Ornament – 13 O 1990 05 24

1 h 37 min · 4,653 words · 24 May 1990

Ornament (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament - 13 O 1990 05 24
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues a teaching on the thirty-six aspects of the exalted knower of paths, covering the aspects of the four noble truths, including the sixteen types of emptiness for true cessation. The teacher explains each emptiness through its basis, using honey in containers as an analogy, and ends by describing how realising emptiness ends rebirth in cyclic existence.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1990-05-24

Duration: 1h 38m

UUID: a9ce6104-6879-4e8e-804f-2cb9f24bf618

Words: 4,649

So mindful of all of sentient beings equal to space and not allowing ourselves to forget them. And mindful of the fact that all of these sentient beings have been our mothers and remembering the great kindness that our mothers have shown us in this life and extending it to all sentient beings in previous lives. And now though they wish happiness, they do not know the ways to or that it that is the causes to bring about happiness. And though they wish to bring about the end of their suffering, they are continually afflicted by suffering. And we, on our side, have attained this a human life.

And we have met with the teachings of Buddha that we are able to practice the Dharma and that we are coming to understand the the way in which to bring ourselves happiness and to abandon abandon suffering. So, at this extremely wonderful conjunction that we have to seek to return the great benefit that our mothers have shown us and that to begin to enact the various deeds to benefit them. If we simply seek to bring them food, clothing, etcetera, this we can’t even do this to bring them temporal happiness. So, we must look at the situation from a deeper point of view and seek to bring about the ultimate welfare of sentient beings. That is by we can do that by eliminating our various faults and bringing to consummation all our various qualities and that is that is attained at the with the attainment of Buddhahood.

By attaining Buddhahood that we can bring complete happiness to others and eliminate all of their problems. And now, practicing the Dharma of the great vehicle, which is the method to, by which we can achieve Buddhahood. And if I train my mind well, and I achieve this this great end, then I will be empowered to be able to establish all sentient beings in happiness and to eliminate all of their suffering. And therefore, I am going to listen to this present teaching as a means to practice and to achieve this end and cultivating this kind hearted attitude of the awakening heart for the next five minutes in meditation. So we’re discussing the thirty six aspects of the exalted knower of paths and beginning with the which is taught in terms of the four noble truths.

And firstly, the Noble Truths of Truth Sources, which in these has eight aspects which are taught in terms of abandonments and antidotes. The characteristics of truth sources. The first characteristic — origin — has three aspects. The second characteristic — cause — has three aspects. The third characteristic — condition — has one aspect and strong production has one aspect made total of eight aspects.

And these are the abandonments and the antidotes which actually abandon these are the actual exalted knower. Then with the Noble Truth of Paths, this is taught in terms of this is the seven aspects of the path, in which there are four characteristics of true paths. The first, these are taught in terms of the thesis and proof. And first of these four is path, and this is taught from the term point of view of this of the two, thesis and proof. Then knowledge, thesis and proof.

Achievement, thesis and proof. And the fourth characteristic, definite emergence, which is taught only from the point of view of thesis — making seven aspects in total. So, true sources has eight aspects. Two paths, seven making total of fifteen that we’ve completed so far. And then the the within the first noble truth, cause of suffering, the noble truth of suffering has five aspects and these are presented from the point of view of the nature of self and general self and general.

So beginning with the contaminated aggregates as a true suffering. That is the aggregates of an ordinary sentient being. The aggregates of forms, feelings, perceptions, thought constructions, and consciousnesses. And as it says in the Heart of Wisdom Sūtra, the We should we should recognize that the the the heart of wisdom sūtra, it mentions the that the five aggregates are empty in there by their nature. And therefore, it is necessary that we are able to recognize what are the five aggregates.

And the true sufferings are presented from the point of view of five characteristics. Previously, they were mentioned in terms of four. But here, previous four, that is, in terms of the characteristic of impermanence, suffering, emptiness, selflessness, but additionally, the fifth characteristic of without nature. These are to be based upon we take as our basis upon which we of illustration is the aggregates. The aggregates are the basis for illustrating these five characteristics.

