45 min · 2,675 words · 25 March 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the four legs of magical manifestation as a path-level form of calm abiding (shamatha) developed through concentration. It covers their focal object, the five faults and eight antidote applications used in meditation, and how the four legs arise in a causal sequence from faith. The explanation draws on Maitreya’s Distinguishing the Middle from the Extremes and Nagarjuna’s Collected Topics.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-03-25
Duration: 45 min
UUID: f0eefea3-f746-43a8-a481-29254e6a15ab
Words: 2,671
Qualities, distinguished in a positive sense. Not this distinguished from other things, but distinguished as in terms of being good. So therefore when we have this happy mind that is engaged in these actions then that means that through that as a basis they’re able to develop these trainings in concentration trainings in meditative concentration So through those, we develop these four different aspects. So the Bodhisattvas develop these four different aspects. That is aspiration., effort, or this this joy, intention, and analysis. So what does this mean and what does this text actually talking about in this case? Well, it’s talking about the fact that the path thoroughly training in concentration comes in many different types, as there are many different types of the path thoroughly training in concentration. Okay. Even though there is many different things many different things that would count as a path thoroughly training and concentration, they are subsumed into four.
That is the limb of miracle of aspiration, the limb of miracle of effort, the limb of miracle of joy, and the limb of miracle of intention, and the limb of miracle of analysis. In order to look at the third division, the path training in concentration, or the four legs of magical manifestation, we need to look at eight different things. Its focal object, the method by which we meditate, its need for meditation, its nature, its classification, its range or its borders, its etymology, and why the great vehicle version of it is the best. So the first one, the focal objects. Because we’re talking about limbs of magical manifestation then the focal objects for these things are miracles that can be performed.
For example if we have this ability to concentrate single pointedly on an object and have what are called the four legs of magical manifestations it means that we have the ability to for example change our one body into many bodies or make those many bodies come back into one body or make that one body disappear completely or from disappearing completely come into being again. Now the ability to do these things rests on this concentrated ability and so therefore we would say that the focus for these magical manifestations or magical emanations whatever you call them is the thing that’s being done so that is based on the meditative concentration that has been achieved so through focusing on meditative through focusing through meditative concentration, one with this with these realizations is able to turn themselves into many or many into one and so forth. So what we’re talking about in terms of this meditative concentration is that, for example, if we are focused single pointedly on an object then the thing that is holding onto that object or the consciousness that is concentrating on that object is said to be a main mind. Along with that main mind many different factors come about.
And these mental factors have different aspects to them. So we may have an aspiration which seeks to focus on that object. And we may have some kind of idea of the reason why we’re doing it as well. But the mental factor that is the abiding in concentration on that object is said to be this meditative concentration. So the meditative concentration is a mental factor that is the abiding abidingness of concentrating on an object.
So through this there can be many different objects for the thing that it’s concentrating on but there’s different types of this abiding which are called the four legs of magical manifestation. So this means that the object of this meditative concentration is the performing of miracles, of different types of miracles or different types of emanations, different types of things that the beings who have this meditative concentrated ability are able to do. But the mental concentration isn’t the actual action. The mental concentration is the mind that is focusing on that action. In order to be able to form these actions you need to have a single point of concentration.
The actions themselves aren’t the object of this concentration which then that concentration then has many different has these sorry four different types. All right so the four different legs. So you’re performing an action which there can be many many different types of actions but the focus that’s concentrate the mind that’s concentrating on those, the mental factor that is the concentration that enables these miracles to be performed has four different types. Hence, it says in the collected topics of Nāgārjuna that what is the focus of the limbs of miracle? It is the action accomplished by concentration.
The method of meditation for this, there is said to be what are called the five faults and the eight antidote applications. So these five faults and eight abandoning applications are exactly the same things as what is used to develop calm abiding. It’s the same process as development of calm abiding or śamatha. The source for this description of the eight antidote applications and the five faults is twofold. It is distinguishing the middle way from the extremes by Maitreya and also the collected topics by Nāgārjuna.
