Ornament for Clear Realisations – 34 2004 06 24 OCR

41 min · 2,625 words · 24 June 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 34 2004 06 24 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching introduces the outline of the meditative absorption of cessation and works through which beings do and do not possess it, according to Cittamatra and Vaibhashika tenets. It covers stream enterers, once and never returners, arhats and Arya bodhisattvas, and explains that Arya bodhisattvas have imprints of ignorance but not seeds, so they are not reborn through karma and afflictions. Student questions and a short discussion of whether transmission can be received by tape are included.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-06-24

Duration: 42 min

UUID: 7dfb7c42-9eda-4029-afd6-b2e7ea90c0ea

Words: 2,621

So the reason that they have an outline in Tibetan text is so that they can be memorized easier. So it’s basically like a table of contents and a list of headings. And if you have a list of headings, you can remember the skeleton of the text, you can remember where everything goes. So that’s the whole point of view of the outline. So the things to remember for this stage, The first heading is what type of being has this concentration?

And the second type is what ground is it developed in dependence upon? And which path is it developed in dependence upon? What does the mind have to do in this meditative concentration? And what is what is Sorry. Refuted.

I had just had a mental blank. Sorry. I forgot the word for this. And he goes, yeah, gopo is gopo. I like, yeah, but that’s not English.

That doesn’t help me. Okay. It says, what is to be refuted as the four objects of refutation? You know you have the objects of refutation in a lot of emptiness texts? What an analysis of the nature of this meditative equipoise, the absorption of cessation, which isn’t a meditative equipoise.

It’s an absorption of cessation. Anyway, the nature, an examination of its nature. Okay. Okay. So the first thing to find out is who doesn’t have this.

Right? From the Cittamātra point of view, who doesn’t have the absorption of cessation? And there’s a big list of people who don’t have it. Stream enterers don’t have it. Stream enterers are Hīnayāna practitioners who have achieved the path of seeing, the Hīnayāna path.

Right? Don’t have it. And never returners oh, no. Once returners don’t have it. Yes?

Neither do never no. Once returners don’t have it, sorry. And then also, never returners who will see the fruits of their practice. Right? In this lifetime, that’s what they’re called.

Never returners who will see the fruits of their practice. They don’t have it either. It says, The reason they don’t have it is because they haven’t achieved absorption of cessation. Oh, no, no, sorry, sorry. I’ve got it wrong.

So we have the stream enterers, and then we have the once returners, and then we have the never returners who will see the results of their practice in this life in their in that lifetime. Then we have never returners who haven’t achieved the absorption of cessation don’t have the absorption of cessation, anyway, which is a good thing. Otherwise, it would be a paradox. And then there’s also arhats who have achieved the path of liberation but have not developed the absorption of cessation, they also do not have it. So we talked about last time when we were talking about had the absorption of cessation from the Vaibhāṣika point of view, we had this discussion about if you can remember about arhats who have developed the absorption of cessation and they were called those with two.

They have both the cessation of suffering, which you get from being an Arahat, and they also have this absorption of cessation. You can actually achieve nirvana, or the cessation of suffering, without achieving the peak of cyclic existence. So, you haven’t achieved the peak of cyclic existence, you don’t have the absorption of cessation. Yeah? So if there’s some arhats who haven’t achieved that, then they don’t have it either.

Right. So who else doesn’t have it? First of all, the reason that these guys don’t have it is because they haven’t achieved the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence, and this is how you develop the absorption of cessation. So who else doesn’t have it? Well, the other people that don’t have it are ordinary beings who are maybe maybe bodhisattvas.

They may be on the path of preparation, path of accumulation, but they haven’t achieved what are called afflictive emotions to be abandoned on the path of seeing through the meditative concentration of the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence. So if you don’t have that, then you don’t have it. Okay. So who has it? Now the first type of beings that have it are those never returners who in the same lifetime they are experiencing are going to achieve the nirvana which has both aspects.

So that is the nirvana which has the cessation of suffering which is the usual definition of nirvana, but also has the absorption of cessation as another characteristic, right? So beings who are going to achieve that realization in that lifetime already have to have the absorption of cessation in order to become an arhat with the absorption of cessation. Right? So those type of beings have it. And then obviously the arhats that they are going to become also have it.

