1 h 29 min · 11,809 words · 1 November 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk introduces the four seals of Buddhist philosophy: all composite phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are suffering, all phenomena are selfless, and nirvana is peace. It explains subtle and coarse impermanence, the five aggregates, and the selflessness of persons, contrasting this with the Upanishadic view of an unchanging atman. It also covers the Hinayana and Mahayana views of liberation and the difference between affirming and negating phenomena. The session closes with a question and answer discussion about reincarnation, commitment and religious conversion.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 29m
UUID: 96c445ad-3c6f-4e5b-8f50-b1e0502588b1
Date: 2014-11-01
Words: 11,805
So I’m sorry to have curtailed the coffee break. All of us would have wished for it to last longer but we must proceed. We have a from a Buddhist standpoint, a student, and from a Christian standpoint, an interference. But the student understands I don’t know. So the key now before we enter in the world of Buddhism is to understand that this is the mental universe we are evolving in, that of the Gangetic traditions.
God is immanent or pantheistic, he is in either impersonal or absent, the world has degrees of unreality, it’s a world to be fled from, it is a cyclical, a historical world, not anthropocentric, beings have infinite past and future lives, and the goal is liberation or moksha. It is in this mental universe that Buddha Śākyamūni, originally Prince Siddhartha Gautama, was born, was raised, it is with masters who held this view he studied, and when he left to follow his own path to gain his own understanding, it is in reaction against this, and by defining himself through this, that he eventually gained full enlightenment and became the teacher who is for those of us who are Buddhist, our teacher. This is a magnificent statue from Ajanta, if you ever have the opportunity to go to India, I heartily encourage you to visit the cave temples of Ajanta and the adjacent Hindu temples of Ellora, it is really worth seeing close to Allahabad. And I thought I would to show you how Buddhism has been perceived by the non Buddhist Indian majority, I thought I would quote from perhaps the best introduction to Indian philosophy ever written by a great Hindu scholar Radhakrishnan.
The Buddhist shock you could you could call it. Radhakrishnan says, the revolt of Buddhism and Jainism, this is how it was seen, and such even such as it was forms an era in the history of Indian thought, for the great Buddhist thinkers logic was the main arsenal whoever forged the weapons of universal destructive criticism. This is how Buddhism is seen by the great Indian traditions. It was a terrifying threat to Hindu orthodoxy. It is actually this the Buddhist threat which led eventually for those of you who know a bit of Hinduism, which led eventually to Shankar.
Shankar’s reaction and Shankar had studied Nāgārjuna to try to formalize Hinduism and to eventually create his own traditional Advaita Vedanta. So if you read Shankar’s works, it’s quite amazing, because he has passages which literally are copied from the Nagarajuna. It’s quite astonishing, and the Buddhist onslaught in India extended basically from, let’s say, the fifth century BC, the end of Buddha’s life, until pretty much the seventh century of the Christian era, the common era. Brahmanism became the dominant philosophical system, it had the support of kings, and it led to this extraordinary passage by one of the very greatest Indian theistic philosophers, Vachaspati. Vachaspati is quite annoyed by the fact that God has not bestowed a son on him, and he says, proud of thy prowess speaking to God, you despise me upon whom your very existence depended when the Buddhists reigned supreme.
There was Vachaspati left to say that God existed. So within the Gangetic traditions, what is the Buddhist difference? There are many ways to enter into Buddhist thought, I think one of the most accessible ones is through the four seals. These are four philosophical positions which all Buddhist schools hold, and if there is something you might want to memorize at the end of this conference, it is these four seals. It is perhaps one of the most helpful topic topics to meditate upon.
They are seals because just as the seals on a letter, they guarantee the authenticity of the doctrine. So what are these four seals? All composite phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are suffering, everything is selfless, nirvana is peace and happiness. The essence of the Buddhist teachings is encapsulated here. You can therefore understand Buddhist teachings as occurring within the gangetic fold, the Buddha never explicitly mentions reincarnation is taken for granted, it is the shared body of teaching of all the gangetic fold, karma is a shared body of teaching of all the gangetic fold.
The biggest difference is the four seals. This is where Buddha Śākyamūni differs from all of the other Upanishadic teachers, and the difference is huge, because Buddha Śākyamūni’s original teachers were Upanishadic teachers, but they did not, they could not lead the Buddha to the attainment he wished for, and eventually he left them and forged his own path. So we will examine each of these four seals in detail, and I think at present we will pass from a purely philosophical expose to one which is much more rooted in actual reality, because the question has to be are these statements true or not? So the first seal, all composite phenomena are impermanent, and I always felt that a field of wheat in the wind describes this very beautifully. Composite phenomena are phenomena which are composed of parts.
In other words, everything which has parts will eventually see the separation of these parts. Now if you reflect on it carefully, it’s an extremely profound and perhaps disturbing statement. For instance, a marriage or any human relation is composed of parts, two people, a marriage is impermanent. Our body is composed of parts of cells, this body is impermanent. Societies in history are composed of parts, societies are impermanent, they disintegrate and they collapse.
Everything which has parts will die. It’s great, great material for meditation, and the death or the change is two fold. First, coarse impermanence, is the actual death, technically the end of the continuum of something, for instance my own death is the end of my continuum, my physical continuum, the death of a vase if the vase falls to the ground is the death, the end of the continuum of the vase, and subtle impermanence, which is the fact that phenomena change instant by instant. Now this is something which is so obvious for us who are raised in a scientific worldview, we don’t realize that until very recently things were considered permanent and unchanging until they collapsed. Like if you read late eighteenth century French or German philosophers, the notion of subtle impermanence is completely absent, and I had the most surreal conversation with a professor of philosophy at the University of Adelaide over lunch a couple years ago, in which he sort of he’s very well known.
He bent over and whispered to my ear, I would be ready to consider that things are impermanent. And this was in 2010. Now we have massive evidence from physics, chemistry and biology, that at the molecular, the atomic, the subatomic level phenomena are changing its and yet it has not permeated large waves of our society. So if we look to physics, what is the shortest interval of time measured so far? It’s twenty attoseconds, so zero point two followed by eighteen zeros seconds.
There is actually theoretical limit called the Planck limit, which is the smallest interval time theoretically measurable, we haven’t even come close, it’s ten to the minus forty four and something. So if this is the case, how do we make sense of the passages in Abhidharma in which it is taught that the shortest interval of time is onesixtieth of the time attempts takes to snap one’s fingers. It seems that the Buddhists were indeed the Great Buddhist thinkers were right in general to teach impermanence and subtle impermanence, but that the scale of the subtle impermanency they taught was totally off. In this case it is very helpful to approach the tradition with a traditional symbol of sympathy, and to examine carefully what is being said. What is not being taught is that the shortest interval of objective time is onesixtieth of the time it takes to snap one’s fingers, but that the shortest interval of perceivable time is onesixtieth of that interval, and the data has just started to flow in from cognitive psychology.
