Ornament for Clear Realisations – 21 2004 05 06 OCR

44 min · 3,204 words · 6 May 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 21 2004 05 06 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk studies the seven limbs of enlightenment (mindfulness, analysis of dharma, effort, joy, pliancy, concentration and equanimity) from the fourth chapter of the Ornament for Clear Realisations, as causes on the path of seeing. It explains that these factors directly perceive the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths, and that the seven can be regrouped into five requisites (abidance, essence, definite emergence, benefit, and requisites without affliction).

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-05-06

Duration: 45 min

UUID: c63a88c6-b36f-4f21-989d-8cb66909f343

Words: 3,200

Oh, yeah. So we should develop a good motivation. We should be thinking that the reason we are studying the fourth chapter of the Ornament for Clear Realisations and in particular the seven limbs of enlightenment or the seven branches of enlightenment is in order for us to be able to understand that and in order to put it into practice to act as a cause for us to become completely enlightened and by becoming completely enlightened be able to lead all sentient beings establish them lead all sentient beings to and establish them in the state completely beyond sorrow and with complete understanding that is of a Buddha. Should try and develop that motivation for studying this section of the text. So what we’re up to is the sixth sixth division that we’re going through and it’s in the thirty seven aspects of enlightenment and that’s talking about the seven limbs of enlightenment which is in relation to the path of realization.

Path of realization is another way of saying the path of seeing. Therefore, in the first sentence when it says there is reason for explaining the path of realization after the path related to realization The path of realization is a synonym for the path of seeing and the path related to realization is a synonym for the path of preparation. The reason that this path of realization is called a path of realization is because it is the part of the path where emptiness is perceived directly. Okay, so it actually has in Tibetan the path of direct realization because it’s making a distinction between that and some other things that we do later. In Haribhādra’s commentary on the Clear Ornament of Realization, he says in the first part of this commentary which he says there is reason for explaining the path of realization after the path related to realization because from obtaining the four stages of nature, stages by nature, heat, etc, the path preparing for realization. Reason for explaining the path of realization after the path related to realization is because by the four stages of the path of preparation then you achieve the path of seeing. This is the state where you perceive directly the nature of the Four Noble Truths.

Now, in explanation to this it says the passing of the Four Truths arises through the Four Comprehensions and there are seven aspects to these. Where it says seven aspects requisites of correct enlightenment so what this is referring to is the causes for enlightenment so the seven different aspects in the wisdom section of the wisdom and method, so the wisdom section has seven different aspects to the causes of enlightenment that are achieved first of all on the path of seeing. That is mindfulness, analysis, effort, joy, pliancy, concentration and correct equanimity. So, when we’re talking about these seven different limbs of enlightenment or here I think it’s been translated as requisites of enlightenment and the other text is translated as branches of enlightenment and Geshe-la says that they’re causes. Did you get all that?

Okay, so what these seven Limbs, Causes, Requisites are. First of all, stick with causes. The cause which is correct mindfulness, the cause of enlightenment which is analysis of dharma, the cause of enlightenment which is correct effort, the cause of enlightenment which is joy, cause of enlightenment which is pliancy, that which is concentration and that which is equanimity. In the definitive analysis or in the more vast explanation of this, there’s actually eight topics and beforehand there used to be seven but there is an extra one which is applying correct examples so we have focal object, method, need, nature, classification, range, etymology, and examples. So the same with the other things that we’ve been talking about, the object of meditation, the focal object is the Four Noble Truths.

Again the objective of meditation is the Four Noble Truths and the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths or the aspects of Four Noble Truths now the difference here however between this object of meditation and the objects of meditation that we discussed in the previous five powers five forces and mindfulnesses and so forth is that when we’re talking about those we’re talking about a generalized image of the emptiness of the four noble truths and when we talk about this meditative object that is the object of the seven limbs of enlightenment or the seven causes of enlightenment what we’re talking about is a direct realization of the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths and their sixteen aspects. So just to back that up from the collected topics text it says what is the focus of the requisites of enlightenment? It is whatever is correct regarding the four noble truths. Okay, alright so then the method of meditation, now the first section of the method of meditation is it sees the faults of not perceiving the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths and the aspects of the Four Noble Truths and through perceiving the fault in thinking that way then sees the emptiness of it so there’s this processes happening that you see the fault for example of permanence and therefore develop a realization of impermanence through seeing the emptiness of impermanence perceiving emptiness and then focusing on the emptiness of impermanence the direct realization of emptiness of impermanence comes about does that make sense and then the next one for example is suffering so seeing the fault of suffering and then you are seeing the fault of suffering is so the wrong consciousness regarding to suffering is perceiving saṃsāra to be happiness right so once you see the lack of happiness to saṃsāra then you focus on the nature of suffering which is one of the aspects of the first noble truth and then you perceive the emptiness of that noble truth of that aspect the emptiness of that suffering is the same with the process the same process when you’re dealing with emptiness that is emptiness of inherent being which is the third aspect of the first Noble Truth and you understand that there is no self there in this gross form and then once you’ve seen the lack of self then you realize the emptiness of that idea that concept and the same with the selflessness, the wrong view associated with selflessness is self once you realize the lack of self then you’re able to see the emptiness of that selflessness.

