Ornament – 12 O 1990 05 17

1 h 38 min · 4,179 words · 17 May 1990

Ornament (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament - 12 O 1990 05 17
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk continues a discussion of the exalted knower of all aspects, explaining the twenty-seven aspects of the knower of basis and the thirty-six of the knower of paths via the four noble truths. It covers the eight aspects of true sources (desire, hatred and ignorance as causes, and the self-grasping conception) and the seven aspects of true paths, which are presented as thesis and proof about the path of seeing directly realizing emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1990-05-17

Duration: 1h 39m

UUID: d0268be5-442e-4acb-a5cc-4c17e9432302

Words: 4,175

So we’re discussing the knower of all aspects and amongst the terms of the eleven topics. So the objects of meditation of the complete the the complete training in the aspects, which is topics. Complete we’re discussing the peak the training in the aspects, which has eleven topics. This is under the objects of meditation of this complete training. There are a hundred and seventy three aspects in terms of the three exalted knowers.

And the first of these, in terms of the exalted knower of basis, is twenty seven aspects. And we discussed these twenty seven aspects in terms of the four noble truths. True suffering having four, true sources having four, true cessation having four, and true paths having fifteen, making a total of twenty seven. So there are three vehicles, the hearer’s vehicle, the solitary realizer’s vehicle, the great vehicle. And the within the hearer’s vehicle, and the solitary realizer’s vehicle.

The main objects of meditation, the main practices are taken up by means of these twenty seven aspects. So mainly they cultivate the mind of renunciation, that is the mind which seeks to definitely emerge from cyclic existence by means of abandon abandoning cyclic existence and achieving liberation. Can you hear me? Can you hear me, Tonya? Knower of path, which has thirty six the exalted knower of path having thirty six aspects is the the main object of meditation by the bodhisattva superior among the two types of superior, the lesser vehicle, and the bodhisattva superior.

The bodhisattva superior takes up the meditation on the thirty It just says the the twenty seven aspects of the knower of basis was was explained in terms of the four noble truths. Likewise, the thirty six aspects of the knower of paths is explained in terms of the four noble truths. But the mode of present but the mode of presentation differs with respect to the four noble truths. In the present explanation, the four noble truths are presented in the order of first true sources, then true suffering, true paths, and true cessation. So the mode of presentation of the four noble truths differs in terms of the explanations of the knower of basis and the knower of paths. In terms of the knower of paths,

First, the causes are presented and the effects of those causes are then explained. Here, in the knower of basis, the effects are first explained, and then the cause is explained. In this present explanation — the knower of paths — the four noble truths are explained with the cause first, and then the effect. For example, the causes of suffering are true sources, and the effects are true sufferings.

Then true paths are presented as a cause for true cessation. The mode of explaining the cause and effect is in terms of entering into or taking rebirth within cyclic existence and being liberated from cyclic existence. It is a cause which brings about rebirth. So first, as far as entering into cyclic existence, taking rebirth — the cause of which is karma and afflictive emotions, which are true sources. The effect of that is suffering. That is a true suffering.

The effect of taking rebirth within cyclic existence is suffering. From the from the point of view of liberation, its cause is our true path, and the effect of true path is liberation from cyclic existence, which are true cessation. The reason in the previous explanation of the Four Noble Truths that true sufferings were presented first, which is the result, is as a means of developing the mind of renunciation with respect to cyclic existence, taking the mind, reflecting upon the sufferings of cyclic existence. Again and again, one develops a mind of renunciation, which is a striving for liberation. So, initially, true sufferings are presented first in order to develop such a mind of renunciation.

So having by means of presenting true sufferings first and reflecting upon the nature of suffering, one may develop the mind of renunciation, that is the striving for liberation, And he goes on to examine what are the causes of cyclic existence in which we seek to be liberated from. And this would take you to an understanding of true sources. And then questioning whether one has the ability to actually be rid of these true sources. Can they be abandoned? This would cause you to understand that the third of the four noble truths — true cessation — that one actually has the ability to attain true cessation, is the understanding of the ability to abandon the causes of cyclic existence.

And then one could go on to question, well, how do I go about abandoning the causes? This would lead you to true paths. So this is what in this manner of presentation, the effect is presented first. So from the within the category of abandonment, first, true true sources are presented, and then the effects of those true sources, true suffering. And within the category of factors to be cultivated, the cause — true paths — are presented, and then the effects, true cessation or liberation itself.

First, the causes within the category of abandonment. This would be true sources and within. There are eight aspects in terms of the exalted knower of paths. Eight aspects of true sources. So as was mentioned previously in the explanation of the four noble truths, that each of the four noble truths has four characteristics making a total of sixteen with respect to the first this mode of explanation, true sources.

