Ornament for Clear Realisations – 58 2004 10 21 OCR

42 min · 3,235 words · 21 October 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 58 2004 10 21 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the sixty-two wrong views and how Nāgārjuna’s Roots of Knowledge groups them into sixteen, eight about beginnings and eight about endings, and into four positions on existence and nonexistence. It describes how understanding of emptiness develops from doubt tending towards truth to direct perception, and explains the different meanings of non-duality. The session ends with morning dedication and prayers.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-10-21

Duration: 43 min

UUID: 6dfc8590-41cb-4e01-a30a-b93eee7a8d7d

Words: 3,231

Okay. So this is very short, so it makes it easier. Now the first of these is the reason why people would have the reason why these are wrong views. And the reason that they’re wrong views is that because they’re collections of wrong views. They’re views that are from a Okay.

Their views that are based on a collection of misperceptions of the transitory collection. Do you remember the transitory collection? The wrong view that was the wrong view of the transitory collection? Yes. So they’re views that were based on a misperception of a collection of the view of the transitory collection.

So that’s the cause for these wrong views to come about. Now the second one, which is what goes before the development of these wrong views, and it says what precedes the development of these wrong views is a listening to and a belief in a collection of different presentations of Dharma that are not correct. Means basically listening to dharmas that are proposed by people who aren’t Buddhist. Okay. The fourth one is no, the third one no, hang on.

We did the base and then what comes before? Okay, the base. Base for them, which is number three, the base for them to develop these wrong views is when they are relying on someone who has dealt or developed realisations in a worldly way that they haven’t developed a correct perception of reality and haven’t developed any what I call transmundane past that is past based on a perception of emptiness. Once people have not developed these perceptions and put forward positions with regards to reality, then they are going to mislead people. If someone is going to rely on teachings given by such a person, then they are going to be confused and develop wrong views.

So that’s the third way to describe these wrong views is that they come from an incorrect base. The fourth one is with regards to time. Now with regards to time, they have developed a misperception of time. They have an idea that their past and the present and whatever they’re looking forward to in the future. These things have a limit and that there will be a time in the future where time ceases to be and that there was a time in the past where time wasn’t.

So this is with regards to time, are also mistaken. So they are also relying on wrong views, which is five. Now, the wrong views that people rely on in order to develop incorrect views or the wrong reasonings, perhaps, is the best way to put it. The wrong reasonings that people rely on in order to develop incorrect views are reasonings with regards to the extreme of existence or the extreme of permanence, reasonings with regards to the extreme of nihilism, also reasonings with regards to nirvana or liberation in that they don’t believe that nirvana or liberation exist. Okay.

So the third one is the those the places where beings who have the sorry. I’ll put it another way. The knowledge of where the knowledge and the beings like this the beings that propound these negative ideas or not not not negative. Where the knowledge, beings that propound these misperceptions comes from. Okay?

Where their where their ideas come from, they they come out with this stuff. And so that is because they have developed a clairvoyance based on the the meditative stabilizations of the form and formless realms. So based on their meditative stabilizations, are able to develop a clairvoyance to a certain degree. Then based on their individual levels of clairvoyance, they then come up with these ideas. They wouldn’t be able to come up with these ideas if they didn’t have some form of clairvoyance, but their clairvoyance and their meditative concentration that they’re depending these views on is afflicted or tainted clairvoyance and tainted meditative concentration.

Okay, so these all of these different types of these are sixty two different wrong views that were described in the previous section that we went through the different sections. Now isolating of these into these categories actually comes from another Nāgārjuna’s text, Roots of Knowledge. And that’s also where these little ways to remember the wrong views come from as well, the pithy little sayings. They come from Nāgārjuna as a root of text, root of knowledge. And so within these, he subsumes all of these categories into eight that deal with Sorry.

Of course. Sorry. I didn’t understand. Okay, so sorry. So he subsumes all of these And again in these texts, Roots of Knowledge by Nāgārjuna, he subsumes these two misperceptions into sixteen misperceptions, eight of which refer to the extreme of things always existing and eight of which refer to the extreme of some kind of end, come something things coming to some kind of end.

Okay. So the eight different views that related to the extreme of some kind of beginning or something to do with beginnings. All right, so the first one of these that relates to the extremes of beginnings is that self came from somewhere. The second one is that the self didn’t come from anywhere. And the third one is that the self both came from somewhere and didn’t come from anywhere.

And the fourth one is that the self neither came from somewhere or didn’t come from anywhere. And the fifth one is that the self is permanent. The second one is that the self is impermanent. And the third one is that the self is both permanent and impermanent. And the fourth one is that the self is neither permanent or impermanent.

So the eight that was with regards to what happens to the self or what will happen to the self in the future that is the extreme a future event, either ending or generating the self is that they there are those that say that in the future, the self will be generated. Those that say or or a self will be generated. Those that say that in the future, self will not be generated, those that say that in the future the self will be both generated and not generated, those that say that in the future the self will be neither generated nor not generated. That’s a double negative. And those that say in the future the self will be permanent.

