Ornament for Clear Realisations – 06 2004 02 12 OCR

40 min · 2,981 words · 12 February 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 06 2004 02 12 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher works through a commentary on realizing emptiness, explaining how knowers of paths realize the lack of inherent existence of their own realizations, and how the five aspects of true sufferings relate to this. He explains that the emptiness of the realizing mind is endless in principle and that fear arising on the verge of realizing emptiness comes from the extreme of nihilism, which can be overcome by recognising one’s conventional existence. The session closes with a brief instruction on reciting the Manjushri Dhi syllable.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-02-12

Duration: 41 min

UUID: 74c6bcbf-8a0f-4dd0-8a15-78769ebe288d

Words: 2,977

K. And now because we’re talking about those with reference to knowers of paths, then we’re talking about minds realizing emptiness. It’s a different focus. So in this instance, all of the things that were they’ve already achieved a direct insight into emptiness. So they’ve already gotten rid of whatever it was they needed to get rid of, right?

And then it’s talking about the emptiness of the subsequent minds, which are realizations because we’re talking about knowers of paths. Yeah? knowers of true paths. Yeah? So it’s like the emptiness of the realisations themselves.

Is that okay? Okay. The next one, it directly realizes all phenomena as ultimately incomprehensible by a valid cognizer. Now what this is saying — it should be perhaps: it directly realizes all inherently existent phenomena as ultimately incomprehensible by a valid cognizer.

Does that make sense? Because it’s saying that, okay, if something was truly existent, then a valid cognizer could recognize it, but because it’s not inherently existent or not truly existent, then it can’t be recognized by a valid cognizer because it’s a non existent thing. Inherent existence is a non existent thing, so therefore, it can’t be recognized. It can’t be comprehended. So, this is another way of saying a realization of emptiness.

Yeah? And therefore, again, this is saying the mind or the understanding that this mind recognizing this perception of emptiness is also empty. Okay. So the Mahāyāna path of seeing has the aspect of deliverance. All right, due to directly realizing all phenomena as the aspect of non-attachment to true existence.

So it’s saying, okay, there’s this realization that ārya Bodhisattvas have, that is they’re not attached to the concept of true existence. They have no attachment to the idea of true existence or they have no attachment itself. Because once they’ve realized their non inherent existence of something, then you can’t be attached to it, yeah? Because there’s no reason to be attached to it. So non attachment to true existence and no attachment.

Now that lack of true attachment is a true path. Right? Which is in the nature of the aspect of deliverer. Yeah? Now the realisation of the emptiness of that realisation is this one, the subject aspect of the antidote class that is to do with the knower of paths in the aspect of deliverer with reference to no attachment to true existence.

Uh-uh. Mm-mm. So, and guess I said another way you could look at it as well is to say they realize the emptiness of attachment itself. So realizing the emptiness of attachment itself is that there’s a mind and realizing the emptiness of the mind realizing the emptiness of attachment is what we’re referring to here. Because it’s realizing the emptiness of that realization.

Okay. So it can get confusing because we’re talking about two different things here because we’re talking about the minds that realize these objects of meditation, and we’re talking about minds that realize the lack of inherent existence here of realizations. So you’ve got two different levels here. But he said if you just wanna think about it in terms of a mind because these beings have realized the lack of inherent existence of things and they realize their emptiness of that directly, then it means whatever they perceive, then they’re able to perceive the lack of inherent existence of that. So if you wanna think about it in terms of just the object that they’re focusing on and that lack of inherent existence, then that is actually knower of paths.

It’s just not the same knower of paths as the knower of the paths of that realization itself. So you can do it in two steps or you can do it in one. So because there’s been things that have been it’s what’s called the thing that has been abandoned or the thing that has been ceased. Yeah? The object of cessation.

The object of cessation was, for example, here grasping at the aspect of attachment to existence. Good. The attachment to existence is a thing that’s been abandoned. So thing that the realization of that thing that has been abandoned then has to be focused on. Is that okay?

The question. Gets the feeling you’re just sitting there going, yeah. Yeah. I’m not understanding anything. You guys even question on the.

Is that it’s a tricky thing to understand. He said it’s something that you have to keep going over and over again until it sticks in your mind. It’s not easy to get your head around it. Okay. Yeah.

It’s like, it’s not okay just to say, for example, that there is a mind or an understanding or an aspect, yeah, of a bodhisattva’s mind that is free from attachment that is craving for desirable objects. Because we’re not talking about, we’re not talking about knowers of bases or knowers of other things here. We’re talking about understanding emptiness. Knowing paths is understanding emptiness here. So in this case, it’s not enough to just say a mind realizing freedom from attachment that is craving for desirable objects.

It’s not enough to say a mind that realizes freedom from attachment, that has abandoned attachment, yeah? It’s not enough to say that because we’re talking here about knowers of paths, right? So, this means that in the mind of bodhisattvas, yeah, in the mind of ārya bodhisattvas, there is a mind, yeah? The mind stream, shall we say, of ārya bodhisattvas — there is a mind that realizes the non-inherent existence of the realisation of, what is it, non-attachment. Okay, because we’re talking here about knowers of paths, and that’s what knowers of paths are — knowers of realisations.

