2 h 20 min · 18,521 words · 10 August 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A conference talk on the mind-brain relation, arguing against materialism using neuroplasticity, single-neuron memory, placebo effects, near-death experiences and reincarnation-type case studies, with a brief question and answer session at the end. The speaker says the material is his own opinion and presents it as evidence for a non-material view of mind, compatible with Indian and Buddhist traditions. Not a Buddhist teaching in the usual sense.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 21m
UUID: 217ab65b-d065-4ade-b5bb-042884caf996
Date: 2014-08-10
Words: 18,517
Right, thank you for your patience and welcome back to those of us who are here yesterday. Hope you slept well and had a good breakfast. Ready for another very stimulating and challenging day today with you to the 2014 TBI Symposium, The Nature of Mind, Science and Buddhism in the twenty first Century. Without any further ado, I would like to hand you straight over to Elliot. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Chris. And thank you all very much for, staggering out of bed on a Sunday morning to attend conferences which are not easy, especially those of you who lasted through yesterday afternoon and still came this morning. Thank you very much indeed. The rest of these conferences will be much more straightforward than the the material we covered yesterday. Then in our process of trying to understand, the genesis of materialism, which is the dominant ideology in the West, and to see whether or not this ideology, because that’s really what it is, is grounded or as grounded as materialist dogmatists would have us believe or not.
We covered yesterday, as you remember, a range of initial arguments against materialism, drawn from the private experience of consciousness, the widespread presence of altruism in, biology, which is very difficult to justify, pre verbal, ethical reactions in infants, between the ages of three and six months, And finally, an argument drawn from linguistics, as you remember, the so called poverty of stimulus argument, that the amount of, data a child receives from its mother in the process of learning a language, let’s say English, simply is insufficient for the child to speak correctly. And yet we all know children do speak correctly, actually do speak. Those were the initial arguments. And then yesterday afternoon, we covered, I would say, the strongest arguments against materialism, unfortunately, also by far the most difficult. These are arguments drawn from quantum physics.
I had covered them once in the past at TBI, and I used this opportunity to go in much greater depth. As you remember, we spoke of von Neumann’s understanding of the wave function, or what is now known currently as a state vector in quantum physics, which describes the behavior of a particle. And the very interesting point this Hungarian-American physicist von Neumann makes, which is that for the wave function to collapse, in other words, for the particle to actually have definite characteristics, energy, spin, momentum, and whatnot, the consciousness of the observer is indispensable, and this consciousness, according to von Neumann, must be nonmaterial. Now this has been the main bone of contention in quantum mechanics since the nineteen thirties. As mentioned yesterday, divided quantum mechanics into two broad camps, that of Niels Bohr and Heisenberg on the one hand, and that of von Neumann, Wigner, Fritz London, and so forth on the other hand.
Recent data has come much closer to corroborating for Neumann’s intuition, and I mentioned yesterday some of the recent studies by Groblacher, which led an American physicist, Richard Conn Henry, and as I mentioned yesterday, people always do this year of their retirement, to publish an editorial in nature stating that the universe was mental. Then all of this is basically data which corroborates quite strongly the core intuitions of all of the Indian schools of philosophy with perhaps exception of the ancient Indian materialists. It is not data which specifically corroborates a Buddhist viewpoint. But as we will see later today, certainly the data from quantum mechanics is not compatible with atheistic viewpoint of the world. Other words, it’s not compatible with Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.
And it is not compatible with materialism either. It is strongly compatible with both Hinduism and Buddhism, and to a lesser degree, Jain. So we’re coming to a point where one can, based on present scientific knowledge, rationally choose a spiritual tradition which is compatible with what is known. Then today, we’re going to cover data which counters the materialist viewpoint drawn from medicine, from biology, and from psychiatry. The data is less clear.
You will not find the type of powerful data we found in the, critique of materialism coming from quantum mechanics, largely because the disciplines themselves are, well, I always felt when I was young that biology was a model discipline. You know, it doesn’t have the clarity of mathematics or physics. But there is data, and there is a strong data. And we will try to understand what this data is, what it implies, and then this afternoon, we shall, draw all this together. I’ll try to make a synthesis to show you what all the data I have presented implies.
There are certain spiritual traditions or even philosophical systems, which are vindicated by the data, and some really are at odds with the data. Interestingly enough, the dominant worldview of the West nowadays is at odds with the data. So what you read in the popular press, if you go on Yahoo, if you go on BBC, and it’s like every couple of days, scientists discover that what might it be? If an electrode is inserted in this part of the brain, the person is happy, something of that nature. And the implicit subtext is happiness is a product exclusively of the brain, as is all mental activity.
This viewpoint is basically at odds with a lot of experimental and theoretical data. Since this causes a lot of problems to our students, who after all come here two three hours a week and are the rest of their time in the world at large, it’s very important to present this data. Then the material over these two days is basically my personal work. This is my private opinion on the topic. It’s a product of more than thirty years, really, of reflection, but especially the product of the last six or seven years in Australia where I really found that our students here are confronted with a tension between the spiritual tradition they study, on the one hand, and what they think science is telling them on the other hand.
And it’s in trying to bridge this gap that these conferences arose. Now the goal of these conferences is not to present a complete system of thought to you, if you wish, to conciliate the inconceivable. The goal is instead to trigger your interest. Each one of you will resonate with a different topic. I know for instance that, Chris, the director of the center, because of his background in palliative care, has resonated very powerfully with the presentation of near death experiences and has pursued his own research in the field, which is exactly the goal of these conferences.
Others will resonate with cases of the reincarnation type, some with physics. In every case, this is the beginning of your own path. How much you do or do not do is entirely up to you. The bibliographies here, this one bibliography per conference, are designed to help you to get into the material. Then because I draw on a large range of material, I’m in the situation of a jack of all trade and a master of none.
So if any of you are trained in some of these fields, please forgive me for approximations. But, we are at a point where we can no longer just blindly rely on specialists a bit as the peasants of the middle age relied on the priests of the cathedral to, you know, impart to reveal the truth. We do have to check this specialist knowledge. And, most of us in this room are reasonably well educated. It is something which can be done.
Then without further ado, what, is the understanding of the mind brain relation in biology, medicine, and psychiatry? You first have to have understand the position of your opponent before countering him. Basically, I think there was, if you wish, a turning point in that understanding with an event, an accident really, which occurred to a railway foreman in the middle of the nineteenth century in America, Phineas Gage. Until then, people had this broad and nebulous idea of the mind as somehow related but separate from the brain. Phineas Gage was a victim of a horrific accident in which a railway tamping iron actually passed through his skull.
Normally, is an accident one should not survive. He did. But what struck nineteenth century Americans and Europeans were the dramatic changes in his personality. Phineas Gage had been a very religious and humble man before the events which occurred, and after experiencing this cerebral trauma, he became according to reports of the fear the the period fitful, in other words, unstable, irreverent, profane, obstinate, capricious, and it seemed, and this is Victorian America and England, to have lost all inhibition, which is as bad as it gets in being antisocial, at least for the period. Then this triggered, a popular sense which eventually infected much of psychology, medicine, and psychiatry that the relation between brain and mind was much more intimate than had ever been suspected before.
And this led to a fundamental methodological problem, a problem in thinking really about the relation between the mind and the brain. A confusion between what we could call causation and correlation. Classical neurology, and basically, this is what my father who was a famous scientist would tell me at the dining room table when I was a child. Classical neurology considered that changes in the brain led to changes in the mind. And as far as classical neurology in this space really goes up to the nineteen seventies was concerned, the brain was a frozen organ pretty much from late childhood onwards.
One experienced a steady loss of neurons, and this steady loss of neurons eventually led to senility in great old age. Neural pathways were definitely not reconstructed or not modified. Then this viewpoint, has basically been turned heads over heel. We mentioned yesterday paradigm shift in physics. There has been a paradigm shift in neurobiology.
With the introduction of neuroplasticity, which came really from the research of Paul Bach-y-Rita especially, and the theoretical work of Donald Hebb on victims of strokes, where they found that stroke victims often were able to regain large amounts of their the capacities they had before the stroke. This implies that parts of the brain are adapting and modifying, which is completely at odds with what was dogma literally in neurology up to that point. So neuroplasticity implies that changes in the mind can lead to changes in the neurological substratum. And neuroplasticity, in other words, plasticity of the brain, has really become the dominant viewpoint. There’s a lot of data which corroborates it.
So its pioneers go way back, but it had remained very much a minority viewpoint. Then what have been the models of mind brain relationship? This is a famous Mongolian used to be called the Turk. It was an automaton in the nineteenth century which played chess. It was the nineteenth the eighteenth century, so I was fascinated by machines which did what humans only could do.
So this automaton played a remarkable game of chess. And it’s only years after that it was discovered that there was basically a midget hidden inside the automaton. It was a very good chess player and who played chess. Right? So it’s already in the eighteenth century that these big questions of what a machine could or could not do had arisen.
Unfortunately, normal machines don’t play a good game of chess. I can vouch for that. Computers is another story. Then there are two broad models of mind. The nonmaterialistic model of mind, which we would say was dominant really up to the nineteenth century, and the materialist model of the mind, which has become dominant ever since.
Now it is striking to see that eminent figures in Western philosophy and science subscribed to the non materialist dogma or philosophy of mind. Kant, for instance, was probably the greatest philosopher Germany produced and really the philosopher of the enlightenment and modernity, clearly subscribes to the non material doctrine of mind. So does William James, the founder of psychology in The United States, and a forgotten but important figure, F. W. H.
Meyer. The materialist view of the mind, perhaps its foremost representatives nowadays would be Turing, the great British mathematician. Some of you may know of him for his work in Cracking the Enigma Code at Bletchley Park. He is one of the great figures in mathematics and philosophy of the twentieth century. And John Searle, perhaps the greatest philosopher of the late twentieth century.
So the non materialistic models of the mind were presented, I think, quite elegantly by Kant in his critique of pure reason, this goes back to the late eighteenth century. The body is not the cause of our thinking, but merely a condition which restricts thinking. And although essential to our sensuous and animal consciousness may be regarded as an impeder of our pure spiritual life. This is basically the viewpoint which is prevalent in the West up to, I would say, 1850 probably. Things have greatly changed.
