Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-02-12 – KR.mp3
UUID: 778e6a5a-09a6-4d35-b343-3a167819cec2
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-02-12
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 34m
Words: 3,350
Alright. In as much as the motivation both to listen and to explain the teachings is critical, one must generate the requisite motivation. And one can do this reflecting on the fact that at present, we have obtained a life, a time, technically in Tibetan, a bodily basis, in other words, a physical body of the aggregates, which lends itself to practice. This physical body we have, this life we have, is a happy rebirth. On this basis, we must resolve to practice for future lives, because our goal is to establish happiness in future lives.
And to establish happiness in future lives, in other words, lives from the next life onwards, one must engage carefully in practice. To do this, one must take the resolve at present to study. We will now meditate for two minutes on generating the motivation. That’s As is said in Dhama Kirti’s Pramanavarttika, hence, from impermanence, realize that selflessness which eliminates suffering. This clearly demonstrates how critical the realization of impermanence is, and as Geshe Chekawa says in his Root Text, First train in the preliminaries.
The preliminaries for the practitioner of a great scope is a practice of the being of middling scope. The preliminary for the practitioner of middling scope is a practice of the being of small scope. And what is supreme in the practice of the being of small scope is meditation on death and impermanence. Now regarding meditation on impermanence, generally speaking, when we refer to impermanence, this impermanence must be posited on the basis of our aggregates, in other words, mainly of our body. And there are two ways to look at impermanence.
The first is to see the instantaneous transit transitoriness of aggregates, the fact that they change instant by instant. The second way of looking at it is to reflect on the fact that the physical aggregate, the body, in other words, has an end. And this end of the aggregate, of physical aggregate, is known as death. Now regarding meditation on death and impermanence, there are two broad ways of thinking about it. The first is the mundane approach in which we are afraid when we think of our death of the fact that we will have to leave our friends, our wealth, and our body behind.
This is not what is referred to in the context of meditation on death and impermanence. Instead, in the context of meditation on death and impermanence, it is the second approach one should focus upon, which is to reflect on the fact that at the time of death there are two paths, one leading to the higher realms and one to the lower realms. Now at present we have no direct experience of the lower realms, but we do understand what it means to be reborn in the higher realms. To just make prayers to be reborn in the higher realms is of no benefit whatsoever. To be reborn in the higher realms, we must create the causes to be reborn in the higher realms, and this is a motivation we should have when meditating on death and impermanence.
And it is said that in the mind training, the Luo Jong texts, that all meditations on death and impermanence should be subsumed in one. And the way one does this is who understanding the actual process of impermanence. Impermanence refers to the fact that instant by instant we change. This is something which is not easily accessible to us, we do not understand it. However, we can understand it if we move upwards in the scale of time.
We we see that if we change second by second, then obviously there would be change minute by minute, and change minute by minute means change hour by hour. Change hour by hour means change day by day. Change day by day means change month by month. Change month by month means change year by year. That Lojong annual change is something we can become aware of even if we have not studied.
So to take an example, for instance, Geshela’s table, Our mind naturally considers that the table of yesterday and today’s table are one and the same. Nonetheless, if we analyze carefully, we can see that yesterday’s table and today’s table are different. The mind which apprehends yesterday’s table as the same as today’s table is the apprehension at the permanence of phenomena. Taking the following following example, our aggregates or our body, the physical aggregate. The mind which apprehends our aggregates as permanent or equal, continuous during time, is that mind which apprehends at the permanence of phenomena.
So when we think I am unchanging, my body yesterday is the same as my body today, This is the mind which apprehends at the permanence of the body which is at work. And it is independence in turn on this apprehension of the permanence of phenomena that desire and hatred, closeness and animosity arise. So as phenomena change instant by instant, as our aggregates change instant by instant, it is independence on that, that the Lojong change is the cessation of the continuum of the aggregates occurs. However, we do not understand this momentariness of phenomena, we can only infer it through the fact that there is an end of this body, the end of this body is the time of death and extrapolating from that, we deduce that the body must have changed instantaneously over many years to reach this point of disintegration. So it is independence on this that we should practice and generally speaking, one’s attraction to pleasure and happiness decreases, once one understands the impermanence of phenomena.
Obviously, how attracted one is to pleasure and happiness depends also very much on whether it is for one’s own sake or that of others. If it is for the sake of others, this is more acceptable than if it is exclusively for one’s own sake. And therefore, reflecting over and again on impermanence and specifically the impermanence of one’s aggregates, one will generate contentment with one’s lot, contentment with whatever happiness we have. Independence on this, one’s attraction to happiness will progressively decrease and the power of the afflictions over one’s mind will also progressively decrease. And independence on what do we generate the wish, the aspiration to attain the state of a god or the human being in future lives.
In other words, the aspiration of the being of small scope. It is independence on repeated habituation to death and impermanence. That mind, realizes death and impermanence, is the root cause which gives rise to a wish for the states of a god or of a human being in future lives, and which turns our minds away from the vanities, from the futilities of this life. And therefore, it is through repeated training and meditation on death and impermanence that we give rise to the wish to be liberated from the lower realms and to the wish to attain the state of a god or a human being in future lives. In other words, the path of the being of small scope.
