Awakening Heart – 2013-11-20 – KR

1 h 5 min · 2,986 words · 20 November 2013

Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart - 2013-11-20 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching opens with the benefits of bodhichitta, the difficulty of generating it, and the practice of exchanging self and others. It then comments on stanzas 23 and 24 of the Catalogue of the Stages of the Path, explaining that concentration alone cannot sever the root of cyclic existence and that insight into emptiness is required. The speaker outlines the four key points of the syllogism for realising that phenomena lack inherent existence, using the example of a vase.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 6m

UUID: ba3b1522-3ec0-4c5e-95df-2dba3fc93358

Date: 2013-11-20

Words: 2,982

As is said in the Bodhisattvacharyavatara, there is no virtue whose results are greater than the generation of bodhichitta. The reason for this is that the virtues which are not upheld by bodhichitta eventually reach their extinction. Whereas, virtues which are upheld by bodhichitta are inextinguishable. Why is this the case? This is the case because the basis for the generation of bodhichitta is immeasurable.

It is the immeasurable sentient beings. Therefore, since the basis is immeasurable, a mind generated on that basis is also immeasurable. In addition, the object of attainment of bodhichitta for enlightenment is also inconceivable. This in turn entails that bodhichitta itself is almost infinite in its vastness. Finally, its function is to eliminate the totality of suffering of sentient beings.

The totality of suffering of the beings of the six realms is well nigh inconceivable. It is for this reason that bodhichitta is so powerful. Another reason for which such a mind is of extraordinary benefit and gives rise to tremendous mental fortitude is because one takes the resolve to help not one sentient being but all sentient beings without exception. It is difficult already to take the resolve to help one sentient being, but here the resolve is taken to help oneself, all sentient beings without exception. We say we practice the Mahayana, the great vehicle, then if that is so, we should train in bodhichitta.

What is our condition at present? We can barely support the scratch of a pin on our forearm. Imagine what it would be like to support immeasurable tears and rends of one’s bodies for the sake of all sentient beings. Yet, this is the motivation we must generate. The great Kadampa Geshe used to say, take all hardship upon oneself, give all benefit to others.

While it may not be possible to do this, this is nonetheless how one should train because if one trains in this way, indeed over time, bodhichitta will increase. And therefore, instead of considering ourselves foremost and others as subsidiary, we should consider others as foremost and ourselves as subsidiary. At present this is very difficult for us to do, since we automatically consider ourselves as foremost due to strong previous habituation from former lives. But this is to be countered, if we do this, then through the practice of the interchange of self and others, we can progressively develop bodhichitta. Then this is somewhat easier to do for those to whom we are related.

We find it easier to sacrifice ourselves for our relatives. But when it comes to people who are completely unknown to us, to whom we are completely unrelated, when we are expected to do something for them, our immediate reaction is to say, who precisely are you to me? Why should I bother? This is the case, isn’t it? It is difficult enough to generate a state of mind with respect to one person, let alone to generate such a state of mind towards infinite beings.

Then we can see for ourselves that in this very life, these states of mind seldom if ever arise, they only arise towards our relatives. And when it comes to people towards whom we feel hostility, we have no interest whatsoever in helping them. Even though Bodhichitta therefore is of great benefit, it is extraordinarily difficult for us to generate. Then we fold our hands and with a modulated expression recite, may all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering, may all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. But these are mere words And for these words to go anywhere else than our mouth and to actually be present as meaning within our minds, this is extremely difficult.

Then it is not the case that activities such as trying to train our minds as best we can in refuge, in an understanding of the four immeasurables, in bodhichitta and so forth, has no result. It does have a result, but we should not expect extravagant results. For ourselves the results will be small and they will occur over time. Then it is quite tragic if one thinks, oh, the results are so small, I can’t be bothered to practice. Or like some people, oh, I have obtained an excellent session, I don’t need to practice anymore.

And therefore, there is no other way for us to generate bodhichitta but to practice, to train in bodhichitta whenever we have a moment. This is the only way it will happen. And it is precisely because of the importance of bodhichitta that Buddha Shakyamuni taught wherever he could the importance of bodhichitta as the foundation of practice. Therefore, let us meditate shortly or briefly, on the following motivation. I vow at present to listen to the teaching on the stages of the path, animated by a bodhichitta which wishes to attain full enlightenment, not for my own sake, but for the sake of all sentient beings with the intent of setting them themselves in that state after generating bodhichitta within their minds.

So we have at present reached stanza 23 of the Catalogue of the Stages of the Path. Wisdom is the eye beholding profound suchness, The path casting away the root of existence from the root. The treasure of qualities praised in all scriptures, renowned as a supreme lamp dispelling the gloom of benightedness. Understanding this wise yearning for liberation, give rise to this path with numerous efforts. I, the yogis, have practiced thus, you too, who wish for liberation, should wish to act thus.