Does that make sense? Because paths of realization. So in actual fact, it’s all the same. It’s all understanding the lack of inherent existence of all these realizations, lack of inherent existence of all these paths, and all these paths are realizations. You’ve got the best faces.

Okay, so we can see the difference clearly in the next one, because we’re up to the five aspects of true sufferings with reference to knowers of paths, okay? Now, the first four of these are impermanence, miserableness, emptiness, and selflessness. Now these are realizations that are, by their nature, known as a basis, because they refer to selflessness or the lack of self of phenomena and person, okay? Now, it says in the commentary that we’ve got here, these four, in dependence on them, there are four aspects.

So it’s not the realization of them themselves, but in dependence on them, there are four aspects of knowers of paths. Okay? So therefore, it’s the emptiness of the realization, the lack of inherent existence of the realization of impermanence, miserableness, emptiness, and selflessness. Okay. So there’s another one with these, number of of five from the five aspects of true sufferings, which is without characteristics because they are empty of a truly existent entity. Now, this means that without characteristics is another way of saying without inherent existence, without true existence, yeah?

So there’s a mind that realizes that these four aspects — the realisation of these four aspects — is not inherently existent. And then there’s another mind that realizes that the mind realizing that is not inherently existent. So it’s basically any mind that comes up, anything that they think they realize, or anything that they think or experience, they realize whatever it is that it’s focusing on — the mind itself, both of them, the object and the subject, are not inherently existent. You’d have to — yeah. You’d get pretty bored.

He said basically no. He said okay. I’ll try and get how do I translate that literally? Yeah. Well, it is called omniscience.

Yeah. Yeah. He said, it’s not me. It’s the text. It’s explaining.

Yeah. A what? How can you? I think I’m gonna have a cup of tea. Oh, no.

It’s empty. I can’t. Yeah. Okay. Okay.

So Geshe-la said that it’s an endless concept. It’s an infinite concept of you think that there’s that that’s empty that’s empty and that is the mind realizing that emptiness is empty and you can go on forever, right? And developing that sense of limitlessness is developing the understanding emptiness because as a Buddha you understand that all objects or all phenomena are empty, yeah? So it’s developing that comprehension. So if they wanna not think about anything else but the emptiness of the mind that’s empty of empty of empty empty of on forever, they don’t have to have a conceptual thought because the greater their understanding of emptiness, the greater their compassion grows, the closer they are getting towards Buddhahood.

And if you have Bodhicitta and understanding of emptiness, it doesn’t matter if you don’t do anything else but meditate on emptiness until you become a Buddha. And as a Buddha, you’re able to see both conventional truth and ultimate truth in one instant. So the emptiness and the object at the same time, in the same moment. Because he said the thing we’re talking about here is people who have perceived the true nature of reality, the lack of inherent existence. So for us to try and conceive from the way that we think of what they’re thinking is almost impossible.

Yeah, and then Buddhists, I forgot something before I didn’t get it out. Buddhists perceive two truths at the same time. So everything appears to them at like an illusion, but and not an illusion, like an illusion, and they see the true nature of reality in all moments. So we’ll stop there because we’re about to go on to sixteen aspects of true cessations, but we’ll start with that next week. Yeah.

No? So if you read this bit first and then this little section to there, this is the line that I want to know whether that is the case or not. So it’s this little bit here. For most of us, when we begin to realize Right. Stopping this fear why?

Because when about to realize emptiness, you stop because of the fear, then you will not be able to bring back the experience again. What? The experience of fear or the experience? Oh. Worried that you haven’t been to the other classes, so you may be a bit confused about what’s going on.

Yeah. Yeah. It’s okay? No. Yeah.

Okay. Okay. Okay. Now, I’ll read this out for the rest of you, yeah? This is a quote from a teaching Is this on Mahāmudrā or?

Okay. Okay, so it says, for most of us when we begin to realize emptiness by recognizing the refuting object, the “I” does not exist, a very, very deep fear can arise with only another minute to the realization of emptiness. So you’re about to achieve realization of emptiness and it’s like, I don’t exist, right? You have to go through this fear. Stopping this fear becomes the greatest obstacle.

Why? Because this is the one fortunate opportunity to realize emptiness. If when you’re about to realize emptiness, you stop because of this fear, then you will not be able to bring back the experience again. Okay, so Geshe-la said, what this is referring to is the extreme of nihilism, right? So, the reason that you develop that fear is because you’ve fallen into the extreme of nihilism.

And while you have that extreme of nihilism, there’s no way you can develop emptiness. So, he’s reading this to mean that you stop because of that fear of nihilism and you’ve gotten into that extreme, you will not be able to experience again emptiness until you’ve gotten rid of the extreme of nihilism. Okay. So it’s not that possible? That’s not possible.

