Calm Abiding – 2013-08-10 – KR

1 h 30 min · 11,264 words · 10 August 2013

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding - 2013-08-10 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A talk on calm abiding (shamatha) in the Gelug tradition, drawing on Maitreya, Asanga and Je Tsongkhapa. It covers the definition of calm abiding, the Vairochana seven/eight-point posture, the five faults and eight antidotes, the nine mental abidings, and the dangers of subtle sinking. It ends with a question session on distinguishing calm abiding from insight and on suitable practice conditions.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 30m

UUID: 44b5529d-2365-4e45-ac10-fe9bbf7bf95f

Date: 2013-08-10

Words: 11,260

So of course, for many, Vasily needs no introduction. Our recent guest speaker from Monastery, Khensur Rinpoche, in conversation with our teacher and founder, Khyongla Rato Rinpoche, Khensur Rinpoche said that Rinpoche described Ilya as a yogi among yogis at the level of a Lharampa Geshe, a former monk who has worked tirelessly as a great benefactor for Tibetan Buddhist Institute and kindly acting as a bridge between, to characterize it as, between East and West. We have a binocular view and so we are very privileged to have Ilya to assist us on this topic. I forgot to mention that when His Holiness was here recently, he said Tibetan Buddhist Institute should be engaged in study and like all the monasteries should be learning, places of learning. And then he said, of course, meditation.

So thank you so much, Ilya. Thank you very much. Then I am delighted to see so many old friends here today and I would like to pay a special tribute to a very old friend, a classmate of mine when I was at the University of Virginia, John Powers, who has since become one of the leading scholars of the mind only tradition in the West. Then I’m absolutely delighted that John was able to come to talk at TBI. John has a very preliminary outlook which I feel will complement very nicely our own presentation here.

And as organizer of the symposium my goal has been to present things in as open a way as possible. So we have had input from Graham Meadows and we’ll have further input from him regarding the utilization of Buddhist meditative techniques in a psychotherapeutic, I think I can use the term psychotherapeutic context. John, I assume will present the contemporary quote unquote Buddhological outlook both on meditative practices in Buddhism in general and his own specialty, the Sutra Unraveling the Thought, the Samdhinirmochana sutra and my friend Ralph will flesh out the possible impact Buddhist meditation could have on society to demonstrate that meditation is not a private perhaps even egotistical purpose but instead practice which is of benefit to the community as a whole. In his position as Professor of Finance and former Dean of the faculty at the University of Adelaide, he is uniquely qualified to do this, as well as with his background from the London School of Economics. You all know what the London School of Economics is.

And this has given me the privilege to give what I enjoy most, an extremely square and traditional presentation. So my first talk will be a presentation of the uncommon contribution which Je Tsongkhapa has made to what I call the synthesis of the various traditions of calm abiding. And tomorrow I will be talking about an extremely important and very sensitive topic which is the impact specific Chinese techniques of meditation derived from Chan Buddhism had on Tibetan Buddhism and their survival within Tibetan Buddhism up to the present day where they have continued to inform controversy up to the present day. So without further ado, let us talk about calm abiding. Calm abiding in a nutshell is the minimum of useful concentration.

It is a state of mind in which the mind is single pointedly focused on an object and in which two specific experiences we shall talk about today, physical and mental pliancy, have occurred. Such a state of mind can be defined and actually Jitsun Choki Gilze defines it as calm abiding. The importance of calm abiding or this minimum concentration from a Buddhist standpoint is that it is the minimum but sufficient state of mind in which to transform the cognitive process. The transformation of the cognitive process, in other words of the way we think, is the goal of Buddhist meditation, a transformation of the cognitive process in accordance with reality. So for this reason, sincere Buddhist practitioners throughout the centuries, certainly in the Indian tradition have tried to obtain calm abiding.

This is a fresco of Maitreya in the one of the Ajanta Caves a couple of years ago, relevant basically because so much of the transmission regarding the practice of calm abiding comes from Maitreya. Whether one views him as a Bodhisattva or a Buddha as we do in the Tibetan tradition or as a purported scholar, Maitreya Natha, which seems to be the viewpoint of most western scholars. So in the Samdhinirmochana sutra, Buddha addressing Maitreya defines calm abiding and subdivides it within mundane. In other words, worldly calm abiding, calm abiding which does not have from a Buddhist standpoint a transcendental goal and Supramundane calm abiding. And define specifically calm abiding which I’ve relied here on the translation of the Lamrim Cemo in English, serenity as one pointed attention, qualified as we said by two blissful experiences, I would almost say ecstatic experiences, the experiences of physical and mental pliancy.

When you concentrate, you must concentrate on something and therefore calm abiding must have an object. It has as many objects as there are objects in existence. But clearly, some are more useful than others. And this is something we shall address shortly. Now the crux with calm abiding from a Buddhist standpoint is that it is not a specifically Buddhist practice.

It is a practice which is definitely shared with the Hindu tradition, probably with the Jain tradition and in my personal opinion many of the ecstatic experiences reported by Christian mystics and mystics of the other traditions are none other than experiences of various Samadis perhaps a kin to calm abiding. So the presentation of calm abiding from a Buddhist standpoint is indispensable both for the practitioner of Vedanta for instance and for the practitioner of any of the Buddhist traditions. It is not a specific Buddhist practice. However, there is a specific Buddhist presentation of calm abiding which is rooted in a series of great texts And my focus today shall be on how these texts have merged to form a tradition. Four texts are foundational.

The Samdhinirmochana sutra, a series of addresses of Maitreya Buddha, excuse me, of Buddha Shakyamuni to Maitreya, the Mahayanasutralamkara and the Madhyantavibhaga, which are two of the five treatises attributed to Maitreya and the Shravakabhumi or the stages of the hearers, which is the work of Asanga, Maitreya’s disciple. These four great treatises in the Indian Buddhist tradition all fuse into one core presentation which was introduced in Tibet by Kamalashira, in the context of the Samya debate, which we shall be talking about tomorrow. It is Kamalashila who in turn is the mainstay of Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation of calm abiding in the context of Lamrim Chenmo. So what I shall endeavor to do today is to deconstruct Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation and show its roots and those aspects of Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation which actually don’t seem to be rooted in any specific text of the Indian tradition and which may be rooted in meditative experience which Je Tsongkhapa had or which he knew other meditators had. I shall have to assume that most of you are familiar with Calm Abiding for this presentation because it is not possible to present such a topic in one hour otherwise.

