Public Talks — 2011-07-31

1 h 34 min · 11,405 words · 31 July 2011 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Public Talks (Khensur Rinpoche)
Public Talks (Khensur Rinpoche)
Public Talks — 2011-07-31
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 94-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche frames paranormal phenomena—telepathy, psychokinesis, and verified reincarnation—as evidence for the non-material nature of mind. He opens by questioning why happiness declines as material wealth increases, then examines Western and Soviet research on ESP: Rhine’s statistical methodology, Soviet government programs including long-distance telepathy experiments, and Ian Stevenson’s meticulously documented reincarnation cases. He maps these to Buddhist teachings on paranormal perception, arguing that meditation-based concentration explains inconsistent psi research results. Throughout, he directly confronts scientific resistance to psi, contending that accepting these phenomena would require fundamental revisions to scientific methodology. Pitched at serious practitioners interested in the mind-matter relationship.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2011-07-31 – KR.mp3

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Compendium of Valid Cognition

Date: 2031-07-11

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~11,534

This transcript was generated using AI speech recognition and correction

File: 2011-07-31 – KR.mp3
Collection: Public Talks
UUID: 0f47517a-16b4-4976-87b1-30f9f618fc23

—

This transcript was generated using AI speech recognition and has been reviewed for Buddhist terminology accuracy. Some inaccuracies may remain. Please refer to the original audio recording as the authoritative source.

# 01-110731_1102.mp3 > **Collection:** Audio Recordings — Public Talks > **Duration:** 94.5 minutes > **Words:** 11,405 > **Model:** Deepgram Nova-3 > **Corrections:** 0 Buddhist terminology fixes > **Transcribed:** 2026-03-05 09:12 — It’s my privilege again to welcome Ilya and in presenting research in paranormal phenomena, previous life memories as the gateway to a twenty first century understanding of mind. Thank…

Read full transcript

# 01-110731_1102.mp3

> **Collection:** Audio Recordings — Public Talks
> **Duration:** 94.5 minutes
> **Words:** 11,405
> **Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
> **Corrections:** 0 Buddhist terminology fixes
> **Transcribed:** 2026-03-05 09:12

—

It’s my privilege again to welcome Ilya and in presenting research in paranormal phenomena, previous life memories as the gateway to a twenty first century understanding of mind. Thank you ever so much, Ilya. Thank you very much. I’m delighted to see all of you here today again. I hope we are all not too exhausted after the steady regimen of fascinating data and different viewpoints we have had yesterday, we will have today.

Then, as I mentioned yesterday, my talks are structured around two main axes, a theoretical axis, which we covered yesterday, and a more concrete axis, which we will cover today. In an academic setting, think we probably would feel very uncomfortable talking about ESP or psi. However, we have a little bit more margin of maneuver here since this is a Buddhist institute, and there has been some very solid research in the field which I would like to bring up with you. The reason I would like to address paranormal phenomena is because I feel that there is a large amount of intra scientific data which comes both from researchers in the medical sciences and researchers in the physical sciences, proving that the dominant scientific paradigm does not completely explain reality. And it is interesting for us because this research certainly at its inception has often been peer reviewed and has been published in leading scientific journals.

So when I met with Khensur Rinpoche Pritchy a couple of days ago, Rinpoche asked me what we would be talking about and I told him I would be talking about what is known in Tibetan as Mngon shes drug gi. It’s often translated as clairvoyances. I prefer to translate it as forms of psi myself. And Rinpoche asked why? And I said because they’re researched by scientists and some scientists have found evidence of their existence.

And I personally feel that this in itself gives strong evidence of the non material nature of the mind. Rinpoche was absolutely delighted, so I was quite reassured that my procedure, line of thought was sound. In addition to the talk which we will be having this morning, I will be showing a video at 12:30 on the research of Doctor Robert Jahn on psychokinesis, which is some of the most interesting and robust research ever done in the field. It’s a half hour video. You’re welcome to attend if you have time or not, it’s up to you.

And we will try to have a bit of discussion afterwards. So for that reason I will not cover Doctor Jahn’s work in detail today during the talk. Now, to reset the cultural context within which we are evolving, as mentioned yesterday, we are evolving at present in a cultural context of soft nihilism. And the harder line of the soft nihilism, I feel, is epitomized by the great French philosopher Albert Camus, who was one of my favorites when I was a teenager.

Albert Camus’ description of the predicament of man is perhaps the clearest description of predicament by a philosopher openly espousing the Nihilist view. As you know, Sisyphus was a hero of Greek mythology who had committed a heinous crime and he was sentenced by the gods to a meaningless task. This meaningless task was to endlessly roll a boulder up a cliff, to then see it plummet back down to ground, and to be sentenced to do this for all eternity. Camus felt that Sisyphus was a metaphor for the predicament of modern man, evolving in a totally meaningless world, and yet condemned to labor which had no fruit. I personally have always felt that it is a great strength and perhaps to the honor of Albert Camus that he drew out the full consequences of a nihilist stance.

And I think to be able to abandon the nihilist position, which I personally feel is a subtext to much of modernity, and certainly of Western modernity, one first must go to the very end of the logic of nihilism. One of my old friends in Paris, Father Boris Bobrinskoy, once said to me, to sometimes you must go to the very edge of the abyss and stare into the depths of the abyss before you are able to back off. So that was a little bit the goal of my talk yesterday, which was to show that nihilism is not a new viewpoint, it is an ancient viewpoint. If I dared, I would say it is an ancient snake. It is a viewpoint which has caused infinite damage in the past, and which is causing more damage nowadays.

And it is a viewpoint we must measure the full consequences of. And I would like to show a couple of charts, which I have shown previously to some of you, which are quite interesting. In this chart, I use two government sources. One publication which is sponsored by the Australian Government, another publication from the Treasury Department, to plot the mean happiness in Australia since the end of World War Two against changes in GDP per capita, which is a good indicator of general wealth in the population. Now you can see GDP per capita is pretty much all over the place, but increases steadily since basically the late nineteen seventy’s.

However, mean happiness in Australia, as reported, and this is always a weakness of these measures, has been decreasing steadily since 1945. So, this raises a major question. If happiness is a direct corollary of material well-being, and if we say that GDP per capita measures material well-being, how is it that happiness is decreasing as broadly speaking, the economic situation is improving? I think this is a first chip or question which has to be lodged against the crassly materialistic world view. Then there is another set of data, which I personally found extremely disturbing, and it is data which I collected from Australia, since this is an Australian environment.

