Ornament for Clear Realisations – 30 2004 06 10 OCR

44 min · 3,166 words · 10 June 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 30 2004 06 10 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains the five paths that abide in happiness in this present life, which correspond to the four formless absorptions and the liberation of cessation. It distinguishes cessation through meditative concentration from liberation of cessation as a non-associated compositional factor, and describes the peak of cyclic existence as mindless concentration. The speaker notes that the form and formless realms represent levels of concentration that can be reached without rebirth there.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-06-10

Duration: 45 min

UUID: f19ab983-e7d7-4f01-af08-f04964cb808d

Words: 3,162

Section, which is the next one, is the path abiding in bliss in this life or the five paths abiding in happiness in this present life. The commentary actually says dense and impenetrable commentary. Now the path which abides in bliss in this life has the self nature of a path which abides in accordance with liberation. It has four aspects of the four formless absorptions and one aspect of self nature of a path which abides in peace which ceases discrimination and feeling. Thus, there are five aspects.

So the five different paths that abide in happiness in this present life, The first four of these are the four levels of the formless realm, and the fifth one is liberation of cessation. This one. Okay. This one. Mhmm.

Oh, yeah. So this is doing my head in. The next one we’re dealing with is the five paths that abide in happiness in this present life. Now in these subtle levels of meditative concentration that bodhisattvas abide in, they experience great bliss. When it talks about the abiding happiness in this present lifetime, it’s talking about the fact that through these levels of meditative concentration that are usually associated with the formless realm, these beings experience intense happiness.

But they don’t necessarily only experience intense happiness because they are dedicated to the welfare of other beings not themselves. The question then comes up why would bodhisattvas working for the benefit of others be all blissed out and experiencing these states? Now it says that they don’t spend all of their time in these states but by developing these understandings they’re able to lead other beings who may need to use those concentrations to develop them in others. So by developing them in themselves, they’re able to bring those understandings to fruition in others. They can’t teach people things that they don’t understand themselves, so they develop these concentrated states in order to help others.

So, yeah, the definition that we’re dealing with here is an exalted knower that is not polluted by coarse afflictions in the continuum of a person who has attained a liberation. An exalted knower that is not polluted by coarse afflictions. What this is referring to is the fact that when a being is in the formless realm, they don’t experience the manifestation of any coarse afflictions. Yeah. So you don’t have any like a even though they haven’t been completely obliterated from the mind stream.

You don’t have any of the negative emotions manifesting. The imprints are still there but that you don’t have any gross manifestations of them in these subtle meditative states. Okay? That’s what that is referring to there. They’re not completely gone from their mind, they’re liberated from that at that present moment.

Now the fifth of these five paths isn’t actually a mind. It’s the lack of something. The liberation of cessation is a cessation. So you talk about true paths and true continuums, right? Sorry, true paths and true cessations.

A cessation isn’t a mind. A cessation is the lack of something. So in this case it’s the lack of the obscurations to subtler concentrations. So the first four are actually minds. They’re the different levels of concentration that you develop as you go through the formless realms.

But the liberation of cessation is the lack of obscurations to those concentrations. So it’s not a mind, it’s a lack of something. Okay. So the other thing is to remember is that that there’s a difference between this thing that we’re calling the liberation of cessation and what’s called a what would you say, cessation that is meditative equipoise. Right?

Now they’re a bit different, although they’re similar because the liberation of cessation is getting rid of obscurations to subtle types of meditation as one progresses up through the formless realm. So you have a very subtle meditative state which is the infinite space level of the formless realm. And then you develop that into a final concentration which has this which has this liberation of cessation that comes along with it. And then you go on to the infinite consciousness and then the nothingness and then the peak of cyclic existence. Now the peak of cyclic existence is sometimes also called the mindless meditative concentration.

Now, what the reason that it’s called a mindless meditative concentration is that there is no gross mind even there at all. All right, so we’ve already gotten rid of the form and the subtle levels of form that can be manifest in the form realm on those concentrations. But when we get up to this peak of cyclic existence, only mind that’s left is the most subtle level of mind and it doesn’t take an object. So therefore, it’s called the mindless concentration. Okay?

And that so that’s what’s called the cessation that is meditative concentration and we need to be able to distinguish the cessation that is meditative concentration, which is a mind even though it’s called mindless, and from the cessation which is liberation, or the liberation of cessation, which isn’t a mind — it is a non-associated compositional factor. Yes. Place in the evening to come out with that one. Non associated compositional factor. Non associated compositional factor.

Okay. Oh my goodness. Alright. There is a liberation of cessation that is in mind and there is a liberation of cessation that is a non associated compositional factor. Hence, we have five paths that abide in happiness in this present life and they’re all minds, including the liberation which is cessation.

