Ornament for Clear Realisations – 46 2004 08 19 OCR

45 min · 2,750 words · 19 August 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 46 2004 08 19 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The transcript is a study discussion of a text’s definitions of the three times (past, present and future), illustrated with the fire, smoke and ash example and the firewood example. It contrasts the Prasangika and Svatantrika Madhyamaka views: both hold that the three times are merely labelled and impermanent, and the present is a momentary instant. The machine transcript is partly garbled and ends mid-discussion.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-08-19

Duration: 45 min

UUID: d5d4e9aa-b01f-4876-89af-e1bb1a112b61

Words: 2,746

Okay. Okay. This one? No. My head’s gonna explode.

Alright. It seems to be a little different from the translation that we have here. And from trying to translate this, I can understand why they have translated it differently. Right? But I’m going to have a have a go.

Okay? So, it’s basically saying and I’m not I’m not actually sure that it does translate. It’s one of those things, right? So, in terms of the word order, right? It says time and then it says, this time which Just laughing at me.

So, it’s literally the time that will disintegrate or the time that’s but it doesn’t have this common locus thing in it, like, that it has here. And I guess that that’s their way of trying to get around what is, like, almost impossible to translate. Right? So it’s like the time that is, that we’ll disintegrate, basically. Let’s try that.

How’s that sound? Alright? Sound something vaguely like now? Okay. Okay, so I’ll just clarify with Geshe-la, there is a common locus in the definition of a present in this text, right?

But it’s not in Tibetan. So we don’t know why they’ve come up with that, right? Probably because it’s almost really difficult to translate. Then the next one though, the definition of the future is basically the same as it says here. It has two aspects to it.

It is being either of the three past, present and future, right? And is the common locus of that not produced and not ceased at this time. Yeah. And the definition of the past is that which is disintegrated at this time. So that’s the same.

Yeah. So the three definitions are okay? Yeah? So the next thing we still need to figure out what smoke is, right, to understand time. It’s very Zen, isn’t it?

Anyway, so we need to now look at it’s a definiendum or an example of that which is defined as smoke. Right? Does that make sense? Okay, so with regards to smoke, example is given as an example for how to understand time. So the thing that causes smoke is fire.

So if you see smoke there, the fire that caused that smoke is a way of understanding the past. The smoke itself is a way of understanding the future and the dust that is will be a result of the fire is the way of understanding it. No, I did that wrong. If you see smoke, the fire that causes smoke is what how you understand the past. Smoke itself is how you understand the present and the embers the ash that will come in the future is how you understand the future, right?

And with regards to smoke. Okay? So the reason that they’re explaining this way is to illustrate and to highlight the connection between the three of these, right. So this means that in general, when we talk about the three times, we think of them as being three solid individual things, but this shows how they’re reliant on each other. So we define the past as that which has already gone, which in relation to now has already gone.

And we define the future as that which is has yet to come in relation to now. And we define now as that which is not the past and what is not the future. The reason that this example of smoke and fire and ash is given is to show that the three things are actually dependent on each other. So in relation to the smoke however, we could say that the in relation to the smoke and the embers are actually, sorry, not embers, the ash is actually the future from the smoke and the fire is the past from the smoke, but we may actually be perceiving the ashes, so we perceive it from our understanding of now, but from the perspective of the smoke it’s different. So it’s the same thing as we can say like yesterday, today, tomorrow, right?

Now from this perspective of today, yesterday is yesterday and tomorrow is tomorrow, but from the perspective of yesterday, yesterday was today and today is tomorrow and the day before yesterday was yesterday, right? And the performance perspective of tomorrow and then tomorrow is today, The day after tomorrow is tomorrow and today is yesterday. Okay? So it’s to show that the all those three things are connected together. So, for example, now we consider tomorrow to be the future because that understanding of tomorrow as being the future is dependent on today being today.

And when it becomes tomorrow, then tomorrow will be today and then it will no longer be the future, it will be the now. Then now is what we’re experiencing now. So if we’re talking about that in terms of yesterday, today and tomorrow, it is a tomorrow hasn’t come yet. Today, we’re saying today is still now and yesterday is gone. So yesterday isn’t now, so what we are experiencing today is said to be the present.