You get similar data worldwide. It is male suicide rate changes since 1900. It’s actually difficult data to get, but what you find, which is quite striking, is that at the beginning of the twentieth century, the highest incidence of suicide was in the 85 age group, followed closely by the group sixty five to eighty four, which makes an awful lot of sense in a society in which medical care was limited and old age would be a period of hardship and impoverishment. Suicide in the fifteen to twenty four age group in 1907 is nominal. It’s approximately six deaths per 100,000.

By 2000, we are looking at twenty deaths per 100,000 in the fifteen to twenty four age group. Teenagers who really have no particular reason to be unhappy are suiciding five times as much nowadays than they were at the beginning of the twentieth century. I was talking about this with our old friend Grant Cameron, some of you have heard about, and Grant was telling me he had actually interviewed a statistician on this topic who had told him that the figures were skewed and understated the nature of the problem. He said that actually a very large number, the statistician told him it ninety percent of car accidents involving single young males in the fifteen to twenty four age group were treated as accidents by the police whereas in fact they were suicides. Now that is the case we’re not looking at a fivefold increase of suicides but perhaps a six or sevenfold increase of suicides.

I have not done the math. I’m sorry, I’ll take questions at the end because there will not be time to finish. I appreciate it’s your specialty and I look forward to your input. So I think we as a society have to ask ourselves what is happening. And there are numerous answers, but the question which has to be addressed is whether these answers cover merely superficial manifestations of the phenomenon or address something more fundamental.

So I wanted to keep this in the background and I must say that there have been there has been a dip in the suicide rate in Australia since and I don’t remember the precise period, nineteen ninety five-two thousand, but this broad increase in suicide among the youngs is attested in The UK. It is for that matter attested in The United States. And what I’d like to address at present are the intimations of the non material nature of the mind, as it comes from ESP research. There was a series of categories of which provide strong evidence for the non material nature of the mind. Telepathy, verified cases of the reincarnation type, remote viewing, what used to be called clairvoyance, psychokinesis, in other words the capacity to affect objects mentally and verified poltergeist experiences.

All of these are controversial and only a couple are considered legitimate objects of scientific inquiry when and if this does happen. Within these categories of psi, there are a couple which I think can easily generate conviction in the non material nature of the mind because they are relatively easy to test and they don’t stretch the dominant paradigm too much. And there have to be three criteria, not only should they be easily testable and should they be credible, but it should be possible to get a large body of data. Three forms of psi satisfy these criteria: telepathy, psychokinesis and cases of the reincarnation type. And I will cover today all three.

PK I will cover briefly because we will have a video during the noon break. So regarding telepathy, which is probably the most studied type of PK, And I have here a diagram of a Zenner card, which is the cards which were inflicted on the poor subjects. You had to try to transmit these little shapes and then the recipient had to try to identify what you had transmitted. I let you imagine how boring the whole process must have been. People basically, Ryan, who did this research, saw terrifying decline rates in the result because his subjects was having dizzy with boredom.

But regarding telepathy, there are broadly speaking two ways to study it, informally and formally. The informal approach are incidental accounts of telepathy from anthropology. The formal are studies which actually focus on telepathy. The strongest accounts of telepathy come from the incidental studies, where telepathy is peripheral to the main focus of the study and there is a surprisingly large amount of anthropological data, where anthropologists who were studying a completely different phenomenon in primitive tribes found cases of telepathy at foot and reported them. Now, these cases are interesting for several reasons.

It is not the main focus of the research. So I personally feel this increases the chances of authenticity of these accounts. They generally present the strongest cases of telepathy. And the account of telepathy is detrimental or at least may be detrimental to publication of the anthropological article. So there is no particular reason for an anthropologist to cook the data.

It is problematical to put it mildly. There are many sources of such accounts. I wanted to take one from Australia, since we are in Australia. And we or were fortunate in Australia to have some of the last surviving Stone Age populations in history. The indigenous Australians, regrettably understudied by the Australians themselves, but which have elicited strong interest from American anthropologists and linguists.

And this is an account by A. P. Elkin, who was one of the fathers of indigenous studies in Australia at the University of Sydney in Queensland, in a book some of you probably know, Aboriginal Men of High Degree, of an instance of telepathy used for communication between two Aborigines. Now, if one works through Elkins’ work, what is striking is that it is very clear that he considers ESP in the indigenous populations as a reality. And he actually inspired several researchers in the field, and I listed them in the bibliography under articles.

There are two very interesting articles by Berndt on Wiradjuri magic and clever men, which cover precisely, the manifestations of ESP within the Wiradjuri tribe as an apartheid or a side effect to the practice of magic which was of interest to Berndt for anthropological reasons. However, the systematic study of ESP has largely been influenced by the work of J. B. Rhine at the University of Duke in, I think, North Carolina. Rhine’s work, I think, is seminal.

It has pros and cons because it really, in many senses, represents a contemporary Anglo Saxon scientific approach to ESP. In other words, ESP is studied statistically as a phenomenon which probably would be present in all and could only manifest through minor deviations in statistical averages. This is by no means the only approach to the study of ESP and we will cover today alternative approaches in the Soviet and Eastern European schools, which are perhaps in terms of results more interesting. Much of the material I will use for that is declassified intelligence material, which has been made available, whereas Rhein’s work is public domain. The pros and cons of Rhein’s methodology.

The pro is that Rhein uses the Zenner cards, we saw, previously and uses forced choice procedures. The subject must transmit one of the Zenner card images, the recipient must identify the image from within those transmitted. In other words, this lends itself very well to statistical analyses, which was Ryan’s goal. In turn, we have very straightforward replication studies. This eliminates the subjective assessment of judges, and it eliminates, and it is a strong critique in my opinion of Ryan’s work, the aesthetic and emotional involvement of the transmitter.

As we will see in the Soviet research, the Soviet research focuses on enhancing the telepathic effect through synesthetic components, drawing in emotional and aesthetic components to try to lead to unambiguous telepathic events. This was not Ryan’s goal in the slightest. Ryan’s goal was to eliminate these components. As a result, and perhaps because of the incredible tedium of transmitting stars for days on end to poor recipients, there is a very strong decline effect in Ryan’s work, which means that after initially strong results, the results very swiftly gravitate towards averages. Rhein’s work seldom elicits strong ESP and you will see I put in the con to Rhein’s work the same topic I put in the pro.

I think it is literally both a pro and a con of Rhein’s work. There’s a certain approach to the study of ESP, which at least as far as telepathy is concerned, is if not discredited nowadays, no longer greatly used. The strong statistical approaches are still used in the study of PK as we will see at noon. I would like to cover in greater detail Soviet research. Basically, the research from Bekhterev and Vasiliev to Kogan and beyond.

