45 min · 2,953 words · 22 July 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This session continues a commentary on the absorption of cessation, covering the Prasangika definition, including its common and unique forms, and the Svatantrika view of the bodily and mental bases needed to develop it. It explains that the absorption requires calm abiding at the peak of cyclic existence and special insight, and that it is attained from the sixth ground or the second moment of the path of seeing, with supporting quotations from the sutras and Nagarjuna.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-07-22
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 3b44c433-77a2-4a71-98b3-db516c24ccc3
Words: 2,949
And Geshe-la said, we want to develop the right motivation for listening to the teachings. So That means thinking that you are listening in order to develop understanding, especially in this case of the absorption of cessation. By listening to the absorption of cessation, teachings on the absorption of cessation, May that be a cause for developing the absorption of cessation and through meditating with the ability of the absorption of cessation may become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. So that should be the proper motivation for listening to the teachings. So we’re up to the consequentialists, the Prāsaṇgika view of the absorption of cessation.
And so the first thing that we need to deal with from that is the definition. Definition of an absorption of cessation in the Prāsaṇgika School is an exalted wisdom of single pointed meditative equipoise on emptiness, reality, the dharmata there is emptiness that abides in a type free from attachment to the peak of cyclic existence. So that just means it is a type. The type of mind that it is is that it’s free from the peak of cyclic existence. And then it depends on a mind which is a super mundane path.
Super mundane path is any level of mind above renunciation, yeah, and which attains it and acts as the actual mind of the peak of cyclic existence. So peak of cyclic existence being free from attachment to cyclic existence acts as a base for this development of the absorption of cessation. So this definition that we just went through is what’s called the common definition from the prasangikas. So it’s this consciousness, which is by nature the peak of saṃsāra but is actually beyond attachment to the peak of saṃsāra and is therefore able to be used in order to perceive emptiness directly, right? Got that?
Good. Now, I was just making sure because then it goes on and we have the definition of the absorption of cessation in the prasangika in what’s called its unique form. So that was its general form which it has a lot in common with the other schools. This is what it’s called its unique form. It doesn’t make sense to me.
Hang on, I’ve got to ask another question, sorry. This is why I’m getting confused and I went over it and I went over over just ended up having this major discussion with Geshe-la about it too and understand it. Okay. I’m just gonna I don’t understand. Okay.
Yep. Yeah. Yeah. Right. Yep.
Anyway, it’s because it’s and I don’t have the imprints. Okay. So there’s a but that is what’s called the common or the ordinary definition according to the. Alright? This definition that you’ve got in the notes here and then there’s also what’s called an uncommon or a unique definition for the prasangikas and this is that an absorption of cessation is a wisdom that is an absorption of cessation that perceives emptiness or dharmata directly which is particularly relevant to the higher practice of the six perfections.
That means that it’s practice. It’s a Mahāyāna mind. Can only be achieved on the level of the level of the Mahāyāna after having developed Bodhicitta and practicing the practices of the bodhisattva, right? So on the one hand, have a common definition that includes it says the super mundane path which is both all three vehicles. Yeah?
And on the other hand, you have a definition that only includes the Mahāyāna. And how that can be? I don’t understand, but I’m just translating. I tried to understand it so I could make sense when I was translating, but can’t. Okay.
So guess the guys, I just thought of an easy way to explain it, he said, I don’t know if this is right but it makes sense and it’s easier than trying to figure out another way of it working. He said that in that case, you can have an uncommon definition and a common definition, right? The uncommon and the unique definition which is the one that revolves around the six practices, six perfections could be a Mahāyāna definition and the other one can be all vehicles definition. The unique aspect isn’t the Prāsaṇgika uniqueness, it’s the Mahāyāna s uniqueness. Does that make sense?
Okay, good. Because up until that point I was like, what? He said if you put if you pause it, this saying one’s unique and one’s not unique, from that point of view, it makes sense and it’s easy to understand. So we’ll do it from there. Then there’s some quotes within the discussion from that Prāsaṇgika point of view of this absorption of cessation.
The first one comes from the Buddha’s Sūtra, the Ten Grounds or the Daśabhūmika Sūtra, Daśabhūmika Sūtra. And it says, hey or oh or whatever, you know, devocative particle. The sons of conquerors or bodhisattvas. Bodhisattvas, the sixth ground upwards to Buddhahood, have the absorption of cessation. Only from the sixth ground up.
