Ornament for Clear Realisations – 27 2004 05 27 OCR

44 min · 2,647 words · 27 May 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 27 2004 05 27 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This session continues from the previous week, moving on to the thirty-four aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects that are harmonious with Bodhisattvas. It explains the three antidote paths (emptiness, signlessness and wishlessness) and the three doors of liberation, with their differing presentations in the Abhidharma, the Sutralamkara and Nagarjuna’s Collected Topics, and how they relate to the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-05-27

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 47787dd9-6ce3-414f-8446-fa3742fb2028

Words: 2,643

I thought that he was about to fall off or something. Okay. Before we start listening to the teachings, we should try and develop the right motivation. Now, the right motivation is that in order to establish all other sentient beings who have been our mothers, in order to establish them in the state beyond suffering of complete enlightenment, then we are doing this virtuous action. So the thing that we’re going to do this evening is look at and listen to teachings from the fourth chapter of the Clear Ornament of Realization.

Now we should think that by listening to these teachings and developing an understanding of these teachings, that then we will be able to eventually put these teachings into practice, and that will be a cause for us to achieve complete enlightenment. Through achieving complete enlightenment, we will be able to fulfill our capacity to benefit others. So last week, we actually finished going through the thirty seven aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects harmonious with hearers and solitary realisers, or the thirty seven aspects of enlightenment is another name that was given. Finished going through all of those different aspects and finishing with the eight limbs of the aryas path. Tonight we start with where we arrived last week.

That is thirty four aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects harmonious with Bodhisattvas. So that’s where we’re going to start this evening. It’s thirty four. Right. So starting to go through the thirty four aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects that are in a Buddha’s mind but are similar to the realizations of a Buddha’s cipher.

Because there are aspects of the exalted, nor of all aspects or aspects of a Buddha’s mind, Bodhisattvas don’t have them, but they have minds that are similar to it. When we’re describing this, the source for the description that’s coming here is a commentary that was given by a man called Haribhādra, an Indian pundit. The set of textbooks develops from this commentary. This commentary, first of all, establishes that there are six different sections to this. They are: The three paths of antidotes The three paths of manifestation, five paths that abide in happiness in this present life, the nine supra mundane paths or unworldly paths, the four paths of abandonment, and paths of a Buddha of the ten paths of Buddhahood, which is another way of saying the the the ten powers.

Okay. So first one of these that we’re going to look at is the three paths of antidotes that are in the continuum of a Buddha Superior but have similar aspects in the continuums of Bodhisattvas. First of all, there is a quote from the Root Text that says, Path of antidotes in the knower of paths, so that is from the knower of paths. So, there are all different sorts of paths of antidotes, but we’re specifically talking about the antidotes that are contained within the subgroup that is knower of paths, right? Chapter two.

Therefore, and it says the antidotes produced by views is another way of saying emptiness. So a view which is an antidote is a view of emptiness. That’s the first one. And then the second one is antidotes of conceptualizations of the signs of that. Conceptualizations of the signs of that, that being emptiness, and so antidotes which are conceptualizations of the reasons for that or the causes of that or the signs of that.

And then this is another way of saying signlessness, that is realizing that emptiness there is no cause for this as well. That’s the second antidote path. The third one is an antidote to longing for the three realms, so that is the desire realm, form realm and formless realm. This is the third one, which is wishlessness. It’s another way of saying the third one, wishlessness, the antidote of wishlessness.

So the rest of the quote from Haribhādra’s commentary says, The entity of the aspects of empty and selfless is the first door of complete liberation. The entity of true cessation and path is the second. The entity of the aspects of impermanence and suffering and the true origin is the third. And last, the three are the aspects of the three doors of complete liberation. So this is how the three doors refer to the sixteen aspects of the four noble truths.

Alright, but we get into more detail of this as the text goes on. The next part we come into that’s in the text. So we go back to doing to explain that clearly but the next part that comes on in the text is the definition of a path of antidote in this instance. That is a path of antidote which is part of a Buddha’s continuum that is similar to Bodhisattvas and is contained within the knowledge of paths. So this definition is: An exalted knower distinguished by the ability to quell the superimposition that is its object to be eliminated through realizing the nonexistence of the referent object of the superimposition that that is its object to be eliminated.