So we have had three different presentations at TBI which I translated and hopefully the broad superstructure is present to your minds. Therefore, I shall not be talking of the preliminaries of Calm Abiding. I just will assume that you know one must dwell in a quiet place without noise in which one can obtain easily the requisites. I shall, however, be talking briefly of the posture to be adopted to show some of the uncommon understandings of the key points of this posture from the standpoint of tantra. Now Rinpoche has told me not to teach tantra at TBI, but this material actually is public material, public domain.

It was mentioned by a great scholar who taught in Hamburg, therefore I feel at liberty to talk about it. So what is the posture to be adopted to gain concentration, to gain calm abiding? It is known as the seven or the eight point posture of Vairochana summarized in this verse attributed to the great Geluk Yogi, Gyelwa Ensapa. Legs, hands and spine make three, brought to form by teeth, lips and tongue. Eye, head, shoulders and breath are four.

These are the eight practices of Vairochana. This is cryptic. Keep in mind this is a stanza which was memorized and which the yogi would recite when sitting into meditation as a rapid check of the posture. If we look at it in a more detailed fashion, the legs must be in Vajrasana, in other words a modified form of the Lotus posture. Both hands in meditative equipoise, four fingers beneath the navel, the spine erect, the mouth in its natural posture with three features of the position of the mouth, teeth in their natural position, lips in their natural position and the tongue touching the palate.

The head must be inclined, the eyes focused on the tip of the nose and open, The shoulders level and the breath loose. The sutra understanding of this posture is that this posture facilitates meditative experience and specifically for appliances. It is what would be called in the Hatha Yoga tradition in India, a Bandha, a lock. It actually locks the body into position. I was privileged enough to have a teacher who had actually attained calm abiding and to actually see him in a state of single pointed meditation and indeed the body needs to be locked.

The posture needs to be a posture such that one cannot fall out of it and one cannot sink because the body becomes from what I saw like that of a dead person. There is actually based on my personal observation no breath whatsoever. Then I did not check closely but Now as we said, the purpose of adopting this posture from the standpoint of the Paramitayana is the facilitation of pliancy. From the standpoint of Tantrayana, there is a much more profound purpose which is that many of the key elements of the posture enable specific winds to enter in the central channel. Then I shall only allude to this today.

Generally speaking, there are 10 winds which according to Anuttara Yoga Tantra circulate within the body, five main winds and five subsidiary winds. These could quite easily be understood as a nervous influx. They are actually seen in the Tibetan tradition as the mount of the mind, the means by which the mind, which is non material, becomes operative. Therefore reading them as a nervous influx, an electrochemical influx is perfectly legitimate in my personal opinion. The key elements in Tantric practice in Anuttara Yoga tantra is through controlling the winds to control the mind.

This is how the mind is controlled. Hence the emphasis in tantra on psychophysiological practices. One can see if one looks at the account given of the benefits of each of the five postures, each of the eight postures that many of them cause specific winds to enter the central channel. The legs in Vajrasana cause what is called the downward voiding wind which controls excretion to enter in the central channel. Hands in position of equipoise, four fingers beneath the navel causes the water wind, the wind associated with the water element to enter the central channel.

The spine which is erect causes the earth wind to enter the central channel and generally speaking allows all winds to enter the central channel easily. And finally, it is said that when the tongue touches the tip of the palate in front of the teeth, Two channels, one in the tongue and one at this point are connected and this has also specific benefits. So I cannot enter into greater detail here but I wanted to mention this to show you that this posture is not merely a culturally conditioned posture to be adopted. There is quite a profound meaning from the standpoint of the traditions which engage in meditation And there are some definite benefits for controlling the mind. I should mention in Apart that it is said that if one cannot enter in Vajrasana, one cannot cause the winds to dissolve in the central channel.

Now, on the basis of what consciousness can calm abiding be attained? This is a very major topic of debate inside and outside the Buddhist traditions. From the standpoint of the Geluk tradition and Je Tsongkhapa’s understanding of it, calm abiding can only be attained on the basis of the mental consciousness. Now when I say can only be attained on the basis of the mental consciousness, I should perhaps have said should only be attained on the basis of the mental consciousness. Because it is clear that there have been cases of practitioners attaining calm abiding using for instance the visual consciousness.

This is practiced to this day in Thailand. My wife’s grandmother is an extraordinary meditator and she has had experiences of attaining calm abiding focusing on the flame of a candle. It was a very interesting conversation we had. Now Je Tsongkhapa says, some after having stared with their eyes at a representation set out in front of themselves immediately engage in meditation. This is invalid from Jetsongkhapa’s standpoint because at this point, calm abiding will have been attained based on a visual consciousness.

So Jetsongkhapa’s position is that of the six sense consciousnesses, five sense consciousnesses, in other words the visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory and tactile sense consciousness and the mental consciousness, only the mental consciousness is the basis on which calm abiding can be attained and it is attained through initially observing an object, any object. It can be a stone, a statue of the Buddha, a flower in the Sarvasvadi tradition. And then after observing the object, desisting from observing it and actually visualizing the object in space at some point in front of oneself with semi open eyes. At this point, one is not using the visual consciousness, one is using the mental consciousness and specifically one is using a conceptual state of mind. In other words, the development of calm abiding is totally conceptual until the actual attainment of calm abiding.

Conceptuality is used as a means to attain the single pointed state of concentration. Geshe Gedun Lodro’s commentary on Calm Abiding which I cannot recommend too strongly, I find it extraordinarily perspicacious, says that the very nature of a mind of calm abiding is a withdrawn state of mind. And this is a very strong argument against calm abiding being developed on the basis of one of the sense consciousness. Because by definition, the sense consciousnesses are outwards focused. Then as I said, there is an ongoing debate.

I certainly know of Buddhist practitioners who have attained calm abiding based on the eye sense consciousness. I don’t know of attaining calm abiding based on any of the other four sense consciousnesses and I have heard of Hindu practitioners attaining it on this basis. I know of at least two Geluk Yogis, my root teacher Geshe Rabten and a close friend of my philosophy teacher at Sera Je, Geshe Yama Rinchen, who both attained calm abiding, this friend of Geshe Yamarinche, just in the last couple of years. Then they attained calm abiding based on Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation, which eliminates many of the risks associated with training in calm abiding. The risks associated with training in calm abiding are not mentioned in the Tibetan tradition simply because the object of observation is very skillfully chosen.