When you’re getting rid of the things that we were talking about before, you are liberated from an obscuration that makes you not have these subtle levels of concentration. When you have that liberation, that’s non associated compositional factor. But there’s also a mind which is liberated from if your mind doesn’t have these negative emotions manifesting in it at that stage, it’s also said that that mind is the liberation of cessation. Okay? But there’s also two different interpretations of it and some people say that this cessation which is meditative concentration is a mind and others say that it’s not and some people say that because it has both of a non associated compositional factor in it and a mind then it can’t be either sorry, then it can’t be a mind.

Sorry. It can’t be a mind so therefore it is a non associated compositional factor. So basically when we’re talking about these five parts that abide in happiness in this present life, the liberation of cessation in that instance is a mind and it is the aspect of the mind that doesn’t have these negative emotions manifesting. There’s these two different things and in actual fact you can say the liberation of cessation which would include the cessation which is this meditative equipoise sorry, cessation of meditative equipoise, which isn’t a mind. It’s a lack of afflictive emotions and it’s also the mind that is free of afflictive emotions.

They can both be called one thing, but then you can separate them out, and one can be called a mind, and the other one can be called as a non associated compositional factor. Oh, yeah. Is that okay? Non associated compositional factor is something that is neither form nor mind. Okay.

So it’s because it’s not associated to either mind or form. And it’s a non-associated compositional factor. Compositional factor is another way of saying a thing. So it’s a thing that is neither form nor mind. So an example of this is time.

And a person. And also, everything to do with time, months, weeks, days, all of that things. Person is a non associated compositional factor. Space is a non associated compositional factor. Yeah.

I got very confused because it was like I got yes. Anyway. Okay. The liberation of cessation has two different aspects to it. It has an aspect Hang on.

It would be better if I ask Geshe-la again. I was going to repeat what I was just trying to say before but it’s better if I ask Geshe-la again because we won’t get it clearer. So what was it again? Okay, so when we talk about the liberation of cessation, right? There’s actually two different parts to that liberation of cessation, when it’s talked about in general.

The first one of these is what’s called a I’m trying to think of the best way I can think of your translation. Yes. It’s cessation maybe cessation through meditative concentration or cessation through placement. Okay? That’s one form of the liberation of cessation.

Cessation through placement. And what that is referring to is when we’re doing these meditations as described in this text, the mind becomes more subtle and more subtle and in the process of becoming more subtle, it gets rid of obscurations to that subtlety, right? The grossness of the mind that may have been able to stop it from being subtle. And every time it gets rid of grossness towards subtlety, it gets rid of a grossness and moves towards that subtlety, then it s said to have a liberation, liberation that is a cessation of grossness, which is this subtler form of meditation. And so the getting rid of something is a liberation of cessation, but it s not this liberation of cessation.

It s a liberation of cessation that is a non associated compositional factor something as opposed to this liberation of cessation. Ani, which is Okay. So, the other part, which is this liberation of cessation. Now, the reason it’s called a liberation is because it has Geshe-la gave me a very specific definition of what it is according to the Tibetan, and it doesn’t work for liberation. Anyway, the liberation means it’s gotten rid of what it set out to get rid of.

Once it’s gotten rid of the things that were obscuring that meditation, then you’re left with a result which is free from obscurations. The mind free from obscurations is this liberation of cessation here, free from manifest negative emotions. That’s what the liberation of cessation is there. But the liberation of cessation in general has these two different aspects. It can be the getting rid of something which is in a mind and it can be the mind itself.

So, when we talk about liberation of cessation, you talk about the liberation of cessation, which is a liberation, a mind that is liberated, and you talk about the liberation of cessation, which is the getting rid of negative or the getting rid of gross aspects of mind. This is a non associated compositional factor. There’s these two different aspects to it. So, they seem really similar, right? Because you basically got a mind that has gotten rid of, that’s lacking.

You’re describing a mind by saying it’s lacking obscurations, yeah? That s the mind one. Then this non associated compositional factor that we re talking about is the lack of obscurations, but you re talking about it from two different perspectives. That means that you can t say that they re mutually inclusive. You canit say that they are exactly the same thing, although that they come up as being the same thing.

You’re talking about two different aspects of the same thing — you’re talking about two different things that are focused on the same process, not two different aspects, but two different things focused on the same process. It’s so clear in Tibetan and it turns into English and it comes as gobbledygook. Yeah. That’s why I can’t yes. I was trying to think of something else.

Non associated compositional factor. So, if I did say that, I didn’t No. It’s not a mind, but the process that’s happening is you’re getting rid of negative minds. So, it’s not getting rid of things that aren’t minds. It’s the process of getting rid of things that aren’t minds which makes it not a mind itself.

It’s a process. It’s a non associated compositional factor. This is for the one aspect of the liberation of Yes. So basically, what you’re doing is you’re talking about Okay. So you have this Okay.

So, the process of getting rid of things, the meditative process of getting rid of these minds that are harmful to concentration, yeah, is said to be this concentrate. It literally says concentration, which is cessation, right? The concentration is cessation. But it’s not like a concentration as in a mind, which anyway, but it’s like the getting rid of something, the process, the getting rid of something, which isn’t a mind. And then there’s the mind that is doing the getting rid of, or has been having these things gotten rid from it.

