44 min · 2,924 words · 20 May 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Commentary on the Abhisamayalankara and its sources, covering the eight requisites of the Arya path likened to rain, the thirty-seven aspects, and the thirty-four aspects harmonious with bodhisattvas. It explains the three doors of liberation (emptiness, signlessness, wishlessness) as antidotes, and uses illusion and magical-illusory-body examples to show how phenomena lack inherent existence while still appearing.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-05-20
Duration: 45 min
UUID: b85f70dc-a934-49ec-83de-5739d259a137
Words: 2,920
So so then we have this quote from the Uttaratantra that explains what it goes into detail about what was just a rough explanation of the way that water acts as a metaphor for these a prerequisites. It says just as very many tastes occur from water issuing from a cloud as cool, delicious, smooth or light, or through being related to a place with salty ground, etc. So just like water from a cloud can become all different types. It can be transformed because of the situation it finds itself in, whether it’s on salty ground or whatever. So too, the rainwater of the eight requisites of the Ārya Path.
So these eight requisites are said to be a metaphor. So rainwater is supposed to be a metaphor for the eight requisites. Okay. So it says issue from the heart of the spacious cloud, the the the good spacious cloud, Geshe-la says it says in I said, well, it says compassion in the translation. And he said, where did they get compassion in?
What’s compassion got to do with it? It’s like they’re talking about rain. Why would they think it was compassion? They’re talking about rain. Okay.
So yeah. Because it says that okay. So in Tibetan, it’s got this word that’s like that’s translated here as compassion. Mhmm. But Geshe-la says, it just means a good cloud because you need a good cloud, otherwise, you don’t get good water.
Right? So that’s strange. Yeah. Because it’s yeah. So it’s not he’s got it’s like a good this I don’t know what the heart of the spacious cloud.
Alright. He’s like, Mhmm. But but the heart can mean essence can’t it? So basically, what it was saying is the essence of a cloud is water, right? And so if you have a good spacious cloud I don’t know if spacious comes from either.
If you have a very powerful cloud or a very big cloud, right, then it’s gonna have a lot of good water come out of it. It’s a clean cloud. It has clean water, so and the essence of the cloud is actually the water. Right? That’s all it says.
No compassion. And comes to pass many different tastes through the different various migrators’ continuum. So it’s like man. I’ve confused myself now because it’s, like, difficult working between two things that don’t seem to add up. Okay.
So he said, basically, all that it’s saying is it’s good water. Because good water comes from good clouds. If you have like, it’s like rainwater, basically. It’s another way of saying rainwater. It’s got nothing to do with compassion or clouds of compassion or anything or, in fact, much else.
It’s just saying that it’s rain water. So if we tell you. And so in Tibetan, it says that which comes out of no. That which comes out of the essence of the vast and vast and good clouds. Right?
And he said, that’s just poetry. So just a poetic way of saying it’s water. It’s a poetic way of saying water. Okay. Okay.
So that’s the description of these eight requisites the Ārya Path. Now, all thirty seven dharmas compatible with enlightenment, which are also the minds that are compatible with hearers solitary realizers minds, but are in the continuum of Ārya Bodhisattvas and Ārya Buddhas. Yeah? Ārya Buddhas right? These are all obtained fully on the path of seeing.
That means that these last two, is the eight requisites of the Ārya path and the seven requisites of enlightenment they are talked about conceptually because you work more with requisites of the Ārya path on the path of meditation than you do with it on the path of seeing. And on the path of seeing, you work more with the seven limbs of enlightenment. But they’re all fully obtained on the path of seeing. So the backup for this is from the Sūtra Alamkara this time, where it says, all varieties of aspects compatible with the enlightenment of the conquerors and their sons. Yeah.
So that’s Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, asserted to be simultaneously with the path of perceptual seeing, as opposed to seeing. Thirty seven aspects. Yeah. And also from Sūtra Alamkara says, Entering the ground is called the principle of the requisites. What that, I suppose, means is it is called so it says that the principles, the prerequisites of enlightenment are attained when you enter the ground, and entering the ground is another way of saying that you achieve a true path, which is path to seeing.
Okay. Right. So thus, in the abbreviated explanation of the many of these, there are thirty seven aspects of the path of all knowing awareness for learners. So, sorry. I was just trying to understand whatever that meant.
So, that means that we have finished the thirty seven aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects harmonious with hearers and solitary realizers. And now, we go on to the thirty four aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects harmonious with Bodhisattvas. So, basically, the other thing to remember is that the thirty seven aspects of an exalted, knower of all aspects harmonious with hearers and solitary realizers is talking about knowers of bases. And what we’re doing going to deal with now, the the thirty four aspects that are harmonious with bodhisattvas is referring to knowers of paths. Of course.
