1 h 42 min · 5,018 words · 1 March 1990
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This commentary on the Ornament for Clear Realization explains how the bodhisattva progresses toward Buddhahood through the four trainings, which work on the three exalted knowledges and their aspects. It covers how meditating on the subjective and objective aspects removes the afflictive and knowledge obstructions, and how serial, momentary and peak training build proficiency. Meditation on emptiness and impermanence is discussed as a means to this end.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1990-03-01
Duration: 1h 42m
UUID: 3acaa276-399c-46e8-a03b-869f497617e1
Words: 5,015
For my for my sake for myself and all other sentient beings, I must completely eliminate all faults and attain all excellent qualities. That is, I must attain Buddhahood. By the attainment of Buddhahood, I will be able to eliminate all the suffering and to establish all sentient beings and complete happiness. And therefore, in order to bring up this about, I’m going to train well my mind perfection of wisdom as set forth in the discourses of the Buddha. And we meditate for five minutes adjusting our motivation in accordance with that.
So the Ornament for Clear Realization sets forth the perfection of wisdom in terms of the eight categories and seventy topics. The main subjects which are covered in the ornament are the eight categories. And these were, as was explained previously, the three knowledges — the three exalted knowledges — the four trainings, and the resultant truth body. So the eight categories are the the foundation of the practice of the bodhisattva. The bodhisattva is seeking to achieve Buddhahood.
That’s his ultimate goal. Resultant truth body is synonymous with Buddhahood. The means which he uses, that is to say the methods for achieving his goal, resultant truth body are the four trainings. That is to say these are the meditations. The objects of these meditations, the objects of his training are the three exalted knowledges.
So by means of taking the three exalted knowledges as objects of the four trainings, he is able to achieve — or she is able to achieve — her ultimate goal, the resultant truth body, and therefore, these eight categories of the foundation of practice. So if we speak in general in terms of attainments within spiritual practice there, the we have a dread of suffering and and to relieve ourselves of that suffering, strive, we have those those goals which are temporal achievements and those which are ultimate achievements in this in this course of seeking to relieve the dread of suffering. So upon our death, we do not become non existent. There is a continuity of our existence which goes on to future life. And the possibilities are definite as to two.
We either take a higher rebirth or we take a lower rebirth. And, the lower rebirth are the bad migrations which entail a great deal of suffering. And it is to free ourselves from the dread of the possibility of the great sufferings of bad migrations in the future that we engage in skillful actions and abandon unskillful actions. And by this method, we are able to attain the highest status of either human or God. But additionally, having attained this excellent human life, we can practice the Dharma and we can practice it proficiently.
And therefore, this practice human life is extremely precious. By means of the practice of Dharma, we can not only having having achieved this temporal goal of the liberation from bad migration, but we can achieve definite goodness, which is constituted of liberation in general and ultimately omniscience. So, by this means, through the practice making use of our human life, we can abandon completely the suffering of cyclic existence and attain the bliss of liberation. But we can with this this precious human life that we now possess, possess, can not only achieve liberation from cyclic existence for ourselves alone but by eliminating all the faults within our continuum and developing all the excellent qualities we can achieve the ultimate goal of Buddhahood. So on the basis of this present human life, we can establish the goal of Buddhahood.
That is to say we can eliminate all faults and develop all the excellent qualities. When we the Buddhahood is constituted of the abandonment of all these faults and the culmination, the consummation of all excellent qualities. What do we, you know, what are the faults that we’re trying to abandon, that we’re trying to get rid of? They are the afflictive obstructions and the knowledge obstructions. By abandoning these, we attain Buddhahood.
So the the various faults within our continuum are the abandonments which hinder ultimate attainment of Buddhahood and these are to be destroyed. These are but what is what is the method for destroying these faults within our continuum? They are the four trainings. It is by means of meditating the four trainings that we abandon the the afflictive obstructions and the knowledge obstructions. Therefore, the method for the attainment of Buddhahood is the practice of the four trainings.
So the the four trainings are the methods for the attainment of Buddhahood. Now to exemplify, to illustrate, we’re going to, look at what is the shortest moment of activity, which constitutes an activity or action. And then we we say that one hour is made of made up of sixty minutes. It has this many parts. Well, if we take a the time of a finger snap, there are the smallest unit of activity is one sixty fourth of the finger snap.
One. There’s sixty four parts in the finger snap. One of those is the smallest unit of time of action. So it is it is this unit which is the smallest measure of time in terms of an action, an activity can take place. One sixty fifth, I think I said fourth.