The minimum rate of perceptible change of sense data is known technically as a fusion threshold, under which things just fuse, perceptions fuse. For the eye is between twenty and thirty milliseconds, for the ear it is a shortest of all, it’s between two and five milliseconds, it has not been measured either for the olfactory or gustatory sense consciousnesses, for the tactile sense consciousness it is ten milliseconds, and therefore in my personal opinion, there is an important discrepancy between the maximal rate of physical change, Planck time, as I mentioned is ten forty four seconds, so I never memorized 5.39106, but that is Planck time, and the maximal rate of perceivable change by a human being. These figures are for human beings. We are dealing with sensory and conceptual figures which prevent the perception of even more rapid change, and as I mentioned in Abhidharma Vasu Bandhu says that according to the Vaibhāṣikas, and it’s a shared position of all the schools of tenets apart from Prāsaṇgika, the shortest interval of measurable time is onesixty fifth of the interval of a finger snap. Then I thought I would do an experiment.
So what I did, it’s a finger snap of a strong person, so I did some push ups before doing the measurement. I snapped my fingers 31 times, and I found I could snap them 31 times in ten seconds. Then you have to keep in mind when you snap your fingers they return, right? So there is an interval of the snap, and part of that interval is wasted returning. So if you consider the actual finger snap is zero one seconds, because a complete finger snap is zero thirty one seconds, one sixty fifth of that is approximately one point five milliseconds.
If you go back to the data, you can see we are exactly in the range, and this is quite astonishing. There is no possible way these ancient Buddhist meditators and thinkers could have access to this information, unless they developed levels of awareness which is so high that they were aware of each instant of subsequent perception. This is I think what happened. I think that this figure was basically put down in writing by an Arhat, who trained in meditative equipoise, limpidity, and focused on breathing, and was able to identify each subsequent interval of visual or auditory perception, probably tactile perception it would not have been possible, And then was able to give an estimate of the fusion threshold, the rate of physiological changes is detectable, which corresponds to modern data, and this data from cognitive psychology is some six or seven years old, it’s only six or seven years ago that this started to be studied, it was possible to do so. So certainly as far as the described rate of change, the Vaibhāṣikas and the scholars of Abhidharma were dead on.
Then the second seal, all contaminated phenomena of the nature of suffering, and I thought nothing represents this better than Edouard Munch’s painting, you all have probably seen or heard of The Scream. So in Buddhist standpoint suffering is subdivided into three broad categories: pain, in other words, the suffering of suffering, which we all recognize, and then Buddha went much further in his analysis of suffering than anyone up to that day. When it considered that pleasure also was suffering, and that for that matter every single experience of an ordinary being was either suffering or neutral. Now this is something which might seem the seem to be the outcome of extreme pessimism, and therefore we must analyze carefully Buddha Śākyamūni’s statement. A clear for the suffering of suffering, the example of cancer is one, you know, we all are aware of, but to say to a modern Westerner that love is suffering or that eating chocolate cake is suffering will elicit guffaws of laughter, and to say that everything is suffering would probably lead to people calling the men in white.
So what precisely is the Buddhist position? If we start by looking at a hierarchy of pleasures from the coarsest pleasures, sexuality, food, urination, defecation, generally speaking connected with sphincters, the opening of the closing of sphincters, to the higher levels of pleasure, social pleasure such as conversation, even higher levels of pleasure, abstract and aesthetic pleasures, the pleasure for instance of mathematics for those who are mathematicians is a very high level of pleasure, to what Buddhists consider to be the highest level of pleasure, the pleasure of meditation, of concentration. Every single one of these pleasures in this analysis is actually of the nature of suffering, and this becomes very clear if we analyze the flow of sensation. So I plotted here in abscissa time and in ordinate the intensity of a given painful stimuli, let us say having one’s arm pinched. At the beginning, as suffering increases in intensity, let’s say, I don’t encourage you to do this, just do it myself, as you increase, because otherwise you know people will wonder about us, as I press my arm ever more, the suffering increases steadily.
Then at a point if I stop pressing my arm, will note that the sensation of suffering faints. I don’t decrease the pressure, but I stop increasing it, there’s a neutral sensation. If I release the pressure, there is a sensation of pleasure. So you can see that the increase in suffering is seen as suffering, the lack of change or approximate lack of change as a neutral sensation, and a decrease in suffering as happiness and pleasure. This cycle of suffering, neutral sensation and suffering of change encompasses all of human existence and this is what Buddha called all pervasive suffering, the suffering of an ordinary being.
Now if we throw in this chart the threshold of attention, most of us have thank heavens mental filters, block most of the unpleasant sensations we deal with, and if you have ever done Satipatthana meditation, insight meditation, where you focus on expanding your awareness, the first experience you will have is one of intolerable suffering. Your entire body is filled with itches and cramps and aches and pains, and people feel like jumping out of their skin. It is not that the suffering is newly arisen, is that one’s threshold of attention or one threshold of inattention should I say, has been lowered. Much which is filtered is now evident. So this is the same chart with the pain threshold, which really is the threshold of inattention.
Everything under this threshold we are unaware of. So we do go through life with the impression impression that there are large swathes of life in which we neither experience happiness nor pain, And this is broadly speaking due to the presence of these filters. Any increase in pain is perceived as a suffering of suffering, more rapid the increase the greater the sensation, and any decrease in pain is perceived as as pleasure. The sharper the decrease, the greater the pleasure. So here great pleasure would be experienced, here less pleasure would be experienced.
This enables us to account for the beauty of music. The key to the beauty of music, which is a big problem for me when I was a young Buddhist, because how do you account for aesthetics, is simply the alternance from disharmony to harmony. Disharmony is unpleasant, the resolution of disharmony is pleasant, it’s the end of a suffering this leads to a pleasurable sensation, or the art of music is to build up a disharmony and lead to its resolution. You can actually construct an entire Buddhist account of aesthetics on this basis. So this leads us to the third seal: all phenomena are empty and selfless and the onion is a marvelous metaphor for this.
Now here I must open a parentheses those of you who are following the tenets class will find this accessible, the others please take what you can. We have to introduce a concept which is central to Buddhism, is a distinction between affirmation and negation or affirmative and negative phenomenon. From a Buddhist standpoint every phenomenon is either an affirmative phenomenon or a negative phenomenon. Negative phenomena can be either implicative or non implicative. Now an affirmative phenomena or an affirmation is simply something which is not understood through refuting its object of negation.
