Ornament for Clear Realisations – 25 2004 05 20 OCR

41 min · 2,718 words · 20 May 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 25 2004 05 20 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk continues a commentary on the eight requisites (eight correct aryan path factors), which are condensed into four groups: analysis, understanding, conviction in others, and antidotes to incompatible states. It explains how these factors are developed mainly on the path of meditation, and uses the image of the wheel, the water-and-vessel analogy from the Uttaratantra, and the differing strength of these qualities across the three types of beings.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-05-20

Duration: 42 min

UUID: fda73bab-82d1-4f68-adec-f649282fbc52

Words: 2,714

So, we were going through the the way that the eight requisites yeah. The eight requisites or the eight aspects of the aarya path of the eight aarya correct paths can be subsumed into four. And then we’re up to the bit where it said from the from the differentiating the extreme from the middle, which is a text by Maitreya. It says through analysis and activating understanding, and three aspects activate conviction in others. Three act as antidotes of incompatible states.

Requisites of the path are eight. Then, after that, there’s another quote commentary we have that hasn’t been translated, and that’s from the Sutralankara. Okay. So, yeah, Sutralankara, which is the Ornament of the Sutras, which is also by Maitreya. And in this, says that so below this or in like manner, that there s different ways of developing analysis or there s different ways of developing investigation.

You can have investigation that s put afterwards, so that s an understanding comes after placement. Then, you can have an understanding that comes with placement. And then, you can have an understanding that comes Sorry. Sorry. Sorry.

Sorry. You can have an understanding that comes through placement meditation, through putting the mind in a meditative state, through I’ve got a mental blank on the word. That’s it! Okay, that’s not a good start. Anyway, there’s analysis that comes from meditative equipoise or investigation that comes from meditative equipoise that develops after that.

There’s analysis that is like meditative equipoise. So, we’re talking about things like vipaśyanā or that there. Then we also have analysis in Meditative Equal Poise. You have these three different types. From these, there’s all a form of the correct perfect version of this.

This is referred to that which is correct to be known, that which is a correct path and the development of qualities. It says meditate on the antidotes to the obscurations. It’s just saying that these eight can also be seen of as being one of three different things. You can be analyzing things as a meditative state, like a meditative state or in a meditative in meditative equipoise. It’s just like a little add on that isn’t in the translation for some reason.

Anyway, in order to summarize meaning, the first thing is the correct view is the requisite of thorough analysis because it is thorough analysis which is equipoise comprehension. Sure, That makes sense. Okay, so this next bit is actually related to that quote from the Sūtra Lamkara because it says, Correct view, which is the view of emptiness, meditating on emptiness, is the requisite of thorough analysis or is the limb or the correct path of thorough analysis because it is through analysis which is equipoise comprehension. What that means is that you settle your mind in meditative equipoise through calm abiding or śamatha and then you investigate that situation through vipaśyanā or special insight. That’s how you develop the direct insight into emptiness, and that’s why the correct view is said to be it is said to be analysis in equipoise.

Yes. Okay. So the next one says investigation is a requisite activating understanding because motivated by investigation one activates understanding speech. So what this means is investigation or correct investigation is said to be the limb or the cause which is activating understanding or that is activating understanding could work there because if you have this idea of investigating something then you have the ability to understand what is being said, that is how emptiness is being described. If go into that with this investigative mind, you’re able to comprehend when the people are explaining emptiness.

Now the next three, which is the requisite of the aria path of correct speech, correct livelihood, correct limb of action, and correct livelihood, are said to be the limb or the group of things that activate develop conviction in others. Reason that speech is included within this group is that through the action of being able to explain emptiness, then you develop understanding and you develop correct view in others. So this the next one, which is the limb of actions or the the correct action, performing the correct actions means doing actions that are virtuous and abstaining from doing actions that are non virtuous. So through these things then beings are able to develop to to show others the way that they need to act. They’re able to explain ethics through their actions of doing positive things and not doing negative things.

This one. Okay. So, the The next one is the livelihood using dharma robes in the way permitted generates conviction that articles are being protected. So now what that refers to is that if now sorry. I’ve got to ask something else because it doesn’t make sense.

Yeah. So I’m just having to ask because it doesn’t make sense. It’s the way that Geshe-la’s explaining it doesn’t fit with the translation. So I’m trying to get now I’m trying to find a way of translating in between the two. Okay.

