1 h 14 min · 9,356 words · 2 October 2010
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A talk arguing that the Buddhist account of dependent origination, especially the twelve links, can be understood in biological terms. The speaker describes living things as self-preserving systems driven by grasping, habit and restlessness, and suggests that long meditation practice changes the mind. The talk is followed by a question and answer session on rebirth, cognition and related science.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 14m
UUID: bd8dbe73-e8f8-4bef-a82b-e8a265eb0d08
Date: 2010-10-02
Words: 9,352
Is that on? Oh, yes. It certainly is. Probably more on than we really wanted. This has been obviously miked for Ilya, not for me.
In the interest of time, welcome back everybody after a delicious lunch. I won’t say too much about Pamela. Her presentation, how Buddhism illuminates biology and vice versa. Two things, Pamela is a Lojong student of Khensur Rinpoche and secondly has done her PhD research into the biology of cognition. Thank you, Pamela.
Thanks. What I’m going to try and do in this presentation, which is a sort of a story in four parts, is I’m going to try to provide a bit of an explanation on why we should never be surprised when someone like Paul Williams becomes a Roman Catholic after thirty years of being a Buddhist. Why anything that attacks delusion is dharma. Why the destruction of community is horrific, and why it has such negative effects on us. And why our own work in this day and age drives our lives biologically.
I’m hoping to build also on what Ilya has already said, you’ll notice that I’m not a sitter. I I I walk. I’m not very good at sitting in one place and talking. So I move around a bit and I hope you don’t find that too distracting. Now, the four parts of this talk are how I came to know anything about biology at all because I’m not a biologist.
The second part is how Buddhism helped me to see how biology works and why. The third part is how biology helped me to appreciate the profundity of Buddhism and the Buddhist path. And the fourth part is where biology’s usefulness ends and where trust in practice really takes over. Now the first part of this story, and I may sit down for this because it’s not very dynamic. I won’t have to write on the whiteboard, in other words.
The first part of this story is inextricably linked with how I came to meet and become devoted to in my own extraordinarily flawed way to Khensur Rinpoche. Had been, To make it sound completely spooky, I had been looking for a teacher since I was a very small child. I had an awareness, in my view, it could only have come from a previous life, that it was possible to live your entire life and on your deathbed, realized that you’d missed the entire point. That you’d missed the opportunity that had been presented by life and that you could die with tremendous regret and a kind of a horror that the entire thing had gone by and you’d really blown it. You’d really blown it.
And I’ve had this feeling since I was about seven or eight. And so I was too young for anybody to have told me that. So I presumed that that might be a clue to the state of mind I was in in my last life if I wasn’t a dog or an ant or something like that, if I had been a human. So I’ve been looking for a very long time, but I didn’t find the dharma until I was in my 40s, my early 40s, which goes to show you just how benighted I really was. Because there was, I had lots in retrospect, I had lots of signs, I had lots of things that were really pushing me in this direction, sort of beckoning me in this direction.
And I was a hedonist and a materialist, Although I believed in rebirth, I was a total materialist in terms of like, enjoy now. But there was another part of me that was looking for a spiritual home. And I found that home when I attended my first teachings with Khensur Rinpoche at Buddha House in 1992, and he was teaching the Heart sūtra. And I wasn’t one of those, you know, suitable disciples where you have tears come to your eyes and all that sort of stuff. Wasn’t anything like that, but I did get goosebumps and I felt like I had come home.
I felt like just intense relief, you know, like at last. And I had forgotten that I’d been looking for a spiritual path. I’d forgotten for about two decades that I’d been looking for a spiritual path when I was very young. And Rinpoche brought me back to that. And so Rinpoche also led me to this state of questioning, to what extent am I being of benefit to others in this life?
Given my endowments, whatever they might be, given what I’m doing, how well am I doing? Am I doing enough? I had had a flirtation with becoming a nun, but that fever broke, thank heaven, and I’m still with Richard. And that is the path that I think Rinpoche saw also for me and for us. But I asked this question and through one of those stock takes of one’s skills and abilities, which in my case is always an overestimation and an underestimation.
It’s like I always overestimate my capacities on one side and I always underestimate them on another. So it’s always a bit of a schmazel. But I I had decided that I was going to do a PhD and so that I could teach. And I was going to do a PhD on this is the overestimation part. I was going to take the Buddha at his words and I was going to see if the four seals, the four established conclusions would hold water today under a Western philosophical and scientific analysis.
It was like, okay, you want us to rub this like gold, you want us to test it by weighing it and measuring it and that sort of stuff, I’ll do it. Well, no, I wasn’t going to do it. Because basically evaluating the four seals is looking at every single major, really subtle concept with Buddhist philosophy. And I couldn’t even read Tibetan. Not, there wasn’t enough secondary material.
I trotted off to Sera where Rinpoche was very kindly laid out all these conditions where I could learn Tibetan. I didn’t become fluent in three months, I’m afraid to say. But I felt confident enough to read texts, which probably was another overestimation of what I was actually capable of. And so I enrolled at ANU and I went, I enrolled at ANU in a PhD program under John Powers, who was at Virginia at the same time Ilya was. And John probably owes his PhD to Ilya as a translator of the language because John isn’t very good in the language despite his great experience in Buddhist philosophy.
