Ornament of clear realisation – 54 O 1989 11 30

43 min · 2,946 words · 30 November 1989

Ornament of clear realisation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament of clear realisation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament of clear realisation - 54 O 1989 11 30
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues an explanation of the nine features of the base knower (the mind as ground of the path). It covers the base knower of the negative class and of the concordant class, with their definitions and ranges, and the bodhisattva’s application, explained through the two truths. It ends by beginning the eighth feature, evenness of the base knower’s application, cut off in the recording.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1989-11-30

Duration: 43 min

UUID: e2c1a721-a86a-4350-9fba-350bf52bf34f

Words: 2,942

The explanation at the moment is on the nine features or attributes representing our base knower and among the nine so far four has been explained. The path knower not abiding in existence, path knower not abiding in the peace, and the base knower far from the resultant mother, base knower close to the resultant mother. And regarding the base knower distant or far from the resultant mother and base knower close to the resultant mother — regarding those two, they are set apart from the other two; those other two are the base knower of the negative class and base knower of the concordant class. So these four are being separated into group of two is because of the principal purpose that they were called, that the person training on the path may have a good idea about the presentation and about the stages of the path whereas in actual case all these four can be grouped into two. The base knower far from resultant mother is same to the base knower of the negative class and the base knower close to the resultant mother is same to the base knower of the concordant class or positive class.

So now we come to the next one. That’s the base knower of the negative class. And regarding it it has three parts, the definition, divisions, and a ranging border. So definition already explained ahead, Rinpoche will say after. And regarding the definition, the definition of the base knower of the negative class, the definition is being a base knower that’s the first part being a base knower and the second part of definition is free of free of the special means and wisdom and why it is called why in the definition the first part being a being a base knower is because it is a base knower so that’s why it is a base knower.

And why it is free or separate from the special means and wisdom is because it’s without great compassion and without wisdom realizing emptiness. And second part is not division. It is synonym. So synonym is this what called base knower of the negative class is synonym with the base knower, base knower bound by truth grasping which is in the continuum of the inferior vehicle’s superior. So to repeat this base knower of the negative class is a synonym to the base knower bound by truth grasping which is within the continuum of a superior of inferior vehicle path or inferior vehicle superior.

And regarding the ranging border, it starts from the work of path of seeing of inferior vehicle. It’s it ranges from path of seeing of inferior vehicle up till path of no more learning of inferior vehicle. So regarding the definition where it says free of the special means and wisdom or it doesn’t need further explanation.

Means refers to bodhicitta and compassion and wisdom refers to realization of emptiness. So now we come to the second one, the base knower of the positive class. Literally, is called base knower of concordant class. So the definition starts: first part, being a knowledge of great vehicle superior, belonging to the group of total realization of inferior vehicle. Second part of definition: held by special means and wisdom.

So this base knower of the concordant class is synonym with the base knower within the continuum of great vehicle superior. That would become the second part definition synonym. It is this — this is synonym to the base knower within the continuum of great vehicle superior. So regarding the border, Mahāyāna path normally is of five, and this is not in the first two paths. It’s not in the path of accumulation and path of preparation.

So it starts from the third part, the path of seeing of great vehicle and goes on or it ranges from there up till Buddhahood. So perhaps there may not be any need to explain about what what is meant by held by special means in wisdom and also no need to explain on what is meant by belonging to the group of total realization of inferior vehicle. They have already been explained in the past. And now it’s the seventh one, and seventh one is called the bodhisattva’s application. Normally, it’s translated as application.

Alternative, you can have what’s called bodhisattva’s integration. So bodhisattva’s integration shown in the context of base knower and that’s the seven one and regarding the seven one how it is the seven one already six has gone in the past. The first six being starting from the path knower not abiding in existence, path knower not abiding in peace, base knower far from the resultant mother, base knower close to the resultant mother, base knower belonging to the negative class, and base knower belonging to the concordant class and this one is the seventh. So this has a definition or division and ranging border, and the definition is quite too long. So with definition first let’s what I call explain it this way. Normally there are two truths: what is normally called conventional truth, literally called all-concealing truth, truth of the concealed.

