Ornament for Clear Realisations – 40 2004 07 29 OCR

45 min · 3,676 words · 29 July 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 40 2004 07 29 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the path and the uninterrupted path, and the ten perfections of Buddhahood: the six perfections plus prayer, power, skillful means and exalted wisdom. It contrasts the Svatantrika and Prasangika views on when the perfections are completed, and the Vaibhashika view of partless particles with the Madhyamaka view of emptiness. Questions follow on no-self, with the self described as a merely labelled, uninvestigated continuum.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-07-29

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 38ca6aeb-140f-4f21-8ce3-b2c39a38abbd

Words: 3,672

So the technical description of this is the definition of the path. The definition of a non-interrupted path is a pure exalted knower which is the direct antidote to the obscurations that need to be abandoned by this direct knower. So and then the definition of the path of release, whether it’s on the path of meditation or the path of seeing, is then an exalted wisdom, which is a meditative equipoise, which is liberated from the obscuration with which it was fighting on the of which which it was opposed, but I guess it literally said with which it was brawling on the path of uninterrupted path, which is its direct cause. Right? So the path of releases, direct causes, path of uninterrupted path. Sorry.

Is that okay? Okay. So the next thing that we come to is number six, the ten parts of Buddhahood, and this actually refers to the ten perfections. So the definition of a path of Buddhahood is a path that leads to Buddhahood by practicing one of the ten perfections. The ten perfections refers to the six perfections that are normally talked about: generosity, ethics, patience, joyous effort, concentration and wisdom.

There are also four more perfections that are practiced. That is the practice of skillful means: prayer, power and exalted wisdom, with exalted wisdom being the final perfection to be practiced. So the the first six, we don’t need to talk about that much, because you should all know the first six perfections and have a general idea of what they mean. The final four may need some explanation, however. The first of these to deal with is prayer, which is number eight anyway and so anything that is mixed with the motivation of Bodhicitta becomes a perfection right?

Becomes a practice of a perfection so if you have Bodhicitta and you are focusing on prayer then that practice is a perfection of prayer so we say prayers we may say prayers to develop Bodhicitta prayers to attain Buddhahood prayers to help other people if we do those from the basis of Bodhicitta then all of those prayers would become the perfection of prayer nine. Perfection of power this is the ability to get rid of any of the things that may stop us from developing the omniscient mind of a Buddha. This can be anything from impermanence to the power of great compassion. Any of these things can come with that. Now exalted wisdom the last of the hang on we should go back to number seven first which was skillful means but Geshe-la actually said that second last skillful means what that refers to is any time someone can do something with a complete understanding of what the best outcome is going to be.

If you’re able to do something knowing what the best outcome is going to be and therefore develop the causes for that outcome, so knowing what’s going to happen, if you know what’s happen, at the end you are able to know the best methods to use. This is what the skillful means refers to. Final one, exalted wisdom, is the final path before becoming a Buddha. This means that you are able to develop an understanding of all of the different paths and all of the different types of knowledge that you may have been able to develop up until that stage. Right.

So it’s interesting because the the definition of the ten parts of Buddhahood or the definition of a path to Buddhahood is said here to be an exalted knower abiding in a type of path that is the means for progressing to the Buddhahood to the Buddhahood to the Buddha ground. Right? Now, when it says abiding in a type of path that is the means for progressing to the Buddha ground, the reason that it says that is because we’re actually dealing here, if you remember, with minds that Buddhas have, understandings that Buddhas have which are concordant with Bodhisattva’s minds. So we’re not talking about Bodhisattva’s developing understandings that lead them to being a Buddha. We’re talking about Buddha’s understanding of minds that lead to becoming a Buddha.

It says abiding a type of path, it means that it’s the Buddha’s realization of these kinds of paths because you can’t be a path to Buddhahood if you are you can’t have a path to Buddhahood in your mind stream if you’re a Buddha. You’ve already done that. Alright? So you can understand a path to Buddhahood in your mind if you’re a Buddha, but you can’t be developing a path to Buddhahood in your mind if you’re a Buddha because you’ve finished the journey. So when it says abiding in a type of path, it means Buddha’s understanding of this realization as opposed to Buddha’s having a path to Buddhahood which they don’t need because they’re already there.