They are as was mentioned, cause and source, condition and strong production. That true sources are causes, that is to say suffering depends upon true sources for their arising. They are sources in that in dependence upon true sources, all suffering arises. They are conditions in that they assist in the production of suffering, and they are strongly strong producers in that by means of true sources, we experience pronounced suffering. As was mentioned, there are eight aspects with respect to this noble truth of sources.

The first characteristic cause has three aspects. Source has three aspects, and condition and strong production which have one each, making a total of eight. So we said there were three aspects to this first characteristic, which is that is cause. And these three these three aspects of this first characteristic cause are the three types of desire attachment three types of desire attachment, desire slash attachment, or something like that. Desire attachment or just attachment.

These three types are thinking about the the desire the desire which arises in respect to gaining future objects. Like, I would like to have that object. Desiring object in the future. Would like to have that object sometime. Then the desire which arises desire attachment which which arises in respect to present objects, holding on to present objects.

Then the desire attachment which arises at the time of death when one is about to die in this life, desiring and having attachment for appropriating a new set of aggregates in the future rebirth. These are the three types of desire attachment, three aspects of cause. So cause has three aspects. Sources also has three three aspects. This is explained in terms of the root of of all suffering arises by means of three.

That is these three being desire attachment, hatred, and obscuring ignorance. Acting as the root of cyclic existence. The source of suffering is in terms of these three aspects, desire, hatred, and obscuring ignorance. These three. The next characteristic — and perhaps the order has changed a little bit — is strong production.

And strong production is we’re going is means of strong production, as was mentioned, is is that the true sources act as a means of producing pronounced suffering. And this is by means of in three ways. And these three ways are combined into taken as one aspect. And these three ways are holding the impermanent aspects, impermanent aggregates, holding grasping the impermanent aggregates as permanent grasping or conceiving the impermanent aggregates as permanent grasping or conceiving the impure aggregates as pure The impure aggregates as pure. Grasping or conceiving the that the nature of the suffering aggregates is happiness or satisfactory.

That the that the the aggregates, which are in nature suffering, have a nature of happiness. These are combined into one aspect. And the fourth characteristic was conditions. These assist in the production of suffering. And this is this aspect is the conception conceiving of the self of persons or grasping the conception of which grasping at the self of persons is conditioned.

So, true sources are to be abandoned. In order to understand what we mean by true sources, and thereby, in order to understand what needs to be abandoned, we have to be able to identify what the true sources are, and we identify them from true sources by means of these eight aspects. As was explained, that the characteristic of cause, there are three aspects. Sources were three, conditions one, and strong production was one. These are the causes of suffering and these are what are to be abandoned.

So when we talk about abandoning true sources, we’re talking about abandoning these eight aspects. So true sources are that which could be abandoned, and we use an an antidote which does the an antidote which does the abandon the antidote does the abandoning. And what is the antidote which does the abandoning? It is the exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness. Exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness is the antidote which does the abandonment of these eight aspects of true sources.

Therefore, because the the bodhisattva superior is seeking to abandon these eight aspects, he or she meditates in order to generate exalted wisdom and realize it. Continue. So this is this is why these eight aspects are objects of meditation of the exalted of the exalted knower of paths because these true sources are there are these eight abandonments of true sources are directly abandoned by means of exalted wisdom, exalted knower of true paths, by means of developing a direct realization of emptiness. So these eight aspects are what are are being abandoned. They themselves are not an exalt, are not aspects of the exalted knower paths.

What is the exalted? What are the eight? There but there are eight corresponding realizations, direct realizations of emptiness, which are the antidotes which abandon these eight abandonments. And these eight are the actual aspects of the exalted knower of paths, which do the abandonment. So then I was having trouble understanding the meaning of of the word, and most of that was just to help me understand the word.

So maybe I might be wrong, but I’ll correct you as we go along. So there were there were eight aspects with respect to true sources in terms of the the antidote which abandons the eight abandonments. And now we’re going to discuss true paths, which is a cause. And we’ll discuss it in terms of, hopefully, two two categories, thesis and proof. Thesis and proof.

So as we as as was previously explained in terms of true paths, there were four characteristics. I hope I correct me if I translate differently this time. I don’t remember. The first was path. The second was knowledge.

Is right? The third was achiever, and the fourth was definite emergence. Is that right? The way I translate this. And these there are seven aspects with respect to these four, which they’ll be shared out amongst these four.

With respect to the first path, in in general, the the great vehicle Dharma is extremely profound and difficult to understand. Difficult to understand in the sense that to come to a stable, thorough understanding is difficult. So there are many tenet holders outside of Buddhism which do not set forth a the the goals of liberation and omniscience. They do not accept these as the existence of these goals. These are held to be within the context of Buddhism distorted views that the nonexistence of liberation and omniscience in order to us to in to come to an understanding of the fact they exist.

