Ornament for Clear Realisations – 31 2004 06 18 OCR

44 min · 3,102 words · 18 June 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 31 2004 06 18 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk begins with the right motivation for listening and practice, then introduces the nine supramundane paths: four form-realm concentrations, four formless absorptions, and the absorption of cessation. It explains the absorption of cessation from the Hinayana hearer tenets, drawing on Vasubandhu’s Abhidharma. The absorption is described as a non-discriminating person and mind, with the cessation of gross discrimination and feeling, and its characteristics and karmic results are outlined.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-06-18

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 71f5158c-79a0-4903-bc05-7957a2adfc99

Words: 3,098

We need to develop the right motivation for listening to the teachings. Not only just listening to these teachings, but whatever we do, whether it’s listening, contemplating or meditating, we should try and develop the right motivation for doing that. The right motivation for us to do these things is to have the idea that whatever it is we’re doing should be a cause for us to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. When we say the benefit of all sentient beings, we mean that we may be a cause for all beings to achieve enlightenment. So I guess I said, okay.

So you’ve got a good motivation now. He doesn’t have to explain him the what motivation you should have because you’re not beginners. And you’ve already meditated. And I said, What’s the definition of a beginner in this instance? And he said, Someone who doesn’t know the right motivation.

Okay. So this evening, beginning to talk about what are called the nine supra mundane paths. When it says supra mundane, what mundane means is non ārya. So anything below the path of seeing is said to be a mundane path, and supra is anything that is above that. Another way that you could say this would be all otherworldly or unworldly paths, so it could be nine unworldly paths or nine super mundane paths.

Now the nine super mundane pas are the four concentrations of the form realm, the four absorptions of the formless realm, and the absorption of cessation. When we talk about these nine different paths, the first four are the four concentrations of the form realm. They’re also called the paths that don’t abide in that. What that is referring to is another way of saying the paths that don’t abide in worldly existence. So in this way they are ārya paths as opposed to worldly paths. That’s what this is talking about. These are ārya paths which accord with the four concentrations of the form realm.

The next four are the four absorptions of the formless realm. The ninth one of these is the absorption of cessation. Now the absorption of cessation isn’t actually an absorption. It is a non associated compositional factor like we were talking about last week. So in this instance it’s called a supermundane path even though it’s not a path because it is a non associated compositional factor and therefore not a mind and therefore not a path.

Alright. Okay. Now I couldn’t yeah. When we’re talking about these nine super mundane paths, they’re explained in a number of different ways. We can explain the nine super mundane paths from the point of view of the hero’s school or hero’s philosophy.

So there’s a difference between a school and a philosophy that they espouse or their tenets. So we can explain the nine supra mundane paths from the point of view of the tenets of the hero’s school. We can explain them from the tenets of mind only school. We can explain it from the tenets of Prāsaṇgika and also from the tenets of the Svatāntrika school. So first of all, we’re going to explain it or go through it from the point of view of the Hīnayāna school, the hearer school, which is the particularists and the sūtra followers, so the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika schools.

This position is espoused through two different things. First of all, a quote from the Abhidharma of Vasubandhu and then an explanation of that quote. Now I can’t find a translation of this quote, right? So this is going to be a dodgy translation, just to give you a rough idea. Okay.

So we have the conceptualization which is a person without conceptualization. No. Sorry. We have the person without conceptualization. Now this conceptualization that we’re referring to here is one of the five aggregates.

You talk about it’s called discrimination or conceptualizing. Okay? I’ll try saying discrimination and see if that works for now. It’s a mental factor that’s seeing how good something is or discriminating to what it is, and has an idea about something. First of all, have the person who doesn’t have this discrimination, and then there is the mind that doesn’t have this discrimination.

And then we have the ripening through these things, right? Then we have the ripening of the non associated compositional factor, which is the absorption of cessation, which comes about because of these two things. Yeah? Because of the lack of discrimination and because of the person without discrimination. Along with these things we then have a meditative absorption.

These are based upon the meditation that is one of the absorptions of the fourth concentration. Within the absorption fourth concentration there’s eight. This is a virtuous mind. Through the development of this virtuous mind, non aryas are able to achieve in one instant the cessation of the cessation that is like the cessation that is like the peak of the cessation sorry. The cessation based on the absorption.

The peak of cyclic existence. So basically we’re talking about can’t translate it all because it’s way complicated and it goes into an explanation it anyway. Therefore, beings can use these in order to develop realizations or they can use them for their own ends, and different beings use these things for different things, so it’s distinguishing which are the things that Aryas use them for and which are the things that they don’t use them for. Okay. So I’m sorry if I I I couldn’t find the translation for that, and it was way too complicated for me to be off the top of my head, this translation from.

