45 min · 2,919 words · 19 August 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a commentary on the eighteen unshared qualities of Buddhas, covering the six unshared realizations (constant compassion, tireless effort, mindfulness, meditative stabilization, wisdom, and liberating activity) and the three unshared enlightened activities. It then begins the explanation of the three times (past, present, future) in the Ornament for Clear Realisations, noting that the Sera presentation will be used rather than the more difficult earlier systems.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-08-19
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 8d284002-44b4-49d0-94b6-5a9988c40918
Words: 2,915
So said, Dependent on intention, we are able to practice the Dharma and develop realization. Dependent on intention, we are able to listen and develop understanding. Therefore, everything depends on our intention. Now, what this is talking about is the development of the right motivation. Before we do anything, we need to have the intention or the motivation to do it. If what we’re doing accords with the teachings of the Mahāyāna, then we really need to develop a Mahāyāna motivation to go with those teachings.
This means that before listening to these teachings from the fourth chapter of the Clear Ornament of Realization, we should think, by listening to these teachings, may I develop understanding of them. Through listening and through developing understanding, may I be able to establish all sentient beings as Buddhas through becoming a Buddha myself. So we should have that as our motivation for listening to these teachings from the fourth chapter of the Clear Ornament of Realization. So please, having developed having the motivation of then listen to the teaching. So we’re going through the eighteen unshared qualities of Buddhas.
And last week, we went through the six unshared behaviors of Buddhas. And this evening, we’ve reached the second section of the eighteen unshared qualities of Buddhas, which is the six unshared realizations. So the first is the six unshared realizations of Buddhas. The first is. The Tathagatas at all times are constantly performing actions for the benefit of sentient beings. This means that their loving kindness and their compassion, etc, towards Okay.
So there’s a the loving kindness and the compassion of the Buddhist, and it says here, etcetera. And I just had to ask what the etcetera was. Geshe-la said, well, that’s basically everything else that the Buddha teaches. That isn’t loving kindness and compassion. So this includes the teachings of the four noble truths, the teachings on emptiness and everything else.
Now these without cessation, without without a break, continually exists. The Buddhas continuously have this loving kindness and compassion towards all sentient beings. This aspiration that they have to work for the benefit of sentient beings, to perform actions for the benefit of sentient beings, which is a constant aspiration. This doesn’t disintegrate in any way. It’s constant.
It’s not something that gets weaker and stronger and and stronger. It’s continuing. It continues on as strong as it can. The second one is the unshared realization of Buddha is the non decrease in effort. Now, there are countless beings in countless realms, and the Buddha is working for the benefit of all of these, putting in effort, putting in effort in order to benefit beings in all of these countless realms at all times.
Thereis no decrease in the effort that they put in. Now, itis almost impossible for us to conceive of all the different realms, Buddhas are able to conceive of them and also to try and constantly work for the benefit of all beings in all of these realms without getting tired. Geshe-la said that this word that’s translated as here means to get tired or to get worn out by doing something. Being worn out would make you decrease it, but it’s not the same thing. So, six unshared realizations would probably be translated as tirelessness in effort.
So the next one is the effort effort the tirelessness in mindfulness, or the non decreasing mindfulness or mindfulness or memory, because mindfulness and memory are the same word in Tibetan. Having become a Buddha, they are able to perceive all sentient beings of all the three times and the behavior of all of these sentient beings. Are able to perceive their behavior and through perceiving their behavior, they know the best way to benefit them, the methods that will enable them to pacify their mind stream in the best way. They know all of these paths and all of these ways that they can benefit sentient beings without needing to think about it. Having known something once, they don’t forget about it.
They’re continually mindful of it, so Therefore, they are able to know the ways in which sentient beings can be benefited without forgetting it, without being unmindful of it, and without having to put any effort in to remember it. When we learn something, we pretty quickly forget it if we don’t keep reminding ourselves of it. But for the Buddha, they know all of these things and they don’t have to put any effort into remember what’s going to be of benefit to sentient beings. They instantly know what’s going to benefit sentient beings. The next one is the non decrease or the non-decrease in meditative stabilization.
What this refers to is the fact that the Buddhas don’t, after a certain amount of years or a certain amount of time meditating on emptiness, become tired and have to focus on something else. The reason for this is because the Buddha’s mind is in constant meditation on emptiness. There is no separation for them between meditative equipoise and post meditative practice. The two have become one. Because there is no cessation in the Buddha’s meditative equipoise, therefore there is no decrease or there is no forgetting or there’s no tiredness that comes about through meditative stabilization.