It’s quite straightforward. For instance, this laser pointer is something I understand without understanding the opposite of the laser pointer. I don’t need to know what the opposite of the laser pointer is to understand this laser pointer. It is therefore an affirmative phenomenon. Most of the phenomena in this room are affirmative phenomena, but from the Buddhist standpoint, the road to wisdom lies through meditating on a negative phenomenon.
Therefore negative phenomena, absences if you wish, are extremely important. A negation or a negative phenomenon is understood by means of the direct severance or refutation of its object of negation. For instance, if you take the absence of trees, trees are the object of negation, the absence of trees is a negative phenomenon because you cannot understand it without understanding first the negation of trees. So far so good, pretty much. Now negations are twofold, some imply something else, some don’t.
Those which imply something else, in a little bit after you’ve negated the object of negation, something is left, are implicative negations. For instance, if you take the hillside devoid of trees, Trees is your object of negation. It must be understood for the negation to occur. Once you have negated trees, however, hillside is left. Therefore, is an implicative negation.
Hillside devoid of trees or man with no money are implicative negations. You negate trees or money, you are left with hillside or man. Non implicative negations on the other hand would simply be the absence of trees. Once you negate trees, you are left with nothing, just the absence of trees. Now this is extremely important because from a Buddhist standpoint emptiness is a non implicative negation.
Once you negate its object of negation, you are left with nothing else. If you were left with something, would be meditating on an affirmation, and it could not act as an antidote to the delusions. So it is perhaps one of the most central points in Buddhist philosophy. I won’t belabor it, but I thought I would bring it up. We do have a fair number of students who do study tenets, and for them it would be really obvious.
For the rest of you, I think you can get a flavor of what is being said. So within the third seal, all phenomena are selfless and empty, what is the selflessness which is taught? If we take the magnificent sūtra of the lack of seven characteristics in the Pali Canon, Anattalakkhana Sutta, there’s a beautiful passage and you can see that the emptiness which is taught in the sūtra of the Pali Canon is remarkably close to the Prasanika Mādhyamika understanding of emptiness. Buddha said, bhikṣu’s form is not the self, feelings is not the self, perceptions are not the self, determinations are not the self, consciousness is not the self, in other words within the five aggregates there is no Ātman, there is no self to be found. This is in direct contradiction to the position of all the Upanishadic teachers, for whom what was left within the aggregates is the Ātman, this is the soul, this is what transmigrates, this is what accumulates Karma and so forth.
Bhikshus, how do you conceive it? Is form permanent or impermanent? Impermanent. Now what is impermanent? What is painful since subject to change?
Is it fit to be regarded as mine, I or myself? No. You can see here an explicit teaching of the non-self nature of the person. So bhikṣu is any kind of form, in other words matter, whatever, is not mine, is not I, is not myself. And this leads to the following state, bhikshus, when a noble follower, a disciple who has heard the truth sees us, he finds estrangement in form.
He has no attachment to form, he finds estrangement in feeling, in perception, in determinations, in consciousness. When he finds estrangement, passion fades out, with the fading of passion he is liberated. This is how meditation on the selflessness of the person and of the aggregates leads to liberation from the Buddhist standpoint. From the Upanishads Upanishads standpoint it is exactly the opposite. Through identifying the Ātman within oneself and seeing it at one as one with Brahman, one is liberated.
You can see that where the Gangetic foundation is the same, the Upanishadic traditions in Buddhism proceed in radically opposite directions, even though they are aiming for the same goal, which is liberation. Now what precisely is this selflessness? Selflessness is subdivided into two: the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. The Hīnayāna, the lower vehicle considers that persons lack self, and distinguishes between subtle and coarse selflessness of persons. The Mahāyāna, the greater vehicle considers that in addition to persons, phenomena also lack self, and distinguishes between the subtle and the coarse selflessness of persons.
So the main distinction between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna from the standpoint of the view, is that for the Hīnayāna there is only a selflessness of persons. For the Mahāyāna there is both a selflessness of persons and of phenomena. And we will not enter the surfaces of phenomena here, that is really being covered in the tenets class, it’s a little bit complicated, but we will focus on the common position of all the Buddhist schools regarding the selflessness of persons. This is the main position which is accepted by all schools. When Buddhists say that persons are empty of a self, what do they mean?
They mean that the Upanishadic ātman, the Upanishadic soul does not exist. In other words, they mean that persons are empty, in other words are not permanent, one and independent. They mean that when you take the person just constituted of the five aggregates, and we will talk very shortly about the five aggregates, and you eliminate these five aggregates, nothing is left. There is no soul inside which is unchanging, which has no parts and which depends on nothing else. This is a fundamental difference.
The Buddhist difference is here. In other respects, the Buddhist position is very similar or identical to the Upanishadic position. It is as far as the Ātman, the individual soul is concerned, and the Brahman, God is concerned, that Buddhism is different. There is no Ātman and there is no Brahman, there is no soul and there is no God. So regarding the person’s being empty of being permanent, we have already talked about impermanence in the first seal, I won’t repeat what was said, this means that the person changes instant by instant.
Literally every single instant of ourselves is different from every subsequent instant. In the same way as my rosary, the only thing which maintains continuity really would be the string of the rosary and the string itself changes instant by instant as well. So the metaphor which is often given in the Pali Canon is a stack of dice. You stack dice on top of each other, nothing connects them, but yes, yet they stay stacked on top of each other. These are the instance of the person.
There is nothing like the Ātman which binds them together. What is meant when one asserts that the person is empty of being one or unitary? This means that the person is multiple, it has numerous parts like these pebbles and what are these parts? The Buddha identified five parts, he could have identified six or three, the key was that he identified parts. These are called the aggregates.
Skanda in Sanskrit or aggregate means a heap of grain. There’s the parts themselves are constituted of other parts and not further parts, it’s just a concatenation of parts. One of these parts is matter, that’s our body, it’s called the form aggregate. The second is sensation, pleasant, neutral and unhappy sensations. The third is discrimination, the capacity to recognize.
This is Alan, this is Chris, the aggregate of discrimination operates. The fourth is compositional factors, which includes everything else pretty much, but mainly karma, all karma goes in the fourth aggregate, and the fifth is consciousness. My eye consciousness, let’s say when I look at the color of the cushion, this goes in the fifth aggregate, my ear consciousness, nose, taste, bodily, mental consciousness, these are all in the fifth aggregate. Then I thought I would give you some passages from the great Śāstras, from Vasubandhu’s work and Asaṇga’s work on the topic. Asaṇga I will quote as long as he does not explicit the Chitamatra view, which draws us too far afield.