Those that say in the future the self will continue indefinitely. Those that say that in the future the self will not continue indefinitely. Those that say that it will both continue indefinitely and not continue indefinitely, and those that say that it will neither continue definitely or indefinitely. This one. So then there’s a quote from the roots of knowledge, and it seemed very, like, Tibetan.

And it says I said, guess what? Can’t translate that on the spot. So can we just leave it? And I said it basically says the same thing as what we just said anyway. He goes, well, it says the same thing.

How come you can’t translate it? And and I said, because it’s in a different we said it in a different way. And he goes, well, then we don’t need to say So then there’s another way to describe wrong views with regards to the fourteen different wrong views. Then there is said to be four that relate to the extreme of what came previously, four that relate to the extreme of what comes in the end, four that relate to the basis of nirvana, and two that relate to the basis of two that relate to the body the basis of body and life force. One relating to the basis of body and one relating to the basis of life force.

Okay. So we have five more pages of different divisions of wrong views. Have you guys had enough wrong views? And next week, we’ll go to definitions or the description of the knowledge characteristics of the application in a noble path? Or do you want to continue with more descriptions of wrong views?

We’re just trying to figure out where to go for two from now. Two or three? He goes, you both all seem so enthusiastic about not skipping anything last week, and now what’s happened? Okay. Yeah.

So next week, we’re gonna do the what’s called the meaning of this text, which is an overview of the knowledge characteristics of the application in a noble path. Okay? Okay. So they said after two weeks, we’ll do the knowledge characteristics of the application in a noble path. We’ve gotta get up at five o’clock.

Two days in a row. I think I’m even. Me. Geshe will be fine. Yeah.

Yeah. I’m just yes. What was I saying? I will not have thoughts about it. I will not have mean thoughts about it.

Okay. So he’s just worried that we would have to get up earlier than that because the sun will come up, and I said, no. There’s daylight savings starts this weekend. And I said, so that makes it worse. That means we have to get up at four o’clock, really.

If it’s five if it’s six o’clock, which is really five o’clock, then he doesn’t think the sun’s gonna be out because of daylight savings. But if it was six o’clock, that was really six o’clock, then the sun would probably be up. Yeah. Three was maybe. Yeah.

But it’s really five. I said, yeah, we’re just trying to sort it out. Guess I said because I I I said, oh, they probably have great questions, Geshelyn. Geshelyn goes, they got questions about the what do you call it? non-Buddhist views?

And he laughed. I have I have three, four questions. non-Buddhist views? Probably. But he said not just emptiness, but also renunciation and refuge.

Loss. Loss. And so he said, basically, what we’re talking they’re talking about here, these sixty two ones, they’re actually what was around when the Buddha came. So that was actually before a Buddha showed up in this world, in this eon. So so the so they so it said that one of the main reasons that the Buddha actually came to Earth was to show people their incorrect views of these sixty two wrong views.

But he obviously didn’t go to corners or whatever it’s corners here. What’s it called? Cosmic pages. But these people were experts. Guess I said, you you know, you we shouldn’t be dis dis like, this dismissive of the people that came up with these ideas because, obviously, if anyone’s had this kind of clairvoyance, then Neither.

It can’t be neither. Yeah. Well, the that because what but the difference is what Nāgārjuna was doing with these four ways that things can exist. It was proving that they can’t exist that way. Yeah.

Yeah. So it’s proving emptiness. But these are people that are positing existence in one form or another or or nihilism in one form or another. So when Nāgārjuna was going through using these four different ways of things existing to to refute other people’s positions, these were the positions that he was refuting. Yeah.

So this is the four ways that things can exist as either something or another as both or neither. Alright? So this is the different positions that people were putting forward. But what then what this is is like collecting people’s views into those four different forms. What Nāgārjuna was using logic to refute each one of those four different ways of existing.

So he used these different ways that things exist to prove that things don’t exist. He was using these four ways that things are said to be able to exist in order to prove that things don’t inherently exist or can’t be truly established. In the roots of knowledge, this is what these negative views were taken from, is the Roots of Knowledge’, a text by ANagarjuna. In the Roots of Knowledge’, he says ‘things can neither be posited as one or another or both or neither. Alright?

So then that’s the basis of this text. He goes through all of these views and said there’s another neither one nor the other nor both nor neither. So it’s taken from the same place. No. What we work I was trying to figure it out.

Yeah. No. The way that we work is we start off with what’s called when we start developing understanding, we develop what’s called a doubt tending towards truth. So we think, well, things probably are empty, or probably they are empty. I guess we go, I don’t know how to translate that.

But it means like maybe. So it’s that we have a doubt tending towards truth. So we can have doubts tending away from truth, doubts tending towards truth. So the way that you start developing a realization of emptiness is what we can develop now is having a doubt tending towards truth. Then we go from a doubt tending towards truth to a doubt that is in between, that is half truth and half turning away from truth.

