45 min · 2,776 words · 1 July 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a commentary on Cittamatra tenets. It covers the mind basis of all as the person, whether the absorption of cessation is pure and whether it is substantially existent or labeled, and which paths can achieve it. It explains the three natures, with emptiness and labels not substantially existent, and that everything arises dependent on mind rather than being mind. It ends with how a shared cup is experienced both uniquely and commonly.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-07-01
Duration: 45 min
UUID: b71292b4-d251-4ad4-97f4-45e92d059b5f
Words: 2,772
The mental consciousness, the neurotic consciousness, and the mind basis of all. Now the definition of a person from the Cittamātra’s point of view is the mind basis of all. Okay? Because they don’t accept anything outside the mind, hence the name mind only. So, they define the person as the mind basis of all, the thing that carries on until enlightenment.
Now, this so this the in mind basis of all, there is a combination of things It’s also translated as the storehouse consciousness. It carries all the imprints and so forth. The neurotic consciousness is just the neurotic aspect of the mind, right? So, you can get rid of the neurotic aspect and still have the mind basis of all. And the mind basis of all can have neurosis in it.
So, they’re considered to be separate in the Cittamātra School’s tenets, but they are connected. Yeah? Does that make sense? Okay. I need that guy that sits at the back, and it always takes Bruce.
Bruce. Yeah. Bruce. I don’t know the name of this. Anyway, so then the next thing we need to decide is whether the absorption of cessation is something that is tainted or pure.
Pure or impure. So because of this, of needing to know this, the text says it will tell you that it is pure. And the reason for this is cited in a text which means like collected, right? By Asaṇga. I have no idea which one it is.
So one of Asaṇga’s texts. In this, Asaṇga says, the absorption of cessation is said to be pure because it is separated from neurosis. It is separated from that which comes along with neurosis. It is separated from an object of neurosis, and it is separated from the generation of neurosis. So this text, whatever its name is, by Asaṇga is written from the point of view of the Cittamātra school.
Okay. Another thing that we need to know about this absorption of cessation from the point of view of the Cittamātra School is whether they consider it to be a substantially existing thing or a labeled thing. Like, the Cittamātra School divides everything into that which is substantially existing and that which is labeled. Not merely labeled, though. Labeled.
Okay? So from amongst these, it is said from amongst these, several Vaibhāṣika or particular schools’ proponents say that the absorption of cessation is actually a substantial thing. But the Chittamatrans don’t say that. And the backup for this or the quote that supports this is from Asaṇga’s text, I don’t know the name of again. He says that if you use your intelligence, then you’ll see that the absorption of cessation isn’t is a labeled object and it doesn’t have ability to be a substantial object.
And there’s no reasoning that accompanies this quote. It’s just this is what the Chittamatrans say, it is thus. And there is no reasoning. Now, the Chitamatran actually say that they divide everything into three different types of objects. And one of these types of objects is what’s called other powered, which is basically compounded existent things, the things we usually refer to as forms in a collective topics and so forth.
Forms, things that come compounded phenomena, another way of describing them. Compounded phenomena are said to be substantially things and everything else a labeled thing. So as the absorption of cessation isn’t a is is a concept as opposed to a an other powered object, then it is said to be a labeled thing as opposed to a explanation that was given earlier. The second one is that this absorption of cessation from the point of view of the Chittamatrans can only be achieved through on the basis of a super mundane path. Another, backup for for this, assertion is the collected topics.
Collected topics of asanga, again, because it’s because if you’re talking about the Chitamatran point of view, it’s usually Asaṇga that’s quoted to back it up. So in the in the collected topics of Asaṇga, he says that the absorption of cessation can only be achieved by a supermundane path. Surprise. Right. He also says that most of the time, the absorption of cessation is developed on the basis of a human existence, although this is not always the case.
Okay. So the in the main Okay. So it’s usual that humans develop this absorption of cessation through the first instant, but it’s also possible that in other areas of the desire realm and the form realm that one is able to get rid of the gross feelings and discriminations, and therefore, through a deflated mind that comes about through this, one is then able to develop the absorption of cessation. So that’s in the also possible in other areas of the desire realm and the form realm. However, it’s not possible to develop the absorption of cessation in the formless realm.