Turing, we mentioned, previously. If you have considered that the mind was basically a computer and devised a test, the famous Turing test, to determine whether a machine was intelligent or not. Turing actually never addressed directly the issue of consciousness, but seems to have conflated consciousness and intelligence. The Turing test basically involved a double blind situation in which one asks something on the other end of a screen or a room questions, and if based on the answers to those questions one is unable to determine whether that thing is machine or man, one is entitled to consider it intelligent. And there have been many critiques of Turing’s tests, the sharpest of which we owe to John Searle, a great American philosopher, the most articulate proponent of the non materialistic view of the mind, because whereas Turing views the mind as really the product of mechanical activity of the brain, John Searle’s view is materialistic but is much more subtle. For Searle, the mind is basically an emergent property of the brain. What he means by this is that even though without the brain there is no mind, the mind is not just the sum of the activities of all the neurons. Just as for instance, if you take a molecule of water, you could not deduce the properties of water from the properties of the constituents of that molecule, hydrogen and oxygen. Hydrogen and oxygen are gases.
Hydrogen, you cannot breathe. Oxygen, you can breathe, although it makes you a bit dizzy and eventually drunk. Then if you put them together and you spark the mixture and stand please well away, actually don’t do this. Okay. Forget forget I mentioned sparking a mixture of hydrogen oxygen.
But in a laboratory, if you were to do this, you would have droplets of water. Now hydrogen you cannot breathe, oxygen you can breathe, water you can’t breathe. Hydrogen and oxygen you cannot drink at room temperature, water is a liquid you can drink it. So suddenly from two gases, you have a compound which has no relation whatsoever to these two gases. Water is an emergent property of hydrogen and oxygen.
This is John Searle’s view of the mind, and he takes odds with Turing’s disciples, the whole of the computational theory of the mind, quite sharply. He accuses them basically of being materialistic theologians, and he says, I have encountered more passion from adherents of the computational theory of the mind than from adherents of traditional religious doctrines of the soul. Many people believe that somehow or other, unless we are proven to be computers, something terribly important will be lost. I never felt that way myself, but perhaps some of you feel that way. So what would be therefore a materialist account of consciousness, no longer just of intelligence or memory, but consciousness?
These accounts are surprisingly weak. This is a picture of, Francis Crick, whom you know is the co discoverer of DNA, and I suppose you could call him his disciple, Koch, who is a leading professor of or the leading scientist and professor of neurobiology at Caltech. So Koch developed a model, a neurobiological model of consciousness and considers that consciousness basically would be due to gamma band oscillations, in other words, electric activity of the brain, which is coherent and synchronized throughout the brain. And it’s worth pointing out that there’s actually very little strong evidence for this. Yes.
Gamma waves are associated with consciousness. Whether coherent electrical activity of the brain is consciousness is very difficult to see. You have a clear case of confusion between causation and correlation. The presence of gamma waves when consciousness is present does not establish causation. It might establish correlation.
We need much more to establish causation, and as we will see a bit later, there are a series of situations such as near death experiences where consciousness is clearly reported and the EEG, the electroencephalograph, is flat. There is no electrical activity of any type whatsoever, gamma, delta, theta, whatever. So what are the problematical issues for a materialist theory of mind? And there is a lot of data. I won’t be able to cover all of it, so I’ll present some points and hope some of you will further the research by yourselves.
The first, which remains highly controversial, is the existence of single neuron memories. We’ll talk about this in a minute. It is the possibility for one single neuron to store a memory. The second is extreme psychophysical influence, psychosomatic influence, leading to physical change of the body due to mental effects. The third, which I won’t cover at all today but it is very interesting, is the existence of savants or calculating prodigies, Often autistic children who have phenomenal mental capacities, enable them, for instance, to square to extract the square root of very large numbers to find prime numbers which are very large and so forth.
There’s no clear explanation for these capacities at present. Then these I would say, these first three cases are cases where more such phenomena could be compatible with a materialist account of the mind. Neurobiology at present is unable to offer any mechanism. Now if you are a materialist, it behooves you to provide a mechanism. You can’t just say this is due to the mechanical or electrochemical activity within an organ or the brain.
You must explain how this is happening. Otherwise, your position is basically a dogmatic position. No mechanism is provided for these. Then the second group of three are highly problematic for material theories of the mind, and basically they can’t be accounted for. The first is verified near death experiences, we’ll talk about later.
These are near death experiences in which the person has access basically through what we would call paranormal capacities to data there is no way they could know. The second is verified past life memories, verified cases of the reincarnation type, in which a child has memories of a past life, and these memories can be verified. And once again, it is material the child could not know. And the last, perhaps the most problematic, Renate was very hesitant about presenting it here because it stretches the Western paradigm significantly, is cases of possession. Now many of these cases are known as dissociative identity disorder in the West and are basically not fully understood.
So you will see once we start entering into an assessment of the mind as a non material phenomenon, that understanding DID as possession appears substantially more convincing. And I will try to make the case that a large part of modern psychiatry, and modern psychiatry really goes back to the eighteen fifties, is rooted in ideology. It’s rooted in an ideology of the mind as matter, and we have interiorized this ideology to an extreme degree. And in some cases, specifically cases of dissociative identity disorder, if one approaches the data, what the patient says objectively without any peace or positions, possession by another spirit is a very convincing case. This is what the patient says.
And this is, as you will see at the end of this conference, what just a naive person looking at the data would think. Then, not all of us, but most of us do acrobatics to try to avoid this one because it involves shifting mental gears to a degree with which we are profoundly uncomfortable. But I thought I would mention it because this is something which is mainstream in Buddhism and Hinduism, and after all, if students come here and are interested in Buddhism and Hinduism, they have to be open to these possibilities. So let us start with the least challenging bit, single neuron memories, and I think we have one neurologist in the audience so this is quite challenging I think for that neurologist. Then, I have no particular claims of competence in the field, but I try to do a bit of background work, and we can’t enter in detail in the biology of memory.
I was going to do it, but there just isn’t time. There’s a marvelous review article of, Eric Kandel in the third biography, your internal critique of materialism within medicine and the life sciences, and it is excuse me, yes, it is on page three, neurobiology and cognitive science. It’s a review article, the biology of memory a forty year perspective in the journal of neuroscience. I’d strongly recommend it to all of you. Is one of the foremost researchers in the field.
Then the biology of memory is not well understood. It’s a work in process, and, he basically, in this review article, tried to summarize what is known. This is important for us because when we start dealing with cases of the reincarnation type, where a child remembers past lives, we have clear cases of memory without any material support for this, and this is something we have to try to account for. So neuronal memory was really postulated by a Polish neurologist, Jerzy Konorski, in the late sixties. There was no empirical evidence, but Konorski thought an individual neuron could store a memory.
This was considered somewhat preposterous to be frank with you, Konorski was world famous, you know, and it was after that. Then to everyone’s great embarrassment, it’s really this one has been a very sensitive topic as far as I understand in neurology. Gabriel Kreiman, an Argentinian neurobiologist, a student of course at Caltech, found in his PhD theses instances of what seemed to be neuronal memory. He found instances of cells in the amygdala which would respond to only one stimuli. And in this case, and I am not making a political statement, those of you who are labored don’t see me as taking position for labored.
These neurons, which are obviously very mistaken, would only respond to images of Bill Clinton. This is true. Then what precisely was happening? This poor deluded patient had been so heavily indoctrinated by the democratic left that his mind, his wounds, would respond to images of one of our most left leaning presidents. There’s no response.
Kreiman himself left Caltech to create a laboratory at Harvard. If you can imagine, in your thirties to be asked to create your own laboratory at at Harvard, the Kreiman Lab, which focuses exclusively on the investigation of single neuron memories. And his mentor, Koch, has basically been backtracking ever since, and as far as I read it at present, the official account for single neuron memories from Caltech is what is called, very euphemistically, sparse coding. Somehow the neuron is not storing individual memories, heaven forbid it should store the image of George Bush, it is storing a very, compact form of coding this information, because obviously, the basic problem with single neuron memories is nobody has any idea of what mechanism might be used to store such information. And as we said, the materialist this is really the, the on which, you know, the materialist is hoisted.
The materialist must provide a mechanism. If you’re gonna say something is electrochemical or mechanical, you have to say how it is electrochemical electrochemical or mechanical. And in the case of single neuron memories, if Kreiman’s research is corroborated, and his team has continued, and if they continue producing a very large volume of work. You can check it on the web if you’re interested. There really is no mechanism at present.
Then I would like to cover with you the second argument against the materialist theory of mind, which is psychophysical influence, and in this case, I thought I would take the case of the placebo effect. A placebo effect is an effect which is widely known in medicine. It is so widely known that every single test for a new drug is designed to eliminate the placebo effect. The placebo effect is a healing effect someone experiences when he thinks he’s receiving medication. That’s quite extraordinary because what is being said here is that medicine as a whole acknowledges an effect of the body on the mind which is so powerful, it heals the body, and instead of doing something with this, design every single test for a new drug to not take it into account.
It’s it’s silly, isn’t it? And this is one lab at Harvard, the first to my knowledge, which actually is trying to use a placebo effect. And since one of the most endemic diseases, mental diseases in the West is depression, I thought I would show you a meta analysis of antidepressants in clinical testing. Now what you have in red here is, you know, the effect of the drug, you know, in the baseline initial severity of depression, and, here you have the improvement in the patient. You will note that it is only with extremely severe cases of depression that there is a statistically significant difference between the effect of the drug and of a placebo.
Otherwise, it is not possible up to basically a baseline of 28 or so to present any statistically significant difference between drug and placebo. In other words, placebos are bloody effective and cheap. It doesn’t cost anything. Then another recent review article in Nature Reviews Neuroscience, this is just a couple years ago old, compares cognitive therapy, in other words basically psychotherapy, meditation, mindfulness, any therapy involving the mind’s action on itself, classical antidepressant medication, and placebo. Now you see that placebo at 25 is not effective in the long-term treatment of depression.
But if you take antidepressant medication and cognitive therapy, in the long-term treatment of depression, cognitive therapy is more effective than placebo. Whether this is significant or not, I do not know. I don’t have the data. Certainly, we can say it is as effective. Now, how much money precisely goes in the development of antidepressant medication?
And how much money goes in actually training the mind? Costs nothing. Right? And it is even more striking if you look at relapse, and this is where cognitive therapies really, stand on their own. You can see that cognitive therapy, if it has occurred before depression, is far more effective than antidepressant medication in preventing relapse.
