45 min · 3,945 words · 29 July 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk continues the study of chapter four of Maitreya’s Ornament for Clear Realisations, explaining the absorption of cessation according to the Svatantrika school. It covers who can develop it, the ground and path it rests on, its purpose for Hinayana and Mahayana practitioners, and its nature as an uncontaminated, acquired phenomenon. It then turns to the realms where it is developed and to the four paths of abandonment in relation to the Four Noble Truths.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-07-29
Duration: 45 min
UUID: ca455a45-6ee2-4d33-aad4-24d5523386ed
Words: 3,941
I wish I could say it at the same speed that he just said that. I said, should I say it that fast as well? He said, no. You try and say it slowly so they understand. Okay.
So in the seven points of mind training it says develop it’s one thing at the beginning and one thing in the end and what this is referring to is that we should have the right motivation when we start to do anything virtuous and we should end anything we do with the right dedication. Now the best motivation we can have for doing anything to do with the Buddhist Dharma is the motivation of the Bodhicitta the wish to attain enlightenment in order to establish all sentient beings in a state beyond sorrow as fully enlightened Buddhas. Now, this wish is what we really need to develop or the motivation that we should have for listening this evening to teachings on the fourth chapter of Maitreya’s Ornament of Realization we should think am listening to this in order to be able to understand it in order to eventually be able to put into practice to become a Buddha so may this positive action listening to teachings on this profound text be mixed with all of the positive the merit from all of the positive actions done by the five types of beings and become a cause for me to become a fully enlightened Buddha so I can benefit all sentient beings.
So please have this motivation for listening to these teachings. The kind of teachings that we are listening to this evening and the texts that we are studying this evening are all what’s called a part of Mahāyāna Buddhism. Mahāyāna meaning the greater vehicle, the altruistic vehicle, the vehicle whose motivation is to liberate all sentient beings, not just a single individual. So, the text that we are studying is a Mahāyāna text and because we’re trying to incorporate Mahāyāna Buddhism into incorporate an understanding of Mahāyāna Buddhism then we should try and make our motivation something which accords with Mahāyāna Buddhism. Now, something becomes Mahāyāna or greater vehicle or altruistic if an action becomes altruistic if its motivation is to benefit all sentient beings.
We should try and develop the motivation. May me listening to these teachings, developing an understanding of these teachings be a cause for me to be able to benefit all sentient beings. So we’ve been talking about what’s called the absorption of cessation and from the point of view of the autonomous school, the absorption of cessation is a non associated compositional factor which acts as a tool to cut away attachment to even the subtlest kinds of minds. Now, when we’re looking at this, we’ve already talked about the types of beings that have it but in the next section, which describes — the next section is divided into sections which describe more precisely what the absorption of cessation is from the point of view of this autonomous The first thing is that it describes what kind of being is able to develop the absorption of cessation. That’s the first thing.
The second is on what ground is this cessation developed. So, the absorption of cessation itself isn’t a mind but it has to have the basis of a mind in order for it to exist. It has to have a mind from which it can be developed in order for it to exist. Then also there is what kind of path is its basis and then also what does the mind do? What is the purpose of developing the absorption of cessation?
What is actually ceased? Says absorption of cessation, so what is actually ceased is the next description. What is the nature of this analysis, the absorption of cessation? What time is it developed? At what time and for how long?
And also in which realms is it developed. This is the way that the absorption of cessation according to the Svatāntrika school is expanded, the explanation is expanded on through these topics. So, it actually says that the first three of these, the type of being that develops this type of cessation, the ground on which it is developed and the ‘path’ on which is developed, it says it’s explained earlier so this is what we did last week and this refers to the fact that the only beings who can develop this absorption of cessation that are the never returners who are going to become arhats with the two understandings, that is the absorption of cessation and nirvana, and then arhats that have become arhats with the two understandings, that is arhats that have achieved nirvana and the absorption of cessation and then also Mahāyāna aryas have it as well, so Bodhisattva aryas also have this absorption of cessation. There’s only three different types of beings that have this absorption of cessation. So the next thing was the type of ground or the kind of base that is developed upon, and this is the mind that is the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence and that’s the base from which is developed and then also the on which is developed the type of path on which is developed is said to be a trans mundane or non worldly path.
It can’t be developed based on worldly types of mind, so one has to at least have achieved renunciation in order to develop this understanding. Okay, this is where I stuffed up last week. There’s two different types of paths only, right? There’s a path, a worldly path, and an unworldly path, or a transmundane path, right? So, the type of path that you can develop this mind on is a transmundane path.