Then these are translated. Vasubandhu’s Abhidharma Kosha and Asaṇga’s Abhidharma Samuccaya are both translated in English. From a French translation, the translation is good enough. I would certainly encourage you to read the Abhidharma Kosha, it’s a big work, but it’s extremely interesting. So according to Vasubandu, the form aggregate is the five sense organs, the eye, the ear, the nose, the tongue and the body, the five things which are perceived, in other words visual objects, sounds, smells, tastes, sensations, and that basically encompasses the form aggregate.
Now you can see that basically most of our life is in relation to the form aggregate. Most of the sensations we experience arise from matter, whether you’re visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory or tactile. It is very easy for us to consider that matter is all that exists, and this is a materialist position. So if we explicate Vasubandhu’s position, we can see that the form aggregate includes the five sense organs and the five sense objects. This, the five sense objects, is the exterior world.
This, the five sense organ of the five sense objects, is the field of investigation of science. It is therefore very easy for science to consider that since this is its field of investigation, and afterward this is all that lends itself to investigation with material tools. This is all that exists, it’s a modern fallacy. So as a system of investigation, the scientific system is extraordinary, but its scope is limited and the mistake which is made by all of us who are specialists in our field is to think that our field is the field. It’s a very human mistake.
Now the second aggregate, the aggregate of sensation according to Vasubandhu, are the painful, pleasant or neutral sensations. And then there are six sensations. What are these six sensations? They are the five sensory sensations, the five sensations connected with the sense organs, and the mental sense sensation. So we have pleasant or unpleasant visual sensations, pleasant or unpleasant sounds, smells, tastes, tactile sensations and mental experiences.
In most of the world suffering arises through the unpleasant sensations of the sense organs. In the West it arises overwhelmingly through unpleasant sensations of the mind. All of the mental suffering, depression, insanity, suffering which arises from anger, these are all sufferings which are rooted in the mind, in mental sensation. They’re not rooted in physical experiences most of the time. It’s quite striking when you speak with people who suffer from these ailments that the outer world has almost completely unrelated to their inner state of experience.
It might be very beautiful outside, everyone might be very kind to them, their life might be flowing very smoothly and the person is profoundly miserable. So this is perhaps a characteristic of a privileged society, where the inner suffering, which is normally hidden under this threshold of an attention, rises to the surface because the threshold of an attention is lowered. Then some come to Buddhist centers to find help, and they may derive some help from the Buddhist techniques. As I mentioned in the past, Buddhist meditation techniques are not designed for this, and therefore whatever help there might be is incidental. Asaṇga, Vasubandhu’s half brother, points out that and I often find Asaṇga fleshes out Vasubandhu’s statements remarkably.
The characteristic of the aggregate of sensation is that it is the karmic maturation of virtuous or non virtuous karmas. From a Buddhist standpoint this experience of pleasant or unpleasant sensations is not random, it occurs as a result of the maturation of past karma. Now this is a case for sensory sensations, if we see for instance a beautiful sunset and it generates a great feeling of happiness within us, this happiness is not just the result of seeing the beautiful sunset, it is a result from past karma which makes such an experience pleasant. Likewise with depression, which is an experience of the mental sensation of suffering. This arises from a past karma within the mind of the person.
This past karma matures and was often a very small, even non existent cause from the outside, tremendous inner suffering occurs. Tremendous inner suffering. And obviously this can be countered with medicine, you know, but one can counter mainly the symptoms. The root cause must be addressed, otherwise it is recurrent. And the third aggregate is the aggregate of discrimination, and Asaṇga points out it involves knowing the terminological imputation, in other words, the name which is assigned to an object.
When I see something and I say this is a table, this is a chair, this is a lamp, the aggregate of discrimination is operative. The fourth aggregate includes mainly Karma. Virtuous, non virtuous and neutral karmas are all placed in the fourth aggregate, And I have skipped the presentation of the fifth aggregate in Abhidharma Samuccaya because it is so closely rooted with Chitamatra, it would take us too far afield. It is just the aggregate of consciousness. The main feature of consciousness is said to be its clarity and cognitiveness.
Consciousness is clear, in other words non material, and cognitive, in other words, its only function is to reflect its object. If you try when you are looking at an object, let’s say this projector, to separate this projector from my eye consciousness which perceives a projector, I think you have a very hard time of it. We’ll be talking about it next week, if you’re still around, you’ll probably be dizzy. It is not possible. The two are blended, and yet it is obvious to us that the projector, the eye consciousness perceiving the projector, two different things.
But the eye consciousness perceiving the projector is like a mirror, what appears in it is a projector. Finally, within the presentation of the selflessness of persons, and we will go back a bit, as you remember we said persons for all Buddhist schools they are to being permanent, one and independent, we have to understand what the lack of independence is, and this is understood in two terms: for the lower schools of tenets is causal interdependence. Phenomena are causally interdependent, because they depend on causes and conditions. Persons are causally interdependent, for instance, every one of us in this room is here because our two parents met. Had they not met, we would not exist.
In my own case, my parents met in Chicago in America. They met there, because my father went to teach at a large university, Northwestern University there. Had he not gone, I would not exist. My father went to the University of Northwestern, because he was in Argentina as a war refugee. Had he not been in Argentina as a war refugee, he would not have gone to America.
He was an Argentina as a war refugee, because he had been a reserve officer in the Royal Yugoslav Army when the Nazis occupied. Had he not been a reserve officer, he would not have gone to Argentina, then he would not have gone to America, I would not have been born, and you can go back down the causal chain, you see that my present existence, in other words this present conversation or this teaching is really a teaching, is rooted in a chain of causes which goes back infinitely in time. If any one of these causes is absent, often very small causes, then in my case I would cease to exist, this teaching would not occur. So this is what is meant by the fact that the person is dependent on causes and conditions. This is the position of all the lower schools of tenets, the higher schools of tenets in addition assert that the person is dependent on the mind perceiving it, and this we will not enter into, this is a more advanced position.
But it is very helpful for us when we meditate, simple meditations, to meditate on these three features of the coarse selflessness of persons. Persons are impermanent, they are multiple and they are dependent. What does it mean that they are impermanent? It means that we change instant by instant. In other words, when you look at me, you say, that’s Ilya.
Strictly speaking this wrong. Strictly speaking the Ilya who came in the room one and a half hours, almost two hours ago, and the Ilya now are two different persons. We attribute a stability and a permanence to persons which is not there. Why is this important? Because it’s on this basis that anger and desire arise.
One of you are old enough to have heard this at least once in your life, someone you are very close to suddenly looks at you no longer with stars in their eyes with a very hurt expression and says you have changed. You have all heard this, right? What happened? You’ve been changing all along, but suddenly the discrepancy between the mental image that person has of you and the sense perception they have of you become so great, the mental image collapses, and at that point the person falls out of love. Then you have a divorce, you lose a lot of money, you get very upset, and you start all over again, right?