So this conventional truth has two or what called it has two aspect or two things can be said about it the entity of the conventional truth and the difference of conventional truth and difference of conventional truth means the divisions, the functions, whatever divisions the conventional truth has and the same is with the second truth it is called ultimate truth, and in literally it is called sublime-meaning truth. So this ultimate truth also has two aspects or two things can be said about it. The entity of ultimate truth and the differences of ultimate truth and differences same means the divisions the functions of ultimate truth. It is like, let’s say, Adelaide is the general thing and then Adelaide has effect, Adelaide has factory places, markets, and so forth, and they are like in this context the differences, the divisions of Adelaide. So in the first part of the our definition, it will need afterward to work or reverse in the translation.

So first part goes apprehension — normally it’s also translated as apprehension or clinging. So clinging mistakenly on the entity of the mode of existence of conventional truth. Clinging mistakenly on the mode of existence of conventional truth and its differences. So that’s the first part. Will need all.

And And second part, clinging mistakenly to the mode of existence of ultimate truth and its differences. And after that, how are any And the third part goes like any any any meditation any meditation any meditation yoga of mind. So altogether in the translation would become reversed. So any yoga of mind meditating — so sorry, the last bit I missed — any mental yoga being meditated as antidote against mistaken clinging regarding the mode of existence of conventional truth and its differences or regarding the mode of existence of ultimate truth and its differences.

Yeah. So it becomes reversed. So this is the definition of the bodhisattvas application or we stick to application instead of integration. So that’s choice and this is the definition of bodhisattva’s application shown in the context of base knower. So is it clear?

bodhisattva’s application shown in the context of base knower. So meaning, bodhisattva’s base knower, which is shown in the context while explaining base knower. Is it all clear? It has ten divisions or perhaps not needed to write down or it’s means they’re all the ten not needed. So we just write there are ten ten divisions.

And regarding the ranging border, it ranges from great vehicle’s path of accumulation up till last continuum. So in the definition where it says the first part mistakenly apprehending or clinging mistakenly or same, clinging mistakenly to the mode of existence of the conventional truth. So to insert here to clarify would be clinging mistakenly to the nature of the mode of existence of conventional truth and this means conventional truths mode of existence for example is like the impermanence nature of conventional things and conventional impermanence, which is one of the modes of existence, one of the ways conventional truths are. So regarding that conventional truth because of being impermanent they don’t last moment so momentarily they disintegrate but still a practitioner in course of not being perfect may some occasionally have a miss apprehension, mistaken clinging or what called mind grasping that all these things are not disintegrating moment after moment instead thinking that they are quite stable static and permanent so that is that is called what is in the definition says apprehending mistakenly regarding the entity or regarding nature of the mode of existence of conventional truth. As conventional truth or things of conventional truth have the aspect of impermanence momentarily disintegrating therefore if there is a mind which holds, claims, that things are not disintegrating moment after moment, then that mind can be called a mistaken mind.

And what can be, what measure or means can be used or applied to overcome that mistaken mind regarding the means it is the realization of the impermanence and that realization impermanence understands that conventional truth things or things of conventional truth nature are impermanent because they don’t they don’t last after moment. So that very realization of impermanence that things momentarily disintegrate is helpful because if one has that mind then it eliminates the mistaken mind holding things as not disintegrating moment after moment. Therefore in the definition we have the term called antidote and that mental so to correlate with the context meaning a mental yoga of the mental yoga as antidote. So that’s why it is called antidote. So that’s what I call the mistaken mind regarding the conventional truth mode of existence generally speaking and the antidote also generally speaking and not to take a specific particular or difference out of that general let’s say our body are literally called in this context aggregate.

So our this body it is an impermanent thing that it doesn’t last after a moment or disintegrates moment after moment but still out of our mistaken attitude if we think and cling to the idea that our body is permanent and it doesn’t disintegrate moment after moment then that mind is a mistaken mind of particular what called mistaken mind regarding the regarding the mode of existence of conventional truth in particular. So in the definition where it says clinging mistakenly to the nature of the mode of existence of conventional truth and its differences. So and its differences to translate more ornamentally can be in and its particular particulars. So this being a case of a particular example or specific particular example of our general impermanent thing therefore this mistaken mind is a mind which is mistakenly clinging to a particular impermanent thing belonging to the group of conventional truth. Is that So this is just a I work on one specific example of a particular or different or specific out of impermanent or generally impermanent phenomena and same can be applied to all other and regarding this mistaken mind holding this body as a not disintegrating moment after moment that mind mistakenly clinging is called a mistaken mind and as an antidote for that one has to generate the realization that the body is not permanent, that it disintegrates moment after moment and same applies to all others.

