Calm Abiding — 2014-05-28

1 h 28 min · 3,662 words · 28 May 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding — 2014-05-28
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. His Holiness the Dalai Lama explores how virtue and non-virtue directly shape our experience of happiness and suffering, using Nāgārjuna’s teaching from the Ratnāvali as his anchor. He opens with tangible examples: how anger and conflict in international politics immediately produce suffering, requiring no faith in rebirth to verify. He then turns the lens inward, using the famous stick-and-dog analogy from Śāntideva to show how shifting anger away from the person wielding a weapon toward the afflictions controlling that person opens the door to genuine compassion. From there he unfolds the three-scope framework of Buddhist practice, examining what it means to renounce this life not as monastic withdrawal but as liberating yourself from craving for worldly gain. He explains how calm abiding meditation serves as the essential foundation: by training the wild elephant mind toward a single virtuous object, you eventually free yourself from dependence on external things and move closer to wisdom that undermines self-grasping. The teaching culminates in a guided question-and-answer on how benefiting others can itself become a path to renunciation. Pitched at practitioners familiar with Buddhist vocabulary and ready for philosophical depth.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-05-28 – KR.mp3

UUID: 2af0d4ee-4974-405a-bbd5-ecbb058a686a

Teacher: HH Dalai Lama

Collection: Calm Abiding

Date: 2014-05-28

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,658

As Nāgārjuna said in his Ratnāvali, his precious garland, from non-virtue, suffering, and all lower rebirths, from virtue, happiness in life after life. How can we understand this quote? In previous lives, we have accumulated both non-virtue and virtue. And as a result of this, we have experienced in this life both suffering and happiness. It is best to start by thinking of the fact that non-virtue gives rise to suffering in this very life, and this is something which we can actually experience directly.

The assertion that non-virtue gives rise to suffering when non-virtue has been accrued in previous lives turns really into an extremely hidden phenomenon, which is difficult to understand. Instances of non-virtue would be anger, envy, or competitiveness. Now the cases in which we can clearly see that non-virtue gives rise to suffering in this very life is international politics. It is obvious that when nations are at odds with each other, and as a result of such conflicts, wars are declared, the human beings on both sides experience tremendous suffering, fear, and death. This is the direct result of the non-virtues of anger, of spite, of competitiveness, and of the deprecation of others.

This is not a hidden phenomenon. This is something which is directly accessible to the senses. This is not something which is directly related to dharma. This is just one’s direct experience. This is the meaning of the verse from non-virtue, suffering.

On the other hand, the second part of Nāgārjuna’s stanza from virtue happiness and or higher rebirth is less accessible to direct perception. It is less evident that from virtue in this life, one experiences happiness in this very life. Now clearly one does experience happiness in future lives, but future lives are somewhat remote for us and we may feel disengaged or lazy. Then within our minds, what would we posit as instances of virtue? Clearly, both love and empathy are present within our minds.

Whether love and empathy are virtues or not is debatable. Impartial love and empathy is. So how should we understand such love and empathy? Our goal is to extend to others without discrimination, the love and empathy we have at present for our close friends, family, and relatives. Now, if we take the instance of someone with whom we are at odds, we are in disharmony with, then obviously whenever we encounter or even think of that person, at once feelings of anger and irritation arise in the mind, don’t they?

All of us experience that, don’t we? Then when we take this other party towards whom we experience anger or irritation or for that matter who is just a target of our resentment. When we are controlled by anger, envy, or spite, we should first reflect on the fact that anger, irritation or envy do not arise causelessly within our minds, and when we have fallen under the power, under the sway of them, we should reflect that the other party is also experiencing the same emotions and has also fallen under their sway and feel compassion for him. When we experience anger or irritation towards somebody, in our mind we think he is the very one. This is the one who is the cause of all my anger and irritation.

Yet, as is very clearly explained in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, he himself is enslaved by these emotions as well. Now let us take an example. If someone were to club one on the head with a cudgel, not one of us would feel anger and irritation towards the cudgel. Why is this the case? After all, it is the cudgel which has clubbed us on the head.

But the cudgel is matter. It is inanimate. This kind of reasoning is not of benefit if you reflect on it casually. But if you think about it in depth, it definitely is of benefit. Then in this room, all of us have studied to some degree, let us therefore analyze.