Placebo seems quite ineffective in preventing relapse. Now placebo and cognitive therapy are one and the same. It is the action of mind on the body in both cases. In the case of cognitive therapy, it’s more analytical. In the case of placebo, we could say it’s faith based.
There are some mechanisms provided to explain the placebo effect in the control of pain, through the release of opioids in the brain. It’s moderately convincing. Where, there is no mechanism whatsoever provided is in the extreme cases of psychosomatic effects, such as this one drawn from the Lancet, in which a patient in a crisis of somnambulism, and this is due to the report of the patient after the event, recollected being tied up, and you can see the wheels appeared on his arm. This is one of the very strong cases of psychosomatic effect. As Stevenson points out, there is simply no mechanism in the present understanding of human physiology allowing for this to happen.
There are accounts of letters appearing on people’s bodies. I have no pictures for this. Then once again, there is no mechanism we know at present allowing the human brain to control, let’s say, in the case of wheels, the human vessels, the blood vessels, and the muscles to such a degree. I should point out this was published in The Lancet. It’s peer reviewed in, what was it, nineteen nineteen forty six.
It’s called abreaction technically. Then psychosomatic effect on such a scale cannot be at present explained by the materialist. The next factor we should address are savants and calculating prodigies. I was going to cover this with you, there just isn’t time. There are some excellent books on the topic.
I would heartily encourage you to read them. It raises a lot of questions about what precisely is not known about the functioning of the human mind. So these first three sets of data, which are at odds with the materialist account of the mind, are problematical for materialism because the materialist, as you see, cannot provide an explanation. There’s no mechanism. With the following sets of data of data, the evidence runs directly counter materialism, and, it has been extremely embarrassing, for those scientists who have taken strong materialist stance.
The first is a study of near death experiences, and this is a picture of Bruce Greyson’s meetings with His Holiness the Dalai Lama. There was a conference, held in Dharamsala, two years ago. I was gonna broadcast it at TBI during the noon break, but there just isn’t time. And I think two conferences a day is already a lot for most of you, but you can watch it on YouTube. I’d really encourage you to do so.
Bruce Grayson makes a presentation in Dharamsala during one of the mind and life conferences on his research in the division of personality studies at the University of Virginia, and he summarizes his data on near death experiences, and he also summarizes his data on cases of the reincarnation type. And I think we have a case of the reincarnation type in the room right now on Aaron’s lap. That cat has a connection. So what are near death experiences? Near death experiences are not necessarily experiences which occur close to one’s actual death.
This is the first key point. These are experiences which can occur when one is physiologically close to death, but they can occur when psychologically one is convinced one is gonna die. Even though one does not die and experiences no dramatic injury as a result, in either case, something happens which seems to lead the mind into over gear, and this over gear brings out capacities which are not present or at least are only latent in the ordinary state of the mind. Some of the best research in the field has been done at my alma mater, the University of Virginia, the division of personality studies. This is these are some of the lead researchers in the field.
Stevenson, whose main focus was cases of the reincarnation type, who is at present deceased. Bruce Grayson, is head of the division, whose main focus is near death experiences. Professor Jim Tucker, who has taken on Stevenson’s research, and Edward Kelly, who has published actually, who’s the editor of an exceptional work. And if there is one book I would recommend you to read, if you want to pursue your research, it is Kelly’s book, Irreducible Mind, Towards the Psychology of the twenty first Century. On the third bibliography, the general section, it’s a huge tome, it’s some 800 pages, but if you really want to spend one year or so well, meaningfully for your practice, read this book.
Kelly draws on the sum total of research which moves the point that the mind is material, bibliography is huge, and, he it’s a collective work, so he contributed mainly the section on f w h Myers philosophy, but Bruce Grayson contributed, data on near death experiences and so forth. It is exceptional. There’s no other word for it. It’s not that expensive either. So the collection of near death experiences at the University of Virginia numbered eight hundred sixty one in two zero seven.
It’s increased since then, but the data is unpublished, I didn’t mention it. Approximately fifty percent of the patients were in no danger of dying, so it’s really a misnomer to call these near death experiences. We might want to call them stress of death experiences or perhaps even high stress experiences. It helps to think of them in these terms. Now if we draw a typology of near death experiences, there are two broad subdivisions, non and veridical near death experiences.
Non vividical NDs are basically subjective experiences. The person has experiences we’ll be talking about in just a couple seconds. The famous tunnel of light experience, we have probably all heard about and so forth, but none of this can be verified. It’s a private experience. It may or may not be true.
Viritical experiences are experiences in which the subject, for instance, sees car plates on the street, knows where things which were hidden are placed, travels to other rooms and sees things he or she is not supposed to see and could not see, and this is verified by interrogating or questioning witnesses. Now near death experiences have a variety of features and not all are universal. Basically, I drew on Grayson’s work, there’s very little statistical breakdown of this material simply because there’s very little funding for this research. So this is fairly old work, it comes from Grayson’s work, if you’re interested in near death experiences, the best reference is Greyson’s The Handbook of Near-Death Experiences published by Preger in 02/2009. It’s an expensive book, it’s some $50.60 dollars, but it’s a very serious scientific presentation of the material.
There’s a lot of, how shall we say, there’s a lot of very exhorted material out there, let’s put it that way, because new death experiences are seen as proving a lot more than they do prove. But, the basic problem is to be taken seriously in this field, one does have to follow certain scientific guidelines, and Bruce Grayson does, and other authors like Sam Parnia and Pim van Lommel also do. So in the case of near death experiences, all these features can be present. Water time, thought processes, life review, sudden understanding, peace, light, joy, cosmic unity, out of the body experiences, enhanced sensory experiences, ESP, recognition, visions of another world, encountered beings, mystical beings and points of no return. But some points are present in more than fifty percent of the cases, and this is my my analysis.
The first is an altered sense of time. The second is a strong sense of peace. The third is a sense of joy and cosmic unity, and out of the body experiences where one leaves one’s body or one feels one leaves one’s body are highly present. And then experiences of another world are also present in more than 50% of the cases. In this, these experiences are transcultural.
There are other elements of near death experiences which are culturally bound. For instance, the famous tunnel of light everyone has heard about from Moody’s research is culturally bound. Westerners experience it. Indians and Thais do not. There’s been a study of Indian and Thai near death experiences, they don’t.
Indians and Thai experience the judgment after death by Yama. Westerners do not. These seem to be culturally bound experiences where one’s religion, one’s culture influence what one experiences, But the features mentioned up here are not culturally valid generally. There are and it’s been a taboo topic for a long time. Not only death experiences are good.
Far from there. Then the research in frightening near death experiences has really only taken off in the last twenty years. I I won’t talk about it here. There have been clear accounts of near death experiences involving encounters with with what seems to be hell beings, basically. Then there’s been a systematic taboo against this, both from the standpoint of the researchers and those who experience this.
The researchers come to near death experiences with certain biases. Typically, they want to hear nice stories, let’s put it that way. And those who have experienced being dragged downwards by hellish beings don’t want to talk about it and definitely don’t even want to reconnect it. When you put the two together, find it’s not talked about, but it’s approximately one third, it seems, of near death experiences. So what near death experiences provide, and Kelly has really hit the nail on the head, is evidence of a type of mental functioning which is independent of the activity of the nervous system.
And this becomes particularly clear in one subset of near death experiences, near death experiences during cardiac arrest. New death experiences during cardiac arrest are at odds with the materialist paradigm. So the pioneer in the field is a Dutch cardiologist, Pim van Lommel, I talked about yesterday, who published an article in his research in the Lancet, the year of his retirement. Now present Sam Parnia, who is cooperating with the AWARE project, studying near death experiences in a multiplicity of hospitals, should be releasing his data shortly. We’ve been expecting it for some time now.
Parnia is one of the leading researchers in a very new medical field, the field of resuscitation. So we can hope simply because of the advance in medical technology to have more and more cases of near death experiences in the future. To understand why near death experiences during cardiac arrest pose a major problem for the materialist paradigm, one has to have a get get a sense of what happens during cardiac arrest. During cardiac arrest, the heart simply stops, blood flow stops, and the oxygen uptake in the brain collapses. EEGs, in other words, the electrical activity of the brain goes flat within ten to twenty seconds.
And you, have rapidly the three major signs of death. No cardiac output, no breathing, and no brainstem reflexes. When you have reported mental activity in these states, you are dealing with something which is totally advanced with the materialist paradigm. And Pim van Lommel, and Pim van Lommel is a cardiologist, he retired after some almost fifty years experience, reported within three hundred cardiac arrest cases, interviewed within two days of resuscitation, there were forty one near death experiences. So if you’re a materialist, this has to be explained.
Because this is if it occurs during the cardiac arrest, this is physiologically impossible. There’s no electrical activity of the brain. There’s no oxygen input. So somehow, this has to be accounted for. And for this reason, even though these near death experiences are nonveridical, right, the patient does not experience something which can be verified by others, just such nonveridical near death experiences during cardiac arrest are a major problem for the materialist account of the brain.
If they occur during cardiac arrest, when there is no electrical activity, they refute the materialist account for the other brain, period. Then this has obviously led philosophers and psychologists of the materialist bent to try to counter this, and Susan Blackmore is one of those interesting cases of someone who lost the true faith, as it were. She believed that near death experiences demonstrated the non material nature of the mind, and then she changed her opinion. And it’s a well known fact that when you change religions, you are more hostile to your former religion than anyone who never was of that religion in the first place. That’s her case and she has been very helpful to us in providing mechanism after mechanism.
So the tunnel of light, which as I mentioned is actually not characteristic of, most near death experiences, is explained according to Blackmore by the shutdown of retinal neurons. Out of the body experiences are explained by the reconstruction of a non physically based self and bliss by the release of endorphins. The basic problem with Blackmore’s explanations is that for the two first ones, there’s no physiological evidence that this is happening. I mean, yes, indeed, the brain does shut down. Whether the shutdown of the retinal neurons would induce an experience of a tunnel of light, nobody has a clue.
That’s what she says. And out of the body experiences as a result of the reconstruction of a non physically based self. The construction and deconstruction of a physically based self is something which is yet to be understood. It’s a hypothesis. And obviously, this account of OBEs, out of the body experiences, collapses if someone has paranormal experiences during an OBE.