If as we shall see later, one relies on an image of a Buddha as an object of observation, which is Kamalashila’s approach, the risk of physical or mental problems is greatly reduced. Calm abiding however has a very bad reputation in the Theravada tradition, especially in Thailand. It is known as Kasina practice and the consensus of the Theravada teachers is that it is a dangerous practice. It leads often to mental instability or physical problems, in my personal opinion largely because of the choice of the object of observation. The object of observation in Kasina practice is a sphere, often of earth, painted in the color of an element one chooses to meditate upon.

From a Buddhist standpoint, such single pointed focus on the symbol of an element could lead to a disruption of the corresponding element within the body. The practice is often engaged in, certainly within Thailand, for the quick attainment of paranormal powers. But I would like to emphasize and this ties in very much with what Graham was talking about this morning, that in their very nature, Buddhist meditative practices were not designed to eliminate psychological problems as we understand them in the West. They may, and if they are skillfully used, can be brought into the fold of psychiatric practice. But while there may be a definite usage for Satipatthana in controlling the wayward mind, calm abiding as a practice is discouraged for people who have troubled minds.

It tends to intensify the problems. So returning to the differentiation between the mind of calm abiding and the sense consciousnesses, we can see that in the case of calm abiding we are increasing the strength of the mental consciousness and we are decreasing the strength of the sense consciousness. We are following exactly the opposite path if you wish, forgive me the term of animality, and therefore a key feature of the practitioner who has attained Calm Abiding is a sharp reduction in the attraction to sensory objects. Karma binding does not act as an antidote to the afflictions but it leads certainly during the meditation and to a degree after to their suspension. What is the object of observation?

And I wish here to show that this practice may have very well occurred under another name in other traditions. This is Saint Jerome, the Latin translator of the Bible, the Vulgata, contemplating a skull, in other words contemplating death. There are as many objects of meditation as there are practitioners. Then the goal is to choose an object of meditation which is meaningful for practitioner. In other words, an object of meditation which is of some benefit to the practitioner’s mind, specifically which causes the mind to become trauma.

And this depends on the psychological disposition, the temperament of the practitioner. So if we analyze the various temperaments from a Buddhist standpoint, we have some practitioners who have a dominant affliction within their mind stream and some who do not have a dominant affliction. So actually choosing an object of meditation is easier for those who have a dominant affliction which are desire, anger, ignorance, pride or discursiveness. Without a dominant affliction, it is really up to the practitioner to choose whichever object he or she finds is most beneficial. If the practitioner has a dominant affliction, all of the great treatises from the Visuddhimagga all the way through to Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Cemo teach that the object must be an object which counters the affliction.

So for instance, if desire, specifically sexual desire is dominant, one should meditate on the foulness of the human body. If anger is dominant, one should meditate on the direct antidote to anger which is love. If it is ignorance, one should meditate on a difficult topic which makes one more humble. This could be the 12 links, this could be the 18 constituent factors, emptiness would definitely qualify. Pride, also the 18 constituents and discursiveness from the standpoint of the Tibetan, specifically Geluk tradition, one should meditate on the flow of breath, in other words Satipatthana or Anapanasati.

Then since most westerners seem inordinately afflicted with discursiveness, I think for us meditation on breath is extremely helpful. If there is no dominant affliction and this is something the practitioner can only determine for himself, then one chooses whichever objects one wishes, perhaps in keeping with the Samadhi Raja sutra, the representation of a Buddha, since through meditating on the image of a Buddha, one in addition to such meditation gains merit. Then I will choose as object of observation here one which Geshe Rabten Rinpoche taught us based on his own experience which is an uncommon object of observation. It is not an easy object of observation, so it calls for the development not only of concentration but also of the courage, which Graeme alluded to this morning. It is observation, it is meditation on foulness.

In the context of the Abhidhamma Kosha, where it takes the form of meditation on the skeleton and specifically on oneself as a skeleton. This is a very powerful meditation which combines meditation on the foulness of the human body with meditation on death in one powerful package. Then some people are unable to meditate on this. In this case, the mind should be directed towards an easier topic of meditation. Geshe Rabten taught this topic exactly as Vasubandhu describes it in the Abhidharma Kosha.

There are three levels to this practice, that is a beginner of an experienced and of an advanced meditation. A beginner meditates on the bone nature of the universe and does this through visualizing himself seated in meditation and then visualizing the progressive disappearance from a small point between the eyebrows of all skin and flesh until he himself is purely a skeleton sitting in meditation. At which point, this boneness, in other words, the nature of death of the meditator expands progressively outwards. All trees become bone, all the earth becomes bone, mountains become of the nature of bone, until the entire universe is none other but bone. And the meditator focuses on this symbol pointedly.

Then, the meditator retracts the meditation, visualizing that the universe and eventually himself from his feet downwards, up to the top of his forehead become once again fleshed. However, the clear benefit of such a practice is that it leads to the cognitive transformation which is the goal of meditation. In other words, a sharp drop in attachment to sense objects which are all seen as transient, ephemeral and ultimately of the nature of death. Experienced and completed meditators modify this meditation and withdraw the observation until only half of the top of the skull remains. Everything else is fleshed but the skull remains of the nature of bone.

And they can if they choose, go around their daily occupations with this image of themselves. Even more advanced meditators imagine that only a small area at the level of the forehead of the nature of bone remains and focus on this single pointedly. This practice combines a training in shamatha with the focus on an extremely beneficial and meaningful object for those who are afflicted with desire. Clearly it would be much less beneficial for someone whose main affliction is anger. Now, more generally speaking, objects of meditation can be divided between conventional and ultimate objects of meditation.

We shall overwhelmingly focus on training using conventional objects of meditation. It is almost unheard of anyone gaining calm abiding for the first time with an ultimate object of meditation such as emptiness because one is compounding the difficulties. One has a difficulty of attaining calm abiding compounded by the difficulty of understanding the object which is emptiness. Some exceptional practitioners and I believe this was the case of Geshe Raptan, choose an immaterial object of meditation to train calm abiding. In Geshe Raptan’s case it seems to have been the nature of the mind.

Then this has specific advantages because if one can train in calm abiding on an object which is immaterial, one has then prepared oneself for practice in insight on emptiness which is immaterial too. And this practice in which one has attained calm abiding on the nature of the mind amounts to the sutra practice of Mahamudra. It is once again not recommended generally because it is extremely difficult. However, the Samadhi Raja sutra teaches a simple and functional object of meditation for those who are Buddhist, which is just the image of a Buddha. The advantages of this object of meditation are two fold.

