Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-03-07 – KR.mp3
UUID: 9fc012f4-7aea-41f4-9ca4-c690dd4b4ca2
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Preliminary Practices (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-03-07
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 53m
Words: 4,858
Generally speaking, since motivation is so critical for whatever we do, one has to analyze it carefully. If we analyze carefully the issue of motivation, we can understand it from the standpoint both of its reasons and of its goal or its object. Therefore, we practice for fifteen minutes, twenty five minutes, ten minutes, irrespective of the duration of our practice, we should check our motivation whether we be on the bus, at home or whatever. How do we go about this process of checking our motivation? If we take for instance the process which leads us from home somewhere, let’s say to work, then we should ask ourselves when I left home, what was my goal?
What was the reason I kept I left home? And then when we think of our goal, our motivation for leaving home will become clear in our minds. Now regarding our coming here tonight to attend teachings, probably in 100% of the cases, the goal is to study the Buddhist teachings. But we have to go one step further in the past. What is the goal for our studying Buddhist teachings?
Is it this life alone or is it future lives? Is it for instance just to increase our professional reputation or is it for something else? And if this type of inappropriate motivation is present in our mind we should discard it at once and give rise to a motivation which wishes to attain the state of unalloyed full enlightenment for the sake of mother sentient beings as vast as space. To attain this state, in turn, we must study these three principles of the path which are renunciation or definite emergence, bodhicitta and the view which realizes emptiness. However, this is very difficult if we do not obtain a human basis for practice.
To obtain such a human basis for practice in the future, at present, we must take the essence of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. This taking the essence of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is none other than the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. And this abandonment of the 10 non virtues, as Geshela has explained, arises through meditating on death and impermanence. Therefore meditating on death and impermanence one gives rise to the state of mind and then strives for higher status in future lives on which basis one is able to practice the three principles of the path. And therefore if such a motivation is present in our mind, this is a sufficient motivation to receive these teachings.
Otherwise if an inappropriate motivation, in other words afflictions as Geshela explained is present, then it is inappropriate and we must discard it. As Panchen Lama looks on to again, the fourth Panchen Lama says in the Lama impair of the Lama trooper, through realizing that this hard to find swiftly fleeting and easily destroyed human rebirth is destroyed with great facility. Do not waste your time on the meaningless activities of this life. This is a very profound passage and it, behooves us to reflect on it, to understand clearly that this human rebirth is difficult to obtain, that it is easily destroyed and that it is fleeting. And on this basis, understanding these key points to take the very essence of this human rebirth and not to waste it on what is meaningless but instead to practice what is meaningful.
Therefore let us generate this motivation. As you said in the path clarifying liberation, the Talam Selje, although they memorize the words do not remain, Understanding the words, they do not understanding the meaning. Even understanding the meaning, they are unable to place it in their continuum. The meaning of this quote is that when we memorize texts, we are unable retain them. When we retain the words, we don’t understand the actual meaning of the words and even though we intellectually understand the meaning, we do not engage in true practice which is mixing the meaning with our minds.
For this reason, it can be said that we have not created a correct tree of accumulation of merit. What is the tree of accumulation of merit in this context? It is twofold. The higher tree of accumulation of merit is none other than the objects of refuge. The lower tree of accumulation of merit is other beings and ourselves.
And therefore, what is the crux, what is the import of this text Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand which we are studying? It can be said to be twofold. It can be said to be either the three principles of the path, definite emergence, bodhicitta and the view realizing emptiness, or alternatively the practices of the beings of the three scopes. However, when we study and we do not understand and realizations do not dawn in our mind stream, then it is in keeping with the quote previously mentioned. They memorize but do not retain the words.
They do not understand the meaning and realizations do not dawn in their continuum. The oral instruction is the accumulation of merit. So the all instruction for those engaging in the practices of Sutra and Tantra for whom realizations do not dawn is none other than the instructions regarding a seed which is assorted with requisite conditions such as manure and heat but lacks water. Even though a seed has the requisite conditions such as manure and heat, if it is not watered then one of the conditions is missing and the seed cannot sprout. Likewise from our side, even though we study and put effort, if we lack one of the conditions which is the accumulation of merit, realizations will not dawn.
