41 min · 2,991 words · 2 September 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a commentary on the stages of application on the path: the applications of one who attains prophecy, of one who is irreversible, of definite emergence, without interruption, close to enlightenment, of one who will soon become a Buddha, and for others’ welfare. These stages rest on the realisation of emptiness and are distinguished by degrees of realisation rather than time. A question session covers whether the stages occur in sequence and how to judge dream prophecies.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-09-02
Duration: 41 min
UUID: de75d664-4b1a-4887-80a1-327c8927e893
Words: 2,987
Providing an insight. They don’t need to rely on this as much, and it becomes subsumed, yes, into the it’s in their continuum, but not as a main focus. Okay. So the next one is application for it’s got here applications for one’s own welfare. So the first of these is application of one who attains prophecy.
So this is talking about people who being unafraid of emptiness or dharmata, which is dharmata or whatever you want to call it, practice the six perfections even in their dreams. Yes. And after doing this they encounter they may encounter the one of the three different bodies of the Buddha in a dream or somewhere else who will tell them when they’re going to attain Buddhahood and how they’re going to benefit beings by attaining Buddhahood. So this is called receiving a prophecy. So hence an application of one who attains prophecy.
So the prophecy comes from the Buddhas. They attain a prophecy from the Buddhas telling them when they’re going to attain Buddhahood. So these three bodies of the Buddha, four bodies of the Buddha, two of which subsumed into one right. So you got the Nirmana kaya which is the form body of the Buddha, the physical manifestations of the Buddha that we can see. The Sambhoga kaya which is the enjoyment body of the Buddha, the manifestations that are very subtle manifestations that are able to be perceived by a high level bodhisattvas and so on.
We have the nature body — well, the truth body is sometimes called truth body — the Dharmakāya, the truth body of the Buddha, which also has the nature body of the Buddha included within that, so the nature body is called the Svabhāvikakāya and the truth body is called the Dharmakāya. Dharmakāya is basically the mind of the Buddha which is in a formless state, but it also has this Svabhāvikakāya element which is the emptiness of that mind. There’s four bodies there, but two subsumed into one being the mind of Buddha, the Dharmakāya. So through any one of these three elements — through the Dharmakāya, the Sambhogakāya, or the Nirmānakāya — they can receive a prophecy telling them when they’re going to become Buddhas. So the next one is application of one who is irreversible.
So that means they have attained irreversibility in their practice and through being able to have a strong comprehension of the mother, which is another way of saying emptiness, in their mind stream they have to have developed this. This can either be what’s an inferential cognition or a direct realization of emptiness, but it has to be stable. So once they have developed a stable understanding of emptiness in this way, then they said that their practice is irreversible, that they don’t have a moment of they can’t slip back in any way and they constantly are focused on emptiness after that. So this irreversibility of practice that comes about through a steady understanding of the mother is this one, the mother being emptiness. So the next one, application of definite emergence.
So what this means is What this means is that these beings have definitely seen the obstacles to developing omniscience that is the knowledge obscurations and the defilements obscurations or the obscurations to liberation. And they’ve seen them for what they are, so they see them as being nothing but faulty and are not caught up in them and because they see these obscurations as being nothing but faults that they need to get rid of this means that they will definitely emerge from those obscurations they’ll definitely be released from them because they understand that they’re nothing but they are completely faulty and therefore definitely want to get rid of them. And once they definitely want to get rid of them and don’t have any attachment to them, then this is a sign there of definite emergence that they will definitely become Buddhas. Okay. So the next one of application without interruption, what this means is that if you are able to get rid of all of the things that may stop you from working towards becoming a Buddha, now this means, for example, gross manifestations of negative emotions and interruptions and anything that any kind of extreme experiences of negative ripening, any of these things that could be an obstacle to you becoming a Buddha.
If you’re able to get rid of those and that means you become close to achieving enlightenment. And through developing an insight of emptiness and getting rid of all of these obstacles to working along the path, you develop this next application without interruption. And the sign that you’ve developed this application is the first one, the application of one who attains prophecy. And so you developed the application without interruption when you attain the application of one who attains prophecy. So the next two, the application close to enlightenment and the application of one who will soon become a Buddha.
Now, you may ask, as I just did, why they would be different? Why someone close to enlightenment wouldn’t be one who is about to become a Buddha? And Geshe-la said, and in Tibetan, in fact, they’re almost the same words as well. And he said, it’s all a matter of degrees. You can be close to enlightenment if you are have achieved the path of seeing but you’re not close to becoming no you’re not about to become a Buddha or soon to become a Buddha because you still have three countless eons to wait.
