Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-03-25 – KR.mp3
UUID: 2985b983-cf3b-4db1-a941-4f94737b7395
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-03-25
Duration: 1h 35m
Words: 3,971
As Aria Chandrakirti says in a famous quote which Geshela will develop, whatever activities the beings of this world engage in, it is important for them to find in these both happiness and favorable conditions. And having at present obtained such a good and worthy physical base, in other words, a human rebirth with all the freedoms and endowments, Should this life be spent meaninglessly, then as Shantideva says, it will be very difficult for one to obtain such a life again in the future. And therefore, if at present when we have such a rebirth, we do not create the perfect conditions for obtaining such a precious human rebirth in the future and are unfortunately reborn in the lower realms, it will be extraordinarily difficult, perhaps impossible on that basis alone to create causes for any higher rebirth. If we do not use careful reasoning and analysis to investigate our motivation, there is a very high risk that this so called motivation, may I attain full enlightenment for the sake of all mother sentient beings, is mere words, mere talk with no weight. Therefore, it is critical for us to look very carefully in the generation of motivation.
As I said in a text transcending the level of the gods whose author Geshela does not remember, practicing dharma, dharma should be held purely and honestly and one should not get involved in mental scattering. This is a profound and difficult quote. The meaning thereof is that, in our case, if we are Buddhists, then it is the Buddhist Dharma which we must practice purely and authentically. Whereas if we were practitioners of another religious tradition, it is that other religious tradition we have to practice authentically. Now in our case, if we consider ourselves as Buddhist and we set Buddhism as our foundation, then what should sentient beings practice as Buddhist?
Sentient beings are beings with minds, beings with consciousness, what we mean by sentient beings. And the foundation of Buddhist practice is training in renunciation or definite emergence, bodhicitta and the correct view of reality. How is it possible to do so if one does not have a good rebirth? Therefore, the foundation of these three principles of the path is finding the means to give rise to a good rebirth first. Now, if on the other hand, we look at the religious positions of those who accept the existence of a creator, of a god, we can see that broadly speaking in the revealed monotheisms, it is asserted that after death, there are only two possibilities.
One is either reborn eternally, one dwells eternally in heaven, or one dwells just as eternally in hell. There is no middle ground between these. Then such a viewpoint, Geshela thinks, is a very strange viewpoint. It means that once one is reborn in heaven, one can never fall from heaven and once one is reborn in hell, one can never rise from hell back to heaven or the realms of ordinary beings. This is not the view this Buddhist viewpoint.
If we take for instance a case of animals, we can see through reflecting as Buddhists that it might be possible to be be reborn as an animal, just as it might be possible for an animal to be reborn out of that state. And therefore, if we look at it at present from a Buddhist standpoint, The main goal, in the context of these teachings is generating bodhicitta as Mahayana practitioners. Generating bodhicitta is extremely difficult. It is probably not possible in one life. It must be trained in life over life after for many lives.
As is said in a famous scriptural quote, to gain realization, familiarize your mind through meditation over and again. So how can we train in bodhicitta over many lives? To do this, we must be sure to get human life after human life. Otherwise, it is not possible. And therefore, what are the collection of causes which are necessary for the attainment of Bodhicitta?
These collection of causes are first and foremost hearing, thinking and meditating on teachings on Bodhicitta and to be able to hear, think and meditate on teachings of Bodhicitta, it is necessary to have a physical basis which allows one to do this. In other words, a precious human rebirth. Therefore, a preliminary is to accumulate whatever causes are necessary to obtain a precious human rebirth over and again life after life. What are these causes? These causes are said by many great scholars to be none other than an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues.
Therefore, this is what we have to train in over and again. The quotes by these great scholars, Geshela feels, establish the fact that such an ethics enables one to obtain a precious human rebirth. Then please let us generate this motivation for a couple of minutes. There is a passage from Sutra which says, all of the rebirths of cyclic existence both the higher realms and the lower realms are impelled by karma which matures from long ago. The meaning of this passage from Sutra is that the 12 links of dependent origination which constitute cyclic existence mature in the following way.
If one has engaged in virtue for most of one’s life, then it is possible to have a strong virtuous mind at the type of time of death and this strong virtuous mind will impel us towards a higher rebirth. If on the other hand, one has mainly engaged in non virtue, the odds are that at the time of death, one will have a strong non virtuous mind and this will impel us towards a lower rebirth. As Thogme Sungbo says in his 37 practices of the bodhisattvas, it is the practice of bodhisattvas to purify themselves. This is the main practice of bodhisattvas. This quote is rooted in two famous passages from Sutra by the Buddha, Shakyamuni.