And I went off to Sarnath and I studied with two, I went off to Sarnath because I was given the money to do this by ANU. They had a lot of money relative to other institutions, and they basically bankrolled it. And so I studied with two scholars. One was an elderly scholar and one of the preeminent senior scholars in the Tibetan tradition, Geshe Yeshe Tapkhe, and one was a junior scholar. And with Geshe Yeshe Tapke, I studied the sixth causation chapter of Candrakīrti’s commentary on Nāgārjuna’s Mūlamadhyamakakārikā.
In that chapter, Candrakīrti provides a number of arguments on how one comes to understand the emptiness of cause and effect, even as it works, even though it works, it is also empty. That was very rigorous and difficult. And with this younger scholar who was a young Geshe from Drepung Loseling, he had selected the text, the 12 links of dependent origination. It was Pänchen Sonam Drakpa’s commentary on the 12 links of dependent origination. And I thought, oh, this is going to be tough, because rebirth really is presumed, it’s just an assumption in the presentation.
And I thought, how am I going to cash this out in a Ph. D? I mean, like I just don’t know how you do that really. And so, but I became, because the 12 links are a positive account about how things work. You know, this is the Buddhist account that says, this is how things work.
This is how the mind works. This is why we experience the birth that we experience. This is why we experience the kinds of things that we experience in our lives. It it is it’s it’s the one sort of take home, Buddhist take home message of you wanna know how it works? This is how it works.
And I became more and more and more fascinated with it. And so I decided that I was going to do my PhD on it. And as luck would have it, because my Tibetan was never up to it, I had a complete change of mind about what the nature of this PhD was going to be. So what I ended up doing was I decided I had this insight and I can only believe that it came from Rinpoche. I’m not saying that this is an endorsement of what I did by Rinpoche.
It’s just that this was my interpretation of my experience. And that was, and it was a very, very, very powerful, powerful experience of the 12 links of dependent origination are true. They are literally true. They would have been true if the Buddha had never said a word about them. Whether or not the Buddha had been there to say anything, the 12 links of dependent origination true.
I have a cellular feeling about this. I have never read anything in science since then to dissuade me from this. And as much of the reading as I do in science, that’s actually saying something. Because this is at the molecular level, this is at the level of organs, this is at the level of whole organisms and at the level of very simple organisms all the way up through to humans. All of it’s true.
Now I already believed in rebirth, so this wasn’t a problem for me. Back then, a if you feeling that you could blow your entire life opportunity and realize that on your deathbed, you have a pretty good idea that you’ve been here before. And I never got the idea that, just because everything recycles, everything recycles. Why is the most causally efficacious phenomenon in the universe that we know of the one thing that just stops and that’s it. It never made any sense.
It just never made any sense to me. So that was never a problem. So I also had the notion that now is the time for I had no reason to believe this really, this was an act of faith. But that now is the time in which the 12 links of dependent origination actually can be cashed out in scientific terms. They can be cashed out in scientific terms without ever referring to these, without ever referring to the Buddhist framework, without ever using any Buddhist terms and only relying on scientific data to cash these out.
Okay? Okay, so in order to do this, I had to do I can’t tell you how these fit because that’s actually something that I do over about 12 sessions and that takes a long time. This is pretty complicated stuff actually. But I can tell you how I tackled the problem. And I think that that is one way of looking at how a Westerner can begin to integrate Buddhist principles into a thinking process.
Okay? Now the first thing I did was I tried to strip back everything that I knew to what I considered to be its absolute essentials. Right? Okay, now this is my interpretation. This is not doctrinal.
I knew that I couldn’t go to any particular account, any particular doctrinal account, because all of those things are open to question. They’re even they’re open to question within the tradition itself. So I was never going to be able to and I didn’t know enough about the arguments about everything in the different traditions to be able to defend any particular doctrinal account. So I had to make sure that I wasn’t using that. So the very first assumption that I made and there were five of them, five of them, maybe four, maybe three, I don’t know.
At any rate, mind is clear and knowing. Remember, we’re talking about not how to become liberated. We’re talking about what is in the positive account of Buddhism about the nature of the world, about our experience of the world. Okay. So mind is clear and knowing.
Okay. Clear? I decided right from the get go I wasn’t gonna deal with that. Because I’m not gonna deal with mental physical. Both of those terms are completely confused.
We don’t know what physical means. We don’t know. It’s not a mind body problem, it’s actually a body problem. If you say that physic physical means whatever physics says it is, well then physics could, you know, physics could decide tomorrow that ghosts exist, and then all of a sudden, that’ll be physic a ghost will be physical. My my greatest example on this is that in the last ten years, physics has adopted two totally occult substances for which they only had theoretical basis for believing.
And one is dark matter and the other one is dark energy. Why are they physical? Because physicists because physicists thought of it? Sorry. I can’t tell you what physical means.
And if I can’t tell you what physical means, I can’t tell you what mental means. So I’m not gonna go there. So I I bracketed all of those metaphysical discussions. Okay? So what is knowing then?
Knowing, now knowing is a really really tricky term in in Western philosophy and biology. And there are all sorts of different, you know, all sorts of different interpretations of this. But if you start with the idea of its apprehension of an object, it is a process or a multifaceted matrix of events which is only once called the mind. It’s a process by which something, some process apprehends or reflects the nature of the reality of something else. Okay?