Then we work towards developing what’s called firm belief. From firm belief, we go on to developing what’s called a So that’s like having a realization of emptiness, a firm belief and conviction in emptiness. Then we go from that to developing what’s called an inferential cognition of emptiness based on that firm belief. From that, working through what’s called subsequent cognition, we end up with a direct perception of emptiness. What do you mean by non duality?

Honestly, because there’s about four different ways that I can ask that. And there’s different ways that it is used in different schools, from different philosophical point of views, from different so I need to know what you mean by nonduality in order to translate it. Coming up in the reading on Tuesday night alone that and it’s being related to the one she realizes emptiness she realizes nonduality. In which way? Who’s saying it first?

Lama Yeshe is saying it? Lama Yeshe. Lama Yeshe. Lama Yeshe. Lama Yeshe taught very eclectically.

So sometimes he teaches from one position, sometimes he jumps to another position, then he jumps to another position. Honestly, because I need to know where you’re coming from before I can ask a question. Because okay. Cool. Geshe-la said non duality can mean at least seven things he can think of off the top of his head, and he’s sure that there are many other things that it can mean.

So I said that you were quoting from Lama Yeshe’s, and Lama Yeshe teaches from all different points of view when he’s teaching, so I’m not sure which one it means. If he’s teaching from the point of view of Mahāmudrā, then the non duality of subject and object can mean two things. It can Mahāmudrā, the non duality of the nature of the mind perceiving emptiness and the emptiness itself. Also, you can also talk about the non duality of the ultimate truth. So that means that if you’re talking about it from a sūtra point of view, a mind perceiving emptiness, when a mind perceives emptiness, the knower, or the mind perceiving emptiness, realizes the emptiness of the mind perceiving emptiness as well as the object being perceived.

And so then it’s said to be the non duality of subject and object from that perspective. Then from other perspectives they say that the mind and the emptiness it perceives are actually of the same nature. Yeah? So that’s another way of saying non duality. So that’s a different definition of non duality.

In Tantra they talk about In tantra, they talk about non duality being the non duality of emptiness and bliss. Loss. Loss. Okay. So loss.

Loss. Loss. Loss. Okay. So and then this is that’s another one.

Quite another one. Is it the in the non duality of bliss and emptiness is another one. Then also in Chittamatrin view, they say that as an object and it’s a subject come from the same imprint on the mind stream that they are non dual. Therefore, the description of emptiness as perceived by the Chittamatrin view and also by the Svatāntrika’s perception of what solitary realisers perceive as emptiness, they’re all non duality, as in terms of the object and the subject having the same essence. Basically, this word that’s translated as non duality in Tibetan is means not to.

Not to. Not to. Yeah? Mi is to. Su means like as.

Yeah? Meba. So not as to. Right? So I guess I said whatever it is that’s not as to depends on whatever text it’s in.

So it’s not it’s not it doesn’t can’t be defined as anything. It depends on what context is being used in. So if something says not to, you need to know what to aren’t separate. Okay? So the nonduality or the you have nonduality of something.

The nonduality of what you need to ask. Nonduality of subject and object, the nonduality of bliss and emptiness, the nonduality of the mind and the mind realizing something. So the non duality of the two truths. Yeah. So there’s all sorts of things.

You need to look at the text, you said. Yeah. So he said, yeah, you need to look in the text for that. They they can’t just say nonduality. They have to say nonduality of something.

Nonduality of bliss and emptiness. So that’s why I going, hang on. You have to tell me what nonduality. It means all sorts of stuff, and you can translate it all different ways. Yes.

Thank you. I have one more question. What is the similarity of the peacock feather? Okay. So he he thinks basically that, honestly, they’re just they’re just making things look pretty.

But So they but where they originally came from is that they had umbrellas back in the day in India that were made from peacock feathers that designated that the person underneath the umbrella was either a king or a very precious teacher or someone of great importance. So it basically means that there is none higher what you’re saying is then there’s none higher than that person because they’re only covered by peacock feathers. Yeah? So it’s a symbol of importance or royalty, and it comes from this idea of the back in the olden days having peacock feather umbrellas. Mabchakki?

Mabchakki. Is it Mabchendro? So they don’t actually use the word feathers. It’s another word. Yeah.

It’s just yeah. It’s a specific word for peacock’s feathers. Is everybody else okay there? Everybody else is going to sleep. Okay.

Here we go. Merry-go-round the essential prayers book. Page oh, no. Twenty six. This one’s easy.

Maybe. Morning prayers. Morning prayers. Morning prayers twenty six. I found them all on the one page.

Okay. So we’re gonna do dedication prayers. You’re gonna do short life oh, hang on. There’s a month. Dollar somewhere too.

No? No. That’s it. Yeah. Yeah.

No. But it’s but oh, no. We don’t have to. Whatever. Okay.

So dedication prayer, short long life prayers for Dalai Lama, and short Vajrasattva. And then one time through prayer for Tsongkhapa because that kinda covers all teachers. Alright?

Key terms in this teaching

Mahamudra chag ya chen po (Tib)
The Great Seal; a profound system of meditation upon the mind and the ultimate nature of reality. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top