45 min · 2,638 words · 22 July 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a commentary on the absorption of cessation from the Sautrantika view, covering who can develop it, its definition as a non-associated compositional factor, and its divisions and boundaries. Student questions then clarify compositional factors and the difference between seeds and impotent imprints.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-07-22
Duration: 45 min
UUID: c22c81a7-a93e-4ee0-80f8-575be16fb6c5
Words: 2,634
At this house, Okay. So the other thing is that this is talking about the first stage that people can develop this absorption of cessation from the point of view of the Sautrantikas. So it’s the first moment of the path of seeing if they have been through the Hīnayāna path to start off with, then the second moment if they haven’t. But that doesn’t necessarily when they’re going to develop it. It’s not something that is definitely developed in the first couple of moments of path of seeing.
There are also beings that develop this absorption of cessation on the first ground, third ground, fourth ground, anytime up until the ninth ground. But on the ninth ground everyone has it. This one? Mm-mm. Okay.
So the type of rebirth that you need to be in in order to develop this absorption and cessation. Most of the texts say that you need to be a human, most of them. Which one is the first one? The Abhidharma says, in order to develop the absorption of cessation, you need to be a human. And then in the collected topics of Ngawang Palden, it says this realization is developed amongst humans.
But this isn’t something that necessarily pervades. It’s not like only humans are able to develop this realization because in other instances there is given examples of people who have developed this realization where they were amongst the three continents it says, there is gods in the. There’s desire realm gods in what’s called the six Okay. So this is this is said to be the six realm six levels of the god realms, and one of these is called the higher Brahma realm. And then within the higher Brahmin realm there has been known people who have developed this.
And also in the twenty-five meditative absorptions of the the form realm, there are sixteen that you can develop here. Okay? So then and that’s the end of this if you remember way back, we were going through the different level like, different outline of text, and there was a description of the base on which you develop the absorption of cessation, and then there was actually going to be an explanation of the nature of the absorption of cessation. So we’re up to number two, description of the nature of the absorption of cessation. This has one, two, three, four parts.
The first of which is the definition, second of which is the divisions, the third of which is the boundaries, and the fourth of which is the presentation of explanation presenting the way the absorption of cessation abides or is. So the first thing is the definition of the absorption of cessation from the point of view of the Sautrāntika. This is that it is a non associated compositional factor. That is an absorption in the continuum of the superior, Abiding in a type. Now when I say abiding in a type, it means one is just like that’s the you know what it means.
Yeah. The way yeah. But it’s like in the group that includes. Yeah? Includes non associated factors distinguished by the cessation of the coarse objects to be stopped along with the accompaniments on the subtle mental consciousness, the basis of the cessation.
Tell me this one. So there’s no, like, coarse objects coming into the mind because they’ve been stopped. When there there’s no coarse objects coming to mind because the coarse objects have been stopped, the cessation of those coarse objects is absorption cessation. I’m just looking So, yeah, in Tibetan, it works from the other way around. So it says that it’s a it’s the basis for this cessation.
Right? The basis for this cessation is a mind which has gotten rid of the gross things that may come into the mind, in dependence on a very subtle mind. And having gotten rid of these gross things that may disturb the mind, subtle cessation of anything disturbing the mind. That lack of something can’t be a mind. It has to be a non associated compositional factor.
And then this kind of lack of disturbance, the cessation, absorption of cessation, can only abide in the continuum of superiors or aryas and it’s a non associated compositional factor. So the first division that we have is the hearer, we’re going through the different types of divisions now. The first one is divisions on the basis or the divisions by basis. So this is referring to the vehicles and you can have an absorption of cessation in the continuum of a being who is on the Mahāyāna path, an absorption of cessation in the continuum of a being that is on the solitary realizer path and one that is also on the hearer path. So then there’s also two different types of absorption of cessation depending on the type of the way that people are progressing along the path.