Alright. So now the the divisions of these ten parts of Buddhahood are said to be their practice. The hang on the practice of the ten perfections that leads to the development of the ten perfections on the ground of a Buddha because according to the Svatāntrika school the bodhisattvas only engage in the practice of perfection. You don’t actually develop the perfections until you become a Buddha because they’re not perfected until you’re a Buddha. That’s according to the Prāsaṇgika school.

The I mean, sorry, the Svatansrika school. The Prasangikas, though, say that because of the etymology, where it says paramita, which means nothing. So the word that they actually translate as perfection is this word paramita, which means the path to the extreme or the path to the other side going to the other side. Right? Or it can it can mean gone to the other side or it can mean going to the other side because it’s using a locative particle to say it’s either so it’s either the path to the other side or gone to the other side, right?

So the Prāsaṇgika could say that it’s because it’s the path to the other side, then the beings practicing these perfections that lead to Buddhahood are actually practicing the perfections themselves, whereas the Svatāntrika can say that they’re not perfected until you’re a Buddha, so they’re not practicing the perfections they’re practicing things that lead to the perfections. Does that make sense? Therefore, finished the thirty-four aspects of an exalted knower, aspects harmonious with the paths of Sravakas and Pratyekabuddhas, and we’re up to the thirty-nine uncommon aspects of an exalted knower the next week. Oh, yeah. I thought you did the.

I wish. Yeah. I guess I was worried that you were bored because you’ve just walked in when they’ve spent, like, three years, and he’s, like, going, oh, poor guy. Probably that would have been like a, that would just made absolutely no sense, and he admires your patience. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. He said, please don’t think that this is the only thing that we do here. So there’s if you come on other nights, and they have different things that aren’t that don’t sound as technical. Yeah.

Yes. Yes. So if anyone has any questions. I’ve got a question. Sure.

Yes? Mhmm. No. That makes sense. Okay.

Yes. Because he’s talking about Shravakas as being Vaibhāṣikas, the lower school of tenets. Yeah. So they are composites of things. So that’s like composites of molecules.

So that’s that’s how they say I understand it. It’s what he’s saying is it the view of inherent existence? Is it different? Yeah. Yeah.

So how is it different? Okay. Is he calling that emptiness? Okay. So I don’t think that Geshe-la would have said that they said that was emptiness, using that word emptiness.

It would have probably been selflessness, which would mean a very easy mistake to make if you’re translating, because they’re very you know, whatever. When it says they understand that things that we perceive are but conglomeration of small things so a hand, for example, is nothing other than a collection of fingers, skin, flesh, etc they say that Everything is made up of smaller components and, therefore, doesn’t have an independent existence. They actually posit the existence of what are called partless particles, which are the smallest building blocks of reality for them, which inherently exist. These partless particles are said to be inherently existent things, and they posit the lack of an existence of a self, so they don’t accept emptiness. That’s why I think that sounds a bit strange.

It’s not emptiness. Yeah? Because you can only have emptiness in a Mahāyāna context. But but usually. But Geshe-la said, but from their in their view, they may say that the lack of self is the emptiness of self, and they can posit the emptiness of self.

That’s their form of emptiness. What they say is that everything is made up of partless particles, and the idea of a self is something that we attach to this conglomeration of partless particles. So that’s why they view different to the Mahāyāna because those partless particles exist. But the Mahāyāna say those particles well, they say those particles exist. Inherently.

Yes. So from the point of view, from the point of view, then they say that those partless particles are inherently existent things, like atoms. They they would say that if they didn’t inherently exist, they would be nonexistent. Partless particles. The smallest particles.

Partless that can’t be divided into smaller bits. Particles can be part have be have parts. So so yeah. So sorry? Echoes.

Is that a science thing that I don’t know? Oh, just echoes because they’re part alright. I get it. So they they actually posit two different things. Right?

There’s this this idea of partless particles, and is the word that they translate as part as particles by itself is the word that is translated as atoms as well. It’s partless atoms, which is another way you could say it. They also posit the idea of partless moments of mind, a moment of the mind stream is partless as well. They say that that that’s an inherently existent thing, that that the self isn’t. So they talk about partless particles and partless moments of mind and say that that’s the building blocks of reality.

So the say that everything is merely labeled and nothing exists from its own side. And he said so the would say that those particles are merely labeled and don’t exist from their own side. These guys say that they are they are not merely labeled. They do exist from their own side. So they’re exactly opposite in a lot of ways, these two views.

