1 h 27 min · 3,320 words · 27 May 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores why understanding the distinction between mind and matter is foundational to Buddhist practice. In this 87-minute teaching, he begins with the purpose of studying Lorig (Buddhist philosophy of mind): distinguishing persons from consciousness and learning to identify afflictions without conflating them with the self. He then traces how karma and afflictions generate suffering in the world, using contemporary examples like international conflicts to show that non-virtue produces suffering and virtue produces happiness—not merely in future lives but visibly in this life. He explains that love, compassion, and contentment, grounded in the mind rather than the body, naturally lead to happiness when extended to all beings. The bulk of the session covers the technical structure of mind: the relationship between main minds and the 51 mental factors, with an extended example of breakfast-making to illustrate the five omnipresent factors (sensation, discrimination, intention, mental application, contact) and five determining factors (aspiration, belief, memory, concentration, wisdom). The teaching concludes with extended Q&A on mental factors, the role of intention in a non-autonomous person, formless-realm beings, and doubt as a mental factor. Best suited to practitioners already studying Lorig or the intermediate path.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-05-27 – KR.mp3
UUID: edf0018e-2a25-42d5-bd5e-74defc306253
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Nature of Mind
Date: 2014-05-27
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,316
As usual, we will generate the motivation to listen to these teachings. The purpose or the intent of Lorig, awareness and knowledge,, is first to be able to differentiate between persons, consciousness and matter. And then, within the various states of consciousness, specifically the afflictions, such as desire and hatred, to be able to identify them, and to be able to ascertain that the person is not of the nature of the afflictions. Without the study of Lorig, it would be very easy for us to assume that the person is of the nature of anger, or the nature of desire in The basis of imputation of the person is constituted of form and of consciousness. Then in the case of our bodies, which are one of the two bases of imputations, our bodies can be traced back to their origin as the egg which arises from the union of the spermatozoa of our father and mother, and then further back through the generations.
Mind, on the other hand, is none other than consciousness, and it is not inappropriate to see our bodies as the slaves or the servants of our consciousness, life after life after life. If one is unable to differentiate between matter and consciousness and between a person and consciousness, then it is impossible to see how one could encourage someone to meditate on forbearance or patience when they are afflicted with anger. Since if that person was one with their body, they would be one with anger, and at this point it would be impossible to separate them from the anger within them, therefore it would be impossible to apply patience, which is the counter to anger meaningfully. There is a quote in Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra, to the effect that the mind is ultimately produced from that the world is ultimately produced from the mind, and likewise are the sentient beings within it. There is also a quote in Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakośa of Vasubandhu which says, the world arises from karma.
There are numerous such quotes. Let us set aside the Buddhist teachings on Karma and causality, which teach that sin accrued in previous lives leads to unhappiness in this life, and virtue accrued in previous lives leads to happiness in this life. If we set them aside, even in this very life, we can see that this can hold true. As Ārya Nāgārjuna says in his Ratnāvali, his Rosary Garland, from non virtue arises all suffering and eventually the lower rebirths, whereas from virtue arises all happiness, and eventually the higher rebirths. If you focus on the first verse of this stanza, from non virtue arises suffering, we can see even in this world of ours that this does hold true.
For instance, if we analyze the source of border conflicts between nations, we can see that their ultimate cause can be found in something like this. If we take for instance, disharmony and eventually conflict between states, We can see that this conflict leads to a great loss of life, in other words, to suffering. Now, this suffering of war, what are its causes? Its causes are initially anger, hatred, enmity, envy, competitiveness between the nations, in other words, the afflictions. It is clear that this ties in with Vasubandhu’s verse, from karma arise variety of the worlds.
Then we can clearly see that these sufferings arise from afflictions such as anger, competitiveness, envy, spite, and so forth. These are none other than non virtuous states of mind. In other words, mental factors from within the subdivision into main minds and mental factors. And in the second part of Nāgārjuna’s stanza of the Ratnāvali, in which it is said, and from virtue happiness, and happiness in all future lives, we can clearly see that in this very life, virtue does eventually give rise to happiness. This is something which can be seen.