It is through repeated training in the mind which realizes the selflessness of phenomena that we give rise to the wish to be liberated from cyclic existence in general, in other words, to the attainment of Nirvana. This mind, which realizes death and impermanence, is rooted in a reality established through a valid cognizer, through a pramana, and it acts through repeated habituation as the antidote to attraction, the vanities, to the futilities of this like, of this life. Therefore, it induces a wish to attain happiness as a human being or a god in future lives. And therefore, the mind, which realizes death and impermanence acts as the antidote to the attractions of this life and generates the wish to attain higher status in future lives. Likewise, the view which realizes selflessness generates the wish to attain the state of liberation from cyclic existence.
How does it do this? It is actually the mind which apprehends the inherent existence of a self, which is the root of both desire and anger. Desire and anger and the other afflictions themselves give rise to contaminated karma and decontaminated aggregates, which chain us to cyclic existence through generating the mind, which realizes the lack of inherent existence of all phenomena, one cuts this process at the root. This is the reason for which this mind is said to lead to liberation, and why it is said in Pramana Vartika from excuse me, from death and impermanence, aspiration towards higher rebirth and from the view of selflessness, liberation. And these reflections and teachings on death and impermanence and or selflessness are indeed taught in the Buddhist scriptures, but more fundamentally, they are in accordance with reality.
They are confirmed through physical experimentation. Now whether from one’s own side, one wishes to come to the Dharma Center to attend teachings, or one prefers to stay at one’s own home, these reflections on death and impermanence, which lead one to reflections on karma and causality, are of tremendous benefit for oneself, in as much as they give rise to that courage which enables us to face up to difficulties. And now regarding the presentation of death and impermanence, in keeping with our text, Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun, this has three subdivisions. Presentation of the certainty of death, of the uncertainty of the time of death, and of the fact that at the time of death, apart from dharma, nothing whatsoever will be of any benefit, possessions, friends, and so forth. Regarding the first of these topics, the certainty of the time of death, we should reflect on the fact that all without one single exception are subjected to death.
Geshela himself is. Buddha Shakyamuni, our teacher, died. And reflecting on this, this should put our minds more at ease regarding our own future demise. And the second subdivision within the certainty of death, as presented in our text, is that irrespective of where one dwells, one will necessarily die, whether one dwells on mountain cliffs, in plains, in the waters up or beneath. There is a doubt regarding this matter and Geshela will mention it even though for some of the students here it may be difficult to understand if they haven’t studied.
And it refers to beings which are abiding in a meditative equipoise on cessation. Specifically, the Shravaka Ahats and the Mahayana Arhats. These are beings which actually, under the force of the mental impulse initiated at the time when they enter in a meditative equipoise on cessation, will remain in that state for as long as they choose, whether it be hundreds, hundreds or thousands of years. And they cannot die during this period. Their physical continuum cannot be interrupted.
It is said in the Mahayana that Shravaka Arhats, when they enter in a meditative equipoise on cessation, even though they themselves believe they have attained Nirvana, which is a cessation of all suffering, including all pervasive suffering, actually are simply reborn in a pure land within an enclosed lotus. And they stay within this state indefinitely, they would stay eternally within this state, unless the Buddha’s manifested and told them you have not reached a true cessation of suffering, you must actually leave this meditation, a meditative equipoise and cessation and reenter the path. So the doubt there is regarding the second subtopic is concerning beings of this nature. Likewise, wherever one is born, whatever one’s situation, it is certain that one will experience death and impermanence. Likewise, no conditions or no possibility, there is no possibility to prevent death.
It is impossible to prevent the process of death irrespective of the efforts we make. We are in the same situation as someone, let us say, in a temple such as this one, in which all four walls of the temple would progressively be coming ever closer. If there is no exit within the temple, then as all four walls are inexorably coming closer, it is certain that we will die. There is no possibility to escape. Therefore, irrespective of the medicines, the drugs or the mantras for that matter which we recite, it is certain that we will die.
Taking the this example, if we try to interpret at present its meaning, all of us are subject to the or subjected to the four sufferings of birth, aging, sickness, death. We all know the sufferings associated with birth, the birth of a child. The sufferings of aging are the sufferings of being bent over and riddled with pain. The sufferings of disease we have, most of us, experienced, and as to the sufferings of death, they are well known. Here death can either occur in its own time, in which case it is a death which is determined by the karma of past lives, which define a maximum lifespan for us, or it can occur through adventitious causes, such as being struck down, for instance, by a sword and more and so forth.
The second main outline is the uncertainty of the time of death. There is not one of us in this room who can say with certainty that next year he or she will be alive. For that matter, we cannot say that this year we will be alive. Now this we can understand through reflecting on the fact that it is through the passage of seconds that minutes pass, through the passage of minutes that hours pass, through the passage of hours that days, months, and years flow. Let us take to understand this better the example of someone whose last hour has come, who has exactly one hour left to live and will die within that hour.