The oh, there’s something I to say before I forgot to say, but they’re pressing the these Vaibhāṣikas, the particularist school. They don’t assert this existence of an inherently existent self, therefore they’re considered Buddhist. Yes. The brawlers. Yeah.

Means uninterrupted. Sorry, is interruption. So the uninterrupted path. Now that’s not my translation by the way. So a pachet is an obscuration to Buddhahood.

Anything that obscures your path to Buddhahood is pachet. Right. Okay? So the pachet Monlam is the path that means to get rid of to destroy. Right?

This where it’s not there. So it’s the path where you get rid of the obscuration to Buddhahood. Right. So uninterrupted. I mean, that’s better.

A path getting rid of interruptions. Yeah. But really, it’s tough to do with obstacles. Well, Obstacles. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Barriers. Barriers. Uninterrupted is the wrong word. Yeah. Uninterrupted doesn’t mean Don’t blame me.

Getting rid of Uninterrupted doesn’t mean getting rid of interruption, but I So I said in the English translation, they’ve translated it as nothing comes to interrupt you. To English language, you’re getting rid of the interrupters. Yeah. So it’s the guy who can translate it? Yes.

So you can go and all bash up Jeffrey Hopkins because I think it was probably him. But but it’s just another thing you’d learn the meaning of. Blah. Sorry. Geshe-la said this.

Yes. No. No. No. You.

Geshe-la said that you had a question. He’s like, the new boy’s got a question. Make sure he gets the answer. That’s what he said. Right.

That’s yes. Yes. Okay. Right. Okay.

Because I think what happened because I asked the same question, and he went off on one. And I was like, no. No. That’s not actually the question he’s asking. And then it was weird because the answer he gave was almost the same as what the answer you gave before.

I said, Gangnam, well, I think that’s probably why he got this answer last time because that’s not what he meant. Right? Okay, so if you say, If there’s no self, who thinks? Yeah? And who has it?

He said there’s actually a classic argument about that in an old text, so this is why you got that answer. But what that argument is actually about is if the argument actually says, If there’s no self, who has the idea of no self? That’s what that person answered you was the classic argument from that text. The person that has the idea of no self is the thought itself, but it’s not actually what you are asking. You are asking, Who is the person who thinks?

Yes, exactly. Geshe-la said, Ah, that’s a different question. The reason he would have got that answer last time was because it’s a very old argument from an old text, right? In order to understand a clearer answer to your question, firstly, you have to understand what no self means. No self doesn’t mean that we don’t exist.

No self just means that we don’t exist as an inherently existent, independent, autonomous thing that comes into being without causes and conditions. Yeah? So that self, that kind of self, that inherently existent, independent, solid thing doesn’t exist. That doesn’t mean that we don’t exist as a person. We just don’t exist the way that we think we do.

Right? So the self that is like a concept, that is a functioning thing, that is a concept, is labeled something, that is a combination of causes and conditions coming together and is labeled self, that exists. It doesn’t exist inherently solidly, but it exists. And that self has a mind stream in which thoughts come up. It’s just that none of those thoughts are independent autonomous things that don’t exist of they exist from their own side.

And we ourselves are not an independent autonomous thing that exists from our own side. Right? So what thinks is the merely labeled self, is the self that’s a that’s a coming that’s an idea that we have labeled a coming coming together of thought, body, and everything that we consider ourselves to be I. The concept of self exists. The inherently existent self doesn’t.

So selfless doesn’t mean we cease to exist because we know we exist. Selfless means we don’t exist as an independent autonomous thing that doesn’t need causes and conditions to come into existence. Did that help or confuse it? So we think about ourselves as being this thing, this inherent thing that experiences things. It creates karma, that experiences suffering, that experiences happiness, that reacts to things that happen to us.

We have this idea of ourselves as being this solid thing. But if we go searching for who is this self that experiences suffering, that experiences happiness, that creates karma. We can’t actually find this being, this independent thing. If we look in our body, it’s not our body. If we look in our mind, we can’t find it in our mind.

But there is something that is here, that we are here and we are experiencing. Something. Just because we can’t find ness of us, the thing ness of us, doesn’t mean that we cease to exist completely because we exist as an idea that we have of us. So, that idea that we have of us is the continuum that experiences all these things and thinks. Now do you understand his life?