In terms of if we divide things into yesterday, today and tomorrow. So this presentation is based on the fire and so on and everything is the clearest one. And it uses these examples to show how the things are connected together and how our perception of things as being three solid different is actually a fallacious and that we need to see how these things are only defined by one another. Now, this is why that they give these examples of fire and all that sort of stuff, but the reason description is actually a lot clearer than in the descriptions that were given earlier that accord with all the other schools, right? So, when you try and understand those other schools, you need all this fire and stuff to try and make sense of it because it’s very Okay.

So then we can look at it from another perspective, the point of view of fuel for a fire or the firewood. Right? That’s what I’m looking for. That’s not on fire. Right?

Firewood that’s not on fire. Now, firewood that’s not on fire, if you take that as being the present, then the past of that fire wood is that fire wood being collected, the collection of that fire wood is caused for there being fire wood, right? So the collection of that fire wood represents the past in that instance and that actual fire wood catching on fire is and the whole process of the fire thingy with the dust and the ashes and everything is the future. So then, the if you take the point of view of the fire itself, then the fire itself is that which is that which has come into existence and has not ceased. So that would be the present.

The firewood that was used for the fire would be the past from the perspective of the fire and the ashes and smoke that were coming after the fire or as a result of the fire are the future for the future from the perspective of the fire. Okay, so this is what this is supposed to show is that if any phenomena’s past, yes, is that which its future is dependent upon, is that which its future needs to be dependent upon. So that which has not been generated by that phenomena is its future. That which that which is the past is dependent on the future of that object. Sorry, that which is the future is dependent upon that which was the past of that object.

Okay. So what this then means is that for therefore any phenomena’s past time is necessarily dependent on what its future is going to be. Its definition of future is dependent on its past. And the past is dependent on the concept of future. So this means that for example, the road of yesterday is on the in dependence on the road of yesterday becomes the road of the future.

And that yesterday’s path so yesterday’s path hang on, So yesterday’s path is defined by the time of today. Okay, so I think this is where they’re getting that common locus thingy from. So therefore the definition of today’s path then is the path, because yesterday’s or path or road, sorry, same thing. Same thing in Tibetan. So the yesterday’s road becomes yesterday’s road depending on today’s road and tomorrow’s road becomes tomorrow’s road depending on today’s road, yeah.

And today’s road becomes today’s road being that it is not it has been generated and it has not yet disintegrated. So that’s the end of time. I said yes, end of time and the end of the session. He said that was simple. You guys should have got that by now.

It’s the same, Svatāntrika and Svata It’s the Mādhyamika view, so it’s both Prasangika and Svatāntrika. Consequentialist and autonomous, both heavy. It’s not that much, basically it means there’s not much difference between the three different times. Oh, sorry, sorry, sorry. There’s not really much difference between the three times from the perspective of both of the Mādhyamika schools.

I thought you were just going to say they’re all labeled. So yes, they’re pretty much basically the same. From the Prāsaṇgika point of view, then they are labeled in dependence upon the other two and it’s the same from the the Prāsaṇgika says they’re all merely labeled as past, present and future. And in the Svatāntrika School, they say that the concept of past is dependent on the concept of the future and the present and the concept of present is dependent on the concept of the past and the future. So it’s a very similar presentation.

Because they both have the idea of the base as well. And I’m like, there’s a base that’s labeled to something dependent on. Because they both have this idea of disintegrating as well. So this idea of time disintegrating as well, of being of momentariness and so therefore that which has become and hasn’t disintegrated yet is now and that which has disintegrated is past and that which has gone. It’s like sorry, it wasn’t base, it was disintegration.

Okay, so this whole idea of disintegration or ceased, I think is how they translate it here. Common locus is not produced and not ceased at this time. And then it says, a common locus of produced at this time and not ceased, yes. And it’s a common locus of that, they’ve got disintegrated, the same thing as ceased, right, as a definition of past here. So that ceased thingy, right, It’s the same word as in Tibetan for momentariness.