This stanza explains the qualities of emptiness. Previously, the practice of concentration was explained and this stanza underlines that concentration itself is insufficient, insight is also required. The first verse, wisdom is the eye beholding profound suchness is to be understood as follows: profound suchness refers to emptiness. Here wisdom is compared to an eye which beholds emptiness because it is with an eye that we can see phenomena, without an eye we are blind. The following two verses or two lines are to be understood as follows, the path casting away the root of existence from the root refers to the root of existence, existence here is psychic existence, and the path which extirpates the root of existence from the root is what is praised in the following line, the treasure of qualities praised in all scriptures.

Renowned as a supreme lamp dispelling the gloom of benightedness. Benightedness here refers to ignorance, and wisdom is compared to a lamp which dispels the darkness of ignorance. Understanding this, the wise yearning for liberation gives rise to this past with numerous efforts. And the last three lines indicate that not only has Jetsun Tsongkhapa himself practiced in this way, so should we. The following stanza, stanza 24, the yogis who seeing that mere single pointed contemplation is unable to sever the root of psychic existence and that irrespective of how much a wisdom bereft of the path of calm abiding analyzes, unable to counter the afflictions, After setting that wisdom decisively assessing the mode of being or the motionless steed of calm abiding with a sharp sword which cognizes the middle lacking extremes, the wisdom of vast correct analysis destroying all targets of observation grasping at extremes enhances the intelligence realizing suchness.

I, the yogi, have practiced thus, you too, who wish for liberation, should wish to act thus. The two first lines of stanza 24, the yogis who seeing that mere single pointed contemplation is unable to sever the root of psychic existence, refers to the fact that single pointed contemplation, in other words dhyana, which is focused on emptiness alone, is insufficient to sever the root of cyclic existence. The mind which actually realizes emptiness is an inferential valid cognizer. This inferential valid cognizer arises initially in dependence on the wisdom arisen from hearing, after that the wisdom arisen from contemplation and from reflection, and finally this gives rise to the wisdom arisen from meditation. The following two lines, irrespective of how much a wisdom bereft of the path of calm abiding analyzes, ’tis unable to counter the afflictions, refers to the fact that a mere insight focused on emptiness which is bereft of calm abiding in and of itself is incapable of countering the afflictions.

After setting that wisdom decisively assessing the mode of being on the emotionless steed of calm abiding with the sharp sword which cognizes the middle lacking extremes, the wisdom of vast correct analyses destroying all targets of observation grasping at extremes enhances the intelligence realizing such ness. This is how the yogi practiced, this is how we should practice. And in this stanza, what is referred to is the process of generation of the wisdom realizing emptiness. This wisdom realizing emptiness is an inferential valid cognizer, an Anumana Pramana, which realizes emptiness. An inferentially valid cognizer arises initially in dependence on the wisdom arisen from hearing, and in dependence on this upon the wisdom arisen from thinking.

It however arises independence on numerous lines of reasoning, numerous means in other words, it doesn’t just arise spontaneously. And this occurs through a realization of the four key points in the syllogism. This subject lacks inherent existence because it is neither inherently one nor inherently multiple. In the context of such a syllogism, these four key points are first an understanding of the key points of the object of refutation, then an understanding of the pervasion or the necessary entailment, then an understanding of both inherent unity and inherent multiplicity, and finally an understanding of their refutation. This is a difficult topic.

So if you have not studied a lot, will be hard to understand. Please listen carefully. So the first of these key points is the ascertainment of the object of negation. The object of negation here is inherent existence or true existence, and while true existence is a non existent, nonetheless it does appear to the mind. It is this mind to which true existence appears which must be eliminated through the refutation of its object of negation.

This is how we should proceed. As is said in Bodhisattvacharyavatara, permanent entities do not exist, and therefore it is when we are able to eliminate the mind to which permanent entities appear that we will have progressed on the path. And therefore, the first step to engage in this practice is for the object of refutation to appear to the mind. If the object of refutation does not appear to the mind, it cannot be negated, in the self same way as if one doesn’t see the target, one cannot shoot at it. So we can use in this matter the simile of apprehending a thief.

If you want to capture a thief, you must have an exact description of the criminal. Otherwise, if you say to your friends, grab the thief, it’s a man wearing white clothes. This is not going to help a lot, because many people do wear white clothes. So you must have a very precise description of the thief, his characteristics and so forth, before you can hope to capture him. And therefore, phenomena do not exist in the way in which they appear to exist to us.