And So there’s non-decrease and non-tiredness in wisdom as well. Buddha possesses and says Buddha has wisdom discriminating all phenomena, and he knows exactly what sentient beings need to hear in order to progress. Understanding all phenomena means that he or she has the wisdom to describe the teachings that the disciples need to hear exactly as they need to hear them. So the last of these six realizations that the Buddha has is that they do not become, there is no decrease, or there is no tiredness involved with their practice of liberating sentient beings. They tirelessly work towards the liberation of sentient beings.
They don’t have to try and figure out how to help sentient beings, and it’s no problem for them. If we were trying to do this, there would be many problems that we would come against. But for the Buddhas, they don’t encounter any problems from their side in leading sentient beings to liberation. Okay. So then there we come to the three unshared and enlightened activities.
The first of these, according to this commentary, is that the Buddha radiates rays of light all around him or her when they are present in a physical body. I asked Geshe-la if that meant that people really couldn’t be saying, You’re not really a Buddha, if someone was glowing. He goes, Unfortunately, people without positive karma do not see their two feet of glowing light around the Buddha, so therefore, if you do if you have doubts, you’re less likely to see the light, and if you don’t have doubts, you’re more likely to see it. That’s the first one. So that’s the example that’s given of the positive physical actions that the Buddha does.
Obviously, they’re able to perform physical miracles and do many other things physically, but the main example that’s given in this text for a physical action that the Buddha the physical enlightened activity of the Buddha is this glowing light thing. So, yeah, they can do more than just be glowing. They can also some of them have been able to manifest water where there wasn’t water, and some of them have been able to make water disappear. It’s like miracles based on earth, miracles based on water, miracles based on fire. They’re able to do many other things that seem extraordinary to the humans that encounter them.
So the second of these three unshared enlightened activities is enlightened verbal activities. That is that a Buddha can can teach the Dharma in accordance with the thoughts of the sentient beings in order to best help them. So the the third of the enlightenment activities is that the Buddhas have gotten rid of all obstacles or obscurations to omniscience, without exception. So this means they’ve gotten rid of all their knowledge obscurations and all of the afflictive obscurations or the obscurations to liberation. They also possess constant compassion and loving kindness towards all sentient beings.
This is the first way of looking at the enlightened mental activity of the Buddha, the third of the three unshared enlightened activities. Now all of these enlightened activities actually have as their cause the omniscient mind of the Buddha of the knower of all aspects. Because they come into being based on the knower of all aspects, or the intention for these actions is the knower of all aspects, then they are unshared with all other sentient beings because they can’t exist without their cause, and their cause is this omniscience. Okay. So the other thing to remember is that these three things are actually also in their by their nature, their omniscient omniscientness or the knowable aspects of a Buddha.
So there’s no break in this in this all knowingness or this omniscience. Omniscience acts as a cause for the three unshared enlightened activities, but it is also present as the three unshared enlightened activities. It’s not as if it acts as a cause and then it has these results, but then it just doesn’t disappear in every moment or in every instance. This cause, which is the omniscient mind of a Buddha, keeps going. Okay.
The three unshared exalted wisdoms is it refers to the past, future, and the present. Now the this This understanding of the three times is different to our understanding of the three times because if we try to focus on the future, we wouldn’t be able to focus on the present. If we were focusing on the present, we wouldn’t be able to focus on the past. Buddha’s wisdom enables them to know the past, present and the future at the same time. This is what he means by unimpeded and unobstructed.
Knowing about one time doesn’t stop them from knowing about another time as it does with us. They can think about future and the past at the same time — they can.. This description of the eighteen unshared qualities of the Buddha accords with Maitreya’s description of this quote from Maitreya’s text, The Uttara Tantra Shastra, in which she says, without and without pointlessness that’s a double negative, anyway then it says, with memory or with mindfulness. Right? So with realizations or with mindfulness.
And then holding the various discriminations, with unfaltering meditative equipoise, with the aspiration that never ceases in effort and mindfulness, the wisdom, the ability to free, the wisdom, the non it’s just almost impossible. No difficulties with regards to perceiving wisdom The karma of a Buddha consists of nothing but the five wisdoms. Because of this, they do not have the obscurations that blocks them from seeing the three times. These are the eighteen unshared qualities of a Buddha. Nobody else has them.
So in the same way that the sky doesn’t share any qualities with sorry. Sorry. It’s not the sky. In the same way that uncompounded space does not share any qualities with the four elements, It’s a problem. It’s problem.
