Ornament for Clear Realisations – 13 2004 03 11 OCR

43 min · 3,281 words · 11 March 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 13 2004 03 11 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk, which continues an earlier session, explains the four close placements of mindfulness (body, feeling, mind and phenomena) from Maitreya’s Abhisamayalamkara, and how they support the practice of the Four Noble Truths. It covers the definition of close placement and mindfulness, where these practices occur on the path, and how the Mahayana version differs from the Hearer and Solitary Realiser versions in its understanding of selflessness.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-03-11

Duration: 44 min

UUID: c07cffde-b69c-44f3-9515-960064c44ca2

Words: 3,277

Okay. So it said that effort is liking doing virtuous things. And so we should really try and apply this when we are studying Prajñāpāramitā through this Abhisamaya or Ornament of Clear Realisation. If we when we do virtuous things, we should try and really enjoy them or have a mind that enjoys doing them. If we really enjoy something, if we get the if we see the point to it and that makes us very happy, then when we’re doing it, we don’t get tired, we don’t get worn out.

Lots of times when we are studying something like this, can get really worn out by it and think, Oh, this is really hard. But we should try and remember to have this joyous effort in what we’re doing. Okay. So the the reason that we’re studying this text is so we can become enlightened. And with this text, then it works in two different ways.

Acts as a cause studying the text acts as a cause for us to become enlightened, but we also need to study the text in order to become enlightened. We need to have an understanding of the paramita or the perfections in order to become enlightened. And whole of the six paramita are discussed in the fourth chapter of the Abhisamayālamkāra. So in actual fact, it’s said to be focused on the paramita of wisdom, but all six paramita or all six perfections are discussed in this fourth chapter. So this text is about is a is a Buddhist text.

And in the in by the type of text that it is also said to be a text of the Mahāyāna It’s said to be explained in an elusive fashion from one thing to another what it is that we need to do in order to become Buddhist so the six perfections are explained in different ways through different perspectives through the Sravakas, hearers and solitary realisers and bodhisattvas. So this text explains these things in this way. So it is something that we should be very happy about because we’re made happy by what happens when we do something. So if doing something is going to give us a good result and this result is to become a Buddha, then we should be very happy about having the opportunity to So this becomes this really a huge reason for us to becomes a really beneficial or important thing for us to do is to study this text. Because by studying it now, what we’re doing is familiarizing ourselves with the text.

We’re imprinting our mind with this text or developing an insight into this text so we can have made a point with what do say? We’ve made a point to this life where we’ve taken the essence from this lifetime by using it in the best way as possible. By studying this text, we’ve created a cause for us to be able to understand this better in the future. So it means we’ve used our lifetime to its best advantage. So there’s a lot of things in this text and it’d be very difficult for us to try and understand or to conceive of everything that’s in the text, let alone try and remember everything that’s in the text.

And it’s probably unlikely that we’re going to remember everything that’s in the text. But what we should be concentrating is on the fact that studying this text, and if even if we don’t understand it, even if we don’t remember it, we’re at least familiarizing ourselves with it, and this is a good process to help us in future lives. So while it may be it may be unlikely that we’re able to practice the six perfections having realized emptiness in this lifetime, by studying this text, we’re setting ourselves in good stead to be able to do that in future lifetimes. Mhmm. So it may be difficult us to develop the four close placements of mindfulness in this lifetime, to be completely aware of what our body, our mind, our feelings and phenomena, to be completely aware of all these four things in one instant or to be able to have mindfulness of all these may be something that’s very difficult for us to develop in this lifetime, let alone the rest of it.

But we’re we’re placing ourselves in good stead for the future if we develop familiarization with this text and an understanding of this text now. So we are going through the. Oh, okay. Guess you said you don’t need to meditate because you’re. So, anyway, so, therefore, we are up to the need for meditation.

And this is within the thirty seven dharmas compatible with enlightenment. And we’re talking about the four close placements of mindfulness, which another way of saying them is the path comprehending phenomena. And we talked about what these were, those being the close placement of body, the close placement of feelings, the close placement of mind, and the close placement of dharmas or phenomena. The thing is that we focus on these objects as an object of attention and through these we develop understandings of impermanent suffering and so forth so they’re said to be what’s called the general characteristics and specific characteristics and in the combination of focusing on the general and specific characteristics of these four objects we then develop foreclosed placements of mindfulness. Now the purpose for or the need the purpose for us meditating on or developing these four close placements of mindfulness is in order for us to enter into the practice or engage in the practice of the four noble truths.

Within the four noble truths there is things to be abandoned and things to be practiced. So this development of the four close placements of mindfulness enables us to develop the things we need to develop from the four noble truths and to abandon things we need to abandon from the four noble truths. So we start by meditating on close mindfulness of body in order to understand that the appropriated aggregates or the aggregates that we have taken through karma and delusion are something that are by nature suffering and uncomfortable is another way of translating what Jungwa here is translated as decline, in decline, of decline. So the body is by nature suffering and uncomfortable and because of this it’s something to be abandoned. So by meditating on close mindfulness of body, we’re able to develop an understanding of this nature of suffering and how we need to get rid of that.