But it doesn’t matter that much because it goes into a main page explanation of what the quote actually says anyway. Is this it’s a battery again, Joe? It’s battery. I’m a do that. Right.

I have to remember what it was about. Tajis. Oh, yeah. No. He said someone put new ones in his room.

Yeah. Right. Yeah. So I’m really one. He said, You’d finished.

Was like, I didn’t start! And this quote isn’t in any of the notes we have here because these notes: basically these notes only refer you know how we said that there’s all the different explanations of these nine Supramundane paths, right? There’s like the Hīnayāna explanation, the Cittamātra explanation, the Prāsaṇgika explanation and the Svatāntrika presentation. The notes only really talk about Svatāntrika presentation. The book that we have and what Geshe-la is explaining is the other people’s explanation.

So we start off with the Hīnayāna explanation, the hearer’s explanation for the nine super mundane paths. This explanation is taken from a text called Abhidharma by a man called Vasubandhu, which was written from the point of view of the Hīnayāna, which the quote is very scary in terms of grammar and everything, so I couldn’t translate it very quickly. But it starts off this explanation of what’s in the quote by saying that it refers to three things when it’s talking about the absorption of cessation and it’s talking about the process of these super mundane paths, but more specifically about the absorption of cessation. Now it refers to three things: first of all, the being who has achieved this lack of discrimination, right? It cuts off their gross minds, their gross minds and mental factors.

Absorption lacks these mental factors, that is discrimination and feeling and the lack of those things, the cessation of those things. So we have a person, we have a mind, and we have a cessation. Is that cool? Now, when we talk about the first one, we’re talking about the being who has gotten rid of gross discrimination and feeling and therefore is experiencing very subtle states of mind and is the absorption of cessation and the absorption of peak cyclic existence. Now this being has certain characteristics, and we have to go through the characteristics to find out what they are.

The first one is that this being is said to be an autonomously existent substance. The reason it’s an autonomously existent substance is because the tenet systems assert that physical form is a autonomously existing substance. Okay. So the next characteristic of the being that has this lack of discrimination, the lack of this mind, this mental factor of discrimination, is that they possess what’s called direct or I’m sorry. I’m having a mental blank.

What’s the opposite of Manifest. Manifest. Woah. I’m sitting there going, word will come. The word will come.

Right. They don’t have manifest or arising minds and mental factors. So it’s back to this thing of they don’t have the gross minds arising in their continuum. They don’t have these manifests. They have what’s called a subtle mind that’s behind everything else but they don’t have this idea of these manifest minds coming up and changing and so forth.

In this meditation, s based on its very subtle form. In this way, we say that they don t have discrimination, so that being without discrimination, without this mind discriminating between this and that, then they don have the mental factors and the minds that are associated with discrimination and feelings. And so this being is an embodied being but doesn’t have the experiences associated with being an embodied being. We experience feelings and discrimination based on our physical form, which are gross feelings and discriminations. We experience illness and sore backs and things like that.

Because these beings are in a single point of concentration in this way and are dealing with this very subtle mind and they don’t have discrimination, it means that they don’t have any minds arise that are reaction or come about from their body, their gross mind. So these beings also have the because they are a being which has a lack of discrimination, it means that they are in possession of the equipoise, which is the absence of discrimination. So we talked about how there was a being and a mind and then a non associated compositional factor which was a cessation, right? So the beings are in possession of the minds that we talked about. The non discriminatory beings have a meditative equipoise of non discrimination which they are the result of.

So they turn into a being without discrimination based on their meditative equipoise that is non discriminatory. The reason that they are able to do this is because they have a basis of meditation which is one of the levels of the absorption of the fourth concentration from the form realm. Based on that meditative concentration they develop this nondiscriminatory meditative equipoise And if they were to die in that state, they have created the causes for being reborn in the absorption of the fourth concentration, which is a form existence. Okay. So the level of absorption that they would be born into if they were to die in this state, and the level of meditative absorption that they use, that is used to develop this non discriminatory equipoise is what’s called the great result.

The great result is one of the eight different sections of the fourth concentration. Within the four concentrations you have seventeen different levels. Three for the first, three for the second, three for the third, and eight for the fourth. And from amongst those eight, this great result, yeah, is the third. This one.

So there’s five characteristics that are associated with this being that we’re talking about here that’s used to describe the Hīnayāna or the hearer’s tenant’s position on absorption of cessation. This is the person. So the five characteristics are: It is an autonomously existing substance two. The being is an autonomously existing substance three. They are not experiencing any manifest minds or mental factors.

