44 min · 3,275 words · 1 July 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a commentary on the Cittamatra school’s account of the absorption of cessation. It covers the subtlest mind on which this absorption is based (the peak of cyclic existence), the supramundane path needed to develop it, and its role in abandoning attachment on the path of seeing. It also explains the mind basis of all and the mirror-like wisdom as the basis for negating the seven consciousnesses.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-07-01
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 154b68ce-a247-41a5-8bd1-8a99246f6905
Words: 3,271
I am. Oh, yeah. You guys do that. You know? Can’t hear it on the side.
Get a good motivation. There you go. So we were up to the nine supramundane paths, and specifically the different schools’ description of the absorption of cessation. And we talked about the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika descriptions of the absorption of cessation. And we’re going through the Cittamātra or Mind Only School’s description of the absorption of cessation.
With reference to the absorption of cessation, there is something that we talked about in conjunction with this, which was the discriminationless cessation which one develops before one can develop the absorption of cessation. Okay? So there’s one that you can develop on the basis of a gross mind, then this is the subtlest one, is this absorption of cessation. Now, when we’re talking about the Cittamātra or Mind Only School version or description of this absorption of cessation, we had talked about the type of being which develops this absorption of cessation, and we’re now onto the type, the ground, which ground or which basis is used for the development of the absorption of cessation. So, the ground or the basis is said to be the subtlest mind that one can develop, which is the mind called peak of saṃsāra.
On the basis of the mind called the peak of saṃsāra, then one is able to develop this absorption of cessation. This is from the point of view of the Mind Only school. Now, from amongst what are called the eight formless minds, so here we’re talking about the eight concentrations of the form and formless realm, there is none more subtle than the absorption of cessation. And as there is no mind more subtle than the absorption of cessation, anything more subtle than the absorption of no. I stuffed up.
Okay. From these eight minds, there is none more subtle than the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence. Right? Start again. Now, as there is no mind more subtle than the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence, anything more subtle than that cannot be a mind.
It has to be an object that a mind takes. Alright? So, therefore, the absorption of cessation as it is not a mind is more subtle than the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence and needs to be dependent on the thing just more gross than that in order for it to develop. So it gets subtler and subtler and subtler, but the most subtle mind is the absorption of peak of cyclic existence and then we have that mind is able to take as an object the absorption of cessation. Okay?
Alright. So sorry. Got a bit confused because it uses as a backup or explanation for this description of the absorption of cessation a quote from the Abhidharmakośa by Vasubandhu, which says, The absorption of cessation is Well, this is very colloquial translation, but it’s as subtle as you can get. Alright? It’s the most subtle, but it literally says it’s as subtle as it comes.
Now, the reason I was confused about that, which I might as well share with you, is that Abhidharma is taught from the perspective of the particularists and the Sūtra schools. And I was wondering why the Chittamatrans were using it as a backup for their argument when they don’t propound those schools. Geshe-la said they accept the Abhidharma, though. They just interpret the Abhidharma in different ways. It’s just generally accepted that Abhidharma is taught from the Cittamātra perspective, but people tend to quote from it, stack up their arguments even if the general tone of it isn’t from their perspective.
Right, then, even though the first moment of the absorption of cessation needs to have the rely on the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence to come about from this Cittamātra’s point of view. Subsequent absorptions of cessation that are being developed aren’t necessarily confined or aren’t necessarily reliant on the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence. As being moves through the eight absorptions of this form and formless realm, then in every stage, there is a cessation. And once a person has developed the absorption of cessation, then as they move up through these different levels of concentration, every time that they have a concentration, they have a cessation. And if they possess the absorption of cessation in their mind stream, then any of the cessation of the of the eight absorptions can become a absorption cessation.
Right. I’m doing all the hard work. I’m trying to figure it out, and then I just say to you, and then it hopefully makes sense. Anyway, and I thought I understood that before I explained that again. Okay.
So the next thing we’re dealing with is what path the absorption of cessation is developed from. Now, in the beginning, it is said that the absorption of cessation needs to be based on or developed from what’s called a super mundane path. Now in this instance, what’s referred to as a supramundane path or an unworldly path is anything above the realization of renunciation. Alright, so as soon as you enter the path of the Hīnayāna through developing renunciation, you have developed a supramundane path, or an unworldly path in your mind stream. So, in the basis of any of these, then you are able to develop this absorption of cessation.
Now the reason that it has to be a super mundane path for us to develop the absorption of cessation on is because there are all these different levels, these nine super mundane paths that we were talking about, yeah? And on each of the super mundane paths, there is things that need to be abandoned. So, for example, at the absorption of the first concentration, there are things to be abandoned from the first concentration. Things to be abandoned on the second concentration, like desires and attachment to those concentrations and so forth. Now there’s also absorption, there is things to be abandoned with regards to the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence.
