45 min · 2,564 words · 4 March 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching is a commentary on the thirty-seven limbs of enlightenment, covering the path of comprehending phenomena, the four close placements of mindfulness. It explains the four focal objects (body, feelings, mind and dharmas), why each is meditated on, and the common method of meditating by reflecting on both specific and general characteristics, with quotes from Nagarjuna’s Samuchaya and Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakosha.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-03-04
Duration: 45 min
UUID: af2b4e14-95a7-4e2c-a24f-5fa544e0b42b
Words: 2,560
Sorry. I’m like, Okay. On page nine. Okay. Geshe-la reckons you all know how to develop the right motivation because you’re experts and you’ve listened to a lot of motivations before.
So, he’s not going to go into a deep explanation of how to develop the right motivation. He just wants to make sure that everyone remembers that the reason that you’re listening or studying the fourth chapter isn’t just for the sake of learning, but you’re listening or studying it in order to develop understandings. Because through developing understandings and then being able to put those into practice, you can then become a Buddha and be able to benefit all sentient beings. So, in order to establish all sentient beings in a state beyond sorrow, in order to lead them to complete Buddhahood, then we first need to become Buddhas. So in order to bring that about, then that’s a motivation that we should have for doing study of this topic.
And so, motivation is a really important thing when we’re doing Dharma practice. That’s why Geshe-la said he talks about it all the time. And he’s so if he talks about the motivation, then when people remember their motivation, and then they’ll develop their right motivation. So Geshe-la said, so you have to remember to develop a good motivation. You you guys all know the motivation of the three scopes.
Yes? So last week, we went through the general overview of the thirty seven limbs of enlightenment or the thirty seven aspects that are that is the other the thirty seven aspects of Buddha’s mind that are similar to Bodhisattva’s. So tonight, we’re going to start going through them individually. So so this path, these are thirty seven aspects that we’re going through. They’re said to be common in terms of everybody on different paths is said to practice these thirty seven limbs.
That is the beings who are trying to achieve liberation practice them, the beings that are trying to achieve omniscience practice them. So they’re not something that is unique to any of the different path. So, the first of the things that we’re going through piece by piece is on page five of the translation of the the path to enlightenment, and it is the path comprehending phenomena. So this first path, the path comprehending phenomena, is talking about the four mindfulnesses, the four close placements are the first section of the thirty seven aspects. The second one, the path derived from effort, is referring to the four thorough abandonings.
The reason that it’s called the path derived from effort is that in order to abandon these negative states of mind, in order to abandon these afflictive emotions, then you need to put in effort. Hence, the path derived from effort. The next one, the path to training and concentration, what this is talking about is the four legs of magical manifestation. The reason that there is a link between these is that these four legs of magical manifestation come about in dependence on meditative concentration. So the path preparing for realization, what this is talking about is the path preparing for realization.
Realization is a different path. And when it says preparing for realization, means trying to develop those realizations or developing those realizations. And this is said to be another way of explaining the five powers. And so the next one, the path of related to realization means that they come about through realization, so therefore they have a connection or they’re part of the process of realization. Okay.
So this one, the path of realization is a synonym of realizations in general or paths in general, and it’s another way of saying the seven branches of enlightenment. And the next one, the path of definite release refers to the eight branches of the superior’s path. So, in general, all of these seven things, the seven, like two point one to two point seven is another way of explaining the thirty seven trainings or all the thirty practices of bodhisattvas. So, what did the explanation of the first which is the path comprehending phenomena or the four close placements of mindfulnesses then it is stated firstly for the path thoroughly comprehending phenomena there are four aspects of close mindfulness thoroughly investigating the specific and general characteristics of body feelings, mind, and Dharma. And the reason for doing this is to understand the four noble truths.
So this first statement where it says it is stated firstly for the path and so on. This is a quote from the commentary on Haribhādra’s commentary on the root text, Abhisamayālamkāra. And so this is in order to explain that meaning then it describes what below is called the textual meaning. And so I was saying that there’s many of them because you need to develop close mindfulness of body, feelings, mind, and dharmas. So the next bit where it says definitive analysis, what this is basically means is in order it means in order to explain it clearly.
And then there’s seven different categories within this definitive analysis. There’s seven different parts to the outline here. The first one of which is the focal object, the thing being meditated on, the method of meditation, the reason for meditating or the need for meditating, the nature of the meditation, the classifications of the meditation, the range which is also the borders. In the other text we’re working with it says the borders, and the etymology, the explanation for why it’s called the path comprehending phenomena. Then we have establishing the great fear called mindfulness as supreme.
So establishing why the Mahāyāna mindfulness is the best. So then the first one of these is the focal object or the thing that’s being meditated on, the object of meditation. The object of meditation then is said to be fourfold or the four close placements of mindfulness. That is body, feelings, mind and dharmas. Dharma here, it’s translated as Dharma.
It’s like phenomenon, not Dharma as in Buddhist Dharma. Okay? Hi, Joe. Sorry to harass you when you’ve just arrived, but if you give me my translation back, I can give this to Anthony. Can you pass it to him, please?
Geshe-la said, I’m waiting for Joe. Thank you. Right. Tardis. He said now it’s all good.
Oh. Oh. Okay. So I have to quickly explain mainly I think to Joe because he was worried you weren’t here. What we’ve gone through up until this point.
Talked about last time we went through a general overview of the thirty seventh dharmas compatible with enlightenment. And this evening we start going through those one by one in more detail and there is seven on the page five of this translation. It goes through two point one to two point seven which are seven different paths. The first of these paths is another way of saying the four close placements. The second one is another way of saying the four thorough abandonings and the third one is another way of saying the four legs of magical manifestation and so forth like through the five powers of five forces, the seven branches and the eight branches of the superior’s path.