Right now, the next one it says through focusing on the truth of origin it seeks and abides in freedom from attachment to that so what this means is that through understanding that the origin of suffering or the cause for suffering is this attachment then you’re able to perceive that therefore you should have a lack of attachment or not abide in attachment or not have attachment so through the lack of creating the causes for suffering which is the second noble truth the cause of suffering by seeing you don’t want to create the causes for that the best way or the way to do that is to understand the lack of inherent existence of it okay so once you understand the lack of inherent existence of it and then you have your perception of emptiness. So through focusing on the causes of suffering and how the causes of suffering are not inherently existent then you’re able to perceive first of all what it is you’re supposed to avoid and then the emptiness of that Okay. Sorry I’m just having a little bit of a meltdown here still in my head in so the next one right because you’re focusing on the truth of cessation you understand that the truth of cessation is perceiving the lack of inherent existence so the thing that needs to be negated, the thing that needs to be ceased, is the lack of inherent existence that gives you an insight into emptiness and it also shows you what it is you want to achieve.

The true cessation is what you’re aiming for. Right the true cessation is the understanding of the lack of inherent existence yeah and so once you’ve understood the lack of inherent existence you have the true cessation right and the true cessation is what you’re supposed to be focusing on so you perceive it as something to be achieved and then understand that it is emptiness. Does that make sense? Okay, so basically what you’ve got is like a symbiotic relationship between this isn’t a direct translation because I’m just trying to understand it, right? So, symbiotic relationship between understanding of the truth of cessation and the achievement of the truth of cessation because you understand the truth cessation when you understand emptiness and when you understand emptiness then you develop the truth of cessation right because you perceive the lack of inherent existence okay so that’s what happens there then when you’re developing this is what he said that was just trying to make that clear so I don’t think I made it clear then when you’re looking at the truth of the path you understand that the truth of the path is what you need to follow in order to develop the realization of true cessation yeah By understanding the emptiness of the truth of the path, you understand what it is you need to meditate on in order to achieve truth of cessation.

The nature of the truth of the path and true cessation are the same thing because they’re both emptiness. He’s like, Joe, you’re not getting it. Can see it’s not going into your head. So, yeah, it’s just trying to get it in my head. Okay so within the Four Noble Truths you have two things to be abandoned and two things to be achieved or two things to be practiced.

So by meditating on the Four Noble Truths themselves you understand what it is that you need to abandon and what it is that you need to practice and what happens in this instance is that you through perceiving the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths, you’re able to see the faulty nature and the problems with the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering and through seeing their emptiness you’re able to perceive how they are to be abandoned, alright? And then through focusing on their emptiness of the truth of the cessation and the truth of the path, you’re able to understand that they are the true nature of things and therefore the perception that you need to cultivate. No, through realizing the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths, you understand the aspects of the Four Noble Truths which are to be abandoned and the aspects of the Four Noble Truths which are to be practiced. Through understanding the emptiness of the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering you understand that those two things are to be abandoned, right? And through understanding the emptiness of the truth of cessation and the truth of the path, understand that that’s their nature and that they are therefore things to be practiced.

Oh, yeah. How? He wants to know if you understand that. And it’s all about you, Joe. By perceiving emptiness, you understand the four truths.

Then he said by understanding the four noble truths, understand what’s to be abandoned and what is not to be abandoned. So, is explained in a quote from the Collective Topics which says, What is this method of meditation? This quote, right, it says What is this meditation? The requisite of enlightenment of correct mindfulness, So we’re talking about the seven aspects or seven causes of enlightenment or seven requisites of enlightenment altogether and it’s using mindfulness as an example in this quote if you guys have got it and the requisite of enlightenment of correct mindfulness and it’s like end the other six, yeah, it’s just using one as an example. Abides in isolation refers to the fact that it doesn’t experience the causes of suffering or doesn’t experience suffering, okay?

Abides in freedom from attachment which means that it doesn’t have the causes for suffering, right? So the isolation means it doesn’t have suffering. Abides in freedom from attachment means that it doesn’t create the causes for suffering in terms of the second Noble Truth, the truth of the origin of suffering, right? The third one abides in cessation means that it is by its nature the third Noble Truth, the truth of cessation, yeah, and thoroughly meditates upon abandoning aspects to be abandoned. That is referring to the truth of the path.

