Ornament for Clear Realisations – 33 2004 06 24 OCR

45 min · 2,883 words · 24 June 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 33 2004 06 24 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk continues an explanation of the nine supramundane paths from the Vaibhashika point of view, focusing on the absorption of cessation: who can generate it (only Aryas, not ordinary beings), how it is developed from the peak of cyclic existence, and how it differs from non-discriminatory meditative absorption. It then moves to the Cittamatra (mind only) account, describing non-discriminatory absorption as resting on the alaya consciousness after the other consciousnesses cease.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-06-24

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 6fa3469a-0c05-460e-af63-7b60aade8c79

Words: 2,879

The nine supramundane paths are actually explained from the point of view of four different schools, and we haven’t finished the first, which is particularist, the Vaibhāṣika School. We’re going through the different sections of that. We’ve done five sections out of nine, six, seven, eight, nine. Think there’s nine. The one we’re up to now is deciding in whose mind stream this is generated.

So we talked about the different types of people that generate this, and at the moment it is to differentiate whether this is actually we’re talking about here is absorption of cessation, whether that is generated in the minds of Aryas or in the minds of non Aryas in terms of other things. So this is all from the point of view of the Vaibhāṣika school. So from the point of view of the Vaibhāṣika school, then it’s only in the continuum of Ārya beings and never in the continuum of ordinary beings that absorption of cessation is developed. This is because the beings who haven’t realized selflessness directly are still grasping at the extreme of existence. There’s this extreme of existence and the extreme of nonexistence.

They’re still grasping at this extreme of existence or grasping the inherent self. Because they are hooked on that, then they can’t develop the absorption of cessation because they haven’t got the ability to get rid of the grasping mind that would inhibit them from developing it. So last week we were talking about the mental absorption which is non discriminatory. Do you remember there was a difference between absorption of cessation and the non discriminatory mental absorption. There was one that you had that led to the other, so non discriminatory meditational absorption leads to the absorption of cessation.

But non discriminatory meditational absorption, that was not in the minds of Aryas. It isn’t in the minds of aryas and the absorption of cessation is in the minds of aryas, so that’s the differentiation between them. Now, the reason for this is this non discriminatory meditative absorption which is like absorption of cessation but not the same thing, is based on a meditative equipoise focused on the body of an individual, what’s called the body which is the base for the being, the body which is the base for self. People who are able to do single pointed focused on the body, on their way to developing the idea of selflessness, have this nondiscriminatory meditative absorption but you can’t call that absorption of cessation. It’s not the same thing.

They’re a similar thing. They’re of a similar nature because they’re single point of concentration, but they’re not the same type of absorption. The reason for this is because absorption of cessation is based on the meditative concentration that is the peak of cyclic existence. Based on that, they’re able to perceive this. If you don’t have this type of absorption, you can’t have the absorption of cessation, and ordinary beings don’t have this.

Sorry. Yes, so they’re not focusing on their body in any old way. They’re focusing on the selflessness of the body, right? So, that’s a gross thing to be focusing on, is the selflessness of the body. It’s not considered a very subtle application.

It’s not a very subtle thing to be concentrating on. Whereas, the selflessness of the mind that is the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence is a very subtle thing to be focused on. So, on one thing you’re focusing on the selflessness of a body, alright? That’s even ordinary beings are able to do that. They may not have realized it directly but they’re able to do it.

In order to be able to be single pointedly focused as an application in meditative absorption on the selflessness of the mind that is the peak of cyclic existence, you need to be an Ārya. Is that okay? So basically, the two things are not the same because the object that is being on in terms of application, in terms of being able to produce joining the mind with the object is very different. In one instance, you have a focus on the selflessness of the physical body, and the other time you have a focus on the selflessness of the most subtle mind that you can develop, the peak of cyclic existence. The same following reasons, yeah?

So it’s about how subtle the difference is in how subtle the mind is. Then we need to find out where these things are, and the thing that we’re dealing with then is how they developed, the way to achieve this absorption of cessation. This is still from the point of view of the Vaibhāṣikas. Now they say that in general the way to achieve the absorption of cessation is through an application. And then once you have applied yourself to something, as in performed the application, then you develop a quality arising from application.

I don’t know if you remember this, but they also have qualities arising from meditation, qualities arising from hearing, qualities arising from contemplation in just normal teachings. Is a quality arising from application. This is in the mind of Ārya beings who have developed this absorption of cessation. Buddhas don’t particularly have this quality arising from application in their mind streams. The reason that they don’t have this quality arising from application in their mind streams is because the quality arising from application in the mind stream of an Ārya actually depends on the motivation with which they perform the application.