There is no imbalance of the elements as associated with the practice of Kasina and the Theravada tradition. And in addition, from a Buddhist standpoint, even if one does not attain calm abiding and none of the westerners I know who have tried to practice this such as our old friend George, George Dreyfus or Alan Wallace have ever attained it. Even if one does not attain calm abiding, one will have become more familiar with the object, the body of a Buddha. This leads to an accumulation of merit and at the time of death, it enables one to focus on the image of a Buddha within the death process. So even if one does not attain one’s goal in meditation, nonetheless, within the death process, sincere Buddhists are able to very clearly bring the Buddha back to mind.

Now, when one starts training in calm abiding, it is critical not to change objects of observation. Changing objects of observation is a major hindrance to the attainment of calm abiding. It slows down or even prevents the attainment of calm abiding. This is, I would say, the consensus teaching of all the practitioners of calm abiding. However, I would like to qualify this here.

There is a specific but limited context in which one should and even must change objects of observation. The goal of the object of observation is to lead to a pacification of the mind, since calm abiding involves an inner withdrawal of the mind. If the object of observation has been badly chosen in the first place, and let us say for someone who is not a sincere Buddhist, the object of observation is the body of a Buddha, and as a person focuses ever more on it, great inner resistance builds up to this. This object of observation is harming the attainment of Karma mind. Then and only in that situation, the person should change objects of observation and they can do so before the attainment of what is known as the third mental level.

After that, it durably harms any attainment in calm abiding. So before engaging in the practice of shamatha, one must be very careful in how one chooses an object observation. Now you will find and I think most of us would like to consider ourselves as fairly subdued persons. But you will find that when you engage either in Sattipattana as Graham was describing it this morning or in calm abiding, that surprising amounts of afflictions arise within your mind. It could be that very powerful lust arises in the mind, it can be that very powerful anger arises in the mind and this seems very difficult to understand.

It basically occurs because when the mind is withdrawn inwards, whatever affliction is dominant in the person’s temperament takes over. So ideally before engaging in a serious practice of calm abiding, one should have some preliminary meditative experience in which one has noticed which of the afflictions floats to the surface during one’s practice. Then one can identify one’s temperament, one’s psychological temperament and choose an object of meditation which in the practice of calm abiding will lead to the abatement of such afflictions. And then the object of meditation contributes to the attainment of the desired state. What are the methods for attaining Karma abiding?

Broadly speaking, there are two different paths, which have been fused in the Tibetan tradition, with tentative fusion occurring in Kamalashila’s stages of meditation. The first we owe unambiguously to Maitreya in his Madhyantavibhaga, it is the practice of the five faults and the eight antidotes. The second is described both by Asanga and by Maitreya, it is the practice of the nine mental abidings. Kamalashila starts the process of fusion of these two practices. We can say it has reached completion in Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo.

We shall start by a description of the process of training the mind through identifying the five faults and applying the eight antidotes. The passage in the Madhyantavibhagga in the fourth chapter which describes it is the following beautiful passage in verse. Functionality in that state leads to all goals. This refers to calm abiding. Abandoning the fivefold with the eight applications arises from the causes taught.

Calm abiding, as those of you who have attended the seminars here know, has specific causes which must be cultivated for its attainment. Now the five faults are described. I assert and I have put them in orange, laziness, forgetting the instruction, thinking and agitation which accounted as one, non application and intemperate application as the five folds. The eight antidotes are described, they are in yellow, dwelling and what dwells, cause and effect, not having forgotten the object, recognizing sinking and agitation, application and entering are the eight antidotes. Now, it is almost certain that you would be unable to attain calm abiding based on these verses alone.

And this is very much part of the Indian tradition that the verses are mnemonic tools for scholars or practitioners who have received the commentary or the explanation of these verses. This explanation is provided in numerous treatises but traditionally is provided by the teacher instructing the disciple. So if we flesh out this stanza to understand precisely how one trains, we have the five faults which we mentioned. I include the Tibetan because some of my students are present here and obviously John is a Tibetan scholar and we can see in the following chart how these five faults are countered by the eight antidotes. Now the first thing you will note is that four antidotes are used to counter the very first thought.

This is a clear indication that the main obstacle to the attainment of calm abiding is this first thought, which is laziness. And laziness here does not refer to what we normally understand as laziness, In other words, just lounging in an armchair watching footy or whatever. It refers actually to the refusal to engage in meditative practice. It could be very advantageously translated in English as resistance, resistance to training. These four antidotes were described in the stanza of the Madhyantavibhanga as dwelling, what dwells cause and effect.

Dwelling refers to faith, the first antidote. Faith in what? Faith in the benefits of calm abiding. One can be a secular materialist and attain calm abiding. The two are not incompatible.

What dwells is aspiration which is the wish to attain calm abiding. The actual cause of calm abiding is enthusiasm which is the main factor which enables one to attain this state. In other words, effort. And the fourth antidote given is pliancy. Pliancy even though it’s mentioned as an antidote to laziness is not applied at the beginning of one’s training since obviously one does not have it.

So here it must be understood as having heard of the benefits of pliancy. The following antidotes are not forgetting the object and here you can see that Maitreya has glossed recollection. I have chosen to translate as recollection the Tibetan term drentha or smriti in Sanskrit, which simply means memory. To gain calm abiding you need a very powerful memory. If your memory is weak it must be trained.

The following antidote is recognizing sinking and agitation. This is vigilance, literally continuous consciousness, Tibetan initiation. The antidote to non application, in other words not applying these previous antidotes is the actual application. This is self evident. And finally, the antidote to intemperate application which occurs when one is very advanced in the approach to calm abiding is desisting from application.

There is a point where the antidotes one has applied so far become part of the problem because one is applying them intemperately, inappropriately when the mind is actually concentrated in a stable and continuous fashion on the object of observation. At this point one should stop from applying the antidotes. So you can see that this presentation of calm abiding in the light of the Madhyantavibhaga is an extraordinarily powerful one in my opinion it is actually clearer than Asanga’s presentation in terms of the nine mental abidings. You have five thoughts and eight antidotes. Four antidotes are applied at the beginning and each of the remaining thought has its respective antidote.

If you understand this, you will attain calm abiding if you put the effort. Then we shall talk somewhat about laziness and its antidotes. Laziness is understood in a far broader sense here than our common understanding of the term. It includes the laziness of neutral deeds which would refer to going shopping instead of meditating. The laziness attached to bad deeds, any deed which troubles the mind and leads it to afflictions, desire, hatred and so forth and a very major obstacle which is discouragement.