Because then, the most plausible explanation is simply that something left the body. But it is worth looking, at these accounts. Her final account is more convincing. It’s well known that endorphins are released during stressful episodes. This could account for the experience of bliss.
It’s perfectly possible. I think our pussycat wants to contribute something to the debate. Do you? Veridical NDs are much more problematic. And Pim van Lommel had a collection of these.
Veridical NDs are near death experiences where the subject has access to information he could not have access to, and this information is independently verified. Pim van Lommel mentions a case of a veridical NDE under cardiac arrest. So here, this is very strong case. It’s occurring under cardiac arrest in a hospital. The patient, a Dutch gentleman, had a heart attack.
He’s brought in cyanotic. In other words, you know, basically, his complexion has veered to the dark blue, gray dark blue color due to lack of oxygen in a coma. And the nurse who was intubating him sees that he has dentures, so she remove removes his dentures before intubating him, putting him on an artificial lung. Then they struggle to maintain the patient alive, and actually the medical staff was half of the opinion that perhaps they should give up. It wasn’t quite clear with the patient’s past history they had access to that he had any chance of survival.
They continue, and a week later, the poor patient had lost his dentures, and when the nurse who intubated him came in the wound, he mentions to her, oh, that nurse knows where my dentures are. And then he explains to her, you took my dentures out of my mouth and put them onto that car. Now, he was cyanotic. According to the personnel in the emergency room, he was in a coma. There’s basically little or no brain activity worth talking of.
Yet, he knows the dentures were removed, and not only that, he knows where they were put. This is quite problematical for a materialist account of consciousness. It appeared that the man had seen himself lying in bed from above, so this is a clear out of the body experience, and that the nurses and doctors were giving CPR. He described in detail the room, this is not compatible with an account of the brain as a machine which needs oxygen to function on a large scale. And he appearance described the appearance of the world present, and he was aware that they were hesitant about continuing CPR and hoped they would continue.
Now this case is not how shall we say? It’s not fail proof, it’s a strong case. It happens in a clinical milieu, it happens with personnel who has no particular bias, if anything, personnel who’s not particularly sympathetic to this opinion. These are people who have something to lose if their credibility is put in question. Pim van Lommel had a lot to lose.
This is why he published in these accounts the year of his retirement, you know. And yet they feel and they counter this, especially nowadays on a regular basis, that they have to talk about it. I would encourage you to go on YouTube and watch Pim van Lommel’s interviews. He’s by all accounts a very nice person, highly articulate and very thoughtful, and if you watch his account of the history of resuscitation you will understand why this is a recent phenomenon, that’s scalar in these. Van Lommel points out that really before the nineteen sixties, when he started working as a young cardiologist, it was not possible to resuscitate someone who had cardiac arrest.
The equipment which enabled such resuscitation was developed in the late 1950s, was extremely expensive. And really, let’s say, my father’s generation, when my father did his medical internship, when someone had cardiac arrest, the only way to resuscitate them was actually direct cardiac massage, which was normally not possible. You know, direct cardiac massage involves basically inter intrathoracic massage of the heart under normal circumstances, unless you’re in a hospital with an operating ward, this doesn’t happen. Otherwise, generally speaking, such patients did not survive, and therefore these accounts of near death experiences during cardiac arrest are quite recent. But in the case of veridical near death experiences, these are a very strong counter to the materialistic counter of consciousness.
They can manifest clear VPSI, telepathy, remote viewing, clairaudience, And in addition, they suggest clearly that the mind is not a byproduct of the brain. And not only this, that the mind is non obstructive and non material. It can travel to walls, to space. Then we have to hope that Parnia’s AWARE project and the increasing number of such cases we will have will contribute to the progressive disappearance of the materialist account of mind. These cases are particularly strong because they tend to occur in a controlled environment, in a clinical environment, at times in operating theaters.
And as I mentioned, they occurred they occur in the presence of personnel who is not sympathetic and who is not searching for near death experiences. If anything, these experiences are something of an embarrassment. The following category of occurrences which really is strongly at odds with the materialist account of the mind are these spontaneous memories of previous lives, cases of the reincarnation type. Now, these have been studied for more than a century. The earliest studies I know of go back in France to Charles Richet, and the SPR in The UK engaged in studies even in the late nineteenth century to my knowledge.
But Stevenson at the University of Virginia is the first to have studied them systematically, and his position as, Chester Carlson professor of psychiatry, and as he was actually associate dean, of the faculty at the University of Virginia, gave him tremendous credibility. These studies are ongoing at the University of Virginia. Jim Tucker continues them. Unfortunately, there is a sore lack of funding, and it at present has been very difficult to input all of Stevenson’s data in a database for more systematic analysis. The funding just isn’t there.
As a result, the data analysis I will present to you is partial. Steven has Stevenson studied in excess of 2,500 cases, but it’s groups of cases which have been analyzed, groups of 800, 900 cases. So memories of past lives can be subdivided into two broad groups: spontaneous memories and memories elicited through hypnotic regression. There’s a third group I didn’t mention, which is memories of past lives due to disease or stress. It does happen, but it’s quite rare.
I will focus on spontaneous cases because they are the most interesting for our purpose. There is no particular intent in bringing them out. One doesn’t have to deal with issues of hypnotic suggestion, even involuntary suggestion by the hypnotist, or cases where the hypnotist might have a bit of an axe to grind, might wish to demonstrate the existence of past lives. This has always been a critique against hypnotic regression. Now spontaneous cases occur both in adults and in children.
They’re not restricted to children, but the cases with which children are particularly strong, because in verified CRTs one doesn’t see how the child could have access to this information. So initially, I’d like to give you a sense of who Ian Stevenson was, because this after all is a component of the credibility of his research. Stevenson is Canadian, he was appointed at a surprisingly young age as chair of the department of psychiatry at UVA, which has one of the best medical schools in The United States. When I was there, it was the second or third medical school in the country. From And early on, I suppose you could say he was a bit of an iconoclast.
He published articles challenging the Freudian viewpoint. Then one of his colleagues who had a sharp tongue asked him whether he still dared to walk the streets unarmed after this. You can see how the Freudian dogma was dominant in the nineteen fifties. But Stevenson, in 1966, published a book which was the first book I ever bought when I arrived at University of Virginia. I didn’t know of its existence.
I went to UVA’s bookstore, and here I saw, and this was in 1986, 20 cases suggestive of reincarnation, published by UVA University Press. And I thought, my goodness. I didn’t even know this was happening. This was before the Internet. Right?
We just didn’t know about these things. And I had the period was a novice monk studying under Geoffrey Hopkins. I was absolutely floored by the quality of Stevenson’s research because I had read books on people purporting to remember past lives, and I always felt it was a bit dodgy. I mean everyone seemed to remember being Cleopatra or Napoleon. Nobody remembered being a peasant toiling away in the mud.
No memories of animal lives. Then, you know, it begs a question, right? I mean, back when I was Napoleon, you know, there are many things I wished I had done. But with Stevenson’s work, he was a psychiatrist, an academic, the former head of the department of psychiatry, who was investigating these cases in a scientific fashion and who was obtaining results which are very convincing, all the more so because they were sometimes slightly at odds with the Buddhist teachings, which is what you would expect. Right?
I mean, whenever I don’t know if you’ve ever heard of data from crime scenes, right? When you’re looking at data from crime scenes in forensics, whenever everything meshes perfectly, you’re entitled to assume something is wrong, because real life doesn’t function like that. Real life tends to be a bit messy. You expect a certain amount of contradictions and incompatibilities. So with Stephenson’s data, you could really see, if you looked at the data in 20 cases, that this was this looked like real life data.
It was a bit messy, but strong. Then Stevenson, two years after the publication of this book, faced near dismissal from the University of Virginia, precisely because of the tenor of his research. The topic was too loaded. He was kept on. He was able to remain full professor at the University of Virginia until the end, largely because of the support of an important American industrialist, Chester Carlson.
And he published two sets of works after this. We have most of his works in the library here. I cannot encourage you too highly to study Stevenson’s works. So if you want to ground your Buddhist practice in something solid and not just to have a faith based practice which is fragile, you must work through part of Stevenson’s works. I couldn’t bring them out, they’re quite heavy, you’ll forgive me.
The following set of publications was cases of the reincarnation type, It’s a series of cases divided by geographical area, Sri Lanka, Turkey, and so forth. And his magnum opus was Reincarnation and Biology, two gigantic volumes of around 2,000 pages each, studying the impact these memories of previous rebirths have on the bodies of the children who have them. It’s an extraordinary piece of work. You really owe it to yourselves to read it. I mentioned to one of you who is a sincere who is sincerely interested in Buddhism that if you are sincerely interested in Buddhism, I would put Lamrim aside, because Lamrim starts too high for us.
I would take one year and just study Stevenson’s data, Work through 20 cases of reincarnation, just small smallish book, then pass up two cases of reincarnation type, and then work quietly your way through reincarnation in biology, and then return to the lumbrim. You will look at the Lamrim with very different eyes. Peer assessment in this field is important since we are not really able otherwise to assess the quality of the research. As I mentioned yesterday, Doris Kuhlmann-Wilsdorf, who has passed on and who was professor of engineering actually in the department of physics, material science, and one of Stevenson’s longtime colleagues mentioned that the statistical probability that reincarnation does in fact occur at least occasionally is so overwhelming, established by thousands of already documented cases of remembered lives and strongly buttressed by the incidence of birthmarks in conjunction with many of Stevenson’s well documented cases, that cumulatively the supporting evidence is not inferior to that for most, if not all cosmology or Darwinian evolution. Then she mentioned this after her retirement.
Lester King, who was book review editor for the Journal of the American Medical Association, is the official journal of doctors in America, it doesn’t get really more square than this in The United States, points out that Stevenson’s data is difficult to explain on other grounds. So if at the end of this two day symposium you leave TBI with the resolve to read Stevenson’s works, and ideally also to read Kelly’s Irreducible Mind, our time will have been well spent. You will then be able on that basis to continue your own investigation by yourself. I would like at present to enter in an analysis of cases of reincarnation type. This is one of the cases I will be talking about, a young Turkish boy.