He knows he will die within that hour and as the minutes pass, the sixty minutes within the hour, he comes closer and closer minute by minute to the time of his death. Such a person has no interest whatsoever in money, in wealth, or in friends. He is totally obsessed with the forthcoming death. This is how one should practice. It’s the same thing with water in a river.
Once water in a river has passed, it cannot be drawn back. Likewise, once the days of our life are past, there is no getting them back. Likewise, it is akin to a shepherd leading out flocks of sheep, goats, and horses. The sheep, goats, and horses will necessarily be gathered back in the stable in the evening. Likewise, the forces of birth, aging, sickness, and death will necessarily lead to our life’s termination.
So there are numerous such examples and we should draw on them in our meditation on death and impermanence to try to gain some understanding of impermanence. We will stop here at the third outline. In other words, that at the time of death, nothing whatsoever apart from dharma is of benefit. We now have the opportunity for questions regarding impermanence. Impermanence.
Impermanence. Impermanence. Impermanence. Impermanence. Permanence.
Yeah. Yeah. Impermanence. Impermanence. Okay.
Thank you. Yeah. One hour. Sure. You’re afraid, aren’t you?
What is all this talk about helping one’s relatives? You can’t help yourself. No. No. They’ve kept I saw many people die.
I never saw someone able to help themselves. You know? Was No. What can you do? What can you do for your relatives?
Yeah. Yeah. I don’t know. Are there other questions? Richard.
This could be very difficult to translate. So Buddha, when we speak of dying, there is dying through karma and afflictions and other forms of dying. Buddha did not die through the power of power of karma and afflictions. So Buddha Shakyamuni was an impermanent being just as ourselves. His death, however, is not the death of an ordinary being in as much as he did not die through the power of karma and afflictions, but chose to die.
There are three major deeds in the Buddha’s life, which are Buddha’s birth, his attaining full enlightenment, and he is manifesting parinirvana. These were undertaken voluntarily. So it is said in the Buddhist scriptures that for the sake of sentient beings, the Buddha manifested the 12 deeds and these 12 deeds include dying. Now this is a bit difficult to explain here. Are there other questions?
Yes. It is extremely beneficial. Generally speaking, in the presentation of the four noble truths, it is said that our aggregates have four characteristics. They are of the nature of suffering, they are impermanent, they are empty, and they are selfless. Any meditation on these four features of the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering and our aggregates by extension is of tremendous benefit.
Then at this point, one might wonder whether there is a contradiction between on the one hand meditating on the filthiness of one’s aggregates, and on the other hand saying that one’s aggregates are precious because they are a basis through which one can attain liberation and full enlightenment. His Holiness has said there is no such contradiction here. One must use the aggregates without being 100% attached to them. Are there other questions? So this is the motivation of practicing dharma when one is reborn as a god is not part of the motivation of the being of small scope.
It is far beyond the motivation of a being of small scope. A being of small scope is interested only in happiness in future lives and to attain that happiness wishes to be reborn as a god or as a human being. Now regarding the treatises, it is said, generally speaking, that within the three realms, the desire realm, the form realm, and the formless realm, the path of preparation from within the five paths, path of accumulation, preparation, seeing a meditation and normal learning, the path of preparation is present in the form realm. It is however present only within its two first levels which are heat and peak. There is doubt whether the level of patience is present or not within the form realm and the level of supreme dharma, cacio, is not present.
Which means that to enter the path of seeing, one must necessarily be reborn at the time of entering the path of seeing in the desire realm. Are there other questions? That’s a good question. The impermanence of a table is something which is pretty self evident. Regarding the mind, how can we see clearly the impermanence of mind?
A course example will make it very obvious for us. If we think of our mental capacity, our capacity for study when we were 15 or 16, then when we were 30, and when we were 60 or 70, it’s very obvious that by the time we hit 60 or 70, our mental capacity for study is nowhere near what it used to be when we were 15 or 16. It has decayed greatly due to age. That means that the mental capacity for study, the power, which was present at 15 or 16 is no longer present. That is a clear sign of the impermanence of mind.
Then another example which will make it easier to understand is if we take the case of memorization. Let us say we memorize two words on day one. Then the next day when we try to recite them, we can’t recite them. Now these two words did exist, but our mind is no longer able to recite them. This clearly demonstrates that the mind which is apprehending these words has degenerated or disappeared.
Alright. This is probably how it should be explained. This is this is just Gesheera’s viewpoint. So next Wednesday, Gesheera will resume the teachings of liberation in the palm of your hand. He would like to encourage all of you to attend because last year we just started it.
And as of this Wednesday, we’re entering into the actual body of the text. Last year is only the preliminaries. And then if you don’t come, it’s okay too. Mhmm.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- parinirvana
- The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shravaka nyen thö (Tib)
- A hearer; a Hinayana practitioner who strives for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a teacher. There are four divisions: stream-enterer, once-returner, non-returner and arhat. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.