So within these thirty four aspects that are harmonious with bodhisattvas. We have three paths of antidotes that are in the continuum of the Buddha superior, three paths of manifestations, five paths that abide in happiness in this present life, nine supra mundane paths, four paths of abandoning, and ten paths of Buddhahood. Sorry, it said, thought it said, The paths of Buddhahood, which are six, and then it goes, But it says ten, and it goes, What are you talking about? And it says, Which are six means that which are the six divisions, not that there are six paths. Anyway, Okay.
So we’re up to these thirty four aspects of an exalted knower. Yeah? And first of all, there has to be a source for our understanding of these thirty four aspects of an exalted knower. According to the commentary, this is from Haribhādra, his commentary on the Clear Ornament of Realization. In this, he just gives a brief quote from him that will go into more details later.
So, just to say that that s the source of all of this. So, then it says, what these things that we re going to deal with are called, the thirty four aspects aspect, so that is the parts of a Buddha s mind which are their nature or they are harmonious with or they accord with the realizations of Bodhisattvas. Then and the first one of these is what’s called the three parts of antidotes. Now I was just getting completely confused. I’m saying, I think it’s time to stop, and Geshe-la goes, okay.
Alright. Because it doesn’t there’s no translation direct translation for this. It’s just notes on it, so that’s why I was like, I’m right. Okay. So these are three parts of antidotes.
I know it says here that the the three parts that we’re talking about here is emptiness, signlessness, and wishlessness. But it actually starts off in the commentary we’re giving an explanation of these as opposed to going into their names. Right? So the first one, the first one is Okay. Yes.
So Geshe-la is just demonstrating that he has memorized this commentary by Haribhādra and says, you know, this bit where it goes, that’s the bit where you have to sing this. Right? But we don’t have to sing that. No. What it actually says is and if we find the Haribhādra, we actually have Haribhādra’s commentary in here somewhere.
So if we find that for next week and we can go over it again. But what it says is the antidote which hang on. It says, the path of antidote which comes about because of the view, right, is the first antidote. And that’s actually referring to this emptiness where it says three doors of liberation that are parts of emptiness, yeah? So, if you develop an understanding of the view, you have an antidote, right?
That’s the first one. The view being the view of emptiness. Okay. And the reason for this is that you have correct or you have a perfect comprehension and that’s what’s talking about Yeah? And which it comes about through this this view of emptiness.
And then, through having seen this, then all of the phenomena of the three realms So therefore, all the phenomenon of the three realms are seen not seen as being anything that is wished for, and therefore, that’s the third antidote which is wishlessness. And these actually come about in Wish, wish, wish, Wish, wish, wish, So these actually come about in order, So you develop this idea of emptiness, the view of emptiness and then, by the way of that, then you develop the antidote which is signlessness, seeing that there is nothing to that you need to have a sign for. And then from that, then you develop this idea of wishlessness, but we can go into it more next week. K. I asked if you guys were allowed to ask questions, and he said no.
Oh, sure. I think he’s joking. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. So and then the. Mhmm. Okay. So you can actually have this wheel representing two different things.
It can represent the three three higher trainings, and it can represent the eightfold path. And it can represent how the eightfold path subsumes into the three higher trainings as well. I guess, as I said, that’s this isn’t the only two things that are represented by this wheel. There’s many other things that the wheel is used to as an analogy for or an example of. Okay.
Very good. Yes. Tasty? Hey? Yeah.
What? Tasty. I tried delicious, but we decided to go back to tasty. I tried that, but it comes out weird if you the yum or yum is a the it’s like an honorific word for mother. It’s a bit strange.
Yeah. Yeah. Yep. I’m sure he is. I’m I’m just trying to remember the word, but Okay.
There is different types of illusory body and different types of magical illusory body. And which you when you’re having dreams, you have a magical illusory body in your dreams because it’s not real. Does that make sense? That any deep body that you have in your dreams is said to be a magical illusory body because it’s not real. And anything that happens to that body doesn’t really happen.
Yeah. So it means that the word that is it means like fake in terms of magic and not like it’s particularly good. This word that means magical illusory doesn’t necessarily mean good. It means fake. Yeah.
Yeah. In tantra, you’re having to emanate a body. Yeah. So, it’s something that people are able to emanate through tantric practices. And we actually did it in here at one stage as well where there was like it was said to be like a mirage and like a magical illusory body which is something that has been generated by mantra, in that it s not real.
So, you re supposed to it s one of the ways of practicing meditation on emptiness to view everything as being magical, like a sorcerer s con whatever. What is a thing a sorcerer sorcerer conjures? The conjure Yeah. But there’s another one that’s like the star. Yeah.