So, this is said to be a division based on the nature of cessation. Now, the two different types of nature that we’re talking about here are those people who progress sequentially along the path, that is that they go through the five paths of the ten grounds in a sequential order. And then there’s those who are called leapers. Right? So they may go to one bit and then jump over a few and go to the next bit.
So for example, go to the path of seeing, have the realization of the path of seeing, skip the second and third grounds and land on the fourth. Right? Leapers. There’s also three ways that we can divide this, depending on which on the results of the absorption of cessation manifest. You can divide it into three ways.
Now, the results of the absorption of cessation can manifest in one lifetime, they can be using the absorption of cessation to get rid of a certain thing to be abandoned in one lifetime. They and then experience results of that in one lifetime it can happen in another lifetime and it can also happen it can also not happen it can also be not definite so you can be using the absorption of cessation to abandon and then be in different situations and not need to abandon it. So all three of these can these three different ways of doing it can be another way for us to differentiate between the different types of absorption of cessation. The borders of this absorption of cessation according to the Sautrāntika system is that it goes from the stage of a never returner up until the ground of a Buddha. Now, never returned with someone who has achieved the path of seeing on the Hīnayāna path.
He said he said I said they said they’re tired, and he said, then they don’t then it’s difficult to understand. And I said, so because they’re tired, they can’t understand or because they’re not able to understand makes them tired? And Geshe-la said, being not able to understand because it’s difficult makes you tired. It’s not associated to either form or mind. Form or mind.
So it’s anything that’s not form or mind. Physical form or mind? Because it becomes about in dependence on a cause. Compounded phenomena is a lot phenomena. It comes into it comes into being in dependence upon a cause.
What did you say? No. Discrimination is, but not compositional factors. Coming come it’s you’re talking about common formations. Yeah.
Yeah. And then Yeah. That’s one of the No. Five aggregates. Yeah.
It’s one of five aggregates, but it’s not all minds. But the performance is full. Yeah. No. He was just saying, what’s he talking about?
Because I tried to say that. He said, how how do you come up with that? So in the composition of factors one or the karmic formations or whatever you wanna call it, there’s things that aren’t mind. So all non-associated compositional factors are included within that that section of the five aggregates. Okay.
So within the composition of factors of karmic formations, there’s mental factors and non associated composition of thingies. I can say things. Yeah. So there’s lots of things in there that aren’t associated with the mind, that are not not associated, that aren’t the same thing as the mind in their compositional factors or karmic formations or whatever, like time as it relates to the being and the cessation of something which isn’t a mind it’s a cessation and also the being the merely labeled being is in a mind it’s a non associated compositional factor. He’s just guessing so there’s lots in there that aren’t mind in that one.
Yeah. So I said is the is the compositional factors in there or the karmic formations of Western, that the kind of miscellaneous section of some of our aggregates? And you said, yes. Things that are mental factors. Yeah.
So, yeah, mental factors and non associated factors. That’s why it’s usually called compositional factors. Okay. Okay? Yeah.
It’s okay? Really? Joe? Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. You’re going like this. That aggregate is using is often called compositional factors. Mhmm. They’re not associated with It’s not yeah.
Yeah. So But that doesn’t translate. So if you have non associated compositional factors that doesn’t include the mental factors that are compositional factors. Okay. So I was trying to find an example of a a mental factor that was in the compositional factors as opposed to the others.
Right? And I asked him if memory was. It’s funny. I kept trying to get an example. He goes, it’s everything that’s not this.
And I’m like, yes. But what is it? It’s everything that’s not this, but what is it? Okay. Right.
This is we have an example of mental factors which are compositional factors. For example, sleep is a mental factor, which is a compositional factor it’s not neither discrimination or feeling it’s a state it’s an element of mind and it’s a compositional factor also some aspects of memory depending on what you’ve remembered if you remember a color then no if you remember a feeling then no but if you remember something then it can be a compositional factor also recognizing things discriminating about them but recognizing them so this is that is a compositional factor yeah this is a red or this is black or this is good or this is bad no right but this is that is a compositional factor Mental mental factor is a compositional factor. And they said to go back to go through them all these heaps. Yeah. Both of them are nonassociated compositional factors.