Right. So the five faults are said to be laziness that acts as an obstacle to entering meditation. To entering meditative concentration. The second one the fault of forgetting the instruction when in preparatory meditation. So that means when you’re doing the meditations and teachings to develop calm abiding forgetting what it is that you were supposed to do.
That’s the second fault. The third fault is excitement and sinking when in actual meditation. The fourth one is not applying the antidotes when sinking or excitement occur. This one. One second.
Sorry. So the fault of forgetting the instructions when you’re preparing your meditation, what this is referring to is the fact that once we’re doing placement meditation, then there is no there is no instructions to be analysed or contemplated on because you are focusing single pointedly on one object or trying to. In this way then there are no instructions to forget because it is focusing on an object. That is why it says in preparatory Then when it goes on to excitement and sinking when an actual meditation that is when excitement and sinking come about when we’re trying to do placement meditation on an object single pointedly. Right?
Then after that it says not applying the antidotes when sinking or excitement occur. And the fifth one, applying antidotes when spontaneously and effortlessly entering concentration free of sinking and excitement. So that is not applying antidotes when you need to and applying antidotes when you don’t need to for four and five. So the source for this idea of the five faults, again, is distinguishing the middle from the extremes by Maitreya as one of his five texts. That is in which he says laziness as the obstacle, the faults of forgetting, excitement and sinking, not applying the antidotes and applying the antidotes the five things to be abandoned.
So the way that we abandon these five negative things is through the eight abandoning applications. Okay. So we have these eight abandoning applications aspiration, exertion, faith, pliancy, mindfulness, introspection, intention, and equanimity. The first four of these being aspiration, exertion, faith and pliancy are said to be the antidotes to the first of the five faults which is laziness that acts as an obstacle to entering meditation. Okay.
So the the the first four is said to be the answer to first one, which is laziness. And then the fifth one, mindfulness, is said to be an antidote to the second which is the fault of forgetting the instructions. The sixth one, introspection, is said to be an antidote to the third one, which is the excitement and sinking when in actual meditation. The seventh one, intention is said to be an antidote to the fourth which is not applying the antidotes. Eighth one equanimity is said to be an antidote to the fifth one which is applying the antidotes when you don’t need to.
Then there is a quote which explains this in a very complicated manner from Maitreya’s distinguishing the extreme from the middle, and so Geshe-la said, tell them it says the same thing as the previous bit. Right. Now, with these the first four of these, they have a causal relationship. So the first one being aspiration is said to be the actual desire or the actual wish to do something and this is also said to be the support for the development of this result which result which is number four which is pliancy. Okay so what we have is a support, what is supported, what acts as a cause for the support, right?
And then the result that comes about. So basically what this means is that you have aspiration and aspiration gives rise to effort, that is aspiration supports exertion. Through exertion we develop faith but faith is actually the reason or the cause for the aspiration and the result of this is then the pliancy. It says in the next bit down it says actual desire precedes exertion. Actual desire being this aspiration precedes exertion which supports it.
This exertion supports the actual desire. Then exertion is supported by faith or is caused by faith. Faith is the cause of aspiration which is the support of exertion And after that from these comes about pliancy through the result of effort. So the way that actually goes is that first of all, have So first of all, what we have is as a cause is faith. Right?
So through faith, which faith is, Geshe-la says, seeing things as they are, seeing what it is that you’re actually doing. So through faith we develop the aspiration to want to do something or Bodhisattva develop the aspiration to want to do something. From this aspiration comes this exertion or the doing of something And as a result of this exertion comes pliancy. Does that make sense? Yeah.
Yeah. But they go like and they have a complicated way of explaining Oh, yeah. So I guess I said, it’s just basically take So just take faith out and stick it first. I mean, it makes sense. So it’s all back in front and around the their way of explaining this around the front and he goes, no, no.