So by meditating on the close placement of mindfulness of feeling, this means that we are able to understand that we have this idea of grasping at that we have this we have the wish or the desire yeah not the grasping at the wish or the desire to be separated from suffering and to be not separated from happiness to not be separated from happiness so we have this desire or wish for this to come about and through this we establish the cause for saṃsāra or the cause for existence and this cause for existence is the main object or the main focus for the second noble truth the truth of the origin of suffering. Once we develop a close placement of mindfulness on the feelings then we understand that this process is happening. We understand that we have feelings that wish to be separated from suffering and wish not to be separated from happiness and by this we then create the causes for saṃsāra and so in order for us to get rid of the causes from saṃsāra then we need to get rid of this wish not to experience suffering and so forth. By doing this close placement of mindfulness on feelings we develop the understanding that feeling of suffering and so forth or the feeling of wishing to not to suffer and so forth is actually said to be the main aspect of the cause of suffering.

Because it’s the main aspect of the cause of suffering then it is something that we need to abandon. So by developing our close placement of mindfulness on feelings we understand we need to abandon the main cause of the root of suffering, which is this grasping or this desire for happiness and the wish to be separated from suffering. Water then after that, through close placement of mindfulness on the mind, then we’re able to understand the specific characteristics of mind. We understand that this thing that we grasp at as being a foundation or a truly existent thing is in fact impermanent and it has other characteristics of mind. This being things like it’s impermanent, it generates, it doesn’t abide, it ceases, it comes into cause, it is based on a cause and so forth.

So we are able to develop these insights into the general characteristics of mind through close placement of mindfulness on the mind. This means also that we’re able to stop the reverse of these understandings. That is the ignorance. Through close placement and mindfulness on the mind we’re able to reverse all our ideas about the mind being permanent and unconceived and so forth and we’re able to be able to perceive it for what it is with its characteristics. And then having done that then we’re able to develop an understanding that sees through the extremes of self and of severance.

So that is eternalism and it’s got severing of self in the translation. Viteshala is saying severing all self. So that would be the extremes of nihilism and the extreme of existence. Once we’ve understood that there is no extreme of self or no extreme of nihilism then we have no fear about developing cessation or developing nirvana because or having nirvana come about because we aren’t clinging to our self and we have no fear of falling into nihilism either. Through meditating on close mindfulness of Dharma, we come to understand that thoroughly afflicted dharmas or neurotic phenomena are not compatible with understanding.

We also understand that pure dharmas or pure phenomena are antidotes to those afflictive dharmas or neurotic dharmas. Through this we develop the understanding or the means for reversing the harm that these negative things or the negative dharmas do. We’re able to develop the antidotes to these negative emotions or afflictive emotions. So in this way, we develop the path, the truth of the path. So this means that through these, we’re developing an understanding of the Four Noble Truths and we’re able to enter into the practice of the four noble truths.

I just didn’t want to make noise while I was moving around. The Distinguishing the Middle from the Extremes text by Maitreya, He then says that because grasping is the cause of the uncomfortable or the suffering states, and the base of this is Oh, no. Sorry. Yeah. Because the grasping is the cause for negative states or these uncomfortable states that we experience in saṃsāra and knowing this is a cause or acts as a base to get rid of ignorance understanding this is a reason to get rid of ignorance then the four noble truths need to be engaged in or the practice of the four noble truths needs to be engaged in.

In order to do this, then we need to practice the four close placements of mindfulness. Okay. So in in you guys’ translation here, they’ve left out the quotes. So I keep saying, this is from Distinguishing the Middle from the Extremes or this is from Samuccaya or whatever it is. They’re not in here.

They’re in here, but they’re not in here. So I’m just letting you know that we’re not making it up. Anyway, so then we’re on to the next one which is the nature of the four close placements of mindfulness. So the definition for the four close placements of mindfulness is the pristine awareness the I’m trying to remember what it’s Usually causes exalted knower in the other translations you’ve got. So exalted knower in the other translations.

And in this one it’s pristine awareness. Now the pristine awareness or the exalted knower entering the path or engaging in the path, which is either mindfulness or wisdom, wisdom meditating through investigation on both the specific and general characteristics of the four body feeling mind and Dharma. So this is the definition of close mindfulness. So this means that the investigation that takes place, the mindfulness that takes place or the wisdom that comes about through that mindfulness on the specific or general characteristics of, for example, body is said to be a close placement of mindfulness of body. The wisdom or mindfulness that comes about through investigating the specific and general characteristics of feeling and with these we’re talking about things like impermanence and so forth, the impermanence and so forth of feeling, then the wisdom or mindfulness that comes about then becomes a close mindfulness of feeling and so forth with mind and dharma.