Now these are generally taken to be abandonment of the path of seeing. Now but we’re able to get rid of some of these things associated with this on the path of preparation and the path of accumulation of any of the Hīnayāna or Mahāyāna path. Now, the reason that we need the absorption of cessation to get rid of the things to be abandoned with regards to this peak of cyclic existence, that it needs to be something more subtle than the thing that we’re trying to abandon attachment to in order for us to abandon it. So for example, if we are trying to abandon the things we need to abandon with regards to the absorption of nothingness, we’d use the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence. If we’re trying to abandon the things we need to abandon with regards to the absorption of infinite consciousness, we’d use the absorption of nothingness and so on.
So you use the thing above it to get rid of the attachments associated with the grosser moment below it. Right? Now the only thing that we can get rid of the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence is as abandoning things, is the absorption of cessation, right? The only thing, if I was gonna be, okay, I’ll try and say it very technically and hope that makes more sense. The things to be abandoned on the path of seeing which are related to the absorption of peak of cyclic existence can only be abandoned through the absorption of cessation.
Yes? So this, because the path of seeing is something that we start focusing on when one develops renunciation or Bodhicitta on the Mahāyāna or Hīnayāna path, right? So you start focusing then on developing the conditions for the path of seeing, right? So because you’re focusing on that and you’re trying to work towards getting rid of the things to be abandoned with relation to the peak of cyclic existence on the path of seeing, it’s only when you have that as your focus that you can start developing or you can develop the absorption of cessation. He reckons you understand He reckons you understand that.
I hope so. Oh, yeah. He said, did I understand? And I said, I hope so. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Really. Okay. So the and then it’s just it first of there was just a backup for for this this explanation that says there is nothing higher than the peak of cyclic existence apart from the cessation.
Because of this, then we may think that this means that the peak of the absorption of cessation necessarily means that the being who has developed the absorption of cessation is completely free from this, what’s called the neurotic mind in a mind only school. You know how we went through those eight different levels of mind, and the one above the mind basis of all is the neurotic mind or the thoroughly afflicted mind. So this neurotic mind is necessarily absent from the continuum of those who develop the absorption of cessation. And the reason for this is that beings who are called never returners have not gotten rid of neurosis, this neurotic mind, in the Cittamātra School’s version of events, but they have this absorption of cessation. So this means that you can have the absorption of cessation, the absorption of peak of existence, have not abandoned or haven’t become an arhat, haven’t gotten rid of the neurosis or even the, what are called the innate neurosis, which is what you get rid of on the path of seeing.
So in order for one to get rid of the attachments that are included within or to the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence or to the absorption of peak of cyclic existence, you need this absorption of cessation, right? And the attachment or the things to be abandoned with regards to the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence are things you get rid of on the path of seeing. So before you can enter the path of seeing and get rid of these things, you need this absorption of cessation. Yeah?
So that means it’s something that’s like a super mundane path, but it’s not something that’s necessarily only developed by aryas, because you need it before you hit the path of seeing. Okay. Then, so that’s the one type one version of saying how which ground or which base this absorption of cessation is developed from. Another way of saying it is that is it developed from inner mind that is free from attachment or is it developed in a mind that has attachment? Now, it’s neither You can’t define it as either one of these because beings who are never never returners haven’t gotten rid of attachment and they’re able to develop the absorption of cessation.
Arhats also have the absorption of cessation, but they don’t have attachment and they don’t have the suffering that comes about from the attachment. So this mind is first of all developed in a reliance on the absorption of peak of cyclic existence. This can happen in any of the lower paths, but it doesn’t actually stop — you don’t cease to have this absorption of cessation. Even arhats have it. So we can’t say it’s those who have attachment that have it or those who don’t have attachment that have it.
What we can say is it’s something that can only be developed on a super mundane path and it’s something that has to be used to get rid of the attachment to the peak of cyclic existence on the path of seeing. Is that okay? In a different school’s explanation. He said he agreed totally with your description of those two ways that you can know something. From either a theory or a personal experience, he said that was a very good way of looking at the way you can know something.
Now this is actually supposed to be though from the point of view of someone who knows these things. And the reason that there are different explanations is because there are different paths that one can be led on. Right? So in response to the different abilities of beings, there is different explanations for the different minds that you can develop. And what this means then is, it isn’t as if there is one set in stone way.
If a Buddha explains or teacher explains these paths to people and they, for example, explain their Chitamatran view and that person meditates on that, they will have the experience of the Chitamatran path and come to the end of the Chitamatran path with a Chitamatran realization. If someone explains to them the Sautrāntika path, they will develop the realizations of the Sautrāntika path and come to the end of the Sautrāntika path. So they can actually all be true because they depend on an individual’s experience, and they can have different experiences depending on what they’re aiming for. You think so? So there’s different ways of explaining it too.