If it is inappropriate to get angry with the cudgel, because it is material, inanimate, and has no will of its own, then why would it be appropriate to get angry with the wielder of the cudgel, since the wielder of the cudgel, the person, is under the sway controlled by anger. The person is not an appropriate object for our irritation. If we are to get angry with anything, we have to get angry with the anger within that person’s continuum. Then, if you have ever struck a dog with a stick, you will notice that the dog becomes annoyed and angry at the stick. Human beings do not.

This is a difference between education and lack of education. Then you will have noticed that when you try to strike a dog with a stick or a cudgel, he would bite at the stick. We ourselves do not get angry at the stick if someone tries to strike us with it, but we get angry at the wielder of the stick, simply because of our greater understanding of the situation. However, our understanding should improve even further, and we should cease getting angry at the wielder of the stick and instead get angry at the anger which causes him to wield the stick. And the supreme form of training is to view this as an object of negation and to counter it. Then through these reflections, eventually true love and empathy will arise within our mind for the other party and authentic compassion.

We will think, my goodness, this poor person is totally overwhelmed by anger, is totally overwhelmed by envy or by spite. They have no control whatsoever. And at this point, when such compassion arises in our mind, this is the gateway to happiness. So this is the meaning of the second part of Nāgārjuna’s stanza, from virtue happiness. So this is therefore the meaning of the last part of the stanza of Nāgārjuna’s verse from the Ratnāvali.

Clearly, to assert that through the safeguard or the protection of ethics, one will experience higher rebirths in future lives, would be true, is very distant from us and is akin to an extremely hidden phenomenon. It is difficult to understand even for those who have studied carefully. However, this example within our own life is something which we can understand. Now I am not saying I myself have any particular experience in the field, but I am encouraging you to reflect on this. Then, so reflecting in this way on the fact that the result of virtue is happiness, we will understand how the result of virtue might be love and happiness within this very life within our mind stream.

As is said in the Bodhicaryāvatāra, without training in love and compassion, what hope would there be to generate bodhicitta, and therefore, with the intent of listening to the Lamrim for the sake of benefiting others, we should attend the teachings. Then let us generate the motivation to listen to these teachings. In this context, when we refer to compassion, we are referring to great compassion. Great compassion is the gateway of the Mahāyāna. When great compassion is present, one can say one has entered the Mahāyāna, otherwise not.

What then would be the gateway of the practice of the being of the middling scope? The gateway of the practice of the being of the middling scope would be the experience of spontaneous renunciation. To be precise, great compassion is the gateway of entry into the practice of the being of the great scope, whereas bodhicitta is the gateway of entry into the practice of the Mahāyāna. As to the practice of the being of the middling scope, as was mentioned, its gateway is the spontaneous experience of renunciation, in dependence on which one engages in meditation on the four noble truths and in practices such as the practice of generosity and ethics, which are specific to the practice of the being of the middling scope. What then is the gateway of the path of the being of the small scope?

It is, as Je Tsongkhapa says in the Three Principal Aspects of the Path, turning away from the vanities of this life. Or it can also be said to be renouncing the eight worldly dharmas or giving up one’s body. So it will be said to be in a nutshell, giving up one’s body in this life. In a nutshell, these are the criteria of entry into the paths of the beings of the three scopes as well as instances. So this abuts on grounds and paths, sa lam.

Then three different terms are used as the criterion for entry into the path of the being of the small scope, turning away from the vanities of this life, renouncing the eight worldly dharmas, and giving up one’s body of this life. These are actually three different ways of saying the same thing, they are synonymous. If we reflect, we can see for ourselves that since beginningless lives we have had incredible attachment to our bodies and to the very life we were in. Then if this is the case, what is the means for us to give rise to a wish to renounce one’s body in this life? Initially, clearly through study. But I would like to ask you what specifically is the means for generating this wish to renounce one’s body in this life?

I am not telling you to give up everything and go forth to a monastery. This is a very narrow minded understanding of what I am saying. I am not saying you have to renounce your house, renounce your partners, renounce your children, renounce your wealth, and leave this life. I am saying that you have been dwelling since beginningless lives in a state of craving for happiness in this life, and it is that craving you must relinquish. This is the road to the practice of pure Dharma.