So the five aggregates are appropriated under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions and therefore they are termed true sufferings. And the first characteristics of true sufferings is impermanence. And this is illustrated on the basis of the appropriate aggregates that our appropriate aggregates have a cause and that is the karma and afflictive emotions due to which we are forced to take birth. Upon taking birth, it’s necessary that there follow disintegration. If there is no birth, then there is no disintegration, or that is to say death.

Just in the case of a flower, once a flower begins to grow, it must eventually die. It is impermanent. If there were, the seed were burnt such that it never germinated, then it would never die. The cause for taking rebirth, that is taking the appropriated aggregates, is by its very nature impermanent. That the cause is itself momentary, that it arises and disintegrates.

And therefore, anything which arises out of this cause that due to the influence of that cause, in itself is momentary, influence that arising and disintegrating likewise. The exalted knower within the continuum of a bodhisattva superior which directly realizes the impermanence of the appropriated aggregates is the first aspect in terms of true sufferings of the exalted knower of paths. So the exalted knower within the continuum of a bodhisattva superior which directly realizes the impermanence of the appropriate aggregates is the first of these five aspects of the exalted knower of paths in terms of true sufferings. And the second characteristic is the characteristic of suffering and again this is applied to the appropriate aggregates, that the appropriate aggregates have the characteristics of suffering. And why is that?

Because they are appropriated under the power of karma and afflictive emotions. And addition that appropriate aggregates, such types of appropriate aggregates are the abandonments of the superiors. They having realized that they are by their very nature defective and therefore are to be abandoned since they are in the nature of suffering. So the exalted knower within the continuum of a bodhisattva superior which realizes the suffering nature of the appropriate aggregates is the second aspect. So the the third characteristic is empty.

Emptiness. And This refers to the that the I, the self, the person, which is which exists in dependence upon the contaminated aggregates is empty of is empty since it is there is no difference with respect to entity. In the case of the of the non-Buddhist assertions, it is that the I, the self, and the aggregates are a different entity. They are they are of other entities, different entities. But here the assertion is that the I and aggregates are the same entity.

That there is no difference in entity and this no difference of entity is referred to as the emptiness. The non difference of entity between the I and the aggregates. The I that goes, that eats, that does all these things and the aggregates, the non existence of a difference entity is the emptiness. The third, so the exalted knower in the continuum of a bodhisattva superior which realizes the non-existence of difference of entity between the I and the appropriate aggregates is the characteristic of emptiness. And the fourth characteristic is selfless.

This is being presented from the point of view of the autonomy middle way school and not the Consequentialist Middle Way school. Therefore, hereby we’re talking about the selflessness of persons and this is the understanding that the appropriated aggregates are empty of being a self sufficient, substantially existent self. That the appropriate aggregates are empty of being a self sufficient, substantially existent self. The exalted knower within the continuum of a bodhisattva which directly realizes the emptiness of the appropriate aggregates of being a self-sufficient, substantially existent self is the fourth aspect.

So the fifth characteristic I think maybe a good translation without self nature. I think I said without nature. I think without self nature. This refers to the lack of true existence of the first four characteristics: impermanence, suffering, emptiness, and selflessness. That they lack true existence.

Therefore the exalted knower within the continuum of a bodhisattva Superior which realizes that these first four characteristics do not truly exist or lack true existence is the fifth aspect. As was mentioned that these five are explained in terms of self and general. The first four were explained in terms of the aggregates in terms of oneself. The fifth characteristic is the fact that these first four are without self nature and this is in terms of it being that they are generally without true existence. They are applied in general to all four of the first four characteristics.

So these five characteristics are each applied to the appropriate aggregates as far as being impermanent, suffering, empty, selfless and then in general lacking true existence. It is from the point of view of the object. Then that which the bodhisattva superior, that is to say that we’re talking about an exalted knower of paths and this only exists in the continuum of a bodhisattva Superior, that exalted wisdom within the continuum of a bodhisattva superior which realizes these five is the five aspects of the exalted knower of paths. So we’ve explained three noble truths. Here the resultant noble truth of suffering has five aspects, making so far a total of twenty-two aspects.

You took. You took. We covered twenty, didn’t we? I understood. Now we’re going to to the resultant noble truth of true cessation.

And this will have sixteen aspects. We’re going to share out sixteen aspects among the four characteristics of true cessation. These four characteristics of true cessation are cessation, pacification, auspiciousness, and definite emergence. So the the perfection of wisdom sutras set out various divisions of emptiness. There’s a division into twenty, into sixteen, and into four.