Buddha Shakyamuni said once, you are your own protectors. There is none but yourself to protect you. This means that apart from ourself, there is nobody who can protect us, who can through a blessing give us liberation. It is through our own efforts that we attain liberation. And likewise, the Buddha said in a sutra, I do not liberate sentient beings with my hand nor do I cleanse their sins through water nor do I bestow blessings.
It is through teaching the suchness of phenomena that I liberate beings. The meaning of this stanza is that Buddha is not a god who can liberate sentient beings by his blessing. The prayers are not effective. What is effective is the actual practice of the four noble truths and the Buddha’s teachings. And therefore, as the son of the or the sign of the bodhisattvas, Thomas Sangbo says, it is the practice of the bodhisattvas again and again to inspect their three doors and to restrain them if necessary.
It is the practice of bodhisattvas to check over and again the three doors of body, speech and mind and if they see their inappropriate behavior to restrain it immediately. It is Geshela’s feeling that there is no other practice but this and this practice is in his opinion certain to lead to a virtuous state of mind at the time of death. And therefore, it is over and again that we have to check our three doors to make sure we are not engaging in the 10 non virtuous deeds and if we are to restrain. And if we do this, Geshela feels it is certain that we will obtain a higher rebirth and on this basis down the line be able to obtain liberation and full enlightenment. What it is said that it is possible to attain liberation and full enlightenment in this life?
Geshela suspects it is extraordinarily difficult. His Holiness of Dalai Lama has emphasized this over and again in almost all the teachings Geshela has received from him. His Holiness teaches this based mainly on reasoning and only partly on scriptures. Generally speaking, both scripture and reasoning are necessary but it His Holiness teaches mainly based on reasoning, saying that on the basis of ethics, it is possible to obtain over and again in the future a happy rebirth. And as Arya Chandra Kirti says, apart from ethics, there is no cause for higher rebirths.
And therefore practicing in this way, it is almost certain that in the last instant of our life, in other words, at the time of death, a virtuous state of mind will arise and we will obtain a happy rebirth in our future life. In this context, we need to have a smooth and uneventful life. It is clear that for us ordinary beings, simple persons, if our death is brutal and violent in a car accident or an accident of any type, the odds of our being able to recollect these practices is very small. Therefore, we must have a very smooth death. And therefore it is critical for us to protect our health and to protect our body.
Regarding death, it is certain that it will come as is said in Shantideva’s Bodhisattva Acharyavatara. However, if we can die in a very smooth and untraumatic way, then having practiced virtue all our life, the practice of virtue will be possible within the death state. As the former abbot of Guimet Tantric College, said in a beautiful statement, it is necessary for us to die and therefore of all the diseases which can cause death, in my opinion diabetes is best because with diabetes the death is very smooth and it is possible to meditate on the stages of death in keeping with the Guhyasamaja Tantra. In other words dissolution of the four elements, the three appearance, the 70 conceptions and so forth. And therefore, it is important for us to protect our health, our physical well-being so that we can live for however long the previously accumulated karma, which created this life, allows us to live, whether it is seventy, eighty or 90 and use those years to practice well, so that in the death process we can practice.
And therefore, in the context of the teachings we are covering, it is important to meditate on death and impermanence to train for this moment. And when the moment of our death comes, the last moment of our life, it is extremely important to generate these virtuous thoughts. If one has great faith and a strong connection with a spiritual teacher, then traditionally, one will place a picture of the spiritual teacher in front of oneself. For instance, His Holiness, the Dalai Lama and focusing on this picture, one will die in a virtuous state of mind. But for this to be possible, it is important for us to meditate on death regularly now so that we have the courage and the strength to do this in the death process.
So the actual mechanism in the light of the 12 links of interdependent origination whereby a virtuous rebirth is generated can be one of the two following mechanisms in keeping with the treatises of Jetsuncukki Giltsein, which are the great monastic treatises of Serraje monastery. Actually, a virtuous karmic imprint which has been accumulated previously is present within the mental continuum and at the time of death, that aspiration for a higher rebirth which encompasses three of the 12 links including craving and holding and which is in actuality of the nature of desire, albeit a virtuous one, causes the maturation of the pre existing karmic imprint and this in turn gives rise to the virtuous rebirth. However, this position is somewhat difficult to defend and Geshela suspects it is actually the virtuous state of mind at the time of death which is combined with the aspiration for a higher rebirth. Once again, of the nature of three of the 12 links and of the nature of desire which causes this to give rise to a higher rebirth. Practicing in this way, we can hope to have fortunate rebirths life after life and on the basis of these fortunate rebirths to engage in hearing, thinking and meditating on the foundation of the path, which are the Four Noble Truths and then over time, over the lives, our habituation with with these will increase and we can realize them.