Yeah. Okay, so this isn’t talking about realizing emptiness directly either. Because if you realize emptiness directly, then you’re working on a understanding of a, from a, what do you call it, inferential cognizer. So if you’re focusing on an inferential cognizer, then you’re beyond doubt, have something solid anyway, so you’re not gonna have any fear coming about from an inferential cognizer. And from an inferential cognizer going to a direct realization, it’s just a matter of it changing from one idea to the other, yeah?

So you can’t develop fear when you’re going from inferential cognizer to a direct realization, right? It doesn’t make sense. So this would have to be in the process of developing and understanding of emptiness. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And while you keep holding onto that idea of nonexistence, you can’t develop.

Yeah, he says this isn’t about realizing it directly, it’s about realizing it. Yeah. So this isn’t realizing it directly. It’s realizing it. So, yes.

So, if you’re about to achieve an understanding of emptiness, which is a direct realization, but an understanding of emptiness, yeah, which is called the first realization of emptiness, but not a direct realization, right? If you’re about to achieve that realization, then you may fall into this fear, which is what happens when you fall into the extreme of nihilism. Yeah? So you may develop this idea of I don’t exist at all. Yeah?

And then you develop strong fear from that. But if you’ve been if you’re training in analysis and this is how you develop the understanding of emptiness, then you pull yourself back from that and go, wait a minute, that’s that is the extreme of nihilism. I do exist, I just don’t exist inherently and have this idea of merely labeled. I merely exist terminologically, and that brings you out of the fear that comes about through the extreme of nonexistence. He said that he seems that it would be It does seem to be kind of inevitable because we’re dealing with the fact that we don’t exist, yeah?

And so once we have that idea of not existing, we can have a sense of fear, but he doesn’t think that it should last very long because it’s pretty simple to get rid of that idea that we don’t exist inherently because it’s like we’re here. So it’s pretty simple to get rid of that idea of I don’t exist because we know that we do exist. It’s just, to get rid of that extreme of fear is pretty easy and shouldn’t last that long. It doesn’t think there’s many people that would think they don’t exist mainly. You know, it’s it’s not something that you would you would you would go to.

He doesn’t think that that would be something that would happen on a on a fairly regular basis. Because it’s pretty easy to go if I don’t to to get out of it by thinking, but I’m here, so how can I not exist? There was a group of Okay. So because I was saying that when you study tenets, one of the, what’s called the, there’s external belief holders that aren’t Buddhists and internal belief holders, right, the four schools. And in one of their external belief holders that’s called the hedonists, they don’t believe in inherent in in existence, and that’s why they think you can do whatever you want because we don’t exist, so why bother?

And Geshe-la said that from the Tibetan Buddhist perspective, there’s this guy called Hashang who got kind of thrown out of Tibet because he had a debate and lost, and that’s why they became Indian Buddhists instead of Zen people, or Chan people. And then Hashangg is said to have a view that was the extreme of nihilism. So there are some people that accept that. So from the Tibetan Buddhist perspective, Hashangg, who was this Chinese Buddhist who had a big argument with another guy in Tibet, his view is said to be the extreme of nihilism. So some people they accept it.

But there’s it was like going yeah. Because it depends like, you know, Chinese Buddhism, they’re all into guess I didn’t say other people. They’re all into nihilism. And then I Geshe I think Geshe did he really say that we don’t exist so? And Geshe will say, well, it depends if everyone has a different view on what Lhasan said.

And there was a couple of people that said that Mahāmudrā was a was a, extreme of nihilism, a couple of Tibetans. I guess that’s yeah. That’s true. I’ve heard about that, but I don’t know anything about it. It’s it’s the thing is for two reasons.

First of all, on a more superficial reason, it’s supposed to make it easier for you to speak. And Mañjuśrī is the deity of speech. Yeah. So it’s supposed to be a help you speak. The other thing is the Dhi is the seed syllable of Mañjuśrī.

So at this stage of the Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi the Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi Dhi, they’re coming into your brain from Mañjuśrī or into your, I can’t describe visualizations very well. Now all the d’s are coming into you. Yeah. The Dhis are coming into you. And therefore, it’s supposed to be a very powerful kind of you’re taking it the essence of Mañjuśrī.

You’re supposed to do a mala. Mala. I because, like, when I we got taught it, then they said do a mala out of it. And when your breath out finishes, then stop. And and then that’s supposed to be a mala in a breath.

Yeah? And Geshe-la said, yeah, but you can start again. However many you wanna do is fine. It just depends on who’s describing it. There’s different ways of saying it.

How do you Is that okay? Sit. Talk to me again. Like, I didn’t talk enough. Yeah.

Yeah. But it’s still opening the mouth.

Key terms in this teaching

conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
Mahamudra chag ya chen po (Tib)
The Great Seal; a profound system of meditation upon the mind and the ultimate nature of reality. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
seed syllable dru (Tib)
In tantric visualizations, a Sanskrit syllable arising out of emptiness and out of which the meditational deity in turn arises. A single syllable representing a deity’s entire mantra. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top