The father of Soviet psi research is Vladimir Bekhterev, who was a disciple of the great neurophysiologist Pavlov. His foremost student is perhaps one of the foremost researchers in the history of telepathy, Vasilyev. Vasilyev obtained some exceptional results in his studies of telepathy using methods which I think we certainly nowadays in the West would consider highly controversial from the standpoint of scientific ethics. But it was perhaps a different age and a different social system. The methodology of the Soviet school of ESP is very different from that used in Western psi research.

Soviet psi research was massively government controlled. The goal was the control of thoughts, emotions and behavior of the population, not merely the transmission of data. When data transmission was a focus as in Kogan’s research, the goal was the elimination of noise in telepathic data research and therefore ensuring as pure a stream of data as possible. The methodology is radically different from Rhein’s. It is a systematic use of powerful emotional and aesthetic stimuli to enhance transmission, to a degree which would be unacceptable in the West.

The focus of Soviet research was the underlying neurological and especially physical mechanisms. Soviet researchers bumped into specific problems because of Marxist Leninist ideology, which excluded the minds being non material. Therefore, you find in Soviet research for ideological reasons a systematic privilege or attempt to privilege electromagnetic hypothesis. Even when Vasilyev himself in his research establishes that this hypothesis is not valid. Finally the Soviet protocols are not aimed at gaining through statistical analysis proof of the existence of a transient phenomenon, but instead they are aimed at screening large numbers of candidates, identifying candidates with exceptional gifts and then testing these candidates to the maximum.

Vasilyev’s pioneering work at the Leningrad Institute of Physiology used the two shielded enclosures represented here. Both are actually huge Faraday cages, which prevent the transmission of electromagnetic radiation within certain wavelength limitations dictated by the size of the grid of the enclosure. In one case, as you can see, the subject actually lived inside the Faraday cage, and was enclosed within the Faraday cage. In the other case, the Faraday cage could be lifted and then repositioned above the subject, before data transmission was started. Vasilyev’s most famous experiment are the long distance data transmission experiments between Leningrad and Sevastopol, a distance of 1,700 kilometers, in which sleep and wake commands were transmitted telepathically at random from Leningrad to a subject in Sevastopol during a pre selected two hour period over two days.

Sleep commands were obeyed within one to three minutes. Wakefulness, however, was more problematic, which I think is the case for all of us. I wish I could wake people up telepathically, it would be a big asset. So here is a reproduction of a translation of some of Vasilyev’s data. You can see that the distances, the period is basically from 1932 to 1935 actually.

Distances ranging between 25 meters and 1,700 kilometers, you will notice that there is no difference in the time taken for the subject to respond to the telepathic instruction to sleep in function of distance. It ranges between one and three and a half minutes, whether the subject is at 25 meters of distance or 1,700 kilometers. This led Vasilyev to suspect that transmission was electromagnetic then at the speed of light, otherwise if another mechanism was involved, Vasiliev suspected that non-speed-of-light transmissions were probable. And then, one unpublished experiment Vasilyev did, which I will cover here, it gives them very much the spirit of Soviet sea research, and also demonstrates, I think, the strength of the Soviet procedure, as well, unfortunately, as the extreme ruthlessness with which these tests were performed, is the following case. Vasilev’s prime subject was a Russian lady who had a little son, who actually did most of this work.

And Vasilyev wanted to test the impact of emotion on strong telepathic transmission. So after positioning his subject in a Faraday cage, he gave her the image of a flower to transmit to the recipient, which was still in Leningrad, and just before the experiment started, Vasilyev himself approached the subject in the Faraday cage, and told her that her little son had just been killed by a tramway in front of his school, And that she would be allowed to see the body once the experiment was over. But that the country and the party demanded that duty come before family obligation. You can imagine the extraordinary sense of distress of the mother, who had to transmit the image of a flower to a recipient after hearing that her only child had just died horrifically in a tram accident. None of this actually was true.

Then Vasilyev contacted the recipient to see what had been received. The recipient stated that he had received the clearest image ever from the transmitter, but it was not the image of a flower, but of a tramway. And then obviously one would assume Vasiliev told his subject that the account was not true. Now, what this experiment, which is reported in Vasilyev’s work, although it was not covered in great detail, clearly shows is the power of emotion and indirectly, we will see later aesthetics, in telepathic transmission and the problems when emotion is evacuated from ESP testing, as it is in much of the research done nowadays. Vasilev’s work had a tremendous impact in The Soviet Union.

Vasilev himself ended up working in the military industrial complex and much of his disciple is focused on telepathy as a means to communicate specifically with nuclear submarines, and this is Kogan’s published research. So, I. M. Cogan actually was a radio engineer by training and he focused mainly on the information theory aspects of telepathy, and in keeping with Soviet procedure, screened large amounts of subjects to find gifted subjects on which he focused his research. The first experiment Kogan makes is an experiment of long distance telepathic data transmission from Moscow to Novosibirsk, which is a solid 3,000 kilometers away from Moscow.

Kogan transmits Morse code telepathically, using two contrasting objects, I do not know which ones, it might have been a fruit and a chair, as symbols for the dot and the dash of the Morse code. Three letter words were then transmitted telepathically from Moscow. The recipient in Moscow actually identified the word. This was reported in a defense intelligence agency, analysis of sea research in the Warsaw Pact, which has been declassified some ten years ago. Kogan gave a brief talk on his research at UCLA in 1968, and then basically was not allowed to leave the Soviet Union after, and disappears from public view around 1972.

I was unable to obtain a picture of him. It is very clear he ended up working in the military industrial complex. As you know, the Soviets had specialized cities for for military research. The second piece of research Kogan was involved in is remarkable because it is one of the strongest cases ever of telepathic transmission. It’s high volume telepathic data transmission, where random digits between zero and nine are transmitted at ranges between several meters and kilometers.

A solid 78% of all numbers transmitted were received correctly and according again to the same DIA report, this is the most statistically significant result ever reported in ESP. Odds of ten-seventy seven for it to have occurred randomly. Then Cogon’s research really focused not so much on the existence of psi, which was taken for granted, as on how to eliminate noise in psi transmission to make psi telepathy a reliable means of data transmission. Other researchers in the field included Sergeyev, who was one of Kogan’s disciples, who noted synchronization of EEG patterns, which patterns are not mentioned, between transmitter and recipient at the Leningrad Institute of Physiology. And at present, will mention briefly one of the top subjects which was used by Kogan and Sergeyev, Nina Kulagina.

Nina Kulagina was a Red Army captain in World War II who had extraordinarily strong telepathic and PK capacities. We will not cover her PK capacities today. They are controversial because she was a KGB subject, and it is unclear how much of her work, was KGB sponsored for purposes of propaganda and how much was not. So I have tried to focus on the data which is quite solid. In the case of Kulagina, she was studied by Sergeyev and Sergeyev reports, and this was verified by independent observers, her capacity to stop the heart of a frog under controlled conditions and to stop and cause arrhythmia in the heart of a skeptical physician, a psychiatrist actually, who was attending the experiment.