Forgive if any one of you is of Turkish origin, forgive my pronunciation, Semih Tutusmus. So if we look at the breakdown of Stevenson’s cases, and this does not include Jim Tucker’s cases, which would add, I’d say, couple 100, mainly of American cases to the set. Stevenson analyzed or investigated a total of 2,500 cases. Keep in mind, this is 2,500 interviews of children and their families all over the world over some fifty years. It’s a gigantic amount of work by one man and a small team.
Of these, 1,600 cases were unverified. In other words, the child had memories. It was impossible to see whether the memories were true or not. It doesn’t mean the memories are false, there’s just no verification. Eight hundred ninety five cases were verified.
This is almost 900 children who had clear memories of past lives. Stevenson investigated the case, grew up a list of the memories, a typical recognition of family members, the names of the family members, items which were hidden and or lost, which a child finds, changes in the house before the child births, the child remembers. There are eight ninety five such cases, and of these cases there are sixty five cases with autopsies of the body of the previous recollected person. Autopsies indicating the cause of death which enabled Stevenson to publish reincarnation in biology, in which he draws a correlation between the cause of death in the previous life and birthmarks or deformations in the present life. It’s quite extraordinary.
You’ve got to recognize. To find sixty five cases of children who recollect past lives, these memories are verified to find the previous personality, to find the autopsy in third world countries, get a copy of the autopsy and then correlate this. And of these there are thirty five so called best cases, these are cases for which Stevenson considered reincarnation was the only explanation. So in these cases there are alternate explanations which have to be excluded. The first obviously is fraud from the investigator of the family, then Stevenson really was above reproach in this matter and had a tremendous amount to lose.
It is far from clear that he ever gained anything from his research. Whatever reputation he had was basically put in question by his research. The families have, in most cases, very little to gain. They don’t want the child to talk about a previous life, in many of the cases as Stevenson studied, most of the cases actually the death is violent, it is connected to accidents or crimes, it is not something the families want to talk about. Self deception is a big risk for the investigator and the family, but again the data is very strong as you will see.
Alternate sources of information like cryptonesia, where you learn something and forget you knew it, is also a big risk. Again, in many of these cases in third world countries, it’s almost impossible to see how the child had access to the information, and there was no financial advantage. Paranormal phenomena to be executed is much more complex. It’s very difficult to know whether these are memories of past lives or cases of telepathy where the child read another reads another person’s memories, clairvoyance of position. The key feature which enables us to separate these two is a strong sense of I of the child.
The child says it was me. He doesn’t say, oh, so and so dropped a red, letter on the street, and it was taken up and hidden in this box. The child says, I saw. The child, in other words, identifies with the events. This is absent in cases of telepathy and cases of clairvoyance.
So what are the universal features of the case? The memories manifest the moment the child can speak. The child speaks and he starts speaking of his past life. The memories are no longer spoken about around ages five or seven. This is not always the case.
Some of the cases, Stevenson’s cases, keep their memories into adulthood. There’s a very high incidence of violent death. Not all the data has been processed, but we’re looking at around seventy percent of the previous lives having had violent deaths, and the mode of death is frequently mentioned. These are universal features in every case. Then there are occasional features, which sometimes are present, sometimes are not.
There can be physical resemblance to the previous life or body, and face is quite striking sometimes, and birthmarks connected with the cause of death. A similar temperament is quite widespread. So is deja vu, the feeling that one has experienced something before without quite knowing why. Memories from past lives and vivid recurring dreams are very common. In terms of behavior, one has frequently unexplainable phobias, which tend to be associated to the mode of death in the previous life.
Behaving as if still an adult, what I think new age inclined people call being old souls. Unusual play is quite common, and this is not something which really concerns Westerners, but unexplainable dietary preferences in many Asian countries, instance, one’s diet is very, constrained by one’s culture. If you’re, for instance let’s say, you live in Burma, you eat spicy cooked fish. Then there’s a bevy of Stevenson’s cases of children remembering being Japanese soldiers killed in Burma, born with deformations due to the torture inflicted to them by the Burmese partisans before they died, who systematically don’t want to eat cooked fish, but want to eat raw fish, which nobody eats in Burma. And which have character traits, which are very akin to those attributed to Japanese soldiers, harshness, a certain cruelty, hardness, and which are very much at once with the Burmese temperament.
Now as I mentioned, we don’t have a breakdown of all of Stevenson’s cases. Hopefully, this will arise in the future, so I have to rely on partial breakdown. Breakdown by gender, a large proportion of the children remembering past lives are male. I think for two reasons, first, because males attract more attention in most countries of the world, male children to the present day. And also because in cases of the reincarnation type there is, generally speaking, little gender crossover.
It happens, but it’s rare. And most of the children who have memories of past lives remember a violent death. Violent deaths are more common among males, much more common in all cultures. Then if we look at the mode of death, in the solved cases, this is a subset unfortunately, fifty percent of the deaths are violent and in the unsolved cases it’s ninety percent of the deaths. An empirical figure which has been relied upon by Stevenson’s team is between seventy and eighty percent of all recollected deaths in previous lives are violent.
And by violent, we mean not necessarily involving crime, but a sudden termination of the life, which from a Buddhist standpoint has a very specific meaning. This is death through being hit by a car, through falling in a river, through being murdered, but it is not death from cancer or a long drawn out disease. Interestingly enough, and this is my personal analysis, almost all the cases of CORTs indicate that the children experience what amounts to post traumatic stress disorder in relation to the memories of their past life. It’s quite striking. There is often no event in their present life to justify such manifestation.
Now what are the features of post traumatic stress disorder? Distressing thoughts or images, nightmares about traumatic events, and intense psychological distress when exposed to something that triggers memories of the traumatic event. Now this occurs with trauma in this life. If someone has been in a war zone, let’s say, and has seen one of his comrades shot in a particularly savage fashion or killed by the roadside, then it is well known that anything related to that can trigger powerful trauma. We see this sort of behavior in children who have past life memories without anything in this life to explain it.
For instance, a child who died by drowning, who recollects dying by drowning, will run away screaming from puddles of water. A child who was murdered with a hammer, one case in Stevenson’s research, it’s an adult who was murdered by a hammer, the child who recollects this is unable to stand hammers. Another child who was driven to a hospital in an ambulance after being hit by a car cannot stand to be driven around in a car. So there are specific phobias which are associated with the recollected mode of death. And in the case of forty seven children recollecting death by drowning, sixty four percent had a phobia of immersion.
Now I what I don’t do for TBI, right, I managed to check phobias of water in Iceland in the As I said, what I don’t do for you. This is how I I like to spend my weekends, you know, phobias of drowning among Icelandic fishermen. Now, is a population in which you would expect a large phobia of water. Right? You’ve got people who are on the sea all the time, who’ve known people who’ve drowned.
You’d expect us to have phobias of water. A very small percentage of the population, it’s two percent, has a phobia of water, as opposed to sixty percent among the children who recollect death by drowning. So if you consider this is representative of a population where that actually be a pretty good ground for phobia by water of water, you can imagine, let’s say, in Australia, you’d have even less than one point eight percent was aquaphobic. Right? And I’d like at present to study with you one case, the case of Semi Tutushma, which is very interesting case.
First, because your child is Turkish, so, he does not come from a society in which the belief in reincarnation is widespread, and because it really encapsulates all the key features of Stevenson’s cases, clear memories of past life lives, recognition of family members, temperament and keeping with the recollected temperament, not just birthmarks but deformations associated with the mode of death. And if we start analyzing the case, the main features are the following. Semih Tutusmus is a young boy, was a young boy, born in 1958. At a very young age, three, he could barely walk, left his family home to walk to a neighboring village with which he had no connection, Hatun Köy. He was profoundly attached to a woman, Katibbe, totally unrelated to his family, who was the widow of someone who was murdered.
And he had a deep hatred for someone he had never met, a certain Işıklar Beli, who had been accused of murder. As a child from the age of eight to 18, he spent most of his spare time planning to murder Işıklar Beli. He suffered from birth deformations, specifically microtia of the right ear, the right ear was underdeveloped as opposed to the left ear, and what’s known as facial hemiplegia, in other words asymmetry of the face, you can see it’s quite striking. One side of the face is underdeveloped, the right side of the face is underdeveloped when compared with the left side of the face. He had clear recollections of a previous life as a certain Selim Fesli, who lived in the village he had walked to as an infant, Hatun Köy, who was married to Katibe, and who was shot by Işıklar Beli during a hunting expedition in the right ear.
He was shot with a shotgun, it seems point blank in the right ear. He survived several hours, it’s actually almost a day, was taken to the hospital, shotgun pellets were embedded in the cranium in the brain, in the right ear, but as you can imagine, massive damage to the right side of the skull. And Stevenson was able, and this is why this case is very interesting, it’s one of the sixty five cases where Stevenson found the postmortem. So this is a postmortem of the recollected personality on the right parietal area of the skull, in the right frontal area, there are six round holes made by buckshot. The shot had entered the brain after penetrating the skull.
Now if we look at the deformations of saline faciae and see how widespread they are, could this just be a fluke in other words? We can see that they are quite rare when, put all together. Microtia of the right ear occurs in one between one to twenty thousand and one to thirty thousand births. The fistulas, in other words, a hose, say, little had in his right ear occur in less than one percent of Caucasian children. Sorry for the whiter to be Caucasian.
And left hemifacial hypoplasia occurs in one to three thousand to one to five thousand births. Altogether, this would be quite rare. Now, obviously, these are not independent events. You could not just basically multiply the the probabilities as you would if they were independent, but they could be considered to be largely independent. So you’re looking at perhaps something occurring in less than a hundred one in a hundred thousand cases, something of that nature.
And you can clearly see here the microtia of the right ear, where the left ear is normal, clear instance of hemifacial hypoplasia, and Stevenson drew the depressions on little Simi Toutouche Musch’s ear, Stevenson took his notes in French as a Canadian. So you see, fossettes small holes which do not lead inside, right ear, and these notes were taken in 1967. Then the case is quite puzzling, and it has all of the key features of one of Stevenson’s cases. You have a child who has clear memories of being murdered. As an infant, he walks alone to the village where he used to live.
He was obsessed with his widow, would not allow her to remarry, which is obviously quite awkward for all concerned. Even more so, was obsessed with taking revenge on the man who had murdered him. He said, Iqbali was actually sentenced to a jail term. Murder was never conclusively proved. He claimed it was a hunting accident.
