Calm Abiding – 2012-09-30 – KR

1 h 51 min · 4,142 words · 30 September 2012

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding - 2012-09-30 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Teaches on calm abiding (shamatha) meditation, explaining meditation as habituation of the mind to an object and the need for a stable object. Covers the three mental factors of concentration, recollection (memory) and vigilance, the elephant-and-rope metaphor, the faults of agitation and sinking, and short session lengths for beginners. Includes a short question and answer session at the end.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 52m

UUID: bf6d1fbb-24fc-4ebf-909a-2a9381e4f1c2

Date: 2012-09-30

Words: 4,138

Geshela had a meeting this morning from 08:00 onwards with representatives of the Tibetan community. They’re now heading downtown to the embassy. And then he hasn’t had time to put a lot of preparation. Geshela, because he had to be involved in these discussions this morning, and from his side, he was not able to enter in detail in the preparation. Therefore, when we come to a detailed presentation today, if there are, from time to time, some approximations, he would like to apologize.

So in the context of calm abiding, we are speaking of meditation, gom in Tibetan. Then what exactly do we mean by the term gompa in Tibetan? Gompa is actually a verb which is related to the verb kompa, which means to become accustomed to. So when we speak of meditation, this is what we are speaking about. So we can meditate on numerous topics.

We can meditate on impermanence. We can meditate on emptiness, on bodhichitta, on forbearance, on compassion. Here, we are meditating on calm abiding. We should try to understand what we mean in this context by meditation or Gompa. Then if we take an example, which is meditation on impermanence.

What do we mean when we say we meditate on impermanence? There are in this context, two phenomena to be considered. The object of meditation, is impermanence, and the mind which is meditating on impermanence. When we say that the mind meditates on impermanence, we mean that the mind becomes accustomed over and over again to the concept of impermanence, which initially does not appear nakedly to the mind, but dawns to the mind through what is known as a meaning generality, in other words, conceptually. And eventually over time through this continuous process of habituation, the mind sees impermanence in the same way as we see a table.

This is what we mean by meditation on impermanence. So so when we’re speaking of meditation, it is therefore important to understand what we’re talking about. We are talking of both an object and a habituation of the subject to that object, of the mind to that object. Then regarding the number of possible meditations, they are countless. If we take for instance the generation of bodhichitta by the twin processes of the seven fold cause and effect generation of bodhichitta and the interchange of self and others generation of bodhichitta.

In both cases, the latter minds become more and more powerful, independent on the generations of the preceding minds. In the case of the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhichitta through generating ever higher mental levels of love and compassion, the resultant, which is the mind of bodhichitta becomes ever more powerful and as a result, we move ever closer to full enlightenment. This is what would be meant by meditation on bodhichitta. We should think about this ourselves. This is the most pleasant and helpful way to go about things.

If we take the case of meditation on great compassion. Meditation on great compassion is the cause for bodhichitta. And it is said that bodhichitta has two aspirations. The first is an aspiration which is focused on all sentient beings, which takes all sentient beings as its object and the second is an aspiration which is in the aspect of aspiring to attain, wishing to attain full enlightenment. This bodhichitta with two aspirations is generated ever stronger as in turn we generate an ever stronger great compassion which acts as its cause.

And since bodhichitta is in the aspect or the aspect of bodhichitta is utter full enlightenment, the attainment of utter full enlightenment. The greater the bodhichitta, the faster the attainment of utter full enlightenment. Now in the context of meditation on calm abiding, initially, one must talk of the object of observation. We can choose whichever object of observation we wish to choose and Geshela explained this clearly yesterday. For beginners such as ourselves, the most important is to become accustomed to the object of observation and one can choose whichever object of observation one wants.

For instance, Geshela said, in India, many generated calm abiding on the basis of the horns of a goat which in Tibetan is pronounced exactly the same way as the Bodhisattva Subhuti that was the problem. Then, it is perfectly possible to generate a calm abiding on this basis. Mhmm. Now for us beginners, in the practice of calm abiding, what is critical when we meditate on the object of observation is for the object of observation to be stable. Now what do we mean when the object of observation is stable?

We obviously are referring to a stability of the mind which observes the object of observation. What does this stability of the mind which observes the object of observation come from? It comes from recollection, from in Tibetan. And this is why it is said in Jetsongkapa’s concise stages of the path, hence powerful yogis continually rely on concentration to overcome the foe of distraction. As Geshela explained yesterday, powerful and powerful yogis refer to yogis striving for calm abiding.