Yeah? So, it’s a mind. Yeah? So, the things that it’s getting rid of, however, are minds. Yeah?

The thing is and in in specific, it’s getting rid of the minds which are discrimination and feelings because there’s no discriminations and feelings at this level of mind. At this, sorry, there’s no discrimination in feelings at this level of concentration. Yeah. Uh-huh. Uh-huh.

Now, did understand that bit, cool, because I got a bit lost with the two things I was going, what? But that one made sense. Go home now? Okay. No.

No. That’s okay. It’s not your fault. Was just this. It’s really complicated stuff and I was having trouble getting my head around it.

Okay. Yes. I didn’t understand that properly when I said it because obviously that’s basic logic. You can’t have a mind without a thing. But what Geshe-la said was a mind without an object.

So what Geshe-la said though is that at the level of Yes. So if you when you achieve this liberation of cessation or the one of the definitions of the liberation of cessation. Alright. So, at level of the peak of saṃsāra, you have this thing that’s a cessation, which is concentration or equipoise, right? The cessation which is equipoise, which is not a mind, is a non associated compositional factor.

At the peak of saṃsāra, when you experience this, it means that that mind disappears. You have all of these different minds disappearing. That’s why it says that there’s mindless. It doesn’t take objects except for the most subtle level of mind. So all of the other minds cease to exist because they don’t take objects and that’s when they turn into this non associated compositional factor which is the cessation of equipoise.

But what’s left, continues, yeah? So all of these minds disappear, all of the things, all the grasping at objects disappears, even down to feelings and discrimination to the focusing through consciousness and so forth, right? But a very, very, very subtle mind still exists, but you continually have this disintegration of all the grosser levels of mind, and so they don’t experience mind the same way this is where I got a bit confused because he said, They don’t experience mind the same way that we experience mind, but there’s still a continuum. So all of the minds disappear, so that’s why it’s called mindless. But there’s a very, very subtle level which still has an object.

He thinks it’s probably a nice place to live. Yeah. Because you don’t experience any suffering at all. But you’re still in some suffering. Uh-uh.

Yeah. So, okay. This is what it is. Right. So what it means is that there is no manifest minds.

The minds don’t manifest and everything like that. So there’s no more taking of objects. There’s just a subtle abiding of the subtlest level. There’s an abiding of the subtlest level mind. So that’s why it’s like there’s no taking of objects.

So it achieves after an intense meditative state and then it needs to be refreshed to get back into these states and it doesn’t last forever, no. So it goes up and down a bit and then you don’t stay in the peak forever, you you have to prop yourself up there. But that’s why it’s called mindless because there’s no taking of objects. I was. Yeah.

Okay. The formless realm was to do with the five paths that abide in happiness in this present life. So, Geshe-la doesn’t think that that is actually referring to Mahāyāna practitioners on the path of accumulation because they are Bodhisattvas, so they don tend to hang out in the formless realm. He thinks that it’s more in reference to the never-returners and the foe destroyers that they would be more likely to be absorbed in the formless realm there because there are non-Buddhists and what do you call them, Individual Liberation Vehicle practitioners in the formless realm.

Yes. So he thinks that the beings who are Aryas that are existing on the peak of saṃsāra aren’t Mahayanists. They say it. So That’s a mind, not a person. So, when we were talking about it beforehand, when you’re talking about three bases of manifestation, those bases that you’re talking about at that stage are beings.

So you’re dealing with beings who are in those levels. We’re not talking about minds. So when you talk about the nine super mundane parts, you’re talking about minds. And just because a Bodhisattva has the mental ability to develop the minds of this formless realm doesn’t mean that they’re born there. So he says, you don’t have to be confused about this.

Right? What the form and formless realms represent are different levels of concentration. Okay? Different levels of subtlety and concentration. You achieve calm abiding and then the form and formless realms talk about the different subtleties of the meditation that you’re able to do.

But you can be a being in a human body in the desire realm and have those levels of subtle concentration in your mind. You can have those meditative concentrations. You don’t have to be reborn into those realms, but if you die without the bodhicitta motivation, you can get reborn into those realms. Okay? So, in order to achieve Buddhahood, you don’t need to develop much past the second level of the form realm particularly.

You can use the second level of the form realm, second concentration or even the first concentration to perceive emptiness, to develop compassion, to use all of those things. The reason that the other types of subtle meditations are used, are developed, is in order to benefit others. But in order to get rid of obscurations, to meditate on emptiness, you don’t need all of those different subtle levels. Yeah. He just said, yes.

Well, maybe it’s like that. It’s like that. I don’t what I’m talking about but I try but I don’t know. That’s basically a translation of that.. Yeah, that’s cool.

Yep. Is this a I’ll I’ll probably ask this question if I’m getting that before. You probably ask it. Stubbornness. Yes.

Key terms in this teaching

desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
individual liberation
The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top