So here, we’re talking about rebirth, not the levels of mind, right? Before we’re talking about the levels of minds associated with the formless realm, here we’re talking about an actual rebirth in these realms. So in the formless realm, being reborn in the formless realm, you cannot develop absorption of cessation. The reason you can’t develop the absorption of cessation is because what the absorption of cessation is, is the cessation of gross minds, yes? And in the formless realm, minds don’t manifest, so you can’t get rid of something that’s not there.
It’s not that it’s completely gone, but it doesn’t manifest, so you can’t get rid of it. Yeah. And then it just repeats. And then Minyak just said there’s a quote further again that says, if you have if you’re abiding in peace and your afflictive emotions aren’t coming up, then you can’t get rid of them. Right?
Sometimes I get a feeling of vertigo. That’s what I miss. The so but we just said that they weren’t they’re in a formless realm. There is no absorption of cessation, but there are beings who are what are called never returners who have developed the absorption of cessation who can actually die meditating in the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence and be reborn in the formless realm. So they’re in the formless realm, but as they are in the formless realm, then their absorption of cessation doesn’t manifest.
So it’s in their continuum and it doesn’t degrade. Yeah. So it can exist in a being who has developed the base who who has achieved the base of the formless realm. Yeah? But it’s not manifest in their continuum.
It doesn’t get worse. It doesn’t yeah. It’s not degrading anyway, but it doesn’t manifest because there’s nothing for it to manifest against. Oh, man. Okay.
This absorption of cessation, but yeah. I don’t know if you remember this, but back a while ago, and we’re talking about how the getting rid of the attachment to the absorption of peak of cyclic existence was a path of seeing abandonment. Alright? And then you can’t develop this and that you couldn’t develop the absorption of cessation on anything but a super mundane path because that was the thing that you were focusing on was getting rid of the attachment to the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence right? Do you remember that?
Right okay what I didn’t understand was that you were developing towards the absorption of cessation at that stage but you only actually have the absorption of cessation on the path of seeing when you get rid of your attachment to the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence. Okay, so you develop doing it then, but you only actually have the absorption of cessation from this path of seeing. So when you get rid of the thing to be abandoned, which is the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence, that’s when you develop the absorption of cessation. Okay? So you’re working towards that on the other super mundane paths, but you don’t actually get it until you become an Ārya.
Choose a path of seeing of either the Mahāyāna or Hīnayāna vehicles. Right? I can’t do this one. But think this I thought that you could develop it, then it came to that point and guess, no, no. You’re developing it, but you don’t fully achieve it until you come to the path of seeing.
Okay. So, therefore, the definition of an absorption of cessation from the point of view of the Cittamātra school, the mind only school, is an object taken an object of inquiry or an object of investigation that is a non associated composition or factor, which is a meditative concentration in a continuum of an ari of being, which is a cessation of the seven gross minds that are the object to be negated in dependence on the wisdom, mirror-like wisdom, and the mind basis of all. Is that okay? It’s an expanded definition. Is there a Chittamatran view version in there? No.
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So then yeah. Next week next week, we move on to the Prāsaṇgika.
And then finally to the that’s this that’s the Svatantra. This is yeah. This isn’t in here. Yeah. He said that we’ll probably get to the Svatāntrika position next week because the Prāsaṇgika explanation is not that long because they have sharp faculty, so they get it quickly.
But this isn’t So it’s not easier. But it’s easy to study. So it’s more difficult to achieve, but it’s easier to study. Okay. So Okay.
In Chitamatron School, we have these three different types of objects. Right? You have other power of phenomena. Then you have thoroughly established phenomena, and then you have labeled phenomena. Alright?
And labeled phenomena and thoroughly established phenomena are said to be not substantially existent. They said to be labeled. Yeah? This is emptiness and concepts of mind. Yeah.
Thoroughly established is emptiness, and labels are these concepts that people come up with. Now the reason that other power phenomena are said to be substantially existent is because they come into being based on causes and conditions. The causes and conditions relate to the mind, but they’re still causes and conditions. The way that emptiness comes into existence isn’t based on causes and conditions, and the way that labels come into existence isn’t based on causes and conditions. It’s based on a concept.
Yeah? So if something comes into existence based on causes and conditions, it’s said to be substantially existent. The nature of the mind? Yeah. And in the nature the Don’t bring out any Mahāmudrā turns on me.