I I I’m watching I’m watching Ilya’s face for these sort of, you know, this sort of stuff. But but this is my, you know, this is this is my, you know, this is this is the basic starting point I I was leaving from, okay. So the second one is all sentient beings have minds, okay? Alright. Sentient being, what does that mean?
Well, sentient means, that means that first of all that they’re embodied minds, they have bodies. Right? They feel, they have feeling, whatever that means. We don’t know what that means, I mean, in a in a western biological sense. We really don’t have a very good handle on that.
But they feel, alright? So you’ve got feeling. And it seemed to me that the next clue to to this lay in the three poisons, that all feeling is conditioned in ordinary existence is conditioned by these. And the first one is attack well, actually, it’s ignorance, because that’s the really critical one. You’ve got ignorance, you’ve got attachment, desire, and you have aversion.
And the most basic way that you can cash that out is this is it’s something mistaken about the self. Alright? That has something to do with that. Attachment has a kind of a positive quality. It’s being drawn to something.
And aversion has a negative quality. It’s moving away from something. Okay? Alright. So once you’ve got these three poisons, the last is it the last?
Yep. It is the last. There’s only four. The last one is that ordinary perception. We’re not talking about we’re talking gross mind, we’re talking gross body.
We’re not talking about higher states of consciousness. We’re not talking about grounds and paths, we’re just talking the gross stuff that you come in with. The gross stuff that you come in with. Okay. Is conceptuality.
One of the principal teachings that I that I distilled from the years of taking teachings from Rinpoche was that there is no such thing as direct and unmistaken perception for ordinary beings, unless they train to experience it. You have to train to experience something that’s direct and unmistaken. Alright? You can get there by a number of ways, but that’s not usually how we experience it. All of our perceptions have sort of dispositions built in.
And those dis dispositions are crucially related to these three poisons. Okay? So nothing is clean. Everything really is tainted right from the start because of these things. Okay?
Now, from the standpoint of method, I decided that, as I said, I would be ontologically neutral. From the second point, I decided that I would only use data from absolutely mainstream science and psychology. I wasn’t gonna use any of the, you know, the sort of scientific looking journals that actually are quite rigorous, but nobody accepts them that have things about parapsychology and stuff like that. You know, the mere fact that the CIA poured, you know, gazillions of dollars into remote viewing experiments, I think says that the, you know, the the government of the United States seems to think there is such a thing as, you know, ESP and remote viewing, but nobody wants to talk about that because it doesn’t fit the paradigm. And if things don’t fit the paradigm, they don’t get discussed.
You have now, we as Westerners don’t appreciate this. We have a tendency to think that science is this really open enterprise, right? You know, that it’s, you know, like it’s it’s let the chips fall where they may, where is the evidence, you know, if the evidence is there, well then of course we’ll follow it, but that isn’t how it works. It’s who you went to school with, who you studied with, what lab you studied in, who know, who do you know on the editorial board of this, that and the other thing? And how well does your work fit within the paradigm that’s currently going?
It is really really hard to do something out of the square, really hard. And everything and and like any community, science closes around when there are when there are mavericks on the on the sidelines. And just to be clear about what science is, science isn’t just physics and chemistry. It isn’t just rendered in formal formulas, which is what Galileo gave us. There is an entire science and it’s called biology and everything related to the life sciences and psychology that relates to description first, really detailed description, and then experimentation trying to understand how they work.
Okay? Biology does not yield very well to to Newtonian mechanics, for example. It’s it’s a it’s really left field, is why Aristotle was great. But at any rate, we won’t go there. Okay.
This is what I found out. Can you just sort of summarize this? Okay. All right. Yeah.
Okay. This is what I found out. And this is going to seem really clean, you know, like it all just sort of laid itself out on a plate, but it didn’t. It took a long time to distill all this stuff. But I, you know, I mean, you can take me up on any of this stuff, but I’m I’m telling you, you can take this to the bank.
I mean, this is this is all really, really, really verifiable stuff. And to a certain extent, it’s mainstream, to a certain extent, it’s not. Okay. Alright. Here’s the mainstream part.
We have this something or other. Alright? And it’s living. It’s alive. Alright?
Now, what this thing does is that it’s in a constant state of bringing in stuff from the outside to build itself up, and it’s exporting stuff from here that is waste product. And it’s also exporting stuff from here that basically sends bits of information out here to tell it how it’s going on the outside. Alright? So there’s an inside and there’s an outside. And the reason why I haven’t drawn a really clear circle is because the borders are really, really fuzzy.
We think they’re really clear, but they’re not. There’s a lot of exchange going on at the skin level. There’s a lot of exchange going on at the single cell level. And there’s matter and energy flowing in and out all through our bodies, right at the borderlines of of our skin, you know, under our arms, all sorts of stuff. There’s this constant flow of matter and energy because if it stopped, you die.
Okay? This is really, really tricky. Really tricky. Because not only are we do we have matter and energy flowing in and out, we also have this thing, whatever it is, producing itself. It manufactures itself as it goes along, as it’s doing all this back and forth thing with the environment and that sort of stuff.