So this so you’re close to it but you’re not quickly going to do it if that makes sense yeah. Close in terms of the realization not in terms of time that’s the whole point of the two use of the separation. Now, so if you have perceived emptiness that means you’re close to the realization of Buddhahood. Yeah, but so this that’s why it’s associated with the path of seeing. All right, the realization of emptiness is this application close to enlightenment.
Now application of one who will soon become a Buddha, Geshe-la thought is another way of saying that momentary application at the end of a continuum. Yes, but I say well in here it says from the second through to the seventh ground of Bodhisattva anyway, the second ground’s close like that. And then and I said they said second ground to seventy goes, yes, suppose if you wanna say it’s close, but you could also say the tenth ground’s closer. But I also said that it says it’s different in different commentaries and he goes, yeah, well, I’d say it’s tenth ground and perhaps, but probably the momentary application at the end of the continuum. That’s it..
So so apparently, said, no. No. I didn’t say three countless eons. I said one. When you get to the path of seeing, you’ve already done the first two countless eons, when you’re in the path of preparation and the path of accumulation.
So by the time you realize emptiness, you’ve only got one countless eons left to go. But he said that, but there’s like this, there’s different ideas. We can say that we are, say for example, close to the water, but we may not necessarily be walking towards the water and getting there quickly. We can be close to it, but we may not necessarily be in it quickly. We’re just close to it.
But if someone’s actually walking towards the water and we’re moving towards it quickly in that way, you’d more likely to say they’re gonna end up in the water quicker as opposed to just being near it. So the next one is application for others benefit or others welfare. Now the way to do this is to instigate the turning of the wheel of in order to benefit beings. The application of others’ welfare is in the Dharma’s way. Now the different beings that we’re dealing with here from the heat level of the path of preparation right up to the tenth ground are able to turn the wheel of Dharma but not to turn the wheel of Dharma in the same way that the Buddha is.
And obviously someone on the tenth ground is going to be able to turn the wheel of Dharma a lot more like a Buddha than someone who isn’t on the tenth ground. Yeah, so the closer they get to Buddhahood, their ability to turn the wheel of Dharma is closer to a Buddha’s. But what they can do is teach for the benefit of other sentient beings and they can do so very clearly and very helpfully. So it’s very important for them to have this aspect to their practice even if they’re not turning the wheel of Dharma like a Buddha. Okay.
So nearly run out of time before we start number three. Might stop. That’s fine as long as there’s milk, he’s fine. They have like a black salty tea called ja tang, which I had in Tso Pema. It’s quite nice.
So they have this like black salty version because if you keep drinking the butter and salt version in India, you get ill. So it’s like, yeah, yeah, I like the black salty version. Version. And yeah. Anyway.
Okay. So if you have any questions. Now that I got out, if they have questions, can they ask them? If you have any questions, you might as well ask him because he’s gonna drink his tea. Ah, so, I was gonna ask, these applications for one’s own welfare, is that a sequential sort of thing?
Because it sort of looked like you were sort of going from seven to twelve as sort of a, you know, progression. This to that to this to this. But then you said that it looked like it was the same ten and seven occurred at the same and this prophecy thingy happens all over the place. So you get an application of one who attains prophecy and then you keep having prophecies after that. So I thought that at the same time because it was the same prophecy because it’s the same word and stuff.
And so the interpreter was saying it’s the prophecy and this prophecy but he was talking about a different prophecy. Sorry. Sequentially anyway, so seven to twelve go sequentially but there’s a different there’s two prophecies. Get so he said that you get a prophecy prophecy back here where the Buddha says you’re going to become a Buddha and then in number ten you get a prophecy saying this is how all of your interruptions are going to be made done with. Made done with?
Again, be obliterated. Yeah. And then the number thirteen, the application of others welfare that doesn’t happen in any solid way. It doesn’t, you don’t, there’s no solid. It doesn’t start from that point.
That sort of happens all the way along, is that? No, hang on. There’s no solid order, right? There’s no solid. I’ll try again.
I’ll just get my brain back into working order. There’s no solid order, but some people for example may start doing application of others welfare and turning the wheel of dharma before they’ve even developed, attain the prophecy. And right and other people may do it right at the end. And so it all depends on the the Bodhisattva. Sorry, because it was, yeah, he’s talking about didn’t say there’s many.
I got confused because they didn’t say that there was many different prophecies and this is just one of them who said prophecy and that can be singular or plural in Tibetan. So I heard it as singular, but it was actually plural, if that makes sense. So it was like the same time as the prophecy, but it wasn’t the same prophecy. You’re right. Sorry.
If the Buddha came along and told you you’re gonna be a Buddha, it’d make you wanna work harder, wouldn’t it? Because it wouldn’t be really that much benefit to us because it’s like trying to learn how to compose poetry when we haven’t learned how ABC, having a thing from the Buddha at the moment. Having a prophecy from the Buddha at the moment. He said if you want to learn to compose poetry, you have to start with Ka Kha or ABCD. Ka Kha Ga in Tibetan.