So on the fifth ground, don’t have it. Fourth ground, you don’t have it. So it’s only from the sixth ground up that you have the absorption of cessation. So in the Precious Garland teachings, Precious Garland by Nāgārjuna, he says the achievement of the cessation of absorption of cessation when it ripens acts as a cause or becomes Buddhahood. So what this means is that by achieving the absorption of cessation you’re able to achieve Buddhahood.
Alright, Larry. So in the also in the So then in the entry to the middle way by Candrakīrti, It says, Having wisdom or abiding in wisdom, which is the wisdom realizing emptiness, leads to cessation. And this is talking about either the cessation of absorption of cessation that we re talking about here but it can also it s like a pun and it can also mean the cessation of obscurations which is Buddhahood. So it s like a way of saying that they re both the same thing. I guess that s confusing so let s just say meditating on emptiness helps you develop helps you develop the absorption of cessation.
Forget the pun. Right. So that’s almost the end of the description of the absorption of cessation from the point of view of the Prāsaṇgika. Now the Prāsaṇgika School don’t posit different understandings of emptiness. Their idea of emptiness is the merely labeled object.
There is like no inherently existent thing and no nothing that you can define by characteristics. So What this means is that they say the arhats, whether they be solitary realizers or hearers, actually develop an understanding of emptiness, not an understanding of selflessness or an understanding of the nondual nature of subject and object. When the Buddha that bodhisattvas don’t achieve this absorption of cessation until they’ve reached the sixth Bhumi or the sixth ground, that is only referring to bodhisattvas because people who are arhats and have completed the path because they have an understanding of emptiness from the Prāsaṇgika point of view have developed this absorption of cessation. Does that make sense? Then we’re on to the Svatāntrika’s point of view.
Now Svatāntrika say that there are two different bases for the absorption of cessation, you have the mental base and the physical base. And they start off with a description of I m sorry, there s another distinction before that. You have two absorption of cessation. There is a description of the absorption of the base of the absorption of cessation. Then there’s also a description of the nature of the absorption of cessation.
So therefore in the first division we have two which is the base which is the body and the base which is the mind. Okay, so then the first thing that we re dealing with then and actually that isn t the outline is the type of base or the type of physical body that is needed or the type of base of experience that is needed in order to achieve this realization, the absorption of cessation. This is all from the Svatāntrika’s point of view. First of all, ordinary beings that is beings without any level of realization starting off with renunciation, they are not able to develop the absorption of cessation. Neither are stream enterers or once returners or hearer arhats who have developed I’m just trying to figure out, it’s a type of Arhat, which is a hearer arhat.
Okay. So, it’s a type of a hearer our heart that is said to have not completed the liberation of wisdom. Now, type of hearer arhat that has not completed the liberation of wisdom is one that has achieved only one of the two legs of liberation. So if someone and they’ve gotten rid of the causes for suffering and therefore have achieved nirvana, but they haven’t developed the absorption of cessation like you remember before when we were talking about Arhats with Two. Do you remember them a couple of weeks ago?
Arhats with Two. Two being they had the absorption of cessation and they were Arhats. They’ve gotten rid of suffering. Yeah? And the causes for suffering.
They had these two different aspects. So beings who only have one of these are called people who are not liberated because of the lack of their wisdom or whatever. So they as well don t have this absorption of cessation. This is from the Svatāntrika point of view. Now the reason why the first of these, the ordinary beings, don t have this absorption of cessation is because they don t have the super mundane path as a basis for developing the absorption of cessation.
And so, the first thought, the ordinary beings, they don’t have a super mundane path so they have no hope. And then the other guys, stream entries and the one returners and the people who are in nirvana but haven t achieved the absorption of cessation or they haven actually achieved any of the formless realm levels of mind either, then they don t have the base which is absorption of the peak of cyclic existence to develop the absorption of cessation. Because you develop the absorption of cessation on the basis of the peak of cyclic existence absorption, right? So they don’t have that, so they can’t do it. So then the beings that do have this are for starters, who do have the absorption of cessation from the point of view of the svatantrikas.
For starters, the beings who are never returners, that is they are going to achieve arhatship in this body and the beings that have achieved arhatship of the kind with the two parts. One is they have achieved the formless absorption of the peak of cyclic existence mind which enables them to develop the absorption of cessation and they achieved nirvana. They achieved both of those levels of mind. The people we were talking about before, they only achieved nirvana. They hadn’t achieved the subtle level of mind of the peak of cyclic existence, right?
So this is the people who have both those abilities. And it’s also when it the it says the never returners, it’s the never returners who are going to develop into the arhats with two types of wisdom, not arhats with one type of wisdom. You get that? I’m just I’m just trying to say it, like, as clearly, and if you don’t get it, yell at me. This one.