It’s producing itself. It’s making the components that will allow it to continue to exist. Alright? And that is the key. It’s preservation.
Self preservation. And what I found out is that we haven’t got a clue how this happened. We haven’t got a clue. Don’t let anybody tell you that we have a general handle on the origin of life because we do not. Yes, in the nineteen fifties, some scientists put a what they thought might be a primeval soup together.
They zapped it with some elect some electricity, and they got amino acids. That was pretty cool. But the guy who did that experiment is still trying to crack the origin of life because those things don’t do anything. They don’t do anything. You it is really hard to get a nucleic acid to form just naturally.
It is really hard to get a bit of RNA to appear and then do something functional. You know why? Because there are no functions separate from this. Functions only exist to keep this going. And unless you’ve got something like a self preserving system, not just a self organizing system, not just a complex system, unless you’ve got a self preserving system, none of that stuff does anything.
They have been doing countless experiments with with RNAs because they both are enzymes and they they they reproduce. You know, they’re they’re part of the the reproduction cycle. And they just don’t do anything. They don’t do anything. So we are a long way from understanding where this came from.
And you folks out there, and I’m sure there’s a couple of you, who think Richard Dawkins is really cool. Good. I don’t either. He basically made us think that we had a handle on this by calling genes selfish. By calling something so basic as a gene selfish, he basically covered up this entire gaping black hole in the biological story.
Okay? So I just wanna make it really, really clear that we don’t know anything about this. Okay? We really don’t. All we know is that this is self preserving.
And it’s it’s self producing and it’s self preserving. Okay. What this means is that everything within this, everything, every single cell in your body, every single protein in your body, every single fluid in your body is geared to preserving this. And there is nothing there. There is nothing there.
There is nothing inherent there. There is nothing enduring there. There is nothing to protect there. And yet the entire thing is geared to protecting something that it thinks is really important, but is essentially a misapprehension. It’s essentially a misapprehension.
It’s a mistake. This is based on a fundamental error, and this is where it begins. It begins with the origin of life on this planet that we know of, with this biology that we’re working with. Okay? So that means that ever given this self preserving impulse, given this grasping at existence, if you will, that means that every single living thing is in one of three states at any given time.
I mean, seriously, at any given time, it’s in one of three states. One is striving to get something it lacks. The other one is basically digesting what it’s got. You know, that’s basically incorporating it into itself, whether it’s a watch, whether it’s, you know, food, whether it’s anything. It’s like, well, I’ve got this car.
What does it mean to me? You know, it’s, you know, it’s like it’s like digesting what you’ve got, and this is sort of getting. And the third one is basically protecting yourself from something nasty. It’s something that destabilizes all of this. Right?
Instability. And one of the reasons why the loss of the community of a a religious community was so devastating. And one of the reasons why the radical autonomy of modernism is so alienating and destabilizing is because the only thing left we have is science. And science, we really need to feel secure. We really need to feel as though we’ve got a handle on things.
Every single organism on the face of the planet needs to feel it like it’s in control of itself. You know, if they if if they’re not in control, they actually go a bit wonky. You know, agency is really, really important. The feeling as though you have control over what you can do means you’re not in danger. It means you’re in this zone.
You’re okay. Alright? You’re okay. And that is the most important thing. The most important thing.
Because if you’re not okay, you’re in danger of being annihilated. And that is basically it. The the system itself does not differentiate between automatically, it does not differentiate between this is a small threat and this is going to annihilate me. In the beginning, it’s all annihilation. You have to learn that this is not going to kill you.
You have to learn that this is not going to annihilate you. You have to learn that. You don’t come in automatically knowing it. That’s one of the reasons why kids scream so much. It’s like it’s like they’re I I think it’s developmental.
It’s like, what is the range of my voice? You know, what can I do in this circumstance? You know, they’re testing out how they are in the world. And this is such a huge growth experience that they just don’t know what their boundaries are yet. They don’t know where this ends yet.
They have to be taught where that ends. Because it’s all kind of amorphous, you know, because your mother’s there, you cry, your mother’s there. Well, if you’re lucky, if your mother didn’t just leave you on somebody’s doorstep or throw you in a dustbin, because that happens too. Where you end and where your mother begins, it’s really, really hard for kids to realize that in the beginning. There’s a lot of lot of lot of data on this.
Okay. Okay. So it also means that you’re constantly restless because nothing stops ever. The whole system is moving all the time. It is in a perpetual motion.
It’s not just atoms and electrons, you know, electrons, protons, you know, atomic constituents that are constantly moving. It is everything in your body is just shuttling around like mad. The inside of a cell is like deli at rush hour. You know, the inside of one cell. You know, the only cell that’s kind of placid because it doesn’t have any DNA is a red blood cell.
You know, all the others are just hives of activity. You know, massive, massive, massive stuff going on. So there is no rest at any moment. So when you sit in meditation, and you’re trying to calm your mind, and you’re trying to not pay attention to bodily sensation, everything in you is geared to generate that cacophony. Everything in you is geared to make you recognize that you are this cacophony and to keep it going.
Everything in you is geared to it. So what this told me was that okay. Let me let me before I go into the next step, I’ve I’ve missed something here. Okay. That means also all of your cognitive apparatus, everything that tells you about what’s happening out here and what’s happening out there in a what is it, is this good, is this bad, is this something I want, is this something I need to escape from, what have I got at any moment.