First, we must eliminate the distorted view which holds their nonexistence. And this is done by presenting a thesis that the path does exist to these ends and then by various types of reasoning proving various types of reasoning establishing that these paths are a means to achieve this end. So they are explained by first posing a thesis that there exists a path and then proving that the path is a means to achieve the ends of liberation and omniscience. Right? Thesis and proof.

So there are numerous types of distorted views, first beginning with the distorted views amongst non-Buddhists who do not accept, for example, the existence of Buddhahood. Therefore, they do not accept the existence of paths leading to Buddhahood. But even within Buddhism, there are those who hold the distorted view that they do not accept the validity of the great vehicle, Dharma, and therefore all the various paths presented within the great vehicle are not actual means to achieve the goal of Buddhahood. But not only but as an example of such a type of person is Vasubandhu. Vasubandhu initially did not accept the existence of the great vehicle, and therefore, did not hold that the great vehicle paths were valid means for achieving Buddhahood.

So previously, when Vasubandhu was a holder of great exposition tenants, he said that Nāgārjuna was an emanation of demons and that Asaṇga his brother was a follower of his. Nāgārjuna is a follower of demons and my brother is an emanation of demons — no, my brother is a follower of his. And Nāgārjuna set forth the the great vehicle and especially in terms of the view of emptiness. And Vasubandhu said that these don’t exist. And his brother was Asaṇga who was his older brother, and his older brother was a a great proponent of the great vehicle.

And that and this is what he said about So the story is that Vasubandhu at this particular time was deprecating the great vehicle of Nāgārjuna and also Asaṇga his brother. Asaṇga wanted to help his younger brother so he sent one of his students and explained to him that his younger brother was deprecating the great vehicle and he told him to go at night to the village where Vasubandhu lived and to spend the night near his house and to there to recite a great vehicle sūtra. And and and Vasubandhu knew that this student of Asaṇga had come and was reciting, and he said, alright. I’m gonna listen over here. I’m gonna over listen.

I’m going to over I’m going to hear. I’m going to listen to. I’m going to eavesdrop on on what what is what he’s chanting when he was reciting this text. And as night proceeded, firstly, the text went through the basis of the path of the great vehicle and Vasubandhu became more and more interested and intrigued by what was being said. And then it came to the various paths of the great vehicle and his enthusiasm began to develop.

And finally, came to the So, you know, Vasubandhu was a great master. He had great wisdom. And by listening, by simply listening to the, this text that was being recited, he came to a quick understanding of the nature of the cause and effect which by which the vehicle was operating. And he developed this having a great developed this great understanding and this great faith, he went to his brother Asaṇga and he said, This is really wonderful. The great vehicle I now have developed this tremendous faith.

And he said, I would like to meet Maitreya. It had happened that many texts through Asaṇga, and Vasubandhu said, I would like to meet Maitreya myself. But Asaṇga communicated with Maitreya passing on his brother’s request saying that Vasubandhu would like to to meet with you. And Maitreya said that previously because Vasubandhu had deprecated the great vehicle so very much he had created a great deal of negativity, and therefore, he he I will be unable to meet him in this life. Having said that because of the negativity you created in this life, I will not be able to meet you in this life.

He said, if you compose many commentaries to great vehicle works, then I will let us say, if you write many texts, commentating on the on the text of the great vehicle, then I will be able to meet you in future life. And therefore, there And the great vehicle is extremely vast and profound. And even with amongst Buddhists, there were there were many who did not accept its existence, who could not fathom it. And therefore, it was necessary to to to, by use of reasoning, prove that paths were an actual means to attain Buddhahood. And therefore, there were seven there developed the seven aspects of true paths in order to bring to establish through reasoning that these were actual means to attain Buddhahood.

So these seven aspects of the of the true path We said that true path has four characteristics. The first is path, and this has two aspects. It has a thesis and proof. Likewise, the second is knowledge, and this has thesis and proof. The third is achiever has thesis and proof.

And the fourth characteristic, which I think translated is definitely emergence, only has thesis. It doesn’t have proof. So these are the seven aspects shared out amongst these four characteristics. So do you understand how the seven aspects of the exalted knower of paths are applied to the four characteristics of true paths? The first characteristic — path — having the two aspects, thesis and proof; knowledge likewise. So these are all aspects: these seven are the seven aspects of the exalted knower of paths.

And as we know, the exalted knower of paths does not exist on the path of accumulation. There are five paths of the great vehicle: path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, no more learning. And the exalted knower of paths does not exist on the first of these two, accumulation and preparation. So with respect to the first characteristic — path — the path is the first of these three remaining paths in which the exalted knower of paths exists upon. The path of seeing, which is the direct which is the exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness, is a path which establishes all sentient beings in liberation.