It’s one sixty-fifth of a finger snap in time. A Buddha is able to understand all phenomena whatsoever in that amount of time. One sixty-fifth of a finger snap. Preliminary to being able to understand all phenomena in one sixty fifth of a finger snap in time, it is necessary to understand all phenomena in a longer length of time. If we can’t understand it in a longer all phenomena in a longer length of time, then there’s no way that we can understand it in the smallest unit of time action.
Therefore, we have to be able to understand all phenomena in a longer length of time and in an effortlessly and effortless manner with no difficulty. Preliminary to understanding all phenomena in the smallest unit of of of time act in which an activity can take place, it’s necessary that that we understand all phenomena in a longer time effortlessly and without difficulty. And the occasion when this occurs is during the the last of the four trainings, and we’re calling that momentary training. So if this is a longer unit of time in which an activity can is taking place, and that activity is the understanding of all phenomena. So it is at this momentary training, which is at the end of the continuum continuum being a sentient being that one is able to understand all phenomena.
But at this point of training, one can understand all phenomena in the in one sixty fifth of a of time unit. Only a Buddha can do that. So this in this unit of time, this training last one moment. The second moment, one attains Buddhahood and is able to understand all phenomena one sixty fifth of a finger snap of time. Previous to this, one wasn’t able to do to do that.
But this so this must be a preliminary to that. So we’re becoming more and more proficient as we approach Buddhahood, but there must be those practices which are preliminary to each of these stages. So at the at the stage of Buddhahood, we are able to understand all phenomena in the smallest unit of time action which is one sixty fifth of a finger snap. Preliminary to that, we must understand all phenomena within a length a longer length of time, one unit of time. This is the momentary training.
And this is done in an effortless manner in which we meditate upon all all phenomena. Preliminary Preliminary to that, again, we have to understand all of all of the aspects of the phenomena. And this is to say we we take in a serial manner all of the aspects of the three exalted knowledges. All we take in a serial manner, one at a time, all of the aspects of the three exalted knowledges. Without this practice, then there’s no way that we can understand all phenomena.
So this must be a preliminary to this to the momentary training, and this preliminary training is called the serial training. So at the point we in dependence upon the serial training, we take the hundred and seventy-three aspects of the three exalted knowers, and we gradually meditate upon them in a serial manner. In dependence upon serially taking these hundred and seventy-three aspects of the three exalted knowers, realizing them, then we attain the momentary training. So in dependence upon serial training, we attain momentary training. And as a preliminary to the attainment of serial training in which we are taking the hundred and seventy-three aspects in a gradual manner, meditating on them.
A hundred and seventy-three aspects of the three exalted knowers. We must attain the power of of of being able to meditate up upon these aspects. And this is the train this involves train this involves peak training. So what do we mean by gaining the power of the meditation? In the one one one develops a a union of calm abiding and special insight and taking as the as one when one is when having developed this this union of calm abiding and special insight using and taking as one’s object of meditation in the manner of taking let’s see.
Taking as the object of meditation the three exalted knowers in a manner of a union of calm abiding and special insight. This is to attain what is called the power of meditation on the aspects of the exalted knowers. So when we say what we mean by the power of having attained the power of the meditation on the exalted knowers, we mean having developed the union of special insight and calm abiding, which takes as its object to three exalted knowers. And this is attained at the peak train during peak training. So, what we mean by power, would be, remember I gave the illustration of somebody who’s who can type and they don’t have to look at the keys.
When someone doesn’t have to look at the keys then they gain power with respect to typing. Maybe power is not the best word, but I don’t know an alternative translation at the moment. Proficiency, maybe. So, you know previously to having gained proficiency in typing that is to say one does not have, one no longer has to look at the keyboard. One had to look at the keyboard and type very slowly each letter one at a time, but they’re customizing by familiarization one gains proficiency.
Meditation can be also the word, the same words, familiarization. So likewise in as a preliminary to the the development of the serial training, one may one must gain proficiency in the three exalted knowers, and this is done by means of the peak training. So this so this is the the manner of the in which the bodhisattva is training his or her mind. They gradually work through the four trainings, removing and abandoning the afflictive and the knowledge obstructions by means of the four trainings, and achieve the resultant truth body. By means of training well in these four trainings, the knowledge and afflictive obstructions are abandoned and one attains the resultant truth body, or Buddhahood.
Definition of peak training as was explained before, it’s very slightly different than what’s presented here. Just a few words absent. It’s a bodhisattva’s yoga which is conjoined with the wisdom. So for those who haven’t previously made notes of these definitions, it would be good for you to write these down because it would be it would help, it would aid in your understanding. Those who have notes of this, of course they don’t need to.