Buddhas don’t have a motivation because they already have achieved something. They have nothing to motivate towards, so they just are spontaneously working for the benefit of others. They’re not working in order to achieve Buddhahood, there’s no motivation there, if that makes sense. Because there was no motivation then that means that they don’t particularly have in their mind stream the quality that arises from application. In this case, the quality that rose from the application which develops the absorption of cessation.

They have the application, the quality arising from the application, but they have an understanding. They understand the qualities arising from the application and the results of that which comes along with their development of omniscience. But it’s not a particular thing that they have created the cause for. They have developed through this and once they achieve omniscience, it comes along with the shebang, it comes along with everything else. So, they don’t have the quality arising from the application which developed the absorption of cessation in their continuum, but they have an understanding of it which comes along with their omniscience.

Are you guys interested in what a group of Vaibhāṣikas from Kashmir said that was a bit different? There’s all different types of Vaibhāṣikas. There were like there’s heaps of them. Heaps of different schools in ancient India. Because most of the time when they talk about the tenet systems from Vaibhāṣika’s point of view, they’re actually talking about the people that wrote what’s called the Great Exposition, which was an explanation of the tenet systems from an ancient Indian philosophical school, which is the Vaibhāṣikas.

But there were different schools of Vaibhāṣikas. Were eighteen main ones, and they were all spread out all over ancient India. Some of them are in Kashmir. Oh, so but we’re gonna yeah. Guess there’s not. Okay, so the reason that most of the teachings that are given from the point of view of the Vaibhāṣika in the Tibetan system come from this school that was known because they were the authors of the great exposition.

The reason that most of the teachings come from them is because they were also the school that included some of the works of Vasubandhu, including the Abhidharmakośa, which is a really famous text. His works are included within that particular school, that’s why most of the tenet systems of the Vaibhāṣika come from the great expositional school of Vaibhāṣika. Now, from that text, there is a quote which explains the eighth point in this discussion. And the eighth point being, in which level or in which realm is this meditative absorption developed? Now, it’s said that in the main, this is developed based on a body or based on a base, which is either a form realm base or a desire realm realm base.

And from amongst those, most of the time it is first of all developed from a human base. So you can be born in a form realm or a human realm and develop this meditative concentration or this absorption of cessation, sorry. But most of the time it happens for the first time in the human form or based on the human form. The quote from the Abhidharmakośa which substantiates this or backs this up is it says, You are able to attain it having both the base of form and the base of the desire realm. But most of the time the first cessation comes about in the form of a human or when you’re a human.

So this is talking about the development of both the absorption which is non discriminatory, the absorption without discrimination in feelings we were talking about last week, and also the absorption of cessation. So that was the end of the explanation of the absorption of cessation, which is the only thing that’s different in the nine supramundane paths from the point of view of the Vaibhāṣika, yeah, or the particularists. And now we’re going to move on to the presentation from the point of view of the mind only or Cittamātra school. Okay. So we’re going to work through a quote then from the collected topics of Asaṇga to explain the Cittamātra’s point of view with regards to the absorption of this cessation.

Geshe-la just read it out and I can’t translate it for you just off the cuff. But he’s going to go through it line by line, which I think can translate it for you. We’re trying to do, like, a translation of a text like that straight off the cuff. The first line of this quote says, What is the meditative concentration without discrimination? So this is the one that ordinary beings have.

What is that? And then it starts off describing it by being something that is based on the absence of attachment or desire, which comes along with what’s called the expansion of virtue, which is third or fourth level, third level of the absorption of the third concentration. This is a form realm concentration, yeah? So based on this meditative concentration in this state, there is no desires that come up. Beings in the absorption of the fourth concentration and in the four formless absorptions don’t experience manifest desire. The place that they work on this, on getting rid of that manifest desire, is in the third concentration of the form realm.

By getting rid of desire, then they make their meditation subtler when they hit the formless realm meditations and the last meditation of the form realm. This is the way that the non discriminating absorption comes about is based on these concentrations of the form realm. Now, the actual absorption of cessation comes about based on cyclic existence, but the development sorry, but this is worked on, like the development of this absorption of cessation based on the absorption of peak of cyclic existence is worked on, is applied in the absorption of nothingness, which is the second one down, number seven. So you guys have still got your map, right? So by working on getting rid of desire or attachment on the third concentration, through the application of getting rid of desire in the third concentration, a being moves to the fourth concentration and develops a nondiscriminatory meditative absorption.

