45 min · 3,253 words · 21 October 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher continues an explanation of the wrong views that a knower of bases counteracts. He covers the wrong views about whether the world and its realms have limits, then the many views on whether gods exist, with their groupings of sixteen, eight, seven and five. He closes by noting that the text presents sixty-two wrong views from other perspectives: cause, preliminaries, base, time, reliance and rebirth.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-10-21
Duration: 46 min
UUID: d5b3e006-8194-4b76-ae35-751983358877
Words: 3,249
I guess he just said he doesn’t have to say too much. He should know how to develop the right motivation. Please have the idea that you’re listening to these teachings in order to attain enlightenment to be the most benefit as you can possibly be to all sentient beings. So please think that by listening to these teachings, you’ll develop understanding of these teachings, through developing understanding of them, you’ll able to put them into practice and by putting them into practice then you become Buddhas and benefit all sentient beings. Okay, so we’re going through the different versions of our wrong views from within the definition of a what a the definition of what the characteristics of a knower of basis is.
So within the characteristics of a knower of bases and another description of it that isn’t actually in these notes is that a knower of bases is the antidote to wrong views and then in order to expand on this definition, the text goes through all of the wrong views that were around. Now, we’re up to the fourth set of wrong views. Now this fourth set of wrong views is said to be related to misperceptions of whether there is a limit or not a limit, an edge or not an edge. Now the first wrong view with regards to whether there is a limit or not was propounded by those who on the strength of a certain amount of clairvoyance Geshe-la said that Chris looked like he was in deep thought, then he said, what on earth is she talking about? Okay.
So first of you look like you’re in deep thought then he had this idea that maybe he’s just going, what on earth is she talking about? We’re actually doing something that’s not in the notes. Right? But it comes under the knowledge characteristic of the application in the knower of bases. Yeah?
Then you have a definition of a knowledge characteristics of an application in knower of a bases. Yeah? Right, such as the arising of the Tathāgata. Now, there’s a different definition as well which says that the definition of a knowledge characteristic for an application in a knower of bases in a Bodhisattva’s Continuum is that which gets rid of wrong views, right? So, then we’re going through the wrong views.
So it comes on the knowledge characteristics of the application in an knower of bases but it’s not actually what’s in the notes. It’s what’s in the text but didn’t actually get taught in these notes. Anyway, this is the wrong views with regards to edges or limits. Okay? The first of which is that the people on the basis of clairvoyance that wasn’t very good clairvoyance, they thought they saw the end of the world.
Alright? And that was it. That was the edge. There was nothing beyond the end of the world. So, eon or so the world disappears and there were every few eons of the world disintegrates into nothing and then other worlds come into being.
So, when someone who had a certain amount of clairvoyance but not complete clairvoyance saw the end of the world, they thought that was it, was the end. So, is the first wrong view based on on clairvoyance that isn’t very good clairvoyance. Now, the second wrong view with regards to limits was the discrimination that there was a time when existence stopped no. That was spent. Wait one second please So someone else with a different type of clairvoyance kept perceiving into the future and as far as they could perceive the world didn’t cease to exist.
They could still see the world coming through different stages and going through different processes and not disintegrating. So, the basis of that clairvoyance, there was people at the time of the Buddha that proposed that there was no end to the they developed the idea that there was no end to the world. Their discrimination led them to believe that there was no end to the world. So that was the second type of misperception with regards to limit misperception with regards to limit was that after trying to find the edge of the ocean and the lowest of hells, they couldn’t see one so they decided that there was no edge the world just kept going on forever, both sideways and up and down. And another being on the basis of their clairvoyance wasn’t able to perceive the form less realms so they proposed that the extent of existence was the form realms down to the hells and they did they missed out on the formless realms so that was another misperception with regards to limit.
And then, so in this way with these different types of limits that we’re talking about the last three ones not the one about whether the world it runs out of a bit stops existing or not but the other two is to the limits of what exists yeah and so there was some that said that things kept going on forever that there was infinite levels realms which is a misperception because there is definite number of realms, yeah, and then there was those that said that there was a definite number of realms which wasn’t the same as what the Buddha saw. Okay, so they missed out on the formless realms and so on. So that’s the four mistakes with regards to limits. Boundaries is probably the best way to put it, boundaries. Okay.