Just take faith out six first. It’s easy. So through this process of these four things, that is first of all having faith, through faith having aspiration, through aspiration going through exertion which develops pliancy, we have the antidote to the first of the five faults which is laziness as the obstacle to entering meditation. After that then comes mindfulness which we use as an antidote for forgetting things and then comes introspection which acts as an antidote to the fault of actually experiencing excitement and sinking. Then comes introspection which allows us to sorry then comes intention.
So mindfulness was for number two. Introspection was for number three. And then intention acts as an antidote for not applying the antidotes. And then equanimity, being in an equanimous state means that we won’t try and apply antidotes when we don’t need to apply antidotes because we have this understanding of equanimity. That is why.
Okay. Right. Now so the next thing is that we need to know is the need for meditation. And it says that the need for meditation is that anything that we can do, any mundane or transcendent excellences or qualities that we may develop, all come about from this development and the development of these four legs of magical manifestation. Now these four legs of manifestation are basically calm abiding.
What it means by the four legs of magical manifestation is these are the things that one is able to do by developing calm abiding. So the four legs of magical manifestation are different ways of looking at calm abiding. And calm abiding or śamatha acts as the basis for us to develop all of these transcendent and mundane qualities or excellences. So it doesn’t mean that the practice of miracles is the basis for all of these but the practice of miracles is a quality of calm abiding and calm abiding is the basis or this meditative concentration is the basis for all of these good qualities. So in this way, then we can see that or we can understand that calm abiding or śamatha has many different forms and one of these different forms is what are called these four legs of magical manifestation.
So the four legs of magical manifestation are śamatha states, but they are not the only types of śamatha states you can have. So they are an example of śamatha states. So there is something that the ability to perform these miracles comes about through the development of a calm abiding or śamatha. So hence, in a sūtra, it’s from the Okay. So in a sūtra that’s included within the Prajñāpāramitā sutras, the Buddha says, They are the results of what?
Referring to all of these excellent qualities. Maitreya replies, They are the results of pure minds. They are the results of pure wisdom. And so this pure mind and this pure wisdom is the mind that is able to focus single pointedly on things and has developed insight. Now the the definition of these four legs of magical manifestation is the pristine awareness entering the path which is concentration reliant on the eight abandoning applications as antidotes to the five faults.
So what this means is that we can see from that because it’s a path then it isn’t all calm abiding or isn’t all states of śamatha because you can have śamatha and not even be a Buddhist. So this śamatha is specifically we’re talking about śamatha or calm abiding which is a path. So it’s not all śamatha or calm abiding. This one? So it says there’s true sources which aren’t in the translation after this, the collected topics of Nāgārjuna where he says that the nature of these magical manifestations is this meditative concentration.
And also in the Abhidharmakośa by Vasubandhu, it says that the four limbs are meditative concentration. Okay. So the fourth the fifth thing is the classification of the divisions of the four limbs of magical manifestation. So these four limbs are the limb of miracle of aspiration. So one is the miracle here and the other is magical manifestation.
Okay. So the limb of miracle of aspiration, the limb of miracle of effort, the limb of miracle of intention, and the limb of miracle of analysis. Okay. So sorry. It’s I was getting very confused because the word that means this joyous effort or whatever it is in Tibetan.
It sounds almost exactly the same as magical manifestations. So I just got my head in a big spin. Was like, what? Can you see why I was confused? Okay, so it all fits together, trust me.
We have these okay, we’re trying to work backwards, right? The reason that these things are called the four legs of magical manifestation is because magical manifestations are able to be done based on this meditative concentration. They aren’t anything to do That’s why they’re called magical manifestations. But they aren’t magical manifestations. They’re meditative concentrations.
They’re of calm abiding. They’ve got nothing to do with but nothing about them is magical manifestation. It’s just that you’re able to perform magical manifestations based on those, right? And therefore the magical manifestations are said to be like the object for this meditative concentration, right? And so this type of meditative concentration is defined by whether magical manifestations are able to be performed based on it.
Does that make sense? Yeah? Okay. Now with this first one which is the limb of miracle of aspiration, right? First of all when you hear limb of miracle you’re not thinking of miracle.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.