So in this antidote where it says, an exalted knower, then an exalted knower is again another way of saying a path, right? And it is an exalted knower that is distinguished by the ability to quell the superposition that is its object to be eliminated. Now this is the definition of all antidotes. All antidotes have this idea of being able to get rid of the that they need to get rid of. In this instance, what we’re dealing with here is a superimposition.

A superimposition is a wrong consciousness, a wrong consciousness which is eliminated by a wisdom. So in this way, an antidote is ability perceive absence of a wrong mind’s object. Does that make sense? So the wrong mind is focused on something that isn’t really there, so the antidote is the wisdom that perceives that that thing that the wrong consciousness is focused on isn’t really there. So there’s another way of saying definition here, there’s no other way of saying it in English.

This definition is a definition because and it says this definition is a something else, but it still means definition in English. But anyway Maybe we could say the thing that is placed no, I just forget it. They’re both definition. Okay. So we can also say its definition, its characteristics, its nature, and there’s this other one that literally is that which is placed is the literal translation.

But it means that which characterizes something, but it’s all saying the same thing. Anyway, so this definition is this thing’s nature, right? These are paths which are antidotes’ nature because it has three characteristics, what are called the three dharmas that define a definition. The first one of these is that it fulfills the characteristics of the object it’s referring to. It describes the characteristics of the object it’s referring to.

The second one is that it doesn’t describe the characteristics of something else. Yeah? That it is an instance of what it is describing. And the third one is that it doesn’t describe an instance of anything else. So it describes what it is.

It doesn’t describe what it isn’t, and it is validated by an instance of the thing it’s describing. Yeah, this is saying that this definition the true definition of a path of antidote indicated here. That is a path of antidote which is a knower of paths. Because the description that’s given in the definition can only refer to this, can only refer to knowers of paths which exist in Buddha’s continuums but harmonious with Bodhisattva’s realizations. Okay?

So it can only refer to this. And that’s why it has these two different aspects to it. It has one saying, It’s an exalted, nor distinguished by the ability to quell the superimposition that is its object. Right? And then this object that is being gotten rid of is eliminated through its nonexistence.

Existence, right? So the superimposition doesn’t exist, so therefore the mind of wisdom can eliminate it. So there’s these two different paths to it. Okay? Which define it?

Right. Now okay. Otherwise I’m going to forget. Was like, Can I please translate that before I forget? Anyway, then there is three different types of antidote in the continuum of a Buddha Superior.

There is an antidote which is emptiness, an antidote which is signlessness, and an antidote which is wishlessness. These together are called the three doors of liberation. You have a door or a cause for liberation, which is emptiness or the realization of emptiness, and a door of liberation, which is signlessness or the realization of signlessness, and a door to liberation, which is wishlessness. So these are three different ones. Now, the description of these three different doors of liberation actually varies depending on which text you read.

So we have the description of these three doors as described in the Abhidhamma. Okay. In the Abhidhamma of Vasubandhu, we have a description of these these three doors of liberation described in the Sūtra Lamkara or the ornament to the sutras of Maitreya. And we also have a description of these three doors of liberation described in the collected topics of Nāgārjuna. There’s three there, and there’s also another, which is the description that’s actually in the clear ornament of realization.

There’s four different ways it’s described, but actually the clear ornament of realizations description and the description in Nāgārjuna’s collected topics are harmonious, or they are basically the same. This one. Okay. So the description of these three doors to liberation from the Abhidharma of Vasubandhu starts off by saying or it says I should say it says, The aspect of peace, which is signlessness, the emptiness The first line from the Abhidharma says: The aspect which is peace is signlessness. And then it says: aspects which are emptiness and selflessness are emptiness and the aspects which is the all the rest of the aspects are are wishlessness so this is referring to the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths.

Right? Yeah? Do you remember them? Everyone got them? Okay, cool.

And so when it says the aspect which is peace is signlessness, then it’s referring to the truth of cessation. That’s another way of saying cessation is this peace. And then it says, the aspect which is emptiness is emptiness and selflessness. Now these are the last two aspects of the first Noble Truth selflessness and emptiness. Then it says that all the rest are wishlessness.