So if one meditates on the impermanence of the person, this will not happen, because persons with which our bodies and mind are seen as flows, continuums, it’s like a river which is flowing. Then the second feature, the multiplicity is extremely helpful, when we look at ourselves as just a heap of things, things and states of mind with no connecting thread, this is very powerful to transform the mind. And then obviously causal interdependence, if we can meditate on the chain of causality which leads to our present condition, it’s a profoundly transformative experience. Now when I was young it was not a formal technique of meditation, but it’s something I did very regularly and you might want to try it’s quite helpful. I would just sit in whatever posture I could sit in and start moving mentally back in time, going from a present experience to whatever cause led to that experience.
Let’s say for instance, to today 11/01/2014, my talking to you about wisdom in Buddhism. What is the cause of this? If I look back the cause is that I changed the topic from the difference between Svatāntrika and Prāsaṇgika to wisdom and Buddhism what is the cause of that that happened a month and a half ago the cause of that is something else what is the cause of that It’s not going back in time and you go back within your life into childhood, you just keep going backwards as far back as you can go. Most of us awareness stop begins around age three or four, with training you can go back much further. Then as you go back, you get a very clear sense that really this thing which we Westerner call freedom is very much a fantasy.
There’s a chain which has led to this conference. When I look back, is our business chain was determined. There is no I, it’s like a sort of little solid thing inside myself, is completely independent from anything else, which takes the decisions without being affected. This does not exist. It’s very powerful for one’s mind to start looking at things like that.
You can go back to the time of conception, you go back into your mother’s womb, logic through imagination, but you can, and then eventually if you train enough, they say you can go back to your previous lives. This is how the yogis, when we collect past lives, proceed. They go back, back, back. But their experiences in this life which you don’t understand, let’s say in dreams they try to find the cause, go back in time, eventually they understand that the mind is just like a river flowing from country to country, and the countries are the bodies, right? Leaves one country, go to another country, leaves that country, goes to a third country.
The mind just passes from country to country and this river of the mind itself changes all the time. You cannot stop and say this is the mind, it’s just a flow of water. Right? And the fourth seal, which I wanted to cover with you today, is that nirvana is peace. What Buddha asserts in the fourth seal is that there is such a thing as nirvana, liberation in other words.
It was not evident because there were schools in ancient India which said, I suppose you would call them the hyper realist schools, life is suffering and there is no liberation. The Buddha did not succumb to radical pessimism, said yes indeed, life is beset by the three categories of suffering, but there is a liberation and he taught the pastor liberation. However, the Buddhist schools disagree on the nature of this liberation. Some consider that nirvana is without remainder when one becomes an Arhat, so as I mentioned before, one becomes an Arhat, one therefore attains liberation, and at the end of that life at death, the lower schools of tenets, Sautrāntika and Vaibhāṣika, consider that everything stops. There is since basically we are propelled from life to life by karma, if all karma is eliminated, the engine of saṃsāra stops, we disappear.
Then some of the Chitamatrans, the so called true aspirant Chitamatrans, that the continuum of consciousness can be severed, but doesn’t have to be severed. Most of the Mahāyāna schools say that the continuum of consciousness is never severed, in other words, we do gain liberation, which death at the end of that life, but our mind then according to the Mahāyāna schools goes to a pure land, and remains in that pure land until we are drawn out of the bliss and our heart experience experiences and induced to enter into Mahāyāna, then precisely because we have gained liberation, we experience no suffering. Therefore our capacity to empathize with the suffering of others is very small, and as a result it takes us much longer to attain full enlightenment if we are an Arhat who enters newly the path of the Mahāyāna, then if we were to enter the Mahāyāna at once, simply because we have no empathy whatsoever. So to conclude this conference, I would like to point out that there are Western philosophers who came very close to an understanding of the Buddhist view. Two in particular, an ancient Greek philosopher Heraclitus, who lived some two thousand six hundred years ago, and a great British philosopher David Hume.
Heraclitus of Ephesus, who was known in Greek as a mysterious because his statement was so profound, lived between 535 and 475, before the Christian era. His works have disappeared, what are left are fragments, but the fragments are very profound. Some of them are profoundly Buddhist, whether you could find them in the Dhammapada, you could find them in Śāntideva, and they are very cryptic and powerful. One of them which always stuck in my mind is this aphorism: the Sun is new every day, but by extension the Sun is new every instant. There’s very clear understanding of subtle impermanence.
And a marvelous aphorism: In the same river we both step and do not step. We both are and are not. Do you understand the aphorism? Could anyone explain to me what Heraclitus is saying? There is No, it’s I put you on the track, he’s talking about identity.
Yes? You’ve got half. What about the other half? He’s saying that and its opposite. He is saying into the same river we both step and do not step.
We do not step it because as you said the river changes instant by instant, but he says we also step into it. Why? It’s the same river, because conventionally it is the same. It’s extraordinarily powerful. It’s a non Buddhist philosopher from the sixth century BC, and he has understood that phenomena change instant by instant, therefore we cannot say that if I step in the river today and tomorrow I’m stepping in the same river, at the same time we can and must say it, otherwise we cannot speak.
You could say he is positing conventional ultimate truths from the standpoint of impermanence. It’s very powerful, isn’t it? In the case of David Hume, it is clear to me that David Hume had an understanding of the full Buddhist sense of the term of the selflessness of persons. David Hume was contemporary of the great French philosopher Rousseau, lived between 1711 and 1776, remarkable man, probably I personally feel very strong Buddhist karmic imprints. He’s an excellent, kind, humble person, became professor of philosophy at the University of Edinburgh, was an atheist all his life, and built his philosophy on the analysis of perception.
If you want to read something fascinating in English, read Hume’s works. His Treatise on Human Nature and his Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. So Hume says in his Treatise of Human Nature: for my part, when I enter most intimately to what I call myself, I always stumble on some particular perception or other of heat or cold, light or shade, love or hatred, pain or pleasure. I can never catch myself at any time without a perception, and can never observe anything but the perception. I may venture to affirm to the rest of mankind that they are nothing, in other words mankind is nothing but a bundle of collection of different perceptions.
It’s extraordinarily closely related to the person not being unitary, which succeed each other with an inconceivable rapidity. It’s a presentation of impermanence, and are in a perpetual flux and movement. Thus, we feign the continued existence of the perception of our senses to remove the interruption and run into the notion of a soul and self and substance to disguise the variation. The soul, the concept of the soul is created to maintain the fiction of the permanence of the person. This is a Buddhist presentation and a very powerful one of the coarse surfaces of persons.
