44 min · 2,511 words · 29 January 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk opens with Lama Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path, explaining that precious human rebirth is hard to find and brief, and that contemplating this and cause and result turns the mind from attachment to this life and future lives, developing renunciation. It stresses that Dharma practice depends on motivation, so study should aim at liberation and Buddhahood for all beings, linking renunciation to Bodhicitta. It then begins on the knowers of all aspects in the fourth chapter of the Ornament for Clear Realisations.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-01-29
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 42d3edab-d509-40a2-a1d5-2ffc5185a59a
Words: 2,507
Our language is telling guests to drink more water. Oh, yeah. Yeah. It was brand new last day. It She said no.
She didn’t tell him she said it’d be beneficial. He’s like, right, drink more water. In the Three Principal Aspects of the path, Lama Tsongkhapa said, this life with leisure and endowment, which is difficult to find, is brief. By familiarizing the mind with this, we stop the allure of this life. If we frequently contemplate the cause and result, that cause and result are non deceptive and the sufferings of the saṃsāra, we stop the allure of future lives.
Now the first part of this, this life with leisure and endowment which is difficult to find is brief. The reason that he says that this life is difficult to find is because we have to have created a lot of good causes conditions and the right amount of karma in order to achieve a precious human rebirth. And even when we have found this precious human rebirth that is difficult to find, the reason it says it’s brief is that we can’t we don’t stay in this life for a long time. We don’t live forever. We have eighty to one hundred years maximum to live in this lifetime.
So the idea of us familiarizing ourselves with this is so that we make use of this this time that we have and we don’t waste it. So the reason that we think on these again and again is if we familiarize ourselves with this idea that this life is short and that it’s difficult to find a precious human rebirth then that stops us from being attached to this lifetime. And if we think about it most of the thoughts that we engage in or most of the thoughts that occur to us during our lives are actually in reference to how to make ourselves happy in this life not in future life. If we look at our experience then we will be able to see this. By thinking about how short this life is then we’re able to develop a renunciation or a turning away from looking at this life thinking about this life.
This also happens when we contemplate cause and effect. When we contemplate cause and effect or karma and we understand that karma is non deceptive that is that there is it is infallible every negative action has a negative result and so forth. Once we think on this then we will finish having attachment to all of our future lives because we will understand that all of our future existences will be governed by cause and effect if we try and get out of saṃsāra. So by contemplating on cause and effect we think about not only how pointless it is to chase after things of this life but the next life, the life after that and the life after that and so on. And then by turning our mind away from attachment to those future lives as well as this life, then we develop a complete renunciation from saṃsāra or another way of saying renunciation complete emergence from saṃsāra, the mind that seeks to emerge from saṃsāra.
So the main point of this verse, the main point of this teaching is for us to develop a renunciation. And the way that we are taught to develop renunciation is by focusing on the shortcomings of this life and future lives. So by focusing on the shortcomings, the faults of this life and future lives, then we will be able to develop renunciation from Samsāra and seek towards the definite emergence of liberation. Now if we think about it, most of the thoughts we have are about this life or future lives. And amongst those, most of the thoughts that we have in the day are about this life, in fact.
We don’t even usually think about future lives very much. So this means that from when we wake up, when we go about our business in the day, of the things that we do, most of thoughts that we have refer to how we can be happy or how we can experience positive things in this life. Now the reason that most of our thoughts are referred to this life or are focused on this life is because we are under the sway of the negative emotions like desire and attachment or hatred or ignorance. So because of these negative emotions that we have, then we focus primarily on this life. Okay.
So this is where most of our thoughts rest during the day or where my mind usually goes to during the day, is to thoughts that are encouraged or thoughts that are caused by any of these negative actions. But in actual fact if we are going to call us Buddhists then we should try and practice Dharma. Practicing Dharma doesn’t rely on what it is that we are actually doing. It relies on the motivation that we have for actually doing something. So this means that we should try and keep setting our motivation with whatever we’re doing.
This is what we need to do if we want to call ourselves Buddhist. So the motivation that we need to have is a motivation for doing something that will cause us to get rid of suffering. Now the way for us to get rid of suffering is to achieve liberation so we need to do something that’s a cause for us to achieve liberation as opposed to a cause for us to experience saṃsāra. So the antidote to saṃsāra is liberation. We need to do something that will be a cause for liberation.
So this means that when we’re going to do something whether it is we’re going to do a normal action we do during the day or whether it’s because we’ve come here to listen to teachings or to teach on the ornament of clear realization or whether if it’s we’re meditating, whatever it is that we are doing, we need to do it with the right motivation. And it’s difficult in fact for us to cultivate the right motivation because in order for us to cultivate the right motivation or a motivation seeking to achieve liberation then we have to focus on or we have understand the faults of saṃsāra, the faults of the existence that we experience at the moment. It’s difficult for us to realize the faults of the existence we experience at the moment so we need to focus on that. So the other thing is we have to make sure that there are no faults in the way that we’re thinking, way that we are the motivation we have for doing something whether it’s listening or teaching to the Dharma. So we shouldn’t be thinking if I do this then people are going to think that I’m a good person or if or if Geshe-la teaches the Dharma then they’ll see that I’m really clever or they’ll understand that I know what I’m talking about or that they’ll know that I know something a bit more than them about it.
We’re not supposed to have any of those motivations. We shouldn’t even be thinking that by studying this it will benefit our mind in this lifetime. Sorry, it will benefit us in this lifetime. So there’s actually many different faults that we can develop in the process of trying to practice Dharma, in the process of trying to have the right motivation that will lead us to be practicing Dharma. So we have to we have to develop renunciation because renunciation developing renunciation is a practice that we need to do in order to develop Bodhicitta.