If it is indeed the case that in this life, happiness and ease arise from virtue, it is up to us to identify what virtue is. Does virtue not exist? What is virtue? Can you give an example? Yeah.
Yes. Indeed. Yes. Indeed. Nonviolence would be an example of a virtue, but it is really a virtue when one starts thinking of future lives.
It is a little bit difficult to see whether non violence necessarily leads to happiness in this life or not. It is, after all, the counter to anger and to violence. But an example which exists in all our minds is love and empathy, which are virtues. Since the context of our discussion at present is this life, we have set aside future lives, and I have tried to show that non virtue leads to unhappiness in this very life, and I would like to show that virtue leads to happiness in this very life as well. Therefore, I would like to give an example of that.
Think about it. What? What is it? To understand? Definitely contentment, but in the case of love and empathy, these are present naturally within our mental continuum.
And we can see for ourselves in this very life, just setting aside all talks of future lives, in this very life, if we wish to be the recipient of love and affection from others, which is a major cause for our happiness, we must extend love and affection to them. If we extend love and affection to them, love and affection will come back our way. Then, since we are convinced that all our problems in this life come from others without exception, it is clear that if we are able to extend the love and affection which we have for our friends and relatives at present to all living beings, then we could never be on the receiving end of, any difficulties from their side. Then such love and affection, that is true virtue. Whether the love and affection within our mind at present is true virtue or not is another question.
And then definitely contentment is also a virtue which leads to happiness within this very life. So if one is absolutely convinced that contentment, love, affection will lead to happiness in this very life, this would have a huge impact on one’s mind. And if you can think about it in this way for a minute or two, that is excellent. Otherwise, it’s even better to do so for an hour, for twenty four hours, for forty eight hours, days, months, And if you do it for years on end, then that is superb. Exactly.
You know? Then it will be extraordinary if we were able to think of these terms, and there is a quote in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, which reads as follows, since all happiness and suffering arise from within the mind, if we do not cleanse it, what hope would there be? And therefore, once we understand that love and empathy on the one hand, but the afflictions as well such as violence on the other hand, are all mental factors, we will study them with great effort. Then in Jangkya Rolpay Dorje’s Lorig, a main mind is defined as a consciousness which is principally posited from the standpoint of apprehending the nature of its object. If we were to understand as a main mind, a mind which engages its object without any particular analysis, this is probably a good way of understanding a main mind.
Mental activities surrounding a main mind are the mental factors, which is why the mental factors are defined in consciousness awareness and knowledge, as knowledge which surrounds the main mind, which is similar to it, and which apprehends whichever feature of its object. Whichever feature of its object here refers to the activities of the mental factors. Then a very good metaphor or example for the relation between mind and mental factors is that of the ocean and its waves. When there is no wind, the ocean is completely still and flat. This is similar to the main mind.
However, when there is wind, the waves which are a part of the ocean arise. These waves are similar to mental factors. Mental factors are also a main a part of the main mind, and they arise in dependence on the inner winds. Then if one analyzes, nobody would say that the waves of the ocean are the ocean, would they? Nobody says that the waves of the ocean are the ocean, do they?
Likewise, nobody says that the mental factor such as the five omnipresent mental factors or the five determining mental factors are the main mind of which they are a part, do they? So in this respect, the example is very accurate. Then in the same way as if there is no wind, it is impossible for waves to arise on the ocean, likewise, it takes something for the main mind to be able to engage the details of its object. From the standpoint of tantra, this is prana or the inner winds which impel the mental factor to its object. And then the 51 mental factors, as you know, are subdivided into six categories.
The five omnipresent mental factors, the five determining mental factors, the 11 virtues, the six root non virtues, the 20 branch non virtues, and the four changeable states of mind. Now it is indispensable that you memorize these six subdivisions, and if possible, you should try to memorize the five omnipresent mental factors, the five determining mental factors, and so forth. Are you able to memorize this? Oh, good. Must memorize them.
Then I don’t see any point in your writing all this down. It’s in the books. It should be in your minds. These teachings on mind and mental factors are critically important in the context of the path of the being of middling scope. Since the focus of the path of the being of middling scope is karma and causality, and karma, causality, and the afflictions are all connected to minds and mental factors.