So, the definition of a complete training is: a bodhisattva’s yoga conjoined with wisdom that meditates on a compendium of the three knowers. So I think I said peak training. I should have said complete training. I think I’ve been understood.
The first of the four s four trainings is called complete training. Isn’t it? Okay. Yeah. That’s good.
The complete training — that’s a different translation for the same term. In Tibetan, there are three words, three syllables. The first stands for the aspects of the three exalted knowers. So we’re going to break down the etymology of this word.
The nam means the aspects of the three exalted knowers. Dzogpa means complete, all — that is to say, all of the realizations. Jorwa is variously translated; here, we’re translating it as training. It means to attain all of the excellent qualities.
So all the aspects of the three exalted knowers, all of them, all of the realizations, to attain these excellent qualities — translated as: complete training. That’s right. So this is complete training. Namdzogpa jorwa.
Yeah. So it’s complete training. Now that’s first one. Namdzogpa jorwa. It’s first training.
Complete training. Yeah. I’m right. Namdzogpa jorwa what? First training.
Complete training. So, again, the complete training. And then we’re looking at this definition, this etymology. Nam means aspect, literally means aspect, and it means the aspects of the three exalted knowledges. And there are one hundred and seventy three aspects to the three exalted knowledges. There are twenty seven aspects with respect to the base knower.
There are thirty six aspects with respect to the path knower. And there are one hundred and ten aspects with respect to the knower of all aspects. So we’re a total of one hundred and seventy three aspects. This is what we mean by aspect, or nam. Dzogpa means complete, all of these.
Not just one, not two, all one hundred and seventy-three. To know complete — and jorwa means to train and to have these qualities arise in one’s continuum — is what we mean by complete training in the aspects. So in this definition of complete training, it says a compendium a compendium of aspects, and this compendium is the the twenty seven aspects of the base knower, the thirty six aspects of the path knower, and a hundred ten aspects of the knower of all aspects. And they are lined up one by one in a compendium. So with respect to these these these three with respect to the aspects of the three exalted knowers, there are two types.
There is the subjective aspect and the objective aspect. The objective aspect is the object itself and the subjective aspect is the consciousness understanding those objects. So if we take an example where in the in terms of meditating on emptiness, the emptiness is the object. Wisdom which realizes that emptiness is the literally the object possessor or we say the subject. And in this case, we if we look at in terms of this definition that we were talking about, the emptiness is the objective aspect, and the wisdom is the subjective aspect.
So taking as an example the meditation on emptiness, the object is the is emptiness. The subject is the wisdom realizing the emptiness. We cannot meditate the object emptiness without meditating the wisdom realizing that emptiness. And likewise, we cannot meditate the wisdom realizing emptiness without meditating the object the object emptiness. We cannot meditate one without meditating the other.
We have to meditate both. Therefore, in in in in meditation, we must become familiar with both the objective aspect and the subjective aspect. So the the same would hold true for other objects of meditation and other types of consciousnesses such as meditation on impermanence. The object of of the meditation on impermanence is is impermanence, and the consciousness realizing it is the subject. And in order to come to an understanding of emptiness, we must familiarize ourselves both.
By meditation, I use the word familiarization. Familiarize ourselves both with the subject of aspect and the object of aspect. So when we meditate on emptiness, we have to eliminate faults from our mind. What is this fault? It is the distorting awareness with respect to emptiness.
Without eliminating this distorted awareness with respect to emptiness, there’s no way that we can gain the realization of emptiness. And the same would hold true with respect to gaining understanding of impermanence. We would have to we would have to eliminate the distorted awareness with respect to impermanence in order to before we can regain the realization of impermanence. So with respect to the ultimate attainment of Buddhahood, it is necessary to progressively eliminate the distorting conscious distorted distorted awarenesses with respect to reality in order to in proportion to gaining a correct realization with respect to reality or the mode of abidance of all things. So by means of the four trainings, we we eliminate the distort distorted awarenesses with respect to the aspects of the three exalted knowers.
These distorted awarenesses with respect to the aspects of the three exalted knowers are the afflictive obstructions. The afflictive obstructions. They are obstructions to liberation. So if we take an easy example of the flower, in order to develop the awareness which realizes that this is a flower, we must eliminate the concept that is distorted conception which holds that it is not a flower. We must eliminate in order to gain the the understanding the the awareness which understands that it is it is a flower.
