44 min · 2,542 words · 19 February 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a commentary on the Ornament for Clear Realisations, explaining the thirty-seven aspects of the exalted knower of all aspects that accord with hearers, and how they differ from the knowers of bases and paths. It briefly outlines the three topics of knowers of bases, paths and all aspects, and how each is realised. The session ends with a discussion of emptiness and the non-inherent existence of time.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-02-19
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 7ec81c1b-34ae-402b-9320-650d7d5a48cc
Words: 2,538
Okay. Now we have another definition, right, that isn’t in you guys’ notes. So if anyone wants to scribble quickly, I tried to work up a translation of it. Okay. So it’s the definition of an antidote to the superimpositions, yeah, that are superimposed incorrectly upon objects of meditation of the knowable aspects in the continuum of bodhisattva superiors. That’s what it is, right?
Okay. The definition of the antidote to superimpositions, yeah, that are superimposed incorrectly upon objects of meditation. You can grunt when you’re you’re getting catching up, guys. Of the knower of all aspects. So it’s objects of meditation of the knowable aspects.
Yeah? In the continuum or the continua, yeah, of Bodhisattva superiors. So it’s basically the antidotes to the superimpositions that bodhisattva superiors have, the way that they’re misguided in perceiving the objects that they need to meditate on in order to become a Buddha. So where they’re going wrong, right? Antidotes to where they’re going wrong, okay, in short form.
Now, that’s what that’s like the definition is yet to come. That’s just what they are. Yeah? Okay. A bodhisattva yoga, which is conjoined with wisdom.
Wisdom, understanding or we we just can’t no. If it’s wisdom, then it understands. Yeah? So wisdom, meditating on or focusing on. You can say here, meditating on, focusing on, habituating itself with, whichever one grabs your fancy, yeah, then knower of all aspects.
Sorry. Sorry. I just realized I didn’t read it out properly. It’s not meditating on the knowable aspects, meditating on aspects of the knowable aspects. Meditating on or familiarizing itself with aspects of the knowable aspects.
Okay, so when we said that the superiors, it’s the Bodhisattva superiors’ yoga, which is meditating or familiarizing itself with the aspect of the knowable aspects. Now what the aspects of the knowable aspects are is all phenomena. Right? So the aspects of the knowable aspects are all phenomena and so it means that the bodhisattvas are developing wisdom with regards to all phenomena. That means understanding all phenomena because with reference to all phenomena and then they have superimpositions That is misunderstandings.
So then when we went on to say that what this is the antidote to superimpositions that are superimposed incorrectly upon objects of meditation of the knowable aspects. Now objects of meditation of the knowable aspects are is a synonym for all phenomena. So it basically means that they’re getting rid of the superimpositions that they have on all phenomena through meditation or familiarization with their true nature. So that’s what bodhisattvas are doing in order to become Buddhas. Okay, so now what we’re onto is the thirty seven aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects harmonious with hearers.
Now another way of saying this is — let me find it. Where did it go? Did you guys steal my translation? Where did I put it? I showed you — I remember.
Cool. There’s a Last one. Last one. I’ll give you a Yeah. Yeah.
Okay. So there’s a I don’t know. I’m trying to figure out if it’s in you guys’ book, right? But there’s a translation by Jampa Tinley of the thirty seven practices for enlightenment, something like that. But there’s nothing else in there?
Because it was on the disc. Thank you. So it looks like this. Okay. Who’s in charge of the class?
It’s on the disc, okay? Thirty seven dhammas compatible with enlightenment. Yeah, you can. Yeah. Rob’s got the disc.
I’ve downloaded most of the disc onto my computer. So so so we because we if you guys had this, then that would make the next bit very helpful because that’s basically we’re up to and there’s like a lot of detail in this thirty seven. Can I photocopy of the next week? Yeah, that’s what Geshe-la said. So maybe we stop here and do an extended question time.
We can get One hundred percent. The things that because otherwise if you guys don’t have this, it may get complicated. I’ll get it photocopied to the next week. I just was, was, because I got given it so I assumed you guys had it. I was just asking these guys and they’re like, what?
