Ornament for Clear Realisations – 14 2004 03 11 OCR

44 min · 3,075 words · 11 March 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 14 2004 03 11 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the four close placements of mindfulness and why the Mahayana practice is considered superior to that of the lesser vehicles. It covers focusing on all beings and on emptiness, seeing the body as like an illusion, feelings as like dreams, the mind as like space, and phenomena as like clouds. It also explains that mindfulness depends on prior wisdom and on renunciation.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-03-11

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 6c1425b7-c66d-4c10-8cb2-da35eaee4e6e

Words: 3,071

So the next one, it focuses on all bodies, etc, self or others. Now, what this refers to is that in the four close placements of mindfulness in the lesser vehicles, then the focus for these four close placements of mindfulness is the person’s own body, feelings, mind and the phenomena that make up the aggregates. That is in terms of the dhamma that make up the aggregates. So that’s the main focus that they have. Whereas in the greater vehicle, they don’t only focus on their own body, feelings, mind, and the phenomena that make up their aggregates, but they understand all other beings’ bodies, all phenomena, all feelings, and all self.

They focus on all of these. And the sixth way that the Great Vehicle’s practice of mindfulness is as supreme is that it pays close attention to the emptiness of the body, the feelings, the mind and phenomena. So in the lower vehicles, they pay attention to the selflessness of the body, the feelings, the mind and phenomena. But in the high vehicle, it’s the emptiness of those things. Okay.

Another way that practicing mindfulness is supreme in the great vehicle is that beings who practice mindfulness and so on through the greater vehicle practices are able to turn contaminated body into an uncontaminated body. Now this doesn’t happen in the vehicles of the solitary realizers and hearers. When the solitary realisers and hearers achieve arhatship, still their mind is still contained in a contaminated body. And this is what’s called nirvana with remainder. And so this is why it said that beings are solitary realisers hearers attain parinirvana when they die because they cease to have contaminated aggregates.

And they only have true nirvana at the time of death because they get rid of the contaminated body that is still contaminated by its nature. It’s still a result of causes and conditions and therefore suffering. In the Mahāyāna vehicle however you’re able to transform the body from a contaminated into an uncontaminated thing. So the next thing that makes the great vehicle mindfulness supreme is that it’s the practice of the four close placements of mindfulness in a greater vehicle are compatible with the practice of the six perfections. Now the practice of the mindfulness in the lower vehicle is a similar practice but because the focus isn’t on emptiness and the achieving of Buddhahood then it means that those mindfulnesses aren’t compatible with the practice of the six perfections Another way that it is said to be established as supreme is that through practicing a great vehicle Close Mindfulness, are able to guide hearers and solitary realisers also.

If you practice the powers of the hearers and solitary realizers, then you’re unable to guide bodhisattvas. So in this way, by practicing the mindfulnesses of the great vehicle, you’re able to guide all beings from all different parts. Another way that these practices are said to be supreme is that it enables us to see our body as an illusion. Now, what this means is that the way that we perceive our body to exist as a true thing, a true entity, is an actual fact a misperception. We’re seeing things in a way that isn’t the way that they actually are.

If we are doing the practices of close mindfulness, especially the one on the body, enables our body to be perceived as an illusion. In the same way we watch things on television, we know that that isn’t something that’s inherently or truly existent in the box. We know that we’re looking at it and it’s appearing as something, but it’s appearing as an illusion. We understand it to be not truly there then through doing the close practices of mindfulness we’re able to develop the same kind of understanding about our bodies we’re able to perceive our bodies as being not truly existent, but like an illusion. And this is like a is an example.

It’s not an illusion, but like an illusion. Yeah. So it’s in the same manner So in this way, Aryas are able to perceive the body as being without a true existence, without a true essence. In this way they see it as if it’s an illusion. It’s not to say that it is an illusion, but it has the same characteristics as an illusion.

Okay. So this is like if we think about this, this is actually true because when we see things on television and then they go away, then we can understand that that’s not a truly existent thing. But if we look at our bodies now, we think that we have the same bodies, we’re the same beings or the same physical beings that we were when we were born or when we were younger. But in actual fact, there is no physical aspect left of that body. That body’s completely changed.

So the idea of us being in an inherent thing is an illusion. Okay. If we think about it in this way then, there’s the that we view ourselves as being an inherently existent thing and we’re not like that. We’re more like an illusion. We can think about this in a way as if we see things on television and then they disappear, then we’re unable to see them again.

We don’t think of them as being inherent thing that’s going to stay there forever. Geshe-la said this is a similar thing to his parents because his parents have both passed away and he had this idea when they were there that they would be there that they were inherent but in actual fact they don’t exist in the same way as the things on the television didn’t exist because they’re not here anymore. There was no inherent existent thing in there that could last forever. In this way, he says that the image of both his parents and the people on television are both illusory. Okay.