This entire apparatus is completely conditioned by this job, This job of keeping the show going. This job of preserving self. This job of doing this incredible thing that people used to think was in violation of physical laws. Basically what happened was that we had to expand physical laws to account for this. We now know that this is a thermodynamically open system.
It’s not a closed system. If it were a closed system, you know, it couldn’t function the way it does. But now that we know that open systems exist, and it was biology that basically led us to this recognition, it’s still a pretty weird thing. I mean, the mere fact that, you know, everybody you’d think that, what time have I got? Ten minutes?
Ten minutes, alright. Okay, good. Yeah. Pretty close to it, I think. So all of the cognitive apparatus is designed to maintain this.
So that means it is intrinsically biased. You can’t look at anything without training, without really hard work, and not see how it relates to you. You can’t perceive anything and not automatically draw a connection with yourself. Because that is what all of your sensory apparatus, all of your information processing apparatus is designed to do. That’s what it’s designed to do.
It’s designed for you to do this and to navigate a world. So that you can keep stuff coming in, to keep the whole show going, keep things away that are gonna hurt you, and get rid of the stuff that you don’t like, which is humans are so good at that, we just move basically. Which is why everybody’s so excited about this exoplanet just discovered it’s only 20 light years, 20,000,000, you know, 20 light years away because, gee, it might be another earth. Once we’ve completely trashed this one, we can, you know, move off somewhere else. So and this this apparatus is really, really intimately conditioned by life experience.
In my personal view, it was, you know, it was conditioned by life experience coming back here, but it’s definitely conditioned by life experience here. And everything you perceive, everything you think, every way you act is is more deeply entrenched through your neural structures. So you’ve got this really, really we are habit machines basically, we’re habit machines. We perceive things, we lay down a habit. We perceive things, we lay down a habit.
We react to something, we lay down a habit. We just lay down habits, lay down habits, lay down habits. Which is why I think it is possible to think of individual species as kind of lineages of grasping. You know, it’s a particular a dog is a particular lineage of grasping at existence in a particular way. An ant is a lineage of existence is a lineage of grasping at existence in a particular way.
A human is an evolved lineage of grasping at existence in a particular way. And I think the thing that really makes us different from other animals is that we have this little tiny sliver of freedom, of the degree of freedom, where we can actually act against this. We can actually recognize that this is going on. We can still feed ourselves, we can still clothe ourselves, we can still seek shelter, we can still do all the things that you have to do to keep this vessel going, but we can actually take steps to undo all of this habit and all of this grasping, grasping, grasping, but it’s really, really, really hard. So even those who can spend a long time in the dharma, can go to a lot of teachings, can be thinking.
I like I like Anthony’s idea of a theoretical Buddhist. Theoretically, I’m a Buddhist. Actually turning this back is about the most difficult thing any being in existence can do. It’s really, really hard, which is why it has to be got at and got at and got at and got at and which is why, please one of these days, let me listen to my words coming out of my own mouth. Meditation is so important, because meditation is where this undoing gets done.
Meditation is where you come face to face with the restlessness of all this. Meditation is where you move through layers of restlessness to layers where things aren’t quite so stirred up to layers where you might even have flashes of clarity. And it’s that clarity, that clarity that is at the base of this that isn’t even perceived by this, you know, because that thing doesn’t need protection. It just is, and it’s not, you know. And and there’s something about there’s some magic thing about ten thousand hours, when I first started reading this stuff, I did some quick calculation, sort of back of the envelope calculations on three and a half year retreats.
And there is something about ten thousand hours of practice. It’s at ten thousand hours of practice that a pianist becomes a professional, that somebody who is swimming becomes an elite athlete. There’s something about ten thousand hours that marks the difference between one way of being in the world and another way of being in the world. And this is now becoming really, really well established, really well established. So it makes sense that if you’re in a long retreat, that by the end of it, your mind is going to be really different.
That doesn’t mean you’re not still gonna get angry, it doesn’t mean that all kinds of things can’t still come up for you. But your mind is different, your mind is different. And if you don’t, you know, immediately go into Rundle Mall and say, yeah, I’ll have that coffee and gee, I have been out of the fashion stakes for so long, I’d really like that outfit and maybe I need a new computer and a new car. You know, if you don’t just dive right back into the whole blooming, buzzing, hedonistic, materialistic thing, you have a chance of holding on to some of that. You know, Richard and I just had a we had a month long retreat in in June, and it was just the most blessed experience.
And we immediately went overseas, you know, and it was just bang, bang, bang, bang, bang. Was like and now it feels like it was years, you know, and it was only June. Feels like years since we were on retreat. So there’s something there’s something about that. And the reason why I’m fascinated by the by Weber’s account of of why our jobs became our life.
I think that that’s really true. I think it’s a it’s a very important insight. But the other reason why our jobs have become our life and why Rinpoche said that in the West we’d we’d we’d we’d developed a new affliction called busyness. You know, that it’s new, you know, it’s kind of a new affliction, you know, it’s unique to us and I think it is actually. And that’s because the capitalist system that we developed has got us on this treadmill like you wouldn’t believe.