That it. Then you also have solitary realizers who have developed the absorption of cessation. They obviously have the absorption of cessation. Then also, beings who have developed the ability to practice the Mahāyāna vehicle, and before they developed the ability to practice the Mahāyāna vehicle had already become a Hīnayāna Ārya, right, who had previously developed the absorption of cessation. You know how we’re talking about these never returners who can if that person was then able to go on and develop a Bodhicitta, then they could be someone who has the absorption of cessation.

But if people haven’t followed the Hīnayāna path before they enter the Mahāyāna path to that stage, then they attain the absorption of cessation on the second moment of the path of No, yes, yes, second moment of the path of seeing, which is the first ground. And at this stage, they have developed the separation from attachment which sees the emptiness of the source forms. Do you remember the source forms? Like, the eye source form, nose source form, or none of them. It’s in the Heart Sūtra.

Jobs. It’s good. It’s it’s a it’s a it’s a, like, a good mark. I said now it’s a holiday, and. He said until you become an, there is no holiday.

And then he said, then you have a real holiday. If you have questions, you’re allowed to ask them. Yes. Sure. Uh-huh.

Arhats. Yeah. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Okay.

Right. Okay. So it’s only Bodhisattva Aryas that don’t come back because of karma. Bodhisattvas can come back because of karma. It’s only Bodhisattva Aryas that don’t.

Once they’ve achieved perception of emptiness directly, they’re able to obliterate the imprint of grasping at existence, and it’s grasping at existence which is the first link in the twelve links of dependent origination that cause birth. Ārya Bodhisattvas don’t have to come back through karma and afflictions. Non-Ārya Bodhisattvas do. They don’t have to come back through karma and afflictions. What happens is they don’t and because they don’t have karma and afflictions, it means that they don’t have desire and they don’t have anger.

But what they do is they choose a specific birth because they have control over the birth that they choose. They choose a birth that’s going to be for the benefit of others. The other thing is when they are born, they behave exactly the same way as everybody else. So we don’t know who’s bodhisattva or not. When do you use the term Ārya bodhisattva?

Path of seeing. An Ārya bodhisattva. An Ārya bodhisattva. Yeah. Because you you said they’ve overcome all their afflictions, I thought, maybe an an arhat they’ve overcome.

Don’t manifest their afflictions. What I guess they said was that they have gotten rid of the imprints to grasping an inherent existence of things. Things. Therefore, they’re not under the power of karma and afflictions. They’re not under the power of karma and afflictions.

Okay, I just found out that there is a distinction between these two words that I thought both meant imprint, and they actually say imprints in dictionaries, but anyway. Right. So, they have imprints for ignorance, but they don’t have seeds of ignorance. Okay? This is the way I’m distinguishing them.

They don’t have the seeds of ignorance because an imprint, there’s like a causal relationship, not causal relationship, a pervasive relationship between these in that that seed is always an imprint, but an imprint isn’t always a seed. Does that make sense? This is why they probably lump in the same thing a lot of time, right? A seed is always an imprint, an imprint isn’t a seed. A seed is given something that has the ability to produce a result and the imprint doesn’t necessarily have that.

So the aryas have imprints but they don’t have seeds. They don’t have they have imprints but they don’t have imprints that are going to cause them to act in a certain way. Our imprints cause us to act in a certain way, so therefore, they’re called seeds. Emotions. Because these imprints don’t have the ability to cause them to have experience negative emotions, but they do cause them to have obscurations to omniscience.

Okay. Yeah. So seeds are imprints, but they’re imprints with ability or imprints with power. It’s very precise, Geshe-la doesn’t think so, but he’s not sure. And I was just telling him, I remember hearing someone ask this question to Rinpoche in India, and Rinpoche just was like, when he stopped laughing, asked them what they thought they were playing at.

But I can’t remember who it was. Geshe said, Oh, yeah, don’t think so. It doesn’t seem to work. Yeah. He said if I use logic, it doesn’t seem like they would.

He hasn’t been He he said he hasn’t ever heard anyone say that you do get it or you don’t get it. Right? But by using his logic, he would say you didn’t. Yeah. Really?