Which can be read perhaps as inordinate expectations from oneself. It seems to afflict western students more than the Tibetans I have known for some reason. Perhaps we have high expectations and perhaps we have more pride in those who are raised in humble cultures and who have had all their life to bow to others. I am no judge in the matter but I have just been struck over and again by the fact that discouragement and obviously more advanced stages of discouragement such as depression seem to be very specific western problem which I, for instance, have seldom encountered in the Tibetan community in exile and have almost never encountered in India. Now as you remember, the second of the five thoughts is forgetting the instructions and instructions here don’t refer to what was taught but the actual object of meditation.

One’s mind as is in this picture follows the object until one ends up in one big nebulous fog and one has forgotten the pose. Then, we have a very nice definition here of recollection or memory by Bhavaviveka and vigilance which is the sentinel which stands guard on the mind. In his Heart of Madhyamika, Bhavaviveka says, after binding securely the wayward elephant of the mind with the rope of recollection to the firm pillar of the object of observation, one will overpower it gradually with the hook of wisdom. This is really the crux of training in shamatha. The mind in its present state is compared to a wayward elephant.

It must be bound by memory, recollection, memory of one object which one has chosen. The object of observation is the object chosen. And the mind is overpowered and this is an uncommon trait of the quote of the Madhyamaka Hridaya, the mind is overpowered by the hook of wisdom. All the other stances on training and calm abiding speak of the hook of vigilance. So clearly, Bhavaviveka’s uncommon position regarding vigilance is that it is a form of wisdom.

It is a form of wisdom which discriminates between agitation and sinking and is able to open the gateway to countering agitation and sinking. Now if we enter into greater detail in an understanding of recollection and vigilance, Recollection is defined by Vasubandhu as that which does not allow the mind to scatter. In other words, memory. While vigilance is that which understands the mind’s having scattered. If these two factors are present in one’s training, one will be able to progress up to the attainment of calm abiding.

If one has the mental factor which understands whether the mind has scattered or not and the mental factor which focuses on the object, calm abiding, will eventually be attained. Then Asanga in his great treatise on Abhidharma fleshes on Vasubandhu’s definition. As you know, Asanga and Vasubandu were half brothers, many beautiful stories regarding their relationship and sometimes when one reads their treatises, one has the impression that they are almost in a continuous dialogue with each other. Asanga says that recollection, in other words memory, is the non forgetfulness of a familiar thing. Two things are critical in this understanding of recollection.

Non forgetfulness, which is a factor of mental strength, and familiarity. One cannot remember what one has not become familiar with. Therefore, before engaging in the practice of calm abiding, one must become thoroughly familiar with the object of observation. One must have, let’s say in the case of the Buddha statue, have observed it over and again until one understands all its factors. If one does not understand all its factors, the mental factor of recollection cannot be brought into play.

Returning to our list of the five thoughts, you can see that the third thought is sinking and agitation. They have respective antidotes and I could not help but feel that this painting described very aptly the state of the mind beset by sinking and agitation. A ship on a stormy sea desperately trying to reach port. And obviously the captain of the ship must have a clear understanding of the seas he is sailing. This is an understanding of sinking and agitation and you do hope that the captain of the ship has clear plans about going to a specific port because if he doesn’t, everyone is in very big trouble and this is shamatha, the goal to be attained.

So Asanga defines agitation in his Compendium of Ascertainment as a mental factor which is connected to desire and this is the key element of agitation. When agitation arises in the mind when one is focused on an object of meditation, this agitation arises because of desire for something else. The first thing after identifying what is occurring within the mind is to see what this agitation or desire is desired for. Then if it continues, it is possible to counter it very forcefully. How does one counter agitation?

Since agitation, as Asanga said, is of the nature of desire, one counters it by bringing the mind down. The mind is too elevated, its intensity, its as Tibetan say is too high, one brings it down through focusing on impermanence, on death. I cringe to say this in front of the gram but one tries to make the mind a bit depressed Because it is fluffy. It is frothy. It is agitated.

And then if one wants to be very forceful in the matter, one applies it to the thoughts of impermanence of the object of agitation. Let us say, if for instance, dreams of the latest Audi arise in the mind of the gentleman in this room who will focus in on the Gudu statue. Then after focusing the mind on the fact that that Audi is going to get rusty in a couple of years, you might focus the mind on the garage bills and the taxes you will have to pay. It is guaranteed to bring the mind down quite sharply. And then after that, you can refocus your mind on the object of observation.

Now in this matter, I think we owe a lot to Je Tsongkhapa who pointed out that war education is very clearly described in all the great Buddhist treatises. It is not, there is not a clear description or a clear account of sinking. Jetsongkhapa attempts to clarify the nature of sinking. The main debates in Tibet regarding calm abiding related to sinking, to the decrease in mental intensity. There was no disagreement regarding core sinking, where the mind actually basically loses the object of observation in a torpor.

But many great Tibetan yogis considered that a very subtle form of sinking, what was identified as a very subtle form of thinking by Je Tsongkhapa was actually an extraordinary state of meditation which they described as single pointed focus with no effort. Then it is really the uncommon contribution of Je Tsongkhapa’s understanding of karma binding to have clarified the thoughts of this subtle thinking. Subtle thinking, we’ll talk about it a bit later, manifests as a clear focus on the object of observation, which appears clearly, in which however the mind lacks a modicum of clarity. And one is convinced that one has very good concentration. There is no agitation.

If one continues to train the mind with such subtle thinking present, it leads to a progressive but steady decline of all the cognitive faculties and specifically of memory. A very clear sign and unfortunately I have seen this with westerners training in calm abiding, that calm abiding is being trained incorrectly is when the memory of the person starts declining and the mind becomes more and more fuzzy. When this happens, the person is confusing, subtle thinking and karma binding. Then this eventually leads to a state of befuddlement. Hence the very great danger of such practice.

So I won’t enter too much in the details of the various forms of reduction of mental intensity. They are clearly explained by some of the later Tibetan commentators such as Jamil Shepa, suffice it to say that the one which is the most important for us is sinking or Qingwa. Others are identified such as lethargy and dishearteness. Kamala Shila whom we mentioned as the great Indian scholar who ushered the teachings of calm abiding into Tibet, mentioned sinking but no mention is made of subtle sinking. And therefore I personally feel that the identification of subtle sinking and the analysis of its thoughts is a specific contribution Je Tsongkhapa made to the understanding of sinking.

Ojjat Sungkapa, in his usual clear style, defines sinking as a mind which has simply lost its object of apprehension. Sinking occurs when you were focusing on the object of meditation and it simply is no longer there. You are in a nebulous state unaware of what you are clearly doing. Such meditation increases ignorance. To put it very bluntly, I hope you will forgive me for using the term, it increases one’s stupidity.

