nonimplicative negation, would become an implicative negation. This is something which is food for thought. Complicated. One difficulty.
And, therefore, when you debate, you would analyze as follows. In as much as the subject emptiness, when it is realized for one not to succumb to the extreme of nihilism necessarily entails the realization of dependent arising or mere nominality, then in debate, you would say the subject emptiness, it follows that it is an implicative negation because the sound uttering it upon negation of its object of negation leaves as a remainder either mere name or dependent arising. This is how you could debate. Sorry. Could you just repeat that?
Whole thing subject of emptiness and So the subject emptiness, it follows that it is an implicative negation because upon uttering the term emptiness after negating the object of negation, the remainder is either mere normality or dependent arising. And Geshe-la said the problem here is differentiating implicative and nonimplicative negations. And, therefore, the subject here, which could be the person or I, when it is asserted to be empty, so as to forswear succumbing to the extreme of nihilism necessarily entails the understanding of the person’s mere nominality or its existence as a dependent arising. If this is the case, this would seem to imply that emptiness is an implicative negation. You understand a bit the difference between implicative and non implicative negations?
As I said, therefore, within the refutation of the self as inherently existent on the one hand and the positing of the self as mere nominality on the other hand, there does not exist even the slightest incompatibility. In other words, even though one refutes a self’s inherent existence, existence from its own side or true existence, one does posit the self’s nominal existence or existence as a dependent arising. The capacity to posit these two features on one basis, in other words, to posit both emptiness and mere nominality on one basis, is what we refer to as the two natures, ultimate and conventional truth. As is said in the Lama Chöpa, in the three principles of the path and in praise of dependent origination, dependent arising and emptiness are not incompatible. Instead, they are mutually beneficial and complementary.
In Lama Chöpa, it is said, bless me to realize that the utter nonexistence of inherent existence of even one atom as well as dependent arising are mutually complementary. Whereas it is said in the three principles of the path, for so long as one has not understood that through appearance, the extreme of existence is negated, whereas through emptiness, the extreme of nihilism is negated. For so long, one will not have understood the intent of the conqueror. And this is therefore how upon one basis, one posits the two truths. If one takes, for instance, a person or oneself, on the one hand, the ultimate truth is the unfindability under ultimate analysis of a truly established, inherently established, or established from its own side person, whereas the conventional truth is the mere nominal existence of such a person.
This is how the two truths are posited on one basis. Two truths. Yeah. That two truths. He has stopped.
So we will stop here on the two truths. Things went very well.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.