We have to eliminate the distorted conception which holds that it is not a flower. So likewise, in the attainment of Buddha Buddhahood, we must we must gain a valid cognition of all phenomena as a means to that end. In order to gain that, we must overcome all of the distorted awarenesses with respect to all phenomena. All these all of these various distorted awarenesses which exist within our mind since they have they been continually present within our mind, not only do they exist, but they leave a latency, a predisposition in our mind. It is these latencies which are the knowledge obstructions or obstructions to omniscience.
So first, we have to, in order to develop the, the the undistorted awarenesses of all phenomena, we must eliminate the various distorted awarenesses of all phenomena. At in the course of this, as the as the power of our meditation increases, we will be able to eliminate from the very roots even the latencies of not only not only distorted conceptions by themselves, but the latencies of these distorted awarenesses. In this way, by doing this, we achieve Buddhahood, which is the elimination of all faults and the the arising of all excellent qualities. So, which I was using analogy to comparing our mind, our mind consciousness to a field. And, you know, as as would happen, for example, in Tibet, sometimes a family, there would be a quarrels within a family.
And though previously they had cultivated their fields well, it was plowed, smooth and it produced a good crop. But due to the breakup of families, various discords that might happen in a family that the, that the field would be left uncultivated. And due to this, they would they would the the field would slowly degenerate due to erosion, to weeds growing up. Rocks would fall down from the mountain in the field, and the field the field would become, very rough, very, unusable in a matter of time. Likewise, our mind, due to our inability to having not practiced previously, we have all of these latencies within our mind which the latencies of various afflictive emotions such as attachment, anger, confusion.
And these are like making our our the field of our mind unusable. So just as in the case of this this poor field, due to our not a our let me say poor. Due to our not being able to have have practiced the Dharma previously, the field of our mind is overrun with various afflictive emotions and this all these various distorted conceptions. So just as in the case of this field wishing to grow a crop, it’s necessary to begin to cultivate the field to remove the various stones and weeds to plow the land to furnish fertilizer, water, etcetera and then we can grow a good crop. And with respect to our mind, our mind having been overgrown with the emotions and distorted awarenesses, we have to remove them.
Removing these weeds of the various afflictive minds and distorted awarenesses, we make use of the plow of the four trainings, meditating on emptiness, impermanence, etcetera. In this way, purifying our mind, clearing our field, and growing all the crop of all of the excellent qualities. So the method for eliminating the distorted awarenesses is just as the bodhisattva in his trainings, making use of the four trainings which have the ability to uproot, to eliminate from their very roots, the very, all of the various distorted conceptions, the afflictive emotions, and to, to grow the complete excellent qualities. So this is extreme. So this is extremely rough explanation on why the the Bodhisattva engages in the four trainings.
Essentially, meditating the four trainings in order to eliminate the afflictive obstructions and the knowledge obstructions and to and ultimately to achieve the resultant truth body. Previously, we had explained the various definitions, divisions, and boundaries of the four trainings. So we’ll stop the discussion of the four trainings there. And if you have some questions, we’ll spend some time on this. It’s very rare that analogy is is applicable to all the the elements under discussion.
This this typing analogy was just applicable to the first two trainings. Here here we’re in a it’s like learning each key in in the terms of the complete training and complete aspects, complete training and the aspects, learning each key. This would be the twenty-seven aspects of the knower of bases, the thirty-six aspects of the knower of paths, the one hundred and ten aspects of the knower of all aspects. One would be learning each of these keys one by one. Then one could engage them all at once.
But then having learned each one individually, then one would engage them all at once and that would be the peak training. But it doesn’t applying this analogy all the way up to all four trainings. So we were discussing the relationship between the pre-peak training and what do we call it? Serial training. Serial training and peak training.
In order to understand all phenomena in this unit of a finger snap of time, we have to train serially in each in all of the aspects. And in order to gain the power to be able to do that, we engage in the first two. The first two trainings give us the proficiency proficiency in order to to meditate serially, in order to by means of which we are able to understand all phenomena of fingers, not over the second. So the first two the first two trainings are to gain proficiency or the power we said. And then they all are meditating on the on all one hundred seventy three aspects.
The first two are in order to gain proficiency. By the term by the term peak, we means we brought the the proficiency to its peak. And now we’re going to — we’re first able to meditate serially on the compendium of all of the hundred and seventy-three aspects in order to do it in one — mind snap. Finger snap.