I actually have a copy of the video which was made at the period. It is difficult to know how authentic the data is. It is quite intimidating. It is quite intimidating, as the experiment actually had to be terminated. We have some sense of the scale of the Soviet research at the period through Spirkin’s statement.

Spirkin was one of the leaders of Soviet ESP research, and he points out that basically by the late sixties, ESP was the main focus of Soviet research. Much of the research was military or under KGB control. Some of the key points as we said were behavior control, control of the germination rate of sprouts and plants, and data transmission. Then the full scale of Soviet research in the field is unclear. Another DIA report indicates that under when Yuri Andropov became head of the Politburo in 1982, the budget for Soviet, ESP research was increased to 500,000,000 rubles, which if one looks at buying power at the period in Soviet Union is basically $500,000,000.

And you have a sense of how ruthless Vasilev’s experiments were. Andropov in a secret, communique, which was, which has been published now, states that Soviet ESP researchers should no longer be embarrassed by whatever harm, the subjects experienced during experimentation. So we do not know what exactly was involved, but with the Soviet focus on the use of powerful emotions as a source, if you want, of energy for data transmission, one can suspect. As a response to the Soviet effort, similar programs were put on foot in The United States and in the West. And these range from Project Scanate to Project Stargate.

Project Scan eight was initiated at the Stanford Research Institute, which is a subsection of Stanford University, takes mainly but not exclusively government contracts, DARPA contracts of a military nature. And eventually the research was transferred to Fort Meade, officially under army control. So this is a list of the acronyms under which US ESP research was conducted. SCANATE at the Stanford Research Institute, which is funded by the CA CIA and actually by the US Navy. Then, unfortunately, as you know, or I suppose my political opinions come through on this one, in the late nineteen seventies, the evangelicals became a very powerful political force in The United States.

And any research involving ESP was hugely controversial. Therefore, the research had to be passed off to other structures and it was transferred from the SRI to the US Army at Fort Meade, which is basically also the base of the National Security Agency, which handles data security in The US. Then it was spun off under the name of INSCOM for two years, and eventually transferred to the Defense Intelligence Agency as Project Sunstreak. It was then transferred to a private institution, the SAIC, which actually is part of the US military industrial complex and does very little, if any, private work. It is just a way of disclaiming responsibility for government research under the name of Project Stargate.

And nobody really knows whether research in the field is continuing or not. As of 1995, it was. The foremost subject of the two main research researchers at the Stanford Research Institute, who were Targ and Puthoff, was an American artist by the name of Ingo Swann. Ingo Swan was by all accounts a gifted subject. Unfortunately, as many subjects with strong ESP capacity, not a very reliable one.

And Puthoff here recounts Swann’s first visit to his physics lab. Putoff was one of the leading quantum physics researchers in The States. Swan’s first visit to the physics lab at Stanford University, during which he actually affected through shielding the operation of a magnetometer and described the inner functioning of the magnetometer. This was sufficient to ensure that Ingo Swann became one of the foremost subjects, of research at the Stanford Research Institute. While the main focus of Soviet research was telepathic data transmission and behavior control or modification, the main known focus of ESP research sponsored by the military and the intelligence agencies was remote viewing.

Remote viewing is a contemporary term for clairvoyance, which means the capacity to view the features of a site or an object at a distance, which has obvious intelligence applications. I have not included a drawing, or a series of drawings actually, which were made by some of the top subjects from the Stanford Research Institute. The focus was largely Soviet military installations. It is clear that the intelligence agencies felt the results more than warranted funding this research. There are two drawings which are public domain.

One is a drawing of a very large set of pulleys of unidentified located in the Eastern Soviet Union. The other is a drawing of an experimental nuclear submarine. Then the other material to this day is still classified, so we have no clear sense of what was investigated. This research focused, because it was mainly military and intelligence oriented, not so much on establishing the existence of the phenomenon as using it. And therefore it does not lend itself very well to an assessment of how reliable, for instance, remote viewing is.

Specifically critiques which have been addressed to the research at SRI are that it involves the assessment of the drawings by judges and the judges obviously are party to the research program and may have a vested interest in the pursuance of the program. However, independent reviews which were sponsored indicate that there is a statistically significant laboratory effect. And this was actually confirmed by Doctor Jessica Utts, a statistician at the University of California Davis, who was hired by the SAIC to assess the quality of the research done so far. Her statement is very strong.

It’s one of the strongest statements in support of see as a reality, which I know. Using the standards applied to any other area of science, it is concluded that psychic functioning has been well established. The statistical results of the studies examined are far beyond what is expected by chance. Argument that these results could be due to methodological flaws in the experiments are soundly rebutted. Effects of similar magnitude to those found in government sponsored research at SRI and SAIC have been replicated at a number of laboratories across the world.

Such consistency cannot be readily explained by claims of flaws or fraud. This is a very strong statement. A very strong statement by an independent expert who had no particular reason to put her career or professional reputation on the line. And this is the last quote I would give. To this day, there is a paranormal unit at the Defense Department, United States Defense Department, and more than 200 tasks of a military nature have been addressed to this department between 1986 and 1995.

So I think what this shows quite clearly is that irrespective of the stance of the scientific community at large, certainly large swathes of the military establishment and the intelligence agencies East West consider ESP a reality and are happy to use it under controlled conditions. Then, having covered briefly telepathy and I have grouped remote viewing under telepathy, I will mention psychokinesis, which is what is called casually in popular culture mind over matter. It is the attempt to influence physical events mentally. The foremost researcher in the field is Robert Jahn, the former dean of the Princeton Engineering faculty, founder of the Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research Lab. And Jahn used a series of apparatuses to test the ability of volunteers to control the flow of events.

These were mechanical random event generators like this generator which basically forces beads through a series of interstices with pegs leading to a statistically random distribution of the beads in a series of tubes. The subject then attempts to control the flow of the beads with a stated intent. Jahn’s work focused on subjects attempting to control and modify the distribution of events with a random event generator, and found that irrespective of the random event generator used, whether it was mechanical, optical, or electronic, this was Jahn’s foremost random event generator, which is a shielded digital number generator. Over large numbers of trials, in this case 120,000 trials, by one subject, clear deviations in a function of the intent of the subject could be observed. This is our baseline here.