And therefore I hope that in this presentation I’ve been able to show how the three questions the Sufi master said encapsulated the difference in the view between different religious systems can be applied. When the mind thinks I, what thinks I? Does it have a beginning? Does it have an end? Then you can come up with your own criteria, but it’s extremely helpful and I think really important for us to proceed in this way, to see whether or not we wish to become a Buddhist, and if we do, to understand fully what it entails.
And studying Western philosophers such as David Hume or Heraclitus, Hume especially is very accessible, I cannot recommend his works too highly. Then I have finished for today, and if you have any questions, I’ll be very happy to take them. Perhaps we can pass the microphone around just so that we can all hear. I would add something regarding David Hume which though for those of you who are Buddhist is very significant. Hume never had an enemy, and when he died, he died in a state of great peace and happiness, which was extremely disturbing to the Scottish Presbyterian clergyman in Edinburgh, because they really felt that you should Hume should be in great terror of, you know, an imminent damnation, and Hume had the most remarkable death.
Hume was treated very badly by a friend of his, Rousseau, the great French philosopher, and he seems never to have borne the slightest grudge. So obviously, a very uncommon person born in a Western culture, who espoused of you as far as I can see, I have read both of his works, I read them when I was very young, which is completely Buddhist. Apart from the fact he never explicitly talked about reincarnation and karma. The concepts were little known at the period. The view is Buddhist and he reached it entirely by himself.
We cannot find an influence on him. So when we speak of Pratyekabuddhas, this is a sort of person we are speaking about. Someone has such powerful karmic imprints by themselves in a different society, they are able to just naturally reach the view and perfect the view. There seems to be a lot of contradictions in the Buddhist tradition. For instance in the Mahāyāna or particularly in the Vajrayana tradition there are deities and how does that fit in with this sort of atheistic worldview?
The term deity is very unfortunate. The big difference between the Mahāyāna and the Hīnayāna is that the Hīnayāna considers the goal of the Hīnayāna is liberation from cyclic existence for oneself. The Hīnayāna considers one cannot work for others, it’s up to each one of us to make our own liberation, if you wish. Once one attains liberation for the Hīnayāna, one ceases to exist. Cyclic existence is over.
The Mahāyāna considers that there is a greater goal than liberation, and that goal is to attain omniscience. This is only possible if we generate bodhichitta first, and then with bodhichitta meditate on emptiness. When we do this, we reach a state of omniscience. The mind is freed of all obstructions, it knows everything there is to know. At this point, to help others, we manifest as illusory beings in whatever aspect is appropriate for the culture.
These are the so called deities, they’re not deities, they be emanation bodies. They happen to have many arms in India because that was a tradition in India. I suppose in the West they could manifest as abstract forms, Westerners prefer abstract forms, like spheres or pyramids or hexagons, I don’t know, polyhedra, if you know, they would communicate since the main function of these beings is to teach. Then for us ordinary beings they can, if we practice enough purification, manifest in dreams. Yogis see them in meditative experiences, they can even manifest in a body.
Then such fully enlightened beings have only one aim, and that is to lead all of the beings to this state. There is in the Buddhist teachings, there are numerous teachings which were intended for people of different capacities, and when people have different capacities, you teach differently. You don’t teach let’s say to a child you will say that Santa Claus exists, to a teenager you will say that maybe he does, maybe he doesn’t, and an adult is strong enough to support the brutal truth, they never want a Santa Claus, right? So Buddha’s teachings are a bit the same. To some Buddha teaches that there is no omniscience, there’s only liberation, and at liberation consciousness ceases, because if your goal is to escape suffering, this is what will motivate you the most.
To others Buddha teaches that the universe is of the nature of mind and that one should strive for full enlightenment. To others again Buddha teaches that the universe is not of the nature of mind but a mere normal imputation. It depends on the trainee. Then what the ultimate view is, Buddhist schools are in strong disagreement and this is very wholesome disagreement because Buddhism is a logical and analytical tradition. In other words, you have to make up your own minds.
Does it answer a bit your question? Do you have other questions? Please? What was the? A big?
Dandruff. Oh, dandruff. Well, yes, because it’s fifteen years of a life which are wasted, right? Yes, it’s very good she died as a Roman Catholic. It’s certainly better than dying as nothing, but the problem is that fifteen years of her life from a Roman Catholic standpoint were wasted practicing something which would be of no help to her as a Roman Catholic.
I think the concept you’re taught in school is that all experiences can be valid. So you don’t think that practice in twenty years That’s Western bias, it’s a Western prejudice. It’s the biggest problem our students have. It’s moral relativism, everything is the same, right? So from a Buddhist standpoint, you have to ask a very simple question: is this true or not?
Then the Westerners don’t want to ask the question, right? So the idea is Roman Catholicism, Protestant Islam, Buddhism, materialism are all the same, it’s all a matter of outlook. Not really, like when it comes to the sciences, if I were to tell you it’s all the same, we could never fly a plane or drive a car, right? But the laws of physics are not all the same, you know, is it true or false? Then if you take the Buddhist teachings on impermanence, the question is is it true or is it false?
It’s actually true. You take the Buddhist teachings on selflessness are they true or are they false? They seem to be true. Then you take reincarnation because that’s perhaps the crux of the matter, right? Is reincarnation something which happens or is it just another of the many opinions people have?
Then there’s a lot of evidence in Stevenson’s research that reincarnation is really something which happens. Not only that, Stevenson’s work seems to indicate that there is something like karma which is operating. Then if that is the case, religious traditions which teach reincarnation are closer to the truth. Christianity is teaching reincarnation too, isn’t it? It’s more complicated than that.
Not really what happened was that Christianity and Alexandria in Egypt was very heavily influenced by Greek civilization, Plato taught reincarnation explicitly. Then when Christianity passed to Alexandria, the great Christian teachers like Origen actually were Platonists and they believed in reincarnation, so they amalgamated the two and Origen had some very strange ideas about reincarnation. Origen thought the stars had consciousness, and when we die in a big spheres of light bouncing, it was very particular, very particular. Then this was condemned very particular. This was condemned by the church in the fifth century, it was not present really before Origen and Clement of Alexandria, so that it was not present before the third century, was not present after the fifth century.
Then reincarnation has periodically made forays in both Judaism and Islam. In every single case you find it comes from Platonism, it comes from Plato, and Plato where Plato, the Greek philosopher of the fifth century BC, got his belief in reincarnation, we don’t know. We know Plato traveled to Egypt, that is pretty much established, and we know that there were important Indian trading colonies in Alexandria. So I have always thought there was a contact between Plato and Indian merchants, and perhaps through that Plato became familiar with the ideas of reincarnation, took them back with him to Greece and taught them. But if you look excuse me to return to your question, it’s really important to decide for oneself whether these issues can be settled or not.
