46 min · 2,640 words · 16 November 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains two of the nine features of the path knower: the path knower not abiding in cyclic existence through wisdom realising the selflessness of persons, and not abiding in peace through great compassion. It explains that the inferior vehicle aims only at personal liberation, while bodhisattvas’ compassion prevents them from settling for that peace. The teaching then moves to questions on the selflessness of persons versus phenomena and on the obscurations.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-11-16
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 14bc4a12-880a-4485-87a6-e0ae74265f05
Words: 2,636
It’s a means to stop the extreme of existence. And whatever kinds of that wisdom, which is either in an ārya’s continuum or in Buddha’s or in Buddha’s continuum, they all are to be understood as means to stop being born in the existence. Once the practitioner has this wisdom directly realizing the selflessness of a person, then from that moment we can say that the practitioner has made extreme of his existence, meaning perhaps more ornamentally to be translated as he has caused the termination of his existence. So extreme in the sense of termination. And whereas for us at the moment, since beginningless time, we have been wandering.
And at the moment, if somebody asks how long you’re still going to be in the existence, in the cycle of existence, Can you tell when it’s extreme or when it’s going to terminate? It would be very difficult to answer because we can’t say. Whereas a person, if we first have say, what I call, intellectual or conceptual understanding of the wisdom directly realizing the selflessness of a person, then after all if we, we were called, familiarize with it again and again in meditative contemplation, then afterward, there comes a point when he directly realizes the selflessness of a person, then from that moment the practitioner or the person what I call has approached the point where he is going to terminate his existence. Therefore, we can say that from that moment, through that means, he has seen the extreme or end of his existence. It has been explained with example in the Lam Rim teachings that it is like a is like a seed of a grain or rice which will continuously be able to use as, say, what I call, as to grow a whole lot of rice in the continuous season after season after season because this seed of rice, you plant it, and then in next season it grows.
And afterward, it will produce another seed, and again you plant that one. So until there’s some fault with the seed, it will continue without stopping to grow, produce, grow, produce. And that being the case, but whereas if we take the seed and defect it with a slight burning into fire, then from that moment onward, the seed has been made impotent. So it hasn’t been able to, from that moment, able to grow. So because of that, it has been also with that explanation, it has been explained that wisdom directly realizing the selflessness is like that fire which makes the seed impotent.
And from that moment onward, the person will not be able to work or will not be will not have to be born in the cyclic existence. So if we really have a strong urge to to get rid of being born in the cyclic existence and having a strong urge to escape from it and to attain liberation, then we really have to practice valid meditation on this wisdom directly realizing the selflessness. So the second one, we will limit to the up till that to the first one. And now the second one, the our path knower not abiding in through compassion. So true compassion has special meaning because it is the compassion through which one does not remain in the peace.
And therefore it is called the means to transcend the extreme or it’s called the means to transcend the extreme of peace. Because bodhisattvas, because of having compassion, they do not remain in peace. Why that is so is because as we as it has been explained before, that great compassion is all the time thinking about others instead of oneself. And also, compassion is of such a quality like it has the quality of all the time thinking: may sentient beings be free of the sufferings and cause of suffering, and may sentient beings be free of sufferings and causes of suffering. Being second, in what we call prayer form.
And third, may myself alone be responsible in actually removing their sufferings and causes of suffering. So regarding the phrase extreme of peace, so this is to be understood, let’s say, with the practitioner of the inferior vehicle. They all the time think only about their own fear of the samsaric suffering. And they all the time only think about themselves alone to get rid of, to escape, sorry, to escape from cyclic existence and to all the time think only about themselves alone to attain the happiness of being freed from samsaric suffering. And with that as a constant way of their thinking, they do meditations principally on the wisdom directly realizing the selflessness.
And through that wisdom, they attain the state free of samsaric suffering and they attain the bliss or happiness of liberation. And that bliss or happiness of liberation is what is called peace, in this context peace. And it’s also called the bliss of the peace or happiness of the peace. In the inferior vehicles, the practitioner only thinks about himself and works for one’s own, removing of sufferings and attaining the happiness or liberation for oneself only. And once they attain that state, they are normally called the arhats, the foe, those who have destroyed the foe, foe being referred to the delusions.