Problem. Same way that the uncompounded space doesn’t share any qualities with those, these eighteen qualities peculiar to the Buddha, and nobody no other beings have any of them. They’re they’re completely nonexistent in the characteristics of other beings. So the next thing that we’re going to get into, which Geshe-la says is difficult, which is a bit scary, is the individual Yes. That’s an ominous warning if Geshe-la says it’s difficult.
Is there how would you say it? An expanded or a greater description of the of the three times according to different schools. Right? Now the first school that we’re talking about is the presentation that accords with Okay. So the first description of the three times comes from the root text and commentaries to a text by Maitreya that is called the Madhyanta Vibhanga or the Differentiating the Middle from the Extremes.
Right? So that’s those group of texts is the first presentation. The second presentation is from the collected topics of Nāgārjuna and the third presentation from the root text the you put? Madhyamaka Avatara and the commentaries, which is the Entrance into the Middle Way. This was a text by Nāgārjuna, and its commentary — its main commentary is by Candrakīrti.
By Candrakīrti. Right? And there’s three texts that are all put together in those cases. And then there’s also the presentation that’s given by the it says from their from their own system. Now this system refers to the Monastery’s presentation, and this actually includes their presentation according to the Sera Monastery presentation according to the autonomous school, the Svatāntrika, as well as the Prāsaṇgika, the consequentialist school.
So the reason that these were picked is because Maitreya’s Differentiating the Middle from the Extremes is actually taught from the perspective of the Cittamātra Mind Only school. And then the collected topics is actually Nāgārjuna’s description of the different sutras. So in this, he actually teaches from many different perspectives. It gives you different ideas on the three times. He presents ideas on the three times based on the sutras in these collected topics text.
And the third one, the one that’s the teachings of the text, the Entry to the Middle Way by Candrakīrti, which is based on a root text by Nāgārjuna. This is actually teaching from the perspective of the Prāsaṇgika. And then when it says their own perspective, this means how the sera textbook writers interpreted these different teachings. Right. So there is actually four descriptions.
It is these four different hang on. So, anyway, hang on. Okay. So Geshe-la says from amongst these four, he actually wants to just jump to the to the the own presentation because the other the others may be too difficult to understand. And in the own presentation, it gives you the reasons why the others are difficult to understand and is a lot clearer.
And and I said, so they didn’t present the other views? And Geshe said, yeah. And I said, he no. He I said too difficult for who? Don’t they have it in the text?
And he said, it may be in the text somewhere. We can have a look at it. And I said, well, do they is it too difficult for Geshe’s to understand or too difficult for us to understand? He goes, oh, no. It’s too it’s it’s easy for Geshe’s to understand, but not for me, is what he said.
And I was like You know, she’s gonna say then then he said that it’s up to you guys if you wanna go through the descriptions of what the the these different texts say about three times and then finally end up with the version of the three times and that’s fine. Or if you just wanna skip to the version, it’s up to you, he said. He said it’s easier if you just skip to the sera version. He said it’ll take a long because in actual in fact, to, in actual fact, to understand this description of time, there we have to spend a lot of time talking about the definition of fire. Because the description of time is dependent on the description of fire and smoke.
So you have to go into a lot of detail. In in these texts, their description of time is based on fire and smoke. So you have to spend a lot of time and he said even maybe a couple of weeks talking about fire and smoke. Right? And that may be a little it may take a long time and be a little frustrating because it’s very difficult to understand the their definitions of how they define fire and smoke and so forth.
So if you just we just skip to the end one, we get a rough overview, and we don’t have to do the whole fire smoke thing. And guess what? So the other thing is that if you haven’t done a lot of debate, then actually getting into these definitions of why when when it goes into these definitions of fire, what’s fire and what’s smoke and what’s the difference between fire and smoke and so forth, you if you don’t have a lot of background in in a dialectics and you don’t have a lot of background in a a sign and reasonings signs and reasonings, it’s very difficult to understand anyway. So he said that it it might be a little bit pointless to go through that. And then it goes through all of these things and actually says in this text, right?
This is like a Geshe text here. And it says, now we get on to the to our our position. This will be easier to understand. He said it. He said he hopes he thinks that it would was easy for who wrote all these textbooks to understand.
But for us to try and understand it is a bit difficult. But literally, he says here, it’ll be that’s because it’ll be easier to understand. That’s a bit scary. Okay. The time that is only the time that is the time that is now is the definition of now.
Okay. So Because it doesn’t seem to like fit fit in with the one that’s here.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.