41 min · 1,710 words · 27 May 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the three doors of liberation, emptiness, signlessness and wishlessness, as tied to three aspects of phenomena: the thing itself, its cause and its result. It notes that the Prajnaparamita Sutras present these through many aspects and that commentaries arrange them in different ways. It then contrasts the selflessness realised by hearers and solitary realizers with the Buddha’s realisation, which is similar but unique.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-05-27
Duration: 41 min
UUID: 64dc4ce0-a5e0-4645-a5bf-09d17e65ec61
Words: 1,706
It says that there is these three different aspects to phenomena. Three different aspects to phenomena are the actual thing itself, its cause and its result. So you have a cause, a thing and a thing’s result. Right? A cause, a phenomenon, and phenomena’s result.
Now there’s three different truths to any phenomena. Now, the first one, the actual thing itself, a meditative equipoise on that is said to be the door of liberation, which is emptiness. The result is said to be wishlessness, and the cause is said to be signlessness. Okay. So sorry.
Okay. Okay. Right. Yeah. So it works this way: because the cause itself is not inherently existent, then a meditative concentration that is focusing on that is said to be signlessness because there is no sign.
The sign is not inherently existent. Because the nature is also said to be not inherently existent, then the meditative equipoise, which is focusing on the nature of the actual thing itself, is said to be emptiness, right? It’s the door of emptiness. And because the result is also not inherently existent, then the meditative equipoise that is focusing on that is said to be wishlessness, because there is no inherently existent result. Okay.
So the boundary of this the boundary of these realizations are from the Mahāyāna path of accumulation and on onward and upward. So basically what this is explaining is that all these different takes have a different way of looking at this, but we’re actually talking about the mind that’s realizing emptiness, the mind that realizes emptiness, and this has different aspects. It has the aspect of being focused on emptiness, it has the aspect of being silent and the aspect of being wishless. Some say that the realization of the lack of inherent existence of characteristics masculine or feminine or abiding and so forth, signlessness. Others say that signlessness is, for example, focusing on the lack of inherent existence of a cause.
It s all about the mind realizing the lack of inherent existence and different aspects that that can have. Okay. So the the reason that there is all these different explanations of how these things fit together is because in the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras, or the Perfection of Wisdom Sutras, then the Buddha actually went through every single aspect. Yeah. So the Buddha explained about a hundred and fifty three.
Okay. It said that the Buddha explained one hundred and fifty three different aspects of phenomena and explained how all of those are empty, signless and wishless. Within each of those one hundred and fifty three aspects there was a whole bunch of other things that were also explained. Within this group of sutras, he’s actually trying to explain how all phenomena are empty and he’s doing it through all these different ways. That meant then when it came to compiling those sutras, up with commentaries on those sutras, because the explanation had been so vast and so in-depth, commentaries then focused on different aspects of that and collated the different descriptions in different ways.
So they came up with different ways of looking at this signlessness, wishlessness and emptiness. Oh, yeah. Okay. Right. So there’s just a little bit at the end that was describing a debate that you could have about the definition.
And, yes, and Geshe-la doesn’t think that it’s worth getting into that. So he thinks that you will have lots of questions instead. Otherwise, yes. Yeah. So next week, there is a what is it called?
The three parts of manifestation so we can have manifestations next week. So you gotta have lots of questions now because I don’t wanna do the debate. Mhmm. Mhmm. Mhmm.
Mhmm. Yes. He said that it does seem weird. They don’t yes. So there’s all these different ways of explaining it, but they’re explaining the same thing.
They’re explaining emptiness. Basically, there are all these different ways of explaining the same thing. So sometimes they can put out in the sutras, it was explained in one way, and if someone didn’t understand that, then they would explain he would explain it in another way. Yeah. Yeah.
So that’s why it says in the beginning of this this session, it says, okay. When we come to the description of the the three doors of liberation, there’s actually different explanations of it, and they’ve all taken a different aspect of the because you don’t want to double some of that. You get a better idea. Okay? But that’s from the from the realization.
Yeah. Yeah. For But not grasping at one part of the teaching. Yeah. Not grasping at one part of the teaching.
Yeah. Yeah. That’s only from that. He said, yes. So that’s that’s he said, yes.
