45 min · 2,605 words · 25 March 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the four legs of magical manifestation as forms of calm abiding, showing how aspiration, joyous effort, continuous practice and familiarity bring about single-pointed concentration. It stresses that calm abiding should be developed only with a firm refuge and renunciation, since otherwise it can lead to rebirth in the form and formless realms. The session ends with recitation of the vows.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-03-25
Duration: 45 min
UUID: f347fad8-761b-4826-97dd-144093017ce1
Words: 2,601
Aspiration is in any way a miracle, right? A limb of a miracle or leg of magical manifestation is a type of calm abiding, is a type of meditative concentration. It’s not a type of miracle. Does that make sense? Okay.
Maybe miracle but not magical manifestation. Maybe magical manifestation is a better translation, right? Okay, yeah definitely. Because it means like smoke and mirrors basically. Magical manifestation comes about because of this concentration.
So this concentration comes about because of this joyous action, that joyous effort or joyously doing something. That joyously doing something comes about because of aspiration. Aspiration comes about aspiration is right? Having respect or having faith in something means that you do something. So you start off with that’s working backwards.
You start off with respect or faith in something. Through that respect and faith in something you develop an aspiration. Through that aspiration you perform an action. Through that performing an action you develop meditative concentration. The aspect of that meditative concentration that is aspiration, yeah, is this first limb.
Is that okay? So when you hear these magical manifestations, you’re not thinking about things appearing in front of you and manifestations that these beings are able to do. When you hear magical manifestations don’t think magic tricks right? Think something that has the ability to do that. So we’re talking about the meditative concentration that have the ability to do that.
Okay, so the second is the concentration contacting single pointed mind reliant on the effort of continuous preparation. It’s interesting when you read something in English and it doesn’t make any sense. Okay, the concentration, the second is the concentration, the meditative concentration is calm abiding or Shamatha, the ability of Shamatha. Contacting single pointed mind which means that it is in the form of a single pointed mind, right? Reliant on the effort of continuous preparation.
So this means what has happened is through a joy in doing these things, through a joy in putting in the actually doing these things comes the ability to be able to do it without cessation, right? That is continuously. And through joyously continuously doing something then you’re able to develop this calm abiding, this śamatha, this type of limb of magical manifestation or a leg of magical manifestation, right? So the aspect of the leg of magical manifestation which is this joyously doing things continuously is the second one. So the third one of these is the is concentration, the meditative concentration that is single pointedly able to sorry.
The third is the concentration which brings about single pointed mind through familiarity with concentration. So This means that through familiarizing ourselves with the idea of single pointed concentration, this can bring about the ability to be able to single pointedly concentrate on things, develop meditative concentration and is a type of Shamatha or calm abiding. So for example if we’ve meditated on lots of calm abiding meditation and developed calm abiding or Shamatha in a previous life then in this life when we do it it will become a lot easier to us. And if we’re used to doing something in this life when we go back to it it will become a lot easier to us. So through the force of that familiarity, through the force of that habit then we are able to develop this calm abiding which is a limb of magical manifestation.
So the aspect of that magical manifestation or that calm abiding which comes about because of familiarity is said to be the third one. The limb of miracle of intention. So the fourth concentration is the aspect of concentration that comes about because of the things that are taught to us in this lifetime. So then there’s a quote from the collected topics of Nāgārjuna again where he said, How do these things all work together? Intention and we have analysis.
These things come together to bring about calm abiding. So you have a combination of having in a previous life habituated yourself towards calm abiding and then having instruction in this life to do it. This is through the analysis in the instruction. Having the aspiration to do it that comes through faith and respect, and then putting the effort in. So the borders or the range it says as before so that means it’s from the beginning of the path of preparation of the Hīnayāna or the hearer’s vehicle all the way through to the ground of a Buddha.
We knew this anyway because it’s said in the definition of this four limbs of magical stuff. It said the pristine awareness entering the path which is concentration reliant on the eight abandoning applications. As soon as you enter that path any concentration that you develop at that stage is said to be this four legs of magical manifestation. So you enter a path the first moment you develop uncontrived renunciation. It says they are called the limbs of miracle because possessing the limbs or possessing the legs means you’re capable of going to the assembly of Buddha fields by means of miracle.