So Geshe laz thinks that this word that is translated here is livelihood livelihood actually means investigation. Now So and they said that the the investigation, the one they’ve translated is investigation, which kind of makes sense in that instance because it’s understanding. It’s more like understanding. Okay? So, he said, once you engage in this one here, which is here, livelihood, right?

But he’s saying it’s more like investigation, then you develop understanding, which is like the second one. Does that make sense? Alright. Okay. So so you said that yeah.

This this one that’s trend let’s let’s try and think of a way of doing this. Investigation is looking at things at and trying to find it in an understanding way. You’re looking at things and you’re cultivating understanding, but before you’re able to cultivate that understanding or activate that understanding, you have to investigate and you have to investigate and what you should do, what you shouldn’t do, what’s going to give good benefits and what’s not going to be beneficial. This is mainly talking to monks, It’s telling them to know how to be a good monk, or know how to have which is investigate what it is that they should do is the way that they’ve explained that he’s saying what livelihood is. Instead of livelihood, it’s investigate what you need to do.

After you’ve investigated what you need to do, then the second one, which is investigation, will be developed. Okay. So he says, what happens is first of all, you’re investigating, which is this one here. You’re seeing what it is you have to do and investigating what will bring happiness and what will progress you, make you progress along the path, right? And once you’ve investigated that, then you understand which is number two, which is here is investigate, okay?

Once you’ve understood, then you’re able to protect, right? Which is like protect your vows, protect yourself from doing negative things, yeah? And that’s the limb of action. So the order it goes is five, two, four. Does that make sense?

So five is you develop the correct you have them correct in say livelihood or correct investigation or correct the correct approach to things. And then number two is you develop understanding. You have the correct understanding. And then from that, you have the correct actions which is number four. Okay.

So I said that it’s got the one that’s the way that it’s translated, this word toa, right, is as a livelihood. And Geshe-la said, yeah, investigating what you should do and what you shouldn’t do. Yeah? And I went, No, it’s actually what you’re doing. And he said, Well, what you’re doing is the limit of action.

That’s the ethics aspect of it, so that can’t be livelihood for the next one because it’s the same thing. That means that livelihood and limited action would be the same thing. Those two limbs would be the same thing. Does that make sense? Sorry about that.

So it means that maybe he changed the second one to understanding and the last and the livelihood one to investigation. So the last three are then subsumed into the requisite or the causes, which are antidotes, because they act as antidotes on incompatible states. And the way they do that is the exertion or effort gets rid of laziness. It gets rid of any kind of affliction that may make you want to abandon meditation. The second one, mindfulness gets rid of sinking and excitement, which are the two things that can stop you having calm abiding.

Then the last one, concentration establishes distinguished qualities such as higher perception, etc. It gets rid of any of the things that may be stopping us from developing those things like high perception, etcetera. So, the range or the border for these realizations, for these eight prerequisites or the eight limbs is that it is mainly on the path of meditation. Now the reason that it says it’s mainly on the path of meditation is that in actual fact you develop these eight things or eight causes on the path of seeing, but they are mainly developed and mainly incorporated on the path of meditation because they mainly get rid of things that need to be abandoned on the path of meditation as opposed to the things that need to be abandoned on the path of seeing. Then this one.

Mhmm. Right. They are called the requisites of the ārya path since they act as the cause or requisite of the ārya path. Which is their result? That’s pretty straightforward.

It’s all that because they are that. Oh, yeah. Okay. So then it says applying examples to the requisites. Well, that’s these eight things that we’re talking about here.

Now there’s two different ways that we can look at these as in metaphoric form. The first is from the sutras and that’s why Geshe-la was cracking up back because he kept saying, Sūtra lamkara. I’m going, I think it’s Sūtra and he said, Sūtra lamkara. I’m going, no. Geshe-la, have a look.

And he looks and he goes, the sūtra, they took away the lamkara a bit. So then he was like, oh. Okay. So so it’s from the sūtra by the Buddha. Right?

Then he explains that these eight this eightfold path is like the Dharma king again. The wheel turning king, the Chakravartin. Know how he has all the different precious things that didn’t make sense last time? This is then talking about one of these which is the precious wheel. Yeah.