He’s gonna he’s Geshe-la because we’re sorry we’ve got quotes both, and then there’s like Geshe-la said, he he according to his logic, they don’t, and he’s gonna give you logic. Alright. So Geshe-la said that this is the reason he would say, You wouldn’t get it, is because by reading a text, you’re reading the words of the Buddha, and you don’t get a transmission from doing that. If that is the exact words of the Buddha and you don’t get a transmission from it, he doesn’t think that a tape can give you a direct transmission either. He said, if you read out a sūtra or a text to me and I was able to listen to it and he was able to read it, I still wouldn’t have the transmission because if he didn’t have the transmission.

Right? So, he can’t see how a tape would have a transmission. He said that that’s just his opinion, but he’s not sure. Yeah. But he doesn’t.

Because he hasn’t heard about whether you’re caught or Because you said that part of the practice of transmission is motivation by the person giving the transmission that they are giving to the transmission to the people listening. He doesn’t think that the Geshe necessarily thought that it was going to you after that via tape. It comes down to that would be the main difference between the presentation in that way. But he’s not certain. He said he said he doesn’t know.

Know. Oh, it is. He just said that he doesn’t know and he’s not certain about it. It’s just that if it was up to his opinion, which is coming down to because he’s never heard any of his teachers explain to him whether you can get it by tape or not. It would have seemed to him that listening to something via tape negates the need for an oral transmission at all, because it’s a process of giving instruction and listening to the words from a teacher.

That’s the whole process of doing it. He would think that listening to a tape is a secondhand experience of that the same way that reading a text would be. But he doesn’t know for certain. That’s just what he would think about it. But he said, but he doesn’t know for sure.

I’m trying to remember again. Pretty sure it’s too soon. Did they say he wants to know if they said the reason that it was okay in the in the I think it was this is still along the lines of the fact that we all have the opportunity to actually have live contact with teachers. Uh-huh. Sure.

This is don’t I was trying to think if they would have had handing out tapes to the Linguaphone machine was around. Oh, and the new one. He said, I’m not arguing that it’s not really beneficial to them. I just don’t understand how they can get. He said yeah.

It could be another you know, it’s pretty Or out of context or something as well. Guess he said he doesn’t know. He said, but they could he could be saying that it could be one opinion. He can’t see how it works, but he’s he’s open to what anyone says. Anyway.

He said, I’m not that I’m doubting the motivations of the Rinpoche that said this. I’m sure that they were fine. I He said he’s just doubting the mind of people who sell things. Okay. He said, probably?

I don’t know. He really hasn’t heard anything about it. He doesn’t know if you’re getting their own transmission or not, but what he does know is it’s going to be of enormous benefit. You’re getting to listen to the teachings and you get to reflect on them and to study them and to hear different people’s interpretations, which gives you a broader understanding of it. No matter whether you’re getting the transmission or not, it shouldn’t really matter.

The main thing is your understanding of the Dharma. Yeah. They know. They know. They know.

They know. Never returners have gotten rid of all of their afflictive emotions and therefore all that causes to be reborn in saṃsāra, grasping at the existence of yourself. Once they’ve got rid of that, then they realize that there’s nothing that will bring them back. There’s no cause to be reborn again. Okay, so they’ve gotten rid of the first link of dependent origination from their point of view, but not from the point of view of the Mahāyāna because they say they’ve only gotten rid of the grasping at inherent self or person and not their grasping at their inherent existence of things.

They’ve gotten rid of their afflictive emotions so they are not going to experience saṃsāra anymore. Is that okay? Are you sorted now? Or is there any more questions? Because you’ve got two weeks holiday.

So you can go and and and memorize the outline. He said that would be great. He said that’s what they did in their holidays. They had a break, and they didn’t have any what this thing called, is going through text, and they didn’t have any debate. All they had was memorization.

And you can say the Tathāgata Sūtra instead. Okay. Geshe-la said, so you guys can say all the the the he’s being silly. Tathāgata Sūtra. Right?

And and he he said, yeah, you guys have to say it lots because I haven’t found a text for me to recite it Almost. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

That’s funny. You guys haven’t found one for me to recite yet. He said, okay. So if they give me the text, I get to read the Buddhist Dharma. If they don’t give me the text, I get a holiday.

Both ways are good. But he said he’s joking. Okay. So.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA
twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top