Much of the meditation the way young westerners practice it nowadays seems to lead to a decline of cognitive faculties. This is incorrect practice of meditation. Meditation correctly practiced should lead to a sharp enhancement of mental faculties. The sign of good shamatha practice is a sharp increase in memory. This is why the very great practitioners seem never to suffer from diseases such as Alzheimer’s which affect so many westerners.

So what are the antidotes to sinking? If the practitioner is fairly uneducated in the teachings, one just focuses on a bright object, any bright object. One could just imagine the sun, it elevates the mind. If however, the practitioner has an understanding of the finer points of the teachings, one can focus on the clear light nature of the mind. So in a nutshell, we can see that stable concentration occurs between agitation and sinking.

The identification of coarse agitation and coarse sinking is quite straight forward once vigilance has been developed. However, it is necessary to identify also subtle agitation and subtle thinking to be able to generate stable and clear concentration and this identification is only possible if one clearly understands what they are. Subtle agitation is quite straight forwards to understand, subtler thinking is not because it looks, if one is inexperienced, like a very good meditative session. So what are the features of these various states? Traditionally in the Gelug tradition, we distinguish four mental factors which qualify calm abiding with a fifth which is the sign of the attainment of calm abiding.

These four factors are stability, limpidity, clarity and intensity. It’s a bit like a four dimensional space. The object of meditation is in a four dimensional space and each of these factors must be fully present. You must have full stability, in other words when you focus on the object, you can see the object and when subtle agitation begins sometimes you will have the sense that the object is vibrating. This is a sign of subtle agitation.

Whereas when subtle sinking appears, you will have a sense of decline in the limpidity or the luminosity of the object. You must have limpidity, which is the full appearance of all the features of the object. You must have clarity, which is not luminosity but there is almost a component of luminosity present and you must have intensity. If these four are present, the mind is close to the attainment of calm abiding. It might be actually on the ninth mental abiding.

Once pliancy which is an uncommon sense of physical and mental bliss arise, the mind will have attained calm abiding. Now you can see with the ninth mental abiding all of these factors but pliancy are present, whereas when coarse agitation is present, stability is gone and limpidity is only partial, with clarity and intensity present, and when coarse sinking is present, only stability is present. The object is totally unclear and is just surrounded as it were by a fog. Then understanding subtle agitation and subtle sinking is much more complex. In subtle agitation it is part of the factor stability which is affected and in subtle sinking it is part of the factor of limpidity and clarity which are affected.

This chart is very much the product of the oral tradition as I have heard it from my teachers. You will not find this in any text. It’s also the product of my own limited understanding of these topics. There are ongoing debates on this matter and I can only refer to the experience of those who have gained calm abiding. So I feel a bit like the proverbial figure in the Samadhi Raja sutra who hails the qualities of sandalwood at a marketplace and says that sandalwood is the most exquisite of woods with the most marvelous of fragrances which cools all the heat.

And finally, bystander comes up to him and says, venerable merchant, do you have this sandalwood which you hail so highly? I would like to purchase some. And the merchant must admit shamefacedly, I have no such sandalwood to sell. So this is a bit my situation in talking to you about calm abiding. Then one small point which I personally find extremely interesting in one of Sthiramati’s commentary on Maitreya’s Madhyantavibhaga is the identification of memory as the cause of vigilance.

In other words, memory and vigilance from the standpoint of Stiramati are not equal in their weight. Without memory, there can be no vigilance. Vigilance actually is the result of memory. It is an effect of memory. Then this is something one should check-in one’s own practice.

The second presentation of calm abiding is that in turn of the nine mental abidings which is adopted or presented both by Maitreya and Asanga. So if we look in Maitreya’s Mahayanasutralamkara at the verses which describe the nine mental abidings, we can see that there are nine verses, in some cases stanzas, which give the features of each of the mental abiding leading up to calm abiding. Focusing, continually, patching, subduing, pacifying, pacifying even more, dwelling within, the ninth stage no application. The ninth stage is still not calm abiding. Each, I have numbered them for convenience, they are not numbered obviously in the Tibetan text, but each of these sections refers to one stage in the generation of calm abiding and they have given the name through the famous chart which I think has been handed out to you.

Each of the mental abidings is known by the keyword in Maitreya’s Mahayanasutralamkara. So if we enter in detail in an analysis of each of the mental abiding, in the first mental abiding, the mind can actually find an object. So if when you start meditating, nothing appears to the mind, you are not at the level of the first mental abiding. However, the first mental abiding is discontinuous. In other words, this application is actually interrupted.

A feature for all those who engage in such practice is a notable increase in conceptuality. This is simply because conceptuality is noticed for the first time. The main obstacles and the antidotes are those which we described in the account of Maitreya’s training according to the five folds in the eight antidotes. The second mental abiding is also discontinuous, as the first one but the mind settles longer on its object and as a result of this conceptual activity discursiveness seems to decrease. This is a sign of increasing pacification of the mind.

In the third mental abiding, the mind can be easily reset on its object. The mind is still discontinuous in its focus on the object of observation. We have still the same main obstacles and the same main antidotes which we had previously. The main obstacles are laziness and forgetfulness and the main antidotes during the first three mental abidings are faith aspiration, exertion and recollection. Slide one: one starts training in common abiding, one can start in function of one’s own capacities for concentration at any of these three levels.

Specifically, if laziness and forgetfulness are absent, one will have started immediately at the very end of the third level, almost at the fourth level. There are practitioners who because of previous habituation to come abiding are able to do this. Others don’t even start at the first level. There is no object which appears to the mind when they try to meditate. I think more than half of the westerners I have talked to don’t even start at the first level.

In other words, when they try to visualize, there is nothing. Then the person is not even on the path of training of calm abiding. At the level of the fourth mental abiding, the mental focus is continuous. The object is no longer lost. This is the fundamental switch between the third and the fourth level.

It’s at this point that agitation and sinking become obstacles. Until then, one is just trying to prevent the continuum of concentration from being severed. It’s at this point that vigilance enters the picture. Before, the mind is simply too coarse for either recollection or vigilance to be fully effective. At the level of the fifth mental abiding, the so called power of vigilance is generated.

In other words, vigilance comes into its full. At this point there is no longer any coarse sinking or coarse agitation present. If they were to occur, they would be immediately subdued. It is at this point that subtle sinking becomes critical and in Je Tsongkhapa’s opinion this is the level which many of the previous meditators in Tibet attained and then stayed at, training as it were in subtle sinking. Then the accounts we have had and some of the cases I have actually met, all describe people who become very kindly but somewhat bemused.