But yeah. The the yeah. But it but the illusion thing has it from your side. Yeah. There’s another word that means the thing that they’ve created.
Yeah. Maybe like that. So, it’s like something that the conjurer has made up that you’ve Yeah. The thing that’s conjured. Right?
That we’ve It’s an illusion that we fall for. That’s a magical illusory body. There you go. It’s a magical illusion. He said it’s even like things that that, you know, that there’s lots of people that are through doing mantra and everything can create things like that and he thinks that happens a fair bit in India, like people doing tricks and stuff.
But he’s also said, even taking into account things like television and whatever, anything that’s created from something that shows you that you look at and it’s not really it, then it’s made from some kind of magic and is illusory. Yeah, or television. Yeah. Yeah. So it’s like If we think, yes.
Not if we think. Not that we think that it is like we think that not that things don’t exist, but they don’t exist in a solid way that we see them. We see that the so we’re actually looking at the that we’re looking at the inherent existence that we which is the way that we see things as a conjurer’s trick. So not existence as a conjurer’s trick, but our labeling it as being solidly existent as a conjurist trick. Sorry.
I was just saying, Geshe-la, because I heard that all the time up at retreat. I could hear Lama Zopa saying, we have to see our grasping and inherent existence as a hallucination, and then come out and everyone outside was saying, this isn’t real, this isn’t a hallucination, which isn’t what he said. Scott Geshe-la just said as well, Geshe-la said, Yeah, yeah, yeah. It’s not the appearance as a hallucination. It’s our view of the appearance as being inherently existence that is a hallucination.
So the problem, if you say that something is an illusion and it’s only created by mind, right, then it ceases to exist. Okay? And so it becomes a near nihilism. That’s why they they say it’s like an illusion, not that it is an illusion. But the thing that’s So the reason that they use all of these examples is because when we look at an illusion or when we look at a mirage or when we look at any what was the other one?
Illusion, mirage, or a conjurer’s trick. Right? Now, illusion is something that isn’t necessarily conjure but something we know isn t really there, then we know it s not inherently existent but we still see it, we can still interact with it, we can still perceive it. It doesn t disappear into nothingness, yeah? So, we re able to perceive it and see that it is, but we don’t hold onto this idea of it being inherently the existence solid thing, and that’s what we’re hallucinating.
That’s what we’re mistaken with, right? So, that’s why they keep using all of these examples is because it gives us this insight into it that it doesn’t disappear, but the way that we perceive that it exists disappears. Yeah. So, our grasping an inherent existence disappears. And that and then and then we can interact with it in the same way that we would interact with an illusion.
Knowing it’s yes. So so the inherent existence isn’t there. Yeah. So actually, it’s weak. Okay.
So it’s it’s it’s interesting because there’s because I was saying it’s the two there’s two different levels of reality, and there’s ultimate reality, and then there’s a relative truth. Right? So we have ultimate truth and relative truth. Now the word for relative truth in Tibetan is like it’s either it says thoroughly hidden or thoroughly fake. Yeah?
So it’s like that means it appears and everything happens, but it doesn’t have an inherent an ounce of inherent truth, the way that we perceive it is as it does have an inherent truth. So it would be like he thinks that someone did a conjurous trick and made his rice disappear, And then all of a sudden it was back and it was gone and then it was back and I was like, how did that happen? Geshe-la said it’s not as if it’s not just by our it’s not just by us labeling things that things come into existence. It’s by valid cognition that things come into existence. So, he says that you could label something as something and it may not be valid cognition, so therefore, doesn’t exist relatively.
And I may see something through valid cognition, means that it exists relatively. And if something exists through valid cognition, then it exists relatively. It’s not an illusion. And again, like, what do you mean? So, Geshe-la said, you can’t necessarily say that he can see something with valid cognition or I can see something with valid cognition and therefore, that thing becomes a relatively existent thing as opposed to something that isn’t true, which is an illusion.
So he said, But the Buddha doesn’t have anything but valid cognition. Valid cognition is this whole area of study, which is called pramāna as well. It means whether something is valid or not, establishing whether something is valid or not. The Buddha can see everything that’s valid, cognizes everything that’s valid, and doesn’t cognize anything that isn’t valid. So that’s the mark of whether something becomes valid or not.
So we also experience valid cognition but we have invalid cognition as well. So something relatively exists or not depending on whether the Buddha perceives it or not. Something, then it doesn’t exist.
Key terms in this teaching
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- illusory body gyu lu (Tib)
- A subtle body generated through practice of the completion stage of Highest Yoga Tantra; the cause of the rupakaya. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
- three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
- The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.