So the next next type of things that people were confused about at this time were whether there are deities or not, whether to propound deities or not. Now, there was four different reasons by which people were confused with regards to this. The first one was that they weren’t dealing with their minds weren’t purified and the second reason that they were confused is that because they have perceived because they have perceptions or realizations they developed arrogance with regards to their realizations and the second one was that they may have had clearer minds but they didn’t know anything certainly still and then the fourth type is the ones that had knowledge but as well as having knowledge they also had a certain amount of unclarity or fogginess with regards to higher paths. So, from this, this means that there were certain people through these four different reasons that could not perceive the difference between what is virtuous and what was not virtuous and that could not understand the four truths which are the definite good, path of emergence and they couldn’t understand how there was two different types of karma that is karma which is contaminated and karma which isn’t contaminated.
Now, from not being able to understand this even though they were given proper answers they didn’t ask questions and therefore were not given proper answers to their misperceptions. Now, this reason is because they had had no idea about abandoning, worshiping, meditating on certain deities that they thought were the ultimate truth. Okay. So they have this technique in texts in order to remember things like this. So it’s basically like a it’s called a dom and I’m trying to think of how to translate that.
There’s lots of them in the Jewel Ornament of Liberation. They so they describe things and then they have a little pithy verse to remember everything, right? So, that’s what I should translate it as. The pithy verse to remember all of the negative views says it says, There’s permanence and there’s a few who say there is no end. There is those who say there is no continuum. There is those grasping on to a border and those that say they won’t abandon no.
Those that say the gods are like Tathagatas. That’s but yeah. It rhymes in Tibetan. This this pithy verse to remember things by, in Tibetan, a dom, which is a lot more pithy, is probably from one of Nāgārjuna’s texts where he refutes the wrong views around at that stage. So, doesn’t know exactly where this remembering tricky thing comes from, but he thinks it’s from one of Nāgārjuna’s texts.
I’m sorry. Okay, so this thing to remember all the negative views with doesn’t explain all of the negative views with regards to gods. In fact, it only explains why the first one it goes through the five previous ones that we’ve done but it doesn’t extrapolate on the wrong views with regards to gods. From amongst the wrong views with regards to God then we are now going to go into more depth about the second one which is the arrogance that comes about indirect through realization. Now, that that that there are gods to be that that so people have realizations and then to arrogantly think that their view is a right and or that they themselves have divine aspects and then propound from that position.
So there’s apparently sixteen people who say that that through their discrimination say that there are gods, sixteen different types of views. There is eight that say there are no gods. And there’s So, and then there is two different no, sorry. There is eight different views that say that there is Okay. There is eight people that propound that there is neither gods nor not gods.
Then there is seven different ways of saying that there is the extreme of nothing in terms of Gods and there is five ways of saying that there are different ways to be free in this lifetime through the relying on Gods. Now, the first has sixteen different aspects so that was the saying that there is an extreme of being. It has sixteen different ways. So, there’s sixteen different ways, this is said. This is how I translate that because it shows you how precise Geshe-la’s mind is.
I said, so all of these are are just to make sure all of these are all about gods. And he goes, no. They’re not about gods. And I was like, oh, no. Forgot I made a mistake.
He goes, they’re not about gods. They’re about whether people are propounding gods or not. So you couldn’t say that I was just reading it in general. Right. So, there’s sixteen different ways that people propound and that people propound or say that there is deities or there is an absolute God are put forward in different ways.
Alright? The sixteen oh, sorry. They’re put forward in sixteen different ways, which I just repeated myself. Sorry. Now, they are, alright, that there is a God God has a self which has form.
The next one is that God has a self which is not form. Then there are those that say that the God has a self which is both form and not form. And then there’s those that say that the God has a self that is neither form nor not form. Right? And then again, I said, so what other Geshe-la said, I said, if they’re not form or not not form, then what is there?
What other option is there? And Geshe-la goes, they’re not Buddhist. They can say whatever they want. Okay? And it doesn’t have to be logical.
So then we were up to so there there was form and not form and then no. So we have form, not form, both form and not form, and then neither form nor not form. Okay? So that’s four. Then we have those that say they are permanent that they have the what’s called the the extreme of self.
Yes? They have the extreme of a self, right? So that’s number five. And then those that say that they don’t have the extreme of a self and then those that say that they have both the extreme of a self and then the extreme of not a self. Then there are those that say that they are neither self nor not self.
Yeah, that’s up to eight. Then we have those that say that there is a self that is bliss and then those that say that the gods have experienced suffering, and those that say that they experience both suffering and happiness, and those that say that they experience neither suffering or happiness. Then there are those that say that the the god is singular, those that say the god is plural, those that say the god is small or limited, and those that say the god is limitless. So this comes to sixteen. Yeah?