Yeah. I might photocopy the first few pages here, though, so I can use it for next week. Okay. Yeah, but because I mean, this is why I think it’d be really good idea and there’s some things along with this, like some charts and everything. It’d be a very good idea to, if you guys I honestly thought it was in this package because I don’t usually get given things.
I was like, Oh, I’ve got it. You guys must have it. What was I going to say? Because it starts off with the thirty seven dharmas are compatible with enlightenment exist in The thirty six exist in unrestricted access aspect for joy, which is another level of the things. So don’t have a translation that’s gonna be difficult to understand.
Okay, so we’re about to go through the one hundred and ten aspects of the exalted, knowable aspects. First of all, when we’re going through those, we go through what are called the thirty seven aspects of an exalted, knowable aspects harmonious with hearers. Now, when we’re talking about these, they’re actually knowers of all aspects which means that they’re in the continuum of Buddha superiors. Although they’re in the continuum of Buddha superiors, what they are are understandings that accord with the understandings of hearers. And because they are accord with the understandings of hearers they’re actually said to be knowers of bases.
But they’re knowers of bases that only exist in the continuum of Buddhas, and therefore they are also knowers of all aspects. Do you understand, Joe? Okay. So there are thirty seven different aspects that are common to knowers of bases and that they that are knowers of bases. But these are knowers of bases that actually only exist in the continuums of Buddhas.
So this makes them different to knowers of bases that hearers may have developed. They’re knowers of bases but they’re specific to the continuums of Buddhas. So because Buddhas know everything, that means there are also knowers of all aspects. Alright? If you’re omniscient, you have knowers of bases. These understandings that are in their mind stream are said to be knowers of bases but because they’re knowers of bases they exist on the ground of a Buddha then they are said to be only knowers of basis which are only knowers of all aspects if that makes sense.
Therefore they are said to be in tune with or to be harmonious with the understandings of hearers. This is similar to the thirty four aspects that are exalted knowers of all aspects harmonious with bodhisattvas. Now bodhisattvas have the understanding of emptiness so when we’re referring to knowers of paths we’re usually referring to understandings of emptiness. These thirty four aspects that are exalted knowers are actually knowers of paths but they’re knowers of paths that are only found on the ground of a Buddha. So therefore they’re said to be exalted knowers of all aspects but they’re harmonious with bodhisattvas, or they are knowers of paths.
And there’s also said to be thirty nine uncommon aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects. So what this means is that there’s thirty nine different aspects to the knowable aspects which are unique to Buddhas. In actual fact, all of them are unique to Buddhas because they only exist on the ground of the Buddhas, all of the one hundred and ten, right? But these ones aren’t like anything else. They aren’t like knowers of paths.
They aren’t like knowers of bases. So this is why they tend to be uncommon aspects. Mm-mm. And so then to go through these a hundred and ten, you go through them very slowly, one by one. Okay, so first of all, the first thing that’s usually gone through within these one hundred and ten aspects of an exalted knower of all aspects is what’s called the four close placements or the four mindfulnesses.
But when we’re talking about the thirty seven dharmas compatible with enlightenment or the thirty seven exalted knowers of all aspects harmonious with hearers, it’s a different way of saying the same thing. You don’t just start off with the close placements of mindfulness. It goes through where these things are, in what realms and what grounds these understandings are developed and on what paths they are meditated on, their classification and so forth. So in general, in a rough overview, then we need to know that these three things that were the three first chapters of the clear ornament of realization that was knowers of bases, knowers of paths, and knowers of all aspects. There are things that are put into practice to develop the understandings of these things because Buddhas have all of these understandings.
But the knowers of bases are also known by hearers and solitary realisers, bodhisattvas and Buddhas. So there in any of the grounds there is these understandings of knowers of bases. The knowers of paths are known by bodhisattvas and Buddhas and the knowers of all aspects are only known by Buddhas. In this way then we can see that there’s the different understandings and then there’s the different practices that are put into or the different applications that are engaged in in order to develop the understandings of these things. So it’s good to remember that there’s these three things and what we’re talking about is different ways of understanding these three things, of bases, knowledge of paths and knowledge of all aspects.