In the same way as through applying to subtle levels of meditation and the absorption of nothingness, you move on to the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence and therefore develop the absorption of cessation. So, through getting rid of desire, it’s the same pattern happening, yeah? Through getting rid of desire and the absorption of the third concentration, you move on to the fourth concentration and the development of the nondiscriminatory meditative concentration. Then in the formless realm you do a similar thing, and through developing the absorption of nothingness you move on to the absorption of the peak of cyclic existence and then develop of cessation. But after the third concentration, you don’t have desire, manifest desire.

Okay. So then the we have to explain the how the concentration of nondiscrimination comes about from the point of view of Mind Only School. Now, the concentration of non discrimination comes about in the fourth concentration of the form realm. The reason that it comes about in this realm is because at that stage, it manifests in the fact that not because of, it manifests in the fact that in the form concentration of the form realm, then you don’t have any desires. Now, this is said to come about through this way.

Based on a desire to get out of Samsāra, renunciation, then one is able to do a meditative practice where you put your mind or rest your mind in meditative absorption in what’s called the storehouse consciousness or the mind basis of all. This one. Okay. Right. Have you guys done Cittamātra stuff before at all?

You have? It’ll probably ring bells anyway because Chögyal Namkhai Norbu goes on about it a lot. In Cittamātra presentation of the way the mind works, there are eight different levels of mind. You have the five sense consciousnesses as the grossest levels of mind, and then below that or on a more subtler level is mental consciousness, and then you have what s called a thoroughly afflicted consciousness, and then what’s called the mind basis of all, or sometimes known by its Sanskrit term, alaya vijnana. Alaya as in Himalaya, it’s the same alaya, right?

So that’s the way they stack up. And so if you get rid of, because Cittamātra’s perceive that attachment comes from not seeing the non dual nature of things, the consciousness and the mind perceiving it. If you get rid of the first five of those, the sense consciousnesses, that allows the sixth consciousness, the mental consciousness, to subside, to not have any activity. And then, if you don’t have any of those six consciousnesses, then there is no thoroughly afflicted consciousness. There’s no neurotic consciousness left because the neurotic consciousness reacts based on the information it gets from the six other consciousnesses.

So all seven of them disappear, yeah, and you’re left in a concentration where you’re focusing on the mind basis of all, the Alaya Vijñāna. As you’re focusing on the alaya vijnana, that means that you are not experiencing desire. Yeah? And therefore, there’s no there’s no meant other gross consciousnesses happening. And this is how they say the lack of desire on the fourth concentration comes about.

That’s cool? Okay. Oh, yeah. That is. So, therefore, this Right.

Okay. So the definition from the Cittamātra’s point of view, mind only school’s point of view, of a nondiscriminatory meditative concentration or absorption is in dependence on the alaya vijnana, so seeing things from the point of view of the mind basis of all, right? Because all the other consciousnesses are being stopped. Then the cessation of the other six consciousnesses which leads to the cessation also of the neurotic or thoroughly afflicted consciousness, focusing on that cessation of that in the continuum of an ordinary being, is the definition of the nondiscriminatory meditative concentration from the point of view of the Cittamātra school. Does that make sense?

Do you want me to say it again? Okay. Right. It is the Yeah, yeah. in dependence on the mind basis of all, right?

So, using that as your mind to look at stuff for it, yeah? Then, the stopping or the cessation of the six consciousnesses, which brings about the cessation of the neurotic consciousness, right? The stopping of that, and so therefore you’re focusing on the stopping of that, yeah? So the thing you’re focusing on is a non associated compositional factor. The cessation of that is neither a mind nor a form, yes?

So you’re focusing on the cessation of that. Focusing on the cessation of these gross minds based on the mind basis of all, this process happening in the continuum of an ordinary being is the definition of the non discriminatory meditative concentration. If you’ve got calm abiding. If you’ve got calm abiding, you can do it. You can keep your mind concentrated on these things, and you’re able to stop your So, that was the preliminary to the absorption of cessation, which is this non discriminatory concentration we’ve been talking about in conjunction with these descriptions of the absorption of cessation.

And now we’re onto the real thing, and it has six parts in its outline. In Tibetan text, and you’ve probably seen this when we have the straight translations, they have lots of headings. Geshe-la just read out the headings that are involved. I’ll just give you a brief overview of the headings.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top