Ornament for Clear Realisations – 15 2004 03 18 OCR

44 min · 3,202 words · 18 March 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 15 2004 03 18 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the four thorough abandonings (the path derived from effort) from the Ornament for Clear Realizations: abandoning arisen non-virtue, preventing non-virtue from arising, generating unarisen virtue, and increasing arisen virtue. It links this to renunciation, bodhicitta, the four close placements of mindfulness and the ten non-virtuous and virtuous actions.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-03-18

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 4382a781-4936-4f8e-ab9f-11f950f4e942

Words: 3,198

It’s motivation and its benefits, so you should all know that now. You should all know what the benefit of developing a good motivation is. If you develop a good motivation for doing something, then the benefits of that become enormous. Perhaps one of the best motivations to develop is to have this idea that whatever you’re doing be conjoined with your rejoicing in the good deeds of all other beings. So those two things combined, may that become a cause for us to achieve complete enlightenment in order to be of benefit to all beings.

So just like us, all sentient beings wish to be happy and don’t wish and wish to be to not have to experience suffering of any of any kind. But, unfortunately, because they are in the mara saṃsāra, they don’t understand what it is that they need to do in order to experience happiness and what it is that they need to do in order to stop experiencing suffering. Because of this ignorance, they are experiencing saṃsāra. What they need to understand is that saṃsāra is actually suffering. In order to do this, they and us need to develop this sense of renunciation that views all things in saṃsāra as suffering.

So we’re in a little we’re having a little bit of an advantage now, though, because we’ve done a little bit of study with and we’ve understood some things from some text, and we’ve been guided through some text. So this means that when we think about renunciation or we think about getting rid of saṃsāra, we have a little bit of an advantage. Now because we know what it means, we have a great idea of what it means. If someone had come up to us and said you have to abandon saṃsāra a while ago before we’d done any study or before we’d had a chance to look at Buddhism in this way, then we would have thought that giving up saṃsāra meant throwing away our house, throwing away our car, throwing away the things that make us happy, and we wouldn’t have really understood what renunciation truly was. So now that we’ve had the opportunity to look at it, we’re in a better place and to understand what it is that we have to actually give up.

So the the thing is that what we’re trying to give up, what we need to abandon in order to attain nirvana is in a is something that’s in our own mind stream. It’s not an external object that we may or may not have. What we need to abandon in order to get out of saṃsāra is our desire for the suffering of change. Because the way we perceive it at the moment, we desire happiness, but because we don’t know what happiness is, we’re actually desiring suffering. That is the suffering of change.

So we need to get rid of this desire, this attachment to the suffering of change because it isn’t actually bringing us happiness, it’s bringing us more suffering. So we know that now. We have an understanding of that. We have an understanding of what it is that we need to give up and what it is that we need to practice in order to attain nirvana. But if someone had told us what it was a while ago, we wouldn’t have understood.

We don’t have to be surprised now. Okay. So in order for us to attain in order for us to attain nirvana, we need to develop renunciation. In order for us to develop renunciation, we need to know what it is that we’re renouncing. So we need to know what the sufferings of saṃsāra is.

And so once we’ve figured this out, once we’ve figured out what the sufferings of saṃsāra is and that we need to renounce those in order to attain true happiness, then we need to look at all other sentient beings and see that all other sentient beings are in the same situation as we are, in that they want to be happy, they don’t want to experience suffering, and they need to know the causes for suffering. So in order for us to be able to show them the causes for suffering, then we need to do to complete the path and become a Buddha. So this mind that we may have developed up into this stage by looking at the sufferings of saṃsāra, realizing that saṃsāra is nothing but suffering, and developing a mind of struggling for liberation or striving for liberation, then this thought can lead us to liberation, but it can’t lead us to anything beyond liberation. So what we need to do then in order to attain complete Buddhahood is develop this enlightened mind or the mind of Bodhicitta. So in order to develop the Bodhicitta, then we need to look at all other sentient beings to see how they are suffering.

So in order for us to achieve this mind where we’re focusing on all sentient beings, we need to give up our own benefits and look to others’ benefit. In order to develop Bodhicitta, we need to switch around so we’re looking at others’ benefits instead of our own benefit. So once we’re looking at others’ benefit instead of our own benefit, then we should think whatever it is that we do, may this be a cause for all sentient beings to become a fully enlightened Buddha. And in order for them to become a fully enlightened Buddha, may I become a fully enlightened Buddha to lead them? Okay.

So this includes the things that we are going to need to abandon in order to become a Buddha. So we should think about everything that we do. May that be a cause for us to become a Buddha to benefit all sentient beings or for all sentient beings to become a Buddha. Tonight, this leads into what we’re talking about tonight, which is called in this summary the path derived from effort, but is actually referring to the four thorough abandonings. And then what the four thorough abandonings means is talking about is the things that we need to get rid of in order to become a Buddha and the things that we need to practice in order to become a Buddha.