So that’s a bit in the Mandala where you say. So the the we it’s said to be like the wheel because this wheel is said to have eight spokes, and the eight spokes is supposed to As we have over there. And they are supposed to represent the eight different aspects of this path. Right? So the reason that it’s used that the wheel is used as a metaphor or as an example or a symbol of this is because what happens is it gets transferred.

It goes from a teacher to a student, teacher to student, teacher to student in the way that the teacher uses the spoke of the wheel, that is the speech and the ethics and the right investigation or the right to looking into what should and shouldn’t be done as a means to develop conviction in someone else and then they’re able to explain the view to them and then through their realizations, they develop those understandings and then they were able to pass it on to someone else. So in the same way, a wheel goes from one place to another to another to another by the means of these eight limbs or these eight requisites. Yeah? Then these understandings go from one person to another. Okay.

And now the the since correct view investigation efforts and mindfulness are also considered to be part of the higher training in wisdom because they annihilate states incompatible with them and our dharma is concordant with the spokes that sever so that is severing ignorance. Efforts and mindfulness are said to be part of the higher training in wisdom because they aren’t the higher training in ethics and they aren’t the higher training in concentration, so they have to go in somewhere. Okay, that works. The next three, correct speech, limit of action, livelihood are subsumed by the higher training in ethics. These three act as a supporting basis of all qualities in a dharma’s concordant with the hub which supports.

Right. So, you know how you have a wheel? Okay. So, the sense of it is like the hub of the wheel. So, that said to be like training in ethics because it acts as a basis for all the different qualities that you can develop.

Yeah? And then, the spokes that go around from that hub are said to be like the training in wisdom because they cut through all of the things that need to be cut through. I like this analogy. Alright. Since the correct concentration is subsumed by the higher training and concentration, it acts to bind the mind to its focus, And this means it’s like the rim which binds.

Some of these examples go, but this one works. Okay. So this is as is explained in the Okay. So, this quote from the Abhidharma, I’m allowed to say that without getting jumped on. The Abhidhamma where it says, The wheel of Dharma is the path of seeing, quickly moving, etcetera, is what was explained before.

And that’s all I wanted to say because she was like, No, no, we’ve moved on. I was like, Yes, but I have to say that. So, we’ve moved on. Right, now. Okay, now, that’s the explanation as it’s given in Sūtra and as it’s commented on Vasubandhu’s text, right?

And then there’s another explanation for the watch. Do you like listening to the shit, boy? Yeah. Yeah. Getting the hard time.

Okay. So there’s another way of putting it or another metaphor that is explained in the Uttaratantra. Yeah. Or yes. Which is another one of Maitreya’s text.

In the Uttaratantra, then it says that there’s all these qualities that water has. The definition of water is something that’s said to be as having no smell and no taste and be clear, right? This is the definition of water, but water can actually take on the characteristics of the vessel that it’s put in. So if we get really good water like say rain water, yeah, and so we collect rain water then which hasn’t any particular stains of its own, right, if it’s really pure rain water then we put it in different vessels, it’s gonna different characteristics depending on the vessel we put it So if we put it in some vessels, it’ll become very harsh. If we put it in some vessels, it’ll become very soft.

If we put it in your other vessels, it’ll even become sweet. Okay? So it depends on what’s holding the water, how nice the water is. Now, this is a similar thing for these eight prerequisites or these eight of the eight ārya limbs or the eight correct ārya path, depending on the continuum they are in, they will have different degrees of power. Right?

So we have the three different types of being here. Now the three different types of being we’re talking about is the beings with sharp intelligence which are said to be the bodhisattvas and the Buddhas. And in their continuum, the water becomes becomes delicious and very sweet and light. If prerequisites are in the continuum of a solitary realizer, then their qualities aren’t as pure as they were in the mind stream of a bodhisattva and a Buddha. And the same thing for a hearer, right?

If these qualities exist in a hearer’s continuum, they aren’t going to be as pure or as sweet as they would if they were in a bodhisattva’s continuum. Yeah. So depending on the container, depending on the mind stream they exist in, intensity varies.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
wheel-turning king chakravartin (Skt); khor lo gyu wä gyel po (Tib)
A king who rules over all four continents, according to Buddhist cosmology, with love and ethics, according to the Dharma. Ashoka is a prime example of a wheel-turning king. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top