There’s seven here and there’s seven different divisions of the thirty seven dharmas, right? So we had that. Then we had, we’re going through the path of comprehending phenomena which is another way of saying the four close mindfulnesses and the reason that the four of these are close mindfulness of body, close mindfulness of feeling, close mindfulness of mind, close mindfulness of dharmas, which is phenomena. Right? And the reason that we have these close mindfulnesses is to understand the four noble truths.
Okay. So the what are we going through? The first one we’re going through now is the focal objects. We have four: the focal object of body, the focal object of feeling, the focal object of mind and the focal object of dharmas. Within the first one there is said to be three divisions.
Is the three different divisions that we focus on with regards to the body and the first of which is said to be the external body such as form and sound etc which are not supports of the sense powers So these are objects of the senses, objects that the senses focus on. The second one says the internal body such as the eyes, etc, which are the five sense powers. So this is the physical aspect that gives rise to the senses. And then it says the body which is both internal and external such as the five of form etc which act as support to the sense powers. This is subtle form which acts as the basis from which the senses are able to operate.
So it’s not the actual eye or the ear itself but it’s a very subtle thing within that which acts as the basis for it. So this means that we have the basis or on the basis of this subtle form we have the sense powers. From the sense powers we develop consciousness. That is the five sense consciousnesses. And then the next one, the feeling there are three different divisions.
There is happiness, suffering and equanimity. Feeling is the experiences we have of pleasantness or unpleasantness and so therefore our reactions or our feelings can be of three types pleasant, neutral, or suffering. So this means that we have three different things that we need to be mindful of with the senses, that is mindfulness of happiness sorry, the feelings. So therefore we have mindfulness of happiness, mindfulness of suffering, mindfulness of equanimity. And then with the body there are three things that we need to be aware of: the perception of external forms, the subtle power for the senses, the subtle capacity for the senses, and then the even subtler base for that power.
Okay. So the next one that we’re going through is the third one. And it’s mind in this case is described as consciousness. Now when we describe the mind as consciousness in this way, it in general refers to the six different types of consciousness, the five sense consciousnesses and the mental consciousness. Now this close placement of mindfulness itself is only a mental consciousness, but the objects it takes, that is the things that it meditates or focuses on, are all of the five different senses as well as mental consciousnesses.
So then what are what is the what are the dharmas that need to be focused on. So this refers to all dharmas which are mental factors other than feeling because feeling is a mental factor so apart from those and non concordant composites and non compounds. Non concordant composites is sometimes also translated as non associated factors. Okay? There’s one.
And then associated factors. Okay. So this means that the things that we’re focusing on with the four close placements cover basically everything. We’ve got all phenomena covered through these four close close placements of mindfulness. So in this way, when we talk about the four close placements of mindfulness on body, feeling, consciousness, and dharmas.
This basically means that we have a very broad view of things. We’re focusing on all phenomena. Now the source for this idea of these being the full close placements of mindfulness is said to or one of the sources for this is said to come from the Samuchaya of Nāgārjuna. In the Samuchaya of Nāgārjuna, it says basically what we’ve just been through, that these four things, the close placements of mindfulness on these four things are what needs to be focused on. So then the reason for positing these four as the focal objects or the things we need to meditate on with the four close placements of mindfulness is because when it says because for children now children refers to ordinary beings He just said ordinary beings and he said I was going to say ordinary beings like us but I can’t really say ordinary beings like us because I don’t know if you guys are ordinary beings but then I can say ordinary beings like myself and probably you guys.
Then he said for beings like this then the body is the support for self. Our body is in a lot of ways how we define ourselves. Think this is I, I and when we think of I in a lot of ways we think about our body. Feelings are the basis of enjoyment of the self. So with our feelings we have this idea of I don’t want to experience suffering, I want to experience happiness and through that we define self as well by whether we’re experiencing suffering or happiness.
Then it says, Mind is the phenomena of self. We also think of our mind as being an inherent object, inherently existent and define ourselves by that as well. And dharma is for the purpose of abandoning conceiving the self as afflicted through attachment or aversion, etc. Now, what this refers to is the things that we need to abandon and the things that we need to practice, and because they the Dharma or the phenomena, then we may become attached to those as being inherently existent as well. So again, from the Samuchaya, the collected topics by Nāgārjuna, it s not in your translation but it’s in the commentary here.
It says, As well as this, then the self, the abiding, is considered the essence of self or the nature of self. And the base for this self is the base for enjoyment. And so the nature of self then is the nature of the thought of self is then a thoroughly afflicted idea that needs to be purified. I think I just made a mistake with that translation of that quote because it’s more like the self which is thoroughly defined by the getting rid of negative actions and the performing of purification of positive actions. So it’s those two aspects.
Sorry about that. Okay, so then, the next thing that we’re dealing with is the method of meditation. Now we’re talking about the method of meditation. There’s said to be two different methods of meditation on the foreclosed placements of mindfulness, the common and the uncommon. This one.
This? So the next one where it says the common method, and it said the method of how one meditates consists in meditating on the four: body, feelings, mind and Dharma. And then when we meditate on these we need to do so by reflecting on both the specific and general characteristics. So this means then for the body, for close mindfulness practice of the body, we need to focus on the specific characteristics of the body and also on the general characteristics of close placement of mindfulness. And similar with feelings, we will meditate on the specific characteristics of feelings and the general characteristics that come along with the four close placements of mindfulness, and so on for the mind and for dharmas.
So to back this up from the Abhidharmakośa by Vasubandhu, Vasubandhu is quoted as saying, The body, these feelings, the mind and dharmas, these should all be investigated through both specific and general characteristics. This is how you should meditate the placements.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- five powers
- The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.