We if our jobs are our lives literally, not because they give us fulfillment, but because we are running like crazy just to feel safe. It okay in this. There’s there’s a there’s a the paradigm for chronic stress, psychological stress in in experimental psychology is a rat or a mouse that’s exposed to chronic restraint. They basically, you know, have them in sort of, you know, really really close spaces so they can’t move around. My theory is that our busyness is actually a form of chronic restraint.
We’re constantly under time pressure. We never have enough time to do anything. We’re always running from one place to another. And I think we are literally under a chronic low level stress that says we’re in danger. We’re in danger here, which is why all of this is so important.
We can’t pull back from our jobs. We can’t pull back from our domestic responsibilities because there is something in our biology and it’s generally hormonal. That’s basically saying, you pull back honey and you are gone. You know, you’re annihilated. And I think that there’s a lot of that going around.
You know, I think that’s the nature of how our bodies throw up these kind of stress responses to this nature of instability that we haven’t even begun to deal with yet. We haven’t even begun to deal with yet, which is why a Buddhist perspective on all this is really, really important. All of this made me realize, I think you’ll get from what I’ve been saying, how important the Buddhist path is. And yet how very difficult it is and how it’s not just a matter of transmission. These things, these concepts have to be taken into our lives and we are probably the very first generation in the history of the world in which we are literate enough and educated enough to understand this enough, to understand why doing it is important.
But this is where biology begins to fail us. Because biology only works with the gross body and the gross mind. It doesn’t deal with anything else. And it’s at precisely that point, you know, enlightened, you’re kidding, you know, liberated, you’ve got to be mad. I mean, look at this stuff, you know, is that even possible?
This is where the spiritual teacher becomes absolutely critical because the spiritual teacher models what is possible. Because nothing in our society, nothing in our knowledge structure says that this is possible. You’d be mad to try. You’d be mad to try. And which is why, you know, I think to a certain extent, it’s sort of magical thinking.
People get so excited about little glimpses of clairvoyance and little glimpses of sort of magical powers because it does point us something beyond this. You know? Because when you’ve got a little taste of something like that, you know that this is not all there is. You know? And that is really, really crucial.
That’s really crucial. So that’s it. Thanks. Questions? Yep.
Thank you. Forgot to go through this, but never mind. Down to our cellular structure where constantly Delhi at rush hour and that’s a fundamental singular reality then the If you don’t believe in rebirth, If you don’t believe in rebirth, it’s impossible. I mean, the whole notion of taking three countless eons to become enlightened is no joke. You know?
This is not this is serious. But if you don’t believe in a rebirth, I wouldn’t even bother. You know, I wouldn’t even bother. I guess the question is, in some sense, that how does the, how does a belief, as for example, belief in rebirth counteract the fundamental reality of the It doesn’t. Yeah.
Without that belief, you can’t do it. I’m just Oh, thank you. What your thoughts are on how it’s just a belief will counteract mental the mental set set of of Yeah, reality. Okay. What what you can do is you can rely on Aristotle.
You can rely on Aristotle because Aristotle said, you know, his you know, this idea about humankind being different, he called it calculative reason. But what he meant by calculative reason is that you can take all of the all of your natural impulses and you can actually begin to distance yourself from them. There’s always the danger of you take out what’s natural and it will, you know, it will come back, you know, of its own accord. But you can start to get a distance from this blooming, buzzing confusion just by recognizing that it’s there. But if you actually wanna be a Buddha, if you actually wanna be liberated, if you believe that’s possible, if you wanna be enlightened, I think that I think that basically you have to have some faith that there’s rebirth.
But if you just wanna be happier, you know, if you just wanna be happier in this life, you can start to recognize how you’re driven by all that. Do you have to be rebirth outside the cellular system? No. Otherwise, you’re back in the same old Delhi at rush hour. But it’s possible, well, look at Rinpoche.
Rinpoche is constituted of cells. He is deli his body is Delhi at rush hour, but there’s no question about who’s running the traffic. There’s no question about who’s running the traffic. I don’t know about you, but I ain’t running this traffic. This traffic is running me.
My hormones spike when I feel threatened, I’m there. Now at least I can step back and go, wait a minute, you’re going there, you’re feeling threatened. That I can do. His cellular structure at some level, some level of organization is at peace. No, no.
Well, what is it that is at peace in the organism that we’re calling life That’s a great mystery, isn’t it? Clear mind. That’s the clear and knowing mind. That’s the clear and knowing mind, yes. Yeah, the clear and knowing mind thing, I asked Rinpoche about this once, about like how do you get scientists to even really understand any of this stuff?
And he said, well, they don’t understand that there’s a very subtle mind. And you can’t, unless you’re really trained to access a really subtle mind, you just don’t, you’re just not gonna, you’re just not gonna see it. And I take it on faith that there’s a really subtle mind. You know, I mean, the mere fact that Rinpoche has come back from Sarah with this story of a monk that stayed in Tukdum for nineteen days. The only way that could be true and many many people witnessed it is if there is a very subtle mind, that’s the only way it could be true.
And it does interact with the coarse body, there’s no question about it. But the nature of that interaction, who knows what it is? So somewhere there we’re incorporating faith along with the scientific Absolutely. Yeah. I’m just looking at where some of those borderlines Yeah.