Okay. The next one, the next area that we’re looking at in this is the reason for which someone would want to do this, which someone would want to develop the absorption of cessation. And the reason it says is that in order for us to completely control the mind, we need to be able to get rid of even the most subtle attachments. Yeah. And the most, one of the most subtle attachments you can have is the absorption, attachments, the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence, that very, very subtle mind.
All right. So then if you’re able to use this absorption of cessation to get rid of the gross feelings and discriminations through, you do this through completely giving up on all of the things that could actually make you feel good in this life, yeah, then that means that you can have a calmness of mind and a bliss of mind which enables you to get your mind to do exactly what you want it to do to the most subtle degree. Alright? So if we could do this, it means we have complete control of our minds even to the most even with regards to its attachment to subtle levels of mind. Right?
So if we can do this, we have no attachments to the things of this life because we’re able to control our minds and no attachments to the levels of meditation. That is fine. And after spending a week watching my mind, that would be cool. The next thing that we need need to look at is what is used as the object for the absorption of cessation, what is the base that is negated, and what the object to be negated depends on. So the base for the object of negation is what’s called the mind basis of all, the alaya vijnana, the lowest level of the mind.
In combination with something that’s called the mirror-like wisdom. So on the basis of the alaya vijnana, the mind basis of all, and the mirror-like wisdom, then one is able to get rid of the things to be abandoned or the things to be refuted, which are the seven gross minds. So the five the six consciousnesses in the neurotic mind. Now you may also wonder, the way they put it is you may wonder why, in fact, hadn’t had a clue about it. Okay, yes.
So you may wonder why they didn’t, in this description, didn’t say that the absorption of cessation takes us is based the absence of the seven negative minds. Right? It says the basis is the mind basis of all. It doesn’t say the basis for this absorption of cessation is the negation of the seven negative minds. Right?
Oh, the sorry, the seven consciousnesses. Now, the reason it doesn’t describe it as the lack of something, even though we’re talking about a cessation, is because there are times when you can’t, when you don’t have those seven, those seven minds active, but it’s not the absorption cessation. For example, when you’re in deep sleep or when you pass out, all right? Or when you’re in a coma, all right? At those stages, you don’t have these active minds, but you don’t have an absorption of cessation.
Yeah, so this is like when they’re describing a cessation as something that’s positive, which is a different thing to do, but that’s why. Okay? He says, no. You don’t have minds, but it’s not exactly a cessation. And it’s like a not a cessation of something.
It’s a not active of something. Now, the other thing is they describe this absorption of cessation from Cittamātra’s point of view as that it uses the neurotic mind as a basis. Now, the reason that it says that it uses the neurotic mind as a basis is because there is only three different times when you don’t have a neurotic mind, right? So, although the neurotic mind isn’t present in them, when a being has the absorption of cessation, it doesn’t necessarily mean that they don’t have the neurotic mind in their continuum. Yeah?
So this isn’t talking about a specific instance. This is talking about in general. It’s not saying you absolutely have to have the neurotic mind to have the absorption of cessation because that’s not true either. But it’s just saying that it can be a basis for the development of the absorption of cessation because basis for the absorption of cessation because beings with a neurotic mind have the absorption of cessation. Right.
So there’s these three times when we don’t have a neurotic mind. The first one is when we are focused on the absorption of cessation, all right? No neurosis, no neurotic, well, no, hang on. Not no neurosis, no neurotic mind present, all right? The second one is when the non-worldly paths are actually actualized in concentration.
Alright? So this means, for example, the non worldly paths are any of the paths. Alright? So it’s talking about anything from renunciation upwards. And when you say a non worldly path is actually in the forefront in concentration.
These beings may have neurosis in their continuum, but if a non worldly path is in the forefront of their mind, so for example, they’re focusing on Chitta, at that point, there is no neurotic mind present. Yes? Same as if they’re focusing on renunciation, emptiness, and so forth. There is no neurotic mind present then. So we have when people when beings are focusing on the absorption of cessation, when they have a non-worldly path in the forefront of their mind or as they focus on concentration, and also when a being has achieved the path of no more learning, whether it be on the Hīnayāna or Mahāyāna path, they don’t have a neurotic mind.
Okay. Right. I just realized that I’m saying neurotic mind, so I ask Geshe-la to clarify that because it doesn’t sound the same in the point of view, it doesn’t in everybody else’s point of view. A neurotic mind in everyone else’s point of view is something that just comes up, a neurotic mind, yeah? The neurotic mind in the Cittamātra’s point of view is a continuum of mind that is thoroughly neurotic.
In a Chitamatran point of view, we have these eight levels of mind, right?
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.