So then we can stop there if people have questions. I was just asking if you had to imagine that tea was en route before you offered it. It’s best if you can, but if you just think it’s tea, then that’s fine. I said there are no questions, I understand everything. The eight pandits of Nālānda.
Okay. So here you’ve got Nāgārjuna and Nāgārjuna’s three students. And here you’ve got Asaṇga and Asaṇga’s three students, many students. So you’ve got like Dharmakīrti and Āryadeva. And then you’ve got three students of Asaṇga, which is Vasubandhu and Gunaprabha and someone else.
I don’t know how to say in in Indian. Yeah. You can talk with it. But Gesh, I can’t see them. So So he knows definitely it’s Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, and then he’s figuring out who the others would be from that because they’re said to be the eight great pandits of India.
It’s the way that they describe. And Buddhapālita as well is the other one. He doesn’t think it’s Sanatheva anymore because they’re the three students of Nāgārjuna. Right. No.
So the eight pandits of Nālānda. One of them is one of them is dividing. So he because he there’s a debated with lots of people. So so it was a sign that they’re having, like they’ve got impostures of debate, and it’s supposed to be a sign that they’re very intelligent and they have very developed minds. Yeah.
He said that it’s superior aryas. When he’s talking about this, he sometimes says. Okay. I said, they’re not asking questions. They seem to be looking down a lot, but they’re not asking questions.
He said, yeah, that’s because we got to the tough bit. Yeah. Yeah. Mhmm. He said, if you want to say it’s referring to the three times in that spine but it’s actually referring to any phenomenon so the three times are phenomena so it means that the three times aren’t observable.
That means that you’re not able to there’s no reference point for them. There’s no inherent existence there. But it doesn’t just apply to the three times. It applies to all phenomena. He said it’s He said he says it’s not referring to the So it’s not referring to the three times themselves as being non observable.
It’s referring to the emptiness of the three times as being non observable. So the inherent existence of the three times is non observable because it doesn’t exist. Is that yeah. So what was it about, Mitra? Are you a secret railian?
These railians keep asking about Gesler, about Maitreya. He said that there s many non observable bits about time, like time isn t permanent, time isn t a being, time isn t a a the permanence of time isn’t something that’s observable because it’s non existent and the beingness, like it’s not a being, right, of time is not observable because it’s nonexistent. There’s many things about time that aren’t observable because they don’t exist. He thinks this is actually referring to the anything that is not inherently existent. Therefore, the inherent existence of that is not observable.
Existent. Yeah. Yeah. No. He’s saying that inherent existence of time doesn’t exist.
You said, no, no. There are the three times. There is the past, there is the present, there is the future. But from the perspective of ultimate truth, there is no past, present and future because they aren’t inherently existent. We identify with dharmakaya.
Oh, dangerous. You want me to say that? Or does that sound a lot like Brahminism? I just said, so we can’t say that the dharmakaya is not not inherently existent. And Geshe-la is going, What?
Okay. Dhammakaya doesn’t exist either. There’s nothing that inherently exists. Unless you’re a Hindu. He said, now I’m gonna drink tea and you can all come watch me.
Can be a show. Okay. Are they bacteria? He said no because it’s very, very, very difficult to get a human rebirth. If it comes down to someone s going get very, very sick as a human and then there s many, many small animals, he said that it s much more important to give the medicine to the person who has a human rebirth because the animals don’t last that long anyway.
So, it’s much more important to focus on the human rebirth in that case. So, the medicine. Okay. So you said but okay. So what you’re doing here is there’s non virtuous action because there is these small bugs that die, but there’s a positive action because you’re helping a human to survive.
So the human to survive thing is more important. If you say mantras, it helps all beings. And so if you do it for the benefit of all sentient beings, that includes them. Don’t just think about the bugs. Yeah.
You’ve been stewing on this. No. No? Uh-huh. Yeah.
Well, you can be a titta matan. He said it’s a difficult thing to get your head around because Buddhist philosophy is very, very, very subtle. It just becomes more subtle and more subtle and more subtle. And until you’re a Buddha, you don’t really get it. So it’s just developing a subtler and subtler understanding.
But you’d have to you’d have to get rid of that before the path of seeing, wouldn’t you? You’d have to get rid of that before the path of seeing, before the path of preparation.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.