And therefore from within the two manners of accumulating merit with respect to the higher field which is the triple gem and with respect to the lower field which is sentient beings equal to oneself, nay sentient beings in general. It is Geshela’s opinion that the presentation of the six preliminary practices in the context of liberation in the palm of your hand which we have started to see refer to preliminary practices in the context of accumulation of merit with respect to the higher field. In other words, the triple gem. Whereas the practices in the context of accumulating merit with respect to the lower field that is with respect to sentient beings such as ourselves are mainly the three first of the six perfections which are the perfection of generosity, of ethics and of forbearance. The fourth perfection, the perfection of enthusiasm or energy has actually two components, one from the standpoint of method and one from the standpoint of wisdom.
And therefore here, as is explained in Liberation in the Palm of your hand, it is on the basis of reliance on the spiritual teacher as the root of the path that one trains. This means that the totality of the paths of the beings of the three scopes arise in dependence on reliance on the spiritual teacher. And as a preliminary to reliance on the spiritual teacher, one engages in these six preliminary practices of which Gesheva has already explained too. These six preliminary practices are explained in the context of liberation in the palm of your hand and probably not in the context of Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Cemo. And therefore this is how one should practice whether one is actually studying, meditating or engaging in retreats.
Then regarding one’s own regular practice, if one is in the situation of someone like Pamela with a small house, then in that section, one has an altar room in which, if one is a Buddhist, one should have the object of refuge which is appropriate for oneself. In this case, a statue of Buddha Shakyamuni. And then when one rises in the morning at five or at six in the morning, this is how one should proceed. Most obviously if we have not gone to bed before twelve at night getting up at five or six in the morning is rather difficult. Then in Gesheva’s own case, he is a little bit odd.
Whatever time he goes to sleep at, he can never sleep more than five hours a night. So if he goes to bed at midnight, he gets up at five. If he goes to bed at 01:00, he can never get up after 06:00 in the morning. But whatever time you get up, you should go into your altar room and then you should perform the six preliminary practices which we have been studying and study them as well. Then to be precise, one really ought to bid farewell to the objects of refuge in the evening before going to sleep and invite them in the morning before one starts one’s practice.
However, most of us do not have the time to do this. This is really a practice for those who are ordained. And therefore engaging in the preliminary practices means after tidying one’s altar room that one should set out the offerings. Geshela mentioned last time a term which was a bit unclear and this refers to causing clatter among the offering bowls. One should not clatter or clash the offering bowls together.
Instead, one should set out the various offering substances, water for instance, in a very smooth harmonious and quiet way. So regarding the third outline which is how to sit, there are some difficult points here, although more so because in the outline of Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand which is actually the outline of the swift path, things are not explained very clearly. So Geshela is going to clarify this for us. And therefore it is said in the outline of the swift path sitting on a comfortable cushion in the eightfold posture give rise to refuge and the uncommon mind. Ageshira will comment at present directly from the outline of the swift path.
So the first thing one does is one sits on a comfortable cushion and then one has to place beneath this cushion cushions and dura grass without mixing them together. However, before doing this one must place on the ground under oneself a swastika which is drawn in white chalk. This swastika symbolizes the double Vajra which has two meanings. It first symbolizes the fact that Buddha Shakyamuni attained full enlightenment in Bodhgaya and secondly it also symbolizes the stability of our own practice. As we ourselves are not fully enlightened, we cannot rest on a double Vajra therefore we draw a as its substitute.
Then on top of the swastika drawn in white chalk, we place durva and Kusha grass with their edges pointing outwards. Kusha grass’s main purpose is to give rise to a hale, hearty and healthy and straight body and durva grass is said to promote long life. And then on top of the Swastika drawn in white chalk, the Kusha and dura grass, one can put whatever extra cushions one wants in Gescheler’s case two. These are unimportant. They are not covered in the posture.
The cushion which is referred to is a cushion which is placed beneath one’s behind and this cushion has the important role of keeping us straight. It is also said that if one sits on an elevated cushion like that, it reduces pain both in the hip and the knees. And at present it is said in the outline one must adopt the sevenfold featured position of Vairochana. The features are as follows. The first is that one should cross one’s legs.
If one can enter into full Vajrasana position, so much the better. Otherwise one crosses one’s legs as Geshela has shown. Then the second element of this sevenfold feature is the hands. One rests one’s right hand on one’s left hand, thumbs touching at the navel. The third feature is the back.