It seems very short range for a hunting accident. And at the moment Semih Tutusmus could walk, his main hobby seems to have been to take rocks and throw them at Işıklar Beli’s stand at which he sold bottles of Holmbrun liquor, Arak. Then Işıklar Beli obviously lived in fear that when the young boy became adult, he would try to take revenge. Semih Tutusmus’s outlook seems to have improved over time, Stevenson intimates that he became less vindictive over the years. So basically, how is such a case of the reincarnation type compatible with the neurobiological understanding of memory?
If memory is physiological, is somehow coded in groups of neurons or individual neurons, how is it possible, in Stevenson’s eight ninety five verified cases, that memories pass from life to life? And all of the memories which are recognized, let’s say, in neurology are present: conditioning memory, procedural memory, memories which are autobiographical, semantic memory. So when it’s clear that memory has a physiological basis, it seems just as clear from Stevenson’s research that there is much more to it than that. And my personal feeling is that the explanation, his willingness to Dalai Lama has proposed, is very sound, which is, and it’s what I will drive at the end of this conference, that while the coarse levels of mind are intimately dependent on the brain and on the neural substratum, subtle levels of mind are not. And this is what we see in near death experiences, where subtle minds manifest with features which are different from main minds.
We have some of our students have had near death experiences, you know, they have direct experience of this. I had a near death experience. I had direct experience of this. The mind, at that point, is much faster, much more powerful, much clearer. It is not the ordinary course slugging mind we deal with on a daily basis.
Then it would be this subtle mind which transmigrates if reincarnation occurs. The precise relationship between the coarse mind and the subtle mind, that is something else. That calls for much investigation. And then, we have come to the point where I feel I can tread where perhaps I shouldn’t tread, which is the issue of modern psychiatry and possession. Now before I go any further, I should make it very clear that I’m in no way implying that all mental disease is due to possession.
Mental disease has a physiological basis, which psychiatry has done much to elucidate. There are huge swathes of mental disease like depression, which are pretty well understood. Pretty well understood. But there are certain categories of mental disease where I think that their classification as physiological ailments is probably due to bias. And those are the ones I would like to talk to you about.
You might find it interesting if you have some spare time to study the history of psychiatry. The history of psychiatry is quite fascinating because one realizes that the founders of modern psychiatry, and that is mainly Charcot, the great French psychiatrist who was a bit of an idol of my father, Pierre Janet, his colleague, and Sigmund Freud, their disciple. The founders of psychiatry had not a hidden, but an overt agenda, accounting for what was considered really up to the beginning of the nineteenth century as cases of possession. So up to the end of the eighteenth century, psychiatric ailments were considered to be due to an exterior entity, a spirit entering the person and causing disturbance. This was just mainstream knowledge.
It’s worth pointing out that nowadays, out of a population of 7,000,000,000, I’d say probably some four to 5,000,000,000 people out of the West still pretty much subscribe to this view. If you live in India, if you travel to Thailand, to much of Asia, this is a mainstream view. People pay lip service to psychiatry, but spirits are a daily reality. They are seen, they are perceived, they can enter unprotected persons, one tries to ward oneself against this. Then in the early nineteenth century, as materialism took hold, it became critically important to disprove this.
Charcot’s project Charcot was really the founder of modern psychiatry, you can say the the chief of La Salpêtrière, the famous insane asylum close to Paris. Charcot’s project was to give an organic base for cases which until then were considered cases of possession, and you can see why. This is a case of what used to be called lethargy, we would say catalepsy now, a lady lying with her neck on one chair and her feet on the other chair. Something which seems physiologically impossible, right, supporting her entire weight, you know, on two points. This is one of Charcot’s famous subjects, Augustine, in a state of ecstasy.
She was one of Charcot’s foremost subjects. Then Charcot used a term for these patients, which is now discredited. He called them hysterical, and the understanding was quite biased, obviously. These cases, are prevalent in women, I must say, far more prevalent in women than in men, were seen to be due to a disturbance of the womb. The womb is called the hystera in Greek.
Now, the term is no longer used, and we now know that these disorders exist in men as well as in women. But while Charcot’s team elucidated a large number of these disorders, there’s one category of disorder which has resistant elucidation and which has resisted treatment, and that’s why I would like to address it. It is now known as dissociative identity disorder. The name keeps changing in a function of the edition of DSM one deals with. And it’s called dissociative identity disorder to really it’s a euphemism to try to avoid addressing the main issues, which is that the person simply claims to be somebody else.
And doesn’t just claim to be somebody else, behaves like somebody else, has somebody else’s memories, speaks like somebody else. There are physiological changes. There are changes sometimes in eyesight, then these cases obviously must be accounted for. Now what are according to DSM four, which is a bible, DSM five has just come out, my apologies, I couldn’t justify spending a $130 on it, so I had to rely on the previous edition. What are the features of DID according to DSM four?
This is the orthodox psychiatric viewpoint. Two or more distinct identities are present in the individual. These identities take over control of the behavior recurrently, they alternate, they’re never present together. The individual is unable to recall important personal information, It’s that there is a split in the mind of the individual, two boxes. And this disturbance is not due to drug usage or an underlying medical condition, let’s say, such as diabetes, which can cause mental problems.
Now what is very interesting is if we rely on the patient’s report, which isn’t interesting enough is systematically evacuated in these cases, the patient reports being somebody else. And these reports, as Kelly points out, involve what appears to be separate memory chains, streams of consciousness and identity, and display all the characteristics we attribute to conscious beings such as memory, intention, volition, and creativity. Then, is psychiatry justified in considering that something has not entered the person in the face of what looks like quite strong reported evidence that this has happened? These cases have become quite prevalent in Europe, due to to immigration, and we encounter cases of possession by jinns, both in The UK and in France. Quite common, jinns, you know, are Islamic spirits which haunt the graveyards.
This is a a Muslim immigrant to The UK who is perfectly functional in daily life until the jinn possesses him, this has been going on for years, at which point he behaves in position a bit like a snake, he hisses. Then he went to see a psychiatrist in The UK to no avail. He was told he suffered from high levels of anxiety, which don’t really seem to represent what is happening, and finally appealed to a Koranic healer who seems to have been of some benefit. When possessed, he has no memories of his daily life. He works I think in a taxi central, and when he’s in a taxi central, he has no memories of what happens when he is possessed.
It’s as if there are two different streams of consciousness. Then what are the features of these cases of DID? And this is once again, broadly speaking, drawn from DSM form. Cadence, change in voice, conversion symptoms which means physical manifestations, it’s a euphemism for psychosomatic manifestations. Changes in vision, there are cases of people who were who had presbyssia, who when they are possessed by a young child lose this presbyssia.
Insensitivity to pain, seizure, differences in the EEG algorithm, and change in handedness. Someone who is right handed becomes left handed, someone who is left handed becomes right handed. These amount to very important changes. Some of the most puzzling are the changes in visual acuity and manifest refraction, where during possession someone who needed glasses no longer needs them, and reciprocally. There’s a very interesting study in your bibliography by Miller in the journal of nervous and mental disease, I encourage you to read it.
Adult personalities show presbyopia, child personalities never do. So at best, this implies a degree of control over the human body, which is very difficult to understand. But it is no mechanism proposed. I mean, I’m sure ophthalmologists would be thrilled or perhaps they will be devastated if it would be possible to heal presbyopia without glasses. You probably destroy the profession.
Now what is interesting, and this is something which I would like to quote from Bethany Brand et al, a survey of practices recommended treatment intervention among expert therapists treating patients with dissociative identity disorder and dissociative disorder not otherwise specified. They are the main textbooks on the treatment of DID. DID is basically very difficult if not impossible to treat, and this is the official view on the topic. So here we have a situation where the report of the patient says that something else is within him. Exterior evidence from observers seems to indicate indeed that we are dealing with two persons.
Actually, DSM four speaks of two personalities. We are unable to treat this, but in what amounts to a dogmatic stance, we assert that the traditional explanation, which is adopted basically by every everybody, except modern Westerners in the last two centuries, is wrong. Now, I didn’t quote I was going to bring it up, but I it’s perhaps stretching things for you a bit. A very interesting report by a Turkish psychiatrist who had to handle cases, DID cases in present Kurdistan, in the part of Turkey, which is claimed by the Kurds, with almost no success, and systematically referred the cases to an Islamic healer whom he said had a far higher success rate than he did. This raises a lot of questions.
And Erlendur Haraldsson, who is Stevenson one of Stevenson’s colleagues, points out that when alter personalities, in other words, these other persons, whether they actually separate entities or not, are interrogated about who they believe they are, they say they are children, helping spirits, demons, another living person, or dead relatives. And Haraldson points Evanson points out, even though the majority of alters claim not to belong to the individual, the prevailing opinion is that these are in fact parts of the individual. So here we have a case where I would say psychiatry, perhaps perhaps for dogmatic reasons, is flying in the face of an awful lot of evidence. And there have been psychiatrists who have broken off with the orthodox dogma. Many French psychiatrists who were directly in contact with DID cases in Africa, often disciples of the great French anthropologist, Auguste Mauss.
So the initiator of the school of psychiatry, ethnopsychiatry, was the director of the department of psychiatry at the at Dakar hospital, professor Henri Collomb, who was repeatedly faced with cases, which at the period, were called multiple personality disorder, now we call them DID, and was unable to treat them, and noticed that the native healers had good results, and put himself to the school of the native healers, feeling after all as a working psychiatrist what counts ultimately is healing the patient. And his disciples, Georges Devereux and Tobie Nathan, have continued this approach in France where there is a very large number of African immigrants, and these problems are extremely widespread. Then Tobie Nathan, who is the famous psychiatrist who integrates what amounts to exorcism in his psychiatric practice gives one case. I remember Nadine, a lady from Cameroon, who underwent such a serious depression that she was unable to take care of her child. This is in Paris.
I spoke to her, touching her hands with reassuring gestures. She entered at once into trance and declared in a man’s voice, actually her father’s voice. He had passed on one year earlier. I want Nadine to come at once to my grave in Cameroon. Then turning to me, he said, just who are you to speak to me?
He then added, how can you take care of my daughter when you aren’t even black? In this type of case, deminathaus says, are only two solutions. Either one stops the therapeutic session or one starts negotiating with the spirit who has appeared. It’s a later option I chose. Look, obviously, if you’re a working psychiatrist in a case like this, you have to work with a case, don’t you?