And if it is a person who has attained that state from the Hearers’ path, then he’s called hearer foe-destroyer. And if it’s a solitary realizer or Pratyekabuddha, then it’s called Pratyekabuddha foe-destroyer. And he remains in that liberation, peace, and happiness for enormously long time. And therefore, it is called extreme, extreme of peace. And in that case, why they do so is because their whole starting point has come from self interest themselves alone.
Whereas with the bodhisattva, because they all the time think about other sentient beings suffering, how to lead other sentient beings to the ultimate happiness. Therefore, for the bodhisattva, that thing is something to be abandoned. For bodhisattva, because of their great compassion, they cannot be satisfied being able to attain happiness alone. Therefore, it is the great compassion within the bodhisattva’s continuum which doesn’t allow or which doesn’t let the bodhisattva aspire for its own personal peace, happiness. Therefore, the great compassion in this context is called the means to transcend the extreme of peace.
Whoever has this great compassion definitely will be in the group belonging to the practitioner of the great vehicle. And it is never a possibility that once a person has great compassion that he still is in the inferior vehicle. But still it’s possible for a practitioner of inferior vehicle after some time to some to meet a great vehicle teacher who shows him the great vehicle teachings and thereby generate great compassion. And from that moment onward, it is possible that through that way, the inferior vehicle practitioner, the cause of that way, becomes one who has entered the great vehicle path. But generally speaking, it is definite that inferior vehicle practitioners never have this what I call great compassion.
And it is only the great compassion which determines the person whether he is in great vehicle implying that it determines the person definite to be attaining the ultimate goal of our Supreme Enlightenment. So the bodhisattvas, in order not to remain in the extreme of the peace, they do such meditation. So so far, the explanation has been about the first two, the path knower not abiding in the existence through knowledge and the path knower not abiding in the peace through compassion and the first two among the nine features representing the base knower. And there are still some time left for question and answer instead of meditation. Yeah.
It is in the form of knowledge and its own wisdom realizing emptiness, wisdom realizing self selflessness is wisdom. So that’s the problem in English. Like normally, literal translation is very good. Wisdom word for wisdom in Tibetan is called supreme knowledge. But wisdom is very abstract word normally.
Supreme knowledge. That’s what’s the word. So it’s in the form of knowledge. So at this point, yes, it is what we call in the aspect of knowing that persons do not truly exist. And in this context, persons do not truly exist and do not truly exist, meaning in this context, it has to be explained as meaning the person not truly existent in the sense of not substantially existent in the form of self sufficiency.
So meaning, that’s a technical norm, how it is said, but it simply means selflessness of the person and understanding that person do not exist as a substance which is self sufficient by its own. So this is to be analyzed in this way whether I or self the person, is existing or not, to analyze that this person or I is only a mere it exists only as a mere label on the five aggregates being composed together. And it’s just a mere label on the continuity of those five aggregates. And apart from the mere label on these two aspects, there is not any person, self, and I which is truly existent. And once you understand that, then that’s the starting point that you are realizing the selflessness of the person.
Yeah. It can help once you so I translated back in Tibetan. If you try to get rid of the misconceptions and the non-conceptions. That’s a technical term in Tibetan, referring to all wrong thoughts. So once you get rid of that, it wouldn’t have to have those storyline or wisdoms.
So it does help because once you analyze the thing, how you misconceive them through those two aspects, either misconceiving or either not conceiving it correctly, then you come closer to the point of understanding the nature of things more clearly. So it helps. Yes. The main barrier is the self grasping mind, truth grasping mind. And because of that truth grasping mind, it obscures us to not see the selflessness.
It is like example like Rinpoche put his hand on this little bone. So that hand is like the self grasping misconception which obscured in seeing that little bone, which is the reality, the selflessness. The self grasping and true grasping of person are called ignorance, not ignorance or not knowing. And why they are called not knowing is because it obscures the person in not knowing the mode of existence, the mode of existence of the things, how things exist. Say someone who’s trained and they has some training in bodhicitta.
But then through meditating on selflessness and persons, realizing that then is that is that that peace of liberation, is that, like, like a drug sort of so attractive that if the training in but, you know, but a tutor is not strong, then it’s easy for a person to fall into that bliss because it’s like a it’s like sort of like a drug. Mhmm. It does happen in the case of not having strong practice on bodhicitta. And on the other hand, it does happen because normally we are mostly inclined in being attached to bliss and happiness. And also being inclined, we have been so familiarized.