These sixteen aspects shared out through the four characteristics are explained in terms of the benefit, in a manner of that which is beneficial, in terms of these sixteen divisions of emptiness. You understand well?

Good. The first three of the sixteen types of emptiness apply to the first characteristic of cessation. Three emptinesses apply to cessation. These three these three emptinesses are emptiness of the inner, emptiness of the external, and emptiness of both internal and external. Internal, external, and both internal and external.

In in general, we can say that there are in fact no actual divisions of emptiness, that that this lack of true existence is simply a non affirming negation which has no no divisions whatsoever. But but we can use the due to the difference in the basis of the emptiness. There are many types of phenomena which act as the basis of emptiness. Using these differences in types of basis of emptiness, emptiness, we can apply the name of different types of emptinesses. We can use these different nomenclatures, the different names to emptiness in terms of the different types of phenomena which serve as their basis.

So using analogy to come to an understanding that that though there are no differences with respect to the emptiness itself due to its basis that we can we can can designate different names to types of emptinesses in the same way that, honey, by its very nature, is sweet. And though it is non non differentiated with respect to its sweetness. But if we take that honey and we put it in three different types of containers, we put it into a, say, earth container, a golden container, and a silver container. Then we can say, this is the honey in an earthen container.

This is the honey of a golden container. This is the honey of silver container. So the honeys are exactly alike even though they are in different containers. We can we can distinguish between those three types of honeys. So in fact, they’re all the same nature.

So applying this to these first three types of emptiness that we’ve listed so far, there was the internal, external, and and both internal, external. The first internal, what what we mean by internal refers to the five sense faculties. Eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, sense faculties. These are said to be internal phenomena. And the emptiness in terms of those internal phenomena are what we mean by internal emptiness.

So the the emptiness of the eye faculty, etcetera, eye faculty, etcetera, is the emptiness of internal. The reason that we term this as internal is that it it has a a connection with the aggregate of feelings. If we were to poke a needle into the eye, we would experience something very painful. We have a very painful feeling. Likewise, if we were to put some kind of soft soothing lotion, then we would experience a pleasant feeling.

It is due to this that the phenomena of the faculties are in connection with, are connected with the feeling aggregate and causes either pleasure or pain that we say is an internal phenomena. So then the these nose. Nose. They didn’t they didn’t get on me. Oh.

She did. Yes. So the second classification was external, and this refers to the objects of these various faculties, these sense faculties. For example, the object of the eye sense faculty is forms, colors such as white, red, etcetera. The object of the, ear sense faculty is sound.

Nose is, odors. Tongue is flavors, and body is, objects of touch. And these are all termed external phenomena, and therefore the emptiness of them is emptiness of the external. The reason they are termed external is because they have no connection with the consciousness or that is more specifically the the feeling aggregate. If we stick a pin in external objects, if we heat them up or freeze them, we get we gain no particular pleasure or painful feelings from that.

When we when we talk about the eye sense faculty, what what do you think that refers to? What is it? So what do we mean by the eye sense faculty? It is a clear subtle a clear matter and it may be referring to the cornea. I’m not sure.

Anyway, it’s not this white part of it’s not the fleshy part of the eye. It’s not the that is to say, it’s not the white of the eye nor is it the iris of the eye or the pupil of the but it’s a remember, was saying it’s a clear subtle matter which is in the center of the eye. Maybe the cornea. I’m not sure. But that’s it’s that’s what we mean by the eye sense faculty, not the eyeball.

Yes. And then the third type of emptiness is, you know, the actual eye sense faculty is that which does the seeing. It is extremely clear matter, but it’s it has a it is has a housing or a room, it’s like in a room. There’s a place where it resides and this is the actual white eyeball, the eyeball and the iris and this is what, and this is, this is what is being, this is both external, this is both what is called an external and internal phenomena. This is the eyeball.

And the emptiness of that is the emptiness of both. So the eyeball that which supports the eye sense faculty is both internal. It’s considered it’s called an internal and external phenomena and therefore the its emptiness is the emptiness of both. So the reason it’s called external and internal is that the the eyes the eye organ. The reason that the eye organ is referred to as both external and internal is it is internal because if one were to stick a needle in the eye, the way you would have a very painful feeling would arise.