So regarding the second part of the definition where it says mistakenly clinging to the nature of the mode of existence, nature has to be inserted because of the following explanation. So the second part of definition says they mistakenly cling ing to the nature of the mode of existence of the ultimate truth and its differences. So ultimate truth also truth is the thing we require in English whereas literally it is just ultimate and as I call specified before ultimate literally in Tibetan is the word sublime meaning. So what is sublime meaning? What is ultimate?

Is the regarding ultimate, regarding what’s sublime meaning? It is the nature of everything devoid of existing truly and it is the emptiness. So ultimate truth sublime meaning refers to emptiness and this nature is with everything but still because of our wrong because of our ignorance if we see or hold an idea clinging to the notion that everything is what could truly existent then that is mistakenly clinging to the nature of the mode of existence of ultimate as general. And regarding the specific would be like the truthlessness of a pot, or a vase, or a normal pot — yeah, the truthlessness of a pot. So that truthlessness of a pot, the pot being not truly existent, is a specific specific example of the ultimate truth but still due to our ignorance if we hold that the pot is truly existent by itself then that is called a mind mistakenly clinging to the to the differences of the ultimate truth.

So differences ornamentally we can have particulars. So a mistake and a mind mistakenly clinging to the particulars of the ultimate and as an antidote as an antidote to these two mistaken mind we have to what we call practice this practice this what we seven seven of the nine features as an antidote to these mistaken minds. Practice this seventh one. So this is the seventh one, seventh in the nine features. So in short what is what this what called the seven one is talking about is normally we group all phenomena into what called two aspects, the conventional truth normally called conventional truth and ultimate truth and conventional truth itself is our call or innumerable diversity it has whole lot of different types of different categories or types within it and same applies with the ultimate truth that ultimate truth also is of countless varieties and because there are those countless varieties of these two truth therefore there there are also our mind in relation to those two and if there is any what I call miss misconception about how these two truth actually are then those misconception also will have in numerable what called diversity in different in numerable varieties.

So with each of the conventional truth and ultimate truth because of our ignorance we perceive or conceive in a different way and they are all called mistaken mind, they’re all called distorted mind, they’re all called wrong mind. And let’s say with an example, suppose the mic or or more specific, let’s say with the flower. So the flower on there, over there it is what I call normally, what I call grouped within the explanation as not truly existent but if there’s a mind which perceive or cling to the idea that the flower is truly existent then that mind is a what I call distorted mind and it’s a mistaken mind and in trying to get rid of that what the bodhisattva in this context of the practice has to do is he has to get used to the has to get used to the realization that the flower is impermanent. So getting used to the that the flower is impermanent. So getting used to the realization of the flower being impermanent ultimately he doesn’t have any clinging that the flower is permanent and same with all different kinds of distorted view with only two types of truth, the bodhisattva get used to their respective antidotes antidotes to each of the distorted views.

And same when this flower because of having aspects of impermanence if a what call if the practitioner bodhisattva has misconception that the flower is permanent, then in that case in order to abandon that miss or what called mistaken mind he has to get used to the realization that the flower is impermanent. So it’s impermanent if it has the what called mistaken idea that it is not impermanent it’s permanent then as an antidote he has to get used to the realization that the flower is impermanent. And in this way he gets rid of the distorted view that the flower is not impermanent, and same applies that way. So with this flower already, the what I call explanation covers about how there are two types of misconcept work on mistaken mind regarding the flower one from ultimate and one from conventional truth and for both we have respective antidotes and same applies — the same reasoning of applying antidote to the two types of mistaken mind — to everything else. So we come to the eighth one.

It is called the base knower’s — better say — evenness of the base knower’s application, or in other words equality or evenness of the base knower’s application and it has three parts definition divisions and ranging border. And regarding the definition, it is a mental yoga to cease truth clinging regarding the divisions, definitions, definitum, object, subject of the base. So to go it over again, it is a mental yoga to cease truth clinging regarding the divisions, the definitions, definitum — so it’s technically called definitum, the thing which is covered by the definition, normally called definitum. So definitions, definitum, object, subject of the base. So all these attributes are of the base.

Mental yoga held by — we missed a little bit. Mental yoga held by wisdom. Mental yoga held by wisdom, and then which is to cease. Perhaps we need clarifying: which is to succeed in the case of held by wisdom, or which is to cease. No.

And the rest is same. No. No.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top