They’re not minds. But when you say both of them, what’s the Sorry. There’s two elements to the karma that you travel on into. Sorry. I had and I I couldn’t actually say it in one thing in Tibetan, so I just split it into the two.
Right? And then we said both of them are. And then then I knew you didn’t ask for two because but I couldn’t say it as one. Anyway, you have the the seeds of karmic actions and also you have imprints. Oh.
That’s a different they’re different things. Yeah. Yeah. So both of those, the karma that we carry along, but they don’t They’re non associated. Compositional factors.
They’re not minds, and they’re not form. Okay. Then neither mind nor form. And I said, are they an object or a subject? Geshe-la said neither and I said but I thought all phenomena could be divided into subjects and objects and he said only when they manifest it’s a potential so it’s not a manifest thing so therefore it’s not it’s not an object or a mind.
It’s a potential or a habit towards something. It’s not like an impression. It’s a footprint in the sand. It’s not like It’s in the sand, but it’s not the sand itself. It’s there.
It’s an impression. Right. Okay. Yeah. He said similar to that because it’s leaving a it’s leaving a a habit or something in the mind, but it’s not the mind.
So the same as this the the way you stamp your foot leaves an imprint in the sand, but it’s not sand. So he’s always said it’s also the the same idea as if you keep drinking tea in a cup. When you finish the tea, can still smell it, but there’s no tea there. But you can still smell the tea, so it’s the same sort of thing in your mind. You can’t see anything.
And there’s no substance there, but you can still smell it. He said exactly the same because if you don’t have mind, you don’t have influence. Okay. So is a imprint. A footprint is an object, and so is an imprint.
They’re both. It’s just that one of them has been impressed into a physical form, and the other one is impressed into mind. Sorry? Geshe-la thinks I was tripping, and I didn’t understand him properly. Okay.
He said that they’re not objects for us. Right? But they’re objects for Buddhas. Okay? So and he said, there is no objects there is no phenomena that are neither objects or subjects.
And I said, that’s what I said. And you said, this was that that these weren’t objects or subjects. And then they went, not objects or subjects for us, but they’re objects or they’re objects for Buddhas. And and then I said, but you said that they weren’t objects or subjects for us. Right?
And then he said, you can’t have a phenomenon that is an object or subject, and I must have been dreaming. And so he’s now saying, no. Nothing is everything is an object or a subject. You can’t, which is what I thought I said. But anyway, that he was talking about from our perspective, not So if something can be validly established, then it is an object, and all phenomena can be validly established, otherwise they are nonexistence.
And because Buddhists can validly establish karmic imprints, then there are they are phenomena. Right? So they are phenomena, but they are not form or mind. Okay this yeah does that make sense because there’s non associated compositional factors now the other thing was that there’s two different types of imprint there’s what’s called seeds and what’s called impotent imprints. So impotent imprints are contained in the mind stream but do not have the ability to ripen into anything and seeds which are a type of imprint but they’re not necessarily the same thing, yeah, have the ability to ripen into something.
Example, if someone has the imprint of desire and they haven’t seen the nature of emptiness, then that imprint of desire when they’re put into a situation where the object of their desire is in front of them will have the mind of desire come up right but if they perceive the nature of true nature of reality and that all things are empty when they’re put into that situation they may have the imprint of desire but they don’t it doesn’t manifest Okay. So not if it’s a not a seed. A seed is a potential. But an imprint that is not a seed is not a potential. Okay.
So if, for example, Okay. So I’m trying to remember all that now because I was just trying to make myself understand. Because I kept saying, so what does it do? What does it do? So, for example, if we have committed a karmically negative like we kill someone right now the karmic result killing someone is to go to hell right of the direct action yeah if you purify that action and that is
Key terms in this teaching
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.