Would be and where we’re making assumptions, however correct those are. Yeah, I think that it’s it’s basically at the borderlines of higher states of consciousness and what it is actually possible to achieve. All I know is that I want out. I want out and I’d like to bring others with me, but I’m being I’m really dragging my heels, I’m sorry. I’m really dragging my heels.
Yeah. I’d like to bring up what’s for me a being with a mind that has feelings, you said, but also engages in karma. In other words, interaction with them has karma. Yep. Then I read something by Susan Greenfield in her book about the brain.
Yep. It was the anonymous strange occurrence of the emperor Hirohito discovered marine bio studied marine biology, and he discovered the sea squirt. Now the c squirt has a movement sensor equivalent to our ear, a very primitive one, a light sensor equivalent to our eye, and a very primitive brain, it could be said, by which it moves around the sea. Then at some point it attaches itself to a rock, lives by filtering seawater, and consumes its own brain. Therefore, it seems to me that it’s no longer interacting with the world.
It was a It seems to be, you know, this is my interpretation, that a sentient being has become a plant because Rinpoche said that trees weren’t sentient beings. Except the Buddha was a tree in a previous life. A sentient being has become a plant. Therefore, is the sea squirt the ultimate form of life that becomes liberated? I think that that is one of those gotcha questions that basically is not intended to be answered.
It’s just it’s intended to be appreciated. So I’ll just leave it at that. Except the sea squirt also reproduces. Yeah. The sea squirt reproduces and reproduce reproduction is another form of self preservation because the material animal is passed on into the into the offspring.
So it’s not a get out of jail free card, I’m sorry. Yeah. When you’re talking about believing in reincarnation and everything Are you liberated? That’s the point though. No liberation without some belief in reincarnation because it’s too hard.
And this is the radical relativism that we’re talking about. But isn’t that actually just a story you tell yourself to make sure that your life is meaningful? But isn’t that a story you’re telling? I don’t think it’s meaningful at all reincarnating. I think it’s a horror story.
I guess I’ve lost I think it’s a total, I think it’s a yeah, but see, 70% of Buddhist, Western Buddhist don’t believe in reincarnation. That’s what that’s what Ilya was talking about. Have to for life to go on and everyone to learn. You don’t have to believe in anything like that. But it took seven years after we dismantled the Glass-Steagall Act in The United States to have a global financial melt on the scale of the Great Depression.
We learn nothing. We learn we’re still at war. We’re destroying people at Learning and growing. Learning and growing in what way? You know, like something’s happening.
The planet is melting. The planet we are learning nothing. We’re here. Just looking after ourselves, basically. I mean, yeah.
Well, I sure hope that’s true, but I’m not living in it. I’m not living in it. If that was enough, why doesn’t why doesn’t the not no. If that was enough, why doesn’t the knowledge why doesn’t the knowledge of smoking the smoking the smoking behavior Why don’t we stop it? I don’t experience that.
I don’t experience that. I’m just really thick. I don’t experience it. Did I say that we were trapped in the system? I didn’t say that.
That’s right. I’m not a spiritual teacher. And also understanding why all beings want to be happy and don’t wanna suffer. I mean, it’s not just a it’s not just a anodyne thing that his holiness says. It’s actually the truth.
Absolutely none. Absolutely none. Zero. None. None.
The moment I say I’m a Buddhist, glaze right over. And and because I don’t lie, I tell them. And they say, you believe in reincarnation? Yep. Yep.
Yep. Yep. Really? Yep. Yep.
Yep. There’s a question down here. Yep. Pamela Yep. It’s interesting that you talked about the busyness that we’ve got ourselves caught up in busyness.
But not all human beings are caught up in that busyness. So why has it affected some human beings especially in the West and not other cultures? I think it’s a point of view. I think I think capitalism has a lot to do with it. Think capitalism capitalistic systems really breed this for all of the reasons that Ilya brought out this morning.
I I thought that, you know, that was a really, really fine analysis of how we basically got into got into this mess in terms of our social structures. And I, you know, you know, you’re talking to a person who believes in in rebirth. Right? You know, we all have we all come in with a different complement of of of dispositions. And some people did a lot of work in previous lives.
You know? It’s all the fault of agriculture. It certainly does. Yeah. Yeah.
We do have a culture here. This isn’t going to work. I’m going to have to put something on. I need a tea towel or something like that. Is it over yet?
We’ve still got a we’ve still got a few more minutes if if Yeah. Okay. You wanna torture me some more? No? Have a question.
Yep. I mean, when you in your diagram, you indicated the classical definition of mind, which is clear and knowing, and said you would leave the knowing component to the side. Can you think of a test akin to the Turing test whereby one could establish whether a system is not intelligent or not, but conscious or not? Everybody’s trying to figure that out. Can’t find that.
Nothing. And the Turing test has been a bit of a it’s been a bit of a failure. I mean, nobody’s been able come even close to being able to do that with an artificial system. But the the point the point is, and I I didn’t really recognize this until I wrote some background papers for a discussion with His Holiness and some Western scientists at ANU when I was, you know, I was required to write a one page description of the difference between Tibetan and the western, you know, concept of mind. One side of each side of the page page paper.