So by its nature it doesn’t have the first truth, the truth of suffering, it doesn’t create the causes for the truth of suffering which is the second Noble Truth. It is by nature cessation it abides in cessation which is the understanding of the realization of emptiness the lack of inherent existence and nature is also this path the truth of the path which is the path to realizing true cessation. So that’s the case for this mental factor which is mindfulness. It’s the case for the mental factor which is the correct analysis. It’s the case for the mental factor which is effort or enthusiasm.

It’s the case for this correct mental factor which is joy, for pliancy, for concentration and for meditative equanimity. Because the main mind is the consciousness directly perceiving emptiness then the mental factors that come along with that which are the seven limbs of enlightenment, yeah, also have these as their nature. Is that okay? Okay so the need for this meditation is that there are things to be abandoned which are called things to be abandoned on the path of seeing. There are things that you can abandon by the meditations and the developments of the path of seeing. Without doing these meditations, without having this focus and these mental factors that come along with it you can’t abandon what it is you need to abandon on the path of seeing and you can’t develop the qualities that come about once you’ve abandoned these things Hence definition, which is number four, which says it’s nature. So this definition says it’s a pristine awareness in the continuum of an ārya acting as the cause of enlightenment which is its result.

Now, pristine awareness is a higher knower, is that what it’s called in the other ones? Exalted knower, sorry that’s the same thing. Pristine awareness, exalted knower, same thing. Basically a realization that is a path. It’s an ārya path which acts as the cause for enlightenment which is this result.

Now if you have a main mind that is focusing on the realization of emptiness then that main mind is a path and any of the mental factors that come along with that main mind are also paths so that means these mental factors which are the seven limbs of enlightenment or the seven causes for enlightenment are the mental factors that come along with the main mind focusing on the lack of inherent existence or emptiness. Is that okay? He’s like, it’s pretty easy, The realization of emptiness is the cause for achieving enlightenment, the mental factors that come along with that are also causes for achieving enlightenment. And that’s the nature of what we’re talking about here. And the reason there is seven is because Nāgārjuna said so in the collected topics and that is mindfulness, analysis of dharma, effort, joy, pliancy, concentration, and equanimity.

Okay, so then the next thing we have is the methods of being requisites and this is because there is another way of explaining these seven and rearranging them into five. The first of which is the requisite of abidance now the requisite of abidance is the same thing as the requisite of mindfulness or the cause of mindfulness it’s just another way of putting it the reason it’s called abidance is because mindfulness which is what keeps the mind in place focused on something right? And that’s why it’s called abidance, another way of saying it is abidance. The second one it says is the second is the requisite of essence and what this is talking about is what was in the last one analysis of Dharma. Now the reason it’s called the requisite of essence is because this analysis of Dharma is another way of saying perceiving emptiness and this perception of emptiness is the essence of the path of seeing, the nature of the path of seeing, the perception of emptiness.

The analysis of Dharma can be subsumed into requisite of essence. Okay, the third of these is the requisite of definite emergence. This definite emergence is another way of saying effort or enthusiasm and the reason it is called definite emergence is because if someone’s happy to engage in positive actions and that makes them that’s what they enjoy doing and then it’s going to be obvious that they will that it will be obvious that they achieve the results thereafter So if what they want to do is to perform these actions to do this practice and then it’s definite that they will achieve the results. So if they’re happy to do something, it’s definite that they’ll get the outcome of what it is they’re happy to do. Oh god.

Now Graham’s pulling a face, and now you’re pulling a face. Okay, so definite emergence literally means the mind set on something. Okay, so in that instance what you’re talking about is a mind set on liberation, right? But we’re not talking about a mind set on liberation here we’re talking about a mind set on omniscience, on Buddhahood so it’s still correct to call it definite emergence but it’s a definite emergence from being a non Buddha to a Buddha, not liberation, not a samsaric being to a liberation. The next one that we have is the requisite of benefit and what that is talking about is joy.

Now, joy is a less intense version of bliss, alright? It’s the same as bliss but it’s not as intense. Now, the reason that it’s called the requisite of benefit is through abidance like through mindfulness and through wisdom which is perceiving the nature of things and through being happy about doing something, right? Then bliss comes about. So the benefits you get from the first three is the fourth one which is joy.

Okay, so the last three are requisites without affliction, that is pliancy, concentration and equanimity. Now, the reason that those three are put together is because they are all related to meditative concentration or like a calm abiding or form of subtle one of the subtle forms of calm abiding. The equanimity that’s referred to here is in your average everyday equanimity. It’s talking about the equanimity of meditative concentration. So, this equanimity is talking about the fact that when you have these very subtle levels of meditative concentration you’re not distracted by anything.

Your mind is in an equanimous state where it is continually focused on

Key terms in this teaching

Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
five powers
The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top