They do not experience any of the gross feelings that come about in relation to the body. They have become a nondiscriminatory person based on the development of the nondiscriminatory meditative equipoise. Once they have that in their continuum, therefore they are the nondiscriminatory person. The level of meditation for this person is said to be the great result, which is the third out of the eight levels of the fourth concentration of form realm. And if they were to die in this meditative experience, they would be born in that realm.

Right. Alright. Alright. Sorry. Just got I was trying to remember.

The next thing we’re dealing with here is the path, which is the meditative absorption of nondiscrimination. Now the meditative absorption of nondiscrimination is defined by certain characteristics in the same way as the being who has this absorption in their continuum is defined by certain characteristics that we just went through. The first of these characteristics is that it is a substantially existing substance which is based on the cessation of gross mental factors that arise in dependence on That depends that that that depends on the being the physical being of the being that we just talked about before. They consider minds and discrimination to be a substantially existent thing, an autonomously existent thing in this tenet systems. So the cessation of those types of minds, equipoise that is getting rid of those types of minds and the lack of the experience of mind and mental factors that relate to the body is one of the characteristics of this equipoise.

So this equipoise does not get interfered with by experiences and sensations of the body. And it is a substantially existent autonomous thing. The next characteristic of this meditative equipoise that is the nondiscriminatory meditative equipoise is that it is based on a definitive arising or renunciation from saṃsāra. If there is no renunciation from saṃsāra then you can’t develop this particular type of nondiscriminatory meditative equipoise because you need to have realized the faults of saṃsāra and then not have any attraction or repulsion from the things of saṃsāra so you won’t get distracted or taken away from what it is that you’re meditating on. It also is used in order to achieve liberation, and so if you don’t have renunciation then you can’t be working towards liberation.

The basis for this meditation or this meditative equipoise is renunciation. This meditative equipoise is also virtuous by its nature because the motivation for using this meditative equipoise is renunciation. If something is motivated by renunciation, then that action becomes virtuous. So therefore, this is a virtuous action. It is by its nature virtuous.

So another way that we describe this is that it is by its karma, or the cause that it creates, the result that it creates. It’s said to be a generating experience or a generating cause. So we have three different types of karma in this description. The Abhidharma description of karma here that karma can be a generating or birth karma, and that generates the cause for being reborn in the next life somewhere. It can be an abiding karma, which means that you experience the results of it in the lives to come.

And it can also be a karma s seen now that it s experienced in this lifetime. Now this kind of mind, this meditative equipoise, is actually said to be a generating karma in that it creates the causes to be born in the fourth level of the form realm, the fourth concentration of the form realm. So this way we say that it’s a generating karma. Because it is something that creates the causes for a being to be born or to generate, then it is said to be a meditative equipoise that is engaged in by ordinary beings and not Ārya beings. Ārya beings are beyond karmic compulsion to be reborn into saṃsāra and therefore can choose their own rebirth.

And because this meditation is something that causes one to be reborn on the fourth level of the form realm, then it’s something that cannot be associated with aryas. Now, one may ask, as I did, why then it is under the heading of nine Supramundane Paths, which are all ārya paths? And Geshe-la replied that in order to understand the different schools’ descriptions of what this meditative absorption is and the absorption of cessation. So in order to understand the different ways that these different schools or the different tenet systems approach this concept of absorption and the different types of absorption that are described in them. So with relation to the third one, which is this actual cessation, the equanimity that is actual cessation, which is absorption of cessation, is described in nine different headings within this text.

The first one is what type of cessation is ceased. What the mind does in this equanimity, what ground it is based on, what type of the three different collections of virtue it is associated with which one of the generating, abiding and experienced types of karma it is associated with an analysis of whether it is in the continuum of an ordinary being or an aarya, the way that it is achieved, which of the three realms it is analysis of which of the three realms these equipoise exists in. So the first one of these is gakta kang gopah. What is to say that it This one. So the first thing is what is ceased?

So, in the same way as in the previous two things that we were dealing with, being who has no discrimination and the meditative equipoise that do not have discrimination, in the same way that both of these things don t generate main mind and mental factors in a gross way, that they remain as a subtle meditative state, then also the absorption of cessation does not have these gross mental states associated with it either. What is actually cessation then? The things that are said to be cessation are the gross experiences of discrimination and feeling. Okay. So this is the presentation that the Hīnayāna tenet systems put forward.

The man who is writing this text says he agrees with this because feelings and discrimination are both said to be ever present mental factors that accompany a mind. If you have a mind, then you have feelings and discrimination along with that mind. In mind and mental factors, there is talk about the five ever present factors. Yes, feelings and discrimination are from there. If you have no feelings and discrimination then you don’t have any gross minds that are associated with these.

If you’re talking about a mind without discrimination or feeling,

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top