So, we have the all of the truth of the origin of suffering and all of the truth of the path. They all come under wishlessness in this analysis. Sorry, I forgot that he’d said something else before. Right. Then this means that the truth of cessation, all four aspects of the truth of cessation, plus it says what are called the five aspects or the five objects which is for example form, smells, sounds, tastes and tactile objects, the tacitly of objects, as well as the signs that indicate masculinity and femininity, and the definitions of compounded phenomena, which is to say that compounded phenomena are generated, abide and disintegrate.

All of these are said to be the ten characteristics which, when we see that they are actually emptiness and are therefore part of the truth of cessation, become the ten aspects of signlessness. Then, if one is able to absorb themselves in meditative concentration focused on these objects, then that meditative concentration is said to be the door to liberation of signlessness. Okay. So then the next group the next group that we have is the the door of selflessness I’m sorry, the door of liberation, which is emptiness. So that one we just deal with signlessness and we have emptiness.

Now the door of liberation which is emptiness is the meditative concentration which is able to abide single pointedly on the two aspects of suffering which are there’s two aspects of the truth of suffering, sorry, which are selflessness and emptiness. The last two aspects. So in this analysis, according to the Abhidharma then, all of the other aspects from the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths, that is, all of the different aspects of the origin of suffering, of the different aspects of the truth of the path, and the first two aspects of the truth of suffering and impermanence, they are all said to be part of the wishlessness. So that is if people are if anyone’s able to focus in meditative concentration on these aspects, then that meditative concentration is said to be the door which is wishlessness, the door to liberation, which is the wishlessness. So Geshe-la just went through everything and goes, Let’s try and make it simple for them.

So the next part, and so Even though he just said a lot, I’m not going to say very much because he simplified it in the end. The way that it is explained in the Sūtra Lankara is that there is a you have these three doors to liberation, right? You have the door to liberation which is emptiness, door to liberation which is signlessness, and the door to liberation which is wishlessness. So first of all in this explanation you perceive the lack of inherent existence within the aspects of the Four Noble Truths, right? And so that is the door to liberation which is emptiness.

That’s the first thing that happens. Then having perceived that you are able to see what it is that in the Four Noble Truths there are things that need to be abandoned and things that need to be practiced. The things that need to be abandoned are based on this idea of things having an inherent existence. You’re able to see that that’s not the case and abandon them, and that’s actually to see signlessness, to see that there is no sign or there’s no cause there so that can be abandoned. And then the third aspect is the achievement of the truth of cessation.

The truth of cessation is said to be wishlessness because it is the understanding that these things do not have a result. Is that okay? So that’s the way that it this process is explained in the Sūtra Lankara or the ornament to the sutras. Okay. So the next way that these things are described is from the collected topics of Nāgārjuna, and in this, it says that these sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths are divided into these three doors of liberation this way.

The two different emptiness aspects of the first Noble Truth, that is selflessness and emptiness, or the two, Another way of looking at that is the selflessness of phenomena and the selflessness of persons, or the subtle and gross selflessness. Those aspects are said to be included within the door of liberation, which is emptiness. Then Okay. Sorry. Then, signlessness.

Okay. Sorry. I just got a bit bit confused between all the different divisions. I thought my eyes were seeing things funny. So, we have these two different aspects, which is selflessness and emptiness from the four different aspects of the First Noble Truth.

The Truth of suffering are in the door of emptiness, the door of liberation which is emptiness. Then the other two aspects of the first Noble Truth which is suffering and impermanence, along with all the four aspects of the second noble truth, which is the truth of the origin of suffering. All six of those are said to be included within wishlessness. And then the truth of the path and the truth of cessation are said to be included within signlessness. The mind meditating on signlessness.

Explanations.

Key terms in this teaching

cessation, the truth of nirodhasatya (Skt); gog den (Tib)
The third of the four noble truths, the complete elimination of all disturbing-thought obscurations, thus stopping suffering and attaining the state of liberation or nirvana. LYWA
Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
three doors go sum (Tib)
Body, speech and mind. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top