This basically is the behavior of the random number generator when the subject attempts no affect. This is the expected range of results and these are the results obtained when the subject attempts to influence generation towards a high range and these are the results obtained when the subject attempts to influence generation towards a low range of the spectrum covered. And this was found to be the case irrespective of the random number generator or the random event generator. So we will cover at noon some of this material. It is the strongest data ever found demonstrating that it is possible for the human mind to affect physical events.

It is data which is so strong, is quite puzzling. It has not been taken on board by the scientific community. And Jahn, in his case, committed the scientific equivalent of Harakiri in the process. Passing from being The United States foremost plasma physics scientist, he actually is the conceptor of the plasma engine, the plasma engine which will, propel spacecrafts in the future. And passing from being the dean of the engineering faculty, at Princeton to being demoted, actually.

Unfortunately, he or fortunately, he had tenure, so he he was allowed to stay on as a professor. But his research was banished to one of the basements of Princeton University, and we will see the basement today, on the video. The third category of, and I will call this casually ESP, which we will cover, are verified cases of the reincarnation type. So as I mentioned, these three categories of events, which are telepathy, PK and verified cases of the reincarnation, seem to me to provide the strongest evidence possible at present for the non material nature of the mind. All three have been very carefully investigated.

None more carefully than PK, but for us I think verified cases of the reincarnation type are particularly interesting. And I have included the figure of two of the foremost researchers in the field, Colonel Albert de Rochas, who is of historic importance as the pioneer of hypnotic regression, who was, the director of the Ecole Polytechnique, in Paris, the equivalent of the period of MIT nowadays, who lost his position as a result of his research. And, Doctor. Ian Stevenson, who was director of the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Virginia, who lost his position as head of the Department of Psychiatry in 1968, came close actually to losing tenure. It’s quite extraordinary.

Thanks to Chester Carlson, he was able to retain tenure and stayed on as professor at the University of Virginia, creating eventually the division of personality studies, under whose polite acronym research cases of the reincarnation type and near death experiences continue to this day. So as handouts, I have given out a bibliography, which you should have. I also have handed out Professor Stevenson’s obituary, which describes much of his research. I have added out one of his most interesting articles on the explanatory value of the idea of reincarnation. And for those of you who are interested, we can print on demand a review article by Robert John, who pioneered the research in PK I mentioned at Princeton on the state of ESP research in 1982.

It’s the last article John was ever allowed to publish in a peer reviewed scientific publication, the proceedings of the International Engineering Association. After that, he was banished to the Journal of Scientific Exploration created by Ian Stevenson. It’s a 35 page article. It’s an outstanding article, but, we can only print them if you are ready to cover the costs. So see with Carol.

Now regarding verified cases of the reincarnation type and here the crux is on verified. In other words, these are not cases of past life memories as such. These are cases of past life memories in which the data has been independently verified and found to be true. Such are of two types, spontaneous verified cases, which are researched by Stevenson and induced verified cases, mainly induced to hypnosis, researched by Durosha, but not only him, by Netherton, Wambach and others. The general features of the spontaneous cases which are by far the strongest cases are as follows.

Stevenson investigated some two thousand five hundred cases of the reincarnation type. Of these, there are a short 900 verified cases during thirty five years. You can see the amount of work this entailed and of these eight ninety five verified cases, there is a small group of 30 or so cases whom Stevenson or which Stevenson considers his strongest cases. These are not just verified cases where the data has been checked. These are cases where the families had no contact with each other before Stevenson investigated the cases.

These are cases where the family had no interest whatsoever in the child’s memories being verified. Cases for instance in which the family was Hindu, the child remembered being a Muslim who was circumcised. Cases in which the family was high caste and the child remembered being a low caste child or the opposite. In other words, cases which are very difficult to fault. This is a peer assessment of Stevenson’s research before he too was banished into the limbo of scientific oblivion.

Lester King, who is the editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association, the foremost publication in medical studies in The United States says, in regards to reincarnation, he has painstakingly and unemotionally collected a detailed series of cases from India, cases in which the evidence is difficult to explain on other grounds. And Harold Lief, who I believe was editor of the Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases says, Stevenson is a methodical, careful, even cautious investigator whose personality is on the obsessive side. Either he’s making a colossal mistake, or he will be known as the Galileo of the twentieth century. This is a breakdown of Stevenson’s cases by reliability. As we said, the total number of cases is two thousand five hundred.

You have to imagine that Stevenson traveled to interview each of the children in question. The volume of work is terrific. Then of these, a large proportion are unverified, unsurprisingly. The child had memories which could not be checked. Of the eight ninety five verified cases, as we said, some thirty and some are best cases.

And all these cases share certain features. These are universal features of children claiming to remember past lives. All start speaking of their past life memories at an early age, Or stop speaking about them with a couple exception around ages five to seven. There is an extremely high incidence of violent death in previous lives. The data has not completely been broken down statistically.

It is in the range of seventy eight percent of violent deaths for some categories of data. And the mode of death is frequently mentioned. Now, there are additional features which are occasionally present and these often are very puzzling. Physical resemblance to the previous life body, especially the face. This is something the Tibetan teachers rely upon a lot when identifying past Lamas.

It’s a common comment I heard in the great monasteries when people saw the picture of the present head of the Karmapa tradition. The monks would say, ah yes, he looks exactly like his predecessor. And this was just one item in the package of data proving the authenticity of the rebirth. Then the presence of birthmarks, deformations and anomalies connected with events in previous lives, specifically connected with traumatic events. The mode of death if it is violent often leaves major scars or damage on the body.

This damage can frequently be picked up on the body of the child who remembers that mode of death. So some of Stevenson’s most troubling research in Reincarnation and Biology, which is his major work, it’s around 3,000 pages of text, was a study of birthmark and deformities in the light of past life memories and a comparison of the normal occurrence of these birthmarks and deformities in communities at large as opposed to their occurrence among children who remembered these violent deaths. I think it is some of the strongest data on record proving the existence of reincarnation. Then among the additional occasional features, a similarity of the mind of the child with that of the remembered persona. Similar temperament and personality, deja vu, which is quite common, memories from past lives, which are the basis for verification and vivid recurring dreams connected with previous life.

As far as behavior is concerned, phobias are very common, especially phobias connected to the mode of death in the previous life. Behaving as if still an adult, which leads to the term which has entered into new age, old souls. There is no such thing as an old soul in Buddhist philosophy. We all are unfortunately, infinitely old souls, but it refers to behaving as still an adult. Unusual play in dietary preferences in many of Stevenson’s Burmese cases where the child remembered being a Japanese soldier who had been slaughtered, I suppose is the right term, at the end of the Japanese occupation of Burma, the child had Japanese dietary preferences, which ran towards raw fish, which is completely absent in Burma.