That’s the that’s the description of the three doors to liberation. None of them are here. So the so the yeah. That’s when if you talk about the nature or the thing itself, which causes energy as a result, that’s what you’re basically talking about. Yeah.
So once we were talking about in the knower of basis, basis in the knower of basis, are the realization that the hearers and solitary realizers have. Here is a realization of a knower of basis and then solitary realizers have a realization of a knower of basis. So for example, if we take the realization of selflessness, hearers and solitary realizers realize selflessness because that’s their main object, and they develop an understanding of that and they direct insight into that. So because a Buddha has omniscience and and knows everything, then they’re obviously going to know this as well. Right?
But they you can’t say that a realization that a Buddha has is a is a hearer’s realization because they’re not a hearer. They’re a Buddha. But they’re a Buddha who has therefore realizations that are similar to a hearer’s realization. But they can’t be hearer’s realizations because they’re a Buddha. They said they still have that so so in this example, they still have the realization of selflessness.
This is the the realization of selflessness in the Buddha’s continuum can’t be a hearer’s. So the realizations of the aspects of the knower of basis aspect, right, and the aspects of Buddha, right, are unique. They they they don’t have anything. They’re not the same as the the realizations of a in the first instance, when we’re talking about the twenty seven aspects of a narrow basis, you’re describing the mind of a hearer or a solitary realizer. And so they have a realization of the selflessness of persons.
Right? Then we go on to describe the mind of an aspect of Buddha. So within that, they have all of these realizations. They have some of the same realizations as those who are another father, and then they have specific realizations to them, uncommon aspects as well. Okay?
So the other people the other the other sections are describing one type of person, and we’re on to describing the Buddha. So some of their realizations are the same as as solitary realizers hearers and bodhisattvas, and some of them aren’t. Right? But because we’re describing the mind of a Buddha, then the whole description, which is the hundred and ten aspects Yep. Is different to the description of the solitary realizers.
Oh, yeah. Yeah. It’s it’s an it’s a matter of numbers. I didn’t say let’s see. You can’t say aspects of an an exalted aspects.
I finally got a so there’s a difference. I was going like this, which is really bad. But, anyway and then he goes, so why is there a difference between these? He goes, I don’t know. But finally, I said, I don’t Okay.
So the okay. So when they’re describing these things, when it says aspects, you’re talking about you’re talking about the aspects of a Buddha’s mind. Right? And when you’re talking about the object, you’re talking about the same objects. Right?
But because that we’re talking about aspects, these aspects by definition have to be different because the mind that’s perceiving them is different. So if you’re talking about the difference between the mind of the Buddha and the mind of the hearer or solitary realizer, okay, or a bodhisattva. So they have the same object, yeah, or the same focus, but they don’t have the same mind. So you’re looking up to see why there’s a difference between them. Okay.
So the difference between, say, for example, the mind that realizing selflessness of a hearer or sort of saying realer, and the mind realizing selflessness of a Buddha is that a he hero realizing selflessness doesn’t have the potential to see this emptiness of all phenomena. So therefore, when a Buddha perceives the selflessness of the person, it’s also able to perceive the emptiness of that concept or that phenomena. Whereas the solitary realizer isn’t able or hearer isn’t able to perceive for every mind that or every, like what’s called an object possessor of a mind. Right? That a Buddha has, which is there is many of them, and there’s a different aspect comes there’s that’s a different aspect of a Buddha’s mind.
So that means that there’s more aspects of Buddha’s mind. Okay. So he thinks that they’re probably the reason that He thinks that probably the reason that that there is more aspect to an exalted knower of all aspects harmonious with hearers and solitary realizers than there is the actual aspects of a knower basis is because it’s it’s it’s it’s looking at those those realizations from the perspective of Buddha. So because the Buddha is able to perceive the emptiness of all phenomena, then they’re going to see have more mind. It’s an aspect like mind.
Right? They’re gonna have more they’re going to be able to perceive that realization with more different mind or minds. Yeah. The Those Buddhas don’t have the perception of all things being like a dream because they realize a lack of inherent existence of all phenomena directly, and they don’t see anything like a dream when they’re not in meditation, concentration like those like those who have realized emptiness do. And in that
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.