Dharma unstained by the eight worldly concerns, and for this, one must initially study. Study is what leads one to a practice of pure Dharma. Then the best is obviously to give up this life, to give up any preoccupation for food, drink, and wealth, clothing in this life, and that is excellent. Who can practice that is another question. And therefore, whether we are talking about giving up one’s body of this life or countering the vanities of this life, what I would like to ask you is, what is the path to generate this?

What are the means to generate this in your opinion? What are the other ones? Why? After reflecting or meditating on death and impermanence, why precisely would you give up this life? It is true that through reflecting over and again on death and impermanence, one is engaging in the foremost means of giving up one’s body of this life.

But why is that the case? So this cannot be the only way to turn away from this life. What are the other ways? Everything can be stolen from you. This body is in the nature of suffering.

For me, it’s analyzing what happiness is and what suffering is and trying to understand how things really are in the case of happiness and suffering. For instance, most of the things that I consider happiness are most probably suffering in nature, similar to what Chris said. There’s some relation. There is some relation. The more one reflects on these topics, more the interior change will begin to occur.

It simply is not the case that such change can occur within a day or one week. That would be extraordinarily difficult, but over time it does happen. So indeed, meditation on death and impermanence is explained in the Buddhist scriptures as the foremost means of countering attachment to this life. However, I have explained another means of doing this, and it is something of which we all have direct experience. Every single one of us is intimately convinced that our happiness is contingent on exterior things, and it is when we analyze that we can see that exterior things can never give us happiness, and here we are not talking of transient happiness, we are talking of permanent durable happiness.

Then every single one of us from the very moment we wake up in the morning is obsessed with exterior things, exterior phenomena, which we are convinced will give us happiness. Now you must remember we are composed of physical and mental components. Undeniably exterior things are necessary for physical happiness, although it would be very difficult for exterior things to provide the totality of physical happiness. But there is also mental happiness, and exterior things do not help in this matter. Then if one thinks about this, it will be of benefit. Unfortunately, it is difficult to think about these topics for a long time.

Then, through meditating over and again on death and impermanence, or through meditating over and again on the fact that external objects, external things cannot be the cause of stable, durable and enduring happiness, eventually, we will reach the point where we are able to turn away from the vanities of this world or to relinquish our body of this life. Because we are sunken so deeply into contaminated aggregates, we have this close intimate relationship with exterior objects. This is where it comes from. Then at this point, realizing that exterior objects can never give us permanent, durable, unchanging happiness, we turn inwards, and we realize that the causes of true happiness are within the mind. What is this true, unchanging, stable happiness?

It is liberation. Where are its causes? Its causes are to be found within our minds. Then when we understand that external objects cannot give us enduring happiness and we turn inwards for the causes of happiness, we will turn towards dharma and towards pure dharma. At this point, we will understand that our minds are not independent, and here I do not speak of independence in a political sense, but in an interior sense.

Our minds are not under their own power, instead they are under the power or the sway of the afflictions. As I said, the person is controlled by his or her mind, and his or her mind is controlled by the afflictions. And therefore, this lasting unchanging happiness we seek is within our mind, and its name is liberation. Its causes also are within our minds. Liberation is not something out there in the sky or in the space.

It is instead within our minds. It is something which we have the path to reach, but which we unfortunately choose not to train in. Then liberation, full enlightenment, these are not extraordinary manifestations in the sky. They exist within our mental continuum. And if one reflects on Buddha nature, it is of great benefit in this context.

As Buddha Śākyamūni said, I only teach the path to liberation. You yourselves must travel the path to liberation. And he added, you are your own teachers. Who else should be your teachers? Then as you remember, when the Dalai Lama came to Tibet, he offered tea. This was not translated, but he said, really, when you offer tea, if you are your own teacher, then you offer tea to yourself, don’t you?

Well, this may have been said humorously. This is very profound. His Holiness does not say things like that casually. When one performs these offerings, one performs them, if one performs them to oneself, one performs them to the mind within oneself, and deep within the mind within oneself, to the fundamental mind of clear light. This is what is alluded to.

And therefore, the stanza in the Lama Chöpa, you are the guru, you are the tutelary deity, you are the protector, you are the Dakinis, I take refuge in you until I attain full enlightenment, exclusively refers to one’s own mind. And therefore, the person is under the sway of the affliction of the mind, and the mind is under the sway of the afflictions. The afflictions themselves are under the sway of self-cherishing, and self-cherishing itself is controlled by grasping at the self. And these eventually, as was mentioned, encounter or connect with self-grasping. Self-grasping itself is in a relation of direct contradiction with the wisdom which realizes the selflessness of persons and of phenomena.