Bemused, befuddled, confused because the power of memory is dwindling. This is a clear sign that one is probably, if one is training in calm abiding, at the level of the fifth mental abiding and subtle thinking is actually becoming very powerful within the mind. Eventually this subtle thinking will lead to core thinking which is certainly not a situation you want to be in if you are involved in mental training. During the sixth mental abiding, the problem is the opposite. The intensity, what depends on height of the mind becomes too great.

Coarse agitation is not present but subtle agitation is present. This manifests by the object of meditation becoming brilliant. It seems to be brighter than it was before. If one understands that subtle agitation is involved, this can be countered. It is far less of a danger than subtle sinking.

During the seventh mental abiding, the power of effort, in other words, has come to its full and there is no longer a risk of either subtle sinking or subtle agitation. In the eighth mental abiding, one merely has to put a little bit of effort at the beginning of the session to focus the mind on the object and from this point on the focus is uninterrupted with neither subtle sinking nor subtle agitation. Whereas in the ninth mental abiding, effort is not necessary to focus the mind on the object of meditation, and there is neither sinking nor agitation, coarse nor subtle. However, the ninth mental abiding is not calm abiding. And this is very clear if you look at Asanga’s presentation of the four attentions, it’s a very powerful way of understanding these nine stages.

During the first two mental abidings, one engages through concentration. In other words, powerful effort from the side of the practitioner is required to put the mind on the object of meditation. Then from the third to the seventh, the mind, this is the feature of the attentions, is interrupted. First interrupted in terms of its continuum during the third repeated placement and then interrupted as we said by coarse and subtle agitation, excuse me, by coarse agitation and coarse sinking and then by coarse subtle agitation and subtle sinking. It’s at the level of the eighth mental abiding that the mind engages uninterruptedly with neither agitation nor sinking and at the level of the ninth that no exertion is necessary.

I hope this clarifies the nine mental abidings. However, the attainment of the ninth mental abiding is not calm abiding. And this is made very clear in the Samdhinirmochana sutra. Bhagavan for so long as a bodhisattva places his mind, the mind which is observing without having observed physical and mental pliancy, for so long what is that called? Maitreya that is not calm abiding.

It is a mind which is concordant with calm abiding. In other words, it is a mind which will usher calm abiding. So what is calm abiding? This is a depiction of a Sangha accompanying Maitreya to Tushita but I feel it could be a beautiful metaphor for the bliss of pliancy which arises within the mind when one feels the experience of pliancy. It is said one feels as if one is flying.

At the level of the ninth mental abiding, eventually an omen, an indicator of pliancy will arise followed by mental and physical pliancy and the blisses which accompany them leading to the state of calm abiding. All of these elements are necessarily present but not necessarily with the same intensity. The omen of pliancy is a sign that pliancy is on the point of arising. It has been described by those who have experienced it as either the sensation of a warm hand on a shaved scalp or the feeling that the brain itself within the brain pan is becoming heavy. There are specific explanations for this which I shall not enter into here.

Are linked actually to the presence of channels or the absence thereof within the brain. But there is an ongoing debate in the Indian tradition regarding the nature of physical pliancy, not regarding the nature of mental pliancy. The Indian and the Tibetan tradition together are in full agreement that mental pliancy is a mental experience, but in the Indian tradition there is a strong school and I am very sympathetic to it which feels that physical pliancy is also a mental experience. However, Sthiramati who was one of the main transmitters of the commentaries on the Madhyat of Ibarga to Tibet is of the opinion that it is not, that it is a tangible material form and this is the dominant opinion in the Gelug tradition with which as I have said I am somewhat uncomfortable. And the synthesis of these two broad strands of explanations of how to attain calm abiding, attaining calm abiding through eliminating the five thoughts by the eight antidotes and through the nine mental abidings is synthesized in the charts you have frequently seen.

This is one I translated from the Central Institute of Higher Tibetan Studies in Varanasi. It’s one of the better ones because actually the author was quite learned in the field. He dedicated his thesis to the translation of the Bhavanakama or should I say the critical edition first of the Bhavanakama. However, these are generally not relied upon in the Tibetan tradition by those who seriously wish to attain karma binding. Instead, they will actually rely on the root texts and the commentaries because these charts are considered as interpretations and one is somewhat at the mercy of the understanding of the artist.

So what is Je Tsongkhapa’s uncommon slant, uncommon contribution? One of the key points Je Tsongkhapa makes is that having attained calm abiding, one is no longer included within beings of the desire realm. One has become a being of one of the higher realms. The attainment of pliancy and calm abiding associates one as it were to beings of the higher realms. And it is this which explains the unobstructedness of the body of one who has attained calm abiding.

It is said in calm abiding that it is possible to travel through walls. And I have no direct experience of this. I think I would have found it very disturbing had I had. But I have had first hand experience of the medically unexplainable capacities of a practitioner engaged in calm abiding. I was a direct witness with a Swiss neurologist.

From Jetsongpa’s standpoint, calm abiding in and of itself is insufficient. Calm abiding must be followed by the practice of insight, which is a practice of analysis within the flow of calm abiding, Where the flow of the mind focused on its object remained and within this there is an inner core, a bit as in a coaxial conductor if anyone of you is electronically inclined. You have an outer shield that would be calm abiding, right, focused on, let us say, the new object emptiness and an inner core which is the inner conductor which is engaged in analysis. Now this component of analysis must be small, otherwise it interferes with the focus. So Je Tsongkhapa quoting the Samadhi Raja sutra points out that calm abiding in and of itself cannot lead to liberation.

This is the core of the disagreement between the ancient Buddhist schools and many of the Indian schools which were widespread at the period. Buddha’s teacher Udraka Ramaputra is said to have attained concentrations which led to rebirth in one of the formless realms. These realms are considered in the Indian tradition as forms of moksha, of liberation. They are not from the Buddhist standpoint. From the Buddhist standpoint, this mind of karma binding must be focused on selflessness for liberation to be possible.

And the criterion for this mind focused on selflessness and engaged in analysis of selflessness attaining what is known as insight or vipassana is the arising of a pliancy within analysis and as a result of analysis. We do not have time here to enter into the characteristics of insight or vipassana. I would point out in a nutshell that the difference between calm abiding and insight is that in the attainment of calm abiding, pliancy is generated as a result of concentration. In the attainment of insight, pliancy is the result of analysis. It is not the result of concentration.