So and also, feelings is then said to be experienced like a dream. He goes, now this one works too. This example works too. Because he said that the experiences that we had yesterday, I guess, the same experiences we had yesterday, we were saying okay we experienced happiness and we were very happy and we experienced sadness and we may have been very sad and that could have even happened in the same day but what are those experiences now? Are we experiencing them now?

No, they’re like a dream that has passed they’re not something that is constantly being experienced now and even the experiences we’re having now there’s no substance to them they don’t stay so even while we’re experiencing them they’re like a dream because they’re gone. In this way, we can look at it and see the experiences we have, the feelings that we have, in the same way as the feelings of a dream and that they’ve gone before we’ve while we’re experiencing them, they’re gone. And then bloody. And it also developed and so We’re also able to develop through these foreclosed placements of mindfulness the idea that our mind is like space. What this means in space is that the definition of space is a lack of obstructing object.

So this means that the absence of obstructing objects, our mind is like that as well. Our mind has no limit. It has nothing to fence it in. If we think India, we’re in India. Our mind is like in India.

We have images of India. If we think China, our mind is in China. If we think of out of space, our mind is in out of space. So in this way, our mind has no form. It has nothing that stops anything.

Nothing it can bump up against it and stop. It has no shape. It has no color. It has no geographical location because it can be anywhere. So in this way, it’s said to be like what’s called uncompounded space.

Okay. So dharma is said to be perceived as like a cloud. Now the reason for this is because dharma here has the meaning of phenomena because sometimes phenomena is there and sometimes phenomena is not there. This is why it’s referred to as a cloud. Sometimes clouds are there, sometimes they’re not there.

They come and then they go and then they come and then they go. This is the same way as phenomena. They’re there and then they’re not there. They’re there and then they’re not there. Developing a close placement of mindfulness on phenomena, it gives us insight into their cloud-like nature in that they come and they go and they don’t have any inherent fixing.

So sometimes there is something that we can have an idea is something and this is how they are phenomena. And sometimes there is nothing that we label as something, and then in that case, there is no phenomena. So in this way, they’re cloud like. Another way that the Mahāyāna, our four close placements of mindfulness, superior to the Hīnayāna four close placements of mindfulness is that in dependence on them, you develop the causes or the result. Develop the causes to have the result of being a being who is a wheel turner, that is to someone who teaches the Dharma with regards to how saṃsāra comes to being.

I misunderstood that. One turning the temporal wheel, and what it is in yeah. In Sanskrit this is another way of saying what’s called a Chakravartin ruler. That is a world ruler. Yeah, Chakravartin, word to learn for the week.

Okay. You’re asking me to spell. C H A K R A V A R T I N. This one? And these Chakravartins are said to be bodhisattvas that are born as world rulers in order to benefit beings.

Oh, yeah. In case you don’t want to get his mic back on. Okay and if one meditates on close mindfulness. You’re able to meditate on close mindfulnesses with what’s called an an especially sharp faculty, which means that you’re able to focus very with the perception of emptiness that comes along with And then also the focus for this is that because it includes everything, then it doesn’t get mixed up with the meditations and teachings of the lesser vehicle because it pervades the lesser vehicle. And you are able to establish what’s called nirvana without remainder And that’s what we were talking about earlier with the non contaminated aggregates so that the body becomes pure instead of being still an example of the truth of suffering as it is for arhats or Hīnayāna arhats.

So He’s saying zero zero. Eight six. That’s great. Take his photo. Brilliant.

I’ve never been in a teaching mode. This has happened before. Oh, no. I have. Level level.

Yes. And I was translating that into and time it seems to happen. I translate this from who got a call from Sikim, told the people in his Oh. Okay. Because so he’s gotta save someone being from being sent back to Tibet.

I think it’s someone that says student that you know or something that he has to ring. So he has to ring. He has to ring and talk to someone’s parents in Tibet and convince them that their son can’t come back to Tibet because if he goes back to Tibet, he’ll be in a lot of trouble. And then they’re saying that he desperately has to go back because there’s problems with the family, but they and they didn’t understand how much trouble he’d be even if he went back to Tibet. And so they’re not gonna listen to him.

So Geshe-la has to ring up and say, if he goes back to Tibet, there’ll be too much trouble and he’ll be he won’t be able to keep being a monk and there’ll be all sorts of problems. He has to ring them up to explain why his their son’s not coming back. Okay? So he had to try and get through and he said the reason he took the call is because they’ve been trying to get in touch with him for days and days and days. Okay.

So wisdom is the mind. Both of these things, I think Wisdom is something focused on an object. Mindfulness is something focused on an object. Right? Now, wisdom is, having focused on an object, analyzing the object.