It means like in an instant to cease, in an instant to cease, in an instant ceased, instant ceased, in an instant ceased, yeah? And so this means that in fact the definition of present can only be momentariness. Only moment, I mean, therefore it can only be one moment. So the difference between Svantandrika and the about this is that as Cittamātrins and everyone below them says that the future and the past are both permanent because they are concepts and they don’t disintegrate and that the present is a momentarily disintegrating thing. And from the point of view of the Prāsaṇgika, all three are impermanent.

Are all impermanent. They’re all things. That’s the way that Mopo is usually translated things. Things is ringing a bell from like collected topics and logic and stuff. There’s things and there’s non things and non things are permanent and things are impermanent.

Yeah. So from the Prāsaṇgika point of view, they’re all things. And from the Svatāntrika point of view and everybody else below them, then the present is a thing and the other two are non things or permanent. He said that this time is a problem. It’s what they spend a lot of time debating on.

Yeah. Good. We’re gonna finish up. So there isn’t any particular definition for momentariness because momentariness is the definition of impermanence. So but momentariness what momentariness means is this, in the instance something is generated, it changes and ceases to exist the way it did.

Okay, so the explanation where the example was saying that today is defined by yesterday, today is now because of the way we think of it is actually an example. It doesn’t follow that today can be a now. And now is the smallest amount of time that can exist, is a moment. Now is only ever the smallest amount of time. As soon as it is generated, disintegrates.

So this idea of today, tomorrow and yesterday enables us to think about things clearer because they have bigger amounts of time. So this way we can think that tomorrow is like the future, yesterday is like the past and today is like the present. But in actual fact, the present can only exist for the smallest amount of time, the smallest divisible amount of time. So you can’t say I’m speaking now So you’ve had heaps. Yeah, hundreds of ‘now’s’ in every time you say ‘now’.

Okay, so you can the middle hour is hours. The first hour will be the past. The middle hour is the present, sorry, previous hour is the past and the future hour is the future. And then we go down to say three minutes, right? One minute is the present, the previous minute to that is the past and the future minute minutes to that is the future.

And then you can take it down to seconds, one second is the present, the previous second to that is the fullest like the past and then second further on from those to future. But then you can go and be lower, a second is like sixty-four moments in a click of a finger, right? So this is the most subtle extent of time that we can have. Now on a relative level, however, these sixty four parts to the click of a finger is the most sensible relative concept of time, yes. So one sixty fourth of a click of a finger is now, right.

As soon as it generates this disintegrate, as soon as it generates disintegrated, but relatively in terms of past, present and future, yeah, there is a now. It’s just that it is constantly changing as in one sixty fourth of a second. The concept sorry, I’ve got to finish. But the concept of now, present and future, the reason that they’re not inherently existent is because they depend on each other. Yeah.

Yeah. But in terms of relative truth, the one moment is now. In actual fact, the past and the future are mutually exclusive. They don’t have any common locus. So the moment, the individual moment, which is the one sixty-fourth of a click of a fingers that separates past and the future is now.

So ultimately none of them exist because they’re ultimately all merely labeled, all right? But from the perspective of that which is merely labeled, there is a moment which is now. And that moment which is now defines what is future and what is past. But all of those are merely labeled and dependent on each other. The present is reliant on the future.

If we did, I made a mistake, which I can under that’s probably true because my head was spinning like a Ferris wheel. So basically, they all come down to now. You define the future and the past by the now. Now the now doesn’t exist for more than a literally a split second, yes, a second split into sixty fourth, all right. But what you define is, but this now is an existing thing, even if it’s only a merely labeled existing thing, yes.

And so the concept of future and past pivot on this concept of now, on the idea of the moment really changing now. As the moment really changing now changes, we put the past and the future changes, but the past no, they don’t change. The past and the future are reliant on that momentarily changing now. So the fact that this the central position changes, and therefore the future and the past pivot on these things is why the Prasangikas say that it’s impossible to argue that one of them is permanent and the other’s

Key terms in this teaching

Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top