Look at it this way, imagine that you’re are gifted, let’s say as a painter, and you instead of studying painting, you work as a carpenter, because you met a very nice carpenter, and you’re never very good at it, but you work as a carpenter, and you work, you work, you work, and a couple years before your death, you meet a marvelous painter, and you start painting, and you realize this is who you were and what you wanted to do all your life. Then you look back on those years as a carpenter as a gigantic waste. I have I’m not taking a moral position. I can see it touches very close to the bone. I and I know it does, which is why I mentioned because whenever I mentioned it, I don’t know if you know something about body language, everyone goes like this, like this, and if they could contort a little bit more than this, they would.
It cuts close to the bone because so many of our students are in that situation. So the thing to do is to become aware of it, and then a human life is short. So if really religions are something else than systems of opinions, it matters a lot to find the one which represents reality the most. If it’s just a system of opinion, then you could just cast dice, you know, choose whichever one you like, which is what a lot of people do. But the end result is that they never erect anything, right?
I mean I have known a lot of them in my life that they start by coming to the Buddhist Center, then they find Taoism is really interesting, then they go back to Zok Chien, because it’s like in between Taoism and Buddhism. I mean we have at least one case I know of, of a student of TBI who became an evangelical Christian and another one I know of a student TBI who became a Muslim. It’s very clear in these cases that something is fundamentally wrong. You’re going from one religious position like the Buddhist one which is atheistic and teaches there is no so, to evangelical Christianity which teaches the existence of a creator God and biblical literalism, or Islam which teaches the existence of a Creator God and submission to the Quran and the Sharia. It is clear that this is sign of great confusion.
So what should be done in this case is before commitment, the person should study. The person should study because commitments have weights. From a Buddhist standpoint, if you commit as a Buddhist and you break that commitment, karmically this is heavy. From a Christian standpoint, if you commit as a Christian and you abandon Christianity, this is a sin. Then all the religions traditions say this, maybe they’re onto something.
If they’re onto nothing, then I think not one of us should be in this room. Certainly in my case, if I really believed what you are saying, which is that it’s a matter of opinion. Well, I I let you bring the issue up with his holiness the next time he comes. I mean His Holiness was very disappointed, but I’m sure that you’d be able to present in such a light that he will see the great benefit. We’ve had a lot of them, you know, so the general sense I was involved in a program for the training of Western monks under the edges of His Holiness in India, it’s a real issue, it’s become an issue since 1989, since His Holiness received the Nobel Peace Prize.
So before 1989 Buddhism was confidential, The people we had typically, they had really they had studied by themselves, there was this real when they came to Buddhism it was a maturation of karmic imprints and a profound personal quest. Now Buddhism is almost the only game in town as far as religions are concerned, and we do get a lot of students who really are here because Christianity is not credible, Judaism is all about ritual observance, Islam has a poor reputation, Hinduism is confused, so what’s left? The default option Buddhism. It’s it’s become the default option. Then we have to encourage these students to leave.
We have to encourage them to go and find something which corresponds to their nature, otherwise it’s harmful for them because they spend a lot of time at the center, they might spend elsewhere, and it’s harmful for the spread of the Buddhist teachings in the West, because we don’t need a lot of students, but we need good students. What about the idea of at least there are karmic imprints being put on, you know, with that example? I mean, I understand what you’re saying, I mean, there is an argument that karmic imprints are being implanted and then in later lives only to fruition and that can people lead then people genuinely into the dharma rather than as a whatever led them to? Possibly, but basically the crux of this presentation was to show that the only core difference between Buddhism and the other religions is a wisdom aspect of the path. The method aspect of the path you can go from higher rebirth to higher rebirth as a Christian, a Muslim, a Jew, or Buddhist, even though you don’t accept their existence, it’s irrelevant.
If you practice virtue as a Muslim, a Jew, a Christian, a Hindu, you will go from higher rebirth to higher rebirth. You will not remember them, but you’ll have an endless stream of higher rebirths. If one does not practice ethics, even though one is a Buddhist, one will go from lower rebirth to lower rebirth. So what matters is a solid foundation for the practice of virtue. That solid foundation does not exist when the person is divided and has doubts.
That is the problem. If you are a sincere Christian, there’s no doubt, and on this basis we see how far Christians can progress, mean some of the Christian saints, like in France, extraordinary. Then Jews are extraordinary figures, the ancient rabbis. If however one is normally a Buddhist, but really one is not quite sure about reincarnation and karma as so so, and one drinks and one uses drugs and one engages in self indulgence, one will be reborn in the lower realms, even though normally one takes refuge every day. And that is why his holiness discourages conversion, because one needs a solid foundation on which ethics will be laid.
Then there are Westerners which are who are able to convert and have a solid practice, but as I showed you in these statistics, we are looking at very few people. If you remember the chart, we’re looking at three percent after ten years, right? Which means that 97% left. Now in France, France is not a mobile society, so people don’t sort like America, which means 97% came and the left. Now just leaving is okay, where it becomes problematical is if the person comes, takes refuge, takes lay vows, takes bodhisattva vows, takes tantric vows, gets a lot of initiations, a lot of commitments and then walks away from everything.
Then from a karmic standpoint there is damage. There is damage, you know, and the person who experiences the damage is that person. Their future practice as a Buddhist will be fragile. People who have broken once with the teachings, they leave again. I’ve seen this many times, you know.
And then the the lack of clarity is a big problem. This is why selflessness must be very clearly explained. We have many so called Western Buddhists who are crypto Hindus. They believe that the soul reincarnates from life to life to life to life, then the very difference in Buddhist essence is not there. So I’m sorry, expanded a lot on your question.
Do you have other questions? Thanks, and this is probably along the same lines actually. Those figures I think they’re probably they’re accurate I’m sure but I’m sure they would also apply to other religions. The same drop off in fact probably just about any human endeavour I think would reflect. I don’t know I think religions are unique all human beings but religions it’s extreme.
But anything that needs a commitment or implies a commitment, that’s probably the same. So I don’t think we should be fearful of that and that’s the end of the statement. What worries me a little bit, I am thinking, speaking subjectively, I came to TBI because I had a belief in rebirth, not a faith. I actually believed it. I worked it out, and I thought that must be the way.
So I don’t have faith. And I don’t know the Christian system that will. I’ve I’ve heard the names of Noah and Jesus and but I don’t know the story. I honestly don’t know. What you’re telling me is that I should actually now go and study that.