There are many different types of miracles that you can have. You can have miracles: magical emanations, magical manifestations. You can have magical manifestations through mantra, magical manifestations through tricks of hand, tricks of what’s called sleight of hand, manifestations through fiddling with elements. These magical manifestations talking about here are magical manifestations that come about because of calm abiding. That doesn’t explain why they’re called magical manifestations but it’s the type of magical manifestations we’re talking about.
The reason that it’s called the legs of magical manifestations is because is because they’re able to take you anywhere you want to go. So it says, why is the great vehicle limb of miracles supreme? The great vehicle limb of miracles are distinguished from these of the lesser vehicle because as the Toh Drigün states: The limbs of miracles of those who are stable possess force appearing characteristics accomplishing every purpose of self and others. Because the lesser vehicle limbs of miracle are only focused on their own benefit and then they are said to not be as stable as the limbs of miracles of the great vehicle because they’re not only focused on their own benefit but also on what benefit they can be to others. I said, I think we’re running out of time, Geshe-la said.
Well, that’s perfect timing because we just finished that section. That doesn’t work my throat. This tastes alright for Ribena. It tastes kinda like pee. Yeah.
I’m hoping. He keeps every time I have a salad, points it and goes, Australian food. Yeah. Yeah. He said that’s Tibetan.
You put butter in it, did you? Yeah. Yeah. It’s like the it’s like the influence. Anyway, yes.
It’s not about fat, is it? No. Good. Mhmm. No, because there’s all different types of things that you can have faith in.
Having faith in the ability to develop a direct understanding of emptiness doesn’t happen when you have the direct understanding of emptiness. It happens when you perceive that you are able to have the direct understanding of emptiness. In this case you see that you can develop calm abiding. You see that you can develop śamatha. So it’s having faith in the idea or having a clear view of the fact that you can develop calm abiding.
So there are many things you can have faith in. You can also have faith in seeing, for example, the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. So through seeing the qualities of the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha you have faith in Buddha, the Dharma and Sangha. Also with a teacher, if you see a teacher’s qualities then you have faith in that teacher through seeing their qualities. Okay.
Geshe doesn’t think that that’s where we should be putting our main focus at the moment because the main things that we need to develop in order to achieve Buddhahood are renunciation, Bodhicitta, and the understanding of emptiness. In order for us to develop those three, then we need to have good refuge. So we need to be focusing on refuge in the sufferings of saṃsāra and in order to do that also to think about abandoning the ten non virtuous actions. Because the main reason that he said this was because non Buddhists develop non Buddhists can also develop calm abiding. If we develop calm abiding without renunciation and without a solid refuge, then our development of calm abiding actually becomes a cause to stay in saṃsāra longer.
So hang on, haven t finished yet. He said, So if we have a very, very strong refuge and a very strong idea of refuge, then he said it would be a good idea to start developing calm abiding. But you have to make sure you have a very strong refuge. Okay. So, said that there is a danger even if we have good refuge No, he said if we have Sorry, first if we have refuge then our efforts to develop this kind of concentration will not become a cause for us to go to the lower realms.
That’s the first thing. Through attachment and so forth. If we do have good refuge there is still a danger that developing calm abiding Shamatha can act as a cause for us to be born in the formless realms without renunciation. But if we have developed calm abiding then it is the easier to develop renunciation. So if you have a stable refuge then it’s good to try develop calm abiding.
But there is this danger of it becoming a cause for us to be born in form and formless realms, we have to be very careful to use it as a reason to develop renunciation and not to become attached to the form and formless realms. So we need to so if because if we don’t do things with a strong refuge, whatever we’re doing doesn’t become Dharma. He wants to know if you’ve got He said that so he said that he said, I think Joey sat there saying, so in the basis of calm abiding, I can develop all supramundane and mundane qualities, all worldly and non worldly qualities. I better get that. Alright?