Therefore, it’s connected up with consciousness and that’s the determining factor whether it’s to be called internal. But it’s also said to be external just in the same way that that the person is said to reside in the room. The room is external to the person. Likewise, the the eye organ is the residence of the eye sense faculty. It is external to the eye sense faculty, and therefore, is also said to be external.

And therefore, it’s both internal and external. So we said that there are four characteristics to true cessation: cessation, pacification, auspiciousness, and definite emergence. And these were in terms of these sixteen types of emptinesses. And the first of these cessation has three internal, external, and both. And the exalted knower in the continuum of a bodhisattva superior which directly realizes these three emptinesses — the first three — are the three aspects of the exalted knower of paths.

And there there are there are eight emptinesses with respect to pacification. So, again, to emphasize, there’s no difference. There’s no division with respect to emptiness itself. It is undifferentiated. But we’re talking about from the point point of view of the object, the property possessor or the basis of the emptiness.

So the the first of these eight or the or the fourth in these sixteen is is the emptiness of the ultimate or ultimate. And this emptiness itself is empty. So the emptiness of the emptiness is what is being referred to as emptiness of the ultimate. The the next, in terms of the sixteen fifth, is the emptiness of the great. And this refers to the environment, that the environment is very vast.

And the emptiness of that is referred to as the emptiness of the great. So I made a mistake with respect to the first of these of these eight, the eight emptinesses of pacification. It wasn’t I said the emptiness of the ultimate. That it’s emptiness of emptiness. Emptiness of emptiness is the is the first one.

And the second one is the emptiness of the great, which refers to the emptiness of the environment. And the third one is the emptiness of the ultimate. Emptiness of the ultimate. And this refers to the emptiness of true paths. That the true paths are are pure.

And this and this emptiness of which is this purity is referred to as emptiness of the ultimate. So the ultimate refers to true paths are the ultimate, and their emptiness is the emptiness of the ultimate. Sir. Never. No, sir.

The The trickery. So then the fourth of these eight is the emptiness of of of the conditioned. Emptiness of the conditioned. And by conditioned, it means that which arises. That which is produced in dependence upon causes and conditions is is the conditioned.

Then then the next emptiness is emptiness of the unconditioned. That which is not produced from causes that which is does not arise dependent upon causes and condition. The emptiness of the unconditioned. The sixth of these eight is the emptiness of the superimposed. And this would refer to by superimposition, it means when to assert that which is nonexistent as being existent.

To impose, for example, we assert that that which is not existent as being truly existent. This is a superimposition. The the emptiness of superimposition. Then the the opposite of that is the emptiness of deprecation or deprecation to assert that which exists as nonexistent. For example, to assert the nonexistence of the law of cause and effect, the emptiness of deprecation.

So that’s one — the emptiness of superimposition and deprecation. Taken as one. Yeah. So the actual term term that we should be using here for this emptiness is the emptiness of permanence and annihilation.

The emptiness of permanence and annihilation. So the permanence represents the superimposition and an annihilation represents deprecation. Then the the seventh is the emptiness of beginning and end. Emptiness of beginning and end. And here by by beginning, we’re referring to the the that one cannot identify a beginning to cyclic existence or one cannot identify a beginning to the contaminated appropriate aggregates.

When when when when when were they first established? There there was never a first time that they were that they we can point to when they began. Therefore, this is what it refers to by “beginning” — that there is no beginning to cyclic existence. So this term should be “beginningless and endless.”

Beginningless and endless. And what we mean by endless is that we can we can identify no time when cyclic existence will finish, when there will be an end to cyclic existence. So what we mean here is the emptiness of cyclic existence. The emptiness of beginningless and the emptiness of endless means the emptiness of cyclic existence. And then the eighth is the is the emptiness of non abandonment.

Refers to the, that, that the generations of the various realizations that we are to generate the various realizations of the path, paths and grounds, that these are to be cultivated and are not abandonments. They are they are not they are not abandonments. They are non abandonments. And the emptiness of these being abandonments is what is being referred to as the emptiness of non-abandonment. So these are the eight emptinesses in terms of the characteristic of pacification, and the exalted wisdom within the continuum of a bodhisattva superior directly realizing these eight are the eight aspects of the exalted knower of paths.