He said it’s not an easy thing, so it’s something you do have to think about. Did you have another question or is it no? Everyone else okay? Okay. Okay, so he said it’s the same thing that we were talking about before, that there’s like, if you look for ourselves, we can’t find ourselves.

So this is why they say that it’s selfless, yes, so we start grasping at this idea of self. But there is a being that experiences things, yeah, We do experience happiness, we do experience sorrow, we do experience death, and our mental continuum does go on into future lives. The mental continuum keeps going on and creates causes for rebirth because we’ve created the causes for rebirth. Geshe-la said the self that is neither truly existent or non existent, that is not investigated, is the way he put it. So, we investigate, we find something, we can’t find anything, but yet there is a self, right?

So, the uninvestigated self, right? So, the merely labeled self, the because if we look for a try and look for self, we can’t find anything, right? So, he said the uninvestigated self keeps going. The the the So yesterday, I didn’t actually get the question out because I said, how Is it this awareness that goes on to the next life? I got out, Is this awareness?

And then he went, The awareness, the place you’re going, the place you’ve been, the mind, all of these things are just concepts. All right? There are labels that we put onto something. So, everything that we deal with is a label. Alright?

But because it is actually a label, we’ve identified it as something, yeah, then that identification process means that it does exist. It just exists as an identification process. So, Geshe-la said, alright. You gotta think about it. This is what I want you to think about.

Alright? He said, if we go looking for self, alright? If we think, Where is myself? Is myself in my physical body? And we don’t recognise ourselves being in our physical body, and then we start going looking for ourselves in our mind, right?

And we go, Okay, am I my mind? Which moment of my mind am I? And if we come down to it, there is no actual moment of time that is now. Because it’s He wants to try and get himself clear. Okay.

So so if we go investigating for ourselves, we can’t find ourselves. Right? We cease to we can’t find that self. If it’s it can’t be in a moment of consciousness because the moment of now is gone. So where is the self?

It’s not in the mind. It’s not in the body. It’s disappeared. Yeah. That’s something different.

Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Because it’s a different point of view. Brian?

Okay. So so you can’t find it anywhere. Right? But then you’re experiencing something. If you don’t investigate, you do experience something.

Yeah? And Geshe-la said it’s a similar thing to if you watch the news on television. Alright? And George Bush is in the television. Yeah?

And if you took the television apart, you can’t find George Bush. But if you don’t investigate, you can see George Bush. Yeah? And he says, it’s a similar process for for our experience. If we go looking for ourselves, we’re not there.

Yeah? But if we don’t investigate, we are here. We can experience ourselves. So that non investigated self, this bit which is a merely labeled thing, this idea of self, right, is what keeps progressing. So even if we don’t find ourselves, it doesn’t mean that we cease to exist.

In the same way as though even though we can’t find George Bush in the television, it doesn’t mean that he ceases to appear on the television. There’s still an appearance of George Bush. There is still an appearance of us. There’s still an experience of us. Alright?

It’s just that it doesn’t exist in a solid way that we perceive it if we don’t investigate to find it. So because I think that example of fire is something that I’ve heard in a different context. Right? And I say to Geshe-la, have you heard this example of the fire? The fire the fire if you have fire and fire, they dissolve into each other, the similarities completely no, hang on.

One dissolves into another, so there’s like a lack of duality. But the fire still exists even though the original fire didn’t. Yeah, but so I said, he said that view, and Geshe-la said, Have you heard that in his Dzogchen teaching? And he said, Yeah, but that’s a different explanation of emptiness, based on the idea of subtle consciousness and the non duality of the consciousness and the object. So it’s different explanation of it.

So Geshe-la said that usually you understand that first. You realize the idea of the television analogy for emptiness first, and then you realize the idea of the fire thing. So it s like a step by step understanding of emptiness. So if you work on the idea of the television concept, then that would be easier to get your head around for now, and then you develop that understanding later. You say, work on the idea of the television, right?

You experience the television, but you can’t actually find that appearance inside the television, although you keep seeing the television. If you think about it in that way, that you’re labeling it as an experience even though you couldn’t actually find this show inside the television. And if you think about emptiness in that way, that’s a good way to to get used to that idea before in order to develop more other ones. Oh, Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
dzogchen
Literally "Great Perfection", the practice to attain the mind's natural, primordial state. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top