It is said that one’s back should be straight as a bamboo pole and the reason for this is that if the back is straight as a bamboo pole then the channels within the back will be straightened. In turn the winds, the prana energy can circulate easily and the mind which rides on these then can flow easily as well. Then the following features are the lips, the teeth and the tongue. Lips and teeth are left as usual, in other words loose and the tongue itself must be placed on one’s palate, one’s upper palate. The reason for this is to prevent when one meditates for hours saliva from flowing outside of the mouth.
Nageshala remembers when he was at Gume Tantric Monastery that there were extremely long rituals and recitations which would last four or five hours. It was therefore impossible to recite continuously and sometimes unfortunately some monks would doze off and they would drool. The following features are the head, the eyes and the shoulder. One’s head should be bent and slightly inclined downwards. One’s gaze should follow one’s nose.
It is said that if one does this, this reduces mental agitation and one’s shoulders should be even and loose. So this is the sevenfold posture of Vairochana and it must be a difficult point since Mahpa Lodzawa said in Tibet none of the great meditators can even sit correctly like I myself Mahpa Lodzawa. The reason for which this is known as the posture of Vairochana is because Vairochana is the purified form of the form aggregate and this posture refers to the posture of the form of the bodily aggregate. This is therefore the sevenfold posture of Vairochana and it becomes an eightfold posture when one adds to it the control of the flow of breath. Mindfulness of breathing in this context, in other words checking the outward and inward flow of breath is engaged in for one specific reason which is to bring the mind back to a neutral state.
If our mind is beset by afflictions such as anger or desire and they are very strong, then irrespective of what we say verbally, I take refuge in the Buddha Dharma Sangha for the sake of all mother sentient beings may I attain full enlightenment. These remain only words. As I said, the mind follows the, the body follows the mind and the mind follows the afflictions. Therefore, the first thing we have to do in this situation is to bring the mind back to a neutral state. The same way as if we have a piece of fabric and we want to dye it red, let us say our piece of white fabric is heavily stained, we first have to get rid of the stains and only after having gotten rid of the stains can we hope to dye it a deep red.
Likewise, if our mind is beset with the afflictions, we first must get rid of the afflictions bringing the mind back to a neutral state and then we can direct it towards virtue. And therefore, this eighth feature of the posture Vairochana mindfulness of breath is engaged in as follows. First one examines one’s mind in the same way as when examined one’s motivation. One asks oneself, am I under the influence of an affliction, of a delusion or not? If one is under the influence of an affliction, then one must bring back the mind to a neutral state.
Therefore, one focuses on the outward and inward movement of the breath without breathing too forcefully and too loudly on the one hand but without breathing too softly on the other hand because if one breathes too softly, one will be unable to count the breaths. And one counts 21 full cycles of breath. All visualizing in the process that when one breathes out, one expels all of the afflictions from one’s mind stream and when one inhales, one inhales the blessings of one’s root teachers. One proceeds in this way for 21 cycles. So we can see for ourselves that if we lose control of ourselves, for instance if we are hiccuping uncontrollably, then when someone asks us to bring them something, we are unable to help them.
And the way one should practice in this context is in keeping Geshela thinks with one of the Vinaya texts in which it is said that there is an exemption for practicing in cold countries where one can for instance sit on leather and so forth. But if there is no such exemption and the instructions are at odds with this, then one should act immediately and discard such an inappropriate base. And therefore if one’s mind is affected by the afflictions initially one must turn one’s mind into a neutral state of mind and then after turning one’s mind in a neutral state of mind one can direct it towards virtuous practices. However, if when checking one’s motivation one finds one is not beset by the coarse afflictions, it is unnecessary to practice this mindfulness of breath. And for this reason, since it is unnecessary to practice mindfulness of breathing if the mind is not beset by the afflictions, it is presented separately from the seven main features of the posture of Vairochana.
Now the outline continues with a difficult point from within a special virtuous frame of mind. The problem which arises here is the meaning of the adjective special. And Jetsongpa asked this question to the assembled great meditators of Tibet in his assorted questions. What in the self same way as at the beginning of sutras and tantras from Sanskrit comes at the beginning of all practice. As you know, at the beginning of sutras and tantras, we have the terms from Sanskrit.