You can’t just say to the patient, look, your stance is completely at odds with DSM four. I’d like you to review your position. Can you? And this actually has led some neurobiologists to investigate the neurobiology of possession. It’s mainly Patrick McNamara at Boston Hospital and Andrew Newberg at the Myrna Brind Center for Integrative Medicine, Thomas Jefferson University Hospital.
Then one of the most interesting studies I have seen on the topic is a study by Brazilian psychiatrists of spirit mediums who practice automatic writing, which I’m heard sure you have heard about. Now normally, these are cases which would be considered cases of dissociative identity disorder. You’d expect the typical pattern which modern psychiatry tells us leads dissociative identity disorder, which is sexual abuse. Officially, is it is this trauma during early childhood which leads to the appearance of a crypto personality which eventually takes over. This is, I would say, current dogma.
Then they found basically that among the 115 spirit mediums they studied, these subjects really did not fit the paradigm. They had a high educational level, they had low levels of psychiatric disorder, they were well adjusted socially. Only in one case did they score highly on borderline personality disorder. And in a subset of 10 cases which were studied, what you can basically see is that the educational level is quite high. These tend to be people who were full time employed, retired or part time employed, in other words, who are able to function in society.
Older people frequently, and what is quite interesting, people who rated very low on the borderline personality disorder of DSM four. There was only one case where the personality rated highly and had suffered child abuse. Then this is quite puzzling. Moreover, the quality of the writing produced was very high, and they did not publish the charts, so I have did not have access to them, but the writing produced in the experienced spirit mediums did not involve the activation of the parts of the brain one would expect to see activated, versus the Broca area and so forth. Then, as the authors of this study, Rodolfo Fernandez and Alexander Moreira-Almeida mentioned, the subjects produced complex content in a trance dissociative state.
There was under activation of the brain areas specifically related to the cognitive processing being carried out. This is very difficult to account for. The quality of the writing is assessed as good by independent university examiners working in double blind position situations. In other words, they don’t know who is basically giving them the text, is it a spirit medium or just a student. You have spirit mediums who are rating very low on borderline personality disorder, only one case of sexual abuse in borderline personality disorder.
Well educated, generally university degrees, seem well integrated in society, it doesn’t fit the paradigm at all. And the subject systematically attributed their work to spirits. So the self description, description of the event from the standpoint of the subjects was that somebody else had taken over. And this leads me to one verified case of possession studied by Stevenson, so I I had to prime you for this one, because otherwise you’d go into a state of advanced shock. There’s not a lot because it’s rare, it’s obviously very taboo in the societies in which it happens.
The first thing typically when there’s a case of parakaya pravesh possession in India is that one calls in an exorcist and tries to get it out of the way and nobody ever talks about it because the family basically is ostracized as a result. But Stephenson was able to investigate one case and I wanted to show you a picture here, a series of pictures I’ve shown previously at GBI of the possession of an African woman in Ghana by the spirit of a python attributed snake spirit. Now you may or may not know that the favorite food of pythons is eggs, and I encourage you to look at the face of this African lady devouring that egg with her eyes. It’s quite astonishing. Whether or not a python spirit is present with her within her, I cannot say, but she’s certainly making a very good case of impersonation.
These were the cases Henri Collomb had to handle at Dakar Hospital. You cannot handle this on a day to day basis without revising your paradigm somewhat. The case I’d like to cover with you is a case of Sumitra Singh, an Indian girl who I mean, this isn’t an Indian village, right, we’re not in a western hospital, showed exterior signs of death on 07/19/1985. She revived a couple minutes later, and to the shock of her family said that she was someone else. She she said her name was Shiva Divedi and that she can be murdered.
She did not recognize her family, but when introduced to them, recognized 13 members of Shiva Devedi’s family. And what is most puzzling is that her behavior changed completely. She was a simple village girl before the apparent death with no education. After the apparent death, she spoke a high level of Hindi and behaved like an urbanite, which Shiva Devedi had turned out to be. She had a bachelor’s degree.
The case was investigated by Stevenson. He interrogated the parties in presence. So during her death she was described, and again this is a description based on the observation of villagers, as pulseless, there was no no pulse, and apneic, no breathing, and her face was drained of blood. Keep in mind however, these are people who have seen a lot of death, much more than you or I probably ever would. After her revival, she behaved like a different person, and she clearly stated she had been murdered by her in laws, which is quite common in India.
She could not recognize the people around her. When her father came, she refused to recognize him and more embarrassingly refused to have anything to do with her husband or her child. She said, literally, you are not my husband. Now if we compare the two cases, Sumitra Singh was born in 1968. She was born in a lower middle class, a takur caste.
Lower class person, peasant background, she had basically not attended school. I think she had attended a couple years of kindergarten. The statement she never went to school is not quite correct. Then the possessing personality, Shiva Divedi, died in 1985. She was of the highest caste, the Brahmin caste, middle class, and urban.
There’s a huge distinctions in India. It’s not a Western country. Someone who lives in a village and someone who lives in a city evolve in two different universes. Shiva DeVedi was highly articulate and literate in Hindi. She had a BA degree and she claimed she was murdered by her in laws.
I think they actually took her to a railway track and tied her her down on the railway track or something of that nature. Then Sumitra’s recognition after possession of members of Shiva Devedi’s family. She recognized herself in her picture, She knew Shiva’s father’s pet names. She recognized her maternal uncle. She knew the name of her maternal uncle, and she even knew the name and the nickname of a childhood friend.
Then this case bears striking resemblance to the cases of reincarnation type. The only difference is that you have incarnation during the life of a person or just after an apparent death. There is, in my personal opinion, no difference in kind between these cases, but indifference in degree. Stevenson does not have a lot of such cases, but the ones he has are well verified. Then if we are ready to accept the notion of a non material consciousness, and I hope to have given you quite a lot of arguments in favor of that, there’s no particular reason we should accept cases of reincarnation type and not accept cases of possession.
And in that case, we are evolving in a very different world from the one you and I are accustomed to. A world in which consciousnesses can be incarnate or disincarnate. Then we who are incarnate, who have bodies, see each others. Most of us do not see disincarnate consciousnesses. My mother-in-law does, for instance, quite common, It’s quite embarrassing when my wife goes with her to the market because my wife doesn’t want to hear about this.
My mother-in-law therefore never reports these cases, but sometimes when they have arrived, says to Mandy, Oh, you know, we crossed so and so and so and so and and so. Then disincarnate consciousnesses would perceive each other and might or might not perceive incarnate beings. This is very much the Buddhist worldview, the worldview of sentient beings. Sentient beings can have a body but do not necessarily have a body. Spirits are seen as beings like us with the afflictions we have, the desires we have.
Sometimes they interact with our world. Most of the times, they do not. But I thought I would mention these cases to give you an idea of just how much of a paradigm shift has occurred in the West in the last two centuries, and as a result, if you yourselves are seriously interested in becoming Buddhists, what sort of a worldview you will be participating in? And you have to ask yourself, is this rational or not? For instance, in the case of the treatment of dissociative identity disorder, think there’s a strong case to be made that psychiatry has operated largely on the basis of bias.
I think the data is pretty much there. In the case of cases of the reincarnation type, which Stevenson presented, interestingly enough, these cases have never really been addressed by the scientific community at large, and nobody has ever questioned Stevenson’s integrity or his methodology. When there have been one or two questions addressed to his methodology, he has actually tried to replicate the case. There have been replication studies. Then cases of near death experience are starting to be well known in Western hospitals.
I think they will occur with an increasing frequency precisely because resuscitation is becoming more and more realistic in our clinical environment. Then it is my personal belief, as I mentioned to you yesterday, that we are in the middle of a paradigm shift. In physics, it has already occurred. In biology and medicine, certainly as far as new death experiences are concerned, the data is piling up. It is going to have to be addressed at some point.
Then paradigm shifts are resisted, and there’s nothing terribly surprising about that. Human beings don’t like change. But as we will see this afternoon, the Indian religious traditions, which are somewhat between religions and philosophies in many senses of the term, are very compatible with the body of data which has come out so far. Then I have covered what I wanted to cover with you this morning. If you have questions, I’d be happy to take your questions.
Please. Elia, thanks again for that presentation. I was interested, well, I smiled to myself when you said that quantum physics doesn’t support Christianity because I went to YouTube last night and on top of my thing there’s what appears to be a very interesting extrapolation of quantum physics and ends up the conclusion there is a God. But I’m more interested in the reincarnation aspects. One question is, I would ask, is why do most of the reincarnation cases seem to come from the third world and not from the Western world?
I know one reason it’s offered is that it’s more acceptable in those communities and people don’t tend to speak out in Western communities for the fear of being ridiculed. However, experience with small children is ridicule is not high on their agenda. They just speak freely anyway. Well, you’re talking I’ll go grab a cushion because it turns out the floor is a lot cooler than I ever thought it would be. My apologies.
Thank you. Yes. Well, quantum mechanics can be invoked to support anything we want because nobody really understands what’s happening. But the reason I said that quantum mechanics is basically very problematical for the monotheistic religious traditions, we’ll talk about it this afternoon, is that in traditional monotheistic philosophies, God is here and the world is there. God is immaterial and the world is material, created by God and not dependent for its daily functioning on him.
And it exists the world, as we know it, exists outside of us. Now, this is not the position of all Christian, Jewish, and Muslim traditions or mystical traditions, which have a much more sympathetic view of the relationship between mind and matter. But overwhelmingly, this is a dominant viewpoint. Such a viewpoint is simply at odds with quantum mechanics. The idea of a material world out there independent of us, created by God however long ago, which functions autonomously, independently of us, is something which is not supported, at least at the subatomic level.
The monotheistic view of the world would be strongly compatible with Newtonian physics. Classical physics would be very happy with that viewpoint. Now your second question, cases of reincarnation type overrepresented in third world countries. Initially, certainly with Stevenson’s research, I think it was simply a case of cultural openness to these memories in countries in which past lives are not as shocking as here. Jim Tucker has focused exclusively on Western cases.
Then we now have a large number of very strong Western cases of memories of past lives. I’ve talked of at least one at TBI, one of the strongest Western cases I know. In these cases, we have all the features we encounter in the Indian, Burmese, or Thai cases. There’s one particular case of a young child, an American child, recollecting a past life as a fighter pilot who fought in World War two. And this child actually manifested very shocking and disturbing behavior.