The Burmese eat a lot of fish, but they cook it. And the child’s personality was described by his family as very un Burmese. Those of you who know the Burmese know that they are marvelous people, very kind and easygoing. And these children had a personality associated with that of Japanese soldiers. My mother served in China at the end of World War II, and the stories she brought back of the atrocities committed by the Japanese soldiers give one a sense of the temperament, these children may have had.

So regarding specific phobia, I created this chart based on forty seven cases of children remembering death by drowning. Of these forty seven children, sixty four percent had a phobia of immersion in water. So there seems to be a correlation with the reconnected death. So we don’t have time to enter in detail in this here. Those of you who attended the two day seminar on reincarnation given over the spring have a lot more data and perhaps we can give it at some point in the future again.

Then this is the coverage for spontaneous cases which are from the scientific standpoint the strongest cases. I will very briefly mention induced cases, are far weaker as far as a scientific establishment of reincarnation is concerned. And I have put here a brief history of hypnotic regression, which in the West is older than the research concerning spontaneous cases. Generally speaking, the problem of hypnotic regression is unsound methodology and a very strong bias in the hypnotist towards finding what he is searching for. I think most of the researchers in the field have fragile procedures, extreme cases of unsound procedures, Morey Bernstein, The Search for Bridey Murphy, and an author who is well known nowadays, Carol Bowman.

Very dedicated and probably a very sincere person, but every single aspect of the child’s behavior is systematically interpreted in terms of a bias towards the existence of past lives. This does not lend itself to decent analyses. Sound procedures can be found in the work of Albert de Rochas, the oldest researcher of this group, who is the only one who systematically tried to verify the cases. Neither Netherton nor Wambach does, but Wambach proceeds to a statistical analysis of large numbers of cases to establish the correspondence between the memories which are reported and lifestyles at the period when the person claims to have lived, which is a very interesting procedure and she finds some very striking correlations. These are the common problems with hypnotic regression.

The first and foremost is the induction of memories by the hypnotist through leading questions. I think Carol Bowman’s approach suffers very heavily from this. The second is cryptomnesia, which is probably connected with the case of Bernadette Brady. Cryptonesia means remembering something one had forgotten and one thinks one never knew. Most of us have gigantic amounts of data stored in our minds, which we do not access and which we think actually we do not know.

The third is a generation of cathartic fantasized personalities. I think this is the bane of all hypnotic regression. Much of the works of Doctor. Weiss I have read, some of Netherton’s work, clearly suffers from this. All of us would have liked to be knights and ladies in the Middle Ages.

The odds are that if we were human, we were probably peasants grubbing in the dust. So this generation of cathartic fantasized personalities may be therapeutic. I am not a therapist. I have no particular opinion to have on this. Perhaps Sylvia can, inform us about this.

But it has little, if anything, to do with reincarnation research. And finally, a very strong criticism of, the induction of past life memories using hypnosis is addressed by Stevenson and many of the researchers working with spontaneous memories, which is that they don’t see any reason for which these past life memories should be cathartic. So the claim of catharsis or a therapeutic component is that which is made by all or most of the hypnotic researchers in the field. Netherton, Weiss, certainly. And yet, Stevenson himself says in a quote we will see later, that all his patients have past life memories, and it doesn’t seem to help them in the least.

Now hypnotic regression does have advantages, and that is why we covered it. It does allow the study of several lives in sequence. Then, with very strong limitations in the empirical procedure, one can try to detect patterns over the lives. Karmic patterns which unfold. It also greatly reduces the bias towards traumatic death experiences, which is the hallmark of all spontaneous cases.

You find that not everyone who has past life memories had a violent death. Actually most of the remembered death in the induced memories are not violent. And it allows, and this is Wambach’s work, the statistical study of social milieu and habitat over large samples of hypnotically regressed subjects, which provides, in my opinion, very strong indirect evidence for the presence of some sort of true reality behind the process of regression. Because what Wambach, was a researcher at the University of Iowa, found was that the milieu, which subjects which were regressed one thousand, two thousand, three thousand years ago, and she could choose the time frame, the milieu which they described corresponded to what historians and anthropologists reported for the period, but did not at all correspond to the fantasized world of that period in popular culture. However, a strong argument against the induction of past life memories is precisely Stevenson’s.

Most of the children I have studied record past life traumas in great detail. This doesn’t stop them from having phobias. So if there is a therapeutic effect to past life regression, something else than regression has to be involved. And then, we have little time, but I would like to conclude this with a Buddhist presentation of ESP, which I think will give us a sense of the raison d’etre of some of the problems in ESP research. Who And else to rely upon but the great Sera Je scholar, Jetsunpa Choki Gyaltsen, who composed our monastic textbooks, which enabled us to study the great treatises with less difficulty than if we had to delve in them directly.

So Jetsunpa Choki Gyaltsen distinguishes six paranormal perceptions. I have first listed the traditional Tibetan names in English translation, and then I will give them modern coordinate. Magical emanation, divine ear, knowing another’s mind, recollecting past lives, divine eye arisen from actual application and direct perception which knows the extinction of contamination. Now if one tries to get a sense in terms of modern psi research of what this is, magical emanation seems to correspond partly to an induced out of the body experience, where the yogi can actually leave his body and travel at very great distances. Divine ear corresponded what’s known as clairaudience, where the yogi can actually hear what is said at very great distances.

Knowing another mind is simply telepathy, recollecting past lives, just past life memories. Divine eye arisen from actual application is remote viewing. An actual application refers here to concentration. It actually refers specifically to which we have covered at the institute. Finally, perception which knows the extinction of contamination is not present in BPSI.

This actually refers to the truth of cessation. Now the general basis for all paranormal perception, and I have chosen to translate which Jeffrey Hopkins translates as clairvoyance as paranormal perception, because clairvoyance is used in modern psi research for remote viewing, which is just one of the categories of mngon shes. So the general basis for paranormal perception is an actual basis of concentration. A concentration which is sufficient to give rise to paranormal perception, which as Rinpoche was telling me a couple days ago, really means Shamatha. The higher Dhyanas are obviously valid as well.

Now these are not specific Buddhist capacities, as Asaṇga says in his Abhidharmasamuccaya, the non Buddhist, the Shravakas, the Bodhisattvas can all attain measureless paranormal perceptions, dependent upon pure concentration. And actually, much of Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras in the Hindu tradition cover the generation of paranormal power on the basis of the concentrations. If we take out of the body experiences, in other words magical emanation, lists four possible causes for out of the body experiences. Past comma, the use of mantra, and quite strikingly because this really does correspond with much contemporary data, the use of medicine or drugs. And finally, concentration.