Therefore one must practice in this way life after life, life after life. It seems difficult to gain any powerful attainment in one life. As Jitsongkapa famously said, to attain the supreme path, in other words, to attain definite excellence and full attainment, liberation and full enlightenment, first attain a fully qualified base, in other words, first attain a precious human rebirth with the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments. And then life after life, having attained such a precious human rebirth, one can meditate on the four noble truths, engaging in the threefold activities of hearing about the four noble truths, then eventually after many lifetimes of hearing, thinking about the four noble truths, and then then after many lifetimes of hear of thinking, eventually meditating on the four noble truths and conjoining this practice with the practice of the three principles of the path, in other words, definite emergence, bodhicitta and the view realizing emptiness, and on this basis, eventually realization is certain. As therefore, Dhama Kirti says in the second chapter of his which Geshela quoted last time, hence, having established the existence of past and future lives, establish the existence of karma and causality and strive for higher status.
On this basis ascertain the four noble truths. And therefore having in ascertain the four noble truths, one such being who wishes to be of benefit to others with a powerful motivation, who wishes to be of benefit to the state or to the city will see that true benefit is only possible with bodhicitta and will strive for bodhicitta. Beings who do not have this innate sense wishing to benefit others can generate it through reflecting on the qualities or the benefits of bodhicitta. To generate bodhicitta, one must initially have trained in great compassion over many lives and great compassion in turn is generated within one of two processes. The sevenfold cause and exchange process of generation of bodhicitta within which great compassion arises or the interchange of self and others.
When definite emergence or renunciation has been generated within the mind, there are two paths. Somebody who has a profound wish to help others having generated renunciation within his mind will then move towards the Mahayana and train in the generation of bodhicitta. On the other hand, someone who thinks others are difficult to help, it may not be worth it, will then take care of his own interest and will focus in training in the Hinayana, in the lesser vehicle. And for such a being who wishes to benefit others and enters in the Mahayana, training in bodhicitta with the aim of leading all sentient beings to the state of full enlightenment. There are two main roads or two main procedures for generating Bodhicitta.
The first is the interchange of self and others which was initially taught by Shantideva in the Bodhisattva Acharyavatara and was explicated by Geshe Chekhawa in the mind training in seven verses. And for one such who wishes to train in the interchange of self and others in keeping with Gishi Chekawa’s instruction in mind training in seven stances. Initially, one starts by wishing to place beings in a state of happiness and with this as a motivation, one reflects on the fact that whole self cherishing has been the the source of all thoughts in past lives. Cherishing others is a source of all qualities. And generally speaking, when we refer to self cherishing as the source of all thoughts, the doubt which might arise in our mind is what precisely the relation is between self cherishing on the one hand and the innate apprehension of a self on the other hand.
They are related indeed, but there is a slight difference. Understanding therefore clearly that self cherishing is the source of all thoughts, we then understand that the suffering which arises does not come from the outside, it does not come from without ourselves, it comes from within ourselves and specifically it comes from karma and afflictions within the mind which in turn arise from the innate apprehension at an inherently existing self. And therefore here, understanding clearly that self cherishing, in other words egotism or egoism, is the cause for the destruction or the elimination of all possible qualities which can be generated and is as well the cause for all possible defects, we strive to eliminate it. This self cherishing manifests in numerous ways. It manifests, for instance, in, envy towards those who are our superiors, in competitiveness towards those who are our equal, and in pride towards those whom we see as our inferiors, as well as anger in general.
It can be seen therefore as a source of all thoughts. And examples of the manifestation of egoism or self cherishing could include the following. For instance, if we are in our house or in our room and suddenly there is a loud noise and disturbance outdoors which interferes with our work, powerful disturbances arise in our minds and we think this is intolerable, this is unacceptable, the afflictions arise, these arise out of self cherishing, out of egotism. Likewise, when we go for walks in Tibet, it was believed that it was a dragon in the sky which initiated thunder and when thunder resounded, one would think heavens are the heavens are going to fall onto me, lightning specifically, and great self cherishing and fear would arise with within the mind disturbing the mind. And likewise, And the third example is if one puts great effort in one’s studies and nonetheless is unable to accomplish one’s goals, the suffering which arises from this is a product of self cherishing.