His family was Baptist Christian family in Louisiana. So as you can imagine, reincarnation does not go down very well in those milieus. At the age of two, the child started having recurrent nightmares. I forget his name, Chris. My apologies.
Do you remember? It’s been a long talk. I I have it in my files. Chris will find it for us, I’m sure. And he started kicking his blankets off for shouting, plane on fire, little man must get out.
Then this these nightmares were recurrent. They occurred first weekly, then almost every night, driving the parents obviously to a frenzy, and they try to draw the child out. Yes. James Leininger. James Leininger.
The case is very famous. When the little child started drawing, exclusively drew drew pictures of planes on fire, propeller planes on fire, plunging towards what he drew as an ocean and surrounded by flashes. To try to disprove his wife’s idea that perhaps these were memories of a past life, his wife had started to turn away from Baptist dogma, I gather, James Leininger’s father decided to investigate his son’s memory and just to demonstrate that they were false. Thanks to the Internet, he was able to track or to verify the data the child provided. The child said that the planes he flew systematically veered in one direction, and indeed, it turns out that the corsairs, which were the plane in question, systematically veered in one direction.
Then the child gave James Leininger gave the name of the aircraft carrier he served upon, called the Natoma Bay. Nobody had ever heard of it, and his father was eventually able to track it down. When the little boy was given toy soldiers, he gave them names which were in keeping with the names of his best friends in his previous life, and one of these best friends he gave the full name of Jack Lawson. Eventually the father was able to track down Jack Lawson, who met with the little boy and who treated him exactly as his lost friend from World War two. The child also showed an extraordinary level of knowledge of how airplanes flew and airplane functioning, and eventually, with his parents, traveled to the site off the island of Okinawa where his plane was shot down.
Then this is one of numerous cases now, and it’s a case which clearly shows why Stevenson had such problems getting such cases. A child was born in Louisiana in a Baptist family, and literally everything possible was done to discourage such memories from emerging. Her father was a prominent businessman. Know, America, especially the South, is profoundly religious. This would have been very harmful to the family status and maybe even to his business.
While the father has eventually had to accept reincarnation, he remains a Christian despite this. I hope that answers your question. In part it does because I think as the world becomes less religious in the Western would expect those constraints about talking about past experiences too. No, I don’t think so, not in the West for a very simple reason. Memories of past lives are not normal.
Stevenson’s research shows that memories of past lives basically don’t occur if the previous death was natural. They occur when the previous death was abrupt and violent. Now everything is done in Western hospitals to draw out the death process, and death generally occurs under morphine. So in these cases, you would expect, assuming that the person who died on a morphine had a human rebirth, which is highly improbable, from Buddhist standpoint we would expect an animal rebirth, but if that person had a human rebirth, we would assume that there would be no memories. Because it is in a violent death, happens is it is the dissolution of the coarse minds into the subtle minds which collapses.
Then it seems that in this process, memories do pass over. They’re not supposed to. It’s not something which benefits the equilibrium of the child. No child who has had memories of past lives seems to have particularly benefited from these memories. If anything, it’s often harmful.
That’s why Stevenson has always been opposed to hypnotic recollection of past lives. He does not view it as therapeutic. In my personal experience, I have regressed at least one patient, is that it’s not therapeutic. It is stressful for the patient and not terribly helpful. Then Jim Tucker has pursued research in the field, what’s basically constraining his research now is funding, and Stevenson has published one book, European cases of the reincarnation type, you might find of interest, in which he focuses exclusively on Western cases.
And the cases are strong. British cases, there are two twins, British twins, very, very strong case. One German case, it’s an older case of the nineteen twenties, a German gentleman who had memories of a previous existence in the Middle Ages as a result of an acute bout of fever, and who was actually able to track down the castle he served in as a soldier and had clear memories of the layout of the castle. In the thirteenth century, the castle had been heavily modified since then, he was able to confirm the thirteenth century layout by investing investigating in the archives, which in Europe are very well kept. Many cases like these are very strong.
You know? So these cases are mentioned in European cases of the reincarnation type, and I would encourage all of you to investigate by yourselves. I heard of one case where young girl identified her killer and the police actually found, because all the details she had about the person and where it happened and whatever, she couldn’t have known, and they slowly tracked it down and they eventually caught the murderer and he got caught. I don’t know the case but it does happen. Like in the case of the Turkish case we mentioned, if Isa Dykberli had not been arrested, I’m quite sure the police would have looked at him very carefully because that young boy was making a strong case.
That’s what happened here too. A very strong case. And the other thing is in the automatic writing thing, I recently watched the documentary on A Course in Miracles and that was all written by automatic writing. Automatic writing is an open question. I I don’t take position either way.
I think there’s a lot of automatic writing which is a product of the person. But there are also cases which are puzzling, and these Brazilian psychographers are puzzling cases. That I didn’t insist on it too much. I want to insist on the very strong cases of possession. Stevenson lists.
But what I would very much like to do, and some of you I think are more sympathetic to the viewpoint, some are not. I would like to encourage you to stretch a little bit your minds. Not everything you are told in school is true. Right? And not everything which is orthodox dogma is true.
Some is. But when it is quite clear that orthodox dogma is basically doing loops, to try to account for phenomena, you are entitled to look elsewhere. And there’s quite a pile up of data, as you can see already in the last day and a half. There’s strong data from physics. I mean, it’s theoretical data.
It’s very difficult to refute from von Neumann’s position. Evidence corroborating his view is building up. Then there is evidence from a lot of diverse fields. We don’t have a clear account of altruism in biology, especially when it comes to primate altruism. We have no account of the fact that children can actually learn to speak.
The poverty of stimulus argument, normally intimates they shouldn’t be able to. Then we have no account for the pre verbal ethical sense which Bloom and his team put in evidence among children aged three to six months at Yale. Again, where does this come from? Right? Then, as I mentioned yesterday, there is strong data supporting the existence of telepathy.
I mean, from a series of different sources, Russian sources, American sources, data strong enough that basically it’s been taken on board by the military. There is substantial data about PSK, about psychokinesis. Then we saw today that there is a broad body of data regarding near death experiences indicating that they do occur during cardiac arrest, and the counterargument is that somehow they would occur before or after, and the person recollects them as occurring during, which is nice and fine, but those who say that provide no evidence whatsoever that they occur before or after. It’s a prejudice. A prejudice is this.
A prejudice means that without data, you advance a position because this is your theoretical framework. You have no data to support it. There’s no data to support this viewpoint. And then verified cases of near death experience where the person knows something they’re not supposed to know are not accountable for in the present paradigm. Cases of reincarnation type, we have 895 verified cases unaccountable for.
And in my opinion, and this is my private opinion, perhaps because I lived many years in Asia and come from a background which is not completely Western in many senses of the term, certain psychiatric ailments really are not well accounted for by psychiatry. And it seems to me in a very naive way that the traditional account is just much more convincing. Do you have any questions before we separate for lunch? Yes, please. Possibly you speak about this this afternoon so might be a bit preemptive.
Regarding possession what would in Buddhist theory the mechanism be for possession because it seems like say a person who then becomes possessed by another does not go through a reincarnation cycle and neither does the spirit die and be reborn in that body It seems like there’s sort of transition between bodies. So what is your personal thoughts on the mechanism? I can give you my personal viewpoint. It’s not been analysed in-depth in Buddhism. Then there are some analyses at the tantric level which I cannot enter into here.
But basically, there’s two possibilities: either the person has died, in other words, consciousness has left the body and another consciousness comes in, Or the person has not died and two consciousnesses coexist with one neural substratum. These are the two possibilities. The first possibility is quite straightforward. The person dies. It’s probably what happened with Sumitra.
Person dies, then that body is physiologically functional for a couple minutes and spirit basically takes over that body and animates it, and then normally the previous personality never returns. In fact, a house has become empty because someone moved out, someone else moves in and that’s it. And the other case is where the squatter wants to live with you. Then this would imply a sharing of the neural substratum, and I think this goes a long way to explain why in full cases of possession the two personalities don’t manifest simultaneously. How would birth occur?
Birth. Say person A is the person who was born by mom and dad, whatever. And then the when the second personality comes in, person b, that person b would be taking rebirth in that other body simultaneously, or it’s just occupying it for a little while? It doesn’t seem to be a rebirth. Yeah.
If it was a rebirth, then person b, the spirit would have to go through a bardo and would have to Would it be there permanently? Yes. It doesn’t seem to be a rebirth, but frankly, don’t know. The cases I have heard of, it’s not a rebirth. Then what you do see in the cases I have personally encountered is in many cases there’s a certain nebulousness.
It is unclear whether food possession has occurred or not. And you see a very distinct change in personal habits. It’s quite striking. One case I know of quite well, someone who is a non smoker and never drinks, always smokes and drinks when possessed. Then this old friend of mine, when possessed, has a clear and very strong paranormal powers, which I personally verified, of the nature of telepathy.
So he could describe someone whom he had never seen and whom I had never met, but had just seen a photo of. And what he described, without our meeting, was in keeping with the picture. So when I met this third party, his description was not in keeping with the third party. So it seems to provide clear evidence that he had access to a mental image in my mind, but did not have access to the reality of the other person. A very clear case over thousands of kilometers, you know.
Then I can only encourage you yourselves to make your own experiences. I know this is quite threatening for quite a few of you. You are moving into a very different universe, very different from the one you’re accustomed to, and the suggestion I would make is to go slowly. Don’t stretch yourself more than is necessary, but I think what I feel I can say in all fairness is that our modern Western outlook is something you hear the Tibetans say very frequently privately in Tibet. It’s very bu sem topa.
It’s very narrow minded. People’s minds are so small, it’s just frightening, you know. Nothing exists out of matter, and and then, obviously, whenever the person comes face to face with something which is completely incompatible with his viewpoint, they run away screaming. Literally, they run away screaming, you know. Then we don’t want you to run away screaming.
Right? So I think this is pretty much it for this morning. We’ll reconvene this afternoon, and this afternoon, we will start trying to draw all this together, make a synthesis, and see how this is linked to Indian schools of thought, and how this might be linked to Buddhist teachings. Thank you very much. So, yes, lunch should be served shortly and it will be a two hour break.
So we’ll just meet just prior to 02:00, ready for the final session. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.