Right, now the second group is what was it was those eight that propound the non existence of deities. But within those that propound the non existence of gods, there are those that there’s eight, right? So there’s those that say there is no physical form to the self of gods, therefore, they’re nonexistent. There are those that say that there is a physical form to gods, so therefore, they can’t be gods and therefore, they’re nonexistent. Then there are those that say they are both, and there are those that say they are neither.
Alright? Four. Yeah. Okay. And then we have those that say that there is they they have the extreme of existence of the gods Okay.
Sorry. I can start those again. I missed a syllable. Okay. So there’s eight.
Start it from the first finger. Alright? Okay. There are those that say they cannot discriminate a physical form of God so therefore they don’t exist. There are those that say they cannot discriminate a discern, sorry discern a non physical form of God so they don’t exist.
There are those that say they cannot discern either a physical form or a non physical form so they don’t exist. And there are those that say they cannot discern they cannot not discern either a physical form or a non physical form so therefore they don’t exist. There are those that say they cannot discern a a a a self, right, of gods therefore they don’t exist. For those that say they cannot discern a nonself of gods, so therefore, they don’t exist. Those that say that they can’t discern both or neither.
So that’s So Yes. Okay. So then the next type of ones that are proposing the the non existence or the existence of gods, those that say they are neither they they are neither existent nor non existent. Alright? And so this one’s easy because the four things that they were saying they that made them existent, yeah, that that were mentioned before, the the sorry.
The eight previous ones that made them existent, they just say they can’t see them. And then the stuff that made them non existent, they say they can’t see them. Does that make sense? Okay Yeah, but the sixteen things that they were saying they were to the sixteen ways that they said they could exist where you were all two takes on one thing. Yeah.
So this is saying if you if you only have one take or one take on both things, then you because you’re saying they can either not exist on or exist, then you end up with eight. Alright. So it’s eliminating half of them. Okay. So the next one is four, which was .
Okay. So the next one is those that propound the seven different ways of propounding the extreme of non existence, okay, with reference to gods, right? So there’s seven different types of gods. There is the gods of the desire realm, the gods of the form realm and the gods of the formless realm. So these are different ways of perceiving gods.
So this has to be four different types in these seven different situations. So sorry four different types of Form Realm Gods, four different types of Formless Realm Gods and Desire Realm Gods, So that makes seven And there is those that say that every one of these different types of gods experiences different things while they’re alive. They experience illness and They experience things like a I thought it was rice but it’s sores. They experience illness, they experience sores, they experience pain, they experience crying until they die when they don’t experience anything because they turn into nothing. Nice.
And so that’s the seven ways that they, there are seven different types of gods. So there are seven different ways that they say that gods are they posit gods, but they also posit extreme of nihilism because they say that gods are made from nothing, nothing important and turn into nothing. So this is the view of the Lokayatas, the materialist. Right? Okay.
So the next type of beings who posit Gods wrongly, those that say that there are five different ways in which you can be that being having a life of a God is in itself liberation. All right, so the first one because the gods do not experience any illness and they have experienced continual bliss and the death of gods wasn’t perceived by these beings, then they thought that being reborn as a god was liberation. Right? And so there’s five different ways that one could be liberated in this way. They could be liberated by being born as a Desire Realm God and they could be liberated as being reborn in one of the four meditative concentrated states of the Form Realm.
That is four different concentrations of the form realm, each of which was considered a different type of liberation. So they didn’t say that you could be liberated by being reborn in a formless realm because they didn’t accept the formless realm, only the form realm. So in this way, they said there was five different ways that being reborn as a god was liberation. Okay. So there’s another of these little thingies that helps you remember it.
And I said, Gallen, can you translate that for me? And he said, no. Don’t worry about it. I don’t know if it’ll help. But yes, so it just basically says what we said before, but it’s in a little so that says that there is sixteen who say they have the discrimination that there are gods.
There is eight that say they have the discrimination that there isn’t gods. There is eight that say they have the discrimination that there isn’t either not or is gods. Yeah. And then there’s seven that say they have the discrimination that the gods are an example of the cessation, the extreme of nihilism. And then there is five that say the gods are an example of liberation in this lifetime.
Okay. So in order to make it says that and therefore they have described sixty two different types of wrong view from different perspectives in this description that we have just been through. In order to make this easier, they’re going to describe it from these views from a different point of view, right? So the different point of view, it means to first of all talk about the cause as described by these wrong views. And the second one is to talk about the preliminaries with regards to these wrong views.
The base of these wrong views, the time of these wrong views and what views that these wrong views rely on and the way that the rebirth is generated in places according to these wrong views? This one.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
- Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.