And hence, Kadampa Geshes proposed metaphors on how to handle self cherishing. Gesher Momopp proposed that one should deal with self cherishing in the self same way as someone who is milling, chilies, crushing it again and again with a pestle in a mortar. Geshe Ben Kungil proposed to deal with self cherishing as a guard at a fort, standing at a guard, standing at guard in front of the fort warily when self cherishing rears its head and standing at ease when it does not. Paul Geshe Langri Tompa said, regarding self cherishing, I handle it as follows, all of my virtue and happiness I give to others, all the suffering of others I take upon myself. Otherwise, if one does not practice in this way, in an extremely crusty Tibetan expression, it is said it is akin to putting monastic robes on a yak and putting the blessing vase of initiation over and again on the yak’s head.
There is no benefit. Therefore, the advice Geshela would give is to train in cherishing others without ever giving a thought as to where the training will stop. It is endless. On and on do we train and if we train in this way, then our minds will be at peace and happy wherever we are and whatever happens. And if for ourselves, taking the case of monks, one studies very intensively and nonetheless this study is not accompanied by cherishing others, there is a great risk that this study will actually go in the direction of the afflictions.
And, at present, Geshela has completed the presentation of, self cherishing. We will start cherishing others next time. When you return to your houses, Geshela would like to suggest that you read the sections in Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun on Cherishing Others since you have a good English translation available. Then we will slowly investigate the relationship between self cherishing on the one hand and the apprehension of an inherently existing self on the other hand, seeing whether there is mutual pervasion or not and what the relationship is. For instance, generally speaking, it is said that the hearers, the Shravakas, and the solitary realizers, the Pratyaka Buddhas, have self cherishing, yet they have realized the selflessness of persons.
In there are fifteen minutes, if you feel like asking questions, we are wide open. Yes. So we cannot identify self cherishing and depression because for instance hearers and solitary realizers have self cherishing. Clearly, they don’t have depression. Depression, however, is a result of self cherishing as many of the afflicted states of mind.
Then Geshela will enter into much greater detail into self cherishing in the next couple of weeks. Are there other questions? Other question? Another question. Yes, Saffo.
So there is no difference between the lay and the monastic state as far as refuge is concerned and as far as the correct generation of refuge based on fear of rebirth in the lower realms and on faith in the Triple Gem’s power to protect us. In both cases what is necessary is a strong reliance on karma and causality. It is not possible for everyone to abandon the lay state and abandon one’s responsibilities as you say. That would be impossible. As Geshe said it would be stupid.
Are there other questions? Yes. Jasmine. So Geshela is uncomfortable with your usage of self in this context. It is not a self which cherishes others and a self which cherishes oneself.
He thinks it is preferable to speak of the mind cherishing others and the mind cherishing oneself. Then regarding the mind cherishing others and the mind cherishing oneself, they are directly contradictory. The causes of the one are exactly the opposite of the causes of the other. Are there other questions? Yes, Chris.
I think I think I understand your doubt. I’ll try to translate it. So while it is true that we must have conviction in the existence of common Once we have conviction in the existence of karma and causality and we practice an ethics which abandons the 10 non virtues, His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said it is basically certain, it is almost certain that we will be reborn in the higher realms. The issue has been settled. Does that answer your question?
Are you asking how much control an ordinary being has over rebirth? Yes. Gesheera thinks he would like me to come to Australia with him. Gesheera thinks that it works. If you make strong prayers to be reborn, let us say in India and in addition to that, you accumulate the virtue for this, then there are strong chances you will be reborn in India.
So there is control. Yes, probably. Yes. Of course. Yes.
Chicken. I have to translate your questions, you know. It gets weirder and weirder by the day. It’s difficult question. Basically, on the foundation of wish and prayer alone to have a happy death is very difficult indeed.
This happy death, this happiness at the time of death can only arise as a combination of numerous factors leading up to that instant. However, our practice in this life contributes and contributes mainly for future lives. So any autonomy we have with respect to the time of death, any power in other words with respect to the time of our own death, any control depends on our practice and powerful aspirations in this life. Then much depends on how much we practice for future lives as well. So your questions are excellent and Gesheera, I would like to encourage you to continue thinking about this topic at home during the forthcoming week.
It’s 12:00 sharp. 08:00. Eight to 12:00.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.