If we don’t have renunciation, we can’t develop Bodhicitta. And likewise, Bodhicitta is a practice that we need to and it’s something we need to develop in order to become a Buddha. So we should be focusing on developing this idea of renunciation of the mind striving for liberation. Now, this is a similar thing when we’re looking at the fourth chapter of Clear Ornament of Realization. Because the fourth chapter of the Clear Ornament of Realization focuses on practices that we need to do, understandings that we need to develop in order to achieve Buddhahood.
We can’t achieve Buddhahood without having these understandings or these practices that are described in the Clear Ornament of Realization. So we should be thinking when we’re listening to or teaching on the fourth chapter of the clear ornament of realization that may we also in the same way that other Bodhisattvas have developed these practices have taken these taken these applications on board and following this developed the omniscience of Buddhahood may we also may this be a cause for us also to develop those understandings and follow that path. So so that’s what we should be focusing on. This is the is the text this is a text or this is an opportunity for us to be able to focus on something that will enable us to achieve realisations in order for us like other bodhisattvas before us to achieve the realisation of Bodhicitta and eventually buddhahood in order for us to be of benefit to all sentient beings. So we need to set our motivation.
We need to focus our thoughts in that way in order for us to be able to study these properly with the right motivation so our study becomes a Dharma practice. So we should think I am doing this, I am studying this fourth chapter of the clear ornament of realization as a cause and may that be a cause for me to become a Buddha, a Buddha. May that be a cause for me to become a Buddha so I may lead all sentient beings to the state of Buddhahood beyond sorrow. So maybe so we should think, may I by by this cause, I achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings? Okay.
So it is a mind or an understanding of both types. Right? So understanding both types is understanding divided into three different bits, the knower of basis, the knower of paths, and the knower of all aspects. Right? So all of those together are all included within the knower of all aspects also.
Those are the applications that are used within this knower of all aspects. Includes knowing everything. Right? Another — it’s another way of saying it’s a knower of everything. It’s a complete knowing.
Complete knowing. Oh. Right. So now within that, we’ve got three different types of knowers. Knower of bases, right?
So within these three different knowers, knower of basis, the knower of paths, and the exalted knower of all aspects, there is a hundred and seventy three different aspects, yeah, which are the complete aspects the application is complete aspect. So you apply yourself to a hundred and seventy three Now what this means is that a bodhisattva yoga is the path of a bodhisattva. So the realizations of bodhisattva, they that are part of their path, have them all lumped together. Right?
To have all of the aspects of the knowers come together. Yeah? Now this is actually difficult to understand because because some of the aspects refer to ultimate truth, and some of the aspects refer to relative truth. And it’s impossible for someone who isn’t a Buddha to have an understanding of relative truth and then ultimate truth at the same time. So what this is actually referring to is it talks about when a bodhisattva having both calm abiding and special insight, vipassana and śamatha.
Right? On the basis of their calm abiding or they then practice the or special insight with the hundred and seventy three aspects that they need to go through. Now they are able to do this in meditative equipoise because the actual nature of all of these hundred and seventy three different aspects is emptiness. The emptiness is the same. So they can go through the different aspects of the knowable aspect in a meditative session.
The hundred and seventy three are on a conventional truth. Right? You have to have meditated in equipoise on a non-analytical ultimate truth which is emptiness. Right? So what happens is the bodhisattvas go through analytical meditation based on calm abiding, meaning that that they can focus on one of these aspects that they need to understand in a consecutive manner without being distracted.
Right? So because they’ve got calm abiding, they can go through the first the first of their aspects in the normal basis is suffering. Yeah? No. Sorry.
Impermanence. So they can focus on, for example, impermanence and then suffering and selflessness and emptiness in an analytical manner going through all a hundred and seventy three aspects of the three knowers of all aspects. After doing this, they can then go into meditative absorption on emptiness and have a single-pointed focus on that. Right? But this is analytical meditation that they need to do on the knowers of all aspects, not placement meditation.
But on the basis of their development of calm abiding and special insight, they are able to focus more pointedly on all a hundred and seventy three aspects in a consecutive manner. Now so these knower of bases, yeah, have twenty seven different aspects. Yeah? There’s twenty seven different aspects to the knower of bases, which is the first section of the exalted knower of bases. Now the knower of bases is referring to the understanding of the solitary realizers and hearers, and it refers to the first twelve — the first twelve of the knower of bases refers to the four aspects of the first three noble truths.
K? And the last fifteen aspects of the knower of basis relate to the truth of the path. So there is four aspects to the truth of suffering, four aspects to truth of the origin of suffering, four aspects the cessation of suffering, and there are fifteen aspects to the truth of the path within these twenty seven aspects of the knower of bases. Now most of the time when we talk about the mind of bodhisattvas, there is they are what is called minds that understand directly the things that they are cognizing as opposed to minds that are analyzing the things that they are trying to analyzing something to try and understand it. Most of the minds of bodhisattvas and most of the consciousnesses of bodhisattvas refer to things that they actually understand. Okay.
Now we’re referring to the twenty seven aspects of the knower of bases. There’s said to be two different things involved here. There is the object that the bodhisattva is focusing on, and this is called the aspect of the object, and then there’s the understanding, the wisdom that is comprehending that object, and that’s called the aspect of the mind or aspect of the mind or the yoga that is comprehending that.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
- A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.