And if after that then someone teaches you a bit more and a bit more and a bit more then you’ll progress slowly like that. But if someone came along in the beginning and started trying to explain the intricacies of poetical grammar to you, you would be a bit lost, right? So the whole point of the Buddha appearing to them then is to because they need that encouragement and the direction from the Buddha telling them how to become a Buddha. If the Buddha showed us how to become Buddha, we wouldn’t know what he’s talking about. Because we got to learn first He all sorts of ways that people can have dreams that they recognize the Buddha in and they can come and tell them they’re gonna be Buddha and also how to get there.
Yeah? And then also they may have someone just walk up to them that’s a Buddha and explain to them. May came the Buddha may manifest as like like us, physical being like us. And sometimes people have pure visions. So they usually say that prophecies are of three types.
Dreams and conversations with people that are physically there and visions. He said, so whichever one is the most benefit to them and that’s the way that they receive it. He said, but prophecies are something you’ve got to be very careful of because you tend to hear lots of prophecies and they could actually be your just your own stuff. So they can be things that put forward as prophecies that are just aren’t. And you can perceive things that you think is a prophecy that it just isn’t as well so you have to be very careful of whether you assume something is a prophecy or not So there’s also things that could be obstacles that could present themselves as a, for the Bodhisattvas as well, there’s obstacles that could present themselves as a prophecy.
He said, I have no idea. You have to become a boarder cypher to figure it out. Once you get to that state you’d be able to tell which was which right but until then if you start trying to kid yourself then he said until then there’s no way you can know. You can’t have that kind of subtle perception. So he said there’s lots of times where you hear about people going, there’s a prophecy and it’s like, well, it a prophecy or was it just in a a dream?
You know, that had a prophetic encounter with a being in a dream or whatever. But it could be a prophetic encounter or it could be their own imprints manifesting in something. So it’s very difficult to differentiate between what is a prophetic encounter in a dream and what is just a manifestation of the imprints on your mind stream, which most dreams here. Yeah. Most dreams are just, yeah, just slideshows from our imprints.
I said that that that is it was Geshe-la saying this because of the gazillion people that come and ask him what their dreams mean. He said, said, yeah, it is a bit strange because the whole thing is like the example of emptiness is it’s like a dream. It’s meaningless. Yeah. And then people come along and say, what does this dream mean?
He goes, it’s like a dream. It is a dream. It’s meaningless. It’s not inherently existent. So the thing is that because again dreams are like imprints, manifestations of our imprints, then we can kind of watch our dreams to see how imprints are going.
But if an individual kind of looks to see what kind of dreams they’re having and how beneficial they are or how they behave in their dreams, they can get an idea if the individual does it. But oftentimes if you try and ask, it doesn’t make sense. What was that? I said Joe doesn’t have to drink. He just had to Oh, sorry.
Sorry. I thought we finished. So which language? Tibetan. So anytime that you see three vehicles, fifteen parts, it refers to these three vehicles, five parts of the three vehicles.
The hearer’s vehicle, the solitary realizer vehicle and the other dudes vehicles, motorcycle vehicles. Now Geshe-la said though that he thought it was a bit strange that they’ve presented it like this because it’s obviously talking about the perception of emptiness. So if they’re talking about it being the application being profound, being a real it was linked to the bases, it has to be the emptiness of bases. It can’t just be included within the basis because to him, it’s very clearly talking about meditating on emptiness, not meditating on the aspects of the basis or the aspects of the path or anything. So these different levels of perception of emptiness, it he hadn’t heard of it directly relating to basis, paths and all aspects.
So he said that perhaps you could use it as a metaphor for that if you’re dealing with the basis or you’re dealing with paths or you’re dealing with a knowable basis, knowable aspects, then you’re talking about different levels of perception. So these different development of the perception of emptiness could be used as examples of could be used. No, you could use the basis paths and knowable aspects as a metaphor for the development of the understanding of emptiness that occurs with these three.
Key terms in this teaching
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- kaya ku (Tib)
- Buddha-body or holy body. A body of an enlightened being. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- Pratyekabuddhayana rang sang gyä kyi thegpa, rang gyälwäi thegpa (Tib)
- The Solitary Realizer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of solitary realizers (pratyekabuddhas), practitioners who attain liberation from cyclic existence autonomously without relying on an external teacher or teachings. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
- The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
- sambhogakaya enjoyment body; long ku (Tib)
- The enjoyment body; the form in which the enlightened mind appears in order to benefit highly realized bodhisattvas. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.