And here, distraction is a mental affliction whose function is to turn the mind away from its object of observation. By which means, do the powerful yogis overcome the foe of distraction through recollection. Recollection whose nature is one of retaining the object of observation and whose function is to be in harmony with the object of observation as opposed to distraction whose function is to move the mind away from the object of observation. Observation. And therefore, for beginners in calm abiding, it is recollection or memory which is critical for maintaining the stability of the object of observation and this is corroborated by Lamrim Cemo by the great stages of the path.

The most important factor for attaining abiding, the most important cooperative conditions which are favorable for the attainment of calm abiding are the six preconditions or the six collections for calm abiding which were explained yesterday. And which include among other living in a favorable environment, having few desires, having contentment, not engaging in numerous activities and so forth. Of all of these, His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said that in a nutshell, what is critical to attain calm abiding is temporarily to abandon all other activities. This means to abandon all activities such as work, business, working in the fields, all of which involve mental distraction. For instance, if you wanted to have an idea of how to generate calm abiding, the best way to go about it would be to go for two weeks on Kangaroo Island all alone as a hermit and see how things work out to get an idea of the conditions you need.

Otherwise, it is not possible to attain it. Oh, if you just go for one day. One day, we will go Kangaroo Island. We will go to Kangaroo Island. If you really want to meditate on calm abiding that is.

This is the case because normally our mind is always moving outwards towards the sense objects. Then when we start training in calm abiding, we want to withdraw the mind inwards before focusing it on the object of observation. Then if we were to take an example to make all of this clearer, let’s take the example of a mother who has only one child whether it be a little boy or a little girl. Then whatever the mother does in her daily life whether she’s eating, sleeping, walking, working, her mind is actually always on her child. She’s always thinking of her child naturally.

Then what part of the mind is leading that mother’s mind to continually think about her little boy or her little girl? What part? That’s recollection or memory. So there’s a very big risk issue that the mother might generate calm abiding with the child as its bases. Geshele is speaking of the object of observation of calm abiding then obviously you have to check the motivation of the mother and continually thinking of her child.

And clearly this is just a simile because the mother is thinking of a lot of other things as well. And the mother is actually aware in the same way as if she was grasping it with her hand, with her very hand, of everything her little boy or her little girl is doing. Whether the little boy is eating, whether he is going to school, whatever he is doing she is aware of. Now what is the force, the mental force which leads the mother to that degree of concentration on her child, on her child’s welfare? It is a maternal love which is akin to memory or recollection in the context of calm abiding and this is why we can use this as an example for focusing on the object of observation.

And in addition to this, any practice of calm abiding must be held by a good motivation or with a good motivation. This can be a motivation of renunciation or a motivation of bodhichitta. In which cases, calm abiding becomes respectively the cause for liberation or full enlightenment. So holding calm abiding with such a motivation, in turn, we engage in the practice of calm abiding which is a visualization of the image of Buddha Śākyamūni in accordance with Lamrim Chenmo, the great stages of the path whose main source in the matter is Kamalaśīla’s middling stages of meditation. Kamalaśīla’s middling Bhāvanākrama.

Then at present, we will engage in a couple of minutes, in this visualization of the body of Buddha Śākyamūni after adopting adopting the eightfold posture of Vairochana which is extremely important for any type of realization. How was the meditation? Hey. Really? Then if we analyze what happens during such a meditative session, once we have focused the mind single pointedly on the object of observation and we keep it, we have kept it there with the rope of memory or recollection, irrespective of what happens around us, we are unaware of this.

For instance, when we are focused in this way on our object of observation, even though Carol is speaking in the kitchen and actually the voice of Carol, the sound of the voice of Carol enters our ear organ and activates the tympanum. Nonetheless, our ear sense consciousness does not perceive the sound of Carol’s voice. Technically speaking, in these matters, the ear sense consciousness which perceives Carol’s voice is what is known as an inattentive mind or in Lorig, a mind which appears but is not ascertained. Then because we haven’t studied Lorig yet, this is a concept which is difficult for us to understand. But the same thing applies to all sense consciousnesses.

We may be meditating, for instance, with our eyes open. Nonetheless, even though phenomena appear in front of our eyes, they do not register on the eye consciousness. Only the mental consciousness is active. For beginners such as all of us in this room, it is better to keep our eyes half open and our gaze focused on the tip of our nose. We could keep our eyes fully open, but if we did this, we would probably move outwards with our consciousness captivated by objects of the senses.

There are major advantages in adopting the body of the Buddha as one’s object of observation among others that we will be able to visualize it clearly within the death process and likewise that we will have a very clear visualization of the body of the Buddha when for instance we perform the seven limb Puja. There is a very great difference between performing, for instance, a seven limb puja with a clear visualization of the body of Buddha Śākyamūni and performing it without that visualization. With a clear visualization, we accumulate a huge number of roots of virtue which are more difficult to accumulate without this. For this reason, it is said in the Lamrim that this clear visualization of the body of the Buddha is very helpful. And therefore, we will meditate during nine or ten minutes on whatever our chosen object of observation is, it is up to ourselves.