I’ll slap you. In my own school Mhmm. Everything is in the nature of mind. Okay. Everything depends on mind.
You can’t say it’s the nature of mind because nature of mind is a whole other thing. Right? So everything depends on mind. It depends on an imprint that comes in that is that embedded in the mind which gives rise to a core which develops the causes and conditions for something to come into about for something to come about, for a situation or an object to come about. So emptiness is the mind in the Chitamachran school.
So the nature of everything is the mind. Yeah. But things actually come about in dependence upon causes and conditions, the imprints in the mind. But not the nature of mind. Is mind, said.
Yes. So but form and and then the form is emptiness and emptiness is form. That’s cocky. Okay. The form is emptiness.
Emptiness is form is the second turning of the wheel. That’s not the It’s it’s not a point of view. It’s point of view. Alright. So what the— I was like, oh. Okay.
So it’s a bit different in the Chitimatran point of view because what they say is it’s the same nature. Alright? It is in that things come into being based on the mind and the mind is the the mind the different minds who have come into being based on the mind based on the same imprint. Alright? And so in that way, they have the same nature, but they don’t say you can’t say they are each other.
Right? They have the same nature of emptiness, which is the mind. Yeah? But they don’t have they they don’t have the same you can’t say they are each other. No.
No. I wasn’t. Which you can in the other school? That’s not mine. That’s that’s brain, Okay.
Right. It’s the opposite, though. Scientists Okay. First of all, first of all, it’s opposite because scientists are saying that everything is matter and there is no mind. And that mind is an epiphenomenon of the brain.
Alright? And the other dudes, the Chittamatrans, are saying that everything is mind. So it’s opposite. But Geshe-la said, wait a minute. They’re not saying everything’s mind.
They’re saying everything comes about in dependence on the mind. They’re not saying that mind and form are the same thing. They’re saying that everything comes about because of the mind. So that’s a bit different. Is that okay then?
Is mind? Uh-huh. Okay. Geshe-la said that that’s not his understanding of the Cittamātra school anyway because that seems to turn all form into mind, you can’t do that because everything ceases to have meaning there. Right?
So he said that seasoned masters don’t say everything is mind. They say everything comes about in dependence on mind. So the reason everything comes into that in dependence on mind is everything comes about in dependence on karma alright karma causes and can create causes and conditions and so forth and all of that comes from mind so the basis of everything the reasoning for everything the thing that brings everything into being is the mind Not that everything is mind. Okay. So Right.
Okay, I think I’ve got it. So the Chittamatrans are not saying that everything is mind. They say that everything comes about in dependence on mind. And in fact, an object and the perception of that object come about in dependence on one imprint. Right?
Now, the reason that this comes in me this is that we have an idea of labeling something that exists as cup. Yeah? And the idea of labeling this thing that exists as cup and the mind that perceives it as cup, right, are the same imprint. So this is a a label thing. It’s not inherently existing.
The only that’s inherently existing is mind. Yeah? And so the the label on the cup, yeah, and the knowing that it’s cup, right? So the the object, you take the the the the idea of cup is the object. Right?
And the mind that recognizes cup, they’re the same imprint. So there is this element of things being merely labeled not merely labeled, but labeled. Not merely not merely labeled, but labeled. Not inherently existent, if that makes sense. So everything So we have one imprint that ripens when, for example, we see cup, and it’s our idea of cup and the experience that we are having of cup are from the same imprint, all right?
So the thing that we label as cup, understanding of cup come from the same imprint. Our mind that recognizes cup come from the same imprint, yeah? Now, my labeling of cup, the way I perceive cup, and my imprint of cup is mine. Geshe-la’s label of cup and the way he sees cup is his, and Judy’s labeling of cup and the way he sees cup is Judy’s. We each have an imprint that ripens when we see the cup, and a cause that has created a cup to be there for us.
Alright? The and we see a different cup, our own individual cup. Yeah? But we have not the same imprint, but a similar enough imprint to be able to share our experience of it. It’s okay?
So in this way, then we each have a, what’s called a unique experience of cup and a shared experience of cup. It’s unique in the fact that it is happening for me because of an imprint that I had of cup and the causes that I created to have a cup there, yeah, and it’s happening for each one of you because of the same thing, but we all have a common experience of cup as well. So that our individual causes for this cup being there and our individual imprints for the cup being there are different, but we have common experiences.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.