Is the collection of text by Ārya. He sent me a text that from amongst the of the trainees or the people who haven’t achieved the end of the path who are once returners in their very body, which means they’re going to become arhats with the two different types of wisdom. And then also the non-trainees or the people beyond learning, which are arhats who have developed both the levels of wisdom, one being the and one being the absorption of cessation and the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence which can develop the absorption of cessation. Both of the This one. Yeah.
Talk about it. Go on this one. Okay. So in order to Sorry, I can’t remember where the last bit stopped because there was so much in that one. We talked about the Hīnayāna people who were able to achieve this but they’re not the Mahāyāna.
Right? Okay. So the Mahāyāna people that achieved this absorption of cessation are first of all, for beings who haven’t been through the Hīnayāna path first, then it’s those that are on the second moment of the path of seeing that they’re able to develop the absorption of cessation. Mahāyāna who haven’t been through the lower paths first. Second moment of the path of seeing.
Those who have been through the lower paths first, it s on the first moment of the path of seeing that they are able to perceive this. This is explained in the sūtra which is called Sūtra of Application for the Peak of the Path. Right? A sūtra from Buddha. And in this the Buddha says, The eight perfected liberations and the final placement in absorption from out of all of the nine, so that s referring to the absorption of cessation because we talked about all the different absorptions here, is type of Dharma is this?
And it is an absorption that is like the meditative concentration an absorption is, the meditative concentration called victory of lions. Now, you achieve the victory of lions level of meditative concentration when you are on the path of seeing. So It s like saying on the path of seeing when you achieve the victory of lion s level of subtlety in your meditation. Is when you are able to achieve the absorption of cessation. So apparently it’s called the victory of lions level of cessation.
I can’t say that was a straight face, that sounds so weird. The victory of lions level of meditative absorption when you are able to meditate without distraction even from things like sleep and so forth. So Geshe-la said that if you watch lions, they seem to be able to concentrate even when they’re not sleeping because there’s no, as soon as comes near them when they’re asleep they’re instantly awake and focused on that. It doesn’t seem like that they’re out of it and you could sneak up on them or anything. The same way that lions seem to be completely aware of everything that’s around them.
So if you have this level of concentration it means that you’re able to concentrate without needing things like sleeping and all the other things. The next thing that we needed to do was to figure out what the mental base for the absorption of cessation is. So the mental base for the absorption of cessation is said to have two parts. The first part is that it is the quiescence or the śamatha practice that is in fact the absorption that is the actuality of the peak of the cyclic existence. And then the second part is that it needs to be a super mundane path, which is a path from renunciation upwards, which by nature perceives special insight and uses it as a cause for the absorption of cessation.
If you don’t have the calm abiding and specifically the level of calm abiding which is the absorption of peak cyclic existence and special insight, then you can’t develop absorption of cessation. So the the reasons for this is the the first one, this level of concentration. You need to have the peak of cyclic existence as your basis for developing this absorption of cessation because it needs to be able to perceive the faults of the peaks of cyclic existence. If you have any lower minds, you can t be perceiving the subtle faults of a mind like the peak of cyclic existence. And this also needs to have the insight of special insight vipaśyanā because you need to be focusing on the nature of reality because getting rid of attachment to the peak of cyclic existence is something you actually get rid of on the path of seeing.
So in order to have the path of seeing, you need to have a special insight as a base. Right? Okay. So then it just says, there’s a Really? In the sūtra granting Dharma or or giving Dharma, the Buddha said monks or monks and nuns, whatever.
It doesn’t say whether it’s male or female. In order to have the absorption of cessation, you need to what these two are is the calm abiding is calm abiding and special insight. And then in the collected topics, is probably by Nāgārjuna. It says, The absorption of cessation. What is it?
Is a the complete lack of or the complete separation from any attachment for the objects of the senses. It s a sphere of objects. You know how there s the eighteen ones? I can’t remember the technical term for it but it wouldn’t make sense anyway. So you have the the mind, seeing the consciousness and the object of the consciousness.
And there s six consciousnesses, so there s eighteen, yeah? Those things. No attachment to any of those at all. S the mind at the peak of cyclic existence, so there s these three parts to it. No attachment to any of the scopes of the senses.
S a calm abiding which is the level of peak of cyclic existence. Then from Abhidharma it says, I m going from more subtle to more subtle levels of absorption. The subtlest is this absorption cessation.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
- Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.