We’re keeping in mind that we are at present within the second outline of the graduated stages of the path which is focusing the mind upon that and that here refers to the object of observation. When we engage in this practice, we will do so with a mind which cannot yet be called a mind of calm abiding, but it can be called a Samādhi or a concentration which will become of the nature of calm abiding eventually. And with this Samādhi or this concentration, we will focus on the object of observation we have chosen. One, trying to maintain two factors simultaneously. Both the factor of stability of the object of observation and the factor of clarity.

And we will keep in mind that when this concentration or this Samādhi is affixed to its object of observation by the rope of memory or recollection, the two main obstacles to the two qualities which are trying, we are trying to develop, which are the factor of stability and the factor of clarity of the object visualized are respectively agitation and sinking. When agitation arises, in other words, when the mind is scattered outwards, then this agitation harms the factor of stability of the object visualized. Whereas, when sinking arises, in other words, the mind is withdrawn inwards too much, the sinking harms the factor of clarity. And having therefore fixed the mind of concentration to its object of observation with the rope of recollection or memory. The function of recollection is to keep the mind on its object of observation.

On the other hand, we do need another mind which checks periodically to see whether distracted. In other words, has moved away from its object of observation or not. This second mind is known as vigilance. So both memory or recollection and vigilance are necessary. Generally speaking, most main minds are accompanied by five accompanying mental factors.

These are aspiration, observation, recollection or memory, concentration and wisdom. There is an affinity between the third and the fourth of these mental factors. In other words, between concentration on the one hand, which ascertains the object and recollection or memory on the other hand. Both of which are focused on the object of observation. Now, to simplify things within the context we are working with, which is a generation of calm abiding, when we meditate on an object of observation, that main mind is accompanied by three mental factors.

These three mental factors are concentration, recollection and vigilance. We can definitely postulate the existence of a main mind accompanied by those three mental factors. This is difficult for you but if you reflect on it, there will be real benefit. So even though this is difficult, it is really helpful to analyze in this way. If we analyze how the main mind, which is focused on its object of observation in the process of generation of concentration functions, the main mind is focused on its object of observation and this main mind has mental factors which are of the same nature as it.

These mental factors include, in this case, concentration or Samādhi, which is the factor of ascertainment of the object and it will also include another mental factor which is recollection whose function is to prevent the main mind from moving away from its object of observation. It’s difficult. How’s it going? Is it hard? This is not easy.

It’s not something we’re accustomed to, but if we become accustomed to it and reflect on it, it will really help us in our practice. And in turn of these three mental factors within the main mind focused on its object of observation, the foremost for us is recollection or memory. The mental factor of recollection or memory has three characteristics or three features. The first is its object, the second is aspect, and the third is function. The object of recollection is an object which has previously been experienced.

Its aspect is the aspect of non forgetfulness and its function is to prevent distraction to other objects. So when we now meditate on our object of observation, irrespective of which one it is, we must do so with these three mental factors which are Samādhi or concentration, recollection and vigilance associated with that meditation, keeping in mind the three factors or the three features of recollection object, aspect and function. And now, when we meditate on whatever object of observation we have chosen, we must do so with a recollection, which is of the nature of remembering or recollecting a previously ascertained object of observation of this nature, which is of an aspect of not forgetting this object of observation and which is of a function of not moving to another object of observation. Taking for instance our topic of study, the great treatise of the stages of the path, the Lamrim Chenmo. What in this context would be the aspect of recollection of such a topic?

The aspect of recollection or memory of the topic Lamrim Chenmo would be the non-forgetting, the unforgetfulness of whatever was taught in the context of And to understand this better in terms of an example, you can observe or look at the handout which I translated for you on the nine stages of mental development in which the mind is compared to a wild, savage, crazed elephant, which has to be tied down, which has to be bound to the pillar of the object of observation with the rope of recollection or memory. Now precisely because the mind is such a wild animal, one needs a particularly strong rope to tie him down to a particularly firm pillar, traditionally an iron pillar. And one restrains him initially with the rope of recollection and in addition with the hook of vigilance, one checks periodically whether the mind has strayed from its object of observation or not and if it has, with the hook of vigilance, the elephant herder, the mahut of ancient India chastises the mind and brings it back to the object of observation. This metaphor for mental development on the path of calm abiding is a traditional Buddhist metaphor which comes from the heart of And therefore as Nāgārjuna says, tie the wild elephant of the mind to the pillar of the object of observation with the rope of recollection and bring him back over and again with the hook of vigilance.