Then, the Chonghapa’s question was what came at the beginning and at the end of all practice? To this, the Penchant Lama, Lobsang Choi Ghi answered, at the beginning and at the end of all practice comes motivation. This is the shared teaching of all of the great teachers starting in the sutras themselves and the great teaching of Arya Nagarjuna and Atisha and so forth. It is therefore critical to generate a powerful, literally a heavy motivation at the beginning of one’s practice and not just merely to recite the words, may I attain full enlightenment for the sake of all mother sentient beings as vast as space, which is totally meaningless when recited in that way and is of no benefit to anybody. Instead, one must generate this powerful motivation.
And there is clear scriptural source for the fact that with such a powerful good motivation even an apparently evil deed, a criminal deed actually becomes virtuous. The example which is given is that of one of the past lives of Buddha Shakyamuni in which he was an important merchant on a trading mission with some 500 other merchants across the ocean and a criminal on board the ship was planning to slaughter the 500 merchants and to appropriate himself their goods. Buddha Shakyamuni in his previous life as a great merchant was aware of this man’s plans and over and again tried to discourage him but was unable to do so. And then reflecting that on the one hand the lives of 500 were at stake as opposed to the life of one evil person and that he himself was not afraid to be reborn in the lower realms for a non virtuous deed with the motivation of saving these 500 merchants he freed from that life this criminal. And as a result of this, not only were 500 lives saved and not only were these merchants grateful to him, but Buddha himself in his previous life accumulated extraordinary it is said, on par with the accumulation of kalpa’s worth of merit.
Another example from days of Yorid India when a kshatriya in other words a member of the military caste and a brahmin in other words a member of the priestly caste both decided to go begging for the rests of the monastic meals. They went together, but they chose different times. The member of the warrior caste, Kasaitriya, knew the time at which the monks finished their meals and went immediately after they had finished their meals and was able to beg enough to satisfy his hunger. However, the member of the priestly caste of the Brahmin caste was not aware of the time when the monks finished their meals and he went long after they had finished their meals when there was nothing else to obtain. Then when the two friends met again, the Kshatriya asked the Brahmin, have you obtained enough to satisfy your hunger?
And the Brahmin was so irritated by his predicament that he said, if only I had the power to do so, I would decapitate all these monks. However, the member of the Kashaytriya cast said, if only I had the capacity to offer to the assembled Sangha meals with 100 different flavors. Then the two friends pursued their travels and since it was very hot that period in India, they lay down by the side of the road to take a nap and a chariot passed and cut the head of the Brahmin friend as a direct result of his evil motivation. The Kshatriya, a member of the warlike caste, continued his path alone and eventually reached a kingdom whose king did not have a son and who adopted him. After adopting him, it is said that in that life or in a future life, probably in that life, Geshela says, this Kshaitriya saw truth.
In other words, he attained the path of seeing. So this should show us clearly the importance of motivation. We can see for ourselves that when we meet with each other, we say, hello, how do you do in Tibetan? Your body well, but the ancient Kadampa Geshes when they were greeted by Atisha, Georgia were asked by Atisha not how they were doing but have you had a good mind today? And when Atisha asked about the mind, he was asking about their motivation.
It is probably a difficult point. As the noble protector Je Tsongkhapa said, from a virtuous intention arise the grounds and paths and from an evil intention neither grounds nor paths arise. Everything arises from the intention. Let us take for instance a case of four persons who are together doing a Tara retreat. And the first person, all four reciting the mantra of Tara together.
So in terms of their practice all are identical. The first is reciting it with Bodhicitta for the sake of all sentient beings. The second is reciting it to gain liberation from cyclic existence for himself alone. In other words, with definite emergence or renunciation. The third is reciting it to get a higher rebirth in a future life.
And the last is reciting it to eliminate obstructions in this life. The result of these four practices is completely different. The first practice is a Mahayana practice and leads to the attainment of full unalloyed enlightenment. The second practice, still the recitation of the mantra of Tara, is a Hinayana practice which leads to liberation. The third, still the recitation of the mantra of is the practice of the lowest category of Buddhist practitioner aiming for happiness in future lives.