Much research on OOBE finds that OOBE actually can occur as a result of medicine or in some cases the result of extreme physical debilitation. The causes of telepathy and past life memories, according to Buddhist scriptures, are broadly speaking similar with two exceptions. Medicine and drugs cannot act as causes of telepathy or past life memories. On the other hand, intelligence can. Understanding can.

The development of intelligence leads to the development of powerful capacities of inference, which obviously, although I have never seen a commentary on this, can eventually trigger both telepathy and past life memories. Therefore, we should put all the effort we can in generating valid inferential cognizers. Now what contribution can the Buddhists make to the problems which face ESP research? I think one of the foremost problems in ESP research is non repeatability. This has been used to damn the field.

One researcher gets strong results, a team at another university tries to repeat it and doesn’t get something even close. I think the Buddhist rejoinder here has to be that this research is occurring in the context of an extremely naive subject object dualism, in which the mind is assumed to have no impact whatsoever on the experiment which is being performed. And this may not be the framework to be adopted for this type of research. The second problem which has plagued ESP is the decline effect which plagued much of Rhein’s research. I think the Buddhist rejoinder here is very simple.

It is impossible to generate ESP regularly and consistently without an actual base of concentration. Once Shamatha has been attained, the systematic and regular generation of ESP poses no problems. Erratic results in remote viewing experiments, which plagued the Stanford Research Institute, I think the explanation is the same. So in conclusion, I could not resist to project a picture of Galileo, whose vagaries with the Inquisition are well known to us. We have to address a series of core issues.

If the scientists who have investigated the field such as Robert Jahn, as Doctor. Stevenson, If the statisticians such as Jessica Utts are right and there is indeed a psi reality, great or small, what impact does this have for the dominant scientific paradigm? The first problem we are facing is that as far as one can ascertain, the better results one gets in a given study of ESP, the more the review team advances the standards of the test. It is a case of mission creep pushed to the extreme. Does there therefore exist a level of proof of the existence of psi which would satisfy the scientific community at large?

Or is a rejection of psi a hidden dogmatic stance? Is it the case that irrespective of the data which is provided, it is simply never ever going to be accepted, in which case perhaps there are better things to spend one’s time upon than psi research, or can the community, scientific community at large, give us finally a standard which we have to meet for our data to be considered convincing? Now this, I think, is a gauntlet which has to be thrown in the face of the scientific community in the light especially as you will see at noon, of the hardship which Robert John experienced. And then as Weinberg, who is one of America’s leading theoretical physicists, and I believe Nobel Prize winner of physics, the existence of any form of psi calls into question the very foundations of the scientific methodology. The distinction between the observed and the observed phenomenon.

It renders obsolete the notion of the repeatability of scientific experimentation. Obviously, if, as in PK, a subject’s mind can affect the experiment, then what repeatability is there? It basically destroys the very foundations of scientific inquiry. The question one has to ask is can science legitimately investigate that which threatens its very existence? It is very clear that Professor Weinberg is fully aware of this as you will hear during the noon video presentation.

Then if psi indeed exists, what modifications to physical theories are necessary to account for such a level of mind matter interaction? So some parts of contemporary physics are much more comfortable with observer observed phenomenon interaction. The biological sciences are profoundly uncomfortable with this and still seem to function on a Newtonian positivistic model of the material world. If any type of psi is a verb, then science, as Jampayinjian said yesterday, as we understand it, has to be reinterpreted. The concept of of knowledge and of scientific investigation must be reinterpreted.

And then, perhaps a very straight forward question, if psi exists, can the experimental procedure be salvaged at all? Much contemporary experimentation relies on the double blind protocol, where neither the experimenter nor the subject knows, for instance in the case of medicine, whether what is being given is actually a drug or placebo. The double blind protocol collapses if psi is a reality. If either the subject or the experimenter has telepathic capacities, let alone clairvoyance of any type, it is not possible to have a double blind protocol. Are there any other possible experimental protocols which could take their place or if psi exists, and I think this is precisely the reason there is such resistance against it, do we have to dispense with the experimental procedure altogether.

And then I will conclude with the words which are attributed to Galileo after he was forced by the Inquisition to recant his position on the heliocentric theory. In other words, his position that the sun was at the center of the solar system and not the earth. Galileo is supposed to have whispered, and yet it moves. I’m sure he whispered it very quietly. So we have finished this presentation.

We have a short ten minutes left, and I am open to your questions to the best of my capacities. Please. Beginning of the presentation with the data you presented about suicide, a happiness, for example, and suicide. Now we we know statistics can be manipulated in many different ways. Okay.

So I’m suggesting that, it’s quite difficult to get accurate data. Uh-huh. So what’s left out of this is what’s happened in the last forty years concerning the age group, the youth group, for example. Mhmm. Just as a separate issue, in the last, say, three years, the overall statistics for the incidence of suicide in that group has decreased.

However you measure the suicide, whatever the nature of the suicide was, whether it was overdose, hanging, we can’t talk about smashing smashed cars, but the things other things. But what has happened in the last forty years is the huge increase in substance abuse in that age group. So they’re injecting, inhaling very dangerous substances that are frying their brain and they’re killing them like overdoses, IVODs, methadone sorry, the heroin, all of the deaths from this. So there’s a huge number and this is unprecedented and it’s continuing to increase and this is responsible. There’s the other factor of these young people growing up in an environment with parents who are drug users who have never worked themselves so there’s a lot of social things involved.

And on the other side in the prevention not that many are coming for help but those that do are helped by medication, by antidepressants. And the problem is there’s a movement to, what’s the word, give medication a bad name. So and one is dealing has to deal with the Scientology and various other factors in society that are saying you shouldn’t be taking medication whatever whatever. So it’s a multifactorial thing and it’s very difficult. And also, I mean, in our society it’s like if you’ve got more money you’re going to be happier, but you’re not.

I mean that’s another thing to investigate. So statistics can be skewed and a lot of information can be left out of the equation that needs to be qualified. I fully agree with you. I’m not a specialist at all in the field. My implicit contention, which I’m sure you have understood, is that behind all of these direct causes, which you mentioned, breakdown of the family, drug usage, general instability, and whatnot, there is an underlying cause.

And this underlying cause is a loss of meaning. Now this is not something I have sucked out of my thumb. In ‘2 or three, there was a publication in the American Journal of Psychiatry by Beveridge, I will be happy to give you the reference, which pointed out that religious belief seems to affect dramatically the decrease in the odds of performing suicide. This raises many questions for us. Obviously, there are direct causes which have to be addressed, but when you see something like that, this is a gigantic increase.

Then it’s an increase which is a steady increase since 1900. Drug usage is a relatively recent phenomenon post World War two. The breakdown of the family is a relatively recent phenomenon. It is strongly connected, it would seem, with the use of birth control. So are there more fundamental causes at work?