This metaphor explains clearly how to train the mind and ideally one would proceed circularly between the various elements of mental training passing from the mind to the object of observation, to analyzing recollection, to analyzing vigilance and back again. And therefore, the quote of Nāgārjuna indicates that the pillar of the object observation must be firm, an iron pillar in the metaphor. Now here, obviously, it is not from the standpoint of the object of observation that firmness is required. The object of observation from its standpoint is irrelevant in a sense. It is the mind which is focused on the object of observation which must be firm or stable.

This is what is to be understood. And here for us beginners, it is memory or recollection which is critical, which is the most important in attaining Shamatha. Without memory, there is no attainment of calm abiding as Lamrim Chenmo, the great stages of the path explained so clearly. Now the quote of the Madhyamica Hridaya, the heart of Madhyamaka refers actually not so much to the hook of vigilance but to the hook of wisdom. And there are quite a few debates about this, but fundamentally the meaning of the quote is the same.

Now in this context of the development of calm abiding, what we want is to conjoin within one mind three components. The component of concentration, of recollection and of vigilance. They are, if you want, three parts of one mind. Now regarding the length of the sessions of meditation, there is no certainty. Kamala Śīla’s Bhavanakama suggests a length of one klebsidra, one water clock which amounts to one hour.

But this is uncommonly long for anyone but an experienced practitioner and for beginners such as ourselves, it is generally suggested to have very short sessions. If a session is long and let’s say goes up to one hour, then forgetfulness may definitely arise because the power of recollection and memory is not strong. Then when forgetfulness arises in turn and one does not recognize it, one becomes accustomed to forgetfulness. Even should forgetfulness not arise, both sinking and agitation may arise because the power of vigilance is not strong and if one becomes accustomed to them this creates difficulties later on. Even should they not arise, subtle sinking may arise which we will be unable to recognize.

And this is why Jetsongkapa suggests initially start with very short sessions and if those short sessions progress well and there is no forgetfulness, sinking or agitation, then extend the session up to one hour. Having a stable object of observation is for the purpose of withdrawing the mind inwards. We will stop here for today. Stop here today. It’s very helpful to reflect on the fact that all of this is happening within one mind, that you have one mind within which you have concentration, recollection, vigilance, and from this also arise the harmful factors such as agitation or sinking.

If there are questions, Geshela will take one or two questions. Yes, please, Julie. I’m sorry. Don’t know. I don’t know.

I’m sorry. Okay. Geshela has no experience. You look at his age yesterday. I have but because I don’t.

I have no experience. No experience. Have have no experience. Geshela has heard about this, but he has no experience. Geshela is not answering your question because he has no experience.

Thinks it’s okay. He has no experience. There are many ways of generating calm abiding. Why not? Yes please.

So the means to increase the power of memory in this context is to study carefully the six preliminaries to Shamatha which are also given as 13 within Asaṇga’s stages of hearers, Śrāvakabhūmi. The second factor for increasing memory is to take good care of one’s body and not to push one’s body in harmful activities? Geshela wonders Judy whether your mention of the nine cycles of breathing, breathing purification might not have occurred within the context of the eighth feature of position which calls for breathing quietly outwards and inwards which may also be connected with mindfulness of breathing. But he doesn’t know whether this is the case or not. Are there other questions?

Geshela doesn’t know. He has no experience. Regarding your question mark on memory, Geshela says that when he was using his memory intensively at the monastery for his studies, he would always look in the morning just upon rising at whatever he had to study during the day. And then it would be studying during the day. This is extremely helpful.

As I said in these 37 practices, use that early mind well because that first mind of the day is very powerful. Then after breakfast, that mind pretty much goes to waste. We know this from experience. Yeah. It is said in the great stages of the path that there are two types of objects of observation in this context.

The first is a purely visualized one. The second is an object which has initially been observed. Geshela would suggest that you rely on an object which is initially observed and look at it over and again. It will progress gradually and incrementally. Otherwise, we jump back and forth, we will all get very confused and the animal is a rabbit.

So it depends what you’re talking of about memorizing. But if it’s texts, then first before memorizing a text, you should actually have listened to teachings on the text. Then memorization when all is said and done is memorization only of the words. Yeah. Alright.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Sure. Please.

Come. As far as the Dalai Lama has said many times that if one is trying to achieve calm abiding, during that period one must give up every single worldly activity, including meeting people, business and all that. Then this for the period of time concerned, it may be a couple of weeks or not or so. Generally speaking, it is said in Buddhist scriptures that one can attain calm abiding in six months. But Geshela is not sure of this because it depends very much on the capacity of the trainees, whether they are of sharp or dull capacities and so forth.

Hi.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top