This is the thesis. A path of seeing, which is the direct exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness, is a path which establishes all sentient beings in liberation. This is the thesis aspect of this first characteristic path. The path of seeing which is the exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness is a path which establishes all sentient beings in liberation. This is the thesis aspect of the path characteristic.

So the thesis is that the path of seeing, the exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness, is a path which establishes all sentient beings in liberation. That’s the thesis aspect. And the proof aspect is because by meditating the this path, there arises the occasion of the liberation of all sentient beings. By meditating this path, there there occurs the occasion of the liberation of all sentient being. So if we’re gonna create, make an analogy with respect to food, that it is beneficial if we take it as our thesis, generally we accept that it’s beneficial to eat nourishing food.

It’s beneficial to eat nourishing food. We accept this thesis. But if we were to say why, that is the supply of proof, because their in dependence upon eating nourishing food, there arises the welfare of the body, the health of the body, the enhancement of the life of the body. Because these occasions of the enhancement or the health of the body arise, this is proof that it is beneficial to eat nourishing food. So if we explain it in in terms of the Dharma, what we’re what we’re what we’re essentially trying to get at is that by means of meditating on emptiness one can attain liberation.

This is our essential thesis and we’re going to try to prove this thesis. Why? Because so we have to have a proof which establishes our thesis. And the proof is that by meditating on emptiness we are able to destroy all the obstacles to liberation, and there is the occasion of the bliss of liberation arises. This is our proof that meditating on emptiness is a means to attain liberation because it is by by means of it is a means because by meditating on the emptiness, we destroy the obstructions to liberation and the occasion of the bliss of liberation arises. So there was, with respect to the characteristic path, thesis and proof.

The second characteristic is knowledge. And that the the knowledge that the that the path of seeing, is the exalted knower, which realizes emptiness, is knowledge because it knows its object directly, which is emptiness. So the third characteristic is achiever. Again, the exalt the the path of seeing, the exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness is an achiever, is an achiever because, and if we just talk about this roughly, that it acts to bring about higher qualities. That is to say, by means of it, all of the higher excellent qualities are attained.

Therefore, it is an achiever by means of which we achieve. And then the fourth characteristic, is definite emergence. So we’re again, we’re trying to we have the thesis that the path of seeing, which is the exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness, is definite emergence. And here, there’s only presented the thesis. There is no proof.

It is said by means of the prior three thesis and proofs, one can come to one is able to understand the proof of why path true paths are a definite emergence. So there are so there are seven aspects to true paths in terms of the four characteristics. These four characteristics, the first is true paths are a path, which has a thesis and a proof. That true paths are a are knowledge, which has a thesis and a proof. True paths are achievers, which has a thesis in the proof, and true paths are a definite emergence, which has only a thesis — making seven.

So these are perhaps a little difficult to understand, but they’re they’re quite deep. So the the the thesis is you know, there’s a standard thesis where you plug in the different characteristics. And we’re saying that the the path of seeing, which is the exalted wisdom directly realizing emptiness is is knowledge. That’s a thesis. Because and then the proof is because it directly knows its object emptiness.

What we mean by knowledge here is that it knows. It directly knows emptiness or it directly realizes emptiness. It directly sees emptiness. And this is what we mean by knowledge. It has it it knows or sees or realizes emptiness.

So this subject is even difficult for the Geshes also to understand. There’s a lot of So the aspect with respect to the characteristic of strong production, it had three parts to it, which combined to make one aspect. And this was the fact that first, the strong production as the aspect that though our body is in fact impermanent, that is transitory, we conceive of it to be permanent. Misconception. That though our body isn’t pure, we conceive of it to be pure.

And that essentially the body is unclean, and since it’s established in dependence upon unclean causes and impures, that is to say the sperm and ovum, are essentially impure. And these, in turn, came about through previous sperm and ova. Those in turn came about through causes of another previous sperm and ova continually such that the causes are impure, and then the result is impure. But but we hold that the aggregates, particularly the body, as being pure. This conception of holding the body as being completely pure.

And the third is that we have, we conceive of the body as being the nature of happiness. That we think body is really wonderful and it has some kind of nature about it which is satisfactory and it can bring us happiness. But in fact that the body is dissatisfactory in its nature, it’s a it’s it does not have this quality or nature of being complete happiness. These are all mistaken awarenesses holding the body as being happiness, permanent, and pure. These concepts bring up or act as causes for pronounced suffering.

Therefore, they’re called strong producers. Because the because our body is produced under the influence of afflictive emotions and karma, that it has a nature of dissatisfaction. It cannot be in the nature of happiness.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top