And then he goes, but if he wants to get it, that’s a good thing. Good He said, unfortunately, falling asleep isn’t calm abiding. You may think that your mind starts to focus on one thing, but actually what happens is all the gross minds disappear, the subtle minds start coming up and flittering around. He said that there’s no calm abiding there. In sleep there is no calm abiding even.
The focus for this here. In this instance, Okay, so in this instance what the object of meditation is, is these magic tricks that they’re performing or they’re able to perform based on these abilities of calm abiding that have been developed. So there’s many different magic tricks basically that they are able to perform and that is the focus of the meditative concentration, is the performing of like turning many bodies into one and so forth. But those magic tricks aren’t the four legs of magical emanation. The four legs of magical emanation are the mind, is mental factor.
The mental factor of concentration that enables this to come about. So we’re basically going through these specific qualities of beings who have entered the path. It’s called thirty seven different limbs of enlightenment that refers to the specific qualities or the different mental abilities of those who have entered the path from all three different vehicles. Yeah? The tricks.
Don’t know. I say that, but I’ll ask. Calm abiding is different to the tricks. The tricks. Sorry.
I keep jumping in. I’m sorry. I’ll shut up. Okay.
So what was the frustrated look was for at the beginning of this statement? He literally said, Magical manifestations aren’t magical manifestations. And I said, What? He said, If you have magical manifestations from elements or magical manifestations from mantra, they’re not magical manifestations. And I said, Well, what are they?
And he said, Magical manifestations. And I said, But you just said they’re not magical manifestations. And he said, They’re magical manifestations but they’re not magical manifestations per se. Does that make sense? I’m a what?
Anyway, because magical manifestations are actually minds in terms of what this is. It’s a mental factor or concentration. And the magical manifestations that come about from stuff alright from mantras and everything aren’t these magical manifestations because these magical manifestations aren’t actually magical manifestations they’re mind. Right. Now as soon as you’ve developed calm abiding you’re able to perform these legs, no not the legs of magical manifestations but you’re able to perform magical manifestations yeah.
Now the purpose of these specific four legs of magical manifestations which are not things that are done by non Buddhists because they’re paths. They’re part of paths. Purpose for those is as it says in the end of the chapter, These limbs of miracle are those who are no, not in the end of the chapter. In the etymology that’s what we’re looking for. Possessing the limbs capable of going to the assembly of Buddha fields by means of miracle.
Now what this means is that you can go anywhere and manifest as anything in order to get teachings. Go and visit Buddhas everywhere you want. So you can manifest bodies to visit Buddhas unmanifest bodies not to disturb once you’ve had the teachings and so forth. I was like, that would be cool because this guy that I wanted to see is not coming, this person from Sera wanted to see is not coming, yesterday goes, Yeah, yeah, it wouldn’t make any difference, you could just emanate in Nepal. It gets confusing because if you say magical manifestations, think are magical manifestations.
We don’t think, that means concentration, which is mind. He said it’s possible, but he doesn’t think any Bodhisattva would come and listen to him. He said if there is one of you who is a Bodhisattva, please say so because he has questions. You need another donkey, as Geshe-la said.
Perfect. Jo, do you want to lead the last prayers? So now there’s another repetition. You need to repeat the following, and which is for once. So now having received the vows, now one is making a pledge that the the meaning of the repetition here is, like all those the supreme and the liberated beings that’s practiced in the past, but the practices the way they have practiced or have done, which are avoiding killings, sexual misconduct, stealings, and so forth.
Taking how to maintain the vows, so according to the numbers you have taken. So and if it’s a killing that like, they have practiced avoiding the act of killing. I shall, until the end of my life, I shall hereby vow to avoid the act of killing like in the way the great practitioners of the Arhats and supreme beings have done. So this is the meaning of that. So killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, and so forth, or any intoxicants, any type of alcohols made out of any grains or anything that does not need to be a alcohol, like a drugs and so forth.
There are so like those masters that avoid, I shall hereby avoid too. And so these these are the meaning of the what you’ll be repeating for one time. Yep.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.