And the thing that’s really struck me as a Westerner was that Buddhists had a definition. They had a definition that they worked with and they explored with and they did a lot of things with. And Westerners have nothing. We say, we haven’t. Okay.
It’s just not this case. This is really disappointing. I’m sure. Yeah. Know.
But how do they inflate mind with Oh, Constantly. Which is why when you’ve got there was a there was a piece of data that came out there was a study that just came out this week on archer fish. Archer fish are these little tiny fish that squirt a jet of water. They’re under the water. They they they hunt for flies above and insects above the water face.
So they are literally shooting from the water to a completely different medium. It’s really hard. Physics are just wildly difficult. And they learn to do this. They don’t just do it instinctively.
They learn to do it. They watch other archer fish doing it, and that’s how they learn. And they never do it first off just by themselves. They always watch, and then they try. It’s kinda weird because they’re really small.
They haven’t got much of a brain. And they just did a comparative study of archer fish and human beings looking at patterns that are either going in the same orientation like this or like this. If you’re looking for something that’s against the background like this, this pops out. If you’re looking for something that’s going like this against the background that goes like this, it’s harder to see. Apparently, archer fish and human beings respond exactly the same way in orientation saliency in visual.
The problem is, archer fish don’t have a visual cortex. Archer fish don’t have anything even remotely like what we have in our brains for doing that. So what do you say? That the archer fish don’t have orientation saliency because they haven’t got a brain that’s like ours that allows us to do this or that orientation saliency is actually something really important to navigate the world with and many different you know, it’s probably really deeply conserved. And our brains just happen to have really, really complex, you know, landscape for doing it.
Which is the answer? There are those and this this strictly divides on an ideological line. There are those who say, well, it can’t possibly be what humans are doing because they have not a brain like human being. Right? And then there are others who are saying, well, if we’re taking evolution seriously, then obviously this is a capacity that’s really, really useful.
You know, if you’re if you’re visual you know, if you if you have to coordinate sensory motor, you know, behavior, this is a really, really useful thing to have. Now, you know, when you look at bacteria, this is where the rubber hits the road. You know? They’re really, really simple relative to us, but they have massively complex behavior. They have individual differentiate you know, all the individuals don’t behave the same.
You know, they you know, they’re you know, do you say that the things that you’re you’re you’re observing can’t possibly be cognition because they don’t even have a neuron, much less a brain? They are a neuron, basically. You know? Or do you say, well, there’s actually some pretty interesting similarities in the behavior, and, actually, this little mechanism that’s used here is used in neurons generating this behavior. What do you say?
It comes down to personal opinion. What what kinds of animals have cognition and which ones don’t? What are what kinds of cognizers and which ones aren’t? You have as many opinions as you have people in the room. There’s just no consensus in the West on a, what what what a cognizer is and what it does, you know?
None. They’ll point to, well, we can look at working memory here and we can look at long-term memory here, and we can look at decision making under uncertainty here. We can look at we can look at, you know, attention, select attention here. And they have all these little bits everywhere. They’re spread out everywhere, and there’s this mountain of data that’s just it’s unbelievable the amount of data that’s coming in and I’m there is nothing to to really help make sense of it.
I mean, it’s it’s amazing actually. You’d think, I as a taxpayer, I think it’s a scandal. Within the cognitive sciences, they are they are complete. They are treated as completely different things entirely. It’s weird.
It’s really weird. Yeah. But Buddhism can teach the cognitive sciences sciences a lot, but there there’s a lot of presuppositions that are going to have to bite the dust first really. Rebirth isn’t one of them. Thank heaven.
Thank you so much Pamela for presenting. We’ll sort that out. Don’t you worry about it. Thank you very much. Oh by the way, thank you.
I have a handout. This is an article. It’s fairly technical but it is an article written about how Buddhism influenced primatology. Because in in the study of primate behavior, in monkey behavior particularly, there was a very famous primatologist by the name of Imanishi, who was Japanese and he was Buddhist and he had a particular view on the natural world. And he came up with some really really interesting insights that now are just mainstream.
But at the time that he was doing this, there was there was a primatologist from England who felt it incumbent upon himself to go all the way to Japan and tell the old gentleman how wrong he absolutely was because none of this could possibly be true because we know that they’re just machines, and we know this and that and the other thing, and they haven’t got internal states, and they haven’t got this and that, and you’re just anthropomorphizing everything. And now we know that that’s not true. And so Buddhism actually has been very undercover, has been very influential in in primatology, and this is an article about that. So I’ve only got 10 copies, but I can we can make more copies if you want. Thank you very much.
We’ll be back there actually at 02:00 for Jamgon Kongtrul. Thank you very much. Good. You’ve got us all busy. You’ve us all busy.
Oh, good. We were already busy.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is there a test like the Turing test that could show whether a system is conscious, rather than merely intelligent?
No one has found one; everybody is trying. The Turing test has been a bit of a failure, since no artificial system has come close to passing it. The deeper problem is that Westerners have no agreed definition of mind or cognition, whereas Buddhists have a definition they work with and explore. Without it, even basic cases divide opinion. Archer fish respond to orientation saliency like humans despite having no visual cortex, and bacteria show complex behaviour without a neuron. Whether these count as cognition comes down to personal opinion, with no consensus on what a cognizer is. Data keeps piling up but little makes sense of it.