I cannot claim to give an answer, but I think one of the goals of our symposium is to raise uncomfortable questions. And when you have a sectional population, which is a section which has the least reason to commit suicide objectively, in which the suicide rate skyrockets, and statisticians actually were saying to Grant, as I mentioned, in a part that the figures are understating the scale of the problem, then how is it that we as a society are not asking the fundamental questions? Are we as a society going in the wrong direction? I think we’re saying the same thing. With pleasure.

With pleasure. Yes. That is very interesting. I have we have time for maybe one more question. Yes, Lily, please.

I’m curious about, without being a scholar in the field, I’m curious about research into things such as substance abuse and in relation to mothers, crack addicted, ice addicted, alcohol addicted. There are a plethora of substances that we discuss in terms of whether it’s mothers or fathers or children in families. I’m curious about how much or whether there’s been any research done into the impact of television addicted mothers on children between zero and two. I’m not expecting an answer but I’m curious about television in particular which has been around here since 1959 and its relationship to the bonding experience between mother and child and the confusion for a child who sees the mother in the room who is not emotionally present or available to that child? I’m sorry.

I cannot answer your I mean, I am working hard at Omniscience but success rate is low. Let us try if we have time to have questions related to the issue of the mind body relationship and ESP. Yes. Lily had one. I ask this question in regards to universal consciousness which a lot of new age groups promote.

There’s a specific series of experiments that showed that once a task or something is learned by either animals or humans in one part of the earth when the task is later presented it is far easier. For example they did two experiments that come to mind. One involved showing a puzzle on the TV in The UK and they gave the answer. They then showed the puzzle on the TV in Australia and or or it might have been Australia first. But in any case the rate of people being able to solve the puzzle was greater once the puzzle answer had been given to a society on the other side of the world and they also did the same with mice in a maze.

Gave them the exact same maze in Australia and in The UK. An inference from that study was that there is some kind of universal consciousness that could be developed. So you seem to be talking about Rupert Sheldrake’s work and the work of Rupert Sheldrake’s successor. Rupert Sheldrake was a biologist who studied the behavior of baboons, if memory serves me well, in Japan and found that his research is very controversial, that when baboons of a given community can learn to perform a task such as peeling sweet potatoes, baboons in other communities with no contact seem to acquire that skill faster. The real challenge work is is very controversial.

It’s not accepted by the mainstream community. I have not studied it. I cannot comment on it. From a Buddhist standpoint, there is no such thing as a universal consciousness. There is a fully enlightened mind with which unfortunately we do not participate, and there is the possibility of telepathic communication, the mind which directly knows another’s mind.

Then the range of telepathic communication is open to question. Researchers in the field like Broad, feel that there could be cases of what he calls strong ESP, telepathic communication or clairvoyance on scales which are so great that they would beggar the imagination. He has little evidence for this, but he uses this as a major argument against Stevenson’s cases. So I can’t answer your question in a nutshell. Please.

Some of those parallel powers that seem to come about through acquiring Shamatha, calm abiding. We know that they are problem beings in this world who have acquired those powers, especially like some of our great masters. If those great masters have those sorts of powers, perhaps the ability to influence others’ minds, etcetera, why would they not make use of those powers to save their whole population, for instance, to death? Could they not communicate with the powers in China and perhaps influence their minds to stop what’s being done to their people? Also, if these beings have these incredible powers of paranormal perceptions, why do they have to rely on spirits and Nechung or the oracles?

Mose to be able to know what to do? Well, your question is is two edged. On the one side, you affirm that those powers exist and at the same time, you seem to be implying that they don’t exist since you don’t see their effects. There are several problems at work. First, if paranormal powers exist, their usage is subject to ethics.

Ethics prevents us from forcing others to do something against their will, and in the Buddhist context, are very strong strictures against manifesting these powers for that reason. Other religions and traditions like Hinduism, in which they are manifested much more casually, suffer from precisely the problem these powers bring, which is a fascination with the paranormal, which I have seen many times in people the first time they experienced that. Then, I think with Westerners, the manifestation of these powers, if it occurred, would profoundly destabilize the person. It would be damaging. With Asians who come from traditional country cultures where they are integrated in the culture, it is less destabilizing, but the same fascination occurs.

This fascination can be harmful. Regarding your question about Tibet, it would be lovely if omniscience went hand in hand with omnipotence. But omnipotence in the Christian sense of a term is not a given for in the Buddhist world. Tibet was a victim of the collective karma of the Tibetans in the self same way as we in this room are the victim of the collective karma of Westerners. Tibet was invaded by China because of reasons connected with Tibet’s collective karma.

In, this room, in a Buddhist temple, we have to speak of the minds being non material because of the collective karma of Westerners, which is profoundly skeptical. So we all of us, as Jampayinjian explained yesterday, we are at the receiving end of a very long continuum of mind. Then, what I would like to conclude with, and your question allows me to reach that point, is that the most important thing I think for us is to gain personal experience. One of the very big problems of Westerners is, if I could use a strong term, voyeurism. It is a fascination for the spiritual experience of others, a consumption of the spiritual experience of others, a bit in the same way as we consume cornflakes at the supermarket.

Unfortunately, that’s of no help. I think we have to go there and see things. And we can go there and see things if we practice, if we do the retreats, if we meditate. It is the retreats and the meditation as Rinpoche has said many times which lead to personal experience. Once one has personal experience, one knows.

Someone who does not have personal experience does not know. Personal experience in the Buddhist tradition cannot be transmitted. For that reason, it is never talked about. Because the person in the receiving end is not going to believe whatever you say. It makes no difference at all.

And for the person who talks about these things, the teacher who talks about these things, it may actually affect his own practice and experience. So I think what is on offer in the Buddhist tradition is for all of us to go and try. Rinpoche has given the teachings, so as the Dhyayama has given the teachings, there are retreat centers, there are meditation centers. Go, try, gain your own personal experiences, and you will know. But otherwise, the experience of others, no benefit.

Sorry. Moose are widely used because it is a very strong part of Tibetan monastic discipline. I’m really unqualified to talk about this. Not to manifest any capacities one might have, then oracles are a way perhaps for the teacher to do this. Then, I think, when the student from his or her side has profound faith, the experience of the teacher changes and the teacher manifests perhaps more in his or her true form.

But our experience is contingent on how we look on the world. If we wear pink glasses, the world is pink. And if we wear black glasses, the world is black. We can hold questions or jot them down as you think about them for the panel later on. But would you please join me for thanking for once again feeding our mind and in a most stimulating way.

So thank you very much Ilya. Thank you. And we will resume at half past for the video if you’d like to come at 12:30. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top