Now regarding the six subdivisions of the 51 mental factors, The first subdivision omnipresent, the five omnipresent mental factors are as follows: the first is sensation, the second is discrimination, the third is intention, the fourth is mental application and the fifth is contact. These five omnipresent mental factors are said to be omnipresent because they are necessarily present with any main mind, since without them the main mind is unable to engage its object. Let us give an example of this. When we rise in the morning, we think about preparing our breakfast. Now our breakfast, for instance, would be our main mind here.
This breakfast has numerous components. These components which constitute breakfast would be the mental factors. Then this only applies to those of you who have breakfast. I don’t, so it doesn’t apply to me. Then when you get up in the morning, mind, which is focused on breakfast in general, if there was such a thing, is the main mind.
And the subsidiary minds which are focused on what is necessary for breakfast would be the mental factors. Then main minds and mental factors are present in the mental continuum of every single one of us. Then we shouldn’t think these are subtle issues, I’ll set them aside. Instead, if we reflect on them, it is something which we can understand. Then if we continue with our example of the main mind focused on breakfast, from within the five omnipresent mental factors, which as you remember are sensation, discrimination, intention, mental application and contact.
The mind which is the actual focus, excuse me, the actual focus on the breakfast, that component of the main mind which is focused on the breakfast, that is the fourth omnipresent mental factor, which is mental application. Then there must be a motivation to for the mind to engage this object. This motivation is the third of the omnipresent mental factors. So we have, as you remember, sensation, discrimination, and intention. Motivation is intention.
Then the second omnipresent mental factor of discrimination intervenes in identifying the components of breakfast. For instance, one must find water and recognize this is water, one must find salt and recognize this is salt, butter or oil, and recognize this is butter or oil. For those who are not vegetarian, one finds meat and identifies this as meat. This is discrimination. Then having assembled all the factors for breakfast, we must actually get in contact with breakfast.
And this is the fifth omnipresent mental factor, the mental factor of contact or connection. Now this does not refer to contact in the sense in which contact is used in the context of the sense consciousnesses, but contact really in the context in which it is used for minds and mental factors. And the fifth of the omnipresent mental factors arises when a sensation, a happy, unpleasant, or neutral sensation occurs having breakfast. If you reflect on the five omnipresent mental factors in this way, it should be easier to understand. The following subdivision of the 51 mental factors are the five determining factors.
These are wishing, believing, recollecting, recollection, concentration and wisdom. So if we take the case of mind awareness and knowledge, as a topic, then what would the five determining mental factors be for a mind focused on Lorig? The first determining mental factor is wishing or aspiration. This is the aspiration to study Lorig. The second factor is belief, in this case the belief or the joy involved in the study of The third is memory, the capacity to remember Lorig, and for this, the fourth concentration is indispensable, without concentration there can be no memory.
And this leads to the arrival of the fifth, which is wisdom. Are you able to reflect on whether the sevenfold division of awareness and knowledge, we studied over the last two months, includes only minds, only mental factors, or both. Do you understand? Good. Who?
Who? Only minds, Lobsang. Oh, good. And, Naila? Was sorry.
Was gonna say the opposite to the mark. Because I think about conviction. Be con be strong in your opinions. And? Say main factors and main ones as well.
And main factors because the the of the five omnipresent main factors, it’s got well, it’s omnipresent, so do Lily? I think neither. So within the seven fold subdivision of awareness and knowledge, one of the seven subdivisions is exclusively constituted of mental factors, and that is doubt. Doubt is exclusively constituted of mental factors. Within the remaining six, the remaining six have both main minds and mental factors.
For instance, an inferential valid cognizer includes both main minds and mental factors. Then if you cycle through the sevenfold subdivision of awareness and knowledge in this way, this should be very helpful. Then if you have questions to ask, now is the time to ask them. Of the omnipresent mental factors, I’m interested to understand the way in which they are ordered because it doesn’t seem that they don’t happen in sequence in terms of our experience. And I also had a question around intention or motivation.