No. In your case, no. You see, if you came to TBI with already a belief in reincarnation, then you are one of a minority of Westerners who have some type of connection. But when I came here in 2008, I found that more than half I would say of Rinpoche’s older students did not believe in reincarnation, and I had some very very surprising and disturbing conversations with students who had everything. Refuge, lay vows, bodhisattva vows, tantric vows, commitments, you name it, And who actually, when we started talking, because I was a Westerner, were quite frank, and I realized that the very basics weren’t there.
Then this is clearly something Rinpoche has seen many times now, and it had become necessary to start to cleanse things and Rinpoche started telling to students that they were not welcome at TBI anymore, you know, it had become necessary. I’ve had to translate a series of letters and to say to students that Rinpoche said that they were no longer welcome here, because the basics of Buddhist belief were not there. Then this is a Buddhist temple, it is clear that if very very basic components are absent, the person is not benefiting, and there are other things he might be doing. Then the situation has changed a lot also, when I was young people very strongly connected to Christianity, now it’s not the case, but it’s still part of the culture, and it is really necessary to make this clear. You’re very right, in one respect our culture is a culture of absence of commitment.
We cannot commit to marriages, we cannot commit to jobs, to relationships, to people, and we tend to view religious traditions in the same way. This is harmful to ourselves, this is harmful to the religious tradition. So I think that’s why His Holiness has become very very clear, it’s something he does systematically now. If you attend a teaching of His Holiness in Australia, in France, in England, His Holiness explains the great world religions, the differences, and says, this is every time, I do not encourage the conversion of Westerners, I think it is better for people to rely on the traditions of their ancestors. If you want to become a Buddhist, think carefully, study and then become a good Buddhist.
Well, is not my own position, you know, at all, and I think it is the way forwards, because when we have figures like this, something is wrong, something seriously wrong. You have to look at it as an investment. I always find that way of looking at things works very well for us. If you’re going to invest, let’s say, in a bond or share, you’re going to a lot of trouble, right? You have money, you’re investigating to share, you have to study, etc.
You want a return, a benefit. If after buying, let’s say, it won’t happen with Australian government bonds, but let’s say you bought a Chinese government bond, assuming it was possible, you did all your research and you bought a thirty year bond, you put your money in, you were expecting let’s say let’s say 4% per annum, let’s assume, right? If after all of that you did not derive a benefit, it would be a huge waste. If you lost money, would be an even greater waste. Why?
Because if you had done nothing, at least you would have the same money you had when you started with. But not only don’t you have the same money, you went to effort and you lost. Now with spiritual practice, it is the same thing. It is a lot of work, a lot of study. If we cannot point at a clear benefit at the end of the life, this is a huge waste, but in the case of that poor lady, perhaps she would have been happier, and it would have been less of a waste of time if she had just lived a quiet life without any religious commitment, or had just remained a regular churchgoer.
Then we have huge efforts, study, trial, and at the end she abandoned everything, which is karmically really heavy. Well, we hope she did. One thing is sure and that is that that karma will ripen, so if she had refuged bodhisattva, tantric vows, commitments and it’s all been abandoned, then a lower rebirth is certain, if not in the next life, in a future life, it’s a given. And therefore before you take refuge, you take bodhisattva vows, you take tantric vows, take commitments, must see from your side whether you believe in this or not. I mean, is excuse me for being brutal, there is a lot of lying and hypocrisy in many of our centers.
The teachers sincerely believe the students are taking vows and commitments, and the student is there and part of the mind is hesitant and doubtful. This is a hypocritical state of mind. It’s a lie. It’s a spiritual lie. This is very heavy.
This is not light. It is better not to do this. It is better to stand back saying, well, I don’t believe in this. It’s perfectly okay. What you come for as long as one wants to teachings without ever taking commitments, that’s also perfectly okay.
I always suggest to people that if it is not in their heart, they should not prostrate. You do not prostrate to Tony Abbott, do you? You should, he’s Prime Minister of Australia. Then you prostrate to a teacher here, then is that level of veneration truly present in our mind or not? If it is not there, we are lying.
We’re lying in public, it’s hypocrisy. We’re lying to look good to fit in the community, this is what Geshela denounced on Wednesday, this is not a social club here, we’re not here to fill the lives of people who have nothing to do on the side. I have a long list of social traps I’m happy to give you. This is a religious structure, it is open to all who wish to study the Buddhist teachings, but we really must encourage people to be sincere, and it came to the floor I remember in 2008, Rinpoche was given the Yamāntaka teachings, and I was just very surprised at the number of students who had taken commitments, broken the commitments, left, it was just astonishing, and I proposed to Rinpoche that the commitments be put in writing and signed. We prepared a form, it was amounted to I recognized it there but hereby to taking Khensur Rinpoche as my spiritual teacher for this life and all future lives, reciting this and this every day, doing this in this retreat, whatever the commitments were signed and dated.
Normally it’s self evident, right? We had a funeral. I think Chris remembers. We had people rebelling, two people formally refused to sign it, then the furor brought out the problem. It made it very clear that the verbal commitment was meaningless.
People said they could say anything, there would be no consequences, but when they had to sign, suddenly it was a contract and Westerners are afraid of contracts. Obviously how would we enforce something like that? We’re sue someone because they didn’t keep their commitments, right? But do you see it was very striking and now it is standard practice, the written commitment signed before people inscribed for teachings, and it’s on that basis that they accepted or not. We have to do this, you know, for the students and for the center.
So the key basically is to be as sincere in one’s religious practice as one would be in one’s personal relationships. Like if people were behaving like this in their relationships, it really would be seen as very bad. If you say to someone that you really like them and you don’t, it’s really bad, isn’t it? And if you string them along to see how it’s going to go, and other people learn about this, you are seen as, you know, worse than nothing, aren’t you? So why is it bad in personal relationships and it’s okay at the dharma center or the church?
You see? It should be the other way around. It should be that the dharma center, the church, when its religious practice, is the highest level of commitment, and other things are below. So I don’t want to go too much into this, but it’s something I’ve brought up several times here. It is very much in keeping with the instructions of instructions of Khensur Rinpoche.
You can be a very good materialist, and as a materialist you can have very good future rebirths if you practice ethics. You will have very good future rebirths in a happy life as a Jew, Christian, Muslim, Buddhist, but you must be sincere. It is not necessary to be a Buddhist to have good future rebirths. Then it is impossible to gain liberation if you are not a Buddhist, but most people do not want to gain liberation. So it is sort of a moot point.
You have any other questions before we separate? Then thank you very much. My apologies if I was a bit forceful, but it only is helpful if one speaks directly and frankly. Very informative and always challenging cutting down to what really matters a lot of food for thought and thank you so much Ilya for bringing us your wisdom today. So if you in a traditional Australian manner.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.