Now generally speaking, there are three modes of appearance of phenomena to beings. We have phenomena appearing as mere nominal imputations, which is the first mode of appearance, and the second mode of appearance is the mode of appearance of a phenomenon such as a vase to someone who does not ask the question whether the vase is inherently existent or not. The vase merely appears. This actually corresponds to the, terminological, or corresponds to a terminological valid cognizer. In other words, a conventional valid cognizer.

The third mode of appearance of the vase is a mode of appearance of vase to a person who strongly acquiesces to the true inherent existence of vase, and says this is something which is truly existent. So here, in the context of the first key point in training the mind, in emptiness, the identification of the object of refutation occurs within the context of a mind which is profoundly convinced that a given phenomenon, such as a vase, exists as it appears to exist. When that mind arises, one then analyzes carefully the object which appears to that mind to see whether it actually does exist in the way in which it appears to exist or not. Then, if one engages in this analysis and one says the vase is not the spout of the vase, it is not the handle of the vase, it is not the body of the vase, nor is it the base of the vase. At that point, one has lost the vase, and one has succumbed into the extreme of nihilism.

Then what is the actual mode of existence of vase? It is that mere appearance of vase in which vase is able to function in the mode in which vases function, as a means for pouring water and so forth, without any undue examination of whether the vase is inherently or truly existent or not. Then one might think that after all, since under analysis and investigation, the vase disappears, the vase actually is utterly non existent. It is not utterly non existent and the counter to its utter non existence is its mere appearance to us. It is this mere appearance which is able to perform the function of a vase.

And this therefore is the first key point, the identification of the object of negation. Having identified the object of negation, we have to ascertain whether the object of negation, which is identified, exists or not. And we do this in the light of the syllogism. The subject in this case vase, it follows that it is not truly existent because, and this is the reason which is twofold, it is neither truly one nor truly multiple. If something exists, it is either one or multiple.

Therefore, if something exists truly or inherently, it is either truly or inherently one or truly or inherently multiple. Therefore, if vase exists truly or inherently, vase is either truly one or truly multiple. So the first reason that the vase is not inherently one is established because if the vase were inherently one, then necessarily the vase would have no parts. However, the vase is not partless, the vase has parts. These parts are the various components of the vase, its color, its shape, the various directions in which it can be subdivided, eastern, northern direction and so forth.

Fact that it is impermanent, fabricated and so forth. The second reason is not established, because if the vase were truly multiple or inherently multiple, then true multiplicity or inherent multiplicity would have to exist. True multiplicity does not exist, because true multiplicity can only exist in dependence on true unity. And true unity does not exist. It is impossible to formulate or to postulate multiplicity without having postulated previously unity.

Therefore, the subject of vase is non-truly existent since it is neither truly one nor truly multiple. In the same way as if something exists in general, that something is necessarily one or multiple, likewise if something is truly existent, it is necessarily truly one or truly multiple. If vase is neither truly one nor truly multiple, it is non truly existent. And therefore, vase is non truly existent because it is neither truly one nor truly multiple, and the examples which are given are that vase is akin to the reflection of a face in a mirror, it is akin to an illusion, or in a more contemporary setting it is similar to a video. When we watch a video or a movie, things appear and strong emotions arise within our mind stream with respect to what appears, but actually there is nothing there in reality.

And therefore we should reflect very carefully on this until we realize that every single phenomenon, every single being which we perceive is a mere mental imputation from our part. There is actually not a single phenomenon or a single being in existence which exists independently of the mind which perceives it. In our own cases, due to beginningless habituation in previous lives to considering that phenomena exist in which, in the way in which they appear to us, this predisposition is strongly rooted in us in this life. And on the basis of this predisposition, we in turn give rise to both desire and to hatred towards these phenomena which seem to exist as they appear. This desire and this hatred in turn enable us or cause us to accumulate karma.

This is how psychic existence proceeds. So we shall stop here for today. As you know, there is a general meeting, an AGM at 08:15. And at 08:15, if we could all reconvene here, and Geshela will give some advice for the annual general meeting. You must have many questions about the meaning of emptiness, but there is no time to enter into them.

So you someone maybe not know, but it’s AGM now. So Geshe-la is going to stay here, and we have a quick break. And if you like to go to toilet or I will let you to have a cup of tea if you make sure look after. You can bring in. Alright?

But after that and please, those who, you know, to attend AGM, you know, we welcome, and it would be a great appreciate. And, also, we do understand if you have to go. So maybe let’s start to have a quick break and grab if you want to have a cup of tea or water, you know. Okay? Then come back.

If somebody can help Geshe-la and Elias tea and it’s the main thing that yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
six realms
The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top