Over the Easter weekend we established that there’s no autonomous person. There’s no what? Autonomous person. There’s no free will as such. So I’m wondering how this motivation or intention arises and is it, how would I say, a function of karmic momentum that these intentions arise?
The ordering of the five omnipresent mental factors is not an ordering in terms of meaning, but in terms of mnemonics. It is an easy way to pronounce the sequence in Tibetan. That’s why it is given in this way. However, if you were to study them from the standpoint of the sequence of generation, then initially you would have intention or motivation, then contact, then sensation, then discrimination and so forth. So when one refers to a substantially autonomous person, one is referring to a substantially autonomous self.
This is what is refuted within Buddhist teachings. What is asserted within Buddhist teachings is merely an accumulator of karma and an experiencer of the results of karma. Nothing more than this is asserted. In other words, this accumulator and this experience of karma is a mere name, a mere nominal attribution. Yes.
Just to clarify, with with the main mind, do all the five omnipresent factors have to be in existence? Yes. Yes. Yeah. So if one reflects on the meaning of the omnipresent mental factors, one can see why they would have to be present surrounding every main mind.
On the other hand, there is no certainty regarding the five determining mental factors. They may or may not be present. For instance, there may or may not be such minds surrounding doubt. My question is just going back to a very earlier teaching in Lorig about when we were looking at non associated compositional phenomena and just thinking about that I’ve been wondering whether beings in the formless realm are examples of not non associated compositional phenomena. And is there a more elegant way of saying it’s not a non associated compositional phenomena?
Non-associated compositional phenomena. Are they or not? Is that your Yes. So are they examples are they examples of not non associated? So generally speaking, from the standpoint of sūtra, and within sūtra from the standpoint of the Prāsaṇgika system, the gods of the formless realms, since that’s the only thing which exists in the formless realms, are not imputed existence, but they are substantially existent, and in this case a substantially existent being would have to be a non-associated compositional phenomenon.
Judy? I understood before that Geshe-la said that doubt was a mental factor and not part of the main mind when he asked that question. How could you have a mental factor that a main mind hasn’t already engaged? How could I have doubt about something that consciousness hasn’t already engaged in? I don’t understand your question.
Do you understand remember when Geshe-la said before that doubt was a mental factor, but all the other. Okay, I can’t understand how you can have a mental factor or say this example doubt. How can you have doubt about something that the main mind hasn’t already engaged in? So clearly, before a main main mind has engaged its object, there can be no doubt. So your doubts are good ones.
Initially, you should analyze what a main mind is, and then look at the definition of doubt and see whether doubt could ever be a main mind or not? I know doubt’s a mental factor, but before, when Geshe-la was talking about the set of awarenesses and knowledges Mhmm. He left out doubt as being a mental a main mind Mental factor. Yes. I explained to Geshe-la what I actually think your doubt is, then it’s a good doubt.
Geshe-la will explain this in detail next time. Are there other questions apart from Denise? I mean, Natalie Du. Probably. Past, present and future would be examples of non-associated compositional phenomena.
Yes, it’s because time obviously has parts, right? So it’s an impermanent phenomenon, but it’s neither matter nor consciousness, so it has to be an unassociated compositional phenomenon. Yeah. Yeah. Alright.
Sorry, I jumped your announcement. Could you just check that the chart’s actually on heat? But that was not my announcement. Those who are wanting to take refuge that haven’t taken refuge before, we’re looking at around or Tenzin saying around Chokor Düchen, so around the July 31, somewhere around there. But next week at 06:00, Ilia will be doing a brief what is refuge session.
So those next Wednesday at 06:00 for those who want to take refuge and have not taken refuge. Thank you. And then Saturday, of course, is the commemoration for Rinpoche at 02:00 to five. Saturday, the first. Saturday the thirty-first, Rinpoche’s commemoration at two
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Do all five omnipresent mental factors have to be present with every main mind?
Yes. All five omnipresent mental factors must be present surrounding every main mind. If one reflects on the meaning of the omnipresent mental factors, one can see why they have to be present with every main mind. The five determining mental factors are different, because there is no certainty about them. They may or may not be present. For instance, there may or may not be such minds surrounding doubt.