And the last practice is a non Buddhist practice aiming for the elimination of interferences in this life. In terms of exterior appearance, the practices are identical. In terms of motivation and a result, they are radically different. And for this reason, when Atisha’s students asked him what the results of practicing, for instance, generosity, ethics or forbearance thinking mainly of this life were, he said happiness in this life. And when they asked him what the results were in future lives, he said rebirth in a hell, rebirth as a hungry ghost, rebirth as an animal.
It is said in the Buddhist philosophical treatises that the definition of virtue is that whose maturing result is pleasant for the mind or the definition of non virtue is that whose maturing result is unpleasant for the mind. If these are the actual definitions, then there is a little bit of a problem in terms of the subdivisions of virtue since one probably has to subdivide virtue into mundane and super mundane virtue. So this is something to be analyzed. And therefore there are some very specific advice which are given to monks in monasteries on the importance of having a good motivation for their studies at which point going to the debate courtyard and debating becomes virtuous and one moves forwards by combining the method and the wisdom aspect of the path. Whereas otherwise the bread and the tea one consumes become occasions for non virtue.
Now in our context here as lay people, it is important that the motivation we generate for receiving teachings be a good one, either a Mahayana or a Hinayana motivation. And this completes explanations regarding the motivation in the context of checking the motivation as a preliminary to practice. So while we are in our room, we should check carefully our motivation and if it is incorrect, we should transform it turning it initially if our mind is afflicted into a neutral state of mind and then turning it into a virtuous state of mind. Otherwise to recite at high speed may all sentient beings without exception be led to a state of full enlightenment is totally meaningless. The goal is to blend the intention with our mind, to blend the words with our mind.
And therefore one should practice in this posture for as long as one is able to a couple hours if one has the capacity otherwise fifty minutes, half an hour, fifteen minutes and if one is a beginner one should start with very, very short sessions practicing first five minutes. Then when the five minutes go well, six minutes and moving upwards in this way. Most of us have to go to work, then those of us who have to go to work probably cannot practice in this way. But if you are able even to practice in this way for five or six minutes, your life will become meaningful. And we have finished the third outline of the preliminary practices of Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand which leads us to page 125 of the English translation.
You should ask me specifically if there was an English translation of this text. Then he would like to ask you when you go home to work through these passages and to read them in English. And therefore we have covered in these three preliminary practices a section from page 104 in the English translation to page 150. Therefore, Geshela would like to ask us to read at home several times these sections and to put them in practice. So Gisher will take at present one question.
So it’s a difficult question. Geshela thinks that basically regarding the actual meaning, but perhaps not the precise enumerations, his explanations should be in full compatibility with Liberation in the Palm of Johan. Now today, Gesheera talked in great detail of a COP topic, which is really not broached in Liberation in the Palm of Johan, which is motivation in the context of the eighth practice. So that you should add to the teachings in liberation in the palm of your hand. It would be impossible to have in liberation in the palm of your hand absolutely everything you need without exception.
Then another question. Yes, Judy. Definitely there is no difference between studying, meditating and doing retreats. This is an artificial conceptual distinction. When we do retreats, we’re doing nothing else than meditating and studying.
Therefore there must be we must draw under a cushion a swastika and put kusha grass. I will summarize. So regarding your question, indeed Buddha Shakyamuni said very clearly that this amounts to a correct definition of virtue since from virtue arises happiness. For instance, from the motivation of bodhicitta arises results which are of the nature of happiness, whereas from non virtue arises unhappiness. Then in your rendition of Geshela’s definition, you forgot the term maturation.
So I asked Geshela if it made a difference. The precise definition is virtue is that whose result of maturation is happiness. Your question was whether virtue is that whose result is happiness. No, I said maturing. You said maturing also.
Then Geshela says even had you forgotten maturation, there is no difference. So to give you or to take the example of the previous life of the Buddha as a merchant which Geshela gave to illustrate this. When the Buddha was a merchant and he chose to kill a criminal to save the lives of 500 other merchants. Because of the motivation of saving the lives of 500 other merchants, which was an extraordinarily powerful motivation, vast waves of virtue were accumulated. Then, however, the deed of killing itself in and of itself is a non virtuous deed which gives rise to its own results.
The two are therefore interwoven. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- chulen
- Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.