It doesn’t mean you can develop it on all types of transmundane paths, yeah? Because you have to have actually become one of those three things we talked about before. But you can only divide paths into two types, transmundane and mundane. Then therefore it says on transmundane paths you can do it, but not all the transmundane paths. That make sense?
Sorted? Yeah. Good. Because I made a mistake with that last week and got myself confused probably. That is.
Now, the fourth division in the extended explanation of the absorption of cessation for the Svatāntrika school is what’s called what the mind does or why the mind develops this absorption of cessation. This is described in two parts: is why someone on the Hīnayāna path would develop the absorption of cessation and why someone on the Mahāyāna path would develop the absorption of cessation. Now, on the Hīnayāna path developed the absorption of cessation through seeing that from gross feelings of suffering attachment and equanimity that this is what can cause act as a cause for suffering discomfort and all other types of feelings so Hīnayāna practitioners are searching for their personal nirvana and in order to achieve that personal nirvana then they may develop this absorption of cessation. They strive for personal nirvana in a similar way to the way that we strive to get rid of illness. Whether the illness is aching pain or a kind of skin infection or an infectious disease or skin on the outside, pain on the inside and that’s the main three ones, an infectious disease.
So the same way that we can see that these things are negative and we would strive to get rid of them, beings striving for personal nirvana on the Hīnayāna path are working towards the extinguishing of gross experiences of attachment and aversion in order to develop the peace of nirvana. Now as they go about doing this job they may realize that the absorption of cessation is a useful tool to bring this about. They don’t necessarily have to, but they can. So they are striving for nirvana to get rid of all suffering and they may see that absorption of cessation is a useful tool in order to bring this about. Therefore, they work on developing it with that motivation of getting rid of all the illnesses and suffering that they may have being caused by gross feelings or gross attachment to aversion attachment to pleasure and aversion from pain and so they’re trying to get rid of those kind of neurosis like the ones we have all the time thinking I want this, I don’t want this, I want this and I don’t want that and the same way that we’re trying to experience getting rid of we experience trying to get rid of suffering and they may use this absorption of cessation in order to bring about that goal So it’s as Asaṇga said in his Compendium of Ascertainments in order to bring about this complete cessation they need to have before doing this they need to have completely controlled the minds in order to do that, they may develop the absorption of cessation.
Whereas those on the path of Mahāyāna don’t develop the absorption of cessation for their own benefit. The only reason they ever develop the absorption of cessation is to be of benefit to others because of their great compassion and their great loving kindness. They wouldn’t ever do anything in order to make themselves happier or more comfortable because everything they do is motivated by benefiting others. Now, they do search, however, for this what’s called the most refined experience of meditative concentration, which is this absorption of cessation. They do search for this and try to attain this but they do it in order to be able to benefit others and show them in an unmistaken way what they need in order to cease experiencing suffering.
So, what these beings on the Mahāyāna path do is they develop these subtle levels of concentration that is all the different absorptions of the form and formless realms in order to be able to use those different levels of meditative concentration to develop along the path, to develop insight into wisdom and so forth and develop their compassion in order to be of benefit to sentient beings. Absorption of cessation. This depends on which level of realization people are dealing with or which level of concentration they’re dealing with. If someone is using the absorption of cessation in the desire realm then what they will be ceasing desisting from is the development of the six gross consciousnesses because they are the main focus for the beings in the desire realm. If a being has developed the form realm levels of concentration then they will use the absorption of cessation to get rid of the four gross levels of mind that are associated with the form realms.
So that is the gross levels of mind associated with the first, second, third and fourth concentrations. They will try and develop through these subtle levels of mental concentration getting rid of the more grosser one that is below it, so from the first to the second to the third to the fourth with the fourth being the most subtle level of concentration. Beings who have developed the formless realm level of meditative concentration only have one thing to get rid of and this is their attachment to the gross aspect of the formless realm. What different senses that are associated with the four concentration realms of the form realm. With each one of these then you get rid of one kind of consciousness, kind of growth consciousness.
In the desire realm, therefore, we have six consciousnesses. We have the five senses and a mental consciousness. In the form realm, you don’t have any smell or taste, There is a subtle form that you’re existing in the level of mind that your mental concentration does experience form in terms of vision and touch and so forth but not in terms of taste and smell. So, with the different levels of concentration, you’re dealing with or with a different sense that you’re getting rid of. Then, in the formless realm, because there’s only consciousness and there is none of the there is only mental consciousness, there’s none of the other types of consciousness, then the only thing that you need to get rid of is the gross mental consciousness.