Wondering that serial. So that the the at the serial training, it’s it’s it’s they are done in a gradual manner, one by one, and that’s in order to be able to do it altogether at the momentary training where they are all taken at once. So these one hundred and seventy three aspects act as antidotes to the various obstructions. They are just as in, you know, they don’t have, each one doesn’t have a particular, isn’t a particular antidote for a particular obstruction, but just in general, for example, the wisdom understanding the impermanence of the aggregates would act as an antidote to the conception which holds the aggregates as permanent. The wisdom understanding the non true existence of the aggregates would act as an antidote to the conception which holds the aggregates as being truly existent.
So the meditating, the meditation on the complete training in aspects, would lessen the power of the afflictions — such as, as the wisdom understanding impermanence increases, then the conception of permanence would decrease proportionately. So there’s a weakening of the afflictions. So this decreasing of the power would go right through the four trainings. As your wisdom of understanding emptiness increased, then your conception of true existence would be decreasing. So the the way in which the antidotes and the the abandonments work is likened to the increasing of a fire.
As the fire increases the coldness decreases proportionally so as the antidote increases the abandonment decreases. Yeah. So does meditation on emptiness — does meditation on impermanence help one understand emptiness? Yeah. And when you meditate on impermanence, you find you become aware that your mind isn’t very clear and you become discouraged.
You become depressed. Okay. And then come and get — [unclear]. So So the meditation on impermanence is a method to be made use of in in approaching the meditation on emptiness. By meditating on impermanence, coming to an understanding of impermanence, we develop a great deal of positive potential and and we develop a wisdom which understands that that emptiness.
And by means of that, this this aids in developing the wisdom which understands emptiness. As far as becoming depressed or realizing the the the unclear of your mind, we simply don’t have much experience at meditation at present. Our minds aren’t very clear because as we spoke previously all the various distorted awarenesses within our mind. That these distortions act as obstructions and that by meditating it’s definite that we can we will improve, our meditation will improve, our ability will become the power of our mind will become greater and greater. It’s just as in the case of if we had just starting a small fire in a forest.
At first it’s very small and it just burns a little twig and then it spreads to a larger bush perhaps and then it spreads to a tree and then a bigger tree and soon the whole forest is ablaze. And likewise in our case we just our our present ability is like this little, it’s the beginning of a little flame. But we will by getting rid of the various faults within our mind, all the various distortions that it will increase, our ability will increase, Our mind will become clear and be able to rid ourselves of all of these distortions and obstructions. So when we meditate and we see that our mind is unclear, we should ask, you know, why isn’t it? And we should understand that we have understand that we have all these various negativities within our mind, various obstructions and we think, well, what can I do about these negativities and obstruction?
And we should make use of methods such as recitation of the hundred-syllable mantra of Vajrasattva, the confession sūtra of the thirty-five Buddhas, these various methods whereby to remove these negativities and obstructions from our mind, confessing, acknowledging our mistakes, and making requests to Mañjuśrī. And it’s definite that our mind, using these methods, will become clearer and clearer. And then there’s no reason why it can’t. You know, I I can become a Buddha. That the Buddha was just like myself with an unclear mind and various faults.
And just like him, there’s no reason why I can’t develop myself and and clarify my own mind just like him. And that we can improve day by day. And this way, we should, try to generate enthusiasm. You have to have courage. So both the awareness of emptiness and the awareness of the mind which meditates on emptiness are familiarized.
There takes place a simultaneous familiarity. The word meditation can be translated as familiarity, customizing. So when we meditate on emptiness, without of course the object emptiness, there’s nothing to meditate on. There’s no object. There’s nothing there’s no meditation.
But also, we have we’re thinking in our mind, well, what is this emptiness? Is this object emptiness? It lacks true existence. What does it mean to lack true existence? Therefore, there’s an awareness which is reflecting upon the meaning of emptiness.
And we accustom ourselves to to that mind. We familiarize ourselves to that mind. So in the meditation on emptiness, there is both this accustoming process of the to the awareness which which is reflecting upon emptiness and the object emptiness itself. That’s was the subjective aspect and object of aspect. So it’s not similar with respect to meditating on compassion because we’re not trying to meditate on an object out there, compassion.
We are trying to, the mind itself arises in the nature of compassion. When the mind when the carrying state arises in the mind, this is the meditation on compassion. But on the other hand, when you meditate on deity, there would be it’s probably the these these two aspects are present. The deity is this objective aspect and the mind which realizes the deity is the subjective aspect. So this is the body which arises in the form of a deity, not the mind.
And it’s in our present state we aren’t actually able to have the body arise in the form of a deity, but to be in our mind’s eye, from the point, from our mind’s eye, we imagine that our our body has arisen in the form of a deity. And that form which we imagine has arisen in is the object of aspect and that which is aware of that aspect is the subject of aspect.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.