When it says thorough, what it’s talking about, it means it means good. Right? So what it means is that there’s there’s certain things that we need to to get rid of in order to become a Buddha, but there’s also things certain things we need to practice in order to become a Buddha. Okay. So these four thorough abandonings are actually different ways of looking at yeah.

From this from this thing, you were on page nine and begin top of page nine. Second division the path derived from effort okay so these four thorough abandonings are that we need to practice which is virtuous create virtue where there is no virtue perpetuate virtue where there is virtue so make it better yeah increase the virtue where there is virtue get rid of negativities where there is negativities and not let negativities that aren’t arise. Right? Now some of these don’t sound like abandoning, but it comes about like if you’re, creating virtues, then you’re abandoning not creating virtues. And if you’re creating more virtues, then you’re abandoning not creating more virtues.

There is a reason, like it says in translation, there is a reason for explaining the path derived from exertion after the path thoroughly comprehending phenomena or the four close placements of mindfulness. This is because after close investigation of the specific and general characteristics of the body, etc, then we are able to perceive what it is that we need to get rid of and what it is that we need to practice in terms of the antidotes to what we need to get rid of. Through close examination, then we’re able to establish what it is we want to do and what it is we don’t want to do, and we’ll have a sense of joyous effort about that process. So when it says in explanation, then this is actually a quote from the commentary that was written to the ornament of clear realization by a man called Haribhadra, who was an Indian pundit. And he said after entering after entering into the full practice of mindfulness, effort arises and we know what it is that we need put exertion into generating and what not to generate in terms of virtue and non virtue.

Right. Right. Sorry about that. Usually, Geshe-la reads it and then goes back and explains it. So if I read it and then explained it, it would get frustrating for you guys.

Right? So I usually wait until he’s explained it, and then he put the translated explanation. And this time, he read it, and I was like, yeah. Yeah. He’ll go back and explain it, and he didn’t.

So I like, what’s going on? You either have to explain it or let me read it out to them. So he went back and explained it. Okay, so in the explanation, right? After entering that, which means practicing the four close placements of mindfulness, Since effort arises from the path derived from exertion generating or not generating non virtue and virtue in order there are four aspects which are correct abandonment.

This means that from this practice then you’re able to perceive what is virtuous and not virtuous and what’s happening in the four things that you’re focusing on in terms of the creation of virtue and the creation of non virtue or the non creation of non virtue. Which leads to four things that need to be abandoned, these four thorough abandonings, are said to be correct sorry, and all of those are said to be joyous effort in the nature of joyous effort in terms of the way that they’re generated. That we have correctly abandoning non virtue which is generated, so we’re already there and not producing non virtue which is not there and increasing virtue which is generated and effort in acting in creating the causes of generating virtue which is not generated. Okay, so the textual meaning is like the way that it’s described in the text. That is the previous explanation.

Means paths derived from exertion or the four thorough abandonings exist because they are correct abandoning producing ungenerated virtuous dharmas. So that is what isn’t generated is generated. What is generated is increased in terms of virtuous things. And what is not generated continues to be not generated in terms of non virtuous things. And what is generated is abandoned in terms of that’s the last two are non virtuous, first two are virtuous.

Okay, so there’s many different things to be abandoned and collected accumulated. There’s said to be many different types of things. There’s things that are virtuous, non virtuous, and neutral. What it’s referring to here is the four specific things that need to be abandoned. So, in order to do this, then we need to develop an understanding of virtue and non virtue.

And that which is non virtuous and hasn’t arisen should be stopped from arising. That which is non virtuous and has arisen should be abandoned. That which is virtuous and has not arisen should be generated. And that which is virtuous and has arisen should be expanded. Now, although this sounds that it’s it’s they’re said to be abandonings with reference to these even though some of them don’t sound like abandonings because they seem to be focused from the negative.

So that is that increasing sorry, generating virtue that is not generated is the abandoning of not generating virtue. All right. So it’s got their double negatives. That’s how they become abandoning. And then the next one, the increasing virtue that is generated is said to be an abandonment of the degradation of virtue.

An abandonment of letting virtue that is created disintegrate. Okay. Okay. It can’t no. Because it’s said to be a path of effort a path derived from effort because through the joyous way that you look at things having focused on the four close placements of mindfulness you will naturally and joyously want to create positivity and get rid of negativity.

The effort is in terms of the effort is not something that needs to be produced in order to get rid of the abandoning things by the effort then things are naturally abandoned. So if you’re happy about doing something because you know what the cause is going to be so then there’s is a joyous effort that’s engaged in there, right? And in engaging in the joyous effort then ungenerated virtuous dharmas are generated and non virtuous dharmas are stopped. Is that okay? It’s just strange because you can use double negatives in Tibetan and in English it just comes out as whack.