The next thing that we look at then is the nature of the absorption of cessation. The first thing to define the nature of the absorption of cessation is to say whether it is a contaminated or an uncontaminated phenomenon. Out of these two are said to be an uncontaminated phenomenon. So, in Asaṇga’s Collected Topics, he says that the reason it is a non contaminated phenomenon is because it is the opposite or the thing that gets rid of afflictive emotions. Absorption of cessation allows us to get rid of neurosis or afflictive emotions or kleshas.
Therefore, because it’s something that’s an antidote to kleshas, we can’t say that it’s contaminated and it has to be uncontaminated. The next thing that we need to define it as is either a substantially existent thing or a labelled thing or an implied thing so from amongst these is said to be an implied thing because from the Svatāntrika point of view you can have things that are defined by their characteristics and things defined by their characteristics the things themselves the labels that we put on them are not the things themselves they are label that we’re dealing with and as this absorption of cessation isn’t something that exists apart from a label because it’s a negative, it’s the lack of something then it’s said to be a not a substantially existent thing but a label thing or a conceptual thing That’s the wrong word because it’s not a concept. How do say that? I’m trying to remember the word for what this phenomena is, and I’m having a mental blank that there was two types of things that needed to be gotten rid of on the different paths. Some of them were naturally existent, and others were something else.
Do you remember that? Acquired. That’s the word I was looking for. Thank you. Okay.
So so there’s like, Sorry. So, this is what it’s called. It’s called substantial phenomena and acquired phenomena. So, it’s a phenomena that you label something, so therefore that’s how it exists as a label as an identity thing yeah so it’s acquired phenomena thank you alright so from amongst substantial phenomena and acquired phenomena this absorption of cessation is an acquired phenomena alright then from amongst non virtuous, virtuous and neutral actions this is a virtuous action and a virtuous object. The reason it’s a virtuous object is because it’s developed through a virtuous motivation.
Things become positive or virtuous or, helpful, depending on the motivation they’re done with, not necessarily on the action themselves. But the only way you can develop the absorption of cessation is through a positive motivation, so therefore the itself becomes positive. The seventh part of the description of the absorption of cessation is the amount of time that beings with this realization engage in the absorption of cessation. Beings on the Hīnayāna path, on the of the lower vehicle who are searching for individual liberation, then this absorption of cessation is engaged in for as long as they want. As long as it will be beneficial to them, they engage in this absorption of cessation.
Bodhisattvas, however, it says they do not indulge in the extreme of time with regards to the absorption of cessation. So they don’t spend a lot of time in the absorption of cessation unless it’s benefiting others. This doesn’t necessarily mean that they always have to abide in this absorption of cessation for short amounts of time however because sometimes abiding in the absorption of cessation can be beneficial to the students of Bodhisattvas so therefore they’ll do it. For example there was a Bodhisattva called Dharmodgata Yeah? Who had a student called he who always cries.
Right? So so I was like, guess what does that mean? He goes, he’s crying all the time. He’s like, yeah. But is there not like I’m looking for Sanskrit word that makes that sound nice, but no.
So there was a Dharmodgata and he has a student called Sadāprarudita, right? And dhamma aarya was trying to impress upon He Who Always Cries the profundity and rareness of the perfect Dhamma how vast it was and how rare it was to get teachings on this so in order to impress this fact upon him, he actually went into the absorption of cessation for seven years until the crying a lot person actually developed an understanding of how vast and profound and rare the Dharma actually is so if you’d actually taught him at the start without making him wait for seven years and watching his teacher in this meditative absorption for seven years then he wouldn’t have got it he wouldn’t have understood how profound it was but actually being with his teacher while his teacher was in his absorbed state meant that he eventually developed an understanding of how profound his teaching was and how he needed to develop it now the reason that his name was cries a lot was because he was always crying about the state of beings so he was actually a bodhisattva himself his teacher was a bodhisattva and he was a bodhisattva and cried a lot because he kept seeing being suffering so that’s how he got his name.
But he needed to develop this absorption of cessation and in order to do that his teacher went into samadhi for seven years before he gave it to him. This isn’t the normal situation, however. Most of the time, bodhisattvas don’t spend seven years in the absorption of cessation unless there’s a really big reason for it. This teacher was trying to develop an understanding in his student’s mind stream and so because of exceptional circumstances he spent seven years in the absorption of cessation. But usually, Bodhisattvas don’t need to spend more than about seven days in this meditative absorption.