This wisdom and self-grasping are in a relationship of harm and harmed. Therefore, since they are directly contradictory, as the wisdom which realizes selflessness increases, self-grasping decreases. When self-grasping is eliminated and eradicated with its roots, at this point, one has attained liberation. It is the ignorance which apprehends the existence of a self and which is present within our very own mind streams and has been becoming stronger and stronger life after life, which must be the target. Therefore, to counter the ignorance of self-grasping, we need wisdom.

To generate that wisdom, we need insight. To generate insight, we need calm abiding. As is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, stake the wild elephant of the mind to the stake of recollection and subdue him with the hook of vigilance. And as is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s concise lamrim, turn the mind into an entity stable as Mount Meru and focus it upon virtue. In those cases, these stanzas refer to training in calm abiding.

Then progressively withdrawing one’s mind inwards away from the objects of the senses, one will subdue both agitation and distraction. And as the powers of concentration increase, one will eventually be able to relinquish dependence on exterior food and rely exclusively on the food of concentration. At this point, one will be free from material hindrances. As was mentioned in Śāntideva’s stanza on training in calm abiding, once calm abiding has been generated, the mind must be focused on virtue. Here, it is probably at the level of the eighth or the ninth level of training in calm abiding that all forms of agitation will have been abandoned, and that the mind can be focused single-pointedly on a virtuous object.

Then at this point, one is free of dependence on exterior objects. One for that matter is free of dependence on food. Then tell me if you are free of dependence on food, there’s a lot of, excuse me, food for thought here. And therefore progressing from the eighth to the ninth mental abiding, after training of the ninth mental abiding, one will give rise to mental and to physical pliancy, normally in that order. It is difficult to generate them in the opposite order, and then in dependence on the pliancies, one says that calm abiding has arisen.

Once calm abiding has been generated, one generates a close approximation to a dhyana, to a contemplation, and at this point one will have ceased to be a being of the desire realm. And the coarse mind of the beings of the desire realms, which is constantly attracted to sense objects, would have been pacified. Do you understand? Do you understand therefore, the person is under the sway of the mind. The mind is under the sway of the afflictions.

The afflictions arise from self-grasping. Therefore, to be free from the afflictions, we must counter self-grasping with wisdom. To generate wisdom, we need insight. To generate insight, we need calm abiding. This is how one progresses.

I will take one question. Kendra? I’m thinking. Good. I want to absorb all of my mind before I commit myself. Good.

Good. Very overturned, you know. Yes, it can be said to be the noble truth of suffering. However, I believe that deeds which are engaged in for the sake of benefiting others do not fall under the nature of suffering. Clearly, if one engages in deeds for the benefit of others motivated by love and empathy, which is sincere, then since what is included within the noble truth of suffering is whatever is caused by karma and afflictions, it seems difficult for such deeds to fall under the noble truth of suffering.

Just one question also. Just one question. Yet another question. Whose need’s left? Must be Heather.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I know the answers. I’m gonna ask you.

So therefore, engaging in activities for the benefit of others doesn’t fall in the category of suffering. Is this one of the bases for attachment of virtue and ignorance in terms of body? So Geshe-la was asking is one of the other than meditation on death and impermanence, is another pathway to renunciation benefiting others. So renouncing on the basis of benefiting others. Renouncing this life is what you’re saying? Yes, on the basis of benefiting others. If you actually have a sincere feeling of altruism, a sincere wish to benefit others, which is spontaneous, then the relinquishing of the body of this life would have occurred long ago, long before that.

Yeah. Yeah. Alright. Thank you. Okay.

I’d like to give me one second and very quick. There’s a number of people interested to take a refuge, and I have organized with Ilya for next week, 6:00 on Wednesday, what is refuge and why we’re taking, etcetera. And Ilya will go, you know, more details on this and so before you take a refuge. So once we have that session passed, then it’s probably we can sort out the time with Geshe-la, and it’s going to be on one of the auspicious days. So probably the Saga Dawa day or the fifteenth.

So please put your name. If you have taken in the past, then you don’t need. If you haven’t, then maybe you think about. And, also, I would like to say this very, very special weekend.

Key terms in this teaching

contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top