So it does happen. But still, even if the practitioner may not be able to generate strong bodhicitta on the other hand, but still he can stop the drawing of that extreme by thinking on the faults of the bliss of the liberation, bliss of the peace, thinking how limited it is in the actual sense, in the ultimate sense. Yes. We can resist and stop that if we, again and again, think about the faults of the bliss of the peace and especially think on the faults of the self-cherishing thought, which as explained in the previous teachings on the thought training, how self-cherishing has all those faults. And if you go on thinking again and again, then it’s possible not to be attracted and stop that attraction.
I thought it must be very strong, the way there’s so much emphasis, the way it’s so important to train very strongly in the in the enlightened mind. Yes. She did. That’s true. But also, it’s also because of the point or purpose on that normally whenever there is, so I call it, teachings and emphasis on the great vehicle’s path and the enlightened mind, then the practitioners are to be drawn to that great vehicle.
And because of that, there is a special emphasis on enlightened thought or mind, because everything in the great vehicle has to come through that thought. And also another additional purpose is more you emphasize on this altruistic enlightenment thought, the more it helps the practitioner to get rid of self-cherishing thought. If through realizing selflessness of persons, we attain freedom from cyclic existence, and then through the power of compassion, take rebirth So where does the selflessness of phenomena come from? So the selflessness of phenomena comes when you enter the great vehicle’s path. Yeah.
I was just, you know, like, in context of what we were saying tonight about I was just thinking, you know, the purpose of this. It seems like the purpose of the selfless person and the compassion, is almost complete. So you’re saying our selflessness as a person. Rinpoche will explain it more clearly. Like in the great vehicle path, once the person enters that, then there are two things which the practitioner has to get rid of, and they are called two obscurations, the afflictive obscurations and the knowledge obscurations.
And these two obscurations cannot be abandoned unless the practitioner practices the, what I call, wisdom realizing the selflessness of phenomena. And that’s why it comes in that context. So in meaning, even though he has got rid of saṃsāra through that selflessness of a person, but still he hasn’t attained the state free of all the obscurations, and that’s why selflessness of phenomena comes in. With the selflessness of a person, once you realize it, you can get rid of the general afflictions and the rebirth in cyclic existence. But in order to get rid of, especially, the knowledge obscuration, you must definitely meditate on and develop understanding of the selflessness of phenomena.
Generally, in special tradition of Jai Lama Tsongkhapa, it has been explained that firstly one has to realize the selflessness of a person and then one has to realize the selflessness of phenomena. Why that is so is because there is a slight difference in the easiness difficulty of understanding or realizing those two. So meaning the first one is easier and then More coarse. More coarse. No.
Because other mean they’re lying. Right? It is more gross, coarse, and that’s why it’s easier. No, it’s not like that. It’s the object to be is more easier to cover or cancel when you establish the selflessness of a person.
So object to be refuted like truly existent self. So that is more easy to establish that being nonexistent with the person, whereas with the phenomena it’s more difficult. No. There is a big difference. With the person, of course, it is a kind of phenomena.
But still, the phenomena in person, there is quite a big difference from the standpoint of object to be refuted, to be cancelled. There is a whole difference of the one being easy to cover, to establish as not being truly existent, and other being more difficult. And because of that difference of easier and difficulty in establishing the canceling of the object to be refuted. Therefore, in the actual emptiness, which is the residue of whatever is canceled, there’s also the whole difference of subtle and gross emptiness in between the two. Yes.
Firstly, when you are what I call apply reasoning, it’s
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- two obscurations dvi-avarana (Skt); drib pa nyi (Tib)
- Deluded mental states that block the attainment of liberation and enlightenment. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If someone's bodhicitta training is weak, can the peace and bliss of liberation from meditating on selflessness become so attractive that they fall into it?
Yes, this can happen when practice of bodhicitta is not strong. It also happens because we are mostly inclined to attach to bliss and happiness, and we have long been familiar with that tendency. Even if a practitioner cannot yet generate strong bodhicitta, the pull toward that extreme can still be stopped by thinking about the faults of the bliss of liberation, the bliss of peace, and how limited it is in the ultimate sense. It also helps to think about the faults of the self-cherishing thought, as explained in the earlier teachings on thought training. By reflecting on these again and again, it is possible not to be attracted and to stop that attraction.