Mindfulness is the focusing without distraction on an object. Both of them talk about knowing, right? But it’s a different way of looking at it because the wisdom is something that knows in terms of it has a realization or an understanding of something. So for example you can have a realization and understanding of cup, that there s a cup and that s an objective knowledge. Mindfulness is holding on to that, focusing on that without forgetting.

The opposite of mindfulness is forgetfulness, right? Or forgetting. So it’s holding on to the idea. It’s grasping on to that idea and not letting it go, not wavering from that idea, not being distracted from that idea, not forgetting that idea, being able to focus on it. He just said, first of all, there has to be wisdom.

And there has to be perception of something before you can have mindfulness. So for Okay. So for example, the mug, right? We’re having the wisdom of mug, right? The wisdom that perceives mug.

Okay. So first of all, have the wisdom perceiving mug, which is the absence of the ignorance of mug. Right? And then once that wisdom has been perceived or wisdom has been developed, mindfulness is the concentration on that understanding and not forgetting that understanding. So the way that mindfulness works is constantly bringing your mind back to mug, right?

If you forget mug, then you have to think of mug again, and then you’re perpetuating the idea of mindfulness. So if your mind forgets mug or drifts away from mug, that’s not mindfulness. It’s bringing your mind back to mug that is mindfulness. If you don’t have mindfulness in there, you have no hope of developing an understanding of wisdom directly. Because what happens Wisdom and understanding emptiness directly is what I was saying.

So first of all, have a wisdom of emptiness. And then you have the mindfulness that keeps focusing on that, close placement of mindfulness on that object. And through that, then you proceed through the inferential cognizers to the direct realization. If you don’t have the mindfulness to focus on emptiness, there’s no way, there’s no hope of you actually ever perceiving emptiness directly. So the mindfulness is the ability to concentrate on the perception of emptiness until it becomes what do you call it, a direct perception of emptiness.

At the time that you have a direct perception of emptiness, there’s no way your mindfulness can decrease. When you first of all have an understanding of emptiness, then your mind can waver from that and you have to keep bringing it back. But when you’ve directly perceived it, there’s no way that your mindfulness goes away after that or disappears. Yeah? Okay.

So it comes about through meditation. The moment you enter the path of accumulation is when you develop renunciation. Right? So you enter the path of accumulation of the Hīnayāna vehicle. Once you’ve developed that, then you have close placements of mindfulness, which is that you’re concentrated without forgetting because you have uncontrived renunciation.

You’re concentrated without forgetting on the things that can help you develop an understanding of the four noble truths. So that is the close place close placement of mindfulness on body and feelings and mind and phenomena. Before that, you do have mindfulness, but it’s not these close placements of mindfulness. So it comes with renunciation. Okay.

So people before they develop renunciation, before they enter this path, have close placements of mindfulness, but they don’t have these four close placements of mindfulness. So from the power of developing or from the as a result of developing renunciation, these four close placements come about. So people have it beforehand, but it’s not developed to the same extent as it does when you have uncontrived renunciation. Yeah. Compassion isn’t ever considered a feeling.

A feeling is something that is either an experience of suffering, equanimity, or happiness or pleasantness. Compassion is said to be a mental factor. Yeah. Only uncontaminated happiness. How about feeling?

Uncontaminated happiness. Yeah. It’s a different word. It’s just that’s the closest one. So the definition of compassion compassion is a is a mind or an idea, this mental factor that wishes either another being or all sentient beings to be free from suffering.

So if it’s one being or several beings, it’s compassion. If it’s all sentient beings, great compassion. I’m asking, is Chris listening?. Therefore, Okay. So to make that clear about the, what their mental factor is and what the main mind is then.

Okay. The main mind, when you have great compassion, is all sentient beings. The focus is all sentient beings. And the mental factor is the wish that they are all free from suffering. So that’s great compassion.

It’s a mental factor. So it’s directed at all sentient beings. And it’s very important. That’s compassion. Thank you.

I keep asking questions. Geshe-la goes, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And then I’m like saying them, but I was just trying to help. The word for what’s translated as compassion in Tibetan is meaning heart, or snying rje. Right?

So it means, yeah, the boss of the heart, literally. Okay. So in this case, heart is a synonym of mind. So the mind wishing others to be free from suffering is said to be the king or the boss of the minds, the best mind. It depends.

There’s different instances. Some beings have a realization, not a direct realization, but a realization of emptiness before they develop renunciation, and others don’t develop a realization of emptiness until after they’ve developed. So those beings who are going to concentrate on the development of renunciation would first of all develop renunciation before they develop any other understandings. But if someone was focusing on emptiness as their main focus for meditation, then they would develop a realization of emptiness before they developed renunciation.

Key terms in this teaching

contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top