They’re able to fulfill the purpose of their meditation within this time. Now, don’t go off spending years and years in this absorption mainly because they are motivated primarily by helping sentient beings and they’re not gonna help sentient beings if they are in samadhi necessarily. So, they constantly trying to help beings and they may Geshe-la said if they spend all their time in meditative equipoise, they are going to run out of time. There is not going be enough time to help beings so bodhisattva is being motivated by helping beings aren’t going to spend more than about seven days in meditative equipoise at a time unless, like we said earlier, there’s exceptional circumstances absorption of cessation from the Svatāntrika’s point of view in detail is the type of realms that these developed in. So the last one is the realms that this absorption of cessation is developed in.
Now, it’s actually developed in all three realms: the Desire Realm, the Form Realm and the Formless Realm. Now, in the Desire Realm, it’s developed in order to cut through the six consciousnesses, gross forms of the six consciousnesses, the five sense consciousness and the mental consciousness. The form realm, it’s developed in order to get cut through the four consciousnesses that are left there, that is the six consciousnesses minus taste and smell and in the Formless Realm it’s used to cut through gross forms of mental consciousness because that’s all that exists in the formless realm. Now, in the desire realm we have Bodhisattvas, Ārya Bodhisattvas and Never Returners and Stream Enterers which are the Hīnayāna practitioners and also arhats who have developed both wisdoms which is the wisdom of nirvana and the wisdom of cessation. In the four concentrations of the form realm there are Ārya Bodhisattvas and there are also never returners who have developed this absorption of cessation and arhats.
In the formless realm there are no Bodhisattvas and therefore the only beings there are the never returners who have developed absorption of cessation and the arhats who have absorption of cessation. And that is the end of the nine supramundane paths. Taken five So the next one is the four paths of abandonment. Now the four paths of abandonment are basically the realizations of uninterrupted paths on the path of seeing. On the path of seeing you realize the truth, the four noble truths, the emptiness of the four noble truths, the emptiness of the truth of suffering, the origins of suffering, the path and cessation.
Now, with all of these four realizations comes two aspects one that’s called an uninterrupted path and the other that’s called a path of release. The uninterrupted paths are also called Dharma forbearances and so this means that the four paths of abandonment refer to the four noble truths. So one path of abandonment is the uninterrupted path concentrating an uninterrupted path which is a Dharma forbearance focusing on the emptiness of the truth of suffering right and the next one is an uninterrupted path which is Dharma forbearance focusing on the emptiness of the truth of the origin of suffering, and so forth. Sorry, I forgot to say something. With every uninterrupted path, that is followed by what’s called a path of release, like an understanding of that.
There is the forbearance which is the uninterrupted path and at the end of that comes the path of release which is said to be a Dharma jnana as opposed to a dhamma forbearance. So, it goes one backwards, forwards, backwards, forwards, backwards, forwards between these four things with relation to the four truths four noble truths So these things that are being abandoned here, what they’re talking about is the process by which being on the path of seeing gets rid of their holding on to the concept of the truth. Oh. And so I’m now lost. Okay.
I have my train of thought and then I got lost. Alright. So, on the path of seeing, when one realizes the emptiness lack of inherent existence of phenomena as a Mahāyānist or the selflessness of the person as a Hinayanist then that realization is called a the process of that realization is called a forbearance and the actual realization of that is called a subsequent jnana, which is the path of release. So, you develop the understanding on the uninterrupted path and it’s completed on the path of release. So this relates to things that need to be abandoned on the path of seeing.
Now the things that are abandoned on the path of seeing are what’s called acquired concepts. Acquired concepts are obscurations to liberation and this works for both the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna path it’s just that the object is being focused on is different so if you’re on a Hīnayāna and you are focusing on the selflessness of the person then at the path of seeing you actually get rid of your acquired concepts which are like formulas, not spontaneous but acquired or conceptual, with regards to the selflessness of the person, alright? So, the Four Noble Truths was relation to the selflessness of the person if you’re doing this on the Mahāyāna path then your focus is emptiness of the Four Noble Truths. Right? So one of them on the Hīnayāna is the selflessness of the person in relation to the Four Noble Truths, and on the Mahāyāna is emptiness of Four Noble Truths.
And you
Key terms in this teaching
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.