Okay. So you can say you abandon the things that could harm You can also say you can abandon the things that could harm the proliferation of positivity or the proliferation of virtue. So that’s another way of looking at it. So the nature of these things then is this joyous effort. And it’s a difficult difficult one is effort because the one the one that’s translated as effort.

Because effort and it has here exertion, which is even scarier. Because in our minds we have this idea of effort and exertion as being something difficult, right? This has nothing to do with difficulty. It’s because the word in Tibetan has two aspects to it. The first one is happiness, a real joy in doing something.

So it’s joyous action. The definition of joyful effort or effort, right, is a mental factor which is by its nature joy. And mental factor which is by its nature joy that goes along with the performing of an action. The joyous activity of getting rid of negativity, of getting rid of that which is negativity which is not generated and stopping that which is not generated and getting rid of that which is generated is two different types of these thorough abandonings, which are by their nature this joyous action or joyous. Joyous effort can work but there’s no grunt in it, There’s no And then on the other side you have the joyous effort that manifests as doing a positive creating positivity or creating a virtue or stopping that virtue which has been created from being harmed or brought down.

So you’re abandoning the bringing down of virtue that’s already there, and you’re stopping that which stops virtue coming about. So to break it down for us, bring it to a level that we can understand, we always focus on the ten non virtuous actions. We should be trying to focus on abandoning the ten non virtuous actions and practicing the ten virtuous actions, which comes about through the abandoning of the ten non virtuous actions. So the way that this would work with that is that getting rid of the ten non virtuous actions is the first abandonment, Then stopping those from coming about, so you’re stopping them from happening is the second abandoning, stopping them from generating abandoning them generating. Then if we’re generating the ten virtuous actions, yeah, then before before they can be generated, they can be things that stop them from being generated.

So we’re abandoning the things that stop them from being generated. Yes. And then once they have generated, there may be things that stop them from getting more and more and more and more and more. Yeah. So abandoning the things that could stop them from getting more and more and more.

Okay. But these things that we’re talking about here, the four thorough abandoning, are not necessarily the same thing as our practice of the abandoning of the ten non virtues. This is because we’re talking about practices that have started to perform on the path of accumulation. How one enters the path of accumulation in the Hīnayāna or on the Hīnayāna vehicle is that you develop a renunciation. After having developed renunciation, then abandoning becomes thorough abandoning.

So at the moment that we’re practicing the abandoning of the ten non virtues, this practicing the abandonment of the ten non virtues actually becomes a cause for us to develop the thorough abandoning, which is what we’re talking about here, the four thorough abandonings. It’s a cause for that. Our efforts in developing the ten virtuous actions and abandoning the ten non virtuous actions become more subtle and more subtle and more subtle. And then having done through this development of the abandoning of the ten non virtuous actions, we develop renunciation. Once we’ve developed renunciation, then our abandoning of the ten non virtuous actions become the four thorough abandoning.

Do you understand? They follow on from it. They don’t arise naturally out of it. They are very easy to develop once you have established the practice of the four mindfulnesses firmly and thoroughly. He said it can be a sign of it because if you really practice the four place four close placements of mindfulness properly, then this getting rid of negative actions will come about very easily or come about from that.

Yes. So it can be a sign of that. Yes. But it doesn’t happen spontaneously. It needs to be meditated on.

But so through through familiarization or meditation, you become an expert in it. And I have no idea why that was funny. Right. So then we go through the definitive analysis of this second division, is the four thorough abandonings. So it’s the same as the full close placements of mindfulness.

We have the object that is the focus of the practice or the meditation, the method, the need for this, the nature of it, the classifications or the divisions of it, where it exists, the border or the range, the etymology of the expression, why the great vehicle correct abandoners are supreme. So the first of these focal object, the first exist because focal objects The first it’s weird. The first exists because the focal objects are the four. What that means is there are four focal objects. That is a generated or an already generated virtue or pristine virtue, ungenerated pristine virtue, and afflictive non virtue and ungenerated afflictive non virtue.

So this means that through the joyous effort, the happy effort that comes about, then these things need to have a focus for the effort. There has to be a thing that’s being done. Because there is a thing that’s being done then that means that there is a focus or a focal object for the practice for this joyous effort. The first focal object for joyous effort is generating ungenerated pristine virtue. The second focus of the effort is to keep what is generated and improve it and then to stop coming afflictive sorry.

Afflictive non virtue coming about, and then to get rid of afflictive non virtue that is already there.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
ten virtuous actions gewa chu (Tib)
Actions of body, speech and mind which are the opposite of the ten nonvirtuous actions, therefore, one refrains from killing, speaks the truth and so forth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top