Conditioned, emptiness of conditioned, and the emptiness of the not conditioned. The the next characteristic auspiciousness has has applied toward one type of emptiness. And this is the emptiness of nature. The emptiness of nature. And this means that all phenomena are free of having a nature of true existence.

All phenomena are free of having a nature of true existence. And this is the meaning of emptiness of nature, a nature of true existence. So rather than saying all phenomena, we’ll say the the combination. So rather than saying all phenomena, we specified it. The combination of both unconditioned and conditioned phenomena are without the nature of true existence.

Conditioned and unconditioned phenomena together. So the exalted wisdom within the continuum of a bodhisattva superior directly realizing that the conditioned and non-conditioned lack a nature of true existence — this is the emptiness of nature. The the fourth characteristic of definite emergence has the has applied to it four types of emptiness. Mhmm. And the first of these is the emptiness of all phenomena.

The second is self nature, emptiness of self nature. The third is the non non the non observable. The fourth is nonfunctional. So we’ve we’ve listed sixteen types of emptiness with respect to these four four characteristics of true cessation. The first was cessation had three characteristics, pacification at eight, auspiciousness had one, and definite emergence had four.

The exalted wisdom within the continuum of a bodhisattva superior directly realizing these sixteen emptinesses is the sixteen aspects of the exalted knower of paths in terms of true cessation. So we’ve completed the thirty-six aspects of the knower of paths. Are you tired? So we’ve completed the twenty-seven aspects of the knower of basis, thirty-six aspects of the knower of paths, and next time we’ll begin the one hundred and ten aspects of the exalted knower of all aspects.

So there are a total of one hundred and seventy-three aspects to the three exalted knowers. So I think the following aspects — in terms of the exalted knower of all aspects — will be more readily understood, and perhaps we can get into the view. So we’ll stop there for today, but if you have some questions. Yes. So it wasn’t called that.

It wasn’t its proper name. It was that was a meaning. So in general In general, we in general, there is an end to cyclic existence, but we cannot cannot point to a time and say this is when it’s going to end and this is what is being referred to here that are that that because we cannot point and say this is when cyclic is going to finish and we say that there is no end. That is, our cyclic existence is endless. But in general, there is an end to cyclic existence.

It’s just that we can’t point to the times and this is where it’s going to end. In the same way that we cannot say when our individual cycle is is going to come to an end. It’s definite that our individual cycle is going to come to an end, but we can’t it would be extremely difficult to say exactly when. Just in the same way, From the point of view, if we have a seed, that if we plant that seed in fertile earth and add water, etcetera, it’s going to grow. But if we were to take that seed and scorch it, then nothing would grow out of that seed.

It would have lost its potency. Likewise, when when we directly realize emptiness, then we will no longer give growth to cyclic existence. But cyclic existence would, at that time, come to an end upon the direct realization of emptiness. But we don’t know. We cannot say when we’re going to directly realize emptiness, and therefore, we can’t say when cyclic existence is going to come to an end for us.

But when we do directly realize an emptiness, it will come to an end for us. When when are you going to directly realize emptiness? So, you know, be more specific about coming to a direct realization emptiness and that our our cyclic existence comes to an end, in which I quoted a a verse in which it says that though simply directly realizing emptiness, by that we cease creating new karma which would force us to take rebirth and cyclic existence, but we still have the old karma, the previously karma created, and therefore, though we have directly realized emptiness, we still are forced to take rebirth in cyclic existence due to the power of previously created karma. But but by proceeding onward, says that within three lives, having directly realized emptiness, we will be able to eliminate all of the karma which forces us to take rebirth and cyclic existence. This is what is meant by, the verse goes on to say, like the the the scorching of a seed such that there’s no potency, nothing can ever grow again from that seed.

Likewise, within though having realized emptiness, we will eventually eliminate all of the karma which forces us to take rebirth and then we are free of cyclic existence altogether. So once once we when we achieve when we have a direct realization of emptiness, we become a superior. And our realization of emptiness will never will never degenerate. It’s never lost. There are some individuals who, upon having directly realized emptiness, will almost immediately be liberated.

Others, depending upon the level of their, their intelligence will require a a second or third rebirth in order to be liberated, and those of the lowest intelligence will require seven more rebirths. But the the actual realization never degenerates.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top