Now the sources for these statements about the definition of four close placements of mindfulness come about from the Samuccaya or collected topics of Nāgārjuna. In this he says, mindfulness and wisdom are anything that understands their nature. And from the Abhidharmakośa Vasubandhu, it says, Wisdom or intelligence that is close placement. It says that close placement is intelligence or wisdom. Okay.

So the reason that we have both this wisdom or intelligence and mindfulness that come about through this process is that every time that we develop an understanding with regards to the things specific and general characteristics we’re meditating on, then that’s called a wisdom or an understanding. Along with this there comes a mindfulness because we’re being aware of the thing that we’re focusing on. So in this way, we experience both mindfulness and wisdom through the practice of the close mindfulnesses. Now the next one is the divisions. And so these are close mindfulness of bodies, feelings, mind, and phenomena.

So we know those are pretty easy. So where these things exist is from the path of accumulation. So the path of accumulation of the Mahāyāna path or Mahāyāna vehicle to the ground of the Buddha. So this means that all beings who have entered into our path and into the true paths and even in a Buddha’s in a Buddha’s continuum, you find the four place close placements of mindfulness. In actual fact, though, these four close placements of mindfulness are in the continuums of all beings on any of the paths.

So that means hearers and solitary realizers who are on the path of accumulation and upwards as well, there is the Four Close Placements of Mindfulness. This is because they are focusing on getting rid of cleaning up the self of persons and desires and so forth as well. Now etymology or the reason that this word is made up. Yeah. It’s a bit strange.

Anyway, so through wisdom being mindful of the focal object, there is close placement. Through not forgetting, it’s like through wisdom being mindful of the focal object, then it’s said to have close placement because wisdom investigating an object means that it has close placement on the object, right? And through not forgetting that close placement by focusing on it and not drifting off then you have mindfulness. So that’s called close placement of mindfulness. So in the difference between the close placements and mindfulness of the lesser vehicle practitioners and the greater vehicle practitioners, there is said to be fourteen differences that prove the greater vehicle to be supreme.

Okay. The first one of these says in the translation it says it focuses on the great vehicle. Now, there could be two different ways to translate this sentence in Tibetan. It could be translated as it focuses on the great vehicle or the focus on the great vehicle is greater. Does that make sense?

Geshe-la said it can be translated either way you can and it’s got a double meaning in it in the Tibetan which means that when you’re on the great vehicle then the focus is Buddhahood, so therefore that’s greater than liberation because if on the lower vehicle or the Hīnayāna, then the focus is liberation. So that’s not as great as yet. So the focus from that point of view isn’t as great. And it can also mean that you’re focusing on the great vehicle itself. So you’re not on the great vehicle, on something else here, focusing on the great vehicle.

And this is focusing on the practices as a great vehicle. So it has these two different meanings to it. He said I said, so it looks like there’s two different meanings to that sentence. He goes, there’s many meanings to it. You could talk pages about the meanings of that sentence.

Okay, so the next one, it says it is reliant on wisdom, and what this is referring to is that it is reliant on the wisdom perceiving emptiness directly or the wisdom perceiving emptiness. This doesn’t happen on the solitary realisers or hearers vehicle. On their path, they focus on the selflessness of the person. It’s reliant on a wisdom, but not the wisdom perceiving emptiness. It acts as an antidote to sixteen wrong engagements.

Okay. Now, it acts as an antidote to sixteen wrong engagements. Now, what that is referring to is what’s called the sixteen aspects of the four noble truths so we have the first one the truth of suffering there is impermanence suffering or misery, emptiness and selflessness and then for the other three then we have the truth of the origin of suffering then we have causes and conditions and so on that goes through all of those sixteen. Now these sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths are to be looked at from two different perspectives. You can look at the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths from the perspective of selflessness of the person or from the of the selflessness of phenomena that includes the selflessness of the person.

Now the beings on the lower parts, the parts of the solitary realizer and the parts of the hearers, they don’t have their insight into the selflessness of phenomena. So that means that they don’t have the complete antidote to the sixteen wrong engagements. They only have the antidote to one aspect of their sixteen wrong engagements that is the wrong engagements that refer to the selflessness of a person not towards the selflessness of phenomena. But from the Mahāyāna perspective then you have the antidote to sixteen wrong engagements completely. So that’s why it says it acts as an antidote to the sixteen wrong engagements.

Okay. So the next one, it enters a meditation on the four truths. Now this is just said from the same thing from a different perspective because the being on the solitary realisers path and the hearer’s path or vehicles. They actually meditate on the Four Noble Truths but they meditate on the Four Noble Truths with relation to the selflessness of the person not towards the selflessness of phenomena. In the Mahāyāna vehicle then practitioners meditate on the Four Noble Truths with relation to both selflessnesses the selflessness of the person and the selflessness of phenomena.

So when it says it enters meditation on the four truths, means in a complete way. And so this is another way of saying it acts as an antidote to the sixteen wrong engagements. There are two ways of saying the same.

Key terms in this teaching

Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top