So if one has shamatha and one focuses shamatha on emptiness, that does not qualify in and of itself as insight. Even if pliancy is present, because the pliancy has not arisen from the analysis of the object which is emptiness. Then this completes an extremely brief presentation of abiding and I apologize to those of you who have not attended the seminars here on calm abiding. It must be quite steep indeed but there was no time to enter into the preliminaries for the attainment of calm abiding. To the others I apologize for taking so much time from the half hour question session but we have some ten minutes and I’ll do my best to answer your questions at present.

Yes please. The distinction Je Tsongkhapa makes between calm abiding and insight in other words shamatha and vipassana is that the attainment of shamatha involves pliancy both physical and mental which arises as a result of concentration. The attainment of insight involves pliancy both physical and mental which arise as a result of analysis. Therefore, calm abiding and insight are two radically different types of meditation. Then there is an ongoing debate to know whether it is necessary to attain calm abiding before insight or not.

It doesn’t seem to be but the consensus is that that is the majority the forms of practice. Do you have other questions? Then we have to distinguish between just increasing one’s concentration or actually planning on obtaining calm abiding. It’s two very different things. Increasing your concentration, the best is to practice just after waking in the morning.

It is the best time. Your mind is very clear. You know, you can hope for good results. You will not be able to attain calm abiding if you practice in that way. To attain calm abiding, you must radically change lifestyles.

You must live basically as a hermit with no necessity to work and no type of external distraction. A guaranteed food supply, water supply and most importantly no noise. Biggest obstacle to any type of concentration is noise. And then once those preconditions are assembled, you have to engage in a large number of very short sessions of meditation a day. A minimum of 18 sessions of five minutes.

Even less than five minutes. Your goal is totally different from that of someone who is just trying to improve concentration or doing analytical meditation. Your goal is to have a perfect meditation session and you make it as short as is necessary to have that. If you can keep concentration on your chosen object, only one or two minutes, you do that. The moment you lose the object, you stop, make a pause.

When you return, after a couple of minutes, you do another session. This is not compatible with family life. Ideally, one should engage in training in calm abiding as a monk, because calm or non. Calm abiding involves withdrawing the mind inwards, out from the senses. So if one cannot pacify coarse sensuality, it is not possible to train the mind in calm abiding.

So those are the two rules. Does that answer your question? Are there other questions? You can definitely start training in calm abiding. I would strongly encourage memorization.

Memorization is used in the monasteries as a preliminary form of mental training. We memorized anything between a verse or two a day to four pages a day. I reached one page a day and this develops the power of recollection. So later on when you wish to engage in a meditative retreat, your memory is very powerful. Yes, Natalie.

Yes, it is. I think there are three points. The first is really one should practice under the guidance of a teacher, a teacher who has himself attained calm abiding. But you can count them on the fingers of one hand in the Gaduk tradition. It’s a great privilege to have such a teacher because this is someone who has actually been there and who knows what the signs are.

If that is not possible, one should study very carefully the texts in which subtle sinking is described and this especially the section on calm abiding of Lamrim Cemo, the great treaties of the stages of the path, which is basically very well translated into English. So I would heartily recommend it to you. Then there is a third approach. If you have not access to a teacher and the signs of subtle sinking during the practice are not clear, check the impact over time of your practice on your mind. If over the weeks, the months and the years, your mind is becoming more dull, this is a sign of very very bad practice.

It’s a clear sign of coarse or subtle sinking. At this point one should stop and one should consult a teacher who is able to identify what is going on and correct one’s practice. The signs of a dull mind is our forgetfulness, incapacity to follow a line of reasoning, what we would call being befuddled, being benighted. The practice of karma abiding eventually leads to the attainment of what is known as the Dharani of memory, to perfect photographic memory. If you have calm abiding, you will never forget anything.

You have the power of memory. My teacher Geshe Rabten had memorized 3,500 pages in Tibetan. Most of the Tibetan Geshe Rabhten have to recite what they have memorized every day. Geshe Raptan recited once a year and he would gather all the other Geshe’s in his room. It took one week for him to recite and they were there with a text in front of them checking what he had recited.

So clearly he had the Dharani of Memory. Does that answer your question? Well, it’s a great critic which Sakya Pandita addresses to certain forms of the Mahamudra tradition known as the single white remedy. That they basically stop training in calm abiding at the level of the fifth mental abiding. The practitioners are therefore training their minds in subtle sinking.

Now from a Buddhist standpoint, this leads to rebirth as an animal. Then I personally feel it is really absurd to put a lot of effort in one’s practice to be reborn as a cow in the next life. You might as well not do anything and perhaps be still reborn as a human being. So if practice leads to a bad rebirth, then this is really meaningless. You could go to the beach.

Analytical meditation is what is of great benefit to all of us from the beginning. You cannot go wrong with analytical meditation on the stages of the path. With calm abiding you can go very wrong and with Tantric practice you can go very wrong indeed. A Tantric practice for instance which I think is the case for most westerners, which is not rooted in the three principles of the path where there is no renunciation, there is no understanding of bodhichitta and there is no understanding whatsoever of emptiness, leads as Jeffrey pointed many years ago, in a very good article, to inflation. Inflation of the ego.

So if one thinks that one tantric practice means thinking I am a god or as some poor lady thinks I am a goddess, one is very much on the wrong track. His holiness was extraordinarily blunt on this in Dharam Sala when he gave the transmission of Kalachakra Mandala and he said, Tantric practice in which one thinks I am a god is wrong practice. If one is not able to generate a wisdom realizing selflessness and to understand how it is possible to impute on the basis of that wisdom a name, an identity, one should not engage in deity yoga. Deity yoga increases the ego. Then increasing the ego is precisely what we are trying to avoid.

So for us, what is really of benefit is analytical meditation. Analytical meditation on basic elements. I think the most beneficial meditation for all of all is meditation in impermanence. It counters the eight worldly concerns. It cannot be of harm.

Does that help? Then it is 12 sharp. If anyone has an urgent question, I’ll be happy to take it. Otherwise, I think lunch is calling.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
central channel sushumna or avadhuti (Skt); tsa uma (Tib)
The central channel runs from the crown of the head to the secret chakra. It is the major energy channel of the vajra body, and is visualized as a hollow tube of light in front of the spine. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Tushita Ganden (Tib)
The Joyous Land. There are two Tushita realms. One is the pure land of